Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

8
Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion

description

But shopping for health is problematic because Information asymmetries Power unequal Very unequal vulnerabilities

Transcript of Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

Page 1: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

Personal health budgets and clinicians

Dr Paul HodgkinSheffield GP

Chief ExecutivePatient Opinion

Page 2: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.
Page 3: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

But shopping for health is problematic because

•Information asymmetries

•Power unequal

•Very unequal vulnerabilities

Page 4: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

“The health economist’s search for the rational consumerof health care is like the search for powdered unicorn horn - never ending, and always destined for disappointment”

Robert Evans Canadian Health Care economist

Page 5: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

So how can we get the benefits of personal healthbudgets without the problems?

By careful extension out from what we have learnt insocial care

By mapping where it helps and where it does not

By having a variety of budget holders

Page 6: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

Life enhancing today

Avoiding death tomorrow

Best solution known/Good evidence

Best solution unknown/No evidence

Co-create using small budget

Significant Discretionary

budget

Vouchers and menu based care+/- discretionary budget Accept/decline

best practice advice

Multiple Co-morbidities

Worried well

screening

Medical aspectsof individual LTC

Much mental health

Life style: obesity, exercise, smoking

Palliative care

Page 7: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

Budget held by professionals

Budget held by client, patient or non-professionals

Palliative care

Exercise ObesitySmoking

StableLTC

+mental Health

Provider market highly regulated

Provider market less regulated

Page 8: Personal health budgets and clinicians Dr Paul Hodgkin Sheffield GP Chief Executive Patient Opinion.

Thank you

Dr Paul Hodgkin

[email protected]