Performing a Community Health Assessment

Performing a Community

Assessment:

Curriculum Overview

Step 1: Develop a Community Partnership

Identify stakeholders

Form a Community Partnership

Assess Partnership’s individual and organizational capacity

Identify benefits and risks

Step 1 Planning Worksheet – Community Partnership Organizational Chart

Step 2: Determine Your Focus

Identify and prioritize community public health needs

Define the problem

Create realistic and achievable goals and objectives

Step 2 Planning Worksheet – Issues, Problems, Goals and Objectives

Step 3: Identify the Information (Data) You Need Articulate the primary questions you would like

to answer

Identify what type of data you will need

Identify data sources

Step 3 Planning Worksheet – Questions, Data Types and Data Sources

Step 4: Determine How to Get the Information (Collect Data) Identify what new data

will need to be collected

Select the appropriate data collection method(s)

Revisit steps 1-3 to make sure you’re on track

Step 4 Planning Worksheet – Data Collection Plan

Step 5: Determine How to Understand the Information (Analyze Data)

Check the data

Go back to the primary assessment questions

Reduce the amount of data

Analyze the data

Verify findings

Interpret findings and draw conclusions

Step 5 Planning Worksheet – Data Analysis Plan

Step 6: Determine How to Use and Communicate Results Identify assessment products

Identify target audiences

Present your findings

Determine next steps

Celebrate and acknowledge your work!

Step 6 Planning Worksheet – Ways to Report the Results to Target Audiences

Appendices A. Data Collection Methods:

– Asset Mapping– Focus Groups– Surveys– Key Informant Interviews– Rapid Appraisal– Community Forums

B. Computer Software to Compile and Analyze Data

C. Materials for Step 5 Data Analysis Exercises

D. Ethical Considerations in Human Subjects Research

E. Resources

Introduction

What is a community? How do you define your

community?

Introduction: What is a Community Assessment?

Process of collecting, analyzing and reporting information about the needs, strengths and assets of a community

Purpose: to identify unmet needs and plan/prioritize ways to meet them

Should be driven by community leaders

Should actively involve community members

Also called a “Community Needs Assessment”

Introduction: Why Do a Community Assessment?

To identify new community public health issues

To better understand known community public health issues

To learn more about the priorities, assets, and concerns of community member

To offer solutions for addressing unmet health needs

To gain community member support for health improvement solutions

Introduction: Why Do a Community Assessment? To collaborate with essential community

health leaders and partner organizations

To convince funders to provide you with needed resources

To convince policymakers and other decision-makers to provide your community with needed programs or services

Your community asked you to do it

You have already received funds to conduct a community assessment

Introduction: What Resources Will I Need?

Will depend on your size and focus

Will depend on the collective resources of your planning group

This curriculum emphasizes a collaborative approach to maximize the collective resources available

A grant may assist you if you need to do a larger assessment than you have resources

If applying for a grant is out of the question, then settle on a smaller assessment

Introduction: How Do I Use This Curriculum?

Complete each of the six step worksheets to create an assessment workplan

Complete the six steps in the order most appropriate for your group and context

Think of this as a dynamic process where the completion of each step informs each of the previous and subsequent steps

If not planning an assessment right away, use this curriculum as a reference for any future assessment or research activities

Introduction: Training Goal

To help participants plan and conduct a community assessment

Introduction: Training Objectives

Upon completion of this workshop, participants will be able to:

1. Develop a Community Partnership to plan and conduct a community assessment

2. Develop goals and objectives to focus the community assessment

3. Identify good sources of secondary (existing) data and determine need to collect primary (new) data

4. Identify appropriate methods for collecting primary data

5. Identify appropriate methods for analyzing data

6. Identify appropriate ways to report results and identify target audiences

7. Complete a community assessment plan

Step 1: Develop a Community Partnership

Step 1.1: Identify Stakeholders Stakeholders: Persons or

organizations with a stake in the community assessment

Step 1.1: Identify Stakeholders

Examples:

– Community leaders or community members

– Policy makers or decision-makers

– Health agencies

– Other community-based organizations, non-profits

– Neighborhood or civic associations

– Voluntary groups

– Religious organizations

– Many others…

Step 1.1: Discussion Questions for Identifying Stakeholders 1. What defines your community?

2. What social institutions exist in your community? Which impact health? Which have an interest in health issues?

3. What clubs, associations, organizations, voluntary groups, support groups and faith-based organizations exist in your community?

Step 1.1: Discussion Questions for Identifying Stakeholders3. Who are respected leaders in your

community? Who do community members go to for support or guidance?

4. Who influences decisions in your community?

Step 1.1: Discussion Questions for Identifying Stakeholders

6. Who of the above would have the most expertise to conduct a community assessment?

7. Who of the above must be involved to conduct a community assessment?

8. Who of the above would most use the results of a community assessment?

9. Who has a positive image and respected reputation in the community?

Step 1.1: Discussion Questions for Identifying Stakeholders

Look at the individuals and organizations mentioned in questions 6-9. These are your community assessment stakeholders.

Step 1.2: Form a Community Partnership Community Partnership: A

collaboration of people and/or organizations that work together while still keeping their separate identities. Also called a “Collaborative” or “Collaboration”.

Step 1.2: Form a Community Partnership Community Partner: One member of the

Partnership

Benefits of engaging stakeholders into a Community Partnership:– Pool resources and skills– Expand the reach and acceptability of the

assessment– Assures the assessment reflects diverse

community beliefs and meets diverse community needs

– Make sure results and reports are widely distributed

Step 1.2: Form a Community Partnership

Invite all stakeholders to participate

Determine what level of participation each wants to contribute

Assess collective resources and skills

Seek out additional community stakeholders if additional resources or skills would help to plan and conduct the community assessment

Benefits of keeping an open invitation to

identified stakeholders

Controversial relationships and issues can be addressed openly and early

The perspectives and values of everyone are considered

Stakeholders make contribution to and have ownership of the plan

You probably will need all the major players in your community to conduct a needs assessment

Opposing views are understood and addressed more easily

Characteristics of a Successful Collaboration

Shared goals and interests

Inclusive governance

Shared responsibility and input

Shared ownership and commitment

Trust

Balance of power and influence

On-going management and support

Clear roles and responsibilities

Set ground rules for maintaining a safe atmosphere

Active participation

Good leadership

Good consensus building and conflict resolution

Step 1.3: Assess Partnership’s Capacity

Important to determine the amount of resources, time and capacity each can actually provide to this effort

Important to assess even if your Community Partnership has already been formed or even worked together before

Will identify Partnership strengths and assets

Will identify Partnership limitations

Will help to overcome limitations or invite more Partners

Will help Partnership to see where everyone is coming from

Will help to see the potential reach of the assessment results


Mission – What is their organizational mission?

Clientele - What community or population(s) do they serve?

Funding - Does their current funding situation allow for them to be involved and at what level? Can they dedicate any funding or other resources to this effort? Are there any conflicts of interest?


Staffing - Do they have staff who can dedicate some of their time to the assessment? If so, what skills do they possess that could be useful to the assessment?

Organizational Support - What role can their current work play in the assessment process? What kind of organizational support can they dedicate to the assessment? Can they dedicate office space?

Research - Do they have any data research capacities? (data collection, data management, data analysis, report writing, other)

Step 1.3: Assess Partnership’s Capacity Technology - Do they have any computer

or other technology that could be useful to the assessment? Can they dedicate any of this technology or the use of it?

Media - Can they offer access to the media for assessment efforts? These could mean contacts within radio, television or newspaper media outlets, or any other ability to get press coverage.


Allies - Do they have a community advisory board or highly involved clientele? Can those allies lend any support or strength to the Partnership or assessment process?

Interests - What is their particular interest in the community assessment? What would they like to see happen as a result of participating in this process?

Involvement - How would they like to be involved in this effort? What level and type of involvement can they commit?

Step 1.4: Identify Benefits and Risks

Working well in a Community Partnership is about maximizing benefits and minimizing risks


Think through ahead of time the potential benefits and risks for:– Community partners– Community residents– Community leaders and advocates– Public health professionals and

agencies– Health service providers– Elected and appointed officials


Examples of benefits:– Greater understanding of health assets and needs

– Community advocates will have the data they need to advocate

– Public health agencies will have the data they need to plan

Examples of risks:– Providers may not share valuable data

– Elected officials may feel findings reflect badly on them

– Community members may feel hostile toward Partnership if not included or findings not used to their benefit

Group Exercise:Complete Step 1 Worksheet

Consider your small group to be the start of your Community Partnership

Complete worksheet for your Partnership using questions on pages 4-7 and 4-8

Identify additional stakeholders if your Partnership lacks necessary resources, staffing or capacities. Answer questions on pages 4-3 and 4-4 to identify new Community Assessment stakeholders.

Step 2: Determine Your Focus

Step 2.1: Identify and Prioritize Community Public Health Needs The public health issue(s) your Community

Partnership prioritizes will become your community assessment focus

– Broad focus: general information about disease rates, available services, or community members’ perspectives on health or health care

– Specific focus: focus on a particular health topic that your Community Partnership agrees is a priority area

If resources are limited, assess one topic well and conduct another assessment later

Step 2.1: Identify and Prioritize Community Public Health Needs Discuss the community health issues your

Partners are most concerned with Create a list

Discuss which of these issues were raised the most or are the most pressing in your community

Prioritize health issues to focus your assessment If you cannot agree on one or two health topics,

then agree to conduct a broad assessment to determine the most pressing health issues in the community

Step 2.2: Define the Problem

Frame the assessment focus in terms of a public health problem:– Unmet needs– Gaps in health care services or programs– Lack of community-wide resources or funding

This will help you:– Further focus the assessment and data collection– Plan for community improvements – Provide a rationale for community improvements– Provide an argument to external audiences when

you seek funding or policy change

What makes good goals and

objectives?

A Goal

Is a broad statement Provides the overall vision, focus

and direction Can be more lofty than objectives

Objectives

Are steps to achieve goal(s) Are always active Are clear Are SMART:

– Specific– Measurable– Achievable given available time, staffing, and

resources– Relevant to the goals, needs, and interests of

the community and Community Partnership– Contain a Time Frame for when it will be

accomplished

Step 2.3: Create Realistic and Achievable Goals and Objectives Assessment goals and objectives are different from

program goals and objectives

They should be specific to your community assessment

They should not promise to: create or implement programs, change policy, change health behaviors, educate the community, provide services, etc.

They could instead promise to: collect/gather/ understand information, examine issues, analyze data, make recommendations, engage Community Partners, etc.

Example Goal and Objectives

Goal: To understand community members’ access to health care

1. Gather secondary data from at least 10 local health care service providers in spring 2008 to better understand which services are most utilized by the community, and which are not.

2. Perform asset mapping in 4 low-income neighborhoods in summer 2008 to determine what services are accessible by what neighborhoods in the community.

3. Survey 20% of residents in summer 2008 about their use of local health care services to better understand community health assets and needs.

Example Goal and Objectives for a More Narrowly Focused

Assessment

Goal: To understand the dietary behaviors of community teens

1. Gather sales data from 2 high school food service directors in 2007.

2. Conduct surveys with 50% of high school students regarding their at-home and in-school dietary behaviors before June 2007.

3. Map the locations of fast food and convenient store outlets before January 2008 near 2 high school campuses and students’ walking routes.


Discuss the public health issues that concern your group members

Prioritize one issue to focus your community assessment

Frame that selected issue as a problem

Discuss and agree on your assessment goal and objectives

Step 3: Identify the Information (Data) You

Need

Step 3.1: Articulate the Primary Questions You Would Like to Answer Clear questions will further focus your

assessment and drive data collection

Develop answerable questions

Number of questions depend on Partnership interests and assessment scope and focus

Good rule of thumb: 3-6 questions

Discuss questions with Partners and prioritize list of clear questions you can realistically answer with available resources

Examples of Primary Questions

1. Where do community residents go for health services?

2. What local health services do residents use the most? Which do they use the least?

3. Are those services accessible to most people? (Are the location and hours of operation convenient? Is there public transportation to the site?)

4. Which diseases or conditions affect the community the most?

Examples of Primary Questions

5. How does our community compare to other communities around health issues?

6. What do high school students know about eating a healthy diet?

7. What foods are available for high school students, both on campus and nearby?

What is data?What types of data

are there?

Different Types of Data

Opinions, priorities

Aspirations, motivations

Level of awareness, knowledge, attitudes or beliefs


Behaviors, practices

Assets, skills

Networks, associations


Needs, fears, problems, concerns

Demographic characteristics

Services or resources provided


Resident utilization of services or resources provided

Numbers or rates of disease, illness, disability, injuries

Sales transactions, purchases


Policies

Pictures

Maps

Step 3.2: Identify What Type of Data You Will Need

Many different types of data can answer your assessment question

It would be good to collect it all, but you need to consider the following when identifying what type of data you need:

– Assessment time frame– Available resources– Dedicated staff time and skills– Assessment goals and objectives– Problem statement– Prioritized questions

Which Types of Data Will Best Answer These Primary

Questions?1. Where do community residents go for health

services? 2. What local health services do residents use the most?

Which do they use the least? 3. Are those services accessible to most people? (Are

the location and hours of operation convenient? Is there public transportation to the site?)





Step 3.3: Identify Data Sources

Start first with data that already exists

Secondary Data: Data that has been collected for another purpose and can be made available to you for your data needs

Ask around your community and ask your Partners to see what data is out there and what you can use


Some local sources of data may include:

– County Health Department

– Vital statistics (birth and death certificates)

– City or County Government

– Schools


– Hospitals or clinics– Health agencies or advocacy groups– Universities or community colleges– Other local surveys or research

efforts?

Other free online sources of data are listed on pages 4-23 to 4-25

Pros and Cons of Using Secondary Data

Pros:

It’s cheaper It’s quicker

You can use your resources for data analysis and report writing

It may have collected data from a large sample

Pros and Cons of Using Secondary Data

Cons: The data may be outdated It most likely won’t be exactly what

you want There may be some sharing/privacy

issues Often not collected on the local level Can’t control the quality of the data

Evaluating Secondary Data

Make sure any secondary data:– Comes from a credible source– Captures what you want to measure– Is applicable to your community– Appears to be reliable and bias-free– Is timely

No data will be perfect. Balance the pros and cons of each source and determine which aspects are most important for your assessment data needs.

Where Can You Find the Data to Answer These Primary

Questions?

1. Where do community residents go for health services?

2. What local health services do residents use the most? Which do they use the least?

3. Are those services accessible to most people? (Are the location and hours of operation convenient? Is there public transportation to the site?)





Group Exercise: Complete Step 3 Worksheet

Create the primary assessment question(s) your group would like to answer

Brainstorm what types of data you would like to collect to answer those questions

Brainstorm where you could find or collect that data

Step 4: Determine How to Get the Information

(Collect Data)

Step 4.1: Identify What New Data Will Need to be Collected Look at your Step 3 Worksheet – which

data types cannot be gathered from secondary data sources?

These are the data you will need to collect

New data you collect is also called primary data

Before selecting data collection method(s), be sure you need this data to answer your questions

What is What is

quantitative data?quantitative data?

----------------------------------------------------------------What is What is

qualitative qualitative data?data?

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Data

Quantitative: Collected in the form of

numbers or percentages

Closed-ended questions Answers who?, what?,

when? and where? Can “represent” a

population by collecting data from a “sample” to approximate the experience of the entire community

Cannot collect new ideas or responses, only those considered ahead of time

Qualitative: Collected in the form of

words, concepts, themes, or categories

Open-ended questions Answers how?, why? Can provide richer,

more in-depth data Can provide data in a

respondent’s own words Can explore new ideas

in a dynamic and unstructured way

Step 4.2: Select the Appropriate Data Collection Method(s)

Appendix A contains information on how to perform these data collection methods:

1. Asset Mapping2. Focus Groups3. Key Informant Interviews4. Surveys5. Community Forums6. Rapid Appraisal Techniques

Data Collection Methods: Asset Mapping An inventory of community health assets

(resources, services, facilities, organizations, associations, etc.)

Usually represented by geographically mapped data

Builds on existing community resources Data can be used to develop, improve or

advocate for additional resources or funding Needs community buy-in and participation

May require a lot of time to survey community and to verify current addresses

Example of Asset Example of Asset MappingMapping

Data Collection Methods: Focus Groups A series of discussions involving 8-12 people,

selected to share their perceptions of a defined topic

Stimulates participants to share their opinions openly in a group discussion

Captures rich data in participants’ own words

Flexible to capture new ideas and issues

Can be difficult to summarize and interpret results across groups

Need to be creative when recruiting busy people

Example of Focus Example of Focus GroupsGroups

Data Collection Methods: Key Informant Interview A survey conducted over the phone or in person

during an interview

Short answer or open-ended questions

Allows respondents to share their opinions without the pressure of the group dynamic

Allows interviewer to clarify questions and draw out thoughtful responses

Selecting the “right” key informants may be difficult so they represent diverse backgrounds and viewpoints

Takes a while to administer; difficult to keep respondents on track

Data Collection Methods: Quantitative Survey

A survey conducted over the phone, in person, or via mail

Closed-ended questions (multiple choice, true/false or yes/no, brief numbered responses)

Easy to administer Large amounts of data can be gathered from many

respondents, and so can collect a larger sample and be representative of the broader population

Must be constructed to avoid “leading” or “loaded” questions

May require additional skills or funding to analyze data

Data Collection Methods: Community Forums A series of public meetings focused on a defined topic

Moderated to ensure that important topics are covered and time is used well

Relatively inexpensive and easy to conduct

Educational

Allows for community and stakeholder participation in issue

Allows for the gathering of many perspectives at once

Participants may not be representative of the larger population, as those who attend may not reflect the entire community or target audiences

Example of Community Example of Community ForumsForums

Data Collection Methods: Rapid Appraisal Methods Observations and photography that can help to

describe or visually depict community conditions

Relatively easy and inexpensive

Data can be gathered quickly

Provide descriptions and visual imagery that give meaning to quantitative data

Can be difficult to represent the entire community experience

Can be difficult to interpret and summarize photographs and observation notes

Things to Consider as You Select Your Methods

What data collection method or methods would best collect the type of data you need, from the source you indicated

Partnership resources: – Time– Staffing– Skills– Funding– Computer technology

Prior experience Potential benefits Potential challenges

Some Helpful Tips About Collecting Primary Data

Be flexible – modify your plan as you gain new insight

Don’t reinvent the wheel – borrow what you can from similar efforts or get online

Don’t bite off more than you can chew – collect fewer data well, rather than many data poorly

Be humble – ask for input and help

Step 4.3: Revisit Steps 1-3 to Make Sure You’re on Track

Before you spend any time or resources collecting data, be sure your community assessment plan so far is:

Feasible – Is the assessment doable?

Useful – Will the data you collect be useful? Will it address the community public health issues you identified?

Accurate – Will the assessment methodologies collect information that accurately reflects reality?

Fair – Will the assessment be conducted with awareness of the rights of the people involved?

Responsive – Is the assessment guided by the previous decisions made by your Partnership throughout the planning process so far?

Completing a Data Collection Plan

Some important issues to consider :1. What types of data (identified in step 3) will be

collected with each data collection method?2. How would you define the source of data for each

data collection method more specifically? In other words, define your target respondents.

3. Which of your assessment questions will each method answer? This will ensure that the data you collect through each method are strategic to answering these questions.

4. What specific activities will need to be accomplished in order to best plan and perform these proposed data collection methods? Some activities may include data collection tool development, data collector training, respondent recruitment, etc.

Group Exercise:Complete Step 4

Worksheet Discuss the questions on pages 4-30 and 4-31

Consider the pros and cons of qualitative and quantitative data

Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the different methods

Decide which method or methods would be most appropriate for your community assessment

Complete the rest of the Step 4 worksheet for each data collection method selected

Step 5: Determine How to Understand the

Information (Analyze Data)

Why It’s a Good Idea to Plan Ahead for Data Analyses

To determine if the data you collect are practical for analyses

To review the appropriateness of your chosen data collection method(s)

To inform the data collection instrument(s) you develop

To decide if you will need help with analyses

Step 5.1: Check the Data

Make sure it’s all there Make sure it makes sense Catch any mistakes that happened while

filling out the survey or entering the data Perform data quality checks throughout your

data collection process Common mistakes:

– A missing or incomplete response

– An impossible response

– A response unrelated to the question

– A response that contradicts an earlier response

Step 5.2: Go Back to the Primary Assessment Questions Be sure to analyze only the data that will help

you answer your primary question(s)

Don’t get side-tracked into analyzing other pieces of data with your limited time and resources

It is normal to collect more data than you will need for your community assessment

You can return to any other interesting data after completing your Community Assessment Plan

Step 5.3: Reduce the Amount of Data

Save your data in its original form so that you can return to it if you need to

Look at it in small chunks at a time Eliminate any irrelevant data from

your analysis

Step 5.3: Reduce the Amount of Data

Create summary documents to help you “eyeball” the data more easily to look for patterns or themes:

– Numeric spreadsheet

– Qualitative summary document

See also Appendix B: Computer Software to Compile and Analyze Data

Example of a Numeric Example of a Numeric SpreadsheetSpreadsheet

Example of a Qualitative Example of a Qualitative Summary DocumentSummary Document

Health workers’ perceptions of public and private sector

Public Sector Private Sector

Low pay Good pay

Work time restrictions Hard work

No resources Resources

Training opportunities No training

Job security No job security

Bureaucracy Profit driven

What is the difference What is the difference between discrete and between discrete and

continuous data?continuous data?

Step 5.4: Analyze the DataQuantitative Data Analysis: Looking

for Patterns in the Data Calculate averages

– Used with “continuous” data: infinite number of values

– Add numbered responses– Divide by number of responses– 2 + 4 + 6 + 10 = 22 22/4 = 5.5

Count frequencies– Used with “discrete” data: set number of

response categories– Count number of responses

Number “yes”, number “no” Number of choice “A”, Number of choice “B”, etc.

Step 5.4: Analyze the Data

Quantitative Data Analysis: Looking for Patterns in the

Data Calculate proportions – Is standardized – Equation: % = # of responses/ total # of

respondents X 100– Example: 45 females/ 97 respondents X 100 =

46% of the respondents were female Calculate rates

– Similar to proportions; also standardized – Easier to compare– Equation: Rate = freq of event in pop/ total pop X

100,000– Example: 15 cases of lung cancer/ population of

3,500 X 100,000 = 428 persons per 100,000 have lung cancer



Data Compare averages, frequencies, proportions, rates

Compare data from different populations: – County vs. County– County vs. State– State vs. US



Data Compare data from different segments of a population:– Male vs. female– African American, white, Latino, Asian,

American Indian, etc.– Children, teens, adults, seniors– Disabled vs. not– Different income or health insurance levels– Married vs. single – Smokers vs. not



Data Present the data in different ways to see

additional patterns and relationships:

– Chart/ table – shows averages, counts, proportions, or rates side-by-side

– Pie graph – demonstrates percentages of the whole

– Bar graph – compares quantities

– Line graph – shows trends over time

Example of a Chart/TableExample of a Chart/Table

Race/Ethnicity Frequency Proportion

Latino 30 15%

Pacific Islander 20 10%

American Indian/ Alaskan Native

20 10%

Asian 30 15%

African American 50 25%

White 40 20%

Other 10 5%

Example of a pie graphExample of a pie graph

25%

40%

35%

Los AngelesOrangeSan Diego

Example of a bar Example of a bar graphgraph

135

102

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

Non smokers Smokers

Example of a Line Example of a Line graphgraph

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

January April August

MenWomen

How to Draw Findings from Tables and Graphs

What does the table/chart or graph say?

Look at each of your frequencies, proportions, averages and rates to describe the responses, characteristics, or health status of community members

How do different groups in the community compare?

Compare the frequencies, proportions, averages and rates between groups to see if there are any differences

Each of the above “facts” drawn from a table or graph is a finding

Example: Proportion of Asthma Cases in CA, by

Race/Ethnicity

Total Latino

American Indian/ Alaska Native Asian

African American White Other

Has asthma 17.7% 10.1% 25.8% 12.7% 22% 15.2% 17.7%

Does not have asthma 82.3% 89.9% 74.2% 87.3% 78% 84.8% 82.3%

Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Same Data in Graph Form: Proportion of Asthma Cases

in CA, by Race/EthnicityDiagnosed with Asthma, By Race/Ethnicity

0102030405060708090

100

Latino AmericanIndian

Asian Black White Other

Per

cen

t

Has asthma

Does nothave asthma

What is the proportion of asthma Cases in children 1-18 years old in California?

Total Latino

American Indian/ Alaska Native Asian

African American White Other

Has asthma 17.7% 10.1% 25.8% 12.7% 22% 15.2% 17.7%

Does not have asthma 82.3% 89.9% 74.2% 87.3% 78% 84.8% 82.3%

Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Which racial/ethnic group in California experiences the highest proportion of asthma cases in children 1-18 years old?

Diagnosed with Asthma, By Race/Ethnicity

0102030405060708090

100



Per

cen

t

Has asthma

Does nothave asthma

Which racial/ethnic group in California experiences the highest proportion of asthma cases in children 1-18 years old?

Diagnosed with Asthma, By Race/Ethnicity

25.8 %

0102030405060708090

100



Per

cen

t

Has asthma

Does nothave asthma

Exercise 5.4A

Look at sample survey and sample spreadsheet in Appendix C

Answer questions on page 4-51 and 4-52

Discuss any difficulties or questions


Qualitative Data Analysis: Looking for Themes in the Data

Qualitative data analysis can be deceptively trickier– Qualitative data is by nature “bigger”– Analysis requires more analytical thinking and

interpretation

Qualitative data is more open to “bias”– Numbers don’t lie– Analysts bring their values, assumptions and opinions– Analysts may think they “know” how people feel

Include at least 2, preferably 3 people in each stage of data analysis to avoid bias

Create as structured of a process as possible to avoid bias


Qualitative Data Analysis: Looking for Themes in the Data

1. Read through all of the data at least twice– Stay “close” or “grounded” in the data

2. Create categories– Focus group or interview questions– Or specific assessment health issues

3. List themes that emerge from discussion– Sub-categories– Ideas

4. Rank order according to frequency of appearance

5. Summarize discussion around each theme6. Determine your findings

How to Draw Findings from Qualitative Data

What are the most frequently occurring themes that arose across all of your focus group/open-ended survey questions?

How do the different themes intersect and relate to each other?

Compare the themes discussed by each type of focus group/survey participant to see if there are any differences

Each of the above “facts” drawn from the qualitative data is a finding

Exercise 5.4B

Look at sample focus group discussion transcript in Appendix C

Answer questions on page 4-56


Step 5.5: Verify Findings

You now have:– Some patterns and relationships you found in your

quantitative data– Some themes and categories you found in your

qualitative data Based on the results you tallied and summarized,

pull out the main findings of each method you used

Verify these findings by re-tallying and re-summarizing the data to make sure you get the same results; correct any mistakes

You can also verify your findings by comparing the results reached by 2 or more analysts independently; correct any mistakes

Step 5.6: Interpret Findings and Draw Conclusions

What possible interpretations, or explanations, could explain each finding?

Invite different perspectives in this process, to make sure one person’s viewpoint does not dominate or bias the conclusions

Some things to consider as you draw meaning from your data findings:– Is this finding similar to what you expected? – How/why is it different?– What do you think could explain this finding?– What are all the different alternative interpretations/ explanations

you may have not considered?– Is there evidence to support any of the interpretation or

interpretations you have considered?– Do you feel comfortable sharing this interpretation with the

general public as a conclusion of your assessment?

Why is Data Interpretation so Important in Community

Assessments? Interpretation is the effort of figuring out

what the findings mean and is part of the overall effort to make sense of the evidence gathered

Uncovering facts regarding a community’s needs is not sufficient to draw conclusions – those facts must be interpreted before conclusions can be drawn

Data must be interpreted to appreciate the practical significance of what has been learned

Interpretations (or explanations) can be strengthened through active discussion and community participation

Exercise 5.6

Look at the secondary data tables in Appendix C

Answer questions on page 4-59


Completing a Data Analysis Plan

Some important issues to consider :

1. What is the nature of the data collected with each method – quantitative, qualitative, or both?

2. What specific activities will need to be accomplished in order to best plan and perform the proposed data analysis?

3. Determine who in your community partnership has the experience, interest and time to accomplish each activity.

4. Select a due date or timeline for each activity so that this planning worksheet can become an achievable Data Analysis Plan.

Group Exercise:Complete Step 5

Worksheet List each data source and data collection

method you selected in steps 3 and 4

Determine whether the data collected with each method will be qualitative or quantitative (or both)

Decide which data analysis activities will be necessary for each method, as described in step 5

Decide who in your group has the skills, interest and time to achieve each data analysis activity

Step 6: Determine How to Use and

Communicate Results

6.1: Identify Assessment Products

Before you begin your assessment, it is important to plan what types of products you would like to use to communicate your findings to external audiences

These may take the form of:– Written reports– Report summaries– Presentations– Recommendations– Fact sheets/ briefs– Newspaper articles– Others

Effective Assessment Products Are…

Concise - Make it short and to the point. Make it easy to find information.

Interesting - Present and discuss the findings that are new and compelling.

Responsive - Consider your target audiences and keep them in mind while writing the report.

Useful - Write clear conclusions and recommendations. They will be more usable.

Attractive - Spend a small portion of your budget to bind your reports or print products in color to distribute to your important target audiences.

Tips on Developing Products

1. Get community input on findings and conclusions

2. Make modifications before finalizing

3. Pull out key points

4. Decide carefully how to present data to back up your findings and conclusions

Graphs and tables Table summarizing main qualitative

themes and descriptions Story boxes highlighting quotes Maps and Photographs

Putting a Report Together…

1. Cover page

2. Executive Summary

3. Table of Contents

4. Introduction

5. Methodology

6. Main findings

7. Discussion

Design Tips for Easy Reading

Use clear, readable, and large font– Times/Times New Roman– Palatino– Garamond– Arial– Tahoma

Avoid script, condensed, or narrow fonts Use clear, uniform heading formats in bold or

bold italic Leave plenty of “white space”

Include page numbers

6.2: Identify Target Audiences

Identify strategic “internal” and “external” audiences to share your results with

Think about:

– Who will want to hear the findings?

– Who needs to hear the findings?

– What do you think each target audience will most want to hear?

– Can you tailor your assessment products to be responsive to the needs/interests of each target audience?

Example Target Audiences

Community Partnership members Community members and patients

Hospitals, clinics, or other health centers

Local businesses and employers

Example Target Audiences

Health insurance plans Other local, regional or statewide

advocacy groups Legislators and policymakers Elected officials

Funders or private foundations

Present Your Findings

Plan your messages for each target audience Formulate your argument and anticipate

opposing arguments (Exercise 6.3 on page 4-68)

Focus your message around common health care values:

– Cost– Quality– Access– Equity– Rights

6.4: Determine Next Steps

Identifying your “next steps” for after the assessment will help your Partnership be more strategic throughout the assessment

These might include….

6.4: Determine Next Steps

Identify additional stakeholders, allies, or partners Seek funding Identify program or service needs Identify necessary policy changes Engage in policy change or advocacy efforts Mobilize leaders and residents around an issue Identify needed research or evaluation activities Develop an on-going collaboration with your

Partnership Develop a longer-term work plan with your

Partnership

6.5: Celebrate and acknowledge your

work!


Identify some strategic assessment products

Identify target audiences for each

Identify what type of findings or data you will highlight for each target audience

Determine product development activities and assign timelines and responsibilities

Performing a Community Health Assessment

Health & Medicine

Transcript of Performing a Community Health Assessment