Paper presented at ACWA ConferenceSydney 18 August 2008

Deborah Brennan (Social Policy Research Centre, UNSW)Bettina Cass (Social Policy Research Centre, UNSW)

Anne Hampshire (Mission Australia)Sue Green (Nura Gili UNSW)

Understanding Grandparent Care

Policy and practice implications of grandparents as primary carers of their

grandchildren in Australia

Australian Research Council Linkage GrantAustralian Research Council Linkage Grant

Researchers from:- Social Policy Research Centre, UNSW- Nura Gili, UNSW- Australian National University

Partner organisations- Mission Australia- FaHCSIA- NT Dept of Health and Community Services - SA Dept for Families and Communities - NSW Dept of Community Services

3 year study (2008-2010)

We aim to:

Bring the voices and perspectives of grandparent-headed families into the policy-making process

Conduct a national audit of policies that impact upon grandparent-headed families

Identify gaps in policies and services and help to formulate solutions

Work collaboratively with research participants and our Industry Partners

Locate Australian practice in comparative perspective

Some features of our study

Three sites: NSW, Northern Territory, South Australia

Focus groups and interviews with:

- grandparents

- grandchildren

- policy-makers and service providers

A major focus on Indigenous grandparents

Links with Canadian researchers

Identifying grandparents providing primary careIdentifying grandparents providing primary care

ABS statistics

- 22,500 grandparent-headed families caring for 31,000 children (ABS 2003)

- Limitations of statistical data Formation of grandparent headed families

- Increase in out-of-home placements in all States

- Decisions of Family Court and Federal Magistrates Court

- Informal arrangements Grandparent care in Indigenous families

- Children 6 times more likely to be in care

- Indigenous Child Placement Principle

Grandparent Primary CarersGrandparent Primary Carers

almost 40% under 55 years two-thirds rely on govt benefit or pension 47% sole grandparents (93% grandmothers) complex family circumstances:

- 1 in 10 care for more than 3 children

- importance of dyadic relationship (grandparent and grandchild)

- and, perhaps, triadic relationship(parents)

Impacts of caringImpacts of caring

Many positives!Many positives!

- love, relief, joy, assistance from love, relief, joy, assistance from childrenchildren

But, profound pressures and strains But, profound pressures and strains includingincluding

- Financial and legal issuesFinancial and legal issues

- Social, health and well-beingSocial, health and well-being

- Lack of information/misinformationLack of information/misinformation

- GriefGrief

Quote

“ The two children are in my care until they are 18. You might as well say I’ve had the eldest all barring a year of his life, but the year he was with them left a lot of scarring, what his dad did to him, what he did to her. It took a lot of hard work from the pre-school. He’s getting there. The other little one I’ve always had problems with. I couldn’t quite put a word on it but there was always something not quite right…his behaviour is becoming worse so I just recently had him assessed and he is autistic. They can’t tell me if it was because mum was on drugs or if dad did that…”

Financial and legal issuesFinancial and legal issues

Economic pressures (costs of child care, schooling, housing, medical)

Curtailment of employment/retirement plans

Financial support varies across jurisdictions and depending on circumstances

Lack of parity with foster carers Uneasy position on boundary between public and private spheres

“Well you worry about your furniture. You work all your life to get it and there is a young child who is frustrated and to get attention pulls the chair over which would have cost $150, $200”

Social, Social, health and wellbeing issueshealth and wellbeing issues

Social isolation Limited opportunities for respite Reduced physical, emotional and psychological well-being

Increased anxiety about ill-health, disability and death

“Our main fear is that we would die and then what would happen to the children…we could go another 10 years without any health problems but who knows what is around the corner”

Quotes

“Sometimes I look at other grandparents and I think all they’ve got to do is play bowls. They can sleep in”

“The sad thing about being a carer for your grandchild is that you cannot be a proper grandmother, because I am the carer”

Quote

“Doing it on my own is the hardest thing. I raised three children with a husband and that has its problems but nothing like this. You’ve got no respite. When you’ve got a kid that cries, and she doesn’t do it now, but for the first three years she had night terrors every night and you are trying to work and you are getting no sleep. It is like a new-born…well she was like that but with night terrors and you couldn’t get near her and you can’t help her. In the end you just get cranky and you think that’s not helping either but you are cranky because you are tired not cranky because you are angry at the child”

THE LAST WORD FROM A GRANDPARENTTHE LAST WORD FROM A GRANDPARENT

It ties you down a lot but when you think back what it could have been if we hadn't taken them and you just think well they might not be here now ... It gives your life love ... I said to him this morning "You're 14 next year mate, you've only got another two years to live with us." He said, "Oh no I'm not leaving here". That just makes you feel good.

Excerpt from Mission Australia (2007) Grandparents raising their grandchildren)