Patents In Telecom Slideshow - UCL · WASHINGTON. D.C. THIS NOTE IS LEGAL TENDER FOR ALL DEBTS....

3
14/11/2014 1 Patents In Telecom David Howard Corporate Vice President and Deputy General Counsel, Litigation and Competition Law Microsoft Corporation November 7 th , 2014 Motorola’s Injunction Actions Motorola demand letter: 802.11 patents 10/21/10 Motorola demand letter: H.264 patents 10/29/10 Day 21: Motorola sues to enjoin Windows and Xbox sales (802.11 and H. 264) 11/10/10 Motorola sues in ITC to block Xbox imports (802.11 and H.264) 11/22/10 Motorola sues in Germany to enjoin Windows and Xbox distribution (H. 264) 7/11 2010 2011 2012 PDX032

Transcript of Patents In Telecom Slideshow - UCL · WASHINGTON. D.C. THIS NOTE IS LEGAL TENDER FOR ALL DEBTS....

Page 1: Patents In Telecom Slideshow - UCL · WASHINGTON. D.C. THIS NOTE IS LEGAL TENDER FOR ALL DEBTS. PUBLIC AND PRIVATE 12 L 11180916 C ONE CL A L12 CL A . IA 055514123 A > THIS NOTE IS

14/11/2014  

1  

Patents In Telecom

David Howard

Corporate Vice President and Deputy General Counsel, Litigation and Competition Law

Microsoft Corporation

November 7th, 2014

Motorola’s Injunction Actions

Motorola demand letter: 802.11 patents

10/21/10

Motorola demand letter:

H.264 patents 10/29/10

Day 21: Motorola sues to enjoin Windows and Xbox sales (802.11 and H.264) 11/10/10

Motorola sues in ITC to block Xbox imports (802.11 and H.264) 11/22/10

Motorola sues in Germany to enjoin Windows and Xbox distribution (H.264) 7/11

2010 2011 2012

PDX032

Page 2: Patents In Telecom Slideshow - UCL · WASHINGTON. D.C. THIS NOTE IS LEGAL TENDER FOR ALL DEBTS. PUBLIC AND PRIVATE 12 L 11180916 C ONE CL A L12 CL A . IA 055514123 A > THIS NOTE IS

14/11/2014  

2  

RAND Royalty: less than $2 million per year

Comparison of RAND Royalty with Motorola H.264 Demand

Motorola Demand: $4 billion per year

PDX028

Motorola Demand: $11.25

Comparison of RAND Royalty with Motorola H.264 Demand for Windows on $500 Laptop

RAND Royalty: $0.00555

PDX027

Page 3: Patents In Telecom Slideshow - UCL · WASHINGTON. D.C. THIS NOTE IS LEGAL TENDER FOR ALL DEBTS. PUBLIC AND PRIVATE 12 L 11180916 C ONE CL A L12 CL A . IA 055514123 A > THIS NOTE IS

14/11/2014  

3  

Motorola Demand: $8.98

Comparison of RAND Royalty with Motorola 802.11 Demand

Xbox 360 Kinect Bundle

RAND Royalty: $0.03471

PDX030