ftpcontent3.worldnow.comftpcontent3.worldnow.com/waga/documents/Complaint.pdfPadget, Graham & Laney,...
Transcript of ftpcontent3.worldnow.comftpcontent3.worldnow.com/waga/documents/Complaint.pdfPadget, Graham & Laney,...
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF HORRY COUNTYSTATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA
TYRELL and NIKKI NELSON, individuallyand as parents and natural guardians ofJORDAN NELSON, a minor,
Plaintiffs,
v.
CAMBRIDGE ELEVATING,INC.;SEASIDE ELEVATORS, LLC; COASTALCAROLINA ELEVATORS, LLC;KENNETH MAHON and DUNES REALTY,INC.,
Defendants.
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
~.-("1'7r---;r..~.~~-::.~
°C~....... :;-.
'2.~C.
CIVIL ACTION ~~FILE NO. ~
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
-:- {1\Q .,c t .;-,-,.,
-'-
COMPLAINT
The Plaintiffs Tyrell Nelson and Nikki Nelson, individually and as parents and natural
guardians of Jordan Nelson, a minor, complaining of the Defendants herein allege as follows:
PARTIES
I.
Plaintiffs Tyrell Nelson and Nikki Nelson are residents and citizens of the State of
Maryland and are the parents and natural guardians of Jordan Nelson, a minor.
2.
This action involves catastrophic injuries sustained by Plaintiffs' minor child, Jordan
Nelson, when he became entrapped and crushed while using an elevator located at 1311 North
Dogwood Drive, Murrells Inlet, Harry County, South Carolina 29576. That elevator will be
referred to herein as "the subject elevator" and the home located at 1311 North Dogwood Drive
will be referred to herein as "the subject home."
3.
Defendant Cambridge Elevating, Inc. was and is at all times hereinafter mentioned a
Canadian corporation with its principal place of business located at 1261 Industrial Road,
Cambridge, Ontario, Canada N3H 4W3. Defendant Cambridge Elevating, Inc. has agreed to
accept service of this Complaint and process through its attorney, J. Kenneth Carter, Turner,
Padget, Graham & Laney, PA, P.O. Box 1473, Columbia, SC 29202. For brevity, Cambridge
Elevating, Inc. will be referred to hereinafter as "Defendant Cambridge."
4.
At all times hereinafter mentioned, Defendant Cambridge has (a) transacted business in
the State of South Carolina; (b) contracted to supply services or things in the State of South
Carolina; (c) committed tortious acts, in whole or in part, in the State of South Carolina; (d)
caused tortious injury in the State of South Carolina by an act or omission outside this State,
while regularly conducting and/or soliciting business and/or engaging in other persistent course
of conduct and/or deriving substantial revenue from goods used or consumed or services
rendered, in the State of South Carolina; (e) entered into a contract to be performed, in whole or
in part, be either party in the State of South Carolina; and/or (f) produced, manufactured anellor
distributed goods with the reasonable expectation that those goods would be used or consumed in
the State of South Carolina, which goods were, in fact, used or consumed in the State of South
Carolina.
5.
The claims and causes of action asserted herein against Defendant Cambridge arise from
the acts set forth in the preceding paragraph.
2
6.
Personal jurisdiction against Defendant Cambridge is proper pursuant to South Carolina's
Long-Arm Statute, S.C. Code Ann. § 36-2-803.
7.
Defendant Seaside Elevators, LLC is a South Carolina corporation with its principal
place of business located at 1044 Redi Mix Road, Little River, Horry County, South Carolina
29566. Defendant Seaside Elevators, LLC may be served through its registered agent for service
ofprocess, Larry R. Tyler, 11354 N. Highway 905, Longs, Horry County, South Carolina 29568.
8.
On information and belief, Defendant Seaside Elevators, LLC installed, inspected and/or
approved of the installation of the subject elevator in the subject home.
9.
On information and belief, Defendant Seaside Elevators, LLC serviced and repaired the
subject elevator after its installation and before Jordan Nelson was injured.
10.
Defendant Coastal Carolina Elevators, LLC is a South Carolina corporation with its
principal place of business located at 1044 Redi Mix Road, Little River, Horry County, South
Carolina 29566. Defendant Coastal Carolina Elevators, LLC may be served through its
registered agent for service of process, Larry R. Tyler, 11354 N. Highway 905, Longs, Horry
County, South Carolina 29568.
11.
Defendants Coastal Carolina Elevators, LLC serviced and repaired the subject elevator
after its installation and before Jordan Nelson was injured.
3
12.
On infonnation and belief, Defendant Coastal Carolina Elevators, LLC (a) is a successor
of Seaside Elevators, LLC; (b) has acquired the assets andlor liabilities of Seaside Elevators,
LLC; (c) has merged with Seaside Elevators, LLC; (d) has assumed the liabilities of Seaside
Elevators, LL<:;:; andlor (e) has engaged in a joint venture with Seaside Elevators, LLC.
13.
Defendant Kenneth Mahon is a resident and citizen of the State of Virginia. Defendant
Mahon may be served at his residence, 1020 N Highland Street, Suite 1119, Arlington County,
Arlington, Virginia 22201.
14.
Defendant Mahon owned the subject home on and before November 26,2013.
15.
At all times hereinafter mentioned, Defendant Mahon has (a) transacted business in the
State of South Carolina; (b) contracted to supply service or things in the State of South Carolina;
(c) committed tortious acts, in whole or in part, in the State of South Carolina; (d) caused tortious
injury in the State of South Carolina by an act or omission outside this State, while regularly
conducting andlor soliciting business andlor engaging in other persistent course of conduct
andlor deriving substantial revenue from goods used or consumed or services rendered, in the
State of South Carolina; (e) had an interest in, using andlor possession of real property in the
State of South Carolina; andlor (f) entered into a contract to be perfonned, in whole or in party,
be either party in the State of South Carolina.
4
16.
The claims and causes of action asserted herein against Defendant Mahon arise from the
acts set forth in the preceding paragraph.
17.
Personal jurisdiction against Defendant Mahon is proper pursuant to South Carolina's
Long-Ann Statute, S.C. Code Ann. § 36-2-803.
18.
Defendant Dunes Realty, Inc. is a South Carolina corporation with its principal place of
business located at 128 Atlantic Avenue, Garden City Beach, Horry Countyt South Carolina
29576. Defendant Dunes Realty, Inc. may be served through its registered agent for service of
process, J.R. Swain, 128 Atlantic Avenue, Garden City Beach, Horry County, South Carolina
29576. Defendant Dunes Realty, Inc. has agreed to accept service of this Complaint and process
through its attorney, Dominic Starr, McAngus, Goudelock & Courie, 2411 North Oak Street,
Suite 401, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577. For brevityt Defendant Dunes Realty, Inc. will be referred
to hereinafter as "Defendant Dunes."
19.
Defendants Dunes is a property management and rental company that entered into a
contract with Defendant Mahon for the management and rental of the subject home, which
agreement was in force and effect on and before November 26,2013.
20.
This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action.
21.
This Court has jurisdiction over the over the parties named herein.
5
22.
Venue is proper in this Court because one or more defendants reside in this County. the
cause of action arose in this County and one or more of Defendants' acts or omissions occurred in
this County.
23.
This action is not removable to federal court because (a) Plaintiffs do not assert any
federal claim or cause of action 0. e., federal question jurisdiction does not exist); and (b) one or
more defendants are citizens of the forum State of South Carolina and thus removal based on
diversity of citizenship is improper under 28 U.S.C. §§1441(b).
FACTS
24.
Plaintiffs and other members of the Nelson family rented the subject home for
Thanksgiving break from November 23 through November 30, 2013.
25.
The subject home is a multi-family structure with two floors of living space. which are
not connected by any interior staircase. The living spaces in the subject home are located on the
second and third stories and can be accessed by separate. exterior staircases. The subject home
also has a residential elevator that services all three stories.
26.
On November 26,2013, Jordan Nelson, then ten (10) years old. was on the second story
of the subject home. Jordan entered the subject elevator from the second story of the subject
home in order to access the third story. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants' acts and
omissions as described herein, Jordan Nelson became trapped in the subject elevator, pinning
6
and crushing him. Jordan was deprived of oxygen and lost his pulse until emergency personnel
extricated him. Jordan's brain and heart were deprived of oxygen for an extended period oftime,
resulting in permanent and catastrophic injuries, including profound brain damage.
27.
As a direct and proximate cause of Defendants' acts and omissions, Jordan Nelson
sustained serious and permanent physical, cognitive and emotional injuries, and has suffered and
will continue to suffer the loss of enjoyment of life at all times in the future. In addition,
Plaintiffs have incurred and will continue to incur medical expenses to treat Jordan's injuries for
the remainder of his life. Upon information and belief, Jordan Nelson will also incur lost wages
and/or significant impainnent of his ability to earn any wages and income in the future.
28.
As a direct and proximate cause of defendants' wrongful acts and omissions, as set forth
herein, Jordan Nelson has required and will continue to require extensive medical care and
treatment for the remainder of his life, as well as other expenses to accommodate and treat his
conditions.
FOR A FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION(DEFENDANT CAMBRIDGE ELEVATING, INC.)
29.
Plaintiffs allege all facts and allegations above as if fully set forth verbatim herein.
30.
Defendant Cambridge designed, manufactured, marketed, labeled, sold, distributed and
placed into the stream ofcommerce the subject elevator.
7
31.
Plaintiffs will show that Defendant Cambridge was negligent in one or more of the
following particulars:
a. In designingt manufacturingt marketing, labelingt selling and distributing the
subject elevator in a defective condition;
b. In designing, manufacturing, marketingt labeling, selling and distributing the
subject elevator without sufficient warnings to advise individuals coming m
contact with the equipmentt particularly the Plaintiffs herein, of its dangers;
c. In failing to adequately test and inspect the product prior to placing it into the
stream ofcommerce;
d. In failing to provide adequate instructions and supervision for the installation and
manufacture of the product to all foreseeable uses; and
e. In failing to include a light curtain in its design and manufacture of the subject
elevator.
32.
That these acts of negligence, combining and concurring with one another and with the
acts and omissions of the other Defendants named herein, were the direct and proximate cause of
the injuries and damages sustained by the Plaintiffs herein.
FOR A SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION(DEFENDANT CAMBRIDGE ELEVATING, INC.)
33.
Plaintiffs allege all facts and allegations above as if fully set forth verbatim herein.
8
34.
That at all times material herein, Defendant Cambridge was engaged in the practice of
designing, manufacturing, marketing, labeling, selling and distributing the subject elevator and
that the product did reach the consuming public without any substantial change in the conditions
from which it was sold; that the subject elevator was in a defective condition and was
unreasonably dangerous to the user or those reasonably expected to come in contact with the
product; and that these defective conditions caused Jordan Nelson's personal injuries set forth
hereinabove as well as the damages recited in this action; that the Plaintiffs are, therefore,
informed and believe Defendant Cambridge is strictly liable to them for their injuries and
damages as prescribed pursuant to §15-73-1 0, et seq, of the South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976.
FOR A THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION(DEFENDANTS COASTAL CAROLINA ELEVATORS, LLC &
SEASIDE ELEVATORS, LLC)
35.
Plaintiffs allege all facts and allegations above as if fully set forth verbatim herein.
36.
Plaintiffs will show that Defendant Seaside Elevators, LLC, its agents and employees,
were negligent in one or more of the following particulars:
a. In failing to exercise due care and skill in the installation, inspection and approval
of the subject elevator; and
b. In failing to exercise due care and skill to ensure that all work was performed in a
workmanlike manner and in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations,
including applicable provision of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers
(ASME) Safety Code for Elevators and Escalators.
9
37.
Plaintiffs will show that Defendant Seaside Elevators, LLC and Coastal Carolina
Elevators, LLC, their agents and employees, were negligent in one or more of the following
particulars:
a. In failing to exercise due care and skill in the service and repair of the subject
elevator;
b. In failing to identify and correct dangerous conditions in the subject elevator;
c. In failing to alert others, including Defendants Dunes and/or Mahon, about
defects and dangerous conditions in the subject elevator; and
d. In failing to remove the subject elevator from service because of its defects and
dangerous conditions.
38.
That the acts and omissions of Defendants Seaside Elevators, LLC and Coastal Carolina
Elevators, LLC, their agents and employees, constitute negligence per se.
39.
That these acts of negligence, combining and concurring with one .another and with the
acts and omissions of the other Defendants named herein, were the direct and proximate cause of
the injuries and damages sustained by the Plaintiffs herein.
10
FOR A FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION(DEFENDANTS KENNETH MAHON & DUNES REALTV, INC.)
40.
Plaintiffs allege all facts and allegations above as if fully set forth verbatim herein.
41.
Plaintiffs will show that Defendants Mahon and Dunes, their agents and employees, were
negligent in one or more of the following particulars:
a. In failing to ensure that the subject home was safe and free from hidden defects,
including the subject elevator;
b. In failing to conduct necessary inspections, service and repairs of the subject
elevator to ensure it was in proper working order and was safe; and
c. In failing to warn Plaintiffs of latent or hidden dangers on the property of which
they knew or should have known.
42.
That these acts of negligence, combining and concurring with one another and with the
acts and omissions of the other Defendants named herein, were the direct and proximate cause of
the injuries and damages sustained by the Plaintiffs herein.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiffs pray for judgment against the Defendants as follows:
A. For such actual damages as the Court may deem just and proper on the Plaintiffs'
First Cause of Action;
B. For such actual damages as the Court may deem just and proper on the Plaintiffs'
Second Cause of Action;
C. For such actual damages as the Court may deem just and proper on the Plaintiffs'
Third Cause of Action;
11
, .•
D. For such actual damages as the Court may deem just and proper on the Plaintiffs'
Fourth Cause of Action;
E. For costs and disbursements in this action; and
F. For such other and further relief as this Court may deem just and proper; and
G. That Plaintiffs have a trial by jury on all issues and claims set forth herein.
HEARN & HEARN, PA
Conway, South Carolina
Dated: 1I-.2(!0/
12