Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and...

59
Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum

Transcript of Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and...

Page 1: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Nyquist barrier - not for all!

Jaan Pelt

Tartu Observatory

Monday, 7. October 2013

Information and computer science forum

Page 2: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Peep Kalv looking through astrophotographic plate (1964-65).

Page 3: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

http://www.aai.ee/~pelt/

Ilkka Tuominen

Page 4: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Gravitational lenses

Rudy Schild and Sjur Refsdalin wild Estonia

Page 5: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Four views

• Time (AR, ARMA, etc)

• Frequency (Power spectrum)

• Time-Frequency (Wavelets, Wigner TF etc)

• Phase dispersion

Page 6: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Phase-process diagram (folding)

Page 7: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Live demo

Page 8: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Weights G are larger than zero when phases of two points in pairare similar, or:

G=0

G=1

Page 9: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

How to compute?

Page 10: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Multiperiodic processes

Page 11: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

An example

???

Page 12: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Why?

Page 13: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.
Page 14: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Carrier fitCarrier frequency

Splines

Function with sparse spectra.

Page 15: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.
Page 16: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.
Page 17: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.
Page 18: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Harry Nyquist

Page 19: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Comb function and its Fourier transform

Page 20: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Fourier transform

Page 21: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Sampling

Page 22: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Spectrum replication

Page 23: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Reconstruction

Page 24: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Aliasing

Page 25: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Simple harmonic, regular sampling

Page 26: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Simple harmonic, irregular sampling

Page 27: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Frequency to the right from Nyquist limit

Page 28: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Here it is !

Page 29: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

From “Numerical Recipes”

Page 30: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

They tell us…

Page 31: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Many possibilities

• Some intervals are shorter (as Press et al).

• Mean sampling step is to be computed.

• Statistical argument, from N data points you can not get more than N/2 spectrum points.

• Every time point set is a subset of some regular grid.

Page 32: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Phases

Arbitrary trial period (frequency) Correct period (frequency)

Observed magnitudes

Phases

s – frequency, P=1/s - period

Page 33: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Old story

Page 34: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Typical “string length spectrum”

Page 35: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Horse racing argument

For “string length” method maximal return time is N! – number of permutations (N is number of data points).

For other methods return time scales as NN.

This comes from Poincare return theory.

Page 36: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Noiseless case, simple power spectrum.

Page 37: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

10% noise

Page 38: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

25% noise

Page 39: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Comments

Page 40: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

More comments

Page 41: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Left from Nyquist limit

Bandlimited process

Page 43: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Ohhh…, no….

Page 44: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.
Page 45: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

But still?

Derivatives of bandlimited functions are also bandlimited! Look at red dots! Zeros are maxima and minima after differentiation.

Page 46: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

First hints

Page 47: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Aharonov again

Page 48: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Berry is more explicit

Page 49: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Abstract

Page 50: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Kempf is the best seller!

Page 51: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Another example

Page 52: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Spectrum of it, no hint of SO-s

Page 53: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Research programme?

1. Super-resolution using super-oscillations. Already done – using nanohole patterns

Page 54: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Antenna beamforming

Page 55: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

But sparse and random array?

Page 56: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Transplanckian frequencies

Page 57: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Superoscillating particles

Page 58: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

And finally…

Where are the super-oscillations here?

Page 59: Nyquist barrier - not for all! Jaan Pelt Tartu Observatory Monday, 7. October 2013 Information and computer science forum.

Gateway to superoscillations:

PROFESSOR SIR MICHAEL VICTOR BERRY, FRS

http://michaelberryphysics.wordpress.com/