Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

31
Henrik von Hofsten Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

description

Harvesting technique, logistic problems/solutions/economy/ecology. By Henrik von Hofsten, Skogforsk, for woodenergyproject.eu

Transcript of Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Page 1: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Henrik von Hofsten

Past, current and future developments

of modern forest fuel systems

Page 2: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Utilization of forest biomass in Sweden

36 %

Paper & Pulp

16 %

Pulp chips

10 % Bark & sawdust

20 %

Sawn goods 46 %

Sawlogs

8 % Traditional firewood

23 %

Energy 46 %

Pulpwood

Annual felling

94 M m3

Source: Skogsindustrierna, 2003 och SCB/SKS

Page 3: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Low fruits are already taken

Bark

Slash

Fire wood

Black

liquers

Saw dust

Stumps

Small trees

Page 4: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

So, what do we do?

Page 5: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Technical development – stump lifter

1978 2008

Page 6: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems
Page 7: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Reduce transport costs

Page 8: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Net cost comparison

0

50

100

150

200

Normal New

SKr/MWh

Soil handling

Transport

Comminution

Lifting

Page 9: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

0 50 100 150 200 250

Euro(2002)/MWh

Cumulative use of biofuels (TWh)

Suorce: M.Junginger & Björheden 2005

Cost reduction of unrefined wood

residues in Sweden 1975-2003

Page 10: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Cost reduction in stump lifting 2006-2010

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

1 10 100 1000 10000

Costs, Skr/MWh

Accumulated area, ha

Sites

Average/yr

Page 11: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

0,0

1,0

2,0

3,0

4,0

5,0

6,0

7,0

8,0

Normal New

Pe

rce

nt o

f o

utp

ut

Soil handling

Transport

Comminution

Lifting

Environmental benefit

Nort

h s

ea o

il

Input/output ratio – fossil vs. forest fuel

Page 13: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Felling methods

0

5

10

15

20

Today Sweep Tomorrow

m3/hour

Page 14: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Felling methods

Diameter 4-8 cm

Yield per corridor

20-40 stems

or 150-300 kg

Page 15: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Max. equipment weight 700 kg

Min. height upper/lower

accumulation arms 55 cm

Accumulating capacity

To accum 40 stems á 4 cm 0,078 m² or 30 cm dia

30 stems á 5 cm 0,09 m² or 35 cm dia

Felling equipment

Page 16: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Profitiability in small dia. stands

Yielded

stems/hour

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

0

Break even

7,5

15,0

22,5

30,0

37,5

m3/h

Diameter, cm

Page 17: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems
Page 18: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Surplus and shortage

areas

Railways ?

Logistic structure

– Terminals

Organization

Page 19: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Railway terminals

Page 20: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Logistics – what goes where and

when

Need for optimization software

Page 21: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Logistics on site – GPS can help

Page 22: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Productivity & fuel consumption

Page 23: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Effect of screen size

-30

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

Production Fuel consump.

Change, %

60 ˣ 40 mm

60 ˣ 240 mm

Page 24: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Maintenance

Page 25: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Knife maintenance

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

120%

140%

160%

180%

0 100 200 300

Tonnes chipped

Knife wear

-20

-15

-10

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

New Bad

Production

Fuel

Page 26: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Other topics of interest

Supply chain

Logistics

Transportation

Certification FSC, PEFC

Business and trade

Page 27: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Terminal solutions

Page 28: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Other topics of interest

Supply chain

Logistics

Transportation

Certification FSC, PEFC

Business and trade

Page 29: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Many trade units = confusion

MWh

Ton dry

Ton raw

Hectare

m3 loose chips

m3 solid biom

m3 solid round wood

m3 solid ub incl. bark

ODt Oven dry tonnes

Page 30: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Costs 2009 Slash Small diam. Round wood Stumps

To land owner 39 14 60 2

Harvest ̶ 41 14 43

Forwarding 33 26 19 25

Other 8 6 9 3

∑ at road side 80 87 102 73

Comminution 44 31 16 40

Terminal costs 7 6 12 8

Road transport 34 34 29 46

Administration 7 6 8 6

∑ at heat plant 172 165 167 174

All costs in SKr per m3loose

Page 31: Past, current and future developments of modern forest fuel systems

Henrik von Hofsten [email protected]

Thank you!