PATANJALI’S YOGA SUTRAS. - LYTTGlyttg.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Patanjali-Oct-2016.pdf ·...
Transcript of PATANJALI’S YOGA SUTRAS. - LYTTGlyttg.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Patanjali-Oct-2016.pdf ·...
Page 1 of 21
PATANJALI’S YOGA SUTRAS.
Patanjali’s yoga sutras are considered to be a central guide to yoga
practice and experience. A guide that it is helpful to return to again and
again as a reference point and map that can help to make sense of some
of the territory we enter through yoga practice. It can give us a foothold
when we first start out in our practice but perhaps much of it only starts
to seem relevant and helpful after some experience and depth of
practice.
Just a reminder on a couple of ideas used in philosophy which may have a
bearing on how we take the book:
Dualism – where the nature of reality is described by separating it out
into component parts: matter, energy and consciousness.
Non-dualism – Where the apparent diversity of life is described as an
illusion or mirage – all is ultimately connected at source – in this case
consciousness.
Patanjali is described as dualistic by some and non-dualistic by others!
Perhaps the confusion is due to the fact that elements of nature and
reality are separated to help explanation. The central question relating to
this is whether there is an aspect of consciousness existing separately
from matter and energy within a human being, a spiritual element if you
like? This could be seen to be implied at times in Patanjali. Or does a base
level of consciousness exist within us only as the deepest layer of our own
mind?
Personally I feel we can happily appreciate Patanjali from a Humanistic
perspective as an exploration of layers of human life and depth
psychology. But equally there is a question of the ‘mystery of
consciousness’ which perhaps leaves a more open question as to how far
consciousness permeates and what its origins are (modern physics/science
is also interested in this question) . Either way the book is a useful guide
to practice.
Page 2 of 21
1. BACKGROUND AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT
Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras were one of six systems of Indian philosophy that
developed during the period 400 BCE - 400 CE. The dates are vague, as
there are no clear records. This text likely had a long gestation period
before ideas from the older books and oral teachings crystallised and
were systematized and written down. If we take the Upanishads as
reflecting the original enlightened wisdom of the Yogis, then the six
systems (traditionally named ‘Darsanas’ – view points) are more
sophisticated analyses of this wisdom and view of reality with each one
looking from a slightly different philosophical angle. Like looking at the
same mountain summit from a different geographical viewpoint, most
scholars tend towards the idea that in general the 6 Darsanas are
complementary views of a many sided reality rather than competing
theories.
In relation to the cultural context of the time, some scholars feel that
the development of the 6 systems was in response to the popularity and
intellectual clarity of Buddhism (even though they don’t contradict
Buddhism). The lists of steps and stages of practice and lists of
obstacles and hindrances in Patanjali perhaps reflect this. Or perhaps
lists were just the intellectual trend of the time as memorising was a key
element of learning as there was no printed matter as such.
In Brief, the six systems are:
1. Nyaya – A system of logic establishing the correct procedure for
gaining knowledge of an object.
2. Vashheshika – identifies an object through the characteristics
that differentiate it from any other.
3. Samkya – A dualist approach that separates matter and
spirit/energy in order to analyse the nature of both, and also how
they interrelate.
4. Yoga (Patanjali) – the practical means of refining perception from
matter though to our true nature as consciousness - presented in a
clearly laid out path .
5. Karma Mimansa – a consideration of the entire field of action to
determine which actions and attitudes are in accordance with the
Page 3 of 21
nature of consciousness; as well as philosophy and morality it
includes the science of Vedic rituals in relation to living in harmony
with the natural order of the elements and consciousness.
6. Advaita Vedanta – (Based on the Upanishads) is non-dualist in that
in the final analysis all of life is unified by being an expression of
consciousness, underlying reality or Brahman. Put another way
there is an underlying Unity within the Diversity.
Patanjali – who was he? In keeping with the vagueness of the dates, was
an enigmatic figure about which little is known. It is generally agreed that
he was not a founder of yoga or anything like that, but someone who
collated and systematized all the information about existing practices and
ideas. It is important to remember that yoga had been evolving in varying
forms in India for a long time albeit in a loosely organised culture. Much
of what is in his work is scattered about in the Vedas, the Upanishads and
the Bhagavad-Gita in a less orderly way.
His Yoga Sutra’s are generally considered to be the definitive guide to
what has become known as Classical Yoga; it is though important to
realise that whilst they represent the mainstream of Yoga philosophy and
theory, he could only collate what he knew about, which in the vastness of
India (and its isolated pockets), was unlikely to be everything. Also he
perhaps only included what he agreed with or with generally socially
acceptable yoga practices and may have been influenced as to what to
include/exclude by other authorities. We also need to bear in mind that
there has always been a healthy diversity within yoga and varying aspects
of the tradition and there is sometimes a tension between more
conservative traditionalists and progressive modernists in any discipline
or art, and both usually have a point. Tantric practices which are arguably
the source of most/much hatha yoga that we practice are less included
perhaps due to some of their practices and lifestyles at the time being
viewed as disreputable (we look at Tantra later)
That said, whilst there has been much creative innovation in yoga practice
and teaching in the modern day, and useful scientific understandings, we
might usefully reflect whether what we are doing is consistent with the
essence of Patanjali’s message, which is generally accepted by most as
providing a useful baseline reference point for authentic yoga practice.
Page 4 of 21
2. MAIN IDEAS MEANINGS AND TERMS.
Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras are organised into 4 books of Sutras (sometimes
called aphorisms). Sutra means thread. A Sutra is a concise one liner
(designed for easy memorising within the oral tradition) that requires
commentary and interpretation by an experienced teacher and
practitioner. The main purpose of the Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras is to
describe the stages, developments and pitfalls of an inner journey that is
unfamiliar to most of us.
In looking at this text we might reconsider closely the main term; yoga
and what our associations with the word are? In relation to Patanjali’s
sutras yoga is described in six ways with perhaps number one being the
primary definition:
1. The stilling of the thought waves of the mind – and ceasing to
identify with thoughts through incorrect identification with a
separate sense of I.
2. Union with the divine/core consciousness– whereby we realise our
true nature beyond the conditioning of body and mind.
3. Integration – of all aspects of ourselves: body, mind/emotion and
spirit/consciousness
4. Connection – as in to connect together ( on many levels)
5. Relationship – to self and other.
6. Yoke – in the sense of a harness.
All of the meanings interrelate and arguably one is not more correct or
definite than another. The idea of yoking or harnessing the forces or
energies of mind and body on various levels is a useful idea to bear in mind
for this text, in addition to the other meanings rather than instead of
them.
In the light of Patanjali’s text we could perhaps describe a Yogi(ni) using
modern terminology as someone with a fully integrated personality
gathered around a still boundless centre. This definition includes all the
above ideas and includes the idea of a rounded personality or character
which cannot be developed without engagement in the world as well as
yoga practice.
As we start to look at the path set out by Patanjali, it seems that a kind
and generous but clear and firm, harnessing and gathering of our
Page 5 of 21
attention is at the centre of the story so that we can look closely at and
SEE CLEARLY our experience of body and mind. In practical and general
terms it describes the path of harnessing the energy of the largely
distracted and outwardly directed mind in various ways in order to draw
that energy inwards to a simpler, clearer consciousness to understand our
inner workings and realise our true essence. The texts describe the
makeup of the mind and the psyche and how to refine our perception in
order to see beyond our conditioned state.
Main Terms
Purusha – Purusha is essentially the same as Brahman, an unchanging
underlying reality or a base consciousness underlying all. Variously
described as ‘The knower’, ‘The seer’ or ‘The witness’ or consciousness
that exists behind the surface activities of the mind. It is possible for
Purusha to be reflected through the subtle quiet aspects of the mind
allowing us clear seeing that this underlying consciousness is our true
nature. The mind, interestingly, is classified under Prakriti or Matter (see
below). Purusha sees things as they are without the warping filter of the
conditioned mind that prevents us seeing and knowing clearly and directly.
The idea of ‘The Witness’ is interesting to consider in relation to
meditation in the form of the question: What is it that is able to
observe our experience of thoughts, feelings and emotions without
identifying with them?
Prakriti – or matter/energy (on gross and subtle levels) - Described as
‘the Known’ – is the primal substance, the matrix of all physical life, the
‘matter/energy’ out of which arises the whole of objective creation
described as ‘the world’. It also includes the physical body, the energetic
body (physiology), The gunas (sattva, rajas, tamas) the elements of life (
earth, water, fire, wind and space) , the psyche, the mind on various levels
(essentially the 5 Koshas, which we look at later in Tantra and Hatha
Yoga)
In this way our nature is described as an interrelating continuum from
gross to subtle – body ( anatomy) energy (physiology), various layers and
functions of mind, feeling and emotion and pure consciousness (our true
nature) .
Page 6 of 21
The Gunas – are the core ‘energetic expressions’ arising from
consciousness as it begins to form into matter/energy - the base
constituents of matter/energy that can be worked with/balanced to some
degree through lifestyle and diet choices and yoga practices:
Rajas – Active energy.
Tamas – inertia or restraining energy that checks the activity of Rajas.
Sattva – Clarity or harmonizing energy that integrates and balances the
effects of Rajas and Tamas.
The Sattvic state is traditionally described as the ideal for Yoga
practitioners and can be facilitated through balanced practice,
appropriate diet and balanced lifestyle choices. The Sattvic state helps
us prepare for meditation and brings us closer to the subtler areas of the
mind able to reflect Purusha/consciousness. It is associated with the
body/mind feeling light and clear.
Excess Rajas can be exacerbated by excessive stimulation though
caffeine, rushing around and overly driven behaviours for example .
Excess Tamas can be due to sloth, heavy foods and alcohol for example.
In terms of health, Sattva could perhaps equate to something like
homeostasis - a term describing balance from western
anatomy/physiology/medicine. Sometimes the gunas are described in
terms of gross or subtle ‘vibration’ with the sattvic lifestyle meaning we
‘vibrate at a higher level or resolution’. Certainly in terms of health and
well-being we can consider the times when we feel light, energised and
centred (Sattva); as opposed to energised in a driven head spinning way
which is ultimately depleting (excess rajas); or heavy, unmotivated,
slothful and tired (excess tamas), and then relate that to our recent
lifestyle choices. It usually adds up!
Elements – are the next stage of development into matter . They are not
so much mentioned in Patanjali but form the basis of most Asian
traditional medical systems including Ayurveda ( a sister science of yoga)
Earth, Water, Fire, Wind, Space.
Page 7 of 21
Very simply: earth and water are our anatomy and fire and wind our
physiology and space is the element within which the other elements
function. Often in yoga parlance we talk about the need to ‘make space’ in
body and mind – this allows the other elements to function well in a
balanced way.
Wind is a name given to movement and energy which is often
interchangeable with Prana ( see later)
Purusha and Prakriti and the interplay between the two is the central
feature in understanding of Patanjali’s yoga and the path to liberation.
Sometimes the language can seem a little esoteric and/or symbolic but in
essence still describes what’s been said already.
Purusha is the Male principle of base consciousness and Prakriti the
Female Principle of dynamic activity and the world. ‘The world’ (Prakriti) is
ultimately a manifestation of Purusha/consciousness. Prakriti depends on
Purusha for her life, as the earth depends on the sun, yet Purusha
remains unaffected by the activity of his consort, Prakriti.
Liberation is when Purusha realises its separateness from Prakriti and is a
silent witness to all activity including that of the body and mind. This why
Purusha is described as ‘the knower’ and Prakriti as ‘the known’ ( this is
also where perhaps the dualism interpretation of Patanjali comes from
).This is the state of freedom when we realise we are, in essence,
unattached consciousness (or spirit), but also paradoxically -
consciousness/spirit that animates all manifestation of energy and matter
(which brings us back to non-dualism).
An important implication of this is that Purusha/consciousness cannot
know itself without the stimulation of Prakriti/Matter or the world. We
need the world as a stimulus and reference point to see if we are on the
right path.
Also described in Patanjali as part of this dynamic, is that while Prakriti
cannot influence Purusha, a mind that is operating from the subtlest level
– clearly reflecting Purusha – can potentially influence any other relatively
grosser level of creation – Prakriti – that it chooses. Or it may be that
phenomena are perceived in an unusual way at this level. This is the basis
of the ‘Siddhis’ or Supernormal Powers found in Book 3 of Patanjali.
Page 8 of 21
A few words to revisit for Patanjali :
Dukkha – The existential suffering/dissatisfaction arising out of the
mind states and incorrect perceptions that arise due to falsely
identifying with a separate sense of self/I. Or otherwise put: the
existential suffering caused by resisting life as it is. This mode of
suffering does though provide a motivation for practice and curiousity.
Samskaras – habits,ruts, entrenched pathways in the brain; tendencies
and patterns of behaviour or reactivity. In jargon terms: subliminal
activators deep in the psyche. Essentially unconscious tendencies (as in,
we are not properly aware of them) that have a significant impact on our
attitudes, choices and responses in life.
An analogy often given for meditation is that the distracted mind is like
the choppy surface of a lake giving no possibility of seeing down; the
process of meditation stills the lake surface allowing a clear view down to
the lake bottom where old objects may be seen – these are the
Samskaras. The increasing awareness bought about by Yoga practice can
allow us to dive down and see clearly these old patterns, hurts and
conflicts and resolve them, thus deactivating negative tendencies.
Traditional language would say it something like: uprooting Karmic seeds
that are waiting to ripen. (See section on Dyhana/Meditation later)
Chitta – The deepest level of the conscious mind – the lakebed where the
Samskaras lie.
Vrittis – Fluctuations of the mind – the multitude of mental distractions
that prevent us seeing down to the Chitta – or lakebed.
Kleshas – literally trouble or affliction – primarily the wrong
identification with ego and the negative emotions, thought patterns and
tendencies that can come out of that.
Vairagya – Non-attachment. To re-clarify this does not mean a
detachment or disconnection from life – quite the opposite – it means
non-attachment to identification with the ego and all the froth and mind
stuff and reactivity that goes with it. So once all that is out the way it is
the most direct connection to life. In its highest form it would be the
Page 9 of 21
Purusha as ‘the knower/witness’ observing all the activity of Prakriti ‘the
known’ in its proper perspective.
Brahma Viharas – the qualities of Purusha - variously translated as
‘divine abidings’ or the ‘four immeasurables’ . Or highest attitudes or
emotions. Common also to Buddhism. Each one arises naturally in the
unconditioned consciousness state but can be practiced as meditations .
Metta is considered the foundation for all the others. Interestingly they
also have a ‘far enemy’ the opposite, and a ‘near enemy’ which can look a
bit like the original but be coloured by negativity .
1. Metta – acceptance, friendliness and active good will towards oneself
and all of life. This quality/practice is considered to be the antidote to
fear and is the foundation from which the following three qualities
emerge naturally.
Far Enemy: Hatred
Near Enemy: Attachment
2. Karuna – compassion – the feeling of the suffering of others as one’s
own .
Far Enemy: Cruelty
Near Enemy: Pity
3. Mudita – Empathetic Joy – the feeling of joy because others are
happy/successful .
Far Enemy: Envy
Near Enemy: Insincerity , Comparison.
4. Upekkha – Equanimity , even mindedness, an ability to stay steady and
treat people impartially .
Far Enemy: Anxiety/Greed
Near Enemy: Indifference , Disassociation .
3 PATANJALIS YOGA SUTRAS - THE 4 BOOKS/CHAPTERS IN
SUMMARY
Page 10 of 21
Book 1. – The Book on Samadhi or Ecstasy – 51 verses
Yoga is defined and its characteristics discussed – also presented are the
difficulties in attaining Yoga and how they may be addressed.
The first four sutras of chapter 1 contain the whole of Patanjali’s
message whilst the rest of the book is an elaboration of the message;
this was the presentation style of the time.
The first four Sutras: (In English combining various translations)
1. And now the teaching on yoga begins.
2. Yoga is the settling of the mind into silence (or is the stilling of
the thought waves of the mind)
3. When the mind has settled, we are established in our essential
nature, which is unbounded consciousness
4. Our Essential Nature is usually overshadowed by the activity of
the mind and our identification with that.
In general the settling of the mind, on whatever level is initially possible
forms the basis of the Yogic path and practice in whatever forms it is
taking.
Book 1 also includes
Obstacles to practice and causes of Dukkha – suffering/dissatisfaction.
V 30
Illness
Fatigue
Doubt
Carelessness
Laziness
Attachment
Delusion
Failure to achieve and maintain samadhi
V 31 - ‘These distractions make the body restless, the breathing course
and the mind agitated. They Result in suffering.’
Page 11 of 21
There is also a description of meditation as a process of increasingly
refined awareness of more and more subtle levels of existence through to
the threshold of pure consciousness. Full enlightenment is when the state
of unbounded awareness is present at all times. (This doesn’t mean there
are no thoughts – just no mistaken identification with them) Essentially
an idea of enlightenment as a fully integrated personality gathered
around a still quiet boundless centre.
Book 2 – The Book on the Path – 55 verses
Describes the necessary qualities to train the mind from a state of
distraction to one of attention. It explains why these qualities are
important and what the practice of them entails. In general there is an
overview including a philosophical assessment of the human condition and
how ignorance arises, and then the practical path of Yoga including the
first 5 of the 8 limbs of Yoga that is the most well known exposition of
the Yogic path.
V2 The causes of Dukkha (suffering/dissatisfaction):
1. Ignorance of our real nature
2. Egoism – false identification to a sense of a separate self.
3. Attachment – to this identification.
4. Aversion – resisting the flow of life – based on 1,2 and 3.
5. Fear of death – as being central in creating a clinging attitude.
V 18 – The world is not denied but its value is seen as to provide us with
experience and thus lead us to liberation. The world is considered as the
manure for enlightenment in both gross and subtle ways. A progressive
level of subtlety of the Gunas is listed – gross, subtle, causal and
unmanifest (existing only as potential) reaffiming the idea that we need
the world (Prakriti) to realise our true identity as Purusha/consciousness.
THE PATH
The eight limbs of Yoga
The genius of Patanjali is that these 8 limbs of the path of Yoga are all
inextricably linked; from the harnessing of the mind by paying attention
to our actions and lifestyle choices and their consequences to how we
feel, through the attention required for Asana and embodiment practice,
through the slow further inward turning towards one pointed
Page 12 of 21
concentration for meditation where we look through layers of the mind to
our source consciousness. There is a consistent thread running through
the limbs asking us to harness and gather in our distracted ‘monkey mind’
tendencies, see clearly and to integrate and heal all aspects of ourselves,
no less. 1 Yamas – (universal ethics and laws of life)
Ahimsa -Non-violence - and its positive side, love and openness.
Satya – Truthfulness and honesty.
Asteya – Integrity/non stealing or its opposite – giving of time, energy or
things. Recognising that any form of stealing arises out of a feeling of
lack.
Brahmacharya - Traditionally sometimes described as celibacy for
ashram and intensive practice situations: but essentially to do with
conserving life force energy and directing it towards yoga practice
instead . In more general terms, and for most of us living in society,
Brahmacharya refers less to celibacy and more broadly to conserving
energy for yoga practice/study and or life’s more worthwhile activities
and not wasting time on activities/distractions that suck your life force
for no obvious value. We may reflect on what these are as there is
arguably a subjective element to this – but I think we can all identify
when we have spent time doing something that leaves us feeling in some
way satisfied, enhanced or enriched as opposed to something that leaves
us a bit flat or empty or drained.
Aparigraha - Non-Attachment or Non-Hoarding - and its positive side –
giving. Uprooting the tendency to reinforce ‘who we are’ by what we own
or presenting a certain persona. Acceptance of our limitations and just
being ourselves.
The Yamas are given as universal ethical guidance – so not commandments
or rules – more ethics to reflect on. At times when we are in touch with
our pure consciousness the suggestion is we would live according to these
without effort – it would just be obvious as these choices are in alignment
with the nature of that consciousness. But they also help support practice
in the first place, with the suggestion that if you live out of alignment
with them, the mind will not settle and other formal structured yoga
practices will be harder. They are practices to reflect on in that we can
Page 13 of 21
notice as we go along the effects of living in alignment with these
principles and how we feel, and the effects and feelings in relation to not
following them.
2. Niyama (Guidance for living and personal qualities to cultivate)
Saucha - Purity/Simplicity – simplify life (as much as is possible in this
society) – also part of the seeing clearly the activities of the mind
through meditation. Keeping integrity by just being who you are.
Santosa – Contentment and equanimity – we may usefully look at times of
discontent and what is at the source of it. Trusting in life.
Tapas – Fire / Purification. Variously translated as:
1. As regards practice – it is a clear directing of our energy to practice -
intentionally creating space in our life to practice so that it is something
of a priority. Self-discipline.
2. Also refers to some of the physical/mental purification effects that
practice has in terms of releasing and clearing the conditioning and
tension stored in the various systems and layers of the body.
Svadyaya - Study and Refinement – traditionally study and reflection on
the texts. But also any self-reflective or enquiring activity; active
curiosity about life, our nature and our yoga practice.
Isvara Prandidhana – openness to explorations of something bigger than
our small self-concerns. A surrender into wider landscape of pure
consciousness and an acceptance that on that level we are not in control.
As with Yamas, Niyamas would occur naturally from the perspective of
Purusha/Consciousness but act as a prompting guide in the meantime.
Yamas and Niyamas 2 – V’s 33- 45 are also considered ways of living that
will ensure safety on many levels; for self, family, community, society and
globally. Imagine a world where most people tried to live this way. They
most certainly aren’t to do with reward or punishment in relation living by
certain rules or commandments; they are an experiment in cause and
effect in how we live, how we feel in response to conscious living and how
the world responds to us – a testing of the law of Karma if you like,
Page 14 of 21
whether how we are living is a cause of mental suffering or a release from
it. In general, as we go about life ,we can notice the movement around the
heart centre in particular and the body in general in relation to ethical
decisions and our general attitudes towards things – if we feel
contraction around the chest, jaw etc – we may reconsider what we are
about to do or reflect on how we are relating to something.
We can consider if this kind of ethical practice as a discipline as a
freedom in and of itself – in that we are liberated from just acting out
every whim (a form of addiction), or just ‘joining in with the crowd’.
The Yamas and Niyamas start to uproot and bring awareness to
Samskaras and negative tendencies. Traditionally speaking we are also
preventing the accumulation of negative karma in form of generating or
giving power to more samskaras or negative tendencies.
In this way our ‘yoga practice’ extends way off the mat/cushion into
everything. Without our regular life we wouldn’t really have a reference
point for our practice.
3.Asana – Sthira (Stable and Alert) and Sukha (Ease, comfort,
release). V’s 46 - 48
That is all that is said about Asana for three possible reasons – one is
that he didn’t consider them very important, another is that they require
a teacher to be taught and another is the practice of them as we might
recognise it was more of a later development. It’s hard to know. Perhaps
it also just relates to our sitting position for meditation – which as we
know – sitting still and upright with stability and ease takes some training
for.
The placing of Asana early in the eight limbs, though, suggests that a
grounding of our attention/awareness in the body as part of the holistic
process of Yoga is very important. It is the beginning of learning how to
turn our attention inward to the felt sense of ourselves. The beginning of
the journey from feeling/working through gross matter towards pure
consciousness. For many of us it is a realistic and convenient place to
start and it is perhaps part of the genius of Yoga that the body is
included in the path rather than ignored or denigrated. A modern term
that has arisen in relation to this is ‘embodiment’ . Embodiment trainings
and practices are now a ‘thing’, certainly in the west.
Page 15 of 21
There is much to consider with asana training. We are working with and
harnessing universal principles of movement relating to physical laws of
nature and the human body and mind as a whole (Gravity breath etc.) If
we consider all the ramifications of Sthira and Sukha in Asana practice
there is much to explore on that basis. We may ask if the physical natural
laws we work with in Asana practice are natural laws in the same way as
the moral ‘natural laws’ arising from Yama and Niyama? In both cases, we
have to focus on the way things actually work and connect together in
relation to the forces acting on us, and work harmoniously with them,
rather than imposing our will onto the situation. On some level Asana
practice can help as part of the clearing and healing of conditioning,
blockages and tension stored in the various systems and layers of the
body. Also from the yogic perspective, as part of the spectrum of
Prakriti, the body is the mind and a useful way in to explore our deeper
layers and tendencies.
4. Pranayama – sometimes translated as breath control – perhaps
more accurately as energy (Prana) awareness, management and
expansion.
Essentially when we develop a more refined awareness of our inner
environment and are less distracted by muscular tensions and external
stimuli, we can become more attuned to the sense of vitality or life force
circulating the body. In India this is traditionally known as Prana, in the
Far East as Chi, and sometimes in modern parlance it is known as ‘bio
energy’.
Somewhat inconveniently for our science orientated western minds it
cannot be measured or seen in the way that it is described in older
Eastern texts. But many Eastern approaches also describe these
energetic ideas in more tangible terms such as element theories – the
earth as body/anatomy, fire as heat in the body, water as our fluid
systems, wind as movement on many levels including: through blood
vessels, nerve conductivity, tendons, muscles , fascia, neuro transmitters,
endocrine (hormonal) influences, mind movements, emotional movements,
thoughts and then the space within which all this occurs . It’s not
surprising that there is an overall feeling of energy – in harmony or not,
or blocked or not. Wind is a term often used interchangeably with Prana
in some Asian traditions and in breathing practices. It is certainly easier
for us in the west to understand prana in terms of movement through all
Page 16 of 21
the pathways described above, which produce ‘feelings of energy’ as
opposed to some mysterious unseeable energetic force.
Our breathing has quite an effect on this level. Breathing and our state
of mind and physiology have a direct interrelationship that can be
observed. I suspect this is really the heart of pranayama – the effects of
the breath on our system and mind.
There are a variety of pranayamas or breathing practices all designed to
further refine our awareness and harmonise our system in readiness for
meditation . Having worked with the breath in various ways it can then
come to its own resting condition more easily which supports the
quietening of the mind.
Pranayama V’s 49 –51
5 Pratyahara – Retirement or withdrawal of the senses, also
translated as the return of the senses to their natural function or
cleansing the doors of perception.
Traditionally described as the turning inward of the attention by turning
the direction of flow of the senses inwards. If we consider that the main
role of the senses is to present the mind with information from the
outside world, and that yoga practice is dealing largely with the inner life
then this limb is to help us centre ourselves inwardly on various levels.
Some would say this is a natural process, as the senses will be drawn
towards what is most ultimately satisfying.
When we consider the idea of ‘returning the senses to their natural
function’ or ‘cleansing the doors of perception’ – this can perhaps help us
be aware of the ‘outer’ whilst being connected to the ‘inner’ so we can
live and respond to life in a more centred way with greater awareness
of our inner responses to outer stimuli.
There is no suggestion here of absence from sensory pleasures – in fact
the more the senses are refined the greater the riches they reveal. This
is an area where there is room for experimentation, for example we can
compare how the world looks through narrow hard eyes as opposed to
wide soft eyes. A related type of practice that is interesting is to try to
live more in the back of the body, and then see how the senses feel? And
maybe we end up living more in the centre of the body? Another
Page 17 of 21
interesting area is hearing; hearing in particular is often given importance
in Yoga and Buddhist meditation teaching – it is reputedly the first sense
to properly awaken in the foetus and the last sense to leave at the time
of death (hence the tradition to read sacred texts to the dying or
‘recently dead’). Often people in a coma, with all other senses seemingly
suspended, report that they could hear. In some forms of Buddhist
meditation – opened relaxed hearing is often given as one of the first
points of attention to widen and expand the mind. In other texts where
Prakriti is broken down more – hearing is said to be the senior sense,
operating through the medium of space, which is the subtlest of the
great elements from which the other four; wind, fire, water and earth
sequentially unfold. It is interesting to experiment with hearing,
particularly relaxed receptive hearing and sensory awareness generally
and how we experience it in different states of mind.
Another description is that with the practice of yoga in general, over
time the senses provide less disturbance to the mind.
Pratyahara v’s 52 – 55
Book 3 – the last 3 stages of the path and the Book on the Powers –
55 verses
Book 3 continues into the last three stages of the eight limbs relating to
Meditation, and is also about Samyama (The simultaneous practice of
Dharana, Dyana and Samadhi) and the Siddhis (powers) that can arise out
of Samyama on various object’s/experiences. The Siddhis in essence arise
out of the relationship between the subtlest levels of mind reflecting
Purusha and its’ ability to influence Prakriti – or how the non distracted
mind can probe deeply into objects and concepts so that they are
experienced in a dimension previously unknown.There are also warnings
about the inherent dangers and distractions from the path that can arise
from the powers and we are advised to move beyond them. In an attempt
to understand or speculate about the Siddhis we could consider that in
quantum physics particles and waves do not behave in the same ways as
the grosser constituents of matter do.
Another way to consider Samyama is that when we experience life
through a non-conceptual meditative state we see things more clearly and
directly for what they actually are.
Page 18 of 21
V’s 45 - 47 give an impressive list of Siddhis that would indeed be handy!
But we are also given various warnings about getting distracted by them
and falling off the path just as we near completion - for example in V 51.
6.Dharana – Concentration – not to be confused with the kind of heady
concentration with its accompanied furrowed brow that we may be used
to; Yogic concentration is a whole body experience free from muscular
and other tension. The body aspect of concentration and meditation
reaffirms the value of asana practice.
To settle the mind we aim the attention on an object (the breath a
mantra or whatever) and try to sustain it. The mind can be harnessed in
this respect – learning to concentrate is not a mystery, it ‘just’ requires
training.
7.Dhyana – Meditation – When the mind is undistracted – a non-
conceptual awareness arises; or when you can aim and sustain mental
attention effortlessly for a period (some say for a minimum of 12 breaths
for example) then awareness arises – again this is not a mystery. Over
time we may find that attention on the chosen object of concentration is
less necessary to stay in open non-conceptual awareness. This is where we
would start to enter the more subtle realms of the mind – it can be
blissful at times though we may also find some helpful trouble lurking in
the form of the Samskaras – we may see/experience these as repeat
thought patterns/emotions or feelings we can then investigate and let go
of in the light of bringing them to consciousness.
A teacher or mentor can be helpful to reflect and clarify your experience
but essentially as we get to more refined states we try to let go each
time we feel contraction/tightness in the body/mind . Each time we shine
the light of awareness on a samskara or tendency and let go of it instead
of allowing it to take hold of us – it loses its power or grip over us – or put
another way we burn off our karma this way; you have to feel it to heal it.
Strong emotional release is possible sometimes (though not necessarily) –
but if there is any trouble that arises and seems unmanageable then
professional help may be advisable. Traditionally a yoga teacher may have
taken on this role – but in our culture this may not always be a good idea.
Teachers who make themselves overly available in this way perhaps need
to be viewed carefully.
Page 19 of 21
8.Samadhi – Ecstasy or pure awareness (Purusha) - relates to further
varying levels of deep absorption (through the subtle layers of the mind)
so that we are connected into Purusha. According to some authors there
are as many as twelve layers of Samadhi (though how someone would be
counting this in non conceptual meditation, or determining when one layer
changes to another, I’m not sure?).
The levels relate to progressively more subtle levels of the mind until the
final level when Purusha shines cleanly through the lens of the mind and
you can see clearly, as when having cleaned a dirty window. These deeper
levels are reached partly by the length of time in undistracted meditation
and partly by the process of letting go through the deeper levels of
conditioning stored in the mind. It is seemingly possible to become
familiar with these deeper levels so it becomes ‘easier’ to reside in them
and to stay with them to a degree in ‘normal waking consciousness’. It’s
not that thoughts and normal processes stop, more that we no longer
identify with them in an attached way that restricts us.
Even if it is hard to maintain that type of awareness in daily living,
experiences of this kind from deeper meditation can sustain us and stay
with us on some level and likely they will change us in some way. In
addition these experiences can have a significant impact on how we then
perceive things and choose to live thus bringing us back full circle to the
practice of Yamas and Niyamas, which may, from a changed perspective,
seem the ‘natural’ or ‘obvious’ way to live.
When we are able to reside in Samadhi all the time we would be in the
enlightened state – this would not be living in some kind of daze, but
seeing and experiencing life from the perspective of ‘the witness’ or
Purusha or pure consciousness - so we would be involved fully in life and
all its attending drama, but see it in its proper perspective. Someone who
is liberated in life is known traditionally as a Jiva-Mukti.
Book 4 – Book on liberation – 34 verses.
This book presents the possibilities for a person who has understood
their nature as pure consciousness – in essence the mind is the servant
and not the master. There is further philosophical consideration of the
path and the enlightened state.
Page 20 of 21
Books
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali – Alistair Shearer
How to know God – Christopher Isherwood and Swami Prabhavananda.
Yoga Unveiled – A Users Guide to the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali – Godfrey
Devereux.
All books are good – some beginners to the subject prefer Shearer.
Christopher Isherwood’s has stood the test of time, and Godfrey
Devereux’s is possibly more Humanist in approach – but maybe a little
harder without having read another version first.
It is interesting to consider that all of these authors seem to interpret
Patanjali ultimately through the filter of Vedanta (i.e. non-dualism),
seeing that as the ultimate goal.
Possible inquiry questions to consider for our session ( in no particular
order) :
Are we clear about Dualism and Non Dualism? – How do you understand
them?
What do you understand by the various meanings of the term Yoga. P.4
What do you think of the Brahma Viharas and their near and far enemies
? p.9
How do you feel about the external world being necessary in order to
become liberated?
How might we practice the Yamas and Niyamas from the perspective of
body/mind direct experience and sensation?
Can the same rules apply to our Asana practice?
Do you think that the Yamas and Niyamas bring us into alignment with
something? If so what?
What might the Gunas tell us about our approach to Yoga Practice?
Page 21 of 21
What do you think the Witness/Consciousness state that is able to
observe our thoughts, emotions, feelings, sensations without identifying
with them is ?
How do life and objects in general appear from the perspective of the
Witness/Consciousness, without the conceptual attatchments? – Can we
experience life in its essence without the concepts and stories attached?
The Purusha/Prakriti dynamic, along with the notion of the Siddhis, raises
some interesting questions about the relationship between matter and
energy and mind. Modern quantum physics has concluded that Energy and
Matter are one and the same which fits with Prakriti nicely – but can
consciousness influence matter? If so in what kinds of ways?
Do you like the description of Liberation or Yoga as being ‘A fully
integrated personality gathered around a silent boundless centre’? Why
or why not?
As we practice more deeply – do our negative tendencies or Samskaras
seem to ‘get worse’ ? If so Why ?