Petitioner P2 Memorial
Transcript of Petitioner P2 Memorial
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
1/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | i
TABLE OF CON TENTS
INDEX OF AUTHORITIES ..................................................... II
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ................................................... V
STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION ........................................ VII
SYNOPSIS OF FACTS ......................................................... VIII
STATEMENT OF ISSUES ...................................................... IX
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS ............................................... X
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED .................................................... 1
I. WHETHER THE DIVORCE NOT BEING IN CONFORMITY
WITH ISLAMIC LAW BE DECLARED AS A NULLITY?...........1
A. That Triple-talaq is not recognized under the Holy Quran,under any source of Shia Law and that the requisite procedurefor talaq under the Quran was not followed......................................1
II. WHETHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 2005 TO THE
EXTENT THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN BEYOND THE
PERIOD OF IDDAT IS AGAINST ARTICLE 25 OF THE
CONSTITUTION?............................................................2
A. That ight to eligion is su!"ect to pu!lic order, #oralityand health and su!"ect to the other pro$isions of %art &&& of the'onstitution of &ndia...................................................................................(). That the *o#estic +iolence Act, ( is applica!le tousli# wo#en............................................................................................../
III. WHETHER THE COURT SHOULD REJECT SHAHEENS
APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT AND
WHETHER AFREEN CAN BE MADE RESPONDENT UNDER
THE SAME ACT?............................................................!
A. The court should grant relief to Shaheen under the*o#estic +iolence Act, (..................................................................0
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
2/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | ii
). That the cousin can !e #ade a respondent under the Act.0'. That the apart#ent in reater %alash co#es under thede2nition of 3shared household4 under section (5s6 of the Act.0*. That the court should pass a protection order under
Section 17 and residence order under Section 18 of the Act.....
PRAYER ................................................................................... XI
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
3/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | iii
INDEX OF AUTHORIT IES
A. INDIAN CASES
1. Ajay Kumar Madanlal Bajla v. Mrs. Neha Vishal Bajla 2011(3)ALLMR303..........................5
2. Ali Nawaz v. Mohd. Yusuf P.L.D. 1963 S.C. 51.........................................................................2
3. Aziz Bano v. Muhammad (1925) 47 All. 823; 89 I.C. 690; (’25) A.A. 720...............................1
4. Danial Latifi and anr. v. Union of ndia! AIR2001SC3958.......................................................4
5. "veneet #in$h v %rashant &haudhri 177(2011)DLT124...........................................................5
6. 'ajendra #in$h v. Mina(shi Yadav MANU/RH/0338/2011......................................................5
7. )*al Bano v. #tate of U.%. and Anr (2007) 6 SCC 785............................................................4
8. sh+al #in$h Kahai v. ,amanjeet Kahai !P 576 "# 2011 $"%&' H*+ C",-.......................5
9. -aved /rs. v. #tate of 0aryana AIR 2003 SC 3057...............................................................3
10. -ohn Vallamattom v. Union of ndia (2003) 6 SCC 611............................................................3
11. Khushi Mohd. and /rs. v. #mt. Aneesha 2011 (3) C-% 7; MANU/RH/0485/2011...............4
12. Kunimohammed v. Ayisha(utty 2010 (2) HC 63.....................................................................2
13. Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. #hah Bano Be$um and /rs (1985) 2 SCC 556.....................................4
14. N. Adithyan v. 1ravan2ore Devaswom Board /rs (2002 8 SCC 106)...................................3
15. Nur Ali 3Md4 v. 1ham*al #ana Bi*i 2007 (1) LT 508.............................................................2
16. %. Ba*u Ven(atesh /rs. v. ,ani 20082L!(C-l)451............................................................6
17. ,amesh Da$a v ,ameshwari Bai(2005) 4 SCC 772................................................................6
18. ,iaz 5atma v. Mohammed #harif I (2007) DMC 26; 135 (2006) DLT 205..............................2
19. ,u(ia Khatun v. A*dul Khali)ue Las(ar (1981) 1 ',. L.R. 375;............................................2
20. #.,. Batra v. 1aruna Batra (2007) 3 S.C.C. 169........................................................................6
21. #amar 'hosh v. -aya 'hosh (2007) 4 SCC 511........................................................................6
22. #andhya Manoj 6an(hade v. Manoj Bhimrao 6an(hade And /thers (2011) 3 SCC 650........5
23. #arat2handra Mishra v #tate of /rissa(2006) 1 SCC 638........................................................6
24. #atya v. #iri ,am AIR 1983 P H 252.........................................................................................6
25. #ha*ana Bano v. mran Khan AIR2010SC305.........................................................................3
26. #hamim Ara v. #tate of U.%. and Anr (2002) 7 SCC 513...........................................................2
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
4/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | iv
27. #mt. #arita v. #mt. Umrao 2008 (1) R. C-. D 97........................................................................5
28. #ri -iauddin Ahmed v. Mrs. Anwara Be$um (1981) 1 LR 358...............................................2
29. #uman Ka+oor v. #udhir Ka+oor AIR 2009 SC 589.................................................................6
30. #yed Md. Nadeem 7 Mohsin and /rs. v. #tate and Anr MANU/D/2460/2011......................4
31. Ummer 5aroo)ue v. Naseema 2005 (4) LT 565......................................................................2
B. BOOKS
1. $ASU DD CNSTITUTINAL LA! I NDIA’ (!ADH!A A ND CMPAN 7TH DITIN
NAPUR ) (R P. 2003)
2. MULLA PRINCIPLS MAHMDAN LA! (LIS NIS $UTTR!RTHS I NDIA 19+
DN. 16+ R PRINT N! DLHI) (2007)
3. NARAANA P. S. LA! DI:RC IN I NDIA (IA LA! ANC I NDIA HDRA$AD)(2007)
4. $ASHI P.M. TH CNSTITUTIN I NDIA (U NI:RSAL LA! PU$LISHIN C. I NDIA 8TH
DN N! DLHI) (2007)
C. DICTIONARIES
1. AIAR R AMANATHA P. 810" LA6 L"9&/N: !ADH!A < CMPAN 2 ND DN. NAPUR
(2002).
2. $LAC HNR CAMP$LL BLA&K# LA6 D&1/NA,Y ’ 6TH DN. CNTNNIAL D.
(18911991).
3. CUR=N. L. $ 8D&1/NA,Y /5 LA6: PITMAN PU$LISHIN 4TH DN. N! DLHI
(1994).4. ARNR $RAN A. 8A D&1/NA,Y /5 M/D",N L"'AL U#A'": RD
U NI:RSIT PRSS 2 ND DN. RD (1995).5. RN$R DANIL AND ALANDRA MILL$R 8#1,/UD;# -UD&AL
D&1/NA,Y /5 6/,D# %0,A#"#: :L. 2 6TH DN. LNDN S!T < MA!LL
(2000).6. >USTIC DSAI M.C. AND AIAR SU$RAMANAM ? LA6 L"9&/N L"'AL MA9M# @
2 ND DN. DLHI DLHI LA! HUS (1980).
7. MITRA $.C. < MITRA A.C. 8L"'AL 10"#A,U#: U NI:RSIT $ ALLAHA$AD
(1997).
8. MS LI=A$TH M. ?&LA##5&A1/N 10"#AU,U# 5/, L"'AL MA1",AL@ 3RD
DN. LNDN $!R SAUR (1992).
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
5/18
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
6/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | vi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
A.I.R. A LL NDA , "%/,1",
All A LLA0ABADAll E.R. A LL " N'LAND , "%/,1",
AP A ND0,A % ,AD"#0
Bom B/MBAY
C.L.R. & /MM/N6"AL10 L A6 , "%/,1",
Cal & AL&U11A
Co. & /M%ANY
Comm. & /MM##/N",
CWN & AL&U11A 6 ""KLY N /1"#
Del D "L0
Edn. " D1/N
e.g. "9"M%LUM ',A1A 3 5/, "9AM%L" 4
K.B. K N'# B"N&0
Lah L A0/,"
LR L A6 , "%/,1",
Mad M AD,A#
MANU MANU%A1,A
M.P. M AD0YA % ,AD"#0
Pat % A1NA
PC % ,VY & /UN&L
p. % A'"
Para. % A,A',A%0 Pn % UN-AB AND 0 A,YANA
!C # U%,"M" &/U,1
!CC # U%,"M" &/U,1 &A#"#
!CN # 0/6 & AU#" N /1&"
U.P. U 11A, % ,AD"#0
W.L.R. 6 ""KLY L A6 , "%/,1#
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
7/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | vii
STATEMENT O F JURISD ICTION
SSHAHNHAHN HASHAS APPRACHDAPPRACHD THTH HHNN’’$L$L HHIHIH CCURTURT N NA:A: DDALLALL UNDR UNDR AARTICLRTICL 226226 THTH
CCNSTITUTINNSTITUTIN II NDIA NDIA. T. THH MATTR MATTR HASHAS $N$N CNNCTDCNNCTD !ITH!ITH ANTHR ANTHR RLATDRLATD !!RITRIT PPTITINTITIN
ANDAND HASHAS $N$N LISTDLISTD R R INALINAL DISPSALDISPSAL. A. ARTICLRTICL 226226 THTH CCNSTITUTINNSTITUTIN II NDIA NDIA RADSRADS ASAS
HRUNDR HRUNDR
226. P226. P"WER "WER "#"# $$I%$I%$ CC"UR&!"UR&! &"&" I!!UEI!!UE CER&AINCER&AIN WRI&!WRI&!.' .' 3
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
8/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | viii
SYNOPSIS OF FACTS
!haheen and !oha(l S+'+ ' +' M,l% %'-- S"+'l ' , M,l%. S+'+
E", - "# A#- B+" S"+'l’ E", - " %'-'l .
Relo)at(on to Na*( Dall+ T+ E",l -l"E' " N' D'll ' '- l* ' 1 $H
''-% -'- P'l'+ "B & A%- S"+'l’ &-"+- ' -%' EJ "# U &, +
%''E E+'-* "# + #l' B- ' & S"+'l. T+ +' *" ' #l' l"- :'-
:+'- K" P+' 3. S"+'l , ' -*- '--+ -- S"+'l < S'+l
A"E' B+ S"+'l’ E"ll* #- S'+l.
&he D(,pte A#- -l"E'" " N' D'll S+'+ B' " +' ' E+l ' ' ' +"%
B+l S"+'l +",*+ B' "" '-l l'* " %' +' '-*,%. A#- B'
,,EE#,l -* &B B". N"%&- 10 2010 S"+'l ' S+'+ +' '
+' '-*,% "- + '% ,. A#- + '-*,% S"+'l -,- '#- 2 +",- #-"% '
B'lF ' "-E S+'+ B+ +- -"",E% "# ?tala)@. A#- B' ' B " +
' E", " l + ' ''-%. S"+'l %" ", "# + +", ' '- l* ' '
- *, +", #-"% + '--+ #-%.
#(l(ng o- the ,(t S+'+ #l ' 'lE'" ,- D"%E :"lE AE 2005 &#"-
M'*-' N' D'll " -#-' S"+'l ' A#- #-"% "* +- #-"% +- ''-%
' '-"'E+ El E",- " * ' El'-'" +' + "-E ' ,ll B+E+ B' #
& S"+'l. S"+'l '-*, +' D"%E :"lE AE 2005 " + K +' * -*+ "
B"% &" + -" "# iddat '*' + #,'%'l -*+ " -'E + -l*" B+l
A#- '-*, +' + E'’ & %' -" ,- D"%E :"lE AE.
Wr(t pet(t(on, S+'+ #l ' B- " E+'ll** + "-- "# + Cl >,* D-E
C",- "# N' D'll. S"+'l #l ' B- " E+'ll** + D"%E :"lE AE 2005.
$"+ %'- +' & E"E & ' "-- "# + N' D'll H*+ C",- ' '- l
"*+- #"- #'l "'l.
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
9/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | ix
STATEMENT OF ISSUES
TH APPLLANTS RSPCTULL ASS TH HN’$L SUPRM CURT I NDIA TH
LL!IN USTINS
I!!UE / II!!UE / I
W$E&$ER &$E DI0"RCE N"& BEIN% IN C"N#"RMI&1 WI&$W$E&$ER &$E DI0"RCE N"& BEIN% IN C"N#"RMI&1 WI&$I!LAMIC LAW BE DECLARED A! A NULLI&1I!LAMIC LAW BE DECLARED A! A NULLI&1
ISSUE – 2ISSUE – 2
WHETHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 200 TO THE EXTENTWHETHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 200 TO THE EXTENT
THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN BEYOND THE PERIOD OFTHAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN BEYOND THE PERIOD OF
IDDAT IS AGAINST ARTICLE 2 OF THE CONSTITUTION!IDDAT IS AGAINST ARTICLE 2 OF THE CONSTITUTION!
ISSUE – "ISSUE – "
WHETHER THE COURT SHOULD REJECT SHAHEEN#SWHETHER THE COURT SHOULD REJECT SHAHEEN#S
APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT ANDAPPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT AND
WHETHER AFREEN CAN BE MADE RESPONDENT UNDER THEWHETHER AFREEN CAN BE MADE RESPONDENT UNDER THE
SAME ACT!SAME ACT!
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
10/18
- P RELIMINARIES A DVANCED- Page | x
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS
NNULLITY ULLITY OFOF DDIVORCEIVORCE
I +,%&l ,&% +' %' E+"l'- "# M'+"%' l'B +' +l +' -l tala)
+' " ,-'E &' #'E "-E +' & E+'-'E-J ' - &'l ' %'--'* +' &
E-& ' ' #unnat. T-ltala) K-l &'-- ,- S+' l'B. ,-+- + ?uran
-E-& ' E-' -"E,- " & #"ll"B &#"- "-E* + B# B+E+ +' & ,+l
& %' E",- + E",- ' B+E+ B' " #"ll"B & S"+'l.
DDOMESTICOMESTIC VVIOLENCEIOLENCE AACTCT BEINGBEING AAGAINSTGAINST AARTICLERTICLE 22 OFOF THETHE
CCONSTITUTIONONSTITUTION..
I ,&% +' A-El 25 " " E"#- ' '&"l, -*+ ' ,&GE " "E'l
-#"-% '%"* "+- +* ' Bll +-#"- & ,&GE " &#E'l l*l'". T+- '
E" &B -l*", -'EE ' -l*", &l# ' A-El 25 '##"- -"E"
"l " -l*", &l#.
RREJECTIONEJECTION OFOF SSHAHEENHAHEEN##SS APPLICATIONAPPLICATION UNDERUNDER THETHE DDOMESTICOMESTIC VVIOLENCEIOLENCE AACTCT ANDAND AAFREENFREEN##SS STATUSSTATUS OFOF RRESPONDENTESPONDENT..
I +,%&l ,&% +' S+'+ ' E% "# "%E "lE. ,-+- + -'-
P'l'+ ''-% E"% B+ + #" "# ?+'- +",+"l@ ,- + D"%E
:"lE AE 2005. L'l A#- E' & %' ' -" ,- + AE.
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
11/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 1 o 5-
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED
I.I. WHETHER THE DIVORCE NOT BEING INWHETHER THE DIVORCE NOT BEING IN
CONFORMITY WITH ISLAMIC LAW BE DECLAREDCONFORMITY WITH ISLAMIC LAW BE DECLARED
AS A NULLITY!AS A NULLITY!
A.A. TTHATHAT TTRIPLERIPLE--TALAQTALAQ ISIS NOTNOT RECOGNIZEDRECOGNIZED UNDER UNDER THETHE HHOLY OLY QQURANURAN,,
UNDER UNDER ANY ANY SOURCESOURCE OFOF SSHIA HIA LL AW AW AND AND THATTHAT THETHE REQUISITEREQUISITE PROCEDUREPROCEDURE FOR FOR
TALAQTALAQ UNDER UNDER THETHE QQURANURAN WAS WAS NOTNOT FOLLOWEDFOLLOWED..
1. I %" +,%&l ,&% +' ' - SE" 2 "# + M,l% P-"'l L'B (S+'-')
AlE'" AE 1937
NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
M,l% -"'l l'B Bll & 'lE'&l "+ ' ,. I #,-+- ,&% +' ' 'l %'--'* +' & "l%J &B '
S, %'l ' ' S+' #%'l. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT I Aziz Bano v. Muhammad +
E",- E B+ '-"'l A%- Al’ E"%%'- " + M,+'%%'' L'B B+E+ ' +'
S+' ' S, %' -%'-- B+", ' E+'* "# E "-
E"%%,". NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
2. I ,&% +' M,l% l'B - " + #",-#"l ll'- "# + fi)h '%l1 + ?uran
3(ita*4! + #unna 3hadith4 N/1","5 ,ef=
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
12/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 2 o 5-
+ ?uran B l""F ' + -'" "# + P-"+ (hadith4 ' # + -"&l% +' " "l,"
+- "# + B" + l -"- 'F " jma. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT I
,&% +' +- " ?urani2 &' " '&l+ +' +- "-E " ' *l "EE'"
+",l '%", " ' --"E'&l "-E; #'E + P-"+ l"-
"-E NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT ' E-& %'--'* NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT '
+ #unnat .
3. I &E+ +' ' - + ?uran! +- %, & ##"- "B'- -E"El'" &B +
"-E. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT T+ B +' & ,+l & + E",- #hamim Ara v.
#tate of U.%. and Anr N/1","5 ,ef=
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
13/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 3 o 5-
4. I ,&% +' + ' E' S+'+ &* ' S+' + #"-% "# tala) Bll & 'l
E " -E"*J ,- S+' l'B. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT ,-+- + "-E
%, & -' ' ' ,ll E +- B' +- ' '% " -E"El'" "- B' '
-'" '* #"- + "-E. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
II.II. WHETHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 200 TOWHETHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 200 TO
THE EXTENT THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMENTHE EXTENT THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN
BEYOND THE PERIOD OF IDDAT IS AGAINSTBEYOND THE PERIOD OF IDDAT IS AGAINST
ARTICLE 2 OF THE CONSTITUTION!ARTICLE 2 OF THE CONSTITUTION!
A A TTHATHAT R R IGHTIGHT TOTO R R ELIGIONELIGION ISIS SUBJECTSUBJECT TOTO PUBLICPUBLIC ORDER ORDER ,, MORALITY MORALITY AND AND
HEALTHHEALTH AND AND SUBJECTSUBJECT TOTO THETHE OTHER OTHER PROVISIONSPROVISIONS OFOF PP ART ART IIIIII OFOF THETHE
CCONSTITUTIONONSTITUTION OFOF IINDIA NDIA ..
5. I +,%&l ,&% +' A-El 25(1) *,'-' " - -" ?+ #-"% "#
E"EE@ ' ?+ -*+ #-l " -"# -'EE ' -"'*' -l*".@ I -aved /rs. v.
#tate of 0aryana N/1","5 ,ef=
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
14/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 4 o 5-
E"," E",- %, #'",- --'" "# ', " ' " #"- ,#"-% -"'l
l'B. I -ohn Vallamattom v. Union of ndia N/1","5 ,ef=
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
15/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 5 o 5-
AE , + B"- ?'**- -"@ 'll"B* ' B %"- "# + -% +, E"-* '
#%'l.
III.III. WHETHER THE COURT SHOULD REJECTWHETHER THE COURT SHOULD RE JECT
SHAHEEN#S APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTICSHAHEEN#S APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTICVIOLENCE ACT AND WHETHER AFREEN CAN BEVIOLENCE ACT AND WHETHER AFREEN CAN BE
MADE RESPONDENT UNDER THE SAME ACT!MADE RESPONDENT UNDER THE SAME ACT!
A A TTHEHE COURTCOURT SHOULDSHOULD GRANTGRANT RELIEFRELIEF TOTO SSHAHEENHAHEEN UNDER UNDER THETHE DDOMESTICOMESTIC
V V IOLENCEIOLENCE A A CTCT, 2005., 2005.
8. I +,%&l ,&% +' S+'+ ' E% "# "%E "lE B+E+ +' & #lE
," +- & S"+'l ' A#-. T+- ' -'"'&l '-+" +' + Bll & "
#-"% +- +'- +",+"l & + -". ,-+- ,- + D"%E :"lE AE 2005+ E", E' & %' ' -".
C.C. TTHATHAT THETHE COUSINCOUSIN CANCAN BEBE MADEMADE A A RESPONDENTRESPONDENT UNDER UNDER THETHE A A CTCT
9. U- E" 2 + AE ' E"%l' E' & #l '*' ' -l' "# + +,&' B+" +'
--' + "lE. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT T+ H"&l AK C",- #andhya
Manoj 6an(hade v. Manoj Bhimrao 6an(hade And /thers N/1","5 ,ef=
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
16/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 6 o 5-
+ &GE ' R'" "# + AE. SE" 17 'E ' -*+ " -E #'",- "# B"%.
T+ 'E% &* ' &#E'l " + C",- +",l F " ,+"l + '-l'%'-
" -'+- +' E"#* l'* " #'* + "&GE "# +
l'B. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
11. I ,&% +' S"+'l + deJfa2to "B- "# + -'- P'l'+ ''-%. H ' +
lE-E E+'-* B'- 'K +", 'K ' %''E. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT A%-
' -%' - "# U *"% ' +' " l + ' #l'. I ' '&l+
-El "# l'B +' B+' E'" & " -El E'" & 'E+ -El +-",*+
-''*%. I# + C",- E' l""F &" + #'E ' ' * E' E"El, +' + "-'ll
E"E, "# E-E,%'E ,** %',l'" & + +,&' "- + -l' " #' '
-*+ +- + B# " ' "-- ,- SE" 19 ,E+ ?l#* "# + l@ +",l &
-"- ".
NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
I El'- +' + S"+'l -'#-- + +", ,- + &-"+-’ '% * " #' S+'+’ -*+ " - +- ' -"- " S+'+’
"" &"+ '- - G"l + +",+"l. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
12. !+", -G,E " + '&" Q,'* ?G" #'%l@ + AE " ' ?H, U
'%l@ B",l E+'* + E,l'- ',- "# + AE. I " '" + '"%'l +' P'-l'%
El'-# +' --E "# l "# + ?-"@ " + ?+'- +",+"l@ ' -"E"
"-- E' & %' ,- SE" 19(1)('). NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT I +' & -,l &
+ S,-% C",- -'l G,*% +' ' G,*% " " & -' ' ' ', E +
#'E,'l %'-K 'l" %"-'. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT I %"-' +-#"- "
*,+ + - E' #-"% + #.,. Batra v. 1aruna Batra N/1","5 ,ef=
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
17/18
- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED- Page 7 o 5-
E.E. TTHATHAT THETHE COURTCOURT SHOULDSHOULD PASSPASS A A PROTECTIONPROTECTION ORDER ORDER UNDER UNDER SSECTIONECTION
$%$% AND AND RESIDENCERESIDENCE ORDER ORDER UNDER UNDER SSECTIONECTION $&$& OFOF THETHE A A CTCT
13. S+'+ +' & ' ?"%E -l'"+@ NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT B+ + +,&'
' ' E% "# "%E "lE ' +' ,##- ?-&'l ' %""'l '&,@ ' ?%'l
+'-%@. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT Ul'-'l E" "# + +,&' "- B# " -#, "
+' E+l- %' '%", " %'l E-,l. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT I# +,&'
l&-'l ' E"l -#, " '# B# ',-'l ' l*%' E-'* " +' '
E+l + -'" -,E +- " '- ' %',-l '##E +- %'l
+'l+. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT
14. I +,%&l ,&% +' + C",- %' ' ' -"E" "-- ,- E" 18 " -"E
'EE " + E%’ '. ,-+- + C",- %' ' ' -E "-- ,- E" 19
-"E +- #-"% &* ". A - "vneet #in$h! + B# l " -E ' -"- E"%%,-' B+ +- l#l ' +- E,-- -E. T+, ll 'l-'
'EE"%%"'" ''l'&l B# +",l & l " - + +'- +",+"l.
NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT S E" 2(') ' 2(#) "# + AE
NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT S E" 3() ' Kl''" I "#
E" 3 "# + AE NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #amar 'hosh v. -aya 'hosh (2007) 4
SCC 511; #uman Ka+oor v. #udhir Ka+oor AIR 2009 SC 589
NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #atya v. #iri ,am AIR 1983 P H 252
-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-
-
8/20/2019 Petitioner P2 Memorial
18/18
-P RA!ER- -Page | xi-
PRAYER
HEREFORE IN THE LIGHT OF THE ISSUES RAISED, ARGUMENT
ADVANCED, REASONS GIVEN AND AUTHORITIES CITED, THIS
HON’BLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED TO99 && "" $$ " L D" L D THAT THE DIVORCE IS A NULLITY . THAT BENEFITS CONFERRED BEYOND THE PERIOD OF I DDAT ARE NOT AVERSE
TO A RTICLE 25. THAT A FREEN CAN BE MADE A RESPONDENT UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
ACT.
&& "" PP A ! !A ! !
A PROTECTION ORDER UNDER SECTION 18 OF THE DOMESTIC V IOLENCE A CT,
2005. A RESIDENCE ORDER UNDER SECTION 19 OF THE DOMESTIC V IOLENCE A CT,
2005.
&& "" !! E &E & AA ! I D E! I D E
THE ORDER PASSED BY THE LD. CIVIL JUDGE, DISTRICT COURT OF N AVY D ALLY .
MM I ! C E L L A N E " U !I ! C E L L A N E " U !
A ND ANY OTHER RELIEF THAT THIS HON’BLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED TO GRANT INTHE INTERESTS OF JUSTICE, EUITY AND GOOD CONSCIENCE
A LL OF WHICH IS RESPECTFULL! SUBMITTED.
CCOUNSELSOUNSELS FOR FOR THETHE SSHAHEENHAHEEN ' O' OTHERSTHERS
-WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE SHAHEEN & OTHERS-