Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online...

23
Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online Environment: Lessons Learned Wayne Pferdehirt, Jeffrey S. Russell, Jeff Haught, Dave Pagenkopf CIEC, February, 2012

Transcript of Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online...

Page 1: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online Environment: Lessons Learned

Wayne Pferdehirt, Jeffrey S. Russell, Jeff Haught, Dave Pagenkopf

CIEC, February, 2012

Page 2: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

The Question

Is online learning an impediment to meaningful group projects? or … Can the format be exploited to enhance collaboration and applied learning?

Page 3: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Our Panelists Jeffrey Russell

UW Vice Provost of Lifelong Learning Course Co-Instructor

David Pagenkopf Director, UW Div. of Info. Technology Former Dir. App. Dev. & Mgt., TDS

Jeff Haught Project Manager, NASA

Wayne Pferdehirt Dir. of Eng. Grad. Dist. Degrees Course Co-Instructor

Page 4: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Context: What is MEPP?

Master of Engineering in Professional Practice

Two-Year Cross-Disciplinary Graduate Degree for Engineers

Focus is Leadership and Management of Technical Projects and Teams

Alternative to an MBA for Engineers

Page 5: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Context: The Students Mid-career engineers

All work full-time

4 to 35 years experience

Project managers to CEOs

Focused on growing as effective leaders

Page 6: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Example Employers of MEPP Students

3M BAE Systems Boeing Cap Gemini Caterpillar Cummins GE Genentech General Motors Google Hamilton-Sundstrand Harley-Davidson IBM Intel John Deere

Kimberly-Clark

Kohler

Kraft/Oscar Mayer

Lockheed Martin

Mercury Marine

Micron

Monsanto

Motorola

NASA

Navistar

Qualcomm

Rockwell Automation

Trane

US Armed Forces

Page 7: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

MEPP Distinguishing Characteristics: Program Design

Fixed, two-year curriculum

Cohort model: a stable, supportive learning community of peers

Only 30 students admitted per year

One week on-campus residency each year

Page 8: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Course Content and Format Optimized for Mid-Career, Practicing Engineers

Collaborative, problem- and project-based learning

Intentionally engages the experience and real-world project responsibilities of the students

Taught via creative mix of asynchronous and synchronous distance education technologies

Page 9: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

MEPP Courses

First Year Curriculum

Network Skills for Remote Learners Residency I

Technical Project Management Management Accounting

Communicating Technical Information Engineering Problem Solving with Computers

Summer Fall Spring

Page 10: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

MEPP Courses Second Year Curriculum

Independent Reading and Research Residency II

Engineering Applications of Statistics International Engineering Strategies and Operations

Applied Leadership and Management of Engineering Organizations

Quality Engineering and Quality Management

Summer Fall Spring

Page 11: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Technical Project Management: Course Topics

Projects and Management

Project Evaluation and Selection

Project Initiation, Scope and Structure

Proposals and Contracts

Team Formation, Team Management and Project Leadership

Project Planning and Scheduling

Project Network Analysis

Project Risk Management

Project Budgeting

Resource Allocation and Management

Project Monitoring and Control

Engineering for Sustainability Applied to Project Management

Project Audits and Closure

Project Reports and Presentations

Page 12: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Typical Weekly Rhythm of MEPP Courses

Listen to

Recorded

Introduction

of Content

Online

Discussion

Web

conferences Homework

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday AM

or Thursday PM

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

Page 13: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Goals of Team Project

Learn by doing

Authentic, real-world opportunity for applying project management strategies

Analysis, decisions and communication to achieve real results

Hone project teamwork skills under pressure

Develop effective collaboration skills for globally dispersed teams

Page 14: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Major Team Project: Elements

1. Proposal to Project Team

2. Team Project Plan

3. Strategic Analysis of Project

4. Project Organization, Schedule & Budget

5. Project Crash Analysis

Page 15: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Major Team Project: Elements

6. Project Monitoring & Control Plan

7. Team Project Presentation

8. Team Final Report

9. Team Self Evaluations

Page 16: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing
Page 17: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Examples of Team Projects

Page 18: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Examples of Team Projects

Electronic Control Unit form Electric Lawn Tractor

Shovel with AC Drive Technology

Page 19: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Team Discussion Forums (Moodle)

Asynchronous, threaded discussion Access limited to team members

Web Conference (MS LiveMeeting)

“Meet Now” rooms for teams to meet and work

Document Management (DocuShare)

Version-controlled document sharing

Email

Telephone

Instant Messaging

Collaboration Tools Support Work of Project Teams

Page 20: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Lessons Learned

Course Context Combine traditional and contemporary

Authentic, collaborative application

Enable and value sharing of experience, insights, best practices

PM tools: support, within context

Page 21: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

Lessons Learned

Project Progressive, authentic deliverables

Detailed, seasoned, timely feedback

Provide and support industrial-strength collaboration tools

Require professional quality of all work products

Have teams develop detailed work plan

Page 22: Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing Engineers in an Online …wordpress.engineering.iastate.edu/cpd-asee/files/2012/05/... · 2012. 5. 22. · Optimizing Group Projects for Practicing

People Set and support high expectations for

professional work

Goal is excellence for all

Value of team self-assessments

Teach, enable, support effective collaboration

Support learning within and across teams

Lessons Learned