Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1...

35
05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 1 Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández (Engineer OAN) Carmen Diez (PM Herschel TTI) Rafael Garcia (Technician OAN) Juan Daniel Gallego (Engineer OAN) Alberto Barcia (Engineer OAN)

Transcript of Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1...

Page 1: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 1

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA

Isaac López-Fernández (Engineer OAN)

Carmen Diez (PM Herschel TTI)

Rafael Garcia (Technician OAN)

Juan Daniel Gallego (Engineer OAN)

Alberto Barcia (Engineer OAN)

Page 2: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 2

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

OUTLINE

• Presentation of Observatorio Astronómico Nacional

• Experience in Cryogenic Amplifiers

• Particularities of Cryogenic Amplifiers

• Devices

• HIFI Amplifiers

• Isolators

• ALMA Amplifiers

• Summary

Page 3: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 3

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

ORGANIZATION

CNIGC en tro N ac ion a l d e In fo rm ac ió n G eog rá fica

Observatorio de Madrid A lcalá de Henares Observatorio de Yebes

Observatorio Astronóm ico NacionalN ation a l A s tron om y O b serva to ry

Instituto Geográfico NacionalN ation a l G eog rap h ica l In s titu te

Ministerio de Fom entoD ep artm en t o f P u b lic W orks

Page 4: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 4

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

ORGANIZATION: AREAS

S in g le D ish V L B I

S c ien c tific

In s tru m en ta tion R /D

Tech n ica l

Observatorio Astronóm ico NacionalN ation a l A n tron om y O b serva to ry

STAFF: Technical: 10 Eng.+ 5 Tech.Scientific: 12 Astr.Admin: 7

Page 5: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 5

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

INTERNATIONAL PROJECTS

IRAMm m W R ad io A s tron om y In s titu te

EVNE u rop ean V L B I N etw ork

ALMAA tacam a L arg e M illim eter A rray

HERSCHELH eterod yn e In s tru m en t

OANO b serva to rio A s tron ó m ico N ac ion a l

Page 6: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 6

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

TECHNICAL PROJECTS (1)

• 40m Antenna: – Commissioning: 2004

– Receivers

– Holography

• HERSCHEL: – DM: finished

– QM: 2003

– FM/FS: 2003-2004

– Launch: 2007

Page 7: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 7

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

TECHNICAL PROJECTS (2)

• IRAM:– Next Generation Plateau de Bure Receivers

• ESOC:– X band Cryogenic Amplifiers for DSN receivers

Page 8: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 8

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Experience in Cryogenic Amplifiers (1)

• More than 150 cryogenic LNAs for different applications:– IRAM: Grenoble, PdB interferometer, 30m (IF amplifiers)– HERSCHEL:

• DMs for mixer groups (CALTECH, DEMIRM, IRAM, JPL, KOSMA, SRON)

• DMs Delivered (QMs, FMs, FSs in ALCATEL)– CFA: Harvard, USA, SMA

– ARECIBO (Puerto Rico)

– BORDEAUX Observatory– EMCOR (Atmospheric sensing)– PRONAOS (mm receiver in stratospheric balloon)– ESOC: DSN X band receivers– CAY: VLBI receivers (X and K band)

Page 9: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 9

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Experience in Cryogenic Amplifiers (2)

• Wide experience with HEMT devices– More than 30 batches of commercial GaAs transistors tested

– Several models of InP transistors measured• JPL-TRW (CHOP program): 15 batches, 9 models

• ETH Zurich: 8 batches, 4 models• Chalmers University: 1 batch

• HRL: 1 batch, 4 models

Page 10: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 10

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Particularities of Cryogenic Amplifiers

• Extreme range of temperatures (400 K)• Mechanical stress due to differential expansion coefficients

– Substrates– Connectors– Epoxy

• Some passive components do not work– Resistors– Capacitors

• Some semiconductors do not work (carrier freezing)– HEMTs may need illumination– LEDs– Zenner

Page 11: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 11

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Stress Relief Contacts

• An example: ‘O’ ribbon connection in the SMA tab contact:– Allows mobility in three axis– Excellent electrical properties compared with traditional SMA

connections

Page 12: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 12

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Microwave Capacitors at Cryogenic Temperature

Page 13: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 13

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Design Description (1)

Interstage matching circuits

MICROTECHDC connector

SMA connector

Bias cavity with biasing circuits

Transistor area detail.See sourceinductive feedbackand drainresistive loading

ETH transistorwith bonding wires

1 2 3

Input matching circuit Output matching circuit

Page 14: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 14

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

3 4 5 6 7 8 90

5

10

15

20

25

30

YCF 2 InP devices comparisonOptimum noise bias

ETH T-35 TRW T-45 TRW T-42

Ga

in (

dB

)

Freq. (GHz)

0.0

2.5

5.0

7.5

10.0

12.5

15.0

Tn

(K

)

ETH T-35 TRW T-45 TRW T-42

TRW T-42 CRYO3 200×0.1 μm gate Best performance

TRW T-45 CRYO4 200×0.1 μm gate Used in DMs Space qualifiable, to be used in FMs CHOP developed

ETH T-35 200×0.2 μm gate Experimental transistor Design by request Used in DMs

0.22 mm

0.19

mm Transistors

Page 15: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 15

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6004

m=65 g 58 x 32 x 15 mm

Page 16: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 16

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6004 (Noise and Gain)

3 4 5 6 7 8 90

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Noi

se T

emp

[K]

f [GHz]

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

YCF 6004V

d1=0.85 V, V

d2=0.5 V, I

d=3 mA

Gai

n [d

B]

Page 17: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 17

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6000 (Noise and Gain)

3 4 5 6 7 8 90

2

4

6

8

10

12

Tn

[K]

Freq. [GHz]

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

HERSCHEL IF1 YCF 6 DMsP

D=4 mW, T=14 K

Gai

n [d

B]

Page 18: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 18

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6000 (I/O Reflection)

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10-30

-25

-20

-15

-10

-5

0

Freq. [GHz]

S11,

S22

[dB

]

HERSCHEL IF1 YCF 6 DMsP

D=4 mW, T=14 K

Page 19: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 19

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6000 (Gain Stability)

10-2 10-1 100 10110-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

YCF 6001 Gain fluctuations Spectrum8 GHz, 14 K Vd1=0.85 V Vd2=0.5 V Id1,2=3 mA

G/G

[H

z-1

/2]

Freq. [Hz]

measured fitted correction

0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.80.00

2.50x10-5

5.00x10-5

7.50x10-5

1.00x10-4

1.25x10-4

1.50x10-4

Gain fluctuations noise floor

YCF 6001 1st stage fluctuations8 GHz, 14 K Id=3 mA

VD1

(device) [V]

G/G

@1

Hz

[1/H

z1/

2]

0.0

1.0x10-5

2.0x10-5

3.0x10-5

4.0x10-5

5.0x10-5

6.0x10-5

VG @

10 H

z [V

/Hz

1/2]

Page 20: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 20

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6000 (Results)

Page 21: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 21

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Isolators: Measurements

Page 22: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 22

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Isolators: Performance

0 2 4 6 8 10 12-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

-5

-4

-3

-2

-1

0

Isol

atio

n [d

B]

Freq. [GHz]

PAMTECH CTH 1365 K10 ISOLATORS (T=15 K)

S12 S21

Lo

sse

s [d

B]

0 2 4 6 8 10 12-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0PAMTECH CTH 1365 K10 ISOLATORS (T=15 K)

S22 S11

Ref

lect

ion

coef

f. [d

B]

Freq. [GHz]

MEASUREMENTS @ 14 K [dB] ISOLATOR MODEL

DATA TYPE S11 < S22 < S12 < S21 >

Gav mean [dB]

ΔTc mean [K]

Best of 9 -19.6 -19.0 -19.6 -0.27 -0.17 0.81

Average -18.8 -18.1 -17.4 -0.36 -0.20 1.12 CTH1365 K4

Worst of 9 -18.2 -17.3 -16.0 -0.46 -0.30 1.48

Best of 5 -18.0 -17.9 -20.7 -0.50 -0.26 1.25

Average -16.2 -15.4 -18.3 -0.58 -0.28 1.38 CTH1365 K10

Worst of 5 -15.0 -14.0 -16.5 -0.66 -0.30 1.47

Page 23: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 23

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

• Isolators measured @ 14 K (PAMTECH gives data @ 77 K)

• Good agreement between measurement and estimation of isolator noise

• Mean contribution 1.1 – 1.4 K

3 4 5 6 7 8 90

5

10

15

20

25

30

YCF 6005 (T=14 K)

Tn

(K)

Freq (GHz)

No Isolator Isolator K10 SN 101

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

G(d

B)

Isolators

ampambiso

c TTG

T

1

1

Page 24: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 24

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

ALMA YCA 1000 FEATURES

• Demonstration prototype

• 3 stages for more gain

• InP in first stage for low noise

• GaAs in 2nd and 3rd stages for easy procurement

• Smaller size and weight (no extra cavity)

• Less limitations in power dissipation

Page 25: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 25

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

ALMA YCA 1002

m=31 g 46 x 29 x 9.0 mm

Page 26: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 26

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

YCA 1002 (Noise and Gain)

3 4 5 6 7 8 90

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Noi

se T

emp

[K]

f [GHz]

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

YCA 1002V

d1=1 V, V

d2,3=2.1 V, I

d=6 mA

Gai

n [d

B]

Page 27: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 27

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

YCA 1001 (Gain Stability)

10-2 10-1 100 10110-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

YCA 1001 Gain fluctuations Spectrum8 GHz, 14 K Vd1=0.9 V Vd2,3=3 V Id1=6 mA Id2,3=5 mA

G

/G [

Hz-1

/2]

Freq. [Hz]

measured fitted correction

Page 28: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 28

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

YCA 1001 (Gain Stability)YCA 1001

(T=16 K LED OFF)

0,0E+00

2,0E-05

4,0E-05

6,0E-05

8,0E-05

1,0E-04

1,2E-04

1,4E-04

1,6E-04

1,8E-04

0,3 0,35 0,4 0,45 0,5 0,55 0,6 0,65

Vd [V]

G

/G @

1 H

z [1

/Hz1

/2]

Id=3 mA

Id=4 mA

Id=5 mA

Id=6 mA

Page 29: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 29

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

HIFI YCF 6004/ALMA YCA 1002

Amplifier HIFI

(YCF 6004) ALMA

(YCA 1002) Band 4-8 GHz 4-8 GHz Average Noise Temperature 3.6 K 3.4 K Average Gain 26.7 dB 39.2 dB Gain ripple 1.1 dB 1.1 dB Normalized Gain Fluctuation

8.6 10-5 Hz-1/2 @1 Hz 6.210-5 Hz-1/2 @1 Hz

Total power dissipation 4 mW 31 mW Dimensions 58 x 32 x 15 mm 46 x 29 x 7.5 mm Weight 65 g 31 g

Page 30: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 30

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

PA/QA (Qualification)

• Performance tests at 15K

• 25 cryogenic cycling between RT and 15K

• 5 warm cycling between RT and 80ºC

• 144 hrs. extended bake-out at 80ºC

• Vibration (sine/random) at 77K

• 25 cryogenic cycling between RT and 15K

• Performance tests at 15K

Page 31: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 31

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

PA/QA (Acceptance)

• Performance tests at 15K

• 3 cryogenic cycling between RT and 15K

• Vibration (sine/random) at RT

• Performance tests at 15K

Page 32: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 32

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Industry: ALCATEL

• Clean room for assembly

• Cryostat (property of OAN) for measurements

• Specialized in production for space (strict QA)

• Experience with HERSCHEL amplifiers

3 4 5 6 7 8 90

5

10

15

20

25

30

NFM Measurements (14 K)V

D1 = 0.85 v , V

D2 = 0.5 v , I

D = 3 mA

YCF AEO01 YCF 6006

Gai

n (d

B)

Freq. (GHz)

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

Tn

(K)

YCF AEO01 YCF 6006

Page 33: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 33

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Industry: TTI

• Bonding machine

• Experience in cryostats

• Complete receiver with S/X cryogenic amplifiers delivered to Finland

• 8.4 K @ 8.4 GHz with Fujitsu devices

(20 h k)

7 8 9 100

5

10

15

20

10

20

30

40YTX 001

Tn

(K)

F (GHz)

Noise

Gai

n (d

B)

Gain

Page 34: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 34

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Summary (1)

• ALMA 4-8 GHz based on the HIFI heritage– Prototype almost ready (correction to power dissipation)

– Isolator available (PAMTECH)

– IRAM (Band 7): 8 units June 2003

– SRON (Band 9): 2 units June 2003

• ALMA 4-12 GHz – Development not started yet

– Prototype Isolator available (PAMTECH)

– 2 Amplifiers needed by December 2003

Page 35: Observatorio Astronómico Nacional Instituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA CAY 05/03/2003IGN (Madrid)1 Development of IF Amplifiers for ALMA Isaac López-Fernández.

05/03/2003 IGN (Madrid) 35

Observatorio Astronómico NacionalInstituto Geográfico Nacional ALMA

CAY

Summary (2)

• PROBLEMS TO SOLVE:

– Procurement of InP devices (Help from ESO needed)• TRW, ETH, HRL ?

– Resources for construction:• More personal needed! (2 Technicians + 1 Eng.)

• Increase efficiency of tests (new test station needed in 2003)

• Decision of construction in OAN or subcontractor

• Cost