OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS...

37
MD EMEA DR. THOMAS BUER OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS OF BIOGAS GLOBAL BIOMETHANE CONGRESS 2012, BRUSSELS Szarvas, Hungary Wastes & Energy Crops BGA RÖBLINGEN, CHICKEN MANURE

Transcript of OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS...

Page 1: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

MD EMEA DR. THOMAS BUER

OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS OF BIOGAS GLOBAL BIOMETHANE CONGRESS 2012, BRUSSELS

Szarvas, Hungary Wastes & Energy Crops BGA RÖBLINGEN, CHICKEN MANURE

Page 2: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

UTS Company Profile Technical Trends Optimising the digestion process Overcoming Feedstock management issues (quality & quantity) Discussion

CONTENT

Page 3: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

UTS Company Profile

Söhnergy, Germany Energy Crops

Page 4: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

COMPANY PROFILE

Founded in 1992 115 employees in Europe 65 in North America (parent company Anaergia Inc.)

German parent company with 100% UK & Ireland, Spain, Italy subsidiary, HU JV, PL, Ro and Gr under preparation (future markets)

Private ownership: Dr. Andrew Benedek via Anaergia Inc. 19 years experience in design & build

biogas plants & technology Technology provider to > 1,600 biogas plants with own

products and manufacturing Design & Build of > 220 turn-key biogas plants Biogas plants from 75 kW to > 5 MW for agricultural wastes, energy crops, commercial and industrial organic wastes & municipal waste,

municipal power plants Representation in 11 European countries Currently about 40 active projects in 9 European countries

DE, IT, UK, PL, GR, ES, HR, RO, HU, International revenue percentage > 50%

Page 5: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

UTS IN EUROPE

Spain /Portugal /France • GM • Sales • Operations

UK & Ireland: • GM • Sales • Operations • Service

Italy: • GM • Sales • Operations • Service

Germany: • MD • Sales • Operations • Service • Products

CEE Poland • Sales • Operations Romania • Sales

Hungary: • GM • Sales • Operations

Greece: • Sales • Project Development

Croatia: • Sales • PM

Page 6: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

HQ & KEY PROJECTS EUROPE

Hallbergmoos - HQ

HU: Szarvas 4.2 MWel

HR Mala I&II 2 MWel

UK Glenfarg, 0.8 Mwel 16 kta waste

DE Soehnrgy 1MWel 350 Nm³h CH4

DE Bieringen 0.8 MWel

IT: Marchesina 1 MWel

DE: Roeblingen 700 Nm³

Page 7: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

UTS CORE TECHNOLOGY Patented and trade know-how protected core products

Hydraulic mixers Service box with roof configuration feeder system and controls Separator pumps

Biogas process design PFD Layout and overall design

Helios/Triton/Kairos Process and component design P&ID Controls (PLC, software code)

Page 8: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

UTS VISION AND VALUES

We are committed to reducing the World’s Carbon Footprint by being a Global Leader in

Sustainable and Economical Distributed Energy Generation from Waste.

Page 9: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

TECHNICAL TRENDS (… REFLECTING ECONOMIC BOUNDARIES)

Bieringen, Germany Energy Crops

Page 10: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

Mid to long term lower feed-in tariffs Rising „fuel‚ costs for maize etc Political debate using food for energy production Increased use of wastes

(cap on maize % in Germany and new Italian FiT) Flexible plants for various substrate rather than bonus optimized plants

(dependency on mono-substrates over plant lifetime)

MARKET TRENDS I

Page 11: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

ECONOMIC BOUNDARIES

Biogas Plant Invest 3000 – 6500 €/kWh Civils 45 % Equipment 55 % Deprec. 7 – 15 a Equipment 15 – 30 a civils Equity 25 – 45 % Loan 3.5% - 9 % Labor 0.5 – 1 ct/kWh Power 0.5 – 1 ct/kWh Service 1.5 – 2.5 ct/kWh Loan for land

Feedstock Energy Crops 15 … 40 €/t Manure 0 … 15 €/t Wastes +50 …- 50 €/t Transport !

Energy Output Electricity 4 ... 7 ct/kWh market price Gas 5 … 7 ct/kWh market price Heat 0.5 … 4 ct/kWh local contract FiT Electr. 9 … 28 ct/kWh @ 5 … 26 a FiT Gas … 12 ct/kWh

Digestate EC & Manure: 0 …- 5 €/t Wastes - 5€/t… + 5€/t Transport!

Page 12: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

CASE 1: ENERGY CROP POWERED BIOGAS PLANT

CAPEX Construction € 4.000.000 Amortisation € 266.667 Financial costs € 145.184 OPEX Operation € 242.505 Manpower € 31.285 Machine € 16.619 G&A € 89.573 Raw Material € 863.093 Total cost € 1.654.927 Revenue € 2.181.267 EBIT € 526.340 ROI 13,16%

ASSUMPTIONS: 1 MW PLANT 28 CT/KWH FIT @ 15 A (ITALY) 90% AVAILABILITY, 7.875 H/A,

7.875 MWH DEPRECIATION 15 A 25% EQUITY/75% LOAN @ 4.9% 21.500 T/A SUBSTRATES @ 32% DS, 96% VSS, 660 L/KG

VSS, 40 €/T CAPEX: 5.23 CT/KWH OPEX: 4.83 CT/KWH TOTAL W/O FS 10.06 CT/KWH FEEDSTOCK: 10.96 CT/KWH TOTAL: 21.02 CT/KWH

Page 13: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

CASE 2: ORGANIC WASTE POWERED BIOGAS PLANT

CAPEX Construction € 5.625.000 Amortisation € 375.000 Financial costs € 170.156 OPEX Operation € 242.505 Manpower € 90.000 Machine € 20.000 G&A € 113.000 Total Costs € 1.010.661

Revenue FiT € 1.134.000 Revenue Feedstock/Waste € 720.000 Costs Waste Disposal € - 180.000 EBIT € 663.339 ROI 11.79%

Assumptions: 0.8 MW plant 18 ct/kWh FiT (UK) 90% availability, 7.875 h/a,

6.300 MWh Depreciation 15 a 45% Equity/55% loan @ 5.5% 18.000 t/a organic waste @ 25% DS 90% vSS, 700 l/kg

vSS, - 40 €/t CAPEX: 8.65 ct/kWh OPEX: 7.39 ct/kWh Total w/o FS 16.04 ct/kWh Feedstock: -8.57 ct/kWh Total: 7.47 ct/kWh

Page 14: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

Power distribution & peak management Energy production in biogas plants independent from out of control

factors wind/sun Biogas plants operation matching „grid demand‚ vs. high uptime to

ensure profitability Gas to Grid (using gas grid for storage) …larger plants > 2 MW (Triton)

Large or external gas covers 2nd CHP for peaking

MARKET TRENDS II

Page 15: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

BIOGAS = ENERGY TO STORE AND REGULATE

Page 16: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

BIOGAS PLANT SZARVAS CUSTOMER: AUFWIND - BAYWA INSTALLED CAPACITY: 4.2 MWEL, 10 MW PRIMARY ENERGY SUBSTRATES: ORG. WASTES, MANURE, CROPS, MUNICIPAL SLUDGE, SLAUGHTERHOUSE WASTE, AND AGRICULTURAL WASTE TO ENERGY REACTOR CONCEPT: HELIOS

Page 17: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

TECHNICAL DETAILS: CHP installed: 3 x 1.190 kWel 1 x 600 kWel Electrical Output: 4.170 kWel Thermal Output: 4.135 kWel Net Electricity production: per Year about 26.200.00 kWh (feed-in capacity) Net Heat Production: per year about 25.500.00 kWh Substrate Solids: Sweet Sorghum, Manure Process Sludge (44.000 t/a) Reception Pit 1: Pig Slurry (33.000 t/a) Reception Pit 2: Slaughterhouse Wastes, Whey (45.000 t/a)

SZARVAS PROJECT DATA

Page 18: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

„CLASSICAL‚ & FLEXIBLE BIOGAS PLANT

CHP

100%

External Heat Use 15-30%

Sale to

Grid 40%

Electrical Energy 40%

Thermal Energy 40 %

Biogas Plant Fermenter 1

0

Biogas Plant

Fermenter 2

Biogas Plant Fermenter 1

Biogas Plant

Fermenter 2

100%

Internal heat consumption approx. 10-25%

CHP 1

50- 100%

External Heat Use ? ? ?

Sale to

Grid 40%

Electrical Energy 40%

Thermal Energy 20 - 40 %

0

50-100%

CHP 2

50 - 100% Sale to

Grid 40%

Electrical Energy 40% 0

0-100%

Internal heat consumption approx. 10-25%

4 – 6 h

2 x (4 – 6 h) = 8 – 12 h

Page 19: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

Optimizing the Digestion Process

Glenfarg, UK Food Waste

Page 20: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

HOW IS BIOGAS BEING PRODUCED?

Org. material

Air tight tank

Decomposition of org. material

Acid-forming bacteria Methane-forming bacteria

Retention time ~ 10 – 60 days

Page 21: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

EXPERIENCE WITH MULITPLE FEEDSTOCKS

Pig manure

Cow manure

Slaughterhouse waste

Corn silage

Organic waste

Biogas yield in l/kg vSS

Stillage

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

sewage sludge

Pig manure

Cow manure

Stillage

Organic waste

Sewage sludge

Page 22: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

EXPERIENCE WITH MULTIPLE FEEDSTOCKS

Pig manure

Cow manure

Slaughterhouse waste

Corn silage

Organic waste

Biogas yield in m³/t of fresh material

Stillage

Sewage:

5 % DSM @ 70 % vSS

400 l/kg vSS -> 14 m³/t

Page 23: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

UTS TRITON ® Preferred design for large plants (> 1 MW) Ring-in-ring arrangement of tanks Outer ring: high rate reactor Inner ring: post-reactor Concrete cover or gas membrane/storage Capacity: 1.8 – 2 MW/system vs. 0.8-1.0 MW Short piping length Low energy losses (5-10% vs. 20-30% therm) Compact construction (-30% footprint) Clean and straight forward plant design

rather than tank/reactor farms Low peristaltic energy consumption due to optimized circular plug flow

(< 7%, less dissipation) Circular and directed flow

Page 24: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

TRITON® VS. CONVENTIONAL TECHNOLOGY

8MW conventional

80m

110m

140m

90m

Z Z

BB

B BB B B B

S

V

S

ZNFSF NFSF

ZNFSF NFSF

ZF F ZF F

SF SF SF SF

V

V V

SS

Typical non-Triton 4 MW plant Triton 4 MW plant

- 30% footprint !

Page 25: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

MANTOVAAGRICOLTURA, 1 MW - EXPANSION, WITH 2ND 1 MW INSTALLATION, ITALY

TRITON

CONVENTIONAL

Page 26: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

Overcoming Substrate Management Challenges

Mantova, Italy Energy Crop & Slaughterhouse Waste

Page 27: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

DOS & DON‘TS OVERCOMING FEEDSTOCK MANAGEMENT CHALLENGES

DOS DON‘TS

Flexible plant design for various substrates (mixing, pre-mixing tanks, volumen)

Recirculation of digestate Long term contracts or partial ownership of land Screening/batch tests Contaminants check Secure => 80% mid to long term supply for base

load Biological healthy substrate mix

Spot substrate market: caution! No quality check of input material Mono-substrates: caution: nutrient management

Page 28: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

SUMMARY Trend to larger plants with increase use of various organic wastes (250-500 kW 1 MW and above)

Flexible plants including power on demand production of electricity or gas to grid

Technology evolution from „farm‚-style plants towards industrial style power plants Efficient & reliable design Higher technical advancements (equipment, PLC/Scada) Safety regulations (maintenance!) Professional and safe operation

Page 29: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

Discussion &

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION !

Fair Oaks, US Gas upgrading to vehicle fuel (CNG)

Page 30: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

BGA BIERINGEN • 800 KWel Plant - • Start Construction June 2010 • Client: • Biogaspark Neckar-Odenwald • Turn-key UTS-Triton Biogasplant • Energy crops (corn silage)

Page 31: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

BGA BIERINGEN

Page 32: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

TRITON® CONCEPT FOR 18 MW

39/27 x 9 m Inner ring with membrane roof

Page 33: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

GLENFARG 3D- LAYOUT

Buffer tank V1 Post Fermenter N1

Fermenter F1

Equipment Building

Page 34: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

TEG GLENFARG

Depackaging and feed transfer pump

EQ / Hydrolisis buffer tank

Fermenter I/II top view

Page 35: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

BIOGAS PLANT GLENFARG

Page 36: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

TEG - GLENFARG

Final digestate storage tank with gas storage

Hygenisation Station

Page 37: OPTIMISING THE UPGRADING PROCESS BIOGASeuropean-biogas.eu/wp-content/uploads/files/2013/11/14-Thomas-Buer... · biogas plants & technology ... Cow manure Slaughterhouse waste Corn

BIOGAS PLANT GLENFARG