PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District...

30
PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District Attorney’s Office APRIL 24, 2019

Transcript of PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District...

Page 1: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

PHILADELPHIACITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING:

District Attorney’s Office

APRIL 24, 2019

Page 2: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 2

Page 3: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 3

By Zip Code

33 Zip Codes

12 Zip Codes

3 Zip Codes

CHANGE IN VIOLENT CRIME RATES IN 2018(as compared to 2017)

_

Page 4: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

VIOLENT CRIME AND POVERTY IN PHILADELPHIA, 2018By Zip Code

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 4

Page 5: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 5

VIOLENT CRIME AND UNEMPLOYMENT IN PHILADELPHIA, 2018By Zip Code

Page 6: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 6

VIOLENT CRIME AND EDUCATION IN PHILADELPHIA, 2018By Zip Code

Page 7: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Diversity & Inclusion

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 7

Page 8: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Krasner New Hires(ADAs Only)

Increasing Diversity

g

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 8

DIVERSITY IN HIRING

Pre-Krasner (ADAs Only)

20%DIVERSE

Krasner New Hires

40%DIVERSE

INCREASE

Establishing a Diverse Pipeline

Broadened Geographic Reach

Started TargetingHBCUs

Bringing Locals Home

Pre-Krasner

30%DIVERSE

28%DIVERSE

INCREASE

Page 9: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 9

Page 10: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 10

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

Page 11: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 11

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

24%

Philadelphians

Page 12: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 12

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

5 out of 6

HBCU Law Schools

Page 13: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 13

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

5 out of 6

HBCU Law Schools

24%

Philadelphians

29

Total Law Schools

Page 14: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 14

53% FEMALE

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

DIVERSITY

INCOMING ADA CLASS (2019)

55%DIVERSE

45% MALE

2% NON-BINARY

GENDER

Page 15: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 15

BRINGING LOCALS HOME

Carla AgbiroNorthwestern School of Law

Page 16: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Tracking Achievements & Reform

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 16

Page 17: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

March 2019Reducing Mass

Supervision: Limiting

Probation & Parole

2018FEB

MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC

February 2018Reducing Mass Incarceration:

Charging, Sentencing, Diversion,

Bail Reform

TRACKING ACHIEVEMENTS & REFORM

February 2019Juvenile System Reforms

AMP Expansion (Diversion)

Evaluation of Bail Reform

Fighting Deed and House Thefts

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 17

April 2018Crime Victim Advisory

Committee

January 2019CARES Launch

Enforcing Failure to Report Lost

or Stolen Firearms

April 2019Predatory Business

Practices

October 2018Strengthening Investigations:

Dangerous Drug Offenders Unit

(Kip & Cambria)

2019JAN

FEB MAR APR

Page 18: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 18

INDIVIDUAL JUSTICE: SAFETY AND SAVINGS

• Reducing the future years of incarceration by nearly 2,000 years

• Reducing future years of probationby over 5,000 years

• Increasing the use of diversion by

approximately 25%

• Reducing the number of juvenilesheld in adult court by over 80%

Page 19: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

FUTURE YEARS & COSTS OF INCARCERATION

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 19

2014 2016 2018

Q2 2014: 4,256 imposed$182M cost

Q4 2018: 2,233 imposed$95M cost

Q1 2014: 4,146 imposed$177M cost

1,913fewer years of

incarceration were

imposed in Q4

2018 vs Q1 2014

$82Mlower cost of

incarceration per quarter

Q4 2017: 3,532 imposed$150M cost

Page 20: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

FUTURE YEARS & COSTS OF SUPERVISION

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 20

Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed$28M cost

Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed$13M cost

Q1 2014: 15,007 imposed$26M cost

7,341fewer years of

supervision were

imposed in Q4

2018 vs Q1 2014

$13.8Mlower cost of

supervision per quarter

Q4 2017: 12,455 imposed$21M cost

Page 21: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

FUTURE YEARS & COSTS OF PROBATION

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 21

2014 2016 2018

Q1 2014: 10,852 years imposed$10.9M cost

Q4 2018: 5,726 years imposed$5.7M cost

Each point in the chart represent the sum of all probation terms imposed in original sentences for the cases disposed in a given quarter. ”Per Disposed Case” figure represents the sum of all of probation terms imposed in original sentences for cases disposed in a given quarter

divided by the total cases disposed of in that quarter. “Disposed” cases in a quarter includes both cases that ended with a p lea or a trial as

well as cases that were sent to a diversion program, were dismissed or were otherwise dropped.

5,126fewer years of

probation imposed

in Q4 2018 vs Q1

2014

$5.1Mlower cost of

probation

per quarter

Q4 2017: 9,460 imposed$9.5M cost

Page 22: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 22

BAIL REFORM: PHASE 1

• Approximately 1,750 people charged with low-level offenses remained in their community

• Caused no increase in FTA Rate or Recidivism Rate

Page 23: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 23

REDUCING MASS INCARCERATION

• Philadelphia Jail population

reduced by 29% since January 2018

• This is roughly equal to the

percent change in the prior 6 years

• Reduced barriers to diversion

USE DIFFERENT PICTURE

HERE – THIS WOULD BE

GOOD FOR HOMICIDES OR

GUN VIOLENCE

Page 24: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia Daily Jail Population, 2012 – March 2019

Febru

ary 2

018 P

olic

y Initia

tives

Highlighted area is District Attorney Krasner’s Tenure

2016 201820142012

OVERALL REDUCTION IN COUNTY JAIL POPULATION

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 24

4,559

9,505

8,099

2012-2017: 32% total drop in county jail population

5% average annual drop in county jail population

29%drop in county jail

population since Jan. 2018

Page 25: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 25

STRENGTHENING INVESTIGATIONS: ECONOMIC CRIMES UNIT

Deed Theft“It robs low-income families, especially African Americans and Latinos [and the elderly], of the opportunity to build generational wealth.”

– DA Larry Krasner

Credit: The Inquirer | Daily News | Philly.com

Page 26: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 26

Predatory Business Practices“Ultimately, this is a story about greed… These scams have no place in our city, they tear down our city and will not be tolerated.”

– DA Larry Krasner

STRENGTHENING INVESTIGATIONS: ECONOMIC CRIMES UNIT

Page 27: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 27

DDOU Investigation

“…the hub of this criminal enterprise that was not only a threat to public safety, but an entity that created revenue to the tune of $5 million a year from the pain and misery that comes from drug and opioid addiction.”

– DA Larry Krasner

STRENGTHENING INVESTIGATIONS: DANGEROUS DRUG OFFENDERS UNIT

Page 28: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 28

31 YEAR OLD HOMICIDE COLD CASE

EL FREE TO ADD DIFFERENT PHOTO

Providing Victims Closure“Don't ever give up and if there is any information that might be helpful to us, something you may have heard that you never thought about before or something that you hear, bring it to us and we are happy to look at it…”

- ADA Anthony VociHomicide Supervisor

Page 29: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office | 29

• 63 fewer juveniles initiallycharged as adults in 2018 ascompared to 2017

• 83% decrease in juveniles whose cases remained in adult court following their preliminary hearing listing

• The number of juveniles from Philadelphia in placement facilities

decreased 44%

JUVENILE REFORM

Page 30: PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL BUDGET HEARING: District ...phlcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/DAO-FY20...Q2 2015: 16,388 imposed $28M cost Q4 2018: 7,666 imposed $13M cost Q1 2014:

QUESTIONS?

Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office |30