Plaintiffs Ex Parte application for Order to Excluding Defendants' Exhibits

8/7/2019 Plaintiffs Ex Parte application for Order to Excluding Defendants' Exhibits

1/14

ETAAKDATE]TBQT@E,LL^Y]KCAK] O. CO@AIIJ(SDK=0>90)A-Gb`l6CoàiijYNetlbw. cjgKrKBM.DJPBF@BK(SDK4=9=21)A-Gb`l6Djybf`bkKNetlbw.cjg4=1> Cjljrbmj Bvakua, Su`ta =>>ASbktb Gjk`cb, CB 0>=>=-114=]alapojka6 3 l>-1?9-55>>Ibcs`g`la6 32>-1?9-5?>>

Bttjrkays ijr ^lb`ktìisFjok E. DrbkcbbkmFjokGcClb`k,Spac`blBmg`k`strbtjrsji toa AstbtajiG`cobalF. Fbchsjk8]rùgpo @ktarkbt`jkbl,@kc'

@WK@]AMS]B]AS M@S]T@C]CJQT]

CAK]TBLM@S]T@C]JI' CBL@IJTK@BUAS]ATKM@Y@S@JK

23

@@2

@2

20

4>

42

44

43

4=

41

FJOK E. DTBKCB,Spac`blBmg`k`strbtjrji toa Astbta ji G`cobalF. Fbchsjk8FJOKGCCLB@K,Spac`blBmg`k`strbtjrji toaAstbta ji G`cobalF. Fbchsjk8]T@QGÔ@K]ATKB]@JKBL,@KC.,b Cblìjrk`bcjrpjrbt`jk,

^lb`ktìis,YS,

OABL]OA UJTLM IJQKMB]@JK,bCblìjrk`bcjrpjrbt`jk8 ]@K@]AMILAA{,bCblìjg`b cjrpjrbt`jk8 bkmMJAS 2-2>,`kclus`va,

Maiakmbtts.

CBSAKJ. CY>0->5>?=MGE(^LBx)

^LB@K]@I'IS'A_ ^BT]AB^^L@CB]@JKI'JT BKJTMATA_CLQM@KEMAI'AKMBK]S'

A_O@D@]SIJTIB@LQTA]J^TJY@MAC JG^TAOAKS@DLAA_O@D@]L@S]BKMBKP A_O@D@]]J ^LB@K]@I'I'S

]r`bl Mbta6Bpr`l20, 4>22Cjgplb`kt I`lam6Saptagd ar 40, 4>>0

Ojk. MjllyG.Eaa

@B240,==3,>2>v.2 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 2 ji 2= ^bea @M #6159>


2/14

@4

F

=

1

]J ]OA CJ@WT],BLL BT]@ASBKM]OA@TB]]JTKAPSJITACJTM6

^LABSA]BHAKJ]@CAtobt ^lb`ktìisFjok E. DrbkcbbkmFjok GcClb`k,

Cj-Axacutjrs ji toa Astbta ji G`cobalF. Fbchsjk (toa Astbta )bkm]rùgpo

@ktagbt`jkbl,@kc.(cjllact`valy, ^lb`ktìis )oarady bpplyAx^brta, pursubkt tj Ljcbl

Tulas 5-20 ijr bk jrmaraxclum`keMaiakmbkts'axo`d`tsbs b rasult jitoa`r ib`lura tj

t`galy prjv`ma^lb`ktìisw`tob cjgpraoaks`dla axo`d`tl`stbkm bkyji toa`raxo`d`ts,bs

raqu`ramdy toa rulas (toa Bppl`cbt`jk ).Bs mascr`damdaljw, ejjm cbusa ax`sts.

Gjra tobk b gjkto obs pbssams`kca Maiakmbktswara raqu`ram tjprjv`ma

^lb`ktìis,bkmto`s Cjurt, bk axo`d`tl`st `makt`'`ketoa mjcugakts toay `ktakm tjusa bt

tr`bl.Bltojueo Maiakmbktsprjmucamsjga sjrt ji l`st,tobt l`stiall ibllsojrt ji gaat`kebky ji toa dbs`c raqu`ragakts ji bk axo`d`tl`st,a.e., mascr`d`ketoa mjcugakt sjueot tj

da usambkm/jrprjv`m`keb dbtas kugdar. ^lb`ktìisobva bshamMaiakmbktsijr b rav`sam

l`stjk kugarjus jccbs`jks sj tobt toa pbrtàsgby gaat bkm cjkiar raebrm`kest`pulbt`ke

tj axo`d`ts,bs toa Cjurt jrmaramtoa pbrtàs tj mj. Maiakmbktsbltarkbt`valyekjramtoa

raquasts, jr `km`cbtamtobt b rav`saml`stwbs ijrtocjg`ke. Djto raspjksas dy Maiakmbkts

obmtoa sbga prbct`cblaiiact6kj cjgpraoaks`dla axo`d`tl`sts`x mbysdaijra tr`bl.

Masp`tatoa`rib`luratj prjv`mabk axo`d`tl`st,Maiakmbktsobva i`lamw`tkass

stbtagakts w`totoa Cjurt raiarakc`ke axo`d`tstobt wara ka`toarprjv`mamtj ^lb`ktìis,

kjr `maktìàmdy toa tr`blaxo`d`tkugdar jk Maiakmbkts'mai`càktaxo`d`tl`st(tj toa

axtakt tobt ^lb`ktìisbra bdla tj uass bs tj wobt mjcugakt `s raiarakcam`kMaiakmbkts'

l`st).Bccjrm`kely, lb`ktìisbra kjt jkly `k toa mbrhbs tj bky ji toa mjcugaktsMaiakmbkts ktakmtj usa bt tr`bl,dut blsj cbkkjt prjparly bkblyza jr jdf act tj

Maiakmbkts'w`tkass stbtagakts w`tojut obv`ke toa raiarakcammjcugakts.

Bs mascr`damdaljw, ejjm cbusa ax`sts ijr toa erbkt`ke ji to`s Bppl`cbt`jk.

Maiakmbktsobva obm bgpla t`ga tj wjrh jk bkmrav`sa bk axo`d`tl`sttobt, bt toa vary

labst, prjv`masb dbtas kugdar jr mascr`pt`jk ji toa mjcugakts sjueot tj da usam.]oay

kaelactamtj mj sj, masp`ta lb`ktìis'raeulbr rag`kmars.Maiakmbktsobva jkca beb`k

@

t2l423

l=21

2

2

@@

42

44

43

4=

41

LB240,==3,>2>v.l 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 4 ji 2= ^bea @M #61592


3/14

@4

F

=

4t44

43

4=

41

49

45

4?

axplj`tam^lb`ktìis'pbtàkca tj toa pj`kt ji savaraly prafum`c`kelb`ktìis' bd`l`tytj

prapbra ijr tr`bl.Suco w`lliulcjkmuct `s ejjm cbusa ijr axclum`keMaiakmbkts' axo`d`tsirjg usa bitr`bl,bkm^lb`ktìisraspactiully raquast tobt toa Cjurt aktar suco bk jrmar.

]oa Bppl`cbt`jk`s dbsamjk to`sKjt`ca ji Bppl`cbt`jkbkmBppl`cbt`jk,toa

bttbcoamGagjrbkmug ji ^j`kts bkmButojr`tàs,toa cjkcurraktly irlam Maclbrbt`jkjiK`kbM.Djybf`bk,bkmbllmjcugakts bkmpbpars jk i`law`totoa Cjurt `k to`sbct`jk.

Maiakmbktswara e`vak kjt`ca ji to`s Bppl`cbt`jk v`bbk agb`l sakt tj Maiakmbkts'

cjuksal, AmebrD. âbsa, @@@,Asq., LbwJii`cas ji AmebrD. âbsa, lll,29411 YakturbDlvm.,Su`ta 5>=,Akc`kj, Cblìjg`b 02=398]al6?2?.0?2.44>>8Ibx6?2?.0?2.44>28

amebrpabsaNegb`l.cjg. SaaMac]bkjkji K`kbM.Djybf`bk,lV,Ax.B. @kraspjksa tj@oaax pbrta kjt`ca, Gr. âbsa lait Gs. Djybf`bkb vj`cagb`l bt l26>9p.g. `kwo`cooajkca beb`k `km`cbtam tobtb rav`saml`st`s ijrtocjg`ke, dut tobt^lb`ktìis gby ej boabm

bkmi`latoa`rbppl`cbt`jkì toay plabsa. @m.,il 3. Gr. âbsa blsj ib`lamtj `km`cbtawoakMaiakmbkts'mjcugakts wjulmda prjv`mamtj ^lb`ktìis.@m.

l2@2

2

@

l9llMbtam6Bpr`l23, 4>2 2

2

2

@

ETAAKDATE][email protected]@E,LL^

Dv6 /s/ K`kbM.Djvb``bk-Bttjgavs ijr ^lb`ktìis Fjok E. DrbkcbbkmFjokGcClb`k,Spac`bl Bmg`k`strbtjrsji toa Astbta jiG`cobalF. Fbchsjk8]rùgpo @ktagbt`jkbl,@kc.

LB240,==3,>2>v.l 2 42>55->2 13>>



4/14

41

49

45

4?

]BDLAJI CJK]AK]S

@. @K]TJMQC]@JK.... ........................... @r. TALAYBK]IBC]S .......................... 2k. BTEQGAK] ...............1

B. Maiakmbkts'Ib`lura ]j Cjgply U`to ]oa Tulas Bkm]oa Cjurt'sJrmar Taebrm`ke^ra-]r`bl Sudg`ss`jks Sojulm ^racluma]oagIrjg @ktrjmuc`keAxo`d`tsBt]r`bl. ................ 1

D. Ejjm Cbusa Ax`stsIjr Erbkt`ke ]o`s Bppl`cbt`jkBs ^lb`kt`iisObva Daak ^rafum`camDyMaiakmbkts'Ib`lura ]j ^rjv`ma BkAxo`d`t L`stBkm BkyAxo`d`ts. ....'..'.'..'.....'....'5

ry. CJKCLQS@JK................... ................0

LB240,==3,>2>v.l 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea = ji 2= ^bea @M #61593


5/14

@4

F

=

1

9

5

?

0

2>

2l24

l3l=l1t9

l52?20

4>

4t44

43

4=

41

49

45

4?

LB240.==3.>2>v.2 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 1 ji 2= ^bea @M #6159=


6/14

1

9

5

?

l224

23

t=@@

2

4l44

43

4=

GAGJTBKM]WGJI' ^J@K]S BKMBQ]OJT@]@AS@. @K]TJMQC]@JK

Maiakmbktsobva daak prjv`mamw`totoa blljwbkcas bkmijre`vakass typ`cblly

rasarvamjkly ijr prj sa l`tèbkts.]oay obva daak trabtambs suco dacbusa toay obva

bctambs suco. Maiakmbktsbra, ojwavar, raprasaktam dy axparàkcamtr`blcjuksal. ]o`s

Bppl`cbt`jk`s `ktakmamtj dr`ke tj toa Cjurt's bttakt`jk, bkmcjgguk`cbta tj Maiakmbkts

tobt suco l`tèbt`jkprbct`cas mj kjt ej w`tojutcjksaquakca. U`to lass tobk b waah

daijra tr`bl,Maiakmbktsobva ib`lamtj prjmuca tj ^lb`ktìisbk axo`d`tl`sttobt `maktìàs

Maiakmbkts'0?4 l`stam axo`d`tsdy dbtas kugdar jr avak b mascr`pt`jktobt wjulm blljw

^lb`ktìistj `maktìitoa mjcugakt. Maiakmbktsobva iuoarib`lam tjprjv`mab s`kela

jka ji toa`raxo`d`tstj ^lb`ktìis,masp`tatoa`r raiarakca tj mjcugakts `k toa`r w`tkassstbtagakts (bkmmasp`ta tb`ktìisprjv`m`keMaiakmbktsw`toblll2 vjlugas ji toa`raxo`d`ts.)

Bs mascr`damk toa cjkcurraktly i`lamMaclbrbt`jkji K`kbM.Djybf`bk, lb`ktìis

obva daak raquast`ke b rav`samaxo`d`tl`stirjg Maiakmbktsijr waahs, bkmobva a`toar

daak èkjram,jr tjlmtobt suco b l`st`s ijrtocjg`ke. ^lb`ktìisw`llda axtragaly

prafum`camiMaiakmbktsbra parg`ttamtj bttagpt tj `ktrjmuca`ktj av`makcabk ukhkjwkkugdar ji mjcugakts w`tojut bky pr`jr hkjwlamea bs tj wobt tojsa mjcugakts bra.

Gjrajvar, Maiakmbkts'ib`luratj sudg`t b wjrhbdla axo`d`tl`stw`llwbsta toa Cjurt'st`ga `kcjks`mar`ketoa bmg`ss`d`l`tyji tojsa mjcugakts, bs ^lb`ktìism`mkjt obva toa

jppjrtuk`ty tj cjks`mar stlbt`ketj Maiakmbkts'axo`d`ts.Maiakmbkts'pbttag jiukt`galy prjv`m`ke,jr ib`l`kebltjeatoar tj prjv`matoa mjcugakts raqu`ramdy toa

Iamarbl Tulas jiC`v`l^rjcamura, toa Ljcbl Tulas, bkmto`s Cjurt's scoamul`ke jrmarsojulmkj ljkear da axcusam.

@@.TALAYBK]IBC]S]oa Tula l9 pra-tr`blmjcugakts, `kclum`keb fj`kt axo`d`tl`st,sojulm obva daak

ilrlamjk Gbrco 2, 4>22. Maclbrbt`jk jiK`kbM.Djybf`bk( Djybf`bkMacl.'),l`=.Bltojueo ^lb`ktìiswara rabmytj i`latoa`rpjrt`jks ji toa raqu`rammjcugakts jk tobt

4

LB240,==3,>2>v.l 242>55->213>>



7/14

@[19

5

?

e

2>

l2l4r3t=l1t9

t52?

r04>

4@44

43

4=

41

49

45

4?

mby,toay beraamtj st`pulbta tj Maiakmbkts'raquast tj axtakmtoa mabml`kaijr i,rl`ke tojsa

mjcugakts tj Gbrco 5,4>22. @m.,k=,Ax.D. ]oa waah daijra toa pra-tr`blmjcugaktswara mua,^lb`ktìis'cjuksal, Gs. Djybf`bk,sakt tj Maiakmbkts'cjuksal, Gr. âbsa,

mrbitsjitoafj`ktpra-tr`blmjcugakts.@m.,k1,Ax.C.Gs.Djybf`bkm`mkjtraca`vabkyraspjksa tj toa mjcugakts soa c`rculbtamtj Maiakmbktsukt`ltoa avak`ke jiSukmby,

Gbrco 9, 4>22, btwo`cot`ga Gr. âbsa lait Gs. Djybf`bkb vj`cagb`l bt oar jii`ca `k

wo`cooa `km`cbtam tobtoa wjulmda sakm`keMaiakmbkts'pjrt`jks ji toa mjcugakts tj

Gs. Djybf`bkjk Gbrco 5, 4>ll,toambytoay waramua.@m.,k 9, Ax'M.Bs b rasult jiMaiakmbkts'ib`lura tjcjgguk`cbta, bkmmalby kc`rculbt`kemjcugakts, ^lb`ktìiswara

ukmarsavara prassura tj i`kbl`zabkmi`labll toa raqu`rammjcugakts dy toa akmjitoa

mby.@m.,lF5. @kbmm`t`jk,Maiakmbkts'pjrt`jksji toa fj`kt mjcugakts wara `ll-prapbrambkm`kcjgplata, pbrt`culbrlyMaiakmbkts'axo`d`tl`st.@m.

]oa axo`d`tl`st tobt Maiakmbktsprjv`mamtj ^lb`ktìisl`stam0?4 axo`d`ts,mascr`dam

kjt dy dbtas kugdar jr bky jtoar mascr`pt`jktobt wjulmblljw ^lb`ktìis,toa Cjurt, jr

bky parsjk tj matarg`ka wobt mjcugakt toa axo`d`t s raiarr`ke tj, dut rbtoar, dy toa

i`lakbga, a.e., vbkcblls-qwa.pmi,(Axo`d`tl>>l)jr sjga jtoar gabk`kelass mascr`pt`jk,

a.e., ibrg`ke (Axo`d`t2240) jr gfqujtas.cjg(Axo`d`t

2,2=?). lm.,il?,Ax.

A.]o`s

wbs mjka masp`tatoa ibct tobt ^lb`ktìisukmartjjh toa durmakbkmaxpaksa jidbtas-

stbgp`ke Maiakmbkts' akt`ramjcugakt prjmuct`jkbkmprjmuc`ketj Maiakmbktsb obrm

mr`vacjktb`k`ke toa`rmjcugakt prjmuct`jk, `k jrmar tj ibc`l`tbtatoa usa ji mjcugakts bt

trbl.@m.,il 0, Ax.I.]oa pbrtàsi`lambk bgakmamaxo`d`tl`stjk Gbrco 2>,4>22. @m.,k2>. ^lb`ktìis

obm blsj`ktakmamtj i`lab cjrraspjkm`ke bgakmamaxo`d`tst`pulbt`jk,dut m`mkjt mj sj

bitar Gr. âbsa raquastam tobtGs. Djybf`bk ksart `ktj tobt mjcugakt (b mjcugakt tobt

wbs c`rculbtamtj Gr. âbsa `k wjrmijrgbt) Maiakmbkts'jdfact`jks tj ^lb`ktìis'

axo`d`ts.@m.,illl,Ax.E. Gr. âbsa obmib`lamtj gbha bky jdfact`jks tj ^lb`ktìis'axo`d`tsupjk toa i`l`keji toa axo`d`tst`pulbt`jkjk Gbrco 5, bkmwbs ojp`ke tobt

^lb`ktìis wjulmgbha Maiakmbkts'dalbtamjdfact`jks tj toa`r jwk axo`d`ts.Gs'

LB240,==3,>2>v.2 2 42>55->213>>



8/14

@4

F

=

1

21

@

2

2

@

4

4=

41

Djybf`bkmacl`kamtj mj sj. @m.,il 22, Ax.E.Jk ]uasmby, Gbrco44,4>2l,Gs. Djybf`bksakt Gr. âbsa b lattar stbt`ke6

Dbsamjk Maiakmbkts'l`st`ke, t`s kabrly`gpjss`dla tj matarg`ka wobtmjcugakt `s da`ke `maktìàmdy abco axo`d`tkugdar.....^lb`ktìis raquasttobt Maiakmbktsrav`sa toa`rpjrt`jk jitoa axo`d`tsl`stspr`jr tj toa pra-tr`blcjkiarakca to`s Ir`mby.Mj`ke sj w`llbss`st bllpbrtàs bkmtoa Cjurt `ktry`keto`s cbsa.@m.,Xl24,Ax.O. @kraspjksa, Gr. âbsa cbllamGs. Djybf`bkbkmsb`m l beraa

2>>%w`toyjur lattar, bkm`km`cbtamtobt Gal w`lsjk, bk jii`car ji djto Maiakmbkts,

wbs rav`s`ketoa axo`d`tl`sttj `kclumaraiarakcas tj toa dbtas kugdar ji toa mjcugakt,

bkmtobt oa sojulm da mjka w`totobt tbsh dy toa ijlljw`ke Gjkmby, Gbrco 4?, 4>22. @m

ti 23. Gs. Djybf`bksakt Gr. âbsa b wjrmmjcugakt ji toa axo`d`tl`sttj ibc`l`tbtaGr.'U`lsjk's wjrh. lm,il2=, Ax. @.

Kjt obv`keraca`vambky rav`saml`st irjg Maiakmbkts, jkGbrco 32, Gs. Djybf`bk

jkca beb`k `kqu`rambs tj toa stbtus jitoa l`st6

Blsj racblltobt FumeaEaa jrmaramtobt toa pbrtàs gaat bkmcjkiarraebrm`kestlbt`ketj axo`d`ts.Jdv`jusly, wa cbkkjt mj to`sukt`lwaraca`va Maiakmbkts'rav`samaxo`d`tl`st, wo`comaktìàsmjcugakts dy dbtaskugdar. Lbst waspjha, yju `km`cbtamtobt Gal U`lsjk axpactamtj obva toarav`saml`stcjgplatam dy Gjkmby. Obs tobtobppakam: @isj, plabsa sakmustoa rav`sammjcugakt bt yjur abrlàstcjkvakàkca sj wa gby bssass toakaamijr bky jdfact`jks.@m.,k51, Ax.F. Bkjtoar waah pbssam,bkmMaiakmbktsst`llib`lam tjprjmuca b

rav`samaxo`d`tl`st.2m.,il 29.Jk Bpr`l0,4>22, `kbk agb`l kjt`ke toa mai`càkcàsw`toMaiakmbkts'w`tkass

stbtagakt ji Hbtoar`ka Fbchsjk, Gs. Djybf`bkjkca beb`k rb`sam toa ssua ji toa axo`d`t

l`st6 Ua blsj kjta tobt Hbtoar`kaFbchsjk's stbtagakt `s g`ss`ke pbea 1, bkmgbhas raiarakca tj axo`d`tstobt obva kjt daak prjv`mamtj us. @obva daakbsh`ke yju ijr waahs kjw, ijr b w`tkass l`sttobt `s usbdla (a.e', prjv`mastoakbga ji toa mjcugakt bkmtoa dbtas kugdar, rbtoar tobk s`gply prjv`m`ke

LB240,==3,>2>v.2 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea ? ji 2= ^bea @M #61595


9/14

@4

F

=

1

toa i`lakbga) sj wa gby gaat bkm cjkiar bs tj toa bmg`ss`d`l`tyji toaaxo`d`ts.Pju obva `km`cbtamtj ga tobt yju/yjur clàkts ba wjrh`ke jk `t,dut obva ib`lam tjprjmuca tj us b rav`saml`st.^labsa mj sj `ggam`btaly.@m.,2l25,Ax.H. Jkca beb`k, kj raspjksa irjg Maiakmbkts,bkmkj rav`samaxo`d`t

l`st.Masp`ta^lb`ktìis'cjuksal's cjggakts raebrm`keGrs. Fbchsjk's w`tkass stbtagaktraiarakc`ke axo`d`tsw`tojut prjv`m`kecjpàs ji tojsa axo`d`ts,toa w`tkassstbtagakts

i`lamdy Maiakmbktsjk Bpkl24,4>22blsj raiarakcamaxo`d`tsw`tojut prjv`m`kecjpàs

ji tojsa axo`d`ts.@m.,k2?, Ax.L. Gjrajvar, toa axo`d`tsraiarakcam`k toa w`tkassstbtagakts bra kjt `maktìàmdy toa tr`blaxo`d`tkugdars jk Maiakmbkts'mai`càkttr`bl

axo`d`tl`st(tj toa axtakt tobt ^lb`ktìisbra bdla tj euass bs tj wobt mjcugakt `s

raiarakcam`k Maiakmbkts'l`st)[email protected] Bpr`l22,4>22, `kbk agb`l bttagpt`ke tj gaat bkm cjkiar raebrm`keprjpjsam

st`pulbtamibcts, Gs. Djybf`bkbeb`k axprassamcjkcag bs tj toa stbtus jitoa axo`d`tl`st6

@bg dacjg`ke vary cjkcagam tobt waobva kjt yat saak b rav`samaxo`d`tl`stirjg Maiakmbkts,bkmbccjrm`kelymj kjt obva bky `mabbs tj toa axo`d`tsMaiakmbkts ktakm jkus`ke bt tr`bl.Bs @gakt`jkam `kSbturmby'sagb`l,avak toa axo`d`tsgakt`jk `k Grs.Fbchsjk's stbtagakt wara kjt prjv`mamkjr`maktìàmkbk bpprjpr`bta gbkkar. Bryju bra wallbwbra, tr`blstbrts `kaèot mbys.@ts `gparbt`va tobt yju prjv`maus w`tob wjrhbdla axo`d`tl`sttobt blljwsus tj `makt`$rMaiakmbkts'prjpjsam axo`d`ts.]o`s sojulmobva daak prjv`mamgbky waahs bej. @rasarva bll ji ^lb`ktìis'jdfact`jkstj bllprjpjsam Maiakmbktaxo`d`ts, kclum`kesaah`ke tj pracluma`ktrjmuct`jkjitojsa axo`d`tsijr ib`luratj ijlljw toa bppl`cbdlaTulas'@m.,kM,Ax.G. Kjtw`tostbkm`kelb`ktìis'cjuksal's axprass stbtagakt bmv`s`ke

ji toa pjss`d`l`tyji saah`ke toa prac`sa ralàisjueot dy to`s Bppl`cbt`jk,Maiakmbkts

jkca beb`k ib`lamtj prjv`matj ^lb`ktìisb rav`samaxo`d`tl`st.2m.,24>.

Jk Bpr`l24,4>L2,^lb`ktìissakt tj Maiakmbktstoa`rcjgplata sat ji axo`d`tsbkmbeb`k raquastam`kijrgbt`jk raebrm`ke toastbtus ji Maiakmbkts'l`sts'2m.,il 42, Ax.K.

@kcjktrbst tj Maiakmbkts' cjkmuct,lb`ktìisprjv`mamMaiakmbktsbk axo`d`tl`stpr`jr tj toa i`l`kejitoa pra-tr`blmjcugakts, bkmobva hapt Maiakmbkts bppr`samjibkyrav`s`jks gbma tj tobt l`st.2m.,k44,Ax.C. @kbmm`t`jk,Maiakmbktsobva toa luxuryji

@

2l2

@

LB240,==3,>2>v.2 242>55->2 13>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 0 ji 2= ^bea @M #6159?


10/14

@4

3

=

1

@

23

@@2

2

2

@

43

4=

41

ravàw`ke lb`ktìis'w`tkass stbtagakts wo`laobv`ke, `k toa`rpjssass`jk ^lb`ktìisiull

sat ji axo`d`ts. 2m.,243,Ax.K. ^lb`ktìis,jk toa jtoar obkm, obvaka`toar bk axo`d`tl`stkjr Maiakmbkts'mjcugakts. @m.,k 4=.

U`to lass tobk b waah daijra tr`bl,Maiakmbktsobva ib`lam tjprjv`mab

cjgpraoaks`dla axo`d`tl`sttj ^lb`ktìisjr to`sCjurt. @kraspjksa tj Gs. Djybf`bk'sax

pbrta kjl`ca, Gr. âbsa lait Gs. Djybf`bkb vj`cagb`l bt l26>9p.g. `k wo`cooa jkca

beb`k `km`cbtamtobt b rav`saml`st`s ijrtocjg`ke, dut tobt ^lb`ktìis'rgby ej boabmbkm

i`latoa`rbppl`cbt`jkì toay plabsa. @m.,k3. Gr. âbsa blsj ib`lam tj `km`cbta woakMaiakmbkts'mjcugakts wjulmda prjv`mamtj ^lb`ktìis.2m.

Gr. âbsa raspjkmam tobtoa axpacts tj obva b rav`samaxo`d`t l`sttj ^lb`ktìisdy

kjjk, Bpr`l 23,4>ll,wo`cow`ll e`va i^lb`ktìisWi,rvambystj eat bt toa mjcugakts.@m.,k 41 . Suco b raprasaktbt`jk kjt jkly lbchscram`d`l`ty,e`vak cjuksal's pr`jr drjhakprjg`sas, dut `s blsj tjj l`ttla,tjj lbta. Avak ìMaiakmbtsmj `k ibct prjv`mab rav`saml`sttjmby,^lb`ktìis wjulmst`llda savaraly prafum`camdy Maiakmbkts'ib`luratj ijlljwtoa raqu`ragakts ji toa rulas.

@@@.BTE]WGAK]

B. Maiakmbkts'tr'b`lura]j Cjgplv U`to]oa Tulas Bkm]oa Cjurt's Jrmar

Taebrm`kq ra-]r`bl Sudg`ss`jks Sojulm^racluma ]oag Irjg @ktrjmuc`keAxo`d`tsBt ]r`bl.Bs mascr`dambdjva, Maiakmbkts'axo`d`tl`st ib`ls kavary raspact tj sarva toa

purpjsas ji bk axo`d`tl`st,kbgaly, `maktì.`keijr toa Cjurt bkmbllpbrtàs, toamjcugakts bkmav`makcaMaiakmbkts ktakmtj usa bt tr`bl.Bccjrm`kely,bs b rasult jiMaiakmbkts'ib`lura tj cjgply w`totoa Iamarbl Tulas ji C`v`l rjcamura, toa LjcblTulas, bkmto`s Cjurt's scoamul`kejrmar, toay sojulm da pravaktamirjg `ktrjmuc`ke toa`r

mjcugakts btlkbl.Iamarbl Tuta ji C`v`l rjcamura 29(i)prjv`mastobt, XjWkgjt`jk jr jk `ts jwk,

toa cjurt gby `ssua bky fust jrmars, `kclum`ketojsa butojr`zam dy Tula 35(d)(4)(B_`-(v``), ib pbrty jr `ts bttjgay...ib`ls tj jday b scoamul`kejr pratr`bljrmar. Iam. T. C`v.

45

4?

@B240,==3,>2>v.2 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 2> ji 2= ^bea @M #61590


11/14

@

t5l?2

^rjc. 29(i)(2)(c). Saa, a.e., Cbrtarv. FbdljkslA,24lIam. Bppx.??? (4mC`r.4>>1)(m`sg`ssbljiplb`ktìiscbsa bs b sbkct`jk ijr ib`l`ketj jday scoamul`kebkmpratr`bljrmars wbs wbrrbktam,woara, masp`tagult`pla axtaks`jks jiiaram dytoa m`str`ctcjurt bkm

cjks`marbdlaaiijrts tj sacura plb`ktìiscjjparbt`jk, plb`ktìi`kaxpl`cbdlyib`lam tjgaatgult`pla mabml`kasraqu`r`keplb`ktìitj i`law`tkassbkmaxo`d`tl`sts.)

Ljcbl Tula 29-4.3 stbtas XtWoapbrlàssobllm`scljsabllaxo`d`tstj da usambt tr`bl

jtoar tobk tojsa cjktagplbtam tj da usamsjlaly ijr `gpabcogakt, bs sat ijrto g

I.T.C`v.p. 49(b_3_B_```).]oa m`scljsura ji axo`d`tssobll da irlamw`totoa cjurt bs

prjv`mam `kL.T. 29-9. Axo`d`tssobll da gbrham`k bccjrmbkcaw`totoa prjcamuras sat

ijrto `k L.T.49-3. Iamarbl Tula ji C`v`l rjcamura 49(b)(3)(B)(```)prjv`mas,`k tug,

tobt b pbriy gust prjv`matj toa jtoar pbrtàsbkmprjgptly i`latoa ijlljw`ke `kijrgbt`jkbdjut toa av`makcatobt `tgby prasakt bt tr`bljtoar tobk sjlaly ijr `gpabcogakt...bk

`maktì`cbt`jkji abco mjcugakt jr jtoar axo`d`t, kclum`kesuggbràs ji jtoar av`makca.

Bs Maiakmbktsobva ib`lamtj cjgply w`toto`s Cjurt's jrmar bkmtoa bppl`cbdlaprjcamurblrulas, toa bpprjpr`bta sbkct`jks ukmarTula 35 `kcluma6prjo`d`t`ketoa

m`sjdamàktpbrty irjg suppjrt`ke jr jppjs`ke masèkbtamclb`gs jr maiaksas, jr irjg

`ktrjmuc`kemasèkbtamgbttars `kav`makca8str`h`keplabm`kes k wojla jr `k pbrt8. . .

m`sg`ss`ketoa bct`jk jr prjcaam`ke`kwojla jr `kpbrt8XjrWrakmar`keb maibultfumegakt

beb`kst toa m`sjdamàktpbrty. Iam. T. C`v.^rjc. 35(d)(4)(B_`,(```),(v),(v`). Dytoavary kbtura ji `ts lbkeubea, sbkct`jks `gpjsam ukmarTula 35(d)gust da lait tj toa sjukm

m`scrat`jkji toa tr`blfumea. Yjk Dr`gar v. Uo`rlpjjl Cjrp.,139 I. 4m ?3? (0to C`r.2059) (axclum`kecartb`kmjcugakts wo`coplb`ktìisobs kjt prjmucamukt`ltoa ava jitr`bl)8saa blsj Gbljka v. Q.S. ^jstbl Sarv`ca,s33 I. 4m24?,@34k '2 (0to C`r. 20?5)

( Bltagbt`vasbkct`jks `kcluma6'b wbg`ke, b ijrgbl rapr`gbkm,plbc`ketoa cbsa bt toa

djttjg ji toa cblakmbr, b ira,toa `gpjs`t`jk ji cjsts jr bttjgay iaas, toa tagpjrbry

suspaks`jk jitoa culpbdlacjuksal irjg prbct`cadaijra toa cjurt...m`sg`ssbljitoa su`tuklass kaw cjuksal `s sacuram...praclus`jk ji clb`gs jr maiaksas, jr toa `gpjs`t`jk ji iaas

bmcjsts upjk plb`ktìilscjuksal. ) (qujtbt`jk jg`ttam)8saa blsj E.F.D.&Bssjc, @kc.v.

@B240,==3,>2>v.2 242>55->213>>

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 22 ji 2= ^bea @M #6155>


12/14

@4

3

=

1

S`kelatjk, el3 I.4m ?4=,?49,?32-34 (2>toC`r.200=)(bii`rg`ke gjkatbry sbkct`jksukmarTula 29(i) ijr cjuksal's ib`lura tj m`scljsa axo`d`tsusambt tr`bl).

Oara, b Cjurt jrmar praclum`keMaiakmbktsirjg us`ke toa`rv`rtubllyuk`maktìàm

axo`d`tsbt tr`bl s bk bpprjpr`bta sbkct`jk ijr Maiakmbkts'w`lliulib`luratj prjv`ma^lb`ktìisbkmtoa Cjurt b prjpar l`stjitoa axo`d`tstj da usambtrr`bl.

D. Ejjm Cbusa Ax`stsIjr Erbkt`ks ]o`s Bppl`cbt`jkBs ^lb`ktìisObva Daak^raùm`camDvMaiakmbkts'tr'b`lura]j ^rjv`maBk Axo`d`tL`stBkmBkvAxo`d`ts.Bs b rasult ji Maiakmbkts'ib`luratj `maktìitoa mjcugakts toay `ktakm tjusa bt

tr`bl,masp`tada`ke prjv`mamkugarjus axtaks`jks tj mj sj, ^lb`ktìisobva daak ukbdla tj

bmaqubtalyprapbra ijr tr`bl.Avak ìMaiakmbktswara tj prjv`ma^lb`ktìis toa`r axo`d`tl`stjk toa mbyji toa i`l`keji to`s Bppl`cbt`jk, lb`ktìis wjulmobva i`vambystj

cjks`marbk ukhkjwk kugdar ji axo`d`ts,matarg`ka woatoar toay obva bkyav`makt`bry

jdfact`jks tj toa mjcugakts, bkmjtoarw`sa `ktaerbtatoag `ktj toa`r tr`blprapbrbt`jk.

Suco prafum`ca,cbusamtorjueo kj ibultwobtsjavar ji^lb`ktìis,sojulm kjt da parg`ttam.

Aqubllycjkcag`ke bs Maiakmbkts'ib`luratj prjv`mabk axo`d`tl`st`s Maiakmbkts'

i`l`keji w`tkass stbtagakts tobtraiarakca

axo`d`tstobt wara (l)kjt bttbcoamtj toa

stbtagakts, bkm(4) kjt `maktìàmdy toa tr`blaxo`d`tkugdars jk Maiakmbkts'mai,tcàkt

tr`blaxo`d`tl`st.@m.,il 2?, Ax.L. Uo`la ^lb`ktìisgby da bdla tj bscartb`kwobt sjga jitoasa axo`d`tsbra, ^lb`ktìiss`gply cbkkjt `maktìy bll jitoagbkmsojulmkjt da put tj

toa r`shji euass`ke rèot jr wrjke jk wobt axo`d`tsMaiakmbktsbra raiarakc`ke.

Gjrajvar, avak ìMaiakmbktsmj prjv`matoa`rrav`samaxo`d`tl`sttjmby,kj `km`cbt`jkwobtsjavar obs daak gbma raebrm`kewoak toay w`llda prjv`m`ketoa bctubl mjcugaktstj ^lb`ktìis.

@ktoa bltarkbt`va, i toa Cjurt `s kjt `kcl`kamtj `ssua bk jrmaraxclum`keMaiakmbkts'axo`d`tsjk bax pbrta dbs`s, ^lb`ktìisraquast tobt toaraquast ijr axclus`jkda oabrm jkb sojrtakam dbs`s. Maiakmbktsobva put ^lb`ktìis`k b pjs`t`jk woara i`l`keb

kjt`camgjt`jk tj toa Cjurt bmmrass`keto`s `ssua `s s`gply kjt iabs`dla.

@2

2

43

4=

LB240.==3.>2>v.2 242>55->213>>



13/14

4l

3l

@6l,2

?

e

2>

22

t423

t=l1t9

t52?

t04>

4l44

43

4=

41

49

45

4?

@kjrmar tj jdtb`k ax pbrta ralàisojrtak`ke t`ga ijr b gjt`jk tj da oabrmjuts`ma

toa jrm`kbrylbwbkmgjt`jk scoamula,toa gjv`ke pbrty gust sbt`siy twj ibctjrs6 I`rst,

toa av`makcagust sojw tobt toagjv`ke pbrty'scbusa w`llda `rrapbrbdlyprafum`camitoa ukmarly`kegjt`jk `s oabrm bccjrm`ketj raeulbr kjt`camgjt`jk prjcamuras. Sacjkm,

`tgust da astbdl`soamtobt toa gjv`ke pbrty `s w`tojut ibult`k crabt`ke toa cr`s`s tobt

raqu`ras ax pbrta ralài,jr tobt toa cr`s`s jccurrambs b rasult ji axcusbdla kaelact.

G`ssjk ^jwar Ake'e Cj. v. Cjkt`kaktbl Cbs. Cj.,??3 I. Supp. =?? ,=04 (C.M'Cbl'

2001). Oara, djto alagakts bra abs`lysbt`siàm,ijr toa sbga rabsjks mascr`dambdjva.

I`rst, ^lb`ktìisw`llobva bt gjst ilrvambystj ravàw Maiakmbkts'rav`samaxo`d`tl`st(bssug`ke tobt `t `s bctubllyprjv`mamtjm, wo`cosavaraly prafum`cas lb`ktìis'tr`bl

prapbrbt`jk.Gjrajvar, dacbusa Maiakmbktsobva kjt prjv`mambky bctublaxo`d`tstj^lb`ktìis, lb`ktìismj kjt hkjw wobtmjcugakts bra raiarakcam`k Maiakmbkts'savak

w`tkass stbtagakts. U`to jdfact`jks tj tojsa w`tkass stbtagakts muajk Bpr`l21,4>22,suco b ib`lurajk Maiakmbkts'pbrt `s ukbccaptbdla.

Sacjkm, ^lb`ktìisraquastam,t`ga bkmt`ga beb`t,tobtMaiakmbktsprjv`matoag

w`tob rav`samaxo`d`tl`st.]ojsa raquasts wara a`toarèkjram jr gat w`toagpty

prjg`sas. ^lb`ktìis m`mavaryto`ke`k

toa`rpjwar tj bvj`mtoa vary s`tubt`jk toaykjw

i`kmtoagsalvas `k.Dacbusa ^lb`ktìisobva kj ibult`kcrabt`ke toa c`rcugstbkcas tobtmagbkmto`s ralài,toay sojulmkjt da sudfactamtj toa rasult`keprafum`ca.

@B240,==3,>2>v.2 242>55->213>>



14/14

@4

F

=

1

9

5

?

0

2>

22

24

23

2=

21

29

t5l?20

4>

4l44

43

4=

41

49

45

4?

@Y.CJKCLQS@JK^lb`ktìisobva daak savaralyprafum`camdy Maiakmbkts'ib`luratj prjv`matoag

w`tob cjgpraoaks`dla axo`d`tl`stbkmMaiakmbkts'axo`d`ts.Maiakmbktsib`lura tj mj sjobs daak w`lliul,bkm cbusamtorjueo kj ibult ji ^lb`ktìis.Bccjrm`kely,bk jrmaraxclum`keMaiakmbkts'axo`d`ts s bpprjpr`bta ukmartoasa c`rcugstbkcas.

Mbtam6Bpr`l23,4>22 ETAAKDATE]TBQT@E,LL^

Dv6 /s/ K`kbM.Djvb``bk-Bttjrkavs ijr ^lb`ktìisFjok C. DrbkcbbkmFjokGcClb``,Spac`blBmg`k`strbtjrs jitoa Astbta jiG`cobalF. Fbchsjk8]rùgpo lktarkbt`jkbl, @kc.

Cbsa 46>0-cv->5>?=-MGE -^LB Mjcugakt 2=4 I`lam >=/23/22 ^bea 2= ji 2= ^bea @M #61553

Plaintiffs Ex Parte application for Order to Excluding Defendants' Exhibits

Documents

Transcript of Plaintiffs Ex Parte application for Order to Excluding Defendants' Exhibits