NZEB at CEPT University: A Living...

46
Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8 th December 2017, Mumbai NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory Yash Shukla Centre for Advanced Research in Building Science and Energy, CEPT University, Ahmedabad Adaptive Comfort and Retro commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8 th December 2017, Mumbai

Transcript of NZEB at CEPT University: A Living...

Page 1: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory

Yash Shukla Centre for Advanced Research in Building Science and Energy,

CEPT University, Ahmedabad

Adaptive Comfort and Retro commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Page 2: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

What is a Net Zero Energy Building?

Building Size Energy Efficiency

On Site Renewable Energy Renewable Energy Credits

Consumption Generation

Page 3: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

N

CEPT University Campus Site

Page 4: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Motivation for NZEB

Application of Theories Example that can be replicated Living Laboratory Source of new knowledge

Page 5: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Performance with Life cycle Analysis Approach

Design

Construction

Operation

Page 6: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

How to Design for Building Energy Efficiency Design as per Adaptive Thermal Comfort Model

How to Construct for Building Energy Efficiency Construct to increase comfort hours and increase

efficiency of building mechanical system

How to Operate for Building Energy Efficiency Operate to reduce energy consumption

Building Performance with Life cycle Analysis Approach

Page 7: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Iterative Design Process

Predesign

Conceptual Design

System Development

Systems Optimization

Three in-person charrettes in Ahmedabad Over 20 virtual meetings and presentations

Page 8: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Predesign Goals

Pre-design energy simulations of a benchmark building

Investigated 80 energy conservation measures (ECMs) in the Ahmedabad climate

KWh/m2

58

237

0 50 100 150 200 250

Benchmark

Bundle 4

Heat Cool Fan/ Pump DHW Lights Equip

Page 9: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Massing Analysis

N

Option 1

Option 2

Option 4

Option 5

Page 10: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Sizing of Lightshelves

Sizing of North Windows

Sizing of South Vision Windows

Interior wall finishes

Sizing Basement Light Monitor

Sizing of Basement Courtyard Windows

Daylighting Analysis Areas Sunshading, Illuminance, Luminance, Daylighting Autonomy, UDI

Page 11: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Adaptive Thermal Comfort

ASHRAE 55 Comfort Band Performance per space type using typical CEPT building standards

Page 12: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Passive Cooling Potential Assess Thermal Comfort and Natural Ventilation with CFD Model

Feb Evening

Jan Morning Month Morning Afternoon Evening

JanWindows

ClosedWindows

OpenWindows

Open

FebWindows

ClosedWindows

OpenWindows

Open

MarWindows

OpenNo No

Apr No No No

May No No No

Jun No No No

Jul No No No

Aug No No No

OctWindows

OpenNo No

NovWindows

OpenNo

Windows Open

DecWindows

ClosedWindows

OpenWindows

Open

Page 13: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Schematic Design and Operational Strategies

07/05/2017 13

Hot Outdoor Environment Comfortable Outdoor Environment

Page 14: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

HVAC Systems

Primary and secondary cooling systems

Radiant System Dedicated outdoor air system VRF / VRV

Chilled water plant

Variable speed Inverter chiller

Page 15: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

HVAC Systems

Page 16: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

HVAC Systems

Page 17: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Integrated PV

Page 18: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

BIM System Integration

Page 19: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Savings by Measure Type

44%

16%

10%

9%

6%

7%

5%3%

Integrated Passive andActive CoolingDaylighting Controls

Vacancy Sensor of Lights

Insulated Walls and Roof

Task Ambient LightingSystemHVAC Controls

Plug Load Controls

Optimized Window Glazing

Page 20: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building External Views

Page 21: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Internal Views

Page 22: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

“Every line is the perfect length if you don't measure it” -Marty Rubin

Page 23: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Information Systems • Thermal Comfort, Temp – Humidity • Visual Comfort, Light • Occupancy • Outdoor conditions • Equipment usage

Building Management Systems • Energy Management

• Energy used to maintain comfort • Energy used for equipment

Monitoring and Control - NZEB

Page 24: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Monitoring and control system

Envelope

Environment

Energy

Behavior

Chiller

HVAC

VFD

Photovoltaic

Outdoor

HVAC

Lighting

Plug Loads

Photovoltaic

Operation

Comfort

Consumption

Generation

Historical Operation

Display Controls Integration Monitoring

Page 25: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Details of Monitoring, Integration and Controls Philosophy

VRF

Energy Meters

Chillers

VRV Units

Digital Scrolls

Envelope

Communic

ation Gateway

Photovoltaic

Lighting

Radiant

Chilled Plant

DOAS

Sensors

and Controllers

Guarded Hot Box

Comfort Chamber

Fans

Monitoring and Integration Controls Hardware

Building Control System

Page 26: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Energy Monitoring System

Page 27: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Building Energy Monitoring System

Page 28: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Environment and Energy

Page 29: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Environment and Energy

Page 30: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Thermal Comfort Surveys and Occupant Feedback

How do you describe your current thermal sensation?

Page 31: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Are you comfortable?

Thermal Comfort Surveys and Occupant Feedback

Page 32: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Energy Consumption Summary

-6000

-5000

-4000

-3000

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 Nov-16 Dec-16

Mon

thly

(kW

h)

Monthly Consumption and Generation

Energy Consumption Energy Generation

Page 33: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

End Use Energy Consumption

Page 34: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Comparison with Design Goals

Page 35: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

“Buying the right computer and getting it to work properly is no more complicated than building a nuclear reactor from wristwatch parts in a darkened room using only your teeth” - Dave Barry

Do we have all ingredients to build NZEBs in

India?

Page 36: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Thermal Conductivity

Thermal Diffusivity

Specific heat

Thermal Characterization

Page 37: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Guarded Hot Box

Non-homogenous Materials

ASTM C 1363 ISO 12567

Thermal Characterization : Wall

Page 38: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Solar Reflectance

Solar Transmittance

ASTM / ISO / EN

Optical Property Characterization

Page 39: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Solar Calorimeter Air leakage Chamber NFRC & ASTM

Fenestration Characterization

Page 40: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Construction Database

40

Indian Materials

Glazing Systems

ISO / ASTM

Presenter
Presentation Notes
(1) Objective (2) Methodology Adopted (3) Present Status (4) Key outcome (5) Major challenges
Page 41: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

U-factor Calculator

41

Presenter
Presentation Notes
(1) Objective (2) Methodology Adopted (3) Present Status (4) Key outcome (5) Major challenges
Page 42: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Sorption Isotherm

Vapor Transmission

Water uptake

Hygrothermal Characterization

Page 43: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

SPSS and Mirror Box

Daylight Simulation Mirror Box

Cloudy Sky Simulation

Single Patch Sky Simulator Clear Sky Simulation

Page 44: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Ahmadabad

Bangalore

Primary City Ahmadabad Bangalore Mumbai Delhi

Secondary City Ahmadabad Bangalore Mumbai Delhi

Climate Comparison

Page 45: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

NZEB Partners

Antech Consultants Clanton & Associates Deep Electricals Gujarat Energy Development Agency, Govt of Gujarat Infinity Technologies Owens Corning Pankaj Dharkar Associates Pidilite Industries

SGL Carbon Shashwat Cleantech The Weidt Group Tripur Builders US Agency for International Development ECOIII Project VMS Consultants Volpak Systems Yogi Engineers

Page 46: NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratorycarbse.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NZEB-at-CEPT... · NZEB at CEPT University: A Living Laboratory . Yash Shukla . Centre for Advanced

Adaptive Comfort and Retro Commissioning EDGE 2017, ASHRAE Region-at-large, Sub region II, 8th December 2017, Mumbai

Thank You

[email protected]