Order on Prenda appeal
Transcript of Order on Prenda appeal
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
1/24
"# $%&
'#($&) *$+$&, -./0$ .1 233&+4,5.0 $%& *&6$% -(07/($
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"#$%&''()&*+,&-&.(/
01234567789781:;
()
:"43
+*'*%,#%&-.//*""**-0
:@@A*B#C6:D08DEE?>F
.//*""#%&-)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:@@A*B$CG#HIJAD+KIA,5I*IA$8K$IGKLI;#MGIC#GIJA
5#MIJAG+8K$IGKLI#C1BBK+#K$%
"#%
&/
;N
))((O
P
!"
#$%&'()
*+&,-.>
12,3*0
*+,
/$0'1
2"
34&51650
45$*'12,3*%
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:=2D78:6=10Q>/)&-&P87;1878FD0?'&>/)&-
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
& "#%&''()&R*$*GSMA,TAC#GAIJK$@*+AB%"#%&-&.(/R*$$MTHKI
IA,I#IJA$*HA@*+AB@MG$M*+II#1+IAG+*B
RJKLJ K$ $MTHKIIA, #+ IJATGKAC$ K+ *LL#G,*+LA RKIJ EA,% =% :@@% 6%
'-U*VU/VUC).
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
2/24
/ "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
YAC#GAZ*LL#G,K+SI#*+
#B, $*WK+S> K$ I# $I#@ ,KSSK+S% 4JA IR# *@@A*B$TAC#GA M$
TGK+S IJ*I I#HK+,> C#G GA*$#+$ IJ*IRKBBTAL#HA *@@*GA+I%
4JA CKG$I>"#%&''()&>L#HA$ I#M$ CG#H IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI\$
#G,AGSG*+IK+S*H#IK#+ C#G*II#G+AW$\ CAA$*+,L#$I$M+,AG
/(D%5%;%]&O/Q CKBA,TW5Y; 1+IAG+AI5AG^KLA$>00; U,_T_*
:4X4V>;#HL*$I;*TBA;#HHM+KL*IK#+$> 00; UL#BBALIK^ABW
`IJA156$aV>*+,:+IJ#+W5HKIJ>,ACA+,*+I$K+IJAM+,AGBW
K+S
BKIKS*IK#+%
4JA
#G,AG
KH@#$A,
b#K+I
*+,
$A^AG*B
BK*TKBKIW
C#G IJA CAA$*S*K+$I6*MB8MCCW>F#J+5IAABA>*+,6*MB3*+$
HAKAG% 4JAWJ*^A *@@A*BA, CG#H IJ*I #G,AG%4JAW,K, +#I>
J#RA^AG>CKBA*H#IK#+AKIJAGI#LB*GKCWIJA+*IMGA#CIJA$*+L
IK#+$#G I#$I*W IJA#G,AG% 1+$IA*,> IJAW$KH@BW,K,+#I@*W%
4JA,ACA+,*+I$IJA+H#^A,C#G*+#G,AGI#$J#RL*M$ARJW
*@@ABB*+I$$J#MB,+#ITAJAB,K+L#+IAH@IC#GIJAKGC*KBMGAI#
@*W> #G K+ IJA *BIAG+*IK^A C#G KHHA,K*IA L#+IAH@I%:CIAG *
JA*GK+S>IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIC#M+,IJ*IIJAWJ*,C*KBA,I#@*W
*+,IJ*IIJAGAR*$+#AcLM$AC#GIJAKGTAJ*^K#G%1IIJM$JAB,
IJAHK+LK^KBL#+IAH@I*+,#G,AGA,IJAHI#@*W&)d#CIJA#GKSK+*B$*+LIK#+$*R*G,I#L#^AGIJA,ACA+,*+I$\*,,KIK#+*B
L#$I$C#GIJAL#+IAH@IBKIKS*IK#+%1I*B$#*$$A$$A,*,*KBWCK+A>
K+ L*$A @*WHA+IR*$ +#I C#GIJL#HK+S% 4JA $AL#+, *@@A*B
TAC#GAM$>"#%&-&.(/>K$CG#HIJAL#+IAH@I@G#LAA,K+S%
7
8
0KSJI$@AA, 9A,K* #@AG*IA$ #+BK+A @#G+#SG*@JW $KIA$%
1BBK+#K$> *S*K+$I #+A F#J+ 8#A ,ACA+,*+I> K,A+IKCKA, #+BW
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
3/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ '
IJG#MSJJK$16*,,GA$$%U:+16>#G1+IAG+AI6G#I#L#B>*,,GA$$
K$IJA
+MHTAG
*$$KS+A,
I#
*@*GIKLMB*G
,A^KLA
#+
IJA
1+IAG
+AI%V8#A\$16*,,GA$$R*$*BBASA,BW*$$#LK*IA,RKIJIJAM+
B*RCMB^KARK+S#C0KSJI$@AA,\$L#+IA+I>H*,A@#$$KTBATWIJA
M$A#C*RK,ABW$J*GA,>`J*LeA,a@*$$R#G,%0KSJI$@AA,IJA+
K,A+IKCKA, *@@G#cKH*IABW .>.))#IJAG$ UIJG#MSJ IJAKG 16 *,
,GA$$A$#+BWV*$*BBASA,`L#L#+$@KG*I#G$aK+*RK,AGA*LJK+S
$LJAHAI#$IA*B@*$$R#G,$*+,L#+IA+I%4JA#+BWL#+$@KG*I#
GK*B*LI*BBASA,R*$IJAM$A#CIJA$*HA@*$$R#G,%4JA+>C#B
B#RK+SRJ*I$AAH$I#TA*@@ABB*+I$\89,2-9/*6#%,$>$AA>*)3)>
.:;9",$%3-0Qf/E%',OO)>OO'U8%;%;KG%
/)&-V>0KSJI$@AA,>*LIK+S *B/#6&*> $AG^A, $MT@#A+*$#+ IJA
156$URJKLJ*IIJ*I@#K+IRAGA+#+@*GIKA$VC#GIJA@AG$#+*B
BW K,A+IKCK*TBA K+C#GH*IK#+ #C A*LJ #C IJA .>.)) *BBASA, L#
L#+$@KG*I#G$>+#+A#CRJ#HJ*,TAA+b#K+A,*$@*GIKA$%4JA
156$GACM$A,I#IMG+#^AGIJAK+C#GH*IK#+*+,K+$IA*,CKBA,*
H#IK#+I#gM*$J*+,C#G*@G#IALIK^A#G,AG%
4JA$I*IA IGK*BL#MGI,A+KA, IJA 156$\H#IK#+>*+,$# IJA
156$$#MSJI*@@ABB*IAGA^KAR%:IIJA$*HAIKHA>8MCCWL*BBA,
*+ *II#G+AW GA@GA$A+IK+S IJA 156$ *+, GAgMA$IA, IJA +*HA
*+, IKIBA#CA*LJAH@B#WAARJ#,ALK,A, IJ*I*+ 156R#MB,+#I L#H@BWRKIJ IJA $MT@#A+*$% 5IAABA IJA+ $MTHKIIA, *+
*CCK,*^KI$I*IK+SIJ*IIJA156*II#G+AWGACM$A,I#@G#^K,AIJ*I
K+C#GH*IK#+% 4JA 1BBK+#K$ 5M@GAHA ;#MGI MBIKH*IABW GMBA,
IJ*IIJAIGK*BL#MGIAGGA,TWGACM$K+SI#gM*$JIJA$MT@#A+*$%
0KSJI$@AA,GA$@#+,A,TW*HA+,K+SKI$L#H@B*K+I#+:MSM$I
'> /)&/> *+, C#GH*BBW+*HK+S *$ L#L#+$@KG*I#G@*GIKA$ IJA
156$ *+, M+K,A+IKCKA, `L#G@#G*IA GA@GA$A+I*IK^A$a #C IJA
156$%4JA L#H@B*K+I@*K+IA,RKIJ*TG#*,TGM$Jh KI*BBASA,
A^AGWIJK+SCG#H
+ASBKSA+LA>
I#
^K#B*IK#+$
#C
IJA
;#H@MIAG
EG*M,*+,:TM$A:LI>&(D%5%;%]]&)')*+,&)')USV> I#,A
LA@IK^A@G*LIKLA$*+,*K,K+S*+,*TAIIK+S%`F#J+8#A>aK+IJA
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
4/24
- "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
*HA+,A,L#H@B*K+I>TAL*HA:+IJ#+W5HKIJ%4JA+>KS+#GK+S
IJAC*LI
IJ*I
IJA
1BBK+#K$
5M@GAHA
;#MGI
J*,
bM$I
GAbALIA,
KI$
GAgMA$I C#G IJA $*HA K+C#GH*IK#+> 0KSJI$@AA, K$$MA, +AR
$MT@#A+*$$AAeK+SIJA@AG$#+*BBWK,A+IKCK*TBAK+C#GH*IK#+#C
5HKIJ\$@MG@#GIA,.>.))L#L#+$@KG*I#G$%
/)&/>IJA156$GAH#^A,IJAL*$AI#IJA8K$
IGKLI;#MGIC#GIJA5#MIJAG+8K$IGKLI#C1BBK+#K$%5AA/(D%5%;%
] &--.UTVU'V% 0KSJI$@AA, KHHA,K*IABW CKBA, *+ AHAGSA+LW
H#IK#+ K+*,^*+LA#C IJAG#MIK+A=MBA/.UCVL#+CAGA+LA>$AA
E78%=%;1N%6%/.UCV>*$eK+SIJACA,AG*BL#MGII##G,AGIJA156$
I#
@G#,MLA
IJA
$*HA
`L#
L#+$@KG*I#G$\a
@AG$#+*BBW
K,A+IKCK*
TBA K+C#GH*IK#+%:I IJA $*HA IKHA>3*+$HAKAG $MTHKIIA, *
H#IK#+C#G/695#7($7**,HK$$K#+iJA,K,+#I K,A+IKCW* B*R
CKGH#+IJAC#GH%5IAABAA+IAGA,*+*@@A*G*+LAK+RJKLJJA
BK$IA,JK$CKGH*$6GA+,*0*R%4JACKGH*CCKBK*IK#+$>J#RA^AG>
IMG+A,#MI I#TA@G#^K$K#+*B> I#@MI KIeK+,BW%:I IJAAHAG
SA+LW H#IK#+ JA*GK+S> 5IAABA K,A+IKCKA, JK$ CKGH *$ 5IAABA
3*+$HAKAG600;>8MCCW$*K,IJ*IJAR*$RKIJ6GA+,*0*R>
*+,3*+$HAKAGR*$RKIJ$#HAIJK+SL*BBA,:B@J*0*REKGH%
5IAABA3*+$HAKAG *+, 6GA+,* *GA BK$IA, *I IJA $*HA $IGAAI
*,,GA$$> &.& "#GIJ ;B*Ge 5IGAAI> K+ ;JKL*S#> K+ ,KCCAGA+I$MKIA$%
:,,GA$$K+SIJA,K$L#^AGWH#IK#+*IIJAAHAGSA+LWJA*G
K+S> 5IAABA $@#eA *I BA+SIJ *T#MI IJA,KGA +AA, C#G IJA GA
gMA$IA,K+C#GH*IK#+%D+L#+^K+LA,>IJA,K$IGKLIbM,SA,A+KA,
IJAH#IK#+> $I*IK+S K+@*$$K+S IJ*IJAR*$`$eA@IKL*B*T#MI
J#RIJK$L*$AL#MB,A^AGTA@MI#+>TMIHWCAAI*GA+#I$AIK+
$I#+A#+ KI% 1\^A$AA+$#HAL*$A$ IJ*I,K,+\I B##e I##J#I*I
IJA$I*GIIJ*IS#ITAIIAGRKIJIKHA%4JK$H*WTA#+A#CIJ#$A
L*$A$%a8ACA+,*+I$IJA+$MTHKIIA,T#IJ*H#IK#+I#,K$HK$$*+,*H#IK#+I#$I*W,K$L#^AGW@A+,K+S*GMBK+S#+IJAC#G
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
5/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ f
HAGH#IK#+%1+"#^AHTAG/)&/>3*+$HAKAG$MTHKIIA,*H#
IK#+I#
RKIJ,G*R
RKIJ#MI
K+,KL*IK+S
RJKLJ
CKGH
JA
R*$
RKIJi
K+9*GLJ/)&'>5IAABARKIJ,GAR%
4JK$R*$+#IIJA#+BWL*$A8MCCW>5IAABA>*+,3*+$HAKAG
J*,*IIJAIKHA%ZJKBAIJAH#IK#+I#,K$HK$$R*$@A+,K+SK+
IJA5#MIJAG+8K$IGKLI#C 1BBK+#K$>* L#MGI K+ IJA;A+IG*B8K$
IGKLI#C;*BKC#G+K*JAB,*JA*GK+S C#GIJAAc@GA$$@MG@#$A#C
Ac@B#GK+SIJAG#BAIJK$IGK#>#@AG*IK+S#CIA+*$`6GA+,*0*R>a
@B*WA,K+$#HAM+,AGBWK+SL#@WGKSJIK+CGK+SAHA+IBKIKS*IK#+%
4J*IJA*GK+S,K,+#IS#RABB C#G IJAHi $*+LIK#+$RAGA KH
@#$A,
#+
*BB
IJGAA
U*H#+S
#IJAG$V
*+,
IJA
H*IIAG
GACAGGA,
I#
* ^*GKAIW #C $I*IA *+, CA,AG*B *MIJ#GKIKA$% 5AA C%3*%2$&D =E
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
6/24
. "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
IAA+,*W$*CIAGIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGISG*+IA,0KSJI$@AA,\$H#IK#+
C#G^#BM+I*GW
,K$HK$$*B>
,ACA+,*+I
5HKIJ
CKBA,
*H#IK#+
C#G
*II#G+AW\$ CAA$M+,AGEA,%=%;K %6% f-U,VU/V *+, /(D%5%;%
]&O/Q%8MCCWCKBA,*GA$@#+$Ai5IAABA*+,3*+$HAKAG,K,+#I%
1+IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGISG*+IA,5HKIJCAA$*+,L#$I$
@MG$M*+II#$ALIK#+&O/Q%4JA#G,AGG*+b#K+IBW*+,$A^AG*BBW
*S*K+$IA*LJ*@@ABB*+I%4*eK+S K+I#*LL#M+IT#IJ IJAGAL#G,
K+ IJA L*$ATAC#GA KI *+, IJA GMBK+S$ K+ #IJAG ,K$IGKLI$> IJA
L#MGI C#M+, IJ*I IJA BKIKS*IK#+ *S*K+$I 5HKIJ `$H*LeA, #C
TMBBWK+S@GAIA+$A%a4JAL#MGI$*K,IJ*IKI$,ALK$K#+I#KH@#$A
$*+LIK#+$
R*$
@*GIKLMB*GBW
K+C#GHA,
TW
IJA
AHAGSA+LW
H#
IK#+C#G,K$L#^AGW%4JA+AcI,*W>3*+$HAKAGCKBA,*H#IK#+I#
^*L*IA#GGAL#+$K,AG>*+,* CAR,*W$ B*IAG5IAABA*+,8MCCW
,K,IJA$*HA%3*+$HAKAG*+,5IAABA*BBASA,IJ*IRJKBA8MCCW
GALAK^A,+#IKLA IJ*I $*+LIK#+$RAGATAK+S $#MSJI> IJAW,K,
+#I%
:CIAG IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGISG*+IA, CAA$*+,L#$I$ C#G5HKIJ>
IJA156$CKBA,*H#IK#+GAgMA$IK+SIJA$*HA%3*+$HAKAG*+,
5IAABA#@@#$A, IJAH#IK#+>*+, $# IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIJAB,*
JA*GK+S I#,A*BRKIJT#IJ IJAH#IK#+ I#GAL#+$K,AG IJA CAA$
*R*G,A,5HKIJ*+, IJA+AR 156H#IK#+% J#RA^AG>
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
7/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ Q
,#A$+#I$M@@#GIIJAH%EKG$I>*$IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIL#+LBM,A,>
A^A+KC
RA
*$$MHA
IJ*I
IJAW
,K,
+#I
J*^A
+#IKLA
#GKSK+*BBW>
IJ*I,ACALIR*$LMGA,RJA+IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGISG*+IA,GAJA*G
K+S#+IJA$*+LIK#+$K$$MA%1+,AA,>K+IJAKGTGKAC$TAC#GAIJK$
L#MGI>5IAABA*+,3*+$HAKAG$AAHI#L#+LA,A*$HMLJ%4JAKG
L#H@B*K+I J*$ $JKCIA, I# #+A C#LM$K+S #+ IJA *,AgM*LW #C
IJAKG#@@#GIM+KIWI#6*-/9%,%1IK$I##B*IAI#LJ*+SAIJA#GKA$>
J#RA^AG>*+,K+*+WA^A+I>IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIL#GGALIBWGMBA,
IJ*IRJ*IA^AG@G#LA,MG*BCB*RIJAGAH*WJ*^ATAA+R*$CMB
BW L#GGALIA,TW*CC#G,K+S*+AR#@@#GIM+KIW C#G*JA*GK+S%
EK+*BBW>IJAWGALAK^A,*,AgM*IA+#IKLAK+IJACKG$I@B*LA%
8MA@G#LA$$GAgMKGA$`+#IKLA mGA*$#+*TBWL*BLMB*IA,>M+
,AG*BBIJALKGLMH$I*+LA$>I#*@@GK$AK+IAGA$IA,@*GIKA$#CIJA
@A+,A+LW#C IJA *LIK#+ *+, *CC#G, IJAH *+#@@#GIM+KIW I#
@GA$A+IIJAKG#TbALIK#+$%\aI%$&*,J&*-.$6:2%,-0C%7)()K-
/$%9-#>ffOD%5%/.)>/Q/U/)&)VULKIK+SL2""#%*()4*%&6#";#%
9(*6M#%NOP62-&49)>''OD%5%').>'&-U&Of)VV%:LIM*B+#IKLA
K$+#IGAgMKGA,%C,)ZA*GA+#I I*BeK+SJAGA*T#MI$AG^KLA#C
@G#LA$$>RJKLJ@G#LAA,$M+,AG*H#GAGA$IGKLIK^A$AI#CGMBA$%
5AAE78%=%;1N%6% -% 1+$IA*,> IJAH#IK#+ C#G $*+LIK#+$R*$
#+A $IA@ K+ *+ #+S#K+S@KALA #C BKIKS*IK#+%2K^A+ IJA LB#$AL#++ALIK#+$ *H#+S IJA B*RWAG$> KI R*$ GA*$#+*TBA C#G IJA
L#MGII#L#+LBM,AIJ*I$AG^KLA#+8MCCWR#MB,$MCCKLAI#SK^A
+#IKLA I#5IAABA *+,3*+$HAKAG *$RABB%4JATAJ*^K#G A*LJ
#+A ,K$@B*WA, IJG#MSJ#MI IJK$ BKIKS*IK#+ M+,AG$L#GA, IJAKG
#+S#K+SGAB*IK#+$JK@*+,L#HHM+KL*IK#+hIJAWM$A,#+A*+
#IJAG\$;9_7;EB#SK+K+C#GH*IK#+>CKBA,H#IK#+$#+TAJ*BC#C
A*LJ#IJAG>*+,$MTHKIIA,$MT$I*+IK*BBW$KHKB*G,#LMHA+I$%
1I K$*B$#R#GIJ+#IK+S IJ*IEA,AG*B=MBA#C;K^KB6G#LA
,MGAfUTVU/VUYVUKV@AGHKI$ BA*^K+S+#IKLA*I*@AG$#+\$#CCKLARKIJ*LBAGe#G$#HA#+AK+LJ*GSA>#GA^A+K+*L#+$@KLM#M$
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
8/24
( "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
@B*LA% 8MCCW GALAK^A, +#IKLA> JA R*$ K+ LJ*GSA #C 6GA+,*
0*R>*+,
IJAGA
R*$
A^K,A+LA
IJ*I
T#IJ
5IAABA
*+,
3*+$HAKAG
RAGAR#GeK+SC#G6GA+,**$RABB%ZJKBA*@@ABB*+I$JMCCIJ*I
IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI`RJ#BBWSB#$$jA,k#^AG IJA C*LIIJ*I3*+$
HAKAG +#IKLA, JK$ *@@A*G*+LA K+ IJA L*$A C#G :B@J* 0*R
EKGH>+#I6GA+,*0*R>a IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIJ*,*H@BAGA*$#+
I#CK+,IJA6GA+,*_:B@J*,K$IK+LIK#+KBBM$#GW*ITA$I>CG*M,M
BA+I*IR#G$I%4R#,*W$#'&*65IAABAH#^A,I#RKIJ,G*RCG#H
IJK$L*$A>JA,ALB*GA,K+*+#IJAG*LIK#+IJ*IJAR*$`#CL#M+
$ABRKIJIJAB*RCKGH>6GA+,*0*R>1+L%a*+,IJ*I3*+$HAKAG
R*$`*B$##CL#M+$ABI#IJACKGH%a8ALB*G*IK#+#CF#J+5IAABA>
C%3*%2$&D=E
8MCCW>5IAABA>*+,3*+$HAKAGA*LJI##eIJAEKCIJK+$IA*,
#C *+$RAGK+S IJA L#MGI\$ gMA$IK#+$ *T#MI *II#G+AWHK$L#+
,MLI*+,IJAGAB*IK#+$JK@TAIRAA+6GA+,**+,#IJAG@#IA+
IK*B$JABBL#H@*+KA$%5AAC%3*%2$&D=E`FM,SA$H*$Jh6GA+,*\$@#G+IG#BBK+S,*W$*GA#^AG>a:G$4ALJ+KL*U:@GKB/>/)&'V>*^*KB*TBA
*I JII@h__*G$IALJ+KL*%L#H_IALJ@#BKLW_/)&'_)-_@GA+,*@#G+
IG#BB$LB*HM@*$IJAKG@B*+$LGMHTBAK+*+B*L#MGIG##H_
U*BBRAT$KIA$LKIA,K+IJK$#@K+K#+RAGAB*$I^K$KIA,#+FMBW'&>
/)&-V%4JAEKCIJ:HA+,HA+I>J#RA^AG>`,#A$+#IC#GTK,*,
^AG$A K+CAGA+LA$ *S*K+$I @*GIKA$ I# LK^KB *LIK#+$RJA+ IJAW
GACM$AI#IA$IKCWK+GA$@#+$AI#@G#T*IK^AA^K,A+LA%aM#B&*6()
!#"8$3$#%90-/fD%5%')(>'&(U&OQ.Vi$AA*B$#
'O)
UQIJ
;KG%
&OOfV%
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
9/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ O
: gMKLe B##e *I @MTBKLBW *^*KB*TBA ,#LMHA+I$ $M@@#GI$
IJA,K$IGKLI
L#MGI\$
CK+,K+S
IJ*I
$AG^KLA
#+
8MCCW
*B$#
*LL#H
@BK$JA, $AG^KLA#+5IAABA*+,3*+$HAKAG% 1+ KI$*@@BKL*IK#+
C#G *MIJ#GKo*IK#+ I# IG*+$*LI TM$K+A$$ K+ EB#GK,*> 5IAABA
3*+$HAKAG> *9K++A$#I* L#G@#G*IK#+> BK$IA, KI$H*KBK+S *,
,GA$$*$&.&"%;B*Ge5I%"#%'/))>;JKL*S#> 10.).)&%6*MB
3*+$HAKAG K$ BK$IA,*$9*+*SAG*+,JK$*,,GA$$ K$ BK$IA,*$
&&&& 0K+L#B+ =,%> 5MKIA -))> K+ 9K*HK YA*LJ> EB#GK,*% 5AA
JII@h__$A*GLJ%$M+TKo%#GS_1+gMKGW_;#G@#G*IK#+5A*GLJ_5A*GLJ
=A$MBI8AI*KB_7+IKIW"*HA_C#GB H&&)))))-Q(-LO)-,O,,
T)L.-)O.TLA/--Q.,.CCQ()C_5IAABAd/)3*+$HAKAG_6*SA&%
1+IAGA$IK+SBW>&.&"%;B*Ge5I%5MKIA'/)) K$*B$# BK$IA,*$
IJA@GK+LK@*B@B*LA #CTM$K+A$$ C#G6GA+,* 0*R> 1+L%> K+ KI$
/)&& *@@BKL*IK#+ C#G *MIJ#GKo*IK#+ I# IG*+$*LI TM$K+A$$ K+
EB#GK,*% 1I$ GASK$IAGA,*SA+I>9*Ge0MIo>M$A$ IJA $*HA9K
*HKYA*LJ*,,GA$$*$3*+$HAKAG,K,K+IJA5IAABA3*+$HAKAG
*@@BKL*IK#+% 5AA JII@h__$A*GLJ%$M+TKo%#GS_1+gMKGW_
;#G@#G*IK#+5A*GLJ_5A*GLJ=A$MBI8AI*KB_7+IKIW"*HA_C#G@
C&&)))))-f&.'Lf)-/'*fTA'-TCOTC--'.C'QL/OCOLL_6GA+,*
d/)0*R_6*SA&%5AA*B$#8ALB*G*IK#+#CYGAII0%2KTT$5M@
@#GIK+S 9#IK#+ C#G 1+,KL*IK^A =MBK+S> C%3*%2$&D=E
9"
ff-)/%5AA
JII@h__HTB$@#GI*B%$#$%$I*IA%H+%M$_YM$K+A$$_5A*GLJ
8AI*KB$sCKBK+S2MK,tQAO').Q( O.,-A)&&*((.))&ALO-CCAQC%
5AA *B$# 8KA4G#BB8KA> `8#R+ IJA =*TTKI 3#BA p 6GA+
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
10/24
&) "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
,*_5IAABA_3*+$HAKAGZ#+,AGB*+,>aUEAT%/(>/)&/V>*^*KB*TBA
*I
JII@h__,KAIG#BB,KA%L#H_/)&/_)/_/(_,#R+IJA
G*TTKI
J#BA
@GA+,*$IAABAJ*+$HAKAGR#+,AGB*+,_%
0KIIBAH#GA+AA,TA $*K,%ZA *GA,K$*@@#K+IA, IJ*I IJA
*@@ABB*+I$\#R+*II#G+AW>8*+KABF%N#ABeAG>R*$AKIJAGM+*
TBA#GM+RKBBK+SI#IABBM$*I#G*B*GSMHA+I*T#MIIJA@GALK$A
GAB*IK#+$JK@TAIRAA+6GA+,**+,:B@J*0*R>,A$@KIAKI$GAB
A^*+LAC#GIJAK$$MA$#+*@@A*B%"#H*IIAGhRAJ*^AA+#MSJ
I#L#+LBM,ARKIJL#+CK,A+LAIJ*I+#IKLAI#8MCCWR*$GA*$#+
*TBWL*BLMB*IA,I#*@@GK$A5IAABA*+,3*+$HAKAG#CIJA@A+
,A+LW
#C
IJA
H#IK#+%
E#G
IJA
KLK+S
#+
IJA
L*eA>
RA
*,,
IJ*I
IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI*B$#C#M+,IJ*I5IAABAGALAK^A,*LIM*B+#IKLA
^K*AH*KB%5HKIJ$A+I+#IKLAI#IJAAH*KB*,,GA$$IJ*I5IAABA
$J*GA,RKIJ8MCCW%ZJKBA8MCCW *GSMA$ IJ*I *CIAGJARKIJ
,GARCG#HIJAL*$AJA,K,+#IGALAK^AIJ#$AAH*KB$>IJA,K$
IGKLIL#MGI,K,+#ICK+,JKHI#TALGA,KTBA%ZAJ*^A+#GA*$#+
I#M@$AIIJ*I*$$A$$HA+I%
S) G//96&2%$&D&9H*;*#6,
5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG *B$# *GSMA IJ*I IJAWRAGA +A^AG
SK^A+*+
#@@#GIM+KIW
I#
TA
JA*G,
#+
5HKIJ\$
H#IK#+%
IJA GAL#G,TABKA$ IJAKG *$$AGIK#+%:$RAJ*^A+#IA,>
IJAWJ*,*,AgM*IA+#IKLA#CIJAJA*GK+S%8MCCW$MTHKIIA,*
HAH#G*+,MH K+ #@@#$KIK#+ I# 5HKIJ\$ H#IK#+>TMI 5IAABA
*+,3*+$HAKAG,K,+#I%"#+AIJABA$$>IJAL#MGIS*^A*BBIJGAA
*@@ABB*+I$ *+#IJAG #@@#GIM+KIW I#TA JA*G, #+ IJA H*IIAG
*CIAGIJAW$MTHKIIA,H#IK#+$I#^*L*IA#GGAL#+$K,AGIJA#G
,AG SG*+IK+S 5HKIJ\$ GAgMA$I C#G *II#G+AW$\ CAA$%YAC#GA IJA
GAJA*GK+S> 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAGT#IJ $MTHKIIA,TGKAC$ K+
#@@#$KIK#+I#;#HL*$I\$CAA$%4JAWLJ#$A+#II#$MTHKI*,,K
IK#+*BTGKAC$U*@*GICG#HRJ*IR*$@GA$A+IA,K+IJAH#IK#+I#
^*L*IA#GGAL#+$K,AGKI$ABCV#+*+W#IJAG*$@ALI#CIJA#G,AG%
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
11/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ &&
:I IJA JA*GK+S 3*+$HAKAG Ac@B*K+A, K+ ,AI*KB RJW JA
IJ#MSJIIJ*I
$*+LIK#+$
$J#MB,
+#I
TA
KH@#$A,
*S*K+$I
JKHi
5IAABA $@#eA*$RABB%4JK$H#GA IJ*+ $MCCKLA,*$*+#@@#G
IM+KIWI#TAJA*G,%
E) CJ!-TL9&$9%-'96:**-
1+ *,,KIK#+ I# LJ*BBA+SK+S IJA *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ C#G5HKIJ>
*@@ABB*+I$*B$#*GSMAIJ*IIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIAGGA,TWSG*+IK+S
CAA$ I# IJA 156$%8MCCW *GSMA$JAR*$+#ISK^A+ *+#@@#G
IM+KIW I# GA$@#+, I# IJA 156$\ GAgMA$I> *+, *BB IJGAA *GSMA
IJAWRAGA +#I SK^A+ *+ #@@#GIM+KIW I# GA$@#+, I# IJA CAA
KIAHKo*IK#+%
#) +2''DT-G//96&2%$&D&9U*-/9%,
ZJKBA5IAABA*+,3*+$HAKAG$MTHKIIA,IKHABWHAH#G*+
,*K+#@@#$KIK#+I#IJA156$\H#IK#+$>8MCCW,K,+#I%3A*$
$AGI$ IJ*IJAR*$+#ISK^A+ *+#@@#GIM+KIW I# GA$@#+,TA
L*M$AIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIGMBA,#+IJAH#IK#+$TAC#GAIJAIKHA
I#GA$@#+,Ac@KGA,M+,AG IJAL#MGI\$ B#L*BGMBA$%4JK$*GSM
HA+IK$CGK^#B#M$%8MCCW,#A$+#ILKIA*+WB#L*BGMBAC#GIJK$
@#K+I> *+, J*, JA I*eA+ IJA IKHA I# B##e *I IJA GMBA$> JA
gMKLeBWR#MB,J*^AGA*BKoA,IJ*IIJAGAR*$IKHAI#GA$@#+,%
4JA 156$ ABALIG#+KL*BBW CKBA, IJAKGH#IK#+$#+"#^AHTAG (>
/)&'%4JAB#L*BGMBA$*BB#R&Q,*W$C#G*+WGA$@#+$AI#ABAL
IG#+KL*BBWCKBA,H#IK#+$%5AA58100=Q%&USVi58100=f%&ULV%
4JAGMBA$@G#^K,AIJ*I`jCk*KBMGAI#CKBA*IKHABWGA$@#+$AI#*
H#IK#+H*W> K+ IJA;#MGI\$,K$LGAIK#+>TAL#+$K,AGA,*+*,
HK$$K#+#CIJAHAGKI$#CIJAH#IK#+%a58100=Q%&USV%8MCCW
J*,M+IKB"#^AHTAG/f>/)&'>I#$MTHKIJK$GA$@#+$A>TMIJA
,K,+#ICKBA*+WIJK+S%4JA,K$IGKLIL#MGISG*+IA,IJA156$\H#
IK#+#+
"#^AHTAG
/Q>
/)&'%
8MCCW
J*,
*+
#@@#GIM+KIW
I#
GA
$@#+,iJA$KH@BWLJ#$A+#II#AcAGLK$AKI%
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
12/24
&/ "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
H) :**$&*8$V#&$9%
:BB IJGAA *@@ABB*+I$ *B$# *GSMA IJAWRAGA+#I SK^A+ *+#@@#GIM+KIWI#GA$@#+,I#T#IJ5HKIJ*+,IJA156$\CAAKIAH
Ko*IK#+*+,RAGA@GAbM,KLA,TW IJK$*BBASA,#HK$$K#+% IJAWHK$$ IJAH*Ge%4JAWJ*, * CMBB#@@#GIM+KIW I#
GA$@#+, I#5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+TMI LJ#$A I# C#LM$#+#IJAG
K$$MA$%ZKIJGA$@ALII#IJA156$\KIAHKo*IK#+>IJAW*GAL#GGALI
IJ*IIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIAGGA,RJA+KIGMBA,I##gMKLeBW>TMIRA
L#+LBM,AIJ*IIJK$AGG#GR*$J*GHBA$$%
5HKIJ CKBA, JK$ KIAHKo*IK#+ #+ "#^AHTAG (> /)&'i JA
*,,A, * +#IKLA IJ*I JAR#MB, G*K$A IJA KIAHKo*IK#+ *I IJA"#^AHTAG&'JA*GK+S% RJKLJ GAgMKGA, 5HKIJ I# GACKBA JK$
KIAHKo*IK#+RKIJ*L#GGALIA,$KS+*IMGATB#Lei5HKIJL#H@BKA,
IJ*I $*HA ,*W% IJA,K$IGKLI
L#MGI #G,AGA, IJA ,#LeAI IAcI I# TA H#,KCKA, I# ,A$LGKTA
,ACA+,*+I$\ "#^AHTAG &/ GA$MTHKIIA, KIAHKo*IK#+ *$ *
$M@@BAHA+I I# IJAH#IK#+ C#G $*+LIK#+$%4JA L#MGI,K,+#I
K+,KL*IA*+WLJ*+SAK+IJA,A*,BK+AC#G*GA$@#+$A%4JAL#MGI
IJA+ K$$MA, KI$ GMBK+S CK+,K+S IJA CAA$ GA*$#+*TBA #+
"#^AHTAG/QPCK^A,*W$#'&*6IJA,*IATWRJKLJ3*+$HAKAG
J*, @G#HK$A, JK$ GA$@#+$A I# 5HKIJ\$ KIAHKo*IK#+% ZJKBA
*@@ABB*+I$L#+IA+,IJ*IIJAL#MGIGA$AIIJAGA$@#+$A,A*,BK+A
#+"#^AHTAG/fRJA+KILJ*G*LIAGKoA,5HKIJ\$GA$MTHKIIA,
KIAHKo*IK#+*$*$M@@BAHA+I>IJAWSK^AM$+#K+,KL*IK#+RJW
IJK$ $J#MB, TA $#% YAW#+, IJA C*LI IJ*I IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI+A^AG*LIM*BBWGA$AIIJA,A*,BK+A>IJAGAR*$+#LJ*+SAI#IJA
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
13/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ &'
$MT$I*+LA#C5HKIJ\$KIAHKo*IK#+%9#GA#^AG>*@@ABB*+I$L#MB,
+#IJ*^A
GABKA,
#+
IJ*I
"#^AHTAG
/f
LJ*G*LIAGKo*IK#+>
TAL*M$A IJAKG,A*,BK+A I# $MTHKI IJAKG#@@#$KIK#+R*$ IJ*I
$*HA,*W%1+$J#GI>*@@ABB*+I$J*,*H@BA#@@#GIM+KIWI#TA
JA*G,#+*+WgMA$IK#+$GAB*IA,I#5HKIJ\$KIAHKo*IK#+#CCAA$%
4JAIKHAIJAL#MGIS*^AC#GGA$@#+$A$I#IJA156$\ KIAHK
o*IK#+R*$ $J#GIAG IJ*+ IJA &Q,*W$ L*BBA, C#GTW IJA B#L*B
GMBA$%:4X4,K,+#I CKBA KI$ KIAHKo*IK#+M+IKB"#^AHTAG&fi
;#HL*$I\$ CKBK+SR*$ A^A+ B*IAG>"#^AHTAG //% 4JA,K$IGKLI
L#MGIGMBA,#+IJA$MTHK$$K#+$#+"#^AHTAG/Q>bM$I&/*+,
CK^A
,*W$
B*IAG%
4JA
L#MGI\$
#G,AG
+#IA,
IJ*I
8MCCW>
3*+$HAK
AG>*+,5IAABAJ*,+#ICKBA,GA$@#+$A$I#IJA$@ALKCKLKIAHKo*
IK#+%1IRA+I#+I#Ac@B*K+IJ*IKIC#M+,*GA$@#+$AM++ALA$
$*GWTAL*M$A>*CIAGJ*^K+SGA^KARA,IJAKIAHKo*IK#+$>KIL#+
LBM,A, IJ*I IJA KIAHKoA, CAA$RAGA GA*$#+*TBA%ZA L*+ *$
$MHAIJ*IKIR*$AGG#GC#GIJAL#MGII#*LLABAG*IAIJAIKHAC#G
GMBK+SRKIJ#MIK+C#GHK+SIJA@*GIKA$#CIJAGA^K$A,$LJA,MBA%
"A^AGIJABA$$>*+W$MLJAGG#GR*$J*GHBA$$%:@@ABB*+I$J*^A
+#ISK^A+M$*+WGA*$#+I#TABKA^AIJ*IIJA156$\KIAHKo*IK#+
R*$ M+GA*$#+*TBA% 1+,AA,> K+ C#LM$K+S #+ IJA AGG#G$ K+
J8$&5\$CAA$>*@@ABB*+I$*GSMAIJ*I5HKIJ\$CAA$*GAM+GA*$#+*TBARJA+L#H@*GA, I# IJA CAA$GAgMA$IA,TW;#HL*$I%ZA
$AA+#GA^AG$KTBAAGG#GJAGA%
7) P$8*"$%*--9'&5*CJ!-TL9&$9%
:@@ABB*+I$+AcILJ*BBA+SAIJA156$\H#IK#+#+IJASG#M+,
IJ*I IJAW,AB*WA, I## B#+STAC#GA CKBK+S KI%4JAW*GAL#GGALI
IJ*IH#IK#+$M+,AG $ALIK#+&O/QHM$I+#ITAM+GA*$#+*TBW
,AB*WA,%G(*6%$&*P6#%-/)49)()45$) C%,2-)P$6*49)>.OQE%/,
Q(O>QO'UQIJ;KG%&O('V%YMIIJAW@M$JIJA@#K+II##C*GRJA+
IJAW*$$AGIIJ*IIJA,AB*W,K^A$IA,IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI#CbMGK$
,KLIK#+#^AGIJAKGH#IK#+%1+G(*6%$&*>IJAL*$A#+RJKLJIJAW
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
14/24
&- "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
GABW> *+ *@@A*B #C IJA bM,SHA+I R*$ @A+,K+S> *+, AKSJI
H#+IJ$AB*@$A,
TAIRAA+
IJA
CKBK+S
#C
IJA
+#IKLA
#C
*@@A*B
*+, IJK$ L#MGI\$ *CCKGH*+LA #+ *@@A*B%8MGK+S IJ*I @AGK#,>
bMGK$,KLIK#+J*,$JKCIA,CG#HIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGII#IJAL#MGI#C
*@@A*B$%:CIAGIJK$L#MGI*CCKGHA,>IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGISG*+IA,
*II#G+AW$\ CAA$@MG$M*+I I#$ALIK#+&O/Q% C,)*IQO/%ZAJAB,
IJ*IIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIR*$RKIJ#MIbMGK$,KLIK#+I#GMBA#+IJA
H#IK#+ C#G L#$I$*+,*II#G+AW$\ CAA$%4JA,K$IGKLI L#MGIJ*,
+#I GA$AG^A,bMGK$,KLIK#+ #^AG IJK$ K$$MA *CIAG IJA +#IKLA #C
*@@A*BR*$CKBA,iIJA$I*IMIA,K,+#IBA*^AbMGK$,KLIK#+K+IJA
,K$IGKLI L#MGI C#G IJK$@MG@#$Ai *+,+#H#IK#+$ L#+LAG+K+S
IJAL*$ARAGA,KGALIA,I#AKIJAGIJK$L#MGI#GIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI,MGK+SIJAAKSJIH#+IJ$IJA*@@A*B#+IJAHAGKI$R*$@A+,
K+S%C,)
4JA LKGLMH$I*+LA$ JAGA *GA A+IKGABW ,KCCAGA+I% YAIRAA+
IJAIKHAIJAL*$AR*$^#BM+I*GKBW,K$HK$$A,I#IJAIKHARJA+
IJA156$CKBA,IJAKGH#IK#+C#G$*+LIK#+$>IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGIGA
I*K+A,bMGK$,KLIK#+i+#*@@A*BR*$@A+,K+S%5HKIJH#^A,C#G
$*+LIK#+$#+:@GKB f> /)&'> *+, IJA,K$IGKLI L#MGI#GKSK+*BBW
SG*+IA,JK$H#IK#+#+
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
15/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ &f
4JAL#MGI#G,AGA,IJAKH@#$KIK#+#C*II#G+AW$\CAA$M+,AG
$ALIK#+&O/Q
CG#H
IJA
K+LA@IK#+
#C
IJA
$MKI%
4JA
$I*IMIA
GA*,$
*$C#BB#R$h
:+W *II#G+AW #G #IJAG @AG$#+ *,HKIIA, I# L#+,MLI
L*$A$K+*+WL#MGI#CIJAD+KIA,5I*IA$#G*+W4AGGKI#
GW IJAGA#CRJ# $#HMBIK@BKA$ IJA@G#LAA,K+S$ K+ *+W
L*$AM+GA*$#+*TBW *+, ^Ac*IK#M$BWH*WTA GAgMKGA,
TWIJAL#MGII#$*IK$CW@AG$#+*BBWIJAAcLA$$L#$I$>Ac
@A+$A$> *+, *II#G+AW$ CAA$ GA*$#+*TBW K+LMGGA,TA
L*M$A#C$MLJL#+,MLI%
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
16/24
&. "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
;#M+I 1 *BBASA, IJ*I IJA 156$ ^K#B*IA, IJA ;#H@MIAG
EG*M,*+,
:TM$A
:LI
U;E::V>
&(
D%5%;%
]]
&)')
*+,
&)')USV>
TWC*KBK+SI#@GA^A+IJ*LeK+S%4JA#+BW*BBASA,*$$K$I*+LAI#
J*LeAG$>J#RA^AG>R*$IJALJ*BBA+SAI#IJA$MT@#A+*%:$Ac
@*+$K^A*$IJA;E::K$>$AAQ#32*%*--45#""*%3*-
&9 &5*498/2&*6:6#2,#%,.H2-*.7&>O-91""%0%=7N%&f.&>
&f.'p.fU/)&)V>IJK$K$*CGK^#B#M$LJ*GSA%
;#MGI11*BBASA,IJ*IIJA156$RAGAM+bM$IBWA+GKLJA,TA
L*M$A IJAW L#BBALIA, $MT$LGKTAG CAA$ CG#H@A#@BARJ#M$A,
IJAK+IAG+AII#S*K+KBBAS*B*LLA$$I#0KSJI$@AA,\$RAT$KIA%4#
IJK$
,*W>
IJA
*@@ABB*+I$
J*^A
@G#^K,A,
+#
$M@@#GI
C#G
IJA
K,A*IJ*IA^AGWIKHA*+K+IAG+AIM$AG,#A$$#HAIJK+SM+B*R
CMB#+BK+A>IJAM$AG\$156K$M+bM$IBWA+GKLJA,TAL*M$AKIL#+
IK+MA$GALAK^K+S$MT$LGKTAGCAA$CG#HIJAH*BAC*LI#G%4JAB*R
K+ C*LI K$ I# IJA L#+IG*GW%5AA &QD%5%;% ] f&/U*V U* `$AG^KLA
@G#^K,AG$J*BB+#ITABK*TBAqC#GK+CGK+SAHA+I#CL#@WGKSJI
TWGA*$#+#CIJA@G#^K,AG\$IG*+$HKIIK+S>G#MIK+S>#G@G#^K,
K+S L#++ALIK#+$ C#Ga H*IAGK*B ,K$IGKTMIA,TW #IJAG$ #+ KI$
+AIR#GeV%
;#M+I 111 *BBASA$ IJ*I IJA 156$RAGAHAHTAG$#C * LK^KB
L#+$@KG*LW I# J*Le *+, $IA*B CG#H 0KSJI$@AA,TAL*M$A IJA
156$ $M@@#$A,BWe+AR#C IJA*BBASA,J*LeK+S *+,WAI@G#
IALIA,IJAF#J+8#A$TWLJ*BBA+SK+SIJA$MT@#A+*%;#M+I111
*B$# IJG#R$ K+ *+ *LLM$*IK#+ IJ*I IJA 156 L#G@#G*IA GA@GA
$A+I*IK^A$RAGAL#L#+$@KG*I#G$%4JA$A*$$AGIK#+$*GAMIIAGBW
RKIJ#MI BAS*BHAGKI%4JAL#H@B*K+I B*Le$A^A+ IJAH#$IGM
,KHA+I*GW*BBAS*IK#+#C*SGAAHA+IIJ*IR#MB,$*IK$CWCA,AG*B
@BA*,K+S$I*+,*G,$%1+*,,KIK#+>*$AG^KLA@G#^K,AG,#A$+#I
GK$eTAL#HK+S * L#L#+$@KG*I#G A^AGW IKHA KI LJ*BBA+SA$ *
$MT@#A+*%4#*GSMA IJ*ILJ*BBA+SK+S*$MT@#A+*H*eA$ IJA156$ L#L#+$@KG*I#G$ K+ * CKLIK#+*B L#@WGKSJI K+CGK+SAHA+I
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
17/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ &Q
GK+S K$ CGK^#B#M$%:@@ABB*+I$\ IJA#GW K$ *BB IJAH#GA #MIG*
SA#M$SK^A+
IJA
C*LI
IJ*I
IJA
1BBK+#K$
5M@GAHA
;#MGI
gM*$JA,
*CM+LIK#+*BBWK,A+IKL*B*TM$K^A$MT@#A+*%
;#M+I 1N*BBASA$ IJ*I IJA 156$^K#B*IA, IJA 1BBK+#K$;#+
$MHAGEG*M,*+,8ALA@IK^AYM$K+A$$6G*LIKLA$:LI>(&f10;5
] f)f_/>TW A+S*SK+S K+ IJA ,ALA@IK^A @G*LIKLA #C *BB#RK+S
KBBAS*B *LLA$$ I# @B*K+IKCC\$ #+BK+A L#+IA+I% 9#GA IJ*+ IJK$>
J#RA^AG>K$+AA,A,I#$I*IA*LB*KHM+,AGIJA1BBK+#K$$I*IMIAh
KIGAgMKGA$`U&V*,ALA@IK^A*LI#G@G*LIKLATWIJA,ACA+,*+Ii
U/VIJA,ACA+,*+I\$K+IA+IIJ*IIJA@B*K+IKCCGABW#+IJA,ALA@
IK#+i
*+,
U'V
IJA
#LLMGGA+LA
#C
IJA
,ALA@IK#+
,MGK+S
*
L#MG$A
#CL#+,MLIK+^#B^K+SIG*,A#GL#HHAGLA%aU9H$%-9%()P9D9
L9&9646*,$&496/)0QQf"%7%/,Of&>O.)U1BB%/))/V%4JA:LI*B
$#L#^AG$M+C*KGL#+,MLI% C,)0KSJI$@AA,\$L#H@B*K+I C*KB$I#
@B*LAIJA,ACA+,*+I$#++#IKLA#CJ#RIJAWH*WJ*^A^K#B*I
A,IJK$$I*IMIA%
;#M+I$N*+,N1*GA$KHKB*GBWHAGKIBA$$%4JAW*BBASAIJ*I
IJA156$*K,A,*+,*TAIIA,5HKIJ*+,IJAIJ#M$*+,$#CF#J+
8#A$TWCKSJIK+SIJA$MT@#A+*$%4JAW*B$#*$$AGI>$#HARJ*I
L#+IG*,KLI#GKBW> IJ*I IJA 156 L#G@#G*IA GA@GA$A+I*IK^A$ *LIA,
#MI$K,A IJA $L#@A #C IJAKG AH@B#WHA+I RJA+ IJAW JAB@A,
RKIJIJ*I*K,K+S*+,*TAIIK+S%4JA$ALB*KH$*GAT*$ABA$$%
4JA,K$IGKLIL#MGI$KHKB*GBW,K,+#I*TM$AKI$,K$LGAIK#+K+
*R*G,K+S*II#G+AW$\ CAA$ I#5HKIJ CG#H IJA K+LA@IK#+#C IJA
$MKI% 0KSJI$@AA, G*K$A, T*$ABA$$ LB*KH$ *+, @GA$$A, C#G *
HAGKIBA$$`AHAGSA+LWa,K$L#^AGWJA*GK+S%4JA,K$IGKLIL#MGI
C#M+,IJ*IIJABKIKS*IK#+`$H*LeA,#CTMBBW@GAIA+$A%a:IIJA
"#^AHTAG&'>/)&'>JA*GK+S#+CAA$>IJAL#MGIL#MB,+#IJ*^A
TAA+H#GA LBA*Gh KI $I*IA, IJ*I *@@ABB*+I$RAGA A+S*SA, K+
`*TM$K^ABKIKS*IK#+q$KH@BWCKBK+S*B*R$MKII#,#,K$L#^AGW
I# CK+,#MI KCW#M L*+ $MA $#HAT#,W%4J*I\$bM$IMIIAG+#+
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
18/24
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
19/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ &O
I# JAB@ jIJA *II#G+AWk SAI JK$TA*GK+S$ K+ L#@WGKSJI
B*R%4J*I
jIJA
L#@WGKSJI
$@ALK*BK$Ik
C*KBA,
*I
IJK$
I*$e
,#A$ +#I H*eA JKH GA$@#+$KTBA C#G ,#LMHA+I$ IJ*I
TA*GjIJA*II#G+AW\$k+*HATMI+#IJK$#R+%
C,)*I'-)%4JA,ACA+,*+IJ*,*GSMA,IJ*IIJAL#@WGKSJI$@A
LK*BK$I $J#MB,TA BK*TBATAL*M$AJA,K,+#I/6*(*%& IJA BA*,
*II#G+AWCG#HCKBK+SM+GA*$#+*TBA*+,^Ac*IK#M$,#LMHA+I$%
ZA GAbALIA, IJ*I GA*$#+K+S *+, L#HHA+IA, IJ*I `j$kALIK#+
&O/Q,#A$+#IGAgMKGAA^AGWB*RWAGRJ#CKBA$*+*@@A*G*+LA
I#GA^KAR*+,^AIA^AGW@*@AGCKBA,TWA^AGW#IJAGB*RWAG%a
C,)
*I
'-&%
4JAGABA^*+IgMA$IK#+IJM$GAB*IA$I#IJA$L#@A#CGA$@#+
$KTKBKIWM+,AGI*eA+TWA*LJK+,K^K,M*B*II#G+AW%1+#MGL*$A>
IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI C#M+, IJ*I RJKBA 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG
RAGA +#I BK$IA, #+ A^AGW L#MGI ,#LMHA+I> IJA A^K,A+LA
$J#RA,IJ*IIJAWRAGA`K+L*J##I$aRKIJ8MCCW*+,R#GeA,
RKIJ JKH I#M$A IJAbM,KLK*B $W$IAH C#G * BAS*BBWHAGKIBA$$
LB*KH% 4JAKG ACC#GI$ $AAH I# J*^A L#+IK+MA, K+ IJK$ L#MGI%
ZJKBAT#IJ 5IAABA *+, 3*+$HAKAG +#R L#+IA+, IJ*I IJAW
$J#RA, M@ K+ IJK$ L*$A #+BW *CIAG IJA CA,AG*B @G#LAA,K+S$
RAGA M+,AGR*W> IJA GAL#G, $J#R$ IJ*IT#IJRAGA *B$# K+
^#B^A,K+IJA$J*,#R$#CIJA$I*IAL#MGI@G#LAA,K+S$%5IAABA
L*BBA, :4X4\$ L#M+$AB *T#MI IJA $MT@#A+*$> *+, JA *@
@A*GA, *+, *GSMA, *S*K+$I IJA 156$\H#IK#+ I# gM*$J *+,
H#IK#+I#$I*W%3*+$HAKAG*@@A*GA,*I*L#+CAGA+LATAC#GA*
H*SK$IG*IAbM,SA*+,R*$ IJA$#BA$KS+*I#GW#C IJA&)@*SA
#@@#$KIK#+ I# IJA 156$\ H#IK#+ C#G IJA $I*W #C ,K$L#^AGW%
ZJKBA5IAABA*+,3*+$HAKAG K+$K$IIJ*IIJAWJ*,#+BWHK+K
H*B*LIK^KIWRKIJIJK$L*$A>IJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI,K,+#I*TM$AKI$
,K$LGAIK#+RJA+KIC#M+,#IJAGRK$A%
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
20/24
/) "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
77
ZAIMG++#RI#L*$A"#%&-&.(/>IJA*@@A*BCG#HIJA#G,AGJ#B,K+S8MCCW>5IAABA>*+,3*+$HAKAG K+LK^KBL#+IAH@I
*+, CK+K+S A*LJ #+A #+AIJKG, #C &)d #C ,ACA+,*+I$\ L#$I$
$IAHHK+SCG#HIJACKG$I*@@A*B%
8
:$RA+#IA,*IIJA#MI$AI>*CIAGIJA,K$IGKLIL#MGI#G,AGA,
*@@ABB*+I$ I#@*W IJA$ALIK#+&O/Q$*+LIK#+$RKIJK+&-,*W$
#C IJA #G,AG> IJAW C*KBA, I# ,# $#%:$ * GA$MBI> ,ACA+,*+I$
$MTHKIIA,*b#K+IH#IK#+C#GL#+IAH@I>#GK+IJA*BIAG+*IK^A>
C#G*+#G,AGI#$J#RL*M$ARJWIJAW$J#MB,+#I*BBTAJAB,
K+L#+IAH@I%:IIJA$J#RL*M$AJA*GK+S>A*LJ*@@ABB*+I*,
HKIIA,IJ*IJAJ*,+#I@*K,*+W@*GI#CIJA$*+LIK#+$%"#+A
IJABA$$> *@@ABB*+I$ *GSMA, IJ*I L#+IAH@I R*$ M+*^*KB*TBA
TAL*M$AIJA$*+LIK#+$#G,AG$J#MB,TAGAS*G,A,*$*H#+AW
bM,SHA+I *+, IJM$ $#HAIJK+S IJ*I K$ +#I A+C#GLA*TBA
IJG#MSJ L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,K+S$% 1+ IJA *BIAG+*IK^A> IJAW
LB*KHA,*+K+*TKBKIWI#@*W%4JAL#MGIIJ#MSJIIJA$*+LIK#+$
#G,AG R*$ AgMKI*TBA *+, A+C#GLA*TBA TW M$A #C L#+IAH@I
@#RAG%Y*$A,
#+
*@@ABB*+I$\
LB*KHA,
K+*TKBKIW
I#
@*W>
IJA
,K$
IGKLIL#MGI#G,AGA,A*LJI#$MTHKI*CK+*+LK*B$I*IAHA+ICG#H
*LAGIKCKA,@MTBKL*LL#M+I*+IIJ*I^AGKCKA,JK$*$$AGIA,B*Le#C
GA$#MGLA$%:BIJ#MSJ IJA CK+*+LK*B $I*IAHA+I$RAGA $MTHKI
IA,> IJAW#@A+A,6*+,#G*\$Y#c%:II*LJA, I#A*LJ CK+*+LK*B
$I*IAHA+IR*$ *T#HT$JABB BAIIAG CG#H *@@ABB*+I$\ LAGIKCKA,
@MTBKL *LL#M+I*+I $I*IK+S IJ*I *@@ABB*+I$ J*, `ABALIA, I#
#HKI$MT$I*+IK*BBW*BB#CIJA,K$LB#$MGA$GAgMKGA,TWSA+AG*B
BW*LLA@IA,*LL#M+IK+S@GK+LK@BA$%a"#I$MG@GK$K+SBW>IJA,K$
IGKLI L#MGI C#M+, IJA $I*IAHA+I$ K+$MCCKLKA+I I# A$I*TBK$J *+
K+*TKBKIWI#@*W%1I*B$#I##e+#IKLAIJ*IIJA$A$*HA*II#G+AW$
J*,@#$IA, B*GSAT#+,$ K+#IJAG L*$A$% 1+ L#+bM+LIK#+RKIJ
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
21/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ /&
IJAC*KBMGAA^A+I#HA+IK#+IJA$A#IJAGL*$A$>IJAL#MGI$*R
IJK$*$
*+
*IIAH@I
I#
KH@A,A
KI$
*TKBKIW
I#
H*eA
*+
*LLMG*IA
*$$A$$HA+I#CIJAKGLMGGA+I*TKBKIWI#@*W%
4JAL#MGIC#M+,IJ*I*@@ABB*+I$J*,RKBBCMBBW^K#B*IA,IJA
$*+LIK#+$#G,AG*+,H*,A+#ACC#GI I# L#H@BW%4JAH*S+K
IM,A #C J*GHR*$ $KS+KCKL*+I> KI *,,A,> @*GIKLMB*GBW *$ IJA
M+,AGBWK+S L*$A R*$T*$ABA$$ *+, * HK$M$A #C IJA L#MGI$%
:,,KIK#+*BBW> IJAL#MGI C#M+,*@@ABB*+I$I#J*^AH*,AHK$
GA@GA$A+I*IK#+$ *+, @GA$A+IA, `J*BCIGMIJ$a *I IJA $J#R
L*M$AJA*GK+S>$J#RK+SLBA*G,K$GA$@ALIC#GIJAL#MGI%4*eK+S
*BB
#C
IJK$
K+I#
*LL#M+I>
IJA
L#MGI
$*+LIK#+A,
*@@ABB*+I$
K+
IJA
*H#M+I#C&)d#CIJA#GKSK+*B$*+LIK#+*+,#G,AGA,IJA$MH
I#TA,K^K,A,AgM*BBW*H#+SIJAH%1I*B$#$AIM@*$LJA,MBA
#C*,,KIK#+*BCK+A$KCIJAWC*KBA,I#L#H@BW%
9
*$TAC#GA>K$C#G*TM$A#C,K$LGAIK#+%5AA.2
&9&*75P*75-)
!"#-&$7 C%,2-)0M)Q)>f/fE%',f-/ UQIJ;KG%/))(V%ZA I*eA IJA
ABAHA+I$K+IMG+%
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
22/24
// "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
4JA,K$IGKLIL#MGI\$#GKSK+*B#G,AGR*$M+*HTKSM#M$%4JA
L#MGIH*,A
LBA*G
IJ*I
KI
R*$
KH@#$K+S
$*+LIK#+$
@MG$M*+I
I#
/(D%5%;%]&O/Q*+,Ac@BKLKIBWL#HH*+,A,*@@ABB*+I$I#@*W
RKIJK+ &-,*W$%:@@ABB*+I$ IGW I# A^*,A KITW *GSMK+S IJ*I
IJAWIJ#MSJIIJA#G,AGR*$C#G*H#+AWbM,SHA+I%YMIIJK$
R*$ +AKIJAG @GK^*IA +#G @MTBKL BKIKS*IK#+ *S*K+$I IJA *II#G
+AW$%ZJ*IR*$*I$I*eAR*$IJAL#MGI\$@#RAGI#S#^AG+KI$
T*G%:$$ALIK#+&O/QU*+,C#GIJ*IH*IIAG/(D%5%;%]&.f&VGA
CBALI>L#MGI$J*^A IJA*MIJ#GKIW> IJG#MSJL#+IAH@I@G#LAA,
K+S$> I# $*+LIK#+ *II#G+AW$ *+, I# A+C#GLA IJAKG#G,AG$% 5AA
4"*(*"#%,;#$64"$%$70 C%7)()!2$3>&).E%',&.f>&.. UQIJ;KG%
&OOQVU`D$A#CIJAL#+IAH@I@#RAGK$*+*@@G#@GK*IAR*WI#A+C#GLA*$*+LIK#+C#GHK$L#+,MLI>RJKLJK$+#I*+#G,K+*GW
H#+AWbM,SHA+I%aVi."/*6%()&&E%',.(O>.O)UQIJ;KG%
&OO'V U`j=MBA&&k,KGALI$ IJA KH@#$KIK#+#C$*+LIK#+$ C#GM+
@G#CA$$K#+*B L#+,MLI K+ BKIKS*IK#+> *+, RJKBA IJA C#GH #C
$*+LIK#+K$#CIA+*+,R*$JAGA*+#G,AGI#@*W*II#G+AW$CAA$
I#IJA#@@#+A+IK+IJABKIKS*IK#+>KIK$$IKBB*$*+LIK#+>bM$I*$
*+#G,AG#CGA$IKIMIK#+ K+*LGKHK+*BL*$A K$* $*+LIK#+A^A+
RJA+ KI,KGALI$ IJ*I@*WHA+ITAH*,A I# *@GK^*IA@AG$#+
G*IJAGIJ*+
I#
IJA
S#^AG+HA+I%aV%
4JA
H#+AW
bM,SHA+I
,A
CA+$ASAI$*@@ABB*+I$+#RJAGA%
:@@ABB*+I$+AcI*GSMAIJ*IIJAGAK$+#A^K,A+LAIJ*IIJAW
,K,%9&$MT$I*+IK*BBWL#H@BWRKIJIJA#G,AG>#G*I BA*$II*eA
GA*$#+*TBA*+,,KBKSA+I$IA@$I#,#$#%4JK$@#$KIK#+KS+#GA$
IJAGAL#G,%:IIJA$J#RL*M$AJA*GK+S*@@ABB*+I$H*,ALBA*G
IJ*IIJAWJ*,+#I@*K,*+WIJK+S*+,>RJA+gMA$IK#+A,*T#MI
@*WHA+I> IJAW+A^AG@#K+IA, I# *+W $IA@ K+ IJ*I,KGALIK#+%
4JAWABALIA,K+$IA*,I#,ACA+,#+IJASG#M+,IJ*IIJAWRAGA
M+*TBAI#
@*W%
1+*TKBKIW
I#
@*W
K$
K+,AA,
*^*BK,
,ACA+$A
K+
L#+IAH@I @G#LAA,K+S$> C% 6* U*-9267* P*75) 496/)> ./- E%',
'Q.> '(Q UQIJ;KG% /)&)V>TMI IJAgMA$IK#+R5*&5*6 IJA $*+L
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
23/24
"#$%&''()&X&-&.(/ /'
IK#+$RAGA@*K, K$,KCCAGA+ICG#HIJAgMA$IK#+R5D@*WHA+I
R*$+#I
H*,A%
4JA
,K$IGKLI
L#MGI
R*$
A+IKIBA,
I#
*+$RAG
IJA
CKG$I#+AK+IJA+AS*IK^A>SK^A+*@@ABB*+I$\*,HK$$K#+#+IJA
GAL#G,IJ*IIJAWJ*,+AKIJAG@*K,IJAGAgMKGA,*H#M+II#,A
CA+,*+I$+#G@#$IA,*$M@AG$A,A*$T#+,%
:@@ABB*+I$+AcI*GSMA IJ*IA^A+ KCLK^KBL#+IAH@IHKSJI
J*^ATAA+ @G#@AG> IJ*I R*$ +#I IJA IW@A #C L#+IAH@I KH
@#$A, *S*K+$I IJAH% 4JAW MGSA IJ*I IJA CK+A KH@#$A,R*$
LGKHK+*BK++*IMGA*+,IJAW*GAIJAGAC#GAA+IKIBA,I#*$A@*
G*IA@G#$ALMIK#+*+,CMBB,MA@G#LA$$%ZA$AA+#IJK+SJAGA>
J#RA^AG>
IJ*I
R#MB,
bM$IKCW
LJ*G*LIAGKoK+S
IJA$A
CK+A$
*$
LGKHK+*B%;K^KBL#+IAH@I@G#LAA,K+S$H*WTAAKIJAGL#AGLK^A
#GGAHA,K*B%5AAI%$&*,J&*-()+9R*"">/fQE%',.O->.OOUQIJ
;KG%/))&V%4JAW*GA`,A$KS+A,AKIJAGI#L#H@ABIJAL#+IAH
+#GK+I#L#H@BK*+LARKIJ*+AcK$IK+SL#MGI#G,AG#GI#L#H
@A+$*IA IJA L#H@B*K+*+I C#G B#$$A$ $M$I*K+A, *$ * GA$MBI#C
IJAL#+IMH*LW%aC,)4JK$CK+AR*$GAHA,K*B%1IR*$@*K,I#IJA
,ACA+,*+I$>$AA;$7N-9%M*5#"'9':*$97N():*$97N>-(fD%5%./->
.'/ U&O((V> *+, KI L#GGA$@#+,A, I# IJA *II#G+AW$\ CAA$ *+,
L#$I$ K+LMGGA,TW,ACA+,*+I$,MGK+SIJAL#MG$A#C BKIKS*IK+S
IJA L#+IAH@IH#IK#+% 4JA C*LI IJ*I IJA L#MGI LJ#$A * CK+AAgM*BI#&)d#CIJA#GKSK+*B$*+LIK#+RKIJ#MIL#+$MBIK+STKBB
K+S$I*IAHA+I$,#A$+#IL#+^AGIIJK$ K+I#*CK+AC#GLGKHK+*B
L#+IAH@I%5AAK(#%-()4$&D9'K(#%-&9%>O-&E%/,-Q'>-QQUQIJ
;KG%&OO&V%
:@@ABB*+I$\GAB*IA,*GSMHA+IIJ*IIJAL#MGI\$K+*TKBKIWI#
@*W*+*BW$K$R*$*+*TM$A#C,K$LGAIK#+ K$AgM*BBWM+*^*KB
K+S%ZJAGA`IJAGAJ*$TAA++#ACC#GI*IA^A+@*GIK*BL#H@BK
*+LARKIJ IJA L#MGI\$#G,AG> IJA K+*TKBKIWI#@*W,ACA+$A GA
gMKGA$*$J#RK+S#C*mL#H@BAIAK+*TKBKIW\I#@*Wai*@@ABB*+I$`J*, IJATMG,A+#CA$I*TBK$JK+S mLBA*GBW>/"#$%"D>*+,2%8$-
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"
-
8/12/2019 Order on Prenda appeal
24/24
/- "#$%&''()&X&-&.(/
N#H"D\ IJ*I mL#H@BK*+LA K$ $8/9--$H"*%\a C% 6* U*-9267* P*75)
496/)>./-
E%',
*I
'(Q
ULKIK+S
;2H*6
()
L#6$%*
L$,"#%,
M#%N>f&
E%',f>&)U/,;KG%&OOfVV%
llllllllllllllllllllll
:@@ABB*+I$\ TMG,A+ K+ A*LJ #C IJA$A @G#LAA,K+S$ R*$
JKSJ *+, IJA GAL#G, $M@@#GI$ IJA ,K$IGKLI L#MGI\$ J#B,K+S$
IJ*I IJAW,K,+#IHAAI KI%:+W*GSMHA+I$ IJ*IRAJ*^A+#I
,K$LM$$A,,#+#IHAGKI$A@*G*IA*IIA+IK#+%ZA:EE1=9IJA#G
,AG#C$*+LIK#+$ KH@#$A,*S*K+$I*@@ABB*+I$ K+"#%&''()&%
ZA*B$#:EE1=9IJA#G,AGK+"#%&-&.(/J#B,K+S*@@ABB*+I$
K+LK^KBL#+IAH@I*+, KH@#$K+SIJA$I*IA,CK+A%;#$I$#C*@@A*B*GAI#TAI*cA,*S*K+$I*@@ABB*+I$b#K+IBW*+,$A^AG*BBW%
5AAE78%=%:66%6%'OU*V%
!"#$% '()(*+' ,-./0$12% (3 456$7% +89('9:+'3 ;"