Strategies for Tier 1 and Tier 2 Interventions. Tier 1: Standards-Based Classroom Instruction.
PBIS Tier 2 Training - RTI Center · •Define the six features of tier 2 interventions and their...
Transcript of PBIS Tier 2 Training - RTI Center · •Define the six features of tier 2 interventions and their...
9/10/2019
1
The Wisconsin RtI Center (CFDA #84.027) acknowledges the support of the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction in the development of this presentation and for the continued support of this federally‐funded grant program. There are no copyright restrictions on this
document; however, please credit the Wisconsin DPI and support of federal funds when copying all or part of this material.
PBISTier2TrainingDay 1: Essential Features
ObjectivesforToday
Teams will…• Create a plan for how the tier 1 and tier 2 teams will collaborate to train and provide ongoing support for staff in using the principles of behavior
• Define the six features of tier 2 interventions and their connection to tier 1
• Analyze current interventions and articulate where they match features of tier 2 interventions
RtI = Response to Intervention
PBIS = Positive Behavior Intervention Supports
CRP = Culturally Responsive Practices
MLSS/MTSS = Multi-level (tiered) System of Support
AcronymsintheField
9/10/2019
2
www.wisconsinrticenter.org/tier2v2
The Wisconsin RtI Center/Wisconsin PBIS Network (CFDA #84.027) acknowledges the support of the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) in the development of this presentation and for the continued support of this federally‐funded grant program. There are no copyright restrictions on this document; however, please credit the Wisconsin DPI
and support of federal funds when copying all or part of this material.
TeamRoles
• Keeps team time bound in
the process• Shares out to whole group
• Documents work, and decisions for team
• Keeps group on track, makes sure all voices are heard
Facilitator Recorder
Time‐keeper
Spokes‐person
Equitable, Multi-level System of Supports
+ CRP RtI (reading/math)
+ PBIS(behavior)
Systematicallyprovidingequitableservices,practices,andresourcestoALLstudentsbasedupontheirresponsivenesstoeffectiveinstructionandintervention.
PuttingitAllTogetherinWisconsin
9/10/2019
3
PutWisconsin’sVisionofCollegeandCareerReadinessINTOACTIONbyImplementinganEquitable,Multi‐levelSystemofSupports
KNOWLEDGE: Students receive equitable access to the academic content
SKILLS: School‐ and classroom‐wide behavioral expectations promote the application of these skills
HABITS: Positive behavioral habits lead to responsibility, perseverance, adaptability, and leadership
Equitable,Multi‐levelSystemofSupports
KeyFeaturesofan
All of these key features inform and impact each other.
Use of EVIDENCE‐BASED PRACTICES to ensure that school and district efforts positively impact learner outcomes
STRONG SHARED LEADERSHIP and POSITIVE CULTURE to provide the context necessary for schools and districts to grow and sustain implementation
SYSTEMIC IMPLEMENTATION throughout the district, schools, teams, and classrooms to promote consistency and effectiveness across the system of supports;
…starting with a strong UNIVERSAL LEVEL OF SUPPORT as the base;
A CONTINUUM OF SUPPORTS for learners…
…among staff, learners, families, and communities
COLLABORATION to make the complex work of system change possible….
We believe in the STRATEGIC USE OF DATA for CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT
Through HIGH QUALITY INSTRUCTION, academic, behavioral, social, and emotional teaching and supports are delivered.
EQUITY is at the center of the framework and is embedded into all other key features.
EQUITY is at the center of the framework and is embedded into all other key features.
We want to challenge and change inequitable access, opportunity, and outcomes experienced by learners currently underserved in Wisconsin schools.
We want to challenge and change inequitable access, opportunity, and outcomes experienced by learners currently underserved in Wisconsin schools.
PositiveCulture
A collective sense of purpose and commitment to ensure the well‐being, sense of belonging, safety, and success of every learner.
All stakeholders demonstrate an unwavering belief in every learner to achieve success and a shared commitment to the vision of success for all.
9/10/2019
4
PositiveCulture
Learners, staff, and families feel physically, socially, emotionally, intellectually, and
culturally validated,safe, and supported.
What does this really mean for:
Learners?Families?Staff?
Discussion
What’s Your Why?
PAGE 6
StrongUniversalLevelofSupport
Instruction, assessment, and collaborative systems and practices are accessible, effective, and reflective of every learner.
Universal practices are culturally responsive to, and reflective of, families and the community.
The universal level is based on high standards and school‐wide expectations.
9/10/2019
5
DoesYourUniversalServeAll?
Tier 1/Universal • Prevention• 80‐90% • 0‐1 ODRs
Tier 2/Selected • Early identification• Reduce risk• 5‐15%• 2‐5 ODRs
Tier 3/Intensive• Reduce severity• 1‐5%• 6+ ODRs
READ&DISCUSS
PAGE 7
Anytown’sUniversal System
ACTIVITY
PAGE 17
Your School’sUniversal System
9/10/2019
6
Liang, X., & Zhang, G. (2009). Muhammad, A., & Hollie, S. (2012). State of Washington Professional Educators Standard Board. (2009).
Capacity
Perceived abilities, skills, and expertise of staff needed to lead a continuous school improvement effort to grow, progress, or improve
Definition adapted from http://edglossary.org/capacity/
StrongSharedLeadership
• All members model cultural competency and advocate for equity
• All members promote a vision of success for every learner and foster a shared commitment to the vision across the school and district
Representative teams with responsibility to lead and oversee implementation of an equitable, multi‐level system of supports.
9/10/2019
7
Leadership teams work together with school and district leaders to make sure the system is implemented with fidelity and is sustainable.
• Determine needs, establish goals, celebrate successes• Plan and coordinate implementation fidelity and sustainability of system
• Ensure effective and reciprocal communication throughout the system
• Identify and support non‐negotiables• Action plan and progress monitor• Provide resources, professional development, and coordinate supports
LeadershipTeams
PAGE 18
Prior data + BIP PlanData
Data from T1+T2 and Individual Student Data
LeadershipTeams
Tier 3
Tier 1
Student‐centered
Tier 2
System Check In/Check Out (CICO)
Schoolwide Expectations, Rules & Routines; Lesson Plans; Reinforcement;
Behavioral Error Definitions; Classroom Rules & Routines; etc.
Major & Minor Office Referrals; Health Room
Visits; Attendance; Grades; etc.
Team: TFI or BoQStaff: SAS Aggregated Student Data
SAIGModified CICO Mentoring
Brief FBA/BIP
WraparoundRENEW
ComplexFBA/BIP
All data from Tier 1 + Daily Progress Report
Data
Team: TFI or BATStaff: SAS
Team: TFI or BATStaff: SAS Aggregated Student Data
Practice/InterventionStudentDataReviewed
SystemDataReviewed
Tier2Leadership
• Coordinate and sustain interventions
• Train and support stakeholders (staff, families, students)
• Provide and solicit feedback to and from stakeholders
• Determine adjustments needed based on individual and aggregate student outcome data
• Monitor intervention response rates and system assessment data
Team members are responsible for supporting staff in carrying out
interventions – not carrying them out!
PAGE 18
9/10/2019
8
ConversationsatTier2
Systems• Examines health
of interventions• Responds to
stakeholder needs• Determines data rules• Monitors intervention
response rates
Student Centered• Student‐specific• Digs deeper into
individual student needs• Creates and monitors an
intervention plan
LeadershipatTier2
Leadership includes stakeholder voices.
*Classroom teacher is required
Systems• Administrator• General education
teacher(s)• Pupil services staff• Educational assistant• Special education
teacher
Student Centered• Family member• Classroom teacher*• Administrator• Pupil services staff• Student’s teacher(s)• Teacher from systems team• Content specialist• Student
DISCUSSION
Leadership and
Implementation
PAGE 19
9/10/2019
9
StrategicUseofData
Ongoing, reflective, and collaborative
analysis of implementation and outcomes data in a problem‐solving process to inform improvement and achieve equity
ContinuousImprovement
PlanPlan
DoDo
StudyStudy
ActAct
DISCUSSION
Your School’s Strategic
Use of Data
PAGE 20
9/10/2019
10
PrinciplesofBehavior
Tier 1/Universal 80‐90% • Prevention• Whole Group
Tier 2/Selected 5‐15%• Early identification• Reduce risk• Small Group
Tier 3/Intensive 1‐5%• Reduce severity• Individual
Behavior• Anything we say or do:Focus on what is observable rather than intentions
• How we react to our environment
• Behaviors are learned and continue because they serve a purpose or function
• We engage in behaviors because we have learned that a desired outcome occurs
Overview of Basic Behavior Principles [PDF Document]. Retrieved from: http://flpbs.fmhi.usf.edu/revision07/overview/general/Overview%20of%20Basic%20Behavior%20Principles%20Handouts.pdf
How do staff use the principles of behavior at the universal level to provide support for students?
Consider: • Tier 1 team’s school‐wide planning • Classroom teacher’s classroom
management
TURN&TALK
9/10/2019
11
ABCs
• Antecedent: What happens right before the
behavior
• Behavior: Observable and measurable
description
• Consequence: What happens after the
behavior
FunctionofBehaviorWhat is reinforcing or maintaining the behavior?
Obtain Avoid
Attention (peer, adult)Tangibles/Activities
Sensory
(b)Behavior
Behaviors need to be defined in ways that are observable and measurable.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
Behaviors need to be defined in ways that are observable and measurable.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
9/10/2019
12
(a)Antecedent
What occurs right before a behavior.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
What occurs right before a behavior.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
(c)Consequence
What happens after the behavior.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
What happens after the behavior.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
Function
The reason the behavior occurred.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
Function?
The reason the behavior occurred.
When students enter the room and are reminded to get started on the activator math problems, four students independently engage in tasks not associated with the math work (ask to go to the bathroom, ask to get a drink, ask to go to their locker, wander around the room). By the time they get to their seats the teacher has started class.
Function? To avoid (a task‐math problems)
9/10/2019
13
IdentifyAntecedent,Behavior,Consequence
During full group instruction, when the teacher asks the students questions, Rachel blurts out the answers without raising her hand and waiting to be called on. The teacher reminds Rachel to raise her hand next time, accepts the answer, and moves on to the next question.
IdentifytheFunction
During full group instruction, when the teacher asks the students questions, Rachel blurts out the answers without raising her hand and waiting to be called on. The teacher reminds Rachel to raise her hand next time, accepts the answer, and moves on to the next question.
Function? To Obtain (teacher attention)
REFLECT&DISCUSS
PAGE 21
Behavior 101
9/10/2019
14
Tier2Interventions• Targeted, group‐based support for some students
‒ Intervention is similar for all students based on need, not that all students receive intervention together
• Connected to tier 1
• Includes the six intervention features
• Team driven
• Potential examples include:‒ CICO‒ Social Skills (friendship groups, lunch bunches, etc.)‒ Academic Seminar‐type Class‒ Mindfulness Groups‒ Mentoring
Tier2InterventionFeatures
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
Tier 1/Universal 80‐90% • 0‐1 ODRs per student• All students• Preventive, proactive
Tier 2/Selected 5‐15%• 2‐5 ODRs per student • Some students (at‐risk)• High efficiency, rapid response• Small group interventions• Limited individualizing
Tier 3/Intensive 1‐5%• 6+ ODRs per student • Individual students• Assessment‐based• High intensity
ContinuumofSupports
9/10/2019
15
EarlyIdentificationofRisk
• Tier 1 data determines– Adjustments needed schoolwide and in classrooms– Students who may benefit from additional support
• Intervening early, efficiently, and quickly minimizes potential of:– Staff frustration and confusion– Academic failure– Social and emotional behaviors escalating
Midwest PBIS NetworkFlorida PBIS Project
ScreeningforEarlyIdentification
A universal screening process uses data from multiple measures that are analyzed to determine whether each student is likely to meet, not meet, or exceed academic
benchmarks or behavioral expectations.
Strategic use of data is not limited to an assessment or rating scale, and should include
information already being collected.
Wisconsin RtI Center Glossary
ScreeningforEarlyIdentification
Internalizing behavior primarily affects the child’s internal psychological environment rather than the external world.
Externalizing behavior primarily affects the child’s external environment (i.e. people or things) and may manifest as a result of internalizing behavior.
Liu, 2004
9/10/2019
16
EarlyIdentificationDataSources
* Indicates to use data source with caution
Internalizing• Health room visits• Attendance• Dropout Early Warning
System (DEWS)• Request for assistance*• Grades or homework
completion*
Externalizing• Minors• Majors• Attendance• Dropout Early Warning
System (DEWS)• Grades or homework
completion*
EarlyIdentification:Caution
• Request for Assistance– Used for exceptions
• Grades and Homework Completion– Standardized system for grading established– Not an academic skill deficit as primary concern– Policies and practices examined for purpose– Instruction is meaningful and engaging
ACTIVITY
Early Identification and Entrance
Criteria (part 1)
PAGE 22
9/10/2019
17
EntranceandExitCriteria
Entrance Criteria
• Determine when to provide additional supports
• Determine when adjustments at tier 1 are necessary
• Include family voice
Exit Criteria
• Determine when students are ready for self‐monitoring and fading of support(s)
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
ExamplesofEntranceCriteria
Internalizing
• Health room visits• Attendance• Request for assistance • Grades or homework completion: one D
Externalizing
• Minors: three in a month for the same behavior
• Majors: one in a month
• Attendance
• Grades or homework completion: one D
ExamplesofExitCriteria
• 6‐8 weeks of sustained improvement as evidenced through progress monitoring
• Improvement in original entrance criteria
Reading interventions are like this too. Students making progress via AIMSWeb and a reading intervention would also need to see a decrease in errors, increase in fluency, etc. in the classroom.
9/10/2019
18
CreatingaSuccessfulExit
• The goal of a tier 2 intervention is for a student to learn how to independently perform a specific skill
• Interventions provide layers of support to aid in skill acquisition and mastery
• As soon as a student consistently demonstrates mastery of the skill, layers of the intervention should be faded back
CreatingaSuccessfulExit
• Purposeful fading reduces the amount of support needed to perform the skill– Increased self‐monitoring – decreased reliance on intervention
• Methods may vary depending on intervention and will include carefully reducing frequency of:– Prompts– Explicit teaching– Adult feedback– Reinforcement
ACTIVITY
Early Identification and Entrance Criteria (part 2)
PAGE 22
9/10/2019
19
IncreaseinTeachingwithOpportunities
toPractice
• Prompts and cues connected to tier 1 language
• Supported in all environments by all staff
• Use of skill in natural environments
• Skill must have been taught to fluency at tier 1
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
DEFINESimply*
MODEL
PRACTICE in setting
MONITOR &ACKNOWLEDGE continuously
ADJUST for
efficiency
Apply to school‐wide
and classroom
expectations
*Classroom and school‐wide matrices should reflect student, staff, and family values.
SkillDevelopmentModel
Newly Taught Skill or Strategy
Learn It With
Accuracy
Practice for Fluency/
Automaticity
Keep Practicing for Maintenance
Now Can Make Generalizations
Adapt/ Apply to New
Situations
9/10/2019
20
Activity
PAGE 24
Increase in Teaching with
Opportunities to Practice
IncreasedAdultFeedback
• Specific, proactive, positive
• Connected to skill‐building
• Specific
• Immediate
• Focuses on execution of skill (not absence of negative behavior)
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
Reinforcement&Feedback
Reinforcement and adult feedback increase the likelihood the behavior (pro‐social or behavioral error) is maintained or increased
• Can be natural or contrived• Used for a targeted pro‐social/adaptive skill that is
challenging or aversive (based on data)
We need to know that the student is able to demonstrate the skill!
9/10/2019
21
Reinforcement&Feedback
• Based on data and relevant skills– Reinforcement provided for progress and growth
• Think A‐B‐C• Reinforcement varies by student• Reinforcement is always paired with:
– High quality instruction – Specific positive feedback
• For most students, adult feedback alone will be sufficiently reinforcing
REFLECT&PARTNERSHARE
Increased Adult Feedback
PAGE 25
IncreasedHome‐SchoolConnection
• Throughout the intervention:
– Family members play an active role
– Ongoing communication with (not just to) includes discussing strengths and needs
• Refer to district policy for consent
– Consent is not the same as ongoing communication
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
9/10/2019
22
IncreasedHome‐SchoolConnection
Questions to consider:
• How can we best communicate with you about your child?
• What are your student’s strengths? Unique needs?
• Does your child feel connected to school?
• If previous interventions were tried do you think they were given a chance to work?
• How would you define progress?
DISCUSSION
Increased Home‐School Communication
PAGE 26
ProgressMonitoring
Process used to:
• assess students’ academic and behavioral performance,
• measure student response to interventions/challenges, and
• evaluate the effectiveness of interventions/challenges
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
9/10/2019
23
ProgressMonitoringIncludes:• Tracking the presence of positive skill• Involving all staff that support the student • Collecting data daily• Assessing student response
– Positive progress within 3‐4 weeks– Improvement in original entry criteria
• Assessing intervention effectiveness– At least 70% of students are making progress– The intervention is delivered as intended
ProgressMonitoring:Student
ProgressMonitoring:Student
9/10/2019
24
DailyProgressReport(DPR)
• Used:– Throughout the intervention(s)–With student outcome data to make decisions
• Essential elements:– Aligned with school‐wide expectations– Scored at natural transitions during the day
• Elementary: 6‐8 blocks per day• Middle/High: Based on class periods (blocks broken up)
– Simple scoring recommended ex: 0, 1, 2
DPRExample
DISCUSSION
Progress Monitoring
PAGE 27
9/10/2019
25
Fidelity
Fidelity gauges the extent to which practices and systems are in place and used in a way that is consistent with
how it is intended.
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
Fidelity:System
• Identify stakeholder perceptions, understanding, and needs to tailor professional development
– Determine how the team
will build staff capacity to
effectively implement
• Review annualassessments and action plan around results
– TFI, SAS, BAT
Fidelity:Practices
• Review each practice/intervention to make sure they are being implemented as designed
• Review student data regularly to ensure positive outcomes
• Outcome/Intervention‐ongoing review–Walkthrough tools
– Staff self‐assessment
– Family interview/assessment
– Student interview/assessment
– Aggregate student data such as ODRs, minors, etc.
9/10/2019
26
DISCUSSION
Fidelity
PAGE 28
Tier2InterventionFeatures
Anderson, Borgmeier (2010)Newcomer, Lori L.; Freeman, Rachel; and Barrett, Susan (2013)
Tier2Interventions• Targeted, group‐based support for some students
‒ Intervention is similar for all students based on need, not that all students receive intervention together
• Connected to tier 1
• Includes the six intervention features
• Team driven
• Potential examples include:‒ CICO‒ Social Skills (friendship groups, lunch bunches, etc.)
‒ Academic Seminar‐type class‒ Mindfulness Groups‒ Mentoring
9/10/2019
27
ACTIVITY
CurrentTier 2
InterventionAudit
PAGE 29
Tier2CriticalThinkingTeams must:
– Act as critical thinkers and ask themselves:• Are the six intervention features evident and maintained?
• Does the intervention align with tier 1 practices?• Is there team oversight or is it person‐dependent?• How will we train and support all staff to be skilled in implementing?
– Remain cautious of quick fixes• Online resources• SOS: Shiny Object Syndrome
SOS negatives:Inability to finish,poor directives,costs resources,
and confuses
stakeholders
General Education and Special Education
Universal/Tier 1Social, Emotional, and Behavioral
Social/Academic Instructional
GroupsModified CICO
Mentoring
First: Check in/Check out (CICO)Then, select one intervention on next level up
Brief Function‐based Problem Solving
Tier2 Tier 3Centered Planning Complex FBA/BIP
9/10/2019
28
ReviewofToday’sObjectives
Teams will…• Create a plan for how the tier 1 and tier 2 teams will collaborate to train and provide ongoing support for staff in using the principles of behavior
• Define the six features of tier 2 interventions and their connection to tier 1
• Analyze current interventions and articulate where they match features of tier 2 interventions
EvaluationandFeedbackt2d1.questionpro.com
On the lookout for your feedback!
CheckInandShareOut
Discuss with your team:
1. What was your one big “ah‐ha” from the day?
2. What are two things your team will accomplish before the next day of training?
3. What is one thing your technical assistance coordinator can do to support your team between today and the next day of training?
9/10/2019
29
ForNextTime
• When did the tier 2 team meet?
• How have you trained your staff on the features of tier 2 interventions?
• What action steps have been set and taken?
• Be prepared to share answers to the above with the rest of the training group!
PAGE 30
Resources
• Consent and Notification within a Multi‐Level System of Support: FAQ
• Family Interview for Culturally Responsive Practices• Request for Assistance• Daily Progress Report (DPR) Examples• Automated Tracking Tool for Tier 2 Interventions• Dropout Early Warning System (DEWS)• Screening within a Multi‐Level System of Support
Stay connected, join the conversation
@WisconsinRtICenter
@WisRtICenter
Tips to Your Inbox: http://bit.ly/WisRtICenter
@Wisconsin RtI Center/PBIS Network
Live webinars and networking events