PINCER - Hot Topics

97
Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth Hot Topics in ICM Steve Mathieu @stevemathieu75 @WessexICS Consultant in Intensive Care Medicine Queen Alexandra Hospital, Portsmouth 27 th February 2015

Transcript of PINCER - Hot Topics

Page 1: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Hot  Topics  in  ICM  

Steve  Mathieu  @stevemathieu75  @WessexICS  

Consultant  in  Intensive  Care  Medicine  Queen  Alexandra  Hospital,  Portsmouth  

27th  February  2015  

Page 2: PINCER - Hot Topics

NAP  4  -­‐  2011  

•  All  NHS  hospitals  for  1  year  ’08-­‐’09  •  184  reports  

 133  anaesthesia   36  ICU   15  ED  

•  Inclusion  criteria     death,  brain  damage   emergency  surgical  airway  

 unanTcipated  ICU  admission   ProlongaTon  ICU  stay  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 3: PINCER - Hot Topics

Summary  of  NAP  4  

  25%  of  major  airway  events  in  a  hospital  occur  in  ICU  or  the  ED  

  46%  of  ICU  events  and  53%  of  ED  events  occurred  out  of  hours      

  50%  of  ICU  events  were  due  to  tracheostomy  related  events  

  50%  events  in  ICU  and  27%  events  in  ED  resulted  in  death  

  61%  events  in  ICU  resulted  in  death  or  severe  neurological  harm  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 4: PINCER - Hot Topics

RecommendaTons    

  Capnography    Airway  equipment    Back  up  planning    Staffing    PaTent  transfers    EducaTon/training    Tracheostomy  tube  design    Team  working  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 5: PINCER - Hot Topics

TracMan  -­‐  2013  

• Early  tracheostomy  (by  d  4)  or  late  (>10/7)  

–   455  paTents  –   Mortality  the  same  31%  –   LOS  the  same  13  d  

–   ComplicaTons  slightly  higher  in  late  group  6%  vs.  5%  

Young  et  al.  JAMA  2013  May  22;309(20):2121-­‐9  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 6: PINCER - Hot Topics

ARDS

Page 7: PINCER - Hot Topics

ARDS  -­‐  Incidence  

•  1  yr  prospecTve  observaTonal  study;  255  paTents  

•  Incidence  7.2/100,000/year  (?  US  75/100,000)  

•  Despite  use  of  lung  protecTve  venTlaTon  overall  ICU  mortality  >40%  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 8: PINCER - Hot Topics

ARDS  -­‐  lots  of  trials    HFOV    Nitric  Oxide    Surfactant      Perflourocarbon    Late  steroids  (LaSRS)  Prostaglandin  E1    Lysophylline  (LARMA)  Ketoconazole  (KARMA)  

  Streptokinase    StaTns  (HARP  2,  SAILS)    Neutrophil  elastase  inhibitor  

  ImmunonutriTon  (Eden-­‐Omega)

  rhAPC    Albuterol/salmeterol  (BALTI  I  &  II,  ALTA)  

  Lower  Vt    ?  Furosemide  (FACTT)  

  Cisatricurium      Prone  ‘back’  in  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 9: PINCER - Hot Topics

OSCAR  

•  795  paTents  with  moderate  -­‐  severe  ARDS  (<26.7kPa  /  200mmHg)  

•  CMV  vs.  HFOV  (MV  <7  days)  •  No  difference  in  

–  30/7  mortality  (41%)  

–  DuraTon  anTmicrobial  agents  (2/3  chest  sepsis)  

–  VasoacTve  support  duraTon  –  ICU  LOS  –  Hospital  LOS  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 10: PINCER - Hot Topics

OSCILLATE  •  548  paTents  with  moderate  -­‐  severe  

ARDS  

•  HFOV  vs  low  Vt/High  PEEP  CV  (MV  <  3d)  •  Trial  stopped  early  as  harm  with  HFOV  

•  HFOV  –  Hospital  mortality  47%  vs  35%  

–  More  sedaTon  

–  More  NMBA’s  

–  More  vasopressors  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 11: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

OSCAR   OSCILLATE  

29  ICU’s  UK   39  ICU’s  5  countries  

795  paTents   548  paTents  (planned  1200)  

PaO2:FiO2  <  200mmHg  

Bilateral  pulmonary  infiltrates  MV  for  LESS  than  7  consecuTve  days  at  the  point  of  randomisaTon    

PaO2:FiO2  <  200mmHg  FiO2  >  0.5  Bilateral  pulmonary  infiltrates  MV  for  LESS  than  3  consecuTve  days  at  the  point  of  randomisaTon    

Encouraged  to  use  PC  6-­‐8mls/kg  and  use  ARDS  protocol  for  FiO2  &  PEEP  R  100  venTlator  PEEP  11  

CV  –  PC  6mls/kg,  3100  B  venTlator  Recruitment  maneuvers  before  HFOV  Protocol  specified  high  PEEP  for  CV  (PEEP  13)    

30d  mortality  42%  vs.  41%  (HFOV  vs.  CV)   30d  mortality  40%  vs.  29%  

Hospital  mortality  47%  vs.  35%  (HFOV  vs.  CV)    

More  NMBA’s   More  midazolam,  vasoacTve  drugs,  NMBA’s  in  HFOV  

Lower  PEEP  strategy     ?  recruitment  maneuvers  of  lung  before  HFOV  injurious  

Mortality  41%  in  control  group   Mortality  35%  in  control  group  

Page 12: PINCER - Hot Topics

PROSEVA  •  466  paTents  with  severe  ARDS  •  Prone  posiTon  vs  supine  posiTon  •  Prone  posiTon  was  associated  

with  

–  Improved  mortality    •  28  day:  16%  vs  33%  •  90  day:  24%  vs  41%  

–  Less  cardiac  arrests  –  No  difference  in  complicaTons  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 13: PINCER - Hot Topics

PROSEVA  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 14: PINCER - Hot Topics

HARP  2  -­‐  2014  

•  540  paTents  ARDS;  40  UK  ICUs  •  ARDSnet  +/-­‐  staTn  for  28  days      (80mg  od  simvastaTn)  

•  Primary  outcome  –  No  difference  in  venTlator  free  days  at  28d  

•  Secondary  outcome  –  No  difference  in  SOFA,  oxygenaTon  –  Elevated  CK  or  ALT/AST  >  in  staTn  group  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 15: PINCER - Hot Topics

StaTns  in  ARDS  

•  MulTcentre,  RCT  •  RosuvastaTn  vs.  placebo  in  ARDS  •  StaTn  may  modulate  inflammatory  response  

•  745  paTents  (trial  stopped  early  because  of  fuTlity)  

•  Primary  outcome:    •  60d  mortality:  28.5%  vs.  24.9%  (staTn  vs.  placebo)  •  VenTlator  free  days:  15.1  vs.  15.1  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 16: PINCER - Hot Topics

StaTn  &  VAP  •  300  paTents  with  suspected  VAP  (CPIS  

≥  5)  

•  SimvastaTn  60mg  vs  placebo    •  No  difference  in  

–  28d  survival  –  ICU  or  hospital  mortality  

–  DuraTon  MV  –  Delta  SOFA  

•  Increased  mortality  in  staTn  naieve  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 17: PINCER - Hot Topics

BALTI  -­‐  2012  

•  162  paTents;  46  UK  ICU’s  •  ARDS  &  MV  

-­‐  salbutamol  15mcg/kg/hr  or  placebo  

-­‐  Treatment  for  up  to  7  d  

•  Mortality  greater  in  those  given  salbutamol  34%  vs  23%  at  28d  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 18: PINCER - Hot Topics

Steroids  in  ARDS  

•  9  studies  (4  RCT’s  &  5  cohort)  

•  648  paTents  •  Trend  to  reduced  mortality  but    

 only  ss  when  result  pooled  

•  Trials  vary  ++  

1.  Dose  2.  IniTaTon  of  treatment  3.  Course  length    4.  Not  all  studies  report  adverse  events    

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 19: PINCER - Hot Topics

Nitric  oxide  –  just  say  No  •  Potent  pulmonary  vasodilator  which  when  inhaled  =  selecTve  vasodilaTon  in  well  venTlated  lung  units  

•  Improved  V/Q  mismatch  and  PVR  &  PAP  •  Also  anT-­‐inflammatory  effects  •  SystemaTc  review  of  12  trials  with  1200  paTents  =  improved  oxygenaTon  d1,  no  improvement  in  mortality  

•  !AKI  and  methaemaglobinaemia    "!intracranial  bleeding  in  children    Afshari  Cochrane  review  2007  -­‐  adults  Barrington  Cochrane  review  2010  –  children  Afshari  –  systema>c  review  2011  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 20: PINCER - Hot Topics

Magnesium  in  asthma  

•  1200  paTents  2008-­‐2012  •  Neb  vs.  IV  Mg  vs.  placebo    •  No  role  for  neb  Mg  •  Limited  role  at  best  for  IV  Mg  

•  Not  life  threatening  asthma  

Intravenous  or  nebulised  magnesium  sulphate  versus  standard  therapy  for  severe  acute  asthma  (3Mg  trial):  a  double-­‐blind,  randomised  controlled  trial  Goodacre  et  al  Lancet  2013  Vol  1  (4)  293-­‐300  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 21: PINCER - Hot Topics

VAP  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

What  is  VAP?  

What  are  the  common  organ

isms  (early  vs.  

late?  

Scoring  systems  e.g.  CPI

S,  HELICS  

What  anTbioTcs  wo

uld  you  use?  

How  can  you  redu

ce  incidence  

Open  Access!#FOAMcc  

Page 22: PINCER - Hot Topics
Page 23: PINCER - Hot Topics

TTM  •  950  unconscious  adults;  36  ICU’s  •  33°C  (n=473)  with  36°C  (n=466)  •  No  difference  in  

–  All  cause  mortality  33°C  (50%)  with  36°C  (48%)  

–  poor  neurological  funcOon  at  180  days  

33°C  (54%)  with  36°C  (52%)  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 24: PINCER - Hot Topics

CogniTve  funcTon  post  TTM  •  652  cardiac  arrest  survivors  from  TTM  

•  Survival  unTl  180  days  52%    -­‐  invited  to  follow  up  

 -­‐  about  half  had  psychometric  tesTng    -­‐  compared  with  a  control  group        (STEMI  but  no  cardiac  arrest)  

•  About  50%  had  cogniTve  impairment  •  33  vs.  36  vs.  control  group  similar  

•  AyenTon  &  mental  speed  more  affected  in  cardiac  arrest  paTents  

•  Memory  &  execuTve  funcToning  similar  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 25: PINCER - Hot Topics

Pre-­‐hospital  hypothermia  •  Prehospital  cooling  vs.  standard  care  •  2L  of  cold  normal  saline  once  ROSC  •  1,359  OOHCA  paTents  •  Cooling  effecTve  (reduced  temp)  •  No  difference  

–  Survival  to  hospital  discharge  •   VF  63%  vs  64%    •   nonVF  19%  vs  16%  

–  Good  neurological  recovery  •  VF  57%  vs  62%      •  nonVF  14%  vs  13%  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 26: PINCER - Hot Topics

IABP  –  SHOCK  II  •  600  paTents  with  cardiogenic  shock  

secondary  to  AMI  

•  IABP  vs  no  IABP  •  All  received  early  revascularisaTon  

and  best  medical  therapy  

•  No  difference    –  30/7  mortality  (40%)  

–  ICU  LOS,  catecholamine,  bleeding  •  Lancet  2013  Sept  –  12/12  results  =  no  

difference  in  mortality  or  reinfarcTon  rate  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 27: PINCER - Hot Topics

VSE  in  cardiac  arrest  •  268  paTents  in  hospital  cardiac  arrest  •  Vasopressin(20IU/CPR  cycle)  +  

epinephrine  (1mg/CPR  cycle)  +  methylprednisilone  (40mg)  vs  placebo  +  epinephrine  (1mg/CPR  cycle)  

•  VSE  group  –  ROSC  at  20  mins  higher  84%  vs  66%  

–  Improved  survival  to  hospital  discharge  with  CPC  1  or  2  

–  Improved  haemodynamics  &  cvSpO2  

–  Less  organ  dysfuncTon  •  and  Academic Department of Critical Care

Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 28: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 29: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

ECMO  

Page 30: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

The  oxygenator  in  veno-­‐venous  ECMO  

Page 31: PINCER - Hot Topics

ECMO  Study type

Year pub

N (ECMO)

N (non

ECMO)

% H1N1

ECMO mortality

Non-ECMO mortality

p

RCT 2009

90 90 0 37% 50% 0.07

RCT 1994

21 19 0 67% 58% 0.8

RCT 1979

48 42 0 90% 92% 0.84

Cohort 2006

32 118 0 47% 29% 0.06

Cohort 2000

62 183 0 45% 39% NS

Cohort 1997

49 73 0 45% 11% <0.001

Case series

2009

68 133 100% 23% 13% 0.06

Case series

2011

69 11 100% 27.5% ?52% ***

Page 32: PINCER - Hot Topics

ECMO  for  H1N1  •  2009-­‐2010  •  80  paTents  referred  for  ECMO  •  69  received  ECMO  •  22  of  these  died  (27.5%)    •  Matching  cohort  =  52%  •  For  paTents  with  H1N1  related  ARDS,  mortality  reduced  with  ECMO  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 33: PINCER - Hot Topics

CHEER  •  Refractory  cardiac  arrest  treated  with  

mechanical  CPR,  hypothermia,  ECMO  and  early  reperfusion  

•  26  paTents  (11  OHCA;  15  IHCA)  •  Primary  outcome  

–  Survival  with  good  neurological  recovery  (CPC  1-­‐2)  14/26  (54%)  

•  Secondary  outcomes  –  ROSC  achieved  in  25/26  (92%)  of  paTents  –  Survival  to  hospital  discharge  14/26  (54%)  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 34: PINCER - Hot Topics

             Passive  Leg  Raise  

Page 35: PINCER - Hot Topics

CO  Monitoring  –  COMET-­‐UK  

•  Survey  to  all  UK  ICUs  •  Respondents  

–  Majority  used  CO  monitoring  •  Oesophageal  doppler  57%  •  LiDCO  43%  •  PiCCO  42%  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

How  does  doppler  work?  ThermodiluTon?    

Pulse  contour  analysis  ?  

Page 36: PINCER - Hot Topics

CO  Monitoring    

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

How  does  doppler  work?  ThermodiluTon?    

Pulse  contour  analysis  ?  

Page 37: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

•  Meta-­‐analysis  

•  16  trials  inc  PEITHO,  MAPPETT,  MOPETT,  TOPCOT  

•  Thrombolysis  +  anTcoagulaTon  vs.  anTcoagulaTon  alone  

•  All  cause  mortality  less  in  thrombolysis  group  but  major  bleeding  &  ICH  higher  

Page 38: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

SEPSIS  

Page 39: PINCER - Hot Topics

The  Sepsis  Studies  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 40: PINCER - Hot Topics

ARISE  •  Randomised,  controlled,  mulTcentre,    

•  51  hospitals  1,600  paTents  with  sepTc  shock  

•  EGDT  vs.  Usual  Care  •  No  difference  in:  

–  All  cause  mortality  at  90d  (18%)  

–  ICU  &  Hospital  LOS    

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 41: PINCER - Hot Topics

ProCESS  •  RCT  31  ICUs  in  US  

•  03/2008  –  05/2013  

•  1351  paTents  with  sepTc  shock  •  3  groups  

–  EGDT  –  Protocol  based  standard  therapy  –  Usual  care  –  No  difference  in  60  d  mortality  between  groups  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 42: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 43: PINCER - Hot Topics

Ferrer:  Empiric  anTbioTcs  in  sepsis  

•  RetrospecTve  observaTonal  cohort  study  •  165  ICUs  –  Europe,  US  &  S  America  •  Jan  2005-­‐  Feb  2010  •  18,000  paTents  with  sepTc  shock  •  Delay  in  anTbioTcs  administraTon  over  first  6  hours  azer  

idenTficaTon  of  SS  or  sepTc  shock  -­‐>  increased  mortality  

•  <  1  hr  24.6%;  1-­‐2h  25.9%  >  6h  33%  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 44: PINCER - Hot Topics

SEPSISPAM  

•  RCT,  mulTcentre,  29  French  ICUs  

•  March  2010  –  Dec  2011  

•  SepTc  shock    

•  Target  MAP  80-­‐85  vs.  65-­‐70  •  No  difference  in  

–  28  day  mortality  (high  MAP  36.6%  vs.  34%)  

•  New  AF  6.7%  in  higher  MAP  group  vs.  2.8%  P=0.02  

•  In  chronic  hypertension  group,  worsening  creaTnine  and  need  for  RRT  was  lower  in  higher  MAP  group  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 45: PINCER - Hot Topics

PROWESS  SHOCK  •  Randomised,  controlled,  mulTcentre,  

parallel  group  study  

•  1,697  paTents  with  sepTc  shock  •  No  difference  in  

–  28  day  mortality  (APC  26.4%  vs  24.2%)  

–  90  day  mortality  (34.1%  vs  32.7%)  

•  No  subgroup  effect  seen  in  protein  C  deficient  group  

•  Serious  bleeding  n  =  10  APC  vs  8  placebo  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 46: PINCER - Hot Topics

B  blockers  in  sepTc  shock  

•  Open  label,  single  unit  •  SepTc  shock  +  HR  ≥  95  +  NADR    •  77  paTents  –  esmolol  infusion  (HR  

80-­‐94)  vs  77  paTents  standard  treatment  

•  Esmolol  group  –  28d  Mortality  50%  vs  81%  in  placebo  

–  Improved  SV  index,  LVSWI,  lactate  

–  Less  NADR  requirement  

–  Less  fluid  requirement  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 47: PINCER - Hot Topics

Esmolol  in  refractory  VF  

•  Single  centre,  non  randomised  •  25  paTents  with  refractory  (>3  defib  

ayempts)  VF  or  pulseless  VT  

•  Esmolol  vs.  placebo  •  Primary  outcome  

–  Survival  with  good  neurological  recovery  –  50%  esmolol  vs  11%  control  group  

–  No  difference  in  rates  of  ROSC  or  survival  to  hospital  discharge  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 48: PINCER - Hot Topics

Steroids  in  Sepsis  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 49: PINCER - Hot Topics

The  evidence…..let’s  give  it  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

8  trials  published  before  ’89      -­‐  No  mortality  benefit  (some  worse)      -­‐  Decreased  Tme  for  shock  resoluTon      -­‐  More  secondary  infecTons      -­‐  Higher  doses  and  for  shorter  periods  

19  ICU’s  300  paOents      -­‐  50mg  hydrocorTsone  +  fludrocorisone  vs.  placebo  by  8hrs  of  onset  of    sepTc  shock.        -­‐  ‘Non  responders’  (adrenal  suppression)  beyer  ICU  (53%  vs.  63%)    and  hospital  mortality  (61%  vs.  72%).        -­‐  Increase  secondary  bacterial  infecTons      -­‐  NNT  =  7    

 (Annane  JAMA  2002)  

Page 50: PINCER - Hot Topics

The  evidence…..perhaps  don’t  give  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

CORTICUS    

 -­‐  52  ICU’s,  499  paTents  

   -­‐  50mg  hydrocorTsone  QDS  vs.  placebo  6/7      -­‐  28/7  mortality  no  different  between  groups  and  subset  of  non-­‐      responders  

Quicker  shock  resoluTon,  catecholamine  sparing,  more  secondary  infecTons    Sprung  et  al.  NEJM  2008:  358;  111-­‐24  

 -­‐  Etomidate  used  in  1/5th  of  paTents    -­‐  Only  35%  power  to  detect  a  20%  mortality  reducTon    -­‐  High  variability  between  laboratories  in  corTsol  assays  

Page 51: PINCER - Hot Topics

Hang  on….  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Post hoc analysis of patients in VASST

Review of patients with noradrenaline (293) and steroids and vasopressin (295) and steroids 28 day mortality difference 44.7% versus 35.9% (p=0.03) ? Increased responsiveness to catecholamines ? Increased vasopressin levels ? Decreased inflammation Russell  J,  et  al,  InteracTon  of  vasopressin  infusion,  corTcosteroid  treatment,  and  mortality  of  sepTc  shock,  Crit  Care  Med  2009  Vol.  37,  811-­‐8  

VANISH  –  second  arm  includes  steroids.  Eagerly  await  results  

Page 52: PINCER - Hot Topics

VASST  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

 -­‐  RCT  778  pts  with  sepTc  shock  

-­‐   Noradrenaline  vs.  Norad  &  Vaso  (0.03  units/min)  

-­‐   No  mortality  benefit  

-­‐   Higher  doses  associated  with  ischaemia  

“Possible  use  if  other  vasopressors  failed”  

Less  severe  shock  associated  with  reduced  mortality  when  vasopressin  used  

Russell  et  al.  NEJM  2008:  358:  877-­‐87  

Page 53: PINCER - Hot Topics

VANISH  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Vasopressin  &  corTcosteroids  in  SepTc  Shock.  A  Pilot  Study  –  Gordon  A,  2014  HydrocorTsone  

 -­‐  vasopressin  sparing    -­‐  reduced  duraTon  vasopressin    -­‐  reduced  dose  vasopressin    -­‐  no  effect  on  vasopressin  levels  

Page 54: PINCER - Hot Topics

TRISS  •  RCT  32  general  ICUs  in  Scandinavia  •  998  paTents  with  sepTc  shock  &  Hb  <9  •  Transfusion  threshold  <7  vs.  <9  •  Excluded  paTents  with  ACS  •  Primary  outcome:  

–  No  difference  in  death  at  90  days  •  Secondary  outcomes:  No  difference  in  

•  VasoacTve  drugs  •  VenTlaTon  •  RRT  •  %  of  days  alive  &  out  of  hospital  •  Ischaemic  events  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 55: PINCER - Hot Topics

OPTIMISE  

•  RCT,  mulTcentre,  17  UK  ICUs  

•  734  paTents  

•  >  50y  undergoing  GI  surgery  with  one  or  more  ‘high  risk’  risk  factors  

•  Algorithm-­‐directed  care  dictaTng  colloid  and  dopexamine  administraTon  using  vs.  clinician  directed  care  without  use  of  CO  monitoring  

•  Primary  outcome:  composite  of  30d  mortality  and  mod/major  complicaTons  –  IntervenTon:  36.6%  –  Control  arm:  43.4%  

•  No  SS  difference  in  secondary  outcomes  –  POMS,  infecTous  complicaTons,  criTcal  care  free  days  at  30d,  mortality  at  30d  

and  180d,  hospital  LOS  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 56: PINCER - Hot Topics

IVOIRE  Study  

•  Randomised,  open  study  

•  18  ICU’s  in  France,  Belgium  and  Netherlands  2005-­‐2010  

•  140  pts  with  sepTc  shock  &  AKI  •  HVHF  70mls/kg/hr  v  35mls/kg/hr    •  Slow  recruitment  

•  No  difference  in  mortality  =  40%  28/7  •  HVHF  not  recommended  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 57: PINCER - Hot Topics

Fluids  •  Don’t  give  too  much  

•  Don’t  give  too  liyle  •  Make  sure  you  give  the  right  

amount  

•  Starches  bad…very  bad    AssociaTon  of  HES  administraTon  with  mortality  and  AKI  in  criTcally  ill  paTents  requiring  volume  resuscitaTon.  Meta-­‐analysis.  JAMA  2013  vol  309  (7)  

•  Albumin  back  in?    SAFE  subgroup  analysis  1200  pts  with  severe  sepsis  -­‐  28/7  mortality  lower  in  albumin  group  (30%  vs.  35%  OR  0.87)    

 Finfer  S  et  al  2011  Intensive  Care  Med  37:86–96      Delayney  metaanalysis.  Role  of  albumin  as  a  resuscita>on  fluid  for  pa>ents  with  sepsis.  17  studies,  1977  pa>ents.  Crit  Care  Med  2011    Albios  Study  –  GaXnoni  (video  ion  ESICM  website)  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

“lets  talk  about  fluid  responsiveness”  

Page 58: PINCER - Hot Topics

ESICM  statement  on  colloids  

 1.  Recommend  not  to  use  HES  with  mw  ≥  200kDa  in  paTents  with  severe  sepsis  or  risk  of  AKI  

 2.  Suggest  avoid  6%  HES  or  gelaTn  in  these  groups  

 3.  Recommend  not  to  use  colloids  in  paTents  with  head  injury  and  not  to  administer  gelaTns  and  HES  in  orhan  donors  

 4.  Suggest  avoid  hyperoncoTc  soluTons  for  fluid  resuscitaTon  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 59: PINCER - Hot Topics

ALBIOS  

•  RCT,  100  ICUs  in  Italy  

•  Aug  2008  –  Feb  2012  

•  1818  paTents  with  severe  sepsis  

•  300mls  20%  HAS  daily  to  maintain  serum  albumin  at  30g/dl  +  CSL  vs.  CSL  •  Primary  outcome:  mortality  at  28d    

–  HAS  +  CSL:  31.8%  –  CSL:  32%  

•  Secondary  outcomes:  90  d  mortality  –  No  difference  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 60: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 61: PINCER - Hot Topics

6S  Study  •  804  ICU  pts  with  severe  sepsis  •  Compared  fluid  resuscitaTon    

–  130/0.4  hydroxyethyl  starch  (tetraspan)  vs  Ringer's  acetate  

•  HES  associated  with  –  Increased  90  day  mortality  

 51%  vs  43%  –  Increased  RRT  requirement  

 22%  vs  16%  

–  Trend  for  increased  bleeding    10%  vs  6%  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 62: PINCER - Hot Topics

CHEST  Study  •  7000  ICU  pts  •  Fluid  resuscitaTon  with  6%  HES  

130/0.4  (Voluven)  or  0.9%  saline  

•  No  differences  in  – Mortality  (HES  18%  vs  17%)  –  LOS  –  ICU  /  Hospital  

•  HES  associated  with  increased  –  RRT  (7%  vs  5.8%;  RR  1.21)  –  Pruritus  /  Rash  /  HepaTc  failure  

-­‐  Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 63: PINCER - Hot Topics

CRISTAL  Study  •  2857  sequenTal  ICU  paTents  

2003-­‐2012  57  ICU’s  

•  Colloids  vs  CSL  for  all  fluid  intervenTons  other  than  maintenance  

•  Colloids  –  Reduced  mortality  at  28d  &  90d  

 (25%  vs  27%  &  30%  vs  34%)  

–  More  days  alive  without  MV  

–  More  days  alive  without  vasopressors  

–  Less  RRT  

-­‐  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 64: PINCER - Hot Topics

GastrointensTnal  

Page 65: PINCER - Hot Topics

Need  a  nice  summary?  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Open  Access!#FOAMcc  

Page 66: PINCER - Hot Topics

CALORIES  •  Open,  mulTcentre,  RCT  

•  2400  paTents  in  33  ICUs  in  UK  •  PN  vs.  EN  within  36  hours  for  5/7  •  Primary  outcome:    

–  All  cause  mortality  33.1%  (PN)  vs.  34%  (EN)  

•  Secondary  outcome:    –  VomiTng  more  in  EN  

–  No  difference  on  other  16  outcomes  including  ‘serious’  hypoglycaemia  

–  NB  daily  calorific  targets  achieved  in  <40%  in  both  groups  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 67: PINCER - Hot Topics

The  SuDDICU  study  SDD  

 12  meta-­‐analyses  of  28  RCT’s.  10  show  reduced  pneumonia  rate;  6  show  morality  benefit  

•  Why  have  clinicians  avoided  implemenTng  it  in  UK?  

•  What  are  the  barriers?  

•  What  further  evidence  is  required  before  full  scale  clinical  implementaTon  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 68: PINCER - Hot Topics

VITdAL-­‐ICU  •  RCT,  Single  Centre  with  5  ICUs  in  

Austria,  475  paTents  

•  Vit  D  or  placebo    •  Primary  outcome:    

–  Hospital  LOS  no  different  •  Secondary  outcome.  No  difference:  

–  ICU  LOS  

–  ICU-­‐,  28d-­‐  ,  hospital-­‐  &  6  month-­‐  mortality  

•  Subgroup  analysis  –  If  severe  vit  D  def  and  given  Vit  D3  -­‐>  improvement  in  

28d-­‐  hospital-­‐  and  6  month-­‐  mortality  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 69: PINCER - Hot Topics

SystemaTc  review:  CCM  2010    In  those  paTents  receiving  enteral  nutriTon,  stress  ulcer  prophylaxis  may  not  be  required  and  may  actually  increase  VAP  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 70: PINCER - Hot Topics

H2R  antagonists  vs  PPI  

•  Cohort  Study  of  35,000  pts  •  MV  >  24  hours  and  either  H2R  antagonist  or  PPI  

•  H2R  antagonist  group  had  –  Less  GI  haemorrhage  2.1  vs  5.9%  

–  Pneumonia  27%  vs  39%  

–  C.Diff  2.2%  vs  3.8%  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 71: PINCER - Hot Topics

Acute  UGI  Bleed  

•  Randomised,  parallel  group  study  

•  921  pts  with  severe  upper  GI  bleeding  •  Compared  restricTve  (Hb  <7g/dL)  vs  liberal  

transfusion  strategy  (Hb<9g/dL)  

•  RestricTve  strategy  associated  with  

–  Reduced  number  of  pts  receiving  transfusion  (15%  vs  51%)  

–  Increased  probability  survival  (HR  0.55)  –  Less  rebleeding  (10%  vs  16%)  –  Less  adverse  events  (40%  vs  48%)  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 72: PINCER - Hot Topics

Hepatology  

•  ALD    Alcohol  related  illness  costs  NHS  £1.7  billion/year    

  SystemaTc  review  of  21  arTcles  

  Overall  ICU  mortality  40-­‐50%    

  Mackle  study  only  one  to  provide  data  on  GI  haemorrhage  -­‐  mortality  48%,  62%,  67%,68%  for  unit,  hospital,  6/12  and  one  yr  -­‐  if  get  out  of  hospital  most  will  survive  

  Organ  support  -­‐  3  papers  (venTlaTon,  vasoacTve  drugs,  RRT)  

  Mackle  -­‐          

-­‐  if  MV  and  vasoacTve  drugs  hospital  mortality  86%  

-­‐  If  MV,  vasoacTve  drugs  and  RRT  >  90%  

-­‐  If  just  MV  31%  

  Saliba  RRT  90%  

  Rye  100%  mortality  if  require  RRT  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 73: PINCER - Hot Topics

Intraabdominal  pressures  

Page 74: PINCER - Hot Topics

TRAUMA  

Page 75: PINCER - Hot Topics

PROPPR  •  RCT  in  12  N.  American  Level  1  

trauma  centres  

•  680  paTents  •  Transfusion  of  plasma:plts:PRBCs  •  1:1:1  vs.  1:1:2  •  Primary  outcome:    

-­‐  24  hour  and  30d  mortality  no  different  

•  Secondary  outcomes:  No  difference    Time  of  haemostasis;  Any  of  23  pre-­‐defined  complicaTons;  Hospital,  venTlator  &  ICU  free  days  

•  Post-­‐  hoc  analysis:  -­‐    Death  by  exasanguinaTon  in  1st  24  hrs  

much  less  in  1:1:1  group  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 76: PINCER - Hot Topics

PROPPR  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 77: PINCER - Hot Topics

TXA   CRASH  -­‐  2  Lancet  2010    

•  tranexamic  acid  in  reducing  transfusion  requirements  and  death  from  significant  haemorrhage  following  injury  

•  20,000  paTents  •  Risk  of  haemorrhage  reduced  by  0.8%  •  No  reducTon  in  transfusion  usage  •  Only  50%  received  blood  and  average  only  3  (?  ‘significant      haemorrhage’)  

 CRASH  -­‐  2  subanalysis    Lancet  2011  •  Mortality  directly  related  to  haemorrhage    •  Tranexamic  acid  only  effecTve  if  within  first  3  hours.  Beyond      this  Tme  mortality  increases  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 78: PINCER - Hot Topics

TXA   CRASH  –  2  Does  TXA  reduce  the  risk  of  intracranial  bleeding  in  paOents  with  TBI?  BMJ  2011    

•  250  of  the  20,000  paTents  eligible.    •  Brain  haemorrhage  growth  5mm  vs.  8mm  (TXA  vs.  placebo)  •  Not  SS  •  No  menTon  of  extent  of  extracranial  injuries  in  either  group  making  mortality  comparisons  difficult  

•  Not  well  matched  as  there  were  more  pts  with  SAH  (61%  vs  43%)  

•  No  increase  is  focal  cerebral  ischaemia  •  Conclusion  “it  is  probable  that  benefits  of  tranexamic  acid  outweigh  risks’  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 79: PINCER - Hot Topics

Trauma  Haemorrhage  

 1.  CoagulaTon  monitoring  and  measures  to  support  coagulaTon  should  be  implemented  early  

 2.  Damage  control  surgery    

 3.  Physiological  targets,  suggested  use  &  dosing  of  fluids,  blood  products  and  TXA  

 4.  PaTents  on  anTplatelet  agents  and/or  oral  anTcoagulants  require  special  ayenTon  

 5.  Mutlidisciplinary  approach  &  evidence  based  protocols  adapted  to  local  circumstances  need  to  be  developed  and  implemented  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 80: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

•  Transfusion  Triggers  

•  Blood  conservaTon  •  Pre-­‐transfusion  clinical  assessment  •  Rate  of  transfusion/fluid  balance  •  InvesTgaTon  adverse  events  •  Storage  duraTon  

Page 81: PINCER - Hot Topics

Neuro-­‐ICU  

ICP  Monitoring  

•  MulTcentre  RCT  of  324  paTents  Bolivia  and  Ecuador  

•  Intraparenchymal  ICP  monitoring  vs.  clinical  &  imaging  

•  No  difference  in  mortality  or  neuropsycholoigcal  status  at  6/12  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

A  Trial  of  Intracranial-­‐Pressure  Monitoring  in  TraumaTc  Brain  Injury  Randall  M.  Chesnut  et  al  N  Engl  J  Med  2012;  367:2471-­‐2481  

Page 82: PINCER - Hot Topics

Neuro  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

hyp://www.wessexics.com/WICS_Guidelines/  

The  SAH  secTon  definitely  worth  a  read  for  the  exam  

Page 83: PINCER - Hot Topics

CATIS  

•  4,071  paTents    •  Within  48  hrs  ischaemic  stroke    

•  nonthrombolysed  and  ↑BP  •  Hypertension  therapy  vs  no  BP  Rx  •  BP  control  effecTve  •  No  difference  

–  death  and  major  disability  

•  14  days  /  hospital  discharge  •  3  months  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 84: PINCER - Hot Topics

INTERACT  2  •  2,839  pts  with  early  spontaneous  

intracerebral  haemorrhage  &  ↑SBP  

•  Compared  SBP  <140  mmHg  vs  <180  •  Aggressive  BP  control  associated  with  

–  Trend  for  less  adverse  events  (p=0.06)  

–  Lower  modified  Rankin  scores  

•  No  difference  in  mortality  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 85: PINCER - Hot Topics

Magnesium  for  aneurysmal  SAH  (MASH-­‐2):  a  randomised  placebo-­‐controlled  trial  Mees  S  et  al.  2012  The  Lancet.  Vol  380  9834:44-­‐49  

•  8  ICU’s  in  Europe  and  S  America  

•  1204  paTents  

•  The  quesTon:  does  Mg  reduce  poor  outcome  by  reducing  vasospasm  and  delayed  cerebral  ischaemia  (DCI)  

•  Magnesium  64mmol/day  for  20/7  or  placebo  

•  Primary  outcome  of  poor  outcomes  as  defined  by  score  4-­‐5  on  modified  Rankin  Scale  at  3/12,  or  death  

•  NO  DIFFERENCE  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 86: PINCER - Hot Topics

Delirium  

HOPE  ICU  •  142  paTents  with  delirium  

•  CAM-­‐ICU  assessment  

•  Double  blinded  

•  Haloperidol  vs.  placebo  •  No  change  in  duraTon  of  delirium  

in  criTcally  ill  paTents  

•  Haloperidol  should  be  reserved  for  short  term  management  on  acute  agitaTon  

Effect  of  intravenous  haloperidol  on  the  duraOon  of  delirium  and  coma  in  criOcally  ill  paOents  (Hope-­‐ICU):  a  randomised,  double-­‐blind,  placebo-­‐controlled  trial  Valeirie  Page.  The  Lancet  Respiratory  Medicine,  Volume  1,  Issue  7,  Pages  515  -­‐  523,  September  2013    

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 87: PINCER - Hot Topics

TreaTng  Delirium  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

101  MV  paOents  RCT  haloperidol  vs.  ziprasidone  vs  placebo  21/7  study  period  No  difference  in  any  of  the  groups!  

Page 88: PINCER - Hot Topics

The  beginning;  Kress  NEJM  2000  ReducTon  in  LOS  

Girard  Lancet  2008  Decreased  ICU  stay,  Tme  on  venTlator  and  mortality  

Strom  Lancet  2010    ReducTon  in  LOS  and  venTlator  days  No  sedaTon  group  -­‐  boluses  of  morphine,  well  established  in  insTtuTon,  more  agitated  delerium  in  no  sedaTon  group  

Jacob  JAMA  2012  PRODEX/MIDEX  No  beyer  than  midaz  or  propofol  at  maintaining  light  to  mod  sedaTon  and  more  adverse  effects.  Increased  paTent  interacTons.  Less  vent  days  than  midazolam  

Ryker  JAMA  2009  ReducTon  in  venTlator  days  and  delirium  

Mehta  2013    For  MV  paTents  managed  with  protocolised  sedaTon,  the  additon  of  daily  sedaTon  interrupTon  did  not  reduce  duraTon  MV  or  ICU  LOS  

Page 89: PINCER - Hot Topics

The  beginning;  Kress  NEJM  2000  ReducTon  in  LOS  

Girard  Lancet  2008  Decreased  ICU  stay,  Tme  on  venTlator  and  mortality  

Strom  Lancet  2010    ReducTon  in  LOS  and  venTlator  days  No  sedaTon  group  -­‐  boluses  of  morphine,  well  established  in  insTtuTon,  more  agitated  delerium  in  no  sedaTon  group  

Jacob  JAMA  2012  PRODEX/MIDEX  No  beyer  than  midaz  or  propofol  at  maintaining  light  to  mod  sedaTon  and  more  adverse  effects.  Increased  paTent  interacTons.  Less  vent  days  than  midazolam  

Ryker  JAMA  2009  ReducTon  in  venTlator  days  and  delirium  

Mehta  2013    For  MV  paTents  managed  with  protocolised  sedaTon,  the  additon  of  daily  sedaTon  interrupTon  did  not  reduce  duraTon  MV  or  ICU  LOS  

Page 90: PINCER - Hot Topics

Don’t  forget  the  simple  things….  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

•  Small  RCT  136  paTents  

•  Used  NEECHAM  score  •  Delirium  (20%)  similar  but  less  mild  confusion  with  ear  plugs  and  good  night  sleep  <50%  vs.  25%  

Page 91: PINCER - Hot Topics

Guidelines  for  managing  delirium  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 92: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

CCM  2013  

Page 93: PINCER - Hot Topics

FuncTonal  disability  5  years  azer  ARDS  

  109  survivors  from  ’98  -­‐  ’01  

  Interview,  PFT’s,  6  min  walk  test,  resTng  &  exercise  oximetry,  chest  imaging,  QOL  survey  

  PFT’s  normalish  

  BUT  6  min  walk  test  76%  predicted,  physical/psychological  problems  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 94: PINCER - Hot Topics

Microbiology  

•  96  ICU’s  

•  Data  from  60,000  admissions  ’09-­‐’11  

•  Invasive  fungal  disease  defined  as  BC  or  sample  from  normally  sterile  site  showing  yeast/mould  cells  in  a  microbiological  or  histopathological  report  

•  383  (0.6%)  were  admiyed  with  or  developed  IFD  

•  Conclusion:  

 Incidence  of  IFD  in  non-­‐neutropenic,  criTcally  ill  paTents  is  low  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Page 95: PINCER - Hot Topics

5  steps  to  keep  up  with  the  literature  afer  the  exam  

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

1.  Sign  up  to  criTcalcarereviews.com  

2.  Check  out  emlitofnote.com,  The  Boyom  Line,  LITFL  &  ScanCrit  

3.  Read  N.Mays  blog  post  ‘Drinking  from  the  Firehose      hyp://stemlynsblog.org/keeping-­‐up-­‐with-­‐literature/  

4.  Get  a  twiyer  account  and  follow  #FOAMcc  &  #FOAMed      hyp://www.wessexics.com/Wessex_ICM_Blog/files/5af570b612a8f22d6841f96179a2fc92-­‐16.html  

5.  Podcasts  –  emcrit,  RAGE,  St.Emlyns,  CRIT-­‐IQ,  PHARM,  JICScast,  FOAMcast  to  start,  CriTcal  Care  PracTToner,  HEFT  EMCAST  

Page 96: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

&  Book  your  place  at  #smaccUS  &  ICSSOA2015  

Page 97: PINCER - Hot Topics

Academic Department of Critical Care Queen Alexandra Hospital Portsmouth

Best  of  Luck!  

www.wessexics.com  

@WessexICS  @WICSBoyomLine  

@stevemathieu75