Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training...

50
Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center Office: 817-735-5473 Email: [email protected]

Transcript of Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training...

Page 1: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Overview of NamUs:The Databases, Personnel and

Forensic Resources

B.J. SpamerDirector, Training and Analysis Division

NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center

Office: 817-735-5473

Email: [email protected]

Page 2: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

The Missing and Unidentified Problem

• On any given day in the United States,

there are between 80,000 to 100,000

active missing person cases entered

into NCIC.

• Almost half of these cases have a date

of last contact over one year ago –

“cold cases”.

Page 3: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) Study

• For many years, the true extent of the

unidentified decedent problem was unknown.

• In June 2007, the Bureau of Justice Statistics

issued a report indicating that medical

examiners, coroners and law enforcement

agencies across the country held the remains of

13,486 unidentified decedents as of 2004.

1 Medical Examiner and Coroners’ Offices, 2004: Hickman, Hughes, Strom and Rupero-Miller. http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/meco04.pdf

Page 4: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

A Much Larger Problem

Taking into account that many agencies retained no records on unidentified decedents, and that remains of many other decedents had been cremated or buried, some experts estimated the actual number of unidentified decedent cases across the country to be closer to 40,000.

Page 5: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Silent Mass Disaster Over Time

One thing is clear. Regardless what the true number of unidentified human decedents is in the United States, the missing and unidentified problem is

truly our nation’s“Silent Mass Disaster”

Page 6: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

www.NamUs.gov

Page 7: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

The UNT Center for Human Identification

3400 Camp Bowie Boulevard

Fort Worth, TX 76107

3 Divisions:

• Laboratory of Forensic Anthropology

• Laboratory for Molecular Identification

• Forensic Services Unit / NamUs

Focus:

• Missing and unidentified persons

• Forensic casework for Texas agencies

Page 8: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

NCIC Entries as of May 1, 2012

Missing Persons (MP)

Active Colorado MP Cases: 1,052

Active Cases Nationwide: 85,184

Unidentified Persons (UP)

Active Colorado UP Cases: 41

Active Cases Nationwide: 7,746

Page 9: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

NamUs Entries as of May 31, 2012

Missing Persons (MP)

Active Colorado MP Cases: 132

Active Cases Nationwide: 7,495

Unidentified Persons (UP)

Active Colorado UP Cases: 34

Active Cases Nationwide: 8,462

Page 10: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

www.NamUs.gov

Page 11: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

www.FindTheMissing.org

Page 12: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

www.FindTheMissing.org

Page 13: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.
Page 14: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

www.IdentifyUs.org

Page 15: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.
Page 16: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

www.ClaimUs.org

Page 17: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.
Page 18: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Regional System Administrators

Region 8:

Jerry Brown817-240-9365

[email protected]

Page 19: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

• Forensic Odontologists on staff

• Fingerprint Examiner on staff

• DNA analyses through the UNT Center for Human Identification’s Laboratory for Molecular Identification

• Coordination with local, state and federal DNA laboratories across the country to affect comparisons

• Forensic Anthropology through the UNT Center for Human Identification’s Laboratory of Forensic Anthropology

Forensic Services AvailableThrough NamUs

19

Page 20: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

• Locating/acquiring dental records

• Coding dentals for NCIC and NamUs entry

• Performing dental comparisons between missing and unidentified persons

Forensic Odontology

Page 21: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

NCIC and NamUs Dental Coding

Page 22: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Forensic Odontology

Dr. John Filippi817-666-5424

[email protected]

Page 23: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Forensic Odontology

Dr. Rich Scanlon817-487-9645

[email protected]

Page 24: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

• Locating/acquiring fingerprint records

• Coding prints for NCIC and NamUs entry

• Facilitating fingerprint database searches

• Performing fingerprint comparisons

Fingerprint Examination

Page 25: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

• It is not sufficient to have your unidentified remains prints run only through your local or state fingerprint databases.

• Prints should also be run through two federal agencies:

1. Federal Bureau of Investigation - Criminal Justice Information Services - Special Processing Center (FBI-CJIS-SPC)

2. Department of Homeland Security US-VISIT Biometric Support Center (DHS-BSC)

Fingerprint Databases

Page 26: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

• The Federal Bureau of Investigation Criminal Justice Information Center’s Special Processing Center (FBI-CJIS-SPC) “contains approximately 66 million criminal fingerprint records that can be searched electronically in its Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS) and approximately 30 million civil and military fingerprints records that can be searched manually”.

• For more information on the CJIS-SPC, visit: http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis

Source: Mulawka, M. and Craig, J. “The Efficacy of Submitting Fingerprints of Unidentified Remains to Federal Agencies”. Journal of Forensic Identification, 92/61 (1), 2011.

FBI CJIS Special Processing Center

Page 27: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Some Sources of BSC’s 100 Million+ Fingerprints:• Known or Suspected Terrorists• Department of Defense Military

Operations• Wanted Persons• Deported felons• International Criminals• Sex Offenders• Aliens/Criminal History• State/Local Criminals• Gangs• Expedited Removals• Visa Denials• Recidivists/Alerts

• US Entries• Visa Applications• Border Crossing Card

Applications• Individuals Granted Asylum• Refugees• Border Patrol Entry/Exit

Approximately 70% of the BSC fingerprints are not replicated in any other local, state or federal fingerprint database.

US-VISIT Database

Page 28: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

NamUs Fingerprint Specialist

William “Bill” Bailey

817-456-0331

[email protected]

Page 29: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Forensic Anthropology

Page 30: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

DNA Profiles Used in MP and UP Cases

Three types of profiles used in missing and unidentified person investigations:

– STR Profiles

• Short Tandem Repeats

• Also commonly referred to as “Nuclear” DNA profiles

– Y-STR Profiles

• Y-Chromosome Short Tandem Repeats

– Mitochondrial (mtDNA) Profiles

Page 31: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Free Online DNA/CODIS Training

www.untfsu.com/onlinetraining.html

Page 32: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Short Tandem Repeat (STR) Profiles

STR profiles (also called NUCLEAR DNA PROFILES) are passed down to a child by both the mother and father – 50% from each parent.

Mother Father

Daughter Son

Page 33: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Short Tandem Repeat (STR) Profiles

Mother Father

Daughter Son

STR profiles (also called NUCLEAR DNA PROFILES) are passed down to a child by both the mother and father – 50% from each parent.

Page 34: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Short Tandem Repeat (STR) Profiles

Mother Father

Daughter Son

STR profiles (also called NUCLEAR DNA PROFILES) are passed down to a child by both the mother and father – 50% from each parent.

Page 35: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Y-Chromosome (Y-STR) Profiles

Y-STR profiles are passed only to a MALE child and only by the FATHER.

Mother Father

Daughter Son

Page 36: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Y-Chromosome (Y-STR) Profiles

All males sharing the same paternal lineage will share the same Y-STR profile.

MissingPerson

Page 37: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)

mtDNA profiles are passed to MALE and FEMALE children, but only from the MOTHER.

Mother Father

Daughter Son

Page 38: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Mitochondrial (mtDNA) Profiles

All females sharing the same maternal lineage will share the same mtDNA profile.

MissingPerson

Page 39: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

From Whom To Collect DNA Samples

You must collect AT LEAST TWO family reference samples for proper CODIS searching to take place:

• Mother• Father• Offspring of Missing Person

– Collect second parent to exclude their STR profile

• Full Sibling • Half Sibling• Consider grandparents, aunts, uncles, etc. for Y-

STRs and mtDNA profiles if closer blood relatives are not available

Page 40: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

New Jersey State Police Lab

MN Bureau of Criminal Apprehension

California Dept of Justice

UNT Center for Human ID

FBI

Arizona Dept. of Public Safety

New York Office of the Chief ME

Virginia Dept. of Forensic Sciences

CODIS Mito Laboratories

Page 41: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Family Reference Collection Kits

Collection kits contain:

Chain of custody form Consent form Relationship of DNA donor Fax-Back form Latex gloves Buccal swab collectors Postage-paid return envelope

These materials ensure proper documentation, collection, and chain of custody on each collected sample

Page 42: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Family Reference Submission Paperwork

Page 43: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Family Reference Collection KitsKits can be ordered through the NamUs DNA screen or from:

[email protected]

1-800-763-3147

Page 44: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

The NamUs DNA Screen

Page 45: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Forensic ArtForensic Art is another investigative tool that can assist with both missing and unidentified person cases:

• Facial reconstructions draw more public attention to an unidentified remains case.

Page 46: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

Project EDAN

Page 47: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

NamUs Analytical Services

• Searches for missing persons

• Locating next of kin for death notifications

• Locating additional family members for DNA collections

Page 48: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

ViCAP• An analyst from the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s

Violent Criminal Apprehension Program (ViCAP) serves as a full-time liaison between ViCAP and NamUs to:

• Review missing and unidentified person cases marked “foul play suspected” for possible referral to ViCAP for more in-depth analysis

• Cross-pollinate missing and unidentified person cases

• Coordinate additional ViCAP resources

Page 49: Overview of NamUs: The Databases, Personnel and Forensic Resources B.J. Spamer Director, Training and Analysis Division NamUs @ UNT Health Science Center.

NamUs Analysts

Missing Person Searches:

Dustin Driscoll

817-240-4106

[email protected]

ViCAP Analysis:

Sue Stiltner

817-487-9970

[email protected]