Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

110
#LKCE13 #realoptions November 5, 2013 Risks and Decisions The ‘When’ rather than the ‘How’ Olav Maassen Xebia [email protected] @OlavMaassen Chris Matts Emergent Behavior [email protected] @PapaChrisMatts

description

While HOW to make decisions is important, the WHEN to make decisions is critical to your chances of success. Olav and Chris present Real Options, an approach they have been working on since 2006 that focuses on the “When” rather than the “How” of decision making. Timing is everything, however deferring commitments causes stress to many people. Real options helps you manage that stress by creating bounded uncertainty in an context of total uncertainty. This is not a simple process that you copy and learn to adopt through practice. This is a new way at looking at the world around you that starts by learning to differentiate between options and commitments. Olav and Chris help do this through an interactive exercise. It turns out that the way you manage your options is to focus on commitments and attempt to avoid or defer them. After identifying commitments, Olav and Chris discuss creating options to turn the commitments into reversible commitments. Olav and Chris have recently creating “Commitment”, the first graphic business novel about managing project risk. Because they eat their own dog food Real Options plays a big part in the creation part of the book as well. They present the creation process as a case study about applying Real Options and how that leads to different behavior. Finally they present a number of mini case studies where other people have applied Real Option thinking in “out of the box” situations. Once you get it, it will change your life.

Transcript of Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Page 1: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

#LKCE13 #realoptions November 5, 2013

Risks and Decisions The ‘When’ rather than the ‘How’

Olav Maassen Xebia

[email protected] @OlavMaassen

Chris Matts Emergent Behavior

[email protected] @PapaChrisMatts

Page 2: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 3: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

“LUPUS”' “HEP'E”'

“LUPUS”'IV'CYTOXIN'

PLASMA'PHERYSIS'

“HEP'E”'NO'TREATMENT'

SOLUMENDROL'

!'

Get'Worse'

No'Impact'

Toast'

Get'beBer'Or''

Get'Worse'

Hurt'him'Just'right'

Page 4: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Options have value

©'luismi1985'

Options expire

©'givepeasachance'

Never commit

early unless

you know why

©'Tub'Gurnard'

Page 5: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Agenda

Real Options: understand the difference between an option and a commitment •  Options and commitments •  Reversibility of decisions •  Applying Real Options in writing a book •  Real world examples

5'

Page 6: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

40 Minutes

6'

Page 7: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

When is something a commitment?

Page 8: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

When is something optional?

©'MacUK'

Page 9: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Do you have a choice?

9'

OpSon'

Commitment'

Page 10: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 11: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

•  This talk •  Could we walk of the stage? •  Hotel this morning (what’s the consequence of not

showing up: Nils panic, never invited again, reputation shot)

•  Is the hotel a commitment •  Is the flight a commitment •  What about five minutes after it has taken of? •  Nils asked us: commitment or option? •  What about the actual event •  If the event got cancelled would we still go? •  Lady gaga concert?

11'

Page 12: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

12'

Page 13: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

13'

Page 14: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

14'

Page 15: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

15'

Page 16: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

16'

Page 17: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

17'

Page 18: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

18'

Page 19: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

19'

Page 20: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

20'

Page 21: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Options have value

©'luismi1985'

Options expire

©'givepeasachance'

Never commit

early unless

you know why

©'Tub'Gurnard'

Page 22: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

1.  Right'2. Wrong'3.  Uncertainty'

©'Bethany'L'King'

©'Violator3'

Page 23: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

•  When do supermarkets open a new till / register -> conditional

•  Published and the customers start to manage it

23'

Page 24: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

30 Minutes

24'

Page 25: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 26: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 27: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Month'

Page 28: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 29: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Day'

Page 30: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

hBp://www.flickr.com/photos/embreyart/4229109725/sizes/m/in/photostream/'

Page 31: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

An'Hour'

Page 32: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 33: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Minute'

Page 34: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 35: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

35'

Page 36: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

If the time it takes to recover, is greater than the time you can survive, you die.

Which means you need more options.

36'

Page 37: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 38: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Month'

Page 39: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 40: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Day'

Page 41: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

hBp://www.flickr.com/photos/embreyart/4229109725/sizes/m/in/photostream/'

Page 42: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

An'Hour'

Page 43: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 44: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Minute'

Page 45: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 46: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

A'Second'

Page 47: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

ROLL$BACK!$

Page 48: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

If the time it takes to recover, is greater than the time you can survive, you die.

Which means you need more options. Monitor the conditions

48'

Page 49: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Its'not''about'

probability'

Page 50: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

It’s'about'survival'

Page 51: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

20 Minutes

51'

Page 52: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Options have value

©'luismi1985'

Options expire

©'givepeasachance'

Never commit

early unless

you know why

©'Tub'Gurnard'

Page 53: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Eat own dog food

53'

Page 54: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

54'

Page 55: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Finding the artist

Page 56: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 57: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

57'

Page 58: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Rough Outline

Page 59: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

First manuscript

Page 60: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 61: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Artwork

Page 62: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 63: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 64: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 65: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

65'

Page 66: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

66'

Page 67: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Different covers

67'

Page 68: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

68'

Page 69: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

10 Minutes

69'

Page 70: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

70'

Page 71: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

71'

Page 72: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

72'

Page 73: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

73'

Page 74: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

74'

Page 75: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

75'

Page 76: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

76'

Page 77: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

77'

Page 78: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

78'

Page 79: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Staff Liquidity

79'

Page 80: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

80'

Page 81: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Analysis' Design' Code' Test' Prod'

Page 82: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 83: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Analysis' Design' Code' Test' Prod'

Page 84: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Analysis' Design' Code' Test' Prod'

Page 85: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

85'

Page 86: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

86'

Page 87: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

87'

Page 88: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

88'

Page 89: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 90: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 91: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13
Page 92: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

School choice

92'

Page 93: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

©'luismi1985'

Options expire

©'givepeasachance'

Never commit

early unless

you know why

©'Tub'Gurnard'

Options have value

Page 94: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

When do we have to decide?

Yellow'+'Blue'opSon'???'

Blue'opSon'???'

Dec'Nov'

Stock'shops'

Oct'

Produce'DVD+box'

Servers'

????'March'

We'are'here!'

©'Pascal'Van'Cauwenberghe'

Page 95: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

When do we have to decide?

Yellow'+'Blue'opSon'???'

Blue'opSon'???'

Dec'Nov'

Stock'shops'

Oct'

Produce'DVD+box'

Servers'

August'March'

We'are'here!'

Design'and'test'(2M)'

©'Pascal'Van'Cauwenberghe'

Page 96: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

How will we decide?

•  IF the new blue design is completely stable •  AND if the estimate of the blue design < 2

months •  THEN we use the blue design •  ELSE we use the yellow design AND we’ll

plan the blue redesign once the blue design is stable

•  Meeting: August 1st

Page 97: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Meanwhile...

•  We develop the site in “black & white”

•  One team member participates in the followup meetings of the new design (2 hours every 2 weeks) and keeps the team informed of the situation

Page 98: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

The day is not done yet

•  A few more questions: •  Developers, what changes when the design

changes? •  Developers show architecture and code

•  What if there was less to change? •  Quick architectural “spike”: remove duplication,

separate concerns... •  How much to refactor the site? •  “We can do it in a few days” •  “Afterwards, any redesign costs less than 1 month”

Page 99: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

When do we have to decide?

Yellow'+'Blue'opSon'???'

Blue'opSon'???'

Dec'Nov'

Stock'shops'

Oct'

Produce'DVD+box'

Servers'

August'March'

We'are'here!'

Design'and'test'(2M)'

©'Pascal'Van'Cauwenberghe'

Page 100: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

When do we have to decide?

Yellow'+'Blue'opSon'???'

Blue'opSon'???'

Dec'Nov'

Stock'shops'

Oct'

Produce'DVD+box'

Servers'

Sept'March'

We'are'here!'

Design'and'test'(1M)'

©'Pascal'Van'Cauwenberghe'

Page 101: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Focus on when to make a commitment!

Page 102: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Understand'the'difference'between'commitment'and'decision'

''Do'you'need'a'rope'to'climb'back'up?''

Page 103: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Key take aways

•  Be aware of options and commitments

•  For the conference: – How does this create options for me? – How does this allow me to push conditions to

a later date in order to gather more info?

103'

Page 104: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Questions are an option

104'

Page 105: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

http://commitment-thebook.com

105'

Contact'info:'[email protected]'twiBer.com/olavmaassen'

Contact'info:'Chris$Ma4s$(Emergent$Behaviour)[email protected]'twiBer.com/papachrismaBs'

Page 106: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Conflict...

we'hide''

intent'and'

informaSon'©'Theqspeaks'

Page 107: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Collaboration...

we'signal''

intent'and'

informaSon'©'Krypto'

Page 108: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Options have value

108'©'Tracy'O'

Page 109: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Options expire

109'

Page 110: Olav Maassen: RISK AND DECISION: THE ‘WHEN’ RATHER THAN THE ‘HOW’ - LKCE13

Never commit

early unless you know

why

110'©'*L*u*z*A'