NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

33
1 For immediate release: For more information: Friday, April 19, 2013 Bill Mahoney (518) 817-3738 Albany’s “Pay-to-Play” Culture An Examination of Central New York Legislators in 2012 Ten state legislators whose current districts include part of Onondaga and Cayuga Counties were incumbents that ran for re-election last year. All but one of these (Assemblyman Don Miller) succeeded. This report examines their fundraising in calendar year 2012, and reveals that like most legislators, those from Central New York relied heavily on funding from lobbyists and interest groups. This finding is not surprising. New York’s current campaign finance system disadvantages candidates who are unwilling to raise funds from the traditional class of potential donors that are able and willing to give thousands of dollars. All too often, this traditional class of contributors has some sort of business before the state. 70% of the donations CNY incumbents raised from businesses, unions, or other incorporated entities came from registered lobbyists or lobby clients. The ten local legislators who ran for state office raised a total of $1,122,627.47 from all incorporated entities in 2012. $65,442.10 of this money came directly from lobby firms, and $719,380.11 came from these firms’ clients. This money from special interest groups and their lobbyists was more than double the amount coming from flesh-and-blood human beings ($359,896.27), and accounted for 52.9% of all itemized donations (not including transfers).

description

NYPIRG examined 2012 campaign donations to Central New York legislators

Transcript of NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

Page 1: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

1

For immediate release: For more information:

Friday, April 19, 2013 Bill Mahoney (518) 817-3738

Albany’s “Pay-to-Play” Culture

An Examination of Central New York Legislators in 2012

Ten state legislators whose current districts include part of Onondaga and Cayuga Counties were

incumbents that ran for re-election last year. All but one of these (Assemblyman Don Miller) succeeded.

This report examines their fundraising in calendar year 2012, and reveals that like most legislators, those

from Central New York relied heavily on funding from lobbyists and interest groups.

This finding is not surprising. New York’s current campaign finance system disadvantages candidates

who are unwilling to raise funds from the traditional class of potential donors that are able and willing to

give thousands of dollars. All too often, this traditional class of contributors has some sort of business

before the state.

70% of the donations CNY incumbents raised from businesses, unions, or other incorporated entities

came from registered lobbyists or lobby clients.

The ten local legislators who ran for state office raised a total of $1,122,627.47 from all incorporated

entities in 2012. $65,442.10 of this money came directly from lobby firms, and $719,380.11 came from

these firms’ clients. This money from special interest groups and their lobbyists was more than double

the amount coming from flesh-and-blood human beings ($359,896.27), and accounted for 52.9% of all

itemized donations (not including transfers).

Page 2: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

2

Client Lobby Firms Lobby Clients

Other Businesses, Unions, and NFPs Individuals

Transfers, Interest, Unitemized

% of all Donations from Lobbyists/ Clients

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO/ DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE $25,992.10 $180,345.00 $55,175.00 $57,659.00 $425.00 64.65%

COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS $38,485.71 $8,150.00 $12,472.00 $4,100.81 65.11%

FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY $1,350.00 $15,775.00 $18,167.46 $20,950.00 $1,190.00 30.45%

FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS $2,100.00 $16,938.00 $14,256.00 $12,680.00 41.41%

FRIENDS OF DON MILLER $12,421.00 $15,511.80 $52,963.34 $2,834.00 15.35%

FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD $11,450.00 $155,334.00 $95,829.00 $60,387.00 $3,250.00 51.64%

FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA $7,400.00 $44,400.00 $11,400.00 $34,660.00 $3,150.00 52.93%

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE $8,750.00 $111,431.40 $84,474.00 $57,436.00 $522.00 45.85%

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI $2,100.00 $36,350.00 $10,350.00 $21,625.00 $919.00 54.60%

VALESKY FOR SENATE $6,300.00 $107,900.00 $24,492.00 $29,063.93 $16,832.00 68.08%

Total $65,442.10 $719,380.11 $337,805.26 $359,896.27 $33,222.81 52.94%

Donations from individual people were not analyzed as part of this report, but it is likely that these

donations similarly came overwhelmingly from those with business before state government. The top

donors to these Central New York legislators include people such as former United States Senator and

current lobbyist Alfonse D’Amato ($2,000 to Senator DeFrancisco), Red Apple founder and New York

City mayoral candidate John Catsimatidis ($1,000 to Senator DeFrancisco), and Destiny USA developer

Robert Congel ($3,200 to Assemblyman Magnarelli, $500 to Senator Valesky, $250 to Senator

DeFrancisco).

Many of the businesses that did not identify as lobby clients nevertheless had business before the state.

Some spent less than the minimum $5,000 needed to register as a lobby client, and the interests of

others (particularly liquor stores and banks), were likely members of trade associations that lobbied on

their behalves.

Appendices A & B (beginning on pages 8 and 11) list the donations from lobbyists and lobby clients.

Page 3: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

3

Political parties

Donations made directly to candidates are not the only sources of spending on campaigns. As the

Syracuse Post-Standard reported last October, party committees pumped huge amounts of money into

the Stirpe-Miller race.1 Notably, this was the only race in which an incumbent was defeated. An

important reality of New York’s campaign finance system is that many incumbents can raise massive war

chests from interests with business before the state, and use their coffers to scare away potential

challengers. Political parties and leadership committees, however, can raise unlimited funds from

donors. As illustrated by the Stirpe-Miller race, these funds play a key role in most of the competitive

elections in the Legislature.

Bills and resolutions introduced by these legislators

When Assemblyman Stevenson was arrested earlier this month, most observers were outraged by his

alleged behavior. An elected official who introduces bills when paid by an affected party violates every

principle of effective and functional representative government. Unfortunately, a completely legal

system that mirrors the alleged bribery of Assemblyman Stevenson exists in Albany. Much of the state’s

business is occurs in an environment suffused with donations from lobby firms and the interest groups

they represent.

Each of the Central New York legislators examined above introduced legislation that would have a

significant effect on at least one of their campaign donors. Most of these organizations reported

lobbying on these bills and resolutions (though lobby reports do not require filers to identify whether

they supported or opposed legislation); some were mentioned by name in the text or sponsors’ memos.

We are not implying that there is a cause and effect relationship between campaign donations and

legislative or other government action. Of course, many of these legislators have spent decades

advocating positions similar to those embodied in these bills. It is likely that most would have

introduced similar legislation without receiving campaign donations. Further, many of the donors listed

may have ignored or even opposed the bills. However, this list once again shows that much of the

money raised by legislators in Albany comes from organizations with a vested interest in the activities of

the state Legislature.

The following list shows two examples of bills introduced by these legislators that significantly effected

organizations that gave them campaign donations.

1 http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2012/10/albany_politicians_contributor.html

Page 4: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

4

J3853

VALESKY -- Commemorating the 115th

Anniversary of The International Brotherhood of

Electrical Workers Local 43

9/17/2012 IBEW LOCAL 43 $1,850.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/12/2012 LOCAL UNION 43 IBEW $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/20/2012 LOCAL UNION 43 IBEW $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/15/2012 IBEW LOCAL 43 $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/17/2012 IBEW LOCAL 43 $250.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

S654

VALESKY -- Permits persons eleven years of

age to possess a rifle under certain

circumstances

10/10/2012 SMITH & WESSON $1,000.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

4/1/2012 NATIONAL SHOOTING SPORTS FOUNDATION, INC. $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/22/2012 NYS RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION PVF $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

S655

VALESKY -- Relates to rates charged volunteer

fire companies and volunteer ambulance

companies

2/6/2012 UNIFORMED FIRE OFFICERS ASSOC. FIRE DEPT. OF NY LO $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

S7655

VALESKY -- Relates to reimbursement for hip

and knee replacement cases at certain hospitals

1/7/2012 GREATER NEW YORK HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION $10,300.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 UHAP PAC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/10/2012 UHAP PAC $350.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/13/2012 UHAP PAC $250.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/26/2012 UHAP PAC $150.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

S6965

VALESKY -- Directs the commissioner of

agriculture and markets to establish a Dine:

Pride of New York program for restaurants

which use ingredients produced in New York

state

2/21/2012 NYS RETAILERS FOR EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT PAC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 U.R.H.T. ASSOCIATION OF NEW YORK STATEWIDE PAC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

S6505

VALESKY -- Creates the strategic farm and

food product development coordinating council

2/6/2012 NEW YORK FARM BUREAU, INC. $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

S3775

VALESKY -- Extends provisions of law

relating to the enriched social adult day

demonstration program

7/18/2012 EMPIRE STATE ASSOC. OF ADULT HOMES, INC PAC $150.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 EMPIRE STATE ASSOCIATION OF ADULT HOMES $1,000.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

Page 5: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

5

PAC

S5078

VALESKY -- Authorizes the liquor authority to

issue farm brewery licenses for the manufacture

and sale of beer on farms

4/10/2012 NYS BEER WHOLESALERS ASSOC., INC. PAC $2,000.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

J3091

DEFRANCISCO -- Commending President and

Chief Executive Officer Julie A. Shimer, Ph. D.,

upon the occasion of her retirement from Welch

Allyn

3/16/2012 WELCH ALLYN $250.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

J3092

DEFRANCISCO -- Commemorating the 50th

Anniversary of Westcott Florist

9/12/2012 WESTCOTT FLORIST, INC. $200.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

S4731

DEFRANCISCO -- Provides for the

registration of professional nurse anesthetist

1/19/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGIST PAC $2,000.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/20/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGIST PAC $2,000.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/30/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PAC $3,000.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

9/12/2012 NURSE ANESTHESIA CRNA PAC FUND $500.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

S4749

DEFRANCISCO -- Relates to the collection of

prescription drug co-payments

8/23/2012 ABBOTT LABORATORIES $500.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/4/2012 BAYER HEALTH CARE LLC $250.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 CAREMARK RX INC $500.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/16/2012 PFIZER PAC $500.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/16/2012 PFIZER PAC $500.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

8/2/2012 ASTRAZENECA $1,000.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/16/2012 MERCK NYS PAC $1,000.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

11/7/2012 ELI LILLY & CO. PAC $500.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/9/2012 ELI LILLY & COMPAY PAC $500.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/16/2012 MERCK NYS PAC $1,000.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

Page 6: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

6

4/11/2012 NOVARTIS PHARMACUTICALS CORP. $300.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 PHARMACY PAC OF NYS $1,000.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

9/6/2012 HEALTHDIRECTOR INST. PHARMACY SERVICES $900.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

S2541

DEFRANCISCO -- Repeals section 474-a of

the judiciary law relating to contingent fees for

attorneys in claims or actions for medical, dental

or podiatric malpractice

3/23/2012 ACADEMY OF TRIAL LAWYERS PAC $1,000.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 ACADEMY OF TRIAL LAWYERS PAC $500.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/11/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

11/15/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,300.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000.00

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

2/1/2012 PHYSICIANS' RECIPROCAL INSURERES $3,000.00

CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

A3963A

Magnarelli (MS) -- Establishes standards and

programs relating to the prevention and/or

reduction of the incidence of hospital-acquired

infections

2/13/2012 UHAP PAC $500.00

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

A8865

Magnarelli -- Authorizes the appointment of

supervising staff in the city school district of the

city of Syracuse by the superintendent of such

district

2/17/2012 VOTE/COPE $500.00

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/19/2012 EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP PAC $500.00

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

A6129

Magnarelli (MS) -- Facilitates enrollment in the

child health insurance plan

8/14/2012 AETNA, INC. POLITCAL ACTION COMMITTEE $1,000.00

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/24/2012 HANYS PAC $600.00

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/13/2012 HANYS PAC $500.00

PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

A10469

Miller D -- Dedicates certain funds for fish and

wildlife purposes

A8587 Miller D -- Exempts veterans from hunting and

Page 7: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

7

gun licensing fees and allows veterans to keep

their combat weapons

10/22/2012 NY STATE RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION $250.00 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

A9208

Roberts (MS) -- Relates to the use of eminent

domain

10/9/2012 CSE POLITICAL ACTION FUND $4,100.00

COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

A9451C

Roberts (MS) -- Relates to assumed

amortization for school projects

4/19/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $1,250.00

COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/2/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $1,000.00

COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/22/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $855.00

COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/30/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $495.00

COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

A5293

Oaks (MS) -- Provides that the owner of 3 or

more trucks used exclusively for business

purposes shall be permitted to stagger the

registration renewal dates

6/30/2012 LEONARD'S EXPRESS $250.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

A5291

Oaks (MS) -- Exempts certain youths program

volunteers from civil liability

7/7/2012 LAW PAC OF NY $2,100.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

1/12/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

A3675

Finch (MS) -- Makes provisions relating to

establishing a dairy farmers' bill of rights

8/16/2012 OAKWOOD DAIRY, LLC $100.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

A7438

Finch (MS) -- Establishes distinctive "New

York funeral director" license plates

10/15/2012 NYSFDA - PAC $500.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

2/28/2012 NYSFDA-PAC $1,000.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/27/2012 NYSFDA-PAC $1,000.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

6/11/2012 PLIS FUNERAL HOME INC $100.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/21/2012 SCI FUNERAL & CEM PURCHASING C $2,500.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/28/2012 CHECHE FUNERAL HOME $100.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/21/2012 DORAN-KELLY FUNERAL HOME, INC $250.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/3/2012 HEIECK - PELC FUNERAL HOME LLC $100.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

9/6/2012 NICPON FUNERAL HOME $100.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

S4793

O'MARA -- Establishes the New York state indigenous natural gas value added task force

3/7/2012 FRIENDS OF NATURAL GAS PAC INC $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

S5358

O'MARA -- Establishes the wine industry and liquor store development act; repealers

3/7/2012 EMPIRE MERCHANTS NORTH LLC $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

Page 8: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

8

S5805A

NOZZOLIO -- Relates to video gaming

machines and disposition of revenues

9/27/2012 GENTING NEW YORK LLC $1,000.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/29/2012 VOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON POLITICAL EDUCATION OF THE $1,000.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/9/2012 VPOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON POLITICAL EDUCATION OF THE $1,500.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

6/27/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION $1,750.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/1/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION $1,500.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

S4917

NOZZOLIO -- Requires the commissioner of

correctional services to consult with the chief

executive officer of the locality where a prison

scheduled to be closed is located

7/18/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $4,800.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $2,500.00

MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

Appendix A: 2012 donations directly from lobby firms and their PACs

Date Donor Amount Candidate Committee

2/2/2012 BMWPAC $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/24/2012 BOLTON ST. JOHNS LLC $500.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $900.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/6/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $500.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/3/2012 DAVIDOFF MALITO & HUTCHER LLP $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 FEATHERSTONHAUGH, WILEY & CLYNE LLP $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 GOTHAM GOV'T RELATIONS LLC $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/16/2012 HARTER SECREST & EMERY LLP $500.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 HARTER SECREST 7 EMERY LLP $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 MALKIN & ROSS PAC $250.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

5/10/2012 MANATT, PHELPS & PHILLIPS, LLP $500.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 MPAC $500.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 STATE & BROADWAY PAC $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

Page 9: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

9

2/2/2012 STATE STREET ASSOCIATES PAC $1,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/25/2012 WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITIZ EDELMAN & DICKER LLP $2,000.00 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/19/2012 BOLT-PAC $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 FEATHERSTONHAUGH, WILEY & CLYNE LLP $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 GOTHAM GOV'T RELATIONS LLC $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 GREENBERG TRAURIG PAC $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/13/2012 HINMAN STRAUB PC $190.50 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 MICHAEL R. HOUSEKNECHT LLC $250.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/1/2012 ONE ELEVEN PAC $2,800.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES LLC $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/23/2012 STATE & BROADWAY INC. $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/23/2012 STATE STREET ASSOCIATES PAC $2,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/23/2012 WHITEMAN OSTERMAN & HANNA LLP $1,000.00 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/1/2012 WHITEMAN OSTERMAN & HANNA LLP $101.60 DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

2/29/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $300.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/2/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $250.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

7/31/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING, PLLC $500.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

9/27/2012 HARTER SECRET & EMERY LLP $300.00 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

3/24/2012 BOND SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $300.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

4/12/2012 HARTER SECREST & EMERY LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NORTHEAST GOVERNMENT CONSULTING $500.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

4/12/2012 STATE STREET ASSOCIATES PAC $300.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 WILSON ELSER PAC $500.00 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

2/21/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK, AND KING LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK, AND KING LLP $200.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/19/2012 CASALE PUBLIC AFFAIRS $350.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

11/6/2012 DAVIDOFF, HUTCHER & CITRON, LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 GREENBERG TRAURIG PAC $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 GREENBERG TRAURIG PAC $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/16/2012 MANATT, PHELPS & PHILLIPS $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 MCKENNA LONG & ALDRIDGE $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/1/2012 PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES, LLC $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/14/2012 STATE STREET ASSOCIATES PAC $2,000.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 TONIO BURGOS & ASSOC. OF NJ $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 TONIO BURGOS & ASSOC. OF NJ $200.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

Page 10: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

10

7/3/2012 WEINGARTEN, REID & MCNALLY $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/29/2012 WHITEMAN,OSTERHOUT & HANNA $500.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 WILSON,ELSER,MOSKOWITZ,EDELMAN, AND DICKER LLP PAC $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/24/2012 WLADIS LAW FIRM $200.00 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/27/2012 BOND,SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

6/29/2012 BOND,SCHOENICK & KING PPLC $250.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

4/2/2012 DAVIDOFF MALITO & HUTCHER LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 FEATHERSTONHAUGH, WILEY & CLYNE, LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

6/29/2012 HISCOCK BARCLAY LLP $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/9/2012 HISCOCK & BARCLAY, LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/3/2012 HODGSON RUSS LLP $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/7/2012 HODGSON RUSS LLP $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/16/2012 STATE STREET ASSOCIATES PAC $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/18/2012 THE RUTNIK LAW FIRM $150.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/12/2012 WEINGARTEN,REID & MCNALLY PAC $500.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/21/2012 WILSON,ELSER,MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER LLP $1,000.00 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/6/2012 BOLTON ST. JOHNS $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 BOLT-PAC $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/24/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING PLLC $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/15/2012 DAVIDOFF HUTCHER & CITRON LLP $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/27/2012 DAVIDOFF MALITO & HUTCHER LLP $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/27/2012 FEATHERSTONHAUGH, WILEY & CLYNE $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/3/2012 GOTHAM GOVERNMENT RELATIONS $250.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/6/2012 HARTER SECREST & EMERY, LLP $500.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/14/2012 NORTHEAST GOVERNMENT CONSULTING $500.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 PLUMMER ASSOCIATES, LLC $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/7/2012 STATE STREET ASSOCIATES PAC $1,500.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/16/2012 WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWTIZ PAC $750.00 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

1/25/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING, PLLC $500.00 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

6/26/2012 CAPITOL PUBLIC STRATEGIES, LLC $100.00 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/9/2012 THE RIDDELL GROUP, LLC $500.00 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/12/2012 WHITEMAN OSTERMAN & HANNA LLP $500.00 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/10/2012 WILSON, ESLER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER LLP $500.00 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

1/9/2012 BMWPAC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 BOND, SCHOENECK & KING, PLLC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/30/2012 BOND, SHOENECK & KING PLLC $350.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 C&C LLC PAC ACCOUNT $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

Page 11: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

11

2/6/2012 CAPITAL STRATEGIES, LLC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/28/2012 DAVIDOFF MALITO & HUTCHER LLP $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 FEATHERSTONHAUGH, WILEY & CLYNE, LLP $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/27/2012 GOTHAM GOVERNMENT RELATIONS LLC $250.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/14/2012 GREENBERG TRAURIG P.A. POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE $200.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 MANATT, PHELPS & PHILLIPS, LLP $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES, LLC $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/28/2012 WHITEMAN OSTERMAN & HANNA LLP $500.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER LLP PAC $1,000.00 VALESKY FOR SENATE

Appendix B: 2012 donations from lobby clients

Date Donor Amount Candidate Committee

2/14/2012 A T & T PAC OF NY $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

8/23/2012 ABBOTT LABORATORIES $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/23/2012 ACADEMY OF TRIAL LAWYERS PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 ACADEMY OF TRIAL LAWYERS PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/6/2012 ADJUSTERS INTERNATIONAL $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/6/2012 AMERICAN FOOD & VENDING ENTERPRISES INC. $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/24/2012 AMERICAN FOOD & VENDING ENTERPRISES INC. $100 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

5/10/2012 AMERICAN INS. ASSOC. PAC OF NYS $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 ANHEUSER-BUSCH SALES OF HAWAII, INC. $3,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS OF NYS PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/20/2012 ATU NEW YORK COPE FUND $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/4/2012 BAYER HEALTH CARE LLC $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/20/2012 BUSINESS-INDUSTRY PAC OF CNY $300 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/6/2012 BUSINESS-INDUSTRY PAC OF CNY $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/6/2012 C.A.R.E. COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 CAREMARK RX INC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/19/2012 CHESAPEAKE OPERATING, INC. $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/13/2012 CITIGROUP INC. PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

Page 12: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

12

1/25/2012 CONSOLIDATED EDUCATION INC. PAC $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/7/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $295 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/11/2012 COVANTA ENERGY CORP. $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

8/15/2012 DELOITTE SERVICES LP $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/25/2012 DISTRICT COUNCIL 37 PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 DISTRICT TEN I.A.T..S.E. $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/3/2012 EMPIRE HEALTH PAC $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/10/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/20/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

8/23/2012 EMPIRE STATE SUBCONTRACTORS ASSOC. INC. $450 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/3/2012 HANSY PAC $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

5/29/2012 HCA PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/6/2012 HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

5/18/2012 HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 HPA PAC $1,350 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $3,500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/6/2012 IUOE LOCAL 158 VPAF STATE & LOCAL $1,800 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/19/2012 J.Y. TRANS PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/18/2012 JOHNSON & JOHNSON CORP. POL. FUND $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/14/2012 JPMORGAN CHASE & CO, PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 KINNEY DRUGS $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/6/2012 KINNEY DRUGS INC. $900 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/4/2012 KPMG LLP $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 LAFARGE MID-ATHLANTIC LLC $2,500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/11/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/6/2012 LIFE INS. COUNCIL OF NY PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/6/2012 LOCAL 376 AFSCME PAC $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/26/2012 LOCAL 700, I.A.T.S.E. $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

5/18/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NY $2,500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/30/2012 MEDTRONIC INC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

8/6/2012 NAIFA-NYS PAC $200 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/31/2012 NATIONWIDE NEW YORK POL. PART. FUND $750 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 NURSE ANESTHESIA CRNA PAC FUND $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/26/2012 NY ALFA PAC $300 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/19/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGIST PAC $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/20/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGIST PAC $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/14/2012 NY BANKERS PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 NY BANKERS PAC STATE FUND $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

8/23/2012 NY CCE NON PARTISAN PAC FOR GOOD GOV'T $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

Page 13: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

13

5/18/2012 NY CCE NON PARTISAN PAC FOR GOOD GOV'T $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/20/2012 NYCAMP $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/10/2012 NYS AFL-CIO COPE ACCT. $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/25/2012 NYS BAR ASSOC. SPECIAL ACCT $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 NYS COURT CLERKS ASSOCIATION $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/14/2012 NYS INDEPENDENT BANKERS PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/25/2012 NYS PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS CIVIL INVOLVEMENT $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/26/2012 NYS RESTAURANT ASSOC. $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/16/2012 NYS RESTAURANT ASSOC. PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/6/2012 NYSAASC PAC $750 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/6/2012 NYSNA PAC $750 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/25/2012 NYSPIA POLITICAL COMM. $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 O'BRIEN & GERE LIMITED INC $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/16/2012 PFIZER PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/16/2012 PFIZER PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

11/8/2012 PHILIP MORRIS USA INC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 PHYSICIANS' RECIPROCAL INSURERES $3,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 PITNEY BOWES INC NY PAC $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 POST NY ALLIANCE PAC FUND $2,500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

5/10/2012 PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

11/8/2012 PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FEDERATION $10,300 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/14/2012 REAL ESTATE BOARD PAC $2,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/6/2012 RPAC OF NYS $5,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/3/2012 RPAC OF NYS $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/2/2012 SUB-CONTRACTORS TRADE ASSN. INC. STATE PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/11/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $1,800 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 TAP-PAC ASSOC. OF PROPRIETARY COLLEGES $500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCAL UNION 817 $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

1/25/2012 THE ASSOC. OF SURROGATES 7 SUPREME COURT REPORTERS $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/31/2012 THE HARTFORD ADVOCATES FUND $1,500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NY PAC $800 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

2/1/2012 U.R.H.T. ASSOC. OF NY STATEWIDE PAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 UHAP PAC $450 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

4/16/2012 UNIFORMED FIREFIGHTERS ASSN. FIREPAC $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

9/12/2012 UNITED NY AMBULANCE NETWORK PAC $3,500 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

3/16/2012 WELCH ALLYN $250 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

10/18/2012 WELLS FARGO & CO. NY EMP. GOOD GOV'T $1,000 CITIZENS FOR DEFRANCISCO

Page 14: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

14

FUND

10/22/2012 1199 SEIU-NYS PAC $4,100 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

8/9/2012 AFSCME PAC $4,100 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

2/13/2012 AMERICAN FOOD & VENDING $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/9/2012 CSE POLITICAL ACTION FUND $4,100 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

9/26/2012 CWA DISTRICT ONE PAC $300 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 DISTRICT COUNCIL #4 PAINTERS LOCAL #31 $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

11/7/2012 DRIVE COMMITTEE $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 IRON WORKERS LOCAL #60 $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

11/7/2012 IUOE LOCAL 159 VPAF STATE & LOCAL $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/23/2012 IUOE LOCAL VPAF STATE & LOCAL $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

11/7/2012 LAW PAC OF NEW YORK $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 LOCAL UNION 43, IBEW $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

11/7/2012 LOCAL UNION 43, IBEW $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/10/2012 NORTHEASTERN PAC $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/23/2012 NY/NJ AMERICAN DREAM PAC $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

6/26/2012 NYS AFL-CIO $1,438 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/12/2012 NYS AFL-CIO COPE PAC $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/7/2012 NYS AFL-CIO COPE PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/2/2012 NYS ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/2/2012 NYS ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

2/13/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING ASSOC. PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/9/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING ASSOC. PAC $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/23/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING ASSOCIATION $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 NYS LABORERS PAC $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/2/2012 NYS PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/23/2012 NYS RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/23/2012 NYS RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

4/19/2012 NYS UAW PAC COUNCIL REGION 9 & 9A $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/12/2012 NYSNA PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/30/2012 NYSNA PAC $198 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 PLUMBERS & STEAMFITTERS PAC $2,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 SEIU 200 UNITED $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

12/21/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

4/6/2012 TEAMSTERL LOCAL 317 PAC $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/3/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCAL UNION #1149 $150 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/10/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCCAL 317 PAC $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

11/7/2012 TEMSTERS LOCAL 317 $500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/2/2012 UPSTATE NY PAC REGION 9 UAW $1,500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

Page 15: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

15

9/26/2012 UPSTTE NY PAC REGION 9 UAW $1,500 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

4/19/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $1,250 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/2/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $1,000 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

10/22/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $855 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

7/30/2012 VOTE/COPE PAC $495 COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAM ROBERTS

9/12/2012 A T & T PAC NEW YORK $7,300

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 ASSOC. GEN'L CONTRACTORS OF NYS PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

8/2/2012 ASTRAZENECA $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/9/2012 AT & T PAC NEW YORK $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/16/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS OF NY PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

6/11/2012 BANK OF AMERICA $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/23/2012 BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/30/2012 C.A.R.E. FOR A RESPON. ELECTORATE $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/16/2012 COMMITTEE FOR MEDICAL EYE CARE $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 COUNCIL OF INSURANCE BROKERS OF GREATER NY INC. $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/16/2012 CUPAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/23/2012 DISTRICT COUNCIL 37 PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/20/2012 EAST 85TH REALTY LLC $5,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/20/2012 EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

11/7/2012 ELI LILLY & CO. PAC $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/9/2012 ELI LILLY & COMPAY PAC $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/5/2012 EMPIRE HEALTH PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 EMPIRE MERCHANTS NORTH LLC $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/9/2012 EMPIRE STATE SUBCONTRACTORS ASSOC. INC. $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

Page 16: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

16

11/9/2012 GREATER NY AUTO DEALERS ASSOC. INC. PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/9/2012 GREATER NY AUTO DEALERS ASSOC. INC. PAC $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

9/17/2012 HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL PAC NY $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

9/10/2012 HSBC NORTH AMERICA PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/9/2012 IPPNY-PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 JP MORGAN CHASE & CO PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

11/15/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,300

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/16/2012 MERCK NYS PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/16/2012 N.Y. EMERGENCY MEDICINE $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

9/12/2012 NAIFA-NEW YORK STATE $200

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

1/23/2012 NAIFA-NEW YORK STATE PAC $200

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/23/2012 NATIONAL GRID VOL. NYS PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/11/2012 NOVARTIS PHARMACUTICALS CORP. $300

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/30/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PAC $3,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 NY BUILD PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NY GAMING ASSOC. PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/20/2012 NY PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOC. PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/9/2012 NY PODIATRY PAC $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/16/2012 NY PROPANE PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/21/2012 NY PUBLIC ADJUSTERS ASSOC. INC. $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 NY RETAILERS FOR EFFECTIVE GOV'T $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

Page 17: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

17

4/13/2012 NY TRUCK PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NYCAMP $750

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NYS ARCHTECTS PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NYS ASSOC. OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

5/23/2012 NYS BEER WHOLESALERS ASSOC. INC. PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NYS CONFERENCE IUOE PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/26/2012 NYS PROF. FIREFIGHTERS CIVIL INVOLVEMENT $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NYSAHU $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $2,500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 NYSFDA PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/2/2012 NYSNA PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 PHARMACY PAC OF NYS $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/9/2012 REPAIR-SHOP & GASOLINE DEALERS ASSOC PAC FUND $250

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/20/2012 RITE AID HDQTRS. CORP. $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 RSA-PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/27/2012 SPRINT NEXTEL CORP. PAC NY $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/16/2012 TAP-PAC ASSOC. OF PROP. COLLEGES $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/5/2012 THE BUSINESS COUNCIL PAC, INC. $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

4/27/2012 TRAVELERS CASUALTY & SURETY CO. $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

8/2/2012 U.R.H.T. ASSOC. OF NY STATEWIDE PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/19/2012 UHAP PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

3/26/2012 UNYAN PAC $1,000

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

Page 18: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

18

9/17/2012 VERTEX PHARMACEUTICALS INC. $500

DEFRANCISCO RE-ELECTION COMMITTEE

2/28/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS OF NY - PAC $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/18/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS ON NY PAC $200 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/9/2012 BUSINESS INDUSTRY PAC $500 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

3/27/2012 BUSINESS INDUSTRY PAC $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

4/3/2012 CARE COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

7/31/2012 CARE COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $225 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/3/2012 EMPIRE DENTAL POLITACAL ACTION COMMITTEE $100 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

7/6/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

3/21/2012 FINGER LAKES RACING ASSN $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

3/16/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

2/28/2012 IPPNY-PAC INDEPENDENT POWER PRODUCERS $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/2/2012 IPPNY-PAC INDEPENDENT POWER PRODUCERS OF NEW YORK $250 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/10/2012 LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS UNION COUNCIL 82 PAC $1,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/24/2012 LAW ENFORECEMENT OFFICERS UNION COUNCIL $200 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/18/2012 LAWPA OF NEW YORK $1,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

7/31/2012 NAIFA-NEW YORK STATE IFAPAC $200 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

4/3/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION PAC $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

3/16/2012 NEW YORK TRUCK - PAC $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/24/2012 NEW YORK TRUCK - PAC $250 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/21/2012 NUCOR STEEL - AUBURN $500 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/16/2012 NYS INDEPENDENT BANKERS PAC $1,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/16/2012 NYSCOPBA $3,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

9/28/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $500 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

10/15/2012 NYSFDA - PAC $500 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

2/28/2012 NYSFDA-PAC $1,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/27/2012 NYSFDA-PAC $1,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

11/9/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $100 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

2/28/2012 THE LIFE INSURANCE COUNCIL OF NY $300 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

8/27/2012 UHAP PAC $1,000 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

11/1/2012 WELCH ALLYN $250 FINCH FOR ASSEMBLY

4/12/2012 CARE COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/30/2012 CARE COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $250 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

10/23/2012 COMMITTEE FOR A STRONG ECONOMY $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/30/2012 CONSTELLATION ENERGY $1,000 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $250 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

Page 19: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

19

10/23/2012 DR PEPPER SNAPPLE PAC $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/9/2012 DR PEPPER/SNAPPLE $85 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/2/2012 EMPIRE DENTAL PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 HANYS PAC $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/30/2012 IBEW LOCAL 840 $600 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/2/2012 IPPNY PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 JY TRANSPAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 KEYCORP ADVOCATES FUND $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

7/7/2012 LAW PAC OF NY $2,100 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

1/12/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 LICONY $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

5/14/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NY $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

1/26/2012 NAIFA NYS $200 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

9/12/2012 NAIFA-NEW YORK STATE $100 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NATIONAL GRID VOLUNTARY NY PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

4/12/2012 NATIONWIDE NY PPC $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NFG NYPAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/30/2012 NY ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NY FI-PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NY GAMING ASSOCIATION PAC $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NY RETAILERS FOR EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT $350 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NYIA PAC $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 NYS PEST MANAGEMENT COALITION $150 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

5/14/2012 NYS SNOWMOBILE PAC $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

4/12/2012 NYSAHU $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/30/2012 NYSEG-RGE PAC $135 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

6/30/2012 PASSERO ASSOCIATES $600 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

11/28/2012 PUSATERI FUNERAL HOMES, INC. $218 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

4/12/2012 REAL ESTATE BOARD PAC $500 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 RPAC OF NYS $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

4/12/2012 VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS GOOD GOVERNMENT CLUB NY $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

3/24/2012 VOTE COPE $300 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

7/12/2012 WASTE MANAGEMENT OF NY LLC $1,000 FRIENDS OF BOB OAKS

7/9/2012 ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS OF NYS PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

7/5/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS OF NY PAC $127 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

3/19/2012 BUSINESS - INDUSTRY PAC OF CENTRAL $250 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

Page 20: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

20

NEW YORK INC

10/9/2012 EMPIRE SATE ABC PAC $175 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

7/2/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $1,270 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

10/18/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $1,200 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

3/3/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

2/1/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $250 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

7/3/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC PAC $200 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

6/20/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $127 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

9/20/2012 NORTHEAST DAIRY FOODS ASSOCIATION $350 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

6/29/2012 NORTHEAST DAIRY FOODS ASSOCIATION, INC $1,270 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

3/5/2012 NY BUILD PAC $500 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

9/28/2012 NY BUILD PAC $296 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

7/26/2012 NY BUILD PAC $250 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

10/22/2012 NY STATE RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION $250 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

7/2/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING ASSOC. PAC $254 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

9/28/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING PAC $444 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

6/29/2012 NYSFDA - PAC $127 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

6/28/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK ST $254 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

9/20/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $350 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

10/17/2012 RSA-PAC $2,000 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC CENTERSTATE CEO $350 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

6/28/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NEW YORK PAC $127 FRIENDS OF DON MILLER

3/15/2012 ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE CO $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/4/2012 AETNA INC. PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/19/2012 AIA $3,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/2/2012 AIA PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/2/2012 AIR EVAC EMS INC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/9/2012 AMERICAN BANKERS INS. CO. OF FL. $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/1/2012 AMERICAN BANKERS INS. CO. OF FLORIDA $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 AMERICAN TRANSIT INS CO $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/8/2012 AMERIGROUP $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/20/2012 ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRATORS OF NYS PAC $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 ASURION $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS OF NY PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 AXA EQUITABLE $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/4/2012 BARCLAY STREET REATY $5,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 BOEHRINGER INGELHEIM USA $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/25/2012 C.A.R.E $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

Page 21: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

21

3/28/2012 C.A.R.E. $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/21/2012 CARCO $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 CAREMARK RX $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 CAREMARK RX, INC. $1,250 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/2/2012 CDPHP $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/22/2012 CENTRAL HUDSON $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 CHUBB $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/3/2012 CHUBB AND SON $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/14/2012 CHUBB INDEMNITY INSURANCE CO. $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/16/2012 CITIGROUP INC., PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/25/2012 CITIGROUP INC., PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/22/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/27/2012 CORNING DEVELOPMENT CORP $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/19/2012 CORNING INT'LCORP. $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/28/2012 COUNCIL OF INS BROKERS OF GR NY $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/2/2012 COUNCIL OF SCHOOL SUPER & ADMIN $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/13/2012 DELOITTE $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 EDPAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/9/2012 EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/2/2012 ELPAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/15/2012 EMBLEM HEALTH NEW YORK PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/22/2012 EMBLEM HEALTH NEW YORK PAC $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 EMPIRE MERCHANTS NORTH $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/22/2012 ENTERPRISE HOLDINGS INC NY PAC $2,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/10/2012 ESIS $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/30/2012 EXXON MOBILE CORPORATION $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 FARM FAMILY LIFE INS $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 FARM NY PAC $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/28/2012 FARMERS GROUP, INC. $750 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 FARMER'S GROUP, INC. $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/22/2012 FIREMAN'S FUND $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/28/2012 GEICO $2,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 GEICO INDEMNITY $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/1/2012 GENWORTH GNA CORP $750 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/27/2012 GR. NY AUTO DEALERS ASSOC. PAF $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/9/2012 GR. NY AUTO DEALERS ASSOC. PAF $250 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 GUARDIAN LIFE $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 GUARDIAN LIFE $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/23/2012 HANYS PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/21/2012 HANYS PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

Page 22: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

22

3/15/2012 HARTFORD ADVOCATES FUND $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/20/2012 HEALTH CARE PROV. PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 HEALTHNOW PAC $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/25/2012 HEALTHNOW PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

11/27/2012 HIC PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/3/2012 HPA PAC $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 HPA PAC, C/O NY HEALTH PLAN ASSOC. $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/27/2012 HSBC N. AMERICA $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

1/20/2012 I.B.E.W. $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/21/2012 IBEW $400 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/25/2012 IBEW $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/13/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $4,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/2/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/23/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/9/2012 JY TRANS PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/28/2012 KPMG LLP $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/10/2012 LABORERS LOCAL 17-PAC $150 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/29/2012 LAW PAC OF NEW YORK $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 LAWPAC $600 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/22/2012 LECHASE CONSTRUCTION $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/14/2012 LIBERTY PAC NY $2,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 LIBERTY PAC NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/3/2012 LIBERTY PAC NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 LICONY $4,400 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/16/2012 LRA PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUTUAL INS CO PAC $400 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF NY PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 METLIFE EMPLOYEE POL PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 METLIFE PAC $2,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/17/2012 MVP HEALTH CARE STATE PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/3/2012 MVP HEALTH CARE STATE PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/29/2012 NAIFA-NEW YORK STATE IFAPAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/1/2012 NAIFA-NY $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/27/2012 NAMIC ADMIN FUND $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/28/2012 NATIONAL SHOOTING SPORTS FOUNDATION, INC. $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/1/2012 NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INC. COMPANY $800 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/3/2012 NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/29/2012 NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

Page 23: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

23

9/28/2012 NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/28/2012 NEW YORK CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS PAC, INC. $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/1/2012 NEW YORK STATE AFL-CIO COPE ACCT. $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/29/2012 NRA POLITICAL VICTORY FUND $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/15/2012 NURSE PRACTIONERS OF NYS $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/25/2012 NY GAMING ASSOC. PAC $300 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 NY LIFE -NYS PAC $2,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/20/2012 NY MEDICAL EQUIPTMENT PROVIDERS $3,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/21/2012 NY PIA $2,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 NY PIA $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/28/2012 NY PIA $800 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 NY PUBLIC ADJUSTERS ASSOC. $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/14/2012 NY RETAILERS FOR EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/12/2012 NY STAFFING ASSOCIATION $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 NY TRUCK PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/20/2012 NYAPAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/3/2012 NYIA PAC $2,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/14/2012 NYIA PAC $1,650 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/10/2012 NYIA PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 NYPIA PAC $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/23/2012 NYS AFL-CIO $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/12/2012 NYS AFL-CIO $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 NYS ARCHITECTS $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/9/2012 NYS ASSOC. OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/23/2012 NYS AUTO VENDING ASSOC $250 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/7/2012 NYS FARM ASSOC. PAC $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/9/2012 NYS FARM ASSOCIATES $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 NYS GAMING ASSOCIATION $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 NYS NURSES ASSOCIATION PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/1/2012 NYS OPTOMETRIC ASSOC. $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/29/2012 NYS RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION PVF $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/26/2012 NYS TELPAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/28/2012 NYSAHU $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/29/2012 NYSAHU $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/14/2012 NYSFDA - PAC $2,300 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

2/16/2012 NYSFDA - PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/3/2012 PCI $3,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/19/2012 PCI STATE POLITICAL ACCOUNT $200 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/16/2012 PFIZER PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

Page 24: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

24

4/2/2012 PHYSICIANS RECIPROCAL INSURERS $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/14/2012 PHYSICIANS' RECIPROCAL INSURERS $3,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/1/2012 PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 PROPERTY CASUALTY IMSURERS OF AMERICA $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 PROPERTY CASUALTY INSURERS ASSOC. OF AMERICA $1,300 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

4/27/2012 PRUDENTIAL NY PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/27/2012 REAL ESTATE BOARD PAC $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/12/2012 REAL ESTATE BOARD PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 RPAC OF NYS $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/31/2012 SECURITY MUTUAL INS. CO. $150 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 SECURITY MUTUAL L.I. CO OF NY $250 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/17/2012 SECURITY MUTUAL LIFE $150 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/19/2012 SECURITY MUTUAL LIFE $75 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/6/2012 SKI AREAS OF NY, INC. $150 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/22/2012 THE AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD CT $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/16/2012 THE BUSINESS COUNCIL PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

10/29/2012 THE HARTFORD ADVOCATES FUND MULTICANDIDATE COMMITT $2,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/24/2012 THE LIFE INSURANCE COUNCIL OF NY PAC $150 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NYS PAC $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 TRAVELERS PROPERTY CASUALTY CO $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/23/2012 UHAP $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/28/2012 UHAP $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/27/2012 UHAP $209 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 UNYAN PAC $2,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

8/28/2012 UNYAN PAC $1,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 UNYAN PAC $400 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

6/15/2012 UNYAN PAC $400 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/23/2012 UNYAN PAC $350 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/11/2012 URHT ASSOCIATION OF NY $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 USAA $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/14/2012 VOTE-COPE $4,500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

3/15/2012 VOTE-COPE $1,000 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

7/3/2012 WALMART $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

5/3/2012 WELLCARE OF NY $500 FRIENDS OF SENATOR SEWARD

9/12/2012 ANHEUSER-BUSCH DISTRIBUTORS OF NEW YORK INC $250 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

9/12/2012 ANHEUSER-BUSCH SALES OF HAWAII, INC $250 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS OF $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

Page 25: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

25

NYS PAC

3/21/2012 ATT&T PAC-NEW YORK $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/29/2012 BUSINESS INDUSTRY PAC OF CENTRAL NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

4/5/2012 BUSINESS-INDUSTRY PAC OF CENTRAL NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

4/2/2012 C.A.R.E. $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/9/2012 C.A.R.E. COMMITEE FOR ACTION $150 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/9/2012 CABLEVISION SYSTMES NY-PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

4/19/2012 CHESAPEAKE OPERATING INC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/30/2012 CORNING INTERNATIONAL $1,800 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 CORNING PROPERTY MGMT $1,500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/6/2012 DOMINION PAC-NY $1,500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/12/2012 EMPIRE DENTAL PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

2/27/2012 EMPIRE DENTAL PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 EMPIRE MERCHANTS NORTH LLC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 EMPIRE STATE ABC-PAC $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/6/2012 FARM NY PAC $250 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 FRIENDS OF NATURAL GAS PAC INC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 HEARING HEALTHCARE ALLIANCE OF NY PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/13/2012 HUNT ENGINEERS, ARCHITECTS & LAND SURVEYORS PC $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

6/29/2012 I.B.E.W. EDUCATIONAL COMMITTEE $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS-PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

2/27/2012 IPPNY-PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 LAWPAC OF NY $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

2/28/2012 LECHASE CONSTRUCTION LLC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

5/10/2012 LIBERTY STREET REALTY LLC $5,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

5/23/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK-PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/7/2012 NAIFA-NEW YORK STATE $100 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOC PAC $2,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/6/2012 NEW YORK INSURACE ASSOC INC PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 NEW YORK TRUCK PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/1/2012 NFG NYPAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

11/1/2012 NFG-NYPAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

2/27/2012 NY BUILD PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/2/2012 NYS ARCHITECTS PAC $450 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/1/2012 NYS ASSOCIATION OF PBA'S $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/9/2012 NYS FARM ASSOCIATES PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

2/27/2012 NYS PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

Page 26: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

26

3/6/2012 NYS PROFESSIONAL FIRE FIGHTERS $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 NYS RESTAURANT ASSOC PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

4/24/2012 NYS SNOWMOBILE PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/29/2012 NYS TELPAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 NYS TROOPERS PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 NYS VETERINARY POLITAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/7/2012 NYS VETERINARY POLITICAL EDUCATION COMMITTEE $150 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

2/27/2012 NYSNA-PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/12/2012 PASSENGER BUS CORP $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

7/6/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/1/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 RSA-PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/14/2012 SALIENT CORP $1,500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/8/2012 SALIENT CORP $1,500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

1/9/2012 SENECA NATION OF INDIANS $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 SENECA NATION OF INDIANS $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

6/27/2012 STAFFING & PAYROLL SOLUTIONS, INC $1,000 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/16/2012 THE BUSINESS COUCIL PAC INC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

3/7/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NY PAC $500 FRIENDS OF TOM O'MARA

8/20/2012 AUGUST A. BUSCH & CO. OF MASSACHUSETTS, INC. $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/16/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS OF NY PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/23/2012 C.A.R.E. COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/15/2012 COMMITTEE FOR A STRONG ECONOMY $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/25/2012 COMMITTEE FOR MEDICAL EYE CARE $300 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/5/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/5/2012 DR PEPPER SNAPPLE PAC $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/24/2012 EMPIRE DENTAL PAC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/30/2012 EMPIRE LIQOUR STORE ASSOCIATION $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/12/2012 EMPIRE MERCHANTS NORTH, LLC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/10/2012 EMPIRE STATE PAC $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

9/24/2012 EXXON MOBILE CORPORATION $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

12/10/2012 FEDERAL EXPRESS NEW YORK STATE PAC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/14/2012 FINGER LAKES RACING ASSOCIATION $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/24/2012 HANYS PAC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/19/2012 HANYS PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/26/2012 HANYS PAC $300 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

5/1/2012 HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/30/2012 IBEW EDUCATIONAL COMMITTEE $1,250 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

Page 27: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

27

8/3/2012 IBEW LOCAL 840 $1,250 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/11/2012 IBEW PAC INTERNATIONAL $2,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/30/2012 IESI NY CORPORATION $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

12/10/2012 INTERNATIONAL UNION PAINTERS AND ALLIED TRADES $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/17/2012 IPPNY - PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/17/2012 IPPNY PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

11/19/2012 JOHNSON EQUIPMENT SALES & SERVICE $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

6/22/2012 JPMORGAN CHASE & CO PAC $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/3/2012 LABORERS INTERNATIONAL UNION OF NORTH AMERICA LOCA $200 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/15/2012 LAW ENFOCEMENT OFFICERS UNION COUNCIL 82 $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/20/2012 LAWPAC OF NEW YORK $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

6/13/2012 LAWPAC OF NEW YORK $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/22/2012 LECHASE CONSTRUCTION $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/26/2012 LECHASE CONSTRUCTION $300 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/5/2012 MCDONALDS NY STATE OWNER $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/30/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF STATE OF NYC PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/24/2012 NAIFA - NYS PAC $150 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

6/27/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION $1,750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/1/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION $1,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

9/26/2012 NEW YORK STATE AFL-CIO COPE ACCOUNT $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/16/2012 NEW YORK STATE TROOPERS PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/1/2012 NFG NYPAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/12/2012 NUCOR STEEL $3,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 NY PROPANE PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/28/2012 NY RETAILERS FOR EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/26/2012 NY TRUCK PAC $4,250 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/5/2012 NY TRUCK PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/30/2012 NYACS PAC $167 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 NYS AFL-CIO COPE ACCOUNT $1,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 NYS ASSOC OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/27/2012 NYS ASSOCIATION OF PBA'S PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

4/27/2012 NYS BEER WHOLESALERS ASSOC, INC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/13/2012 NYS CONFERENCE IUOE $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/25/2012 NYS MOTOR TRUCK ASSOCIATION $764 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/30/2012 NYS SNOWMOBILE PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/19/2012 NYS TELPAC $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/7/2012 NYS TROOPERS PAC $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

Page 28: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

28

7/18/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $4,800 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/6/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/6/2012 NYSEG-RG&E POLITI $1,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/15/2012 NYSFDA - PAC $3,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/28/2012 NYSFDA-PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/3/2012 NYSPIA POLITICAL COMMITTEE $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

11/2/2012 PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FEDERATION $3,400 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/20/2012 PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FEDERATION $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/23/2012 PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FEDERATION $2,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/24/2012 PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FEDERATION $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/6/2012 R.E. GINNA NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, LLC $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

6/28/2012 REAL ESTATE BOARD PAC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/5/2012 RIVER YORK BARCLAY LLC $5,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/26/2012 ROCHESTER BUILD PAC $250 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/1/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/23/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

2/16/2012 RSA PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/24/2012 SEIU 200 UNITED $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/4/2012 SHEET METAL WORKER LOCAL 46 $2,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/24/2012 TIMEWARNER CABLE NY PAC $300 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/30/2012 TOMRA $2,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

7/2/2012 UHAP PAC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/1/2012 UHAP PAC $750 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/18/2012 UPSPAC $2,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

8/6/2012 URHT ASSOCIATION OF NY STATEWIDE PAC $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/29/2012 VOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON POLITICAL EDUCATION OF THE $1,000 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

3/9/2012 VPOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON POLITICAL EDUCATION OF THE $1,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/22/2012 WASTE MANAGEMENT OF NEW YORK, LLC $2,500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

10/22/2012 WASTE MANAGEMENT OF NEW YORK, LLC $500 MIKE NOZZOLIO FOR STATE SENATE

12/17/2012 1199 SEIU NYS POLITICAL ACTION FUND $4,100 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

8/14/2012 AETNA, INC. POLITCAL ACTION COMMITTEE $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/12/2012 AIR EVAC EMS INC $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

12/17/2012 ANHEUSER BUSCH COMPANIES $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

8/20/2012 ANHEUSER-BUSCH DISTRIBUTORS OF NEW YORK, INC. $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/22/2012 BUSINESS-INDUSTRY PAC OF CENTRAL NY $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/6/2012 CARE COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/23/2012 COVANTA ENERGY CORPORATION $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/11/2012 CREDIT UNIONS PAC $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

Page 29: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

29

10/2/2012 DRIVE COMMITTEE $4,100 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/19/2012 EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

1/31/2012 EMPIRE STATE PRIDE AGENDA PAC $250 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

7/16/2012 EMPIRE STATE REGIONAL COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS POLITI $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/24/2012 HANYS PAC $600 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/13/2012 HANYS PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/17/2012 HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/4/2012 HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL PAC-NY $600 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

6/8/2012 HSBC NORTH AMERICA PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/4/2012 IBEW EDUCATIONAL COMMITTEE $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/4/2012 IBEW LU 1249 PAC $250 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/19/2012 IUOE LOCAL 158 VPAF STATE & LOCAL $600 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/7/2012 LAWPAC OF NEW YORK $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/23/2012 LOCAL UNION 43, IBEW $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

6/26/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK POLITICAL $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/15/2012 NEW YORK BANKERS PAC STATE FUND $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/14/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/3/2012 NEW YORK STATE ARCHITECTS PAC $600 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/19/2012 NEW YORK STATE LABORERS' PAC $900 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/13/2012 NEW YORK TRUCK PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/22/2012 NY BUILD PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/1/2012 NYS ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/4/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING ASSOC. PAC $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/16/2012 NYS CONFERENCE IUOE PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/9/2012 NYS PIPE TRADES PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

8/23/2012 NYSNA - POLITCAL ACTION COMMITTEE $900 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

1/30/2012 NYSNA PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/26/2012 NYSNA PAC $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/23/2012 PLUMBERS & STEMFITTER LOCAL 267 PAC $1,200 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

6/26/2012 PLUMBERS & STEMFITTER LOCAL 267 PAC $200 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

9/19/2012 PROPERTY CASUALTY INSURERS ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/26/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/4/2012 SEIU 200 UNITED $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

3/20/2012 SPRINT NEXTELL CORPORATION PAC NY $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

5/31/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC CENTERSTATE CEO $900 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

6/19/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCAL 317 PAC $1,000 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/22/2012 THE BUSINESS COUNCIL PAC, INC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

Page 30: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

30

1/25/2012 THE LIFE INSURANCE COUNCIL OF NEW YORK PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

4/17/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NEW YORK PAC $300 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/13/2012 UHAP PAC $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/10/2012 UNITED NY AMBULANCE NETWORK $750 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

2/17/2012 VOTE/COPE $500 PEOPLE FOR MAGNARELLI

9/3/2012 AMERICAN FOOD & VENDING SERVICES, INC. $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/17/2012 ANHEUSER-BUSCH DISTRIBUTORS OF NY INC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS OF NYS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 AUTOMOBILE DEALERS OF NY PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 BUSINESS-INDUSTRY PAC OF CENTRAL NY INC $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 BUSINESS-INDUSTRY PAC OF CENTRAL NY, INC. $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 C.A.R.E. COMMITTEE FOR ACTION $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/3/2012 COMM. FOR ACTION FOR A RESPONS. ELECTORATE $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 CONVENIENCE PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/3/2012 CSX CORPORATION $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 CUPAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/12/2012 CWA DISTRICT ONE PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/17/2012 DRIVE COMMITTEE $2,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/21/2012 EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 ELI LILLY AND COMPANY PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 EMPIRE DENTAL ASSOCIATION PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 EMPIRE MERCHANTS NORTH LLC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 EMPIRE STATE PRIDE AGENDA $750 VALESKY FOR SENATE

6/16/2012 ENTERPRISE HOLDINGS INC., NEW YORK PAC $2,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

11/28/2012 GREATER NEW YORK AUTO DEALERS ASSOC., INC. PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/7/2012 GREATER NEW YORK HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION $10,300 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 HANYS PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 HANYS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/18/2012 HCA PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 HEARING HEALTHCARE ALLIANCE OF NEW YORK PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/28/2012 HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL PAC-NEW $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

Page 31: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

31

YORK

9/3/2012 HSBC NORTH AMERICA PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/18/2012 IBEW LOCAL 1249 PAC $150 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/17/2012 IBEW LOCAL 43 $1,850 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/15/2012 IBEW LOCAL 43 $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/17/2012 IBEW LOCAL 43 $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 INDEPENDENT AGENTS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 IPPNY $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/13/2012 IRON WORKERS LOCAL #60 PAC $1,850 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/12/2012 IRON WORKERS LOCAL #60 PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/3/2012 IUOE LOCAL 158 VPAF STATE & LOCAL $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 J.Y. TRANS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/10/2012 LAWPAC OF NEW YORK $5,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/21/2012 LEADING AGE NY PAC $750 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/12/2012 LOCAL UNION 43 IBEW $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/20/2012 LOCAL UNION 43 IBEW $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/30/2012 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUTUAL INSURANCE CO PAC $350 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/12/2012 MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NY PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 N.Y. EMERGENCY MEDICINE $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/29/2012 NATIONAL FUEL'S NEW YORK PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/21/2012 NATIONAL GRID VOLUNTARY NYS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

4/1/2012 NATIONAL SHOOTING SPORTS FOUNDATION, INC. $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/29/2012 NATIONWIDE NEW YORK POLITICAL PARTICIPATION FUND $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK BUS OPERATIONS FOR EFFETIVE GOVERNMENT $5,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK FARM BUREAU, INC. $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK GAMING ASSOCIATION PAC $750 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK STATE ARCHITECTS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/25/2012 NEW YORK STATE ARCHITECTS PAC $100 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK STATE FOOD INDUSTRTY PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/13/2012 NEW YORK STATE LABORERS' PAC $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/26/2012 NEW YORK STATE LABORER'S PAC STATE FUND $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/23/2012 NEW YORK STATE NURSE'S ASSOC. $100 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK STATE TROOPERS PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NEW YORK TRUCK PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/10/2012 NORTHEAST DAIRY FOODS ASSOCIATION, $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

Page 32: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

32

INC.

10/11/2012 NORTHEASTERN POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE NEPAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/29/2012 NY ALFA PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NY BUILD PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 NY CCE NON PARTISAN PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/27/2012 NY CCE NON PARTISAN PAC FOR GOOD GOV. $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

6/14/2012 NY PODIATRY POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NYS ASSOCIATION OF PBA'S PAC INC. $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

6/7/2012 NYS AUTOMATIC VENDING ASSOC. PAC $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

4/10/2012 NYS BEER WHOLESALERS ASSOC., INC. PAC $2,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/11/2012 NYS CONFERENCE IUOE PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

6/7/2012 NYS LABORER'S PAC STATE FUND $400 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/30/2012 NYS NURSE'S ASSOCIATION PAC $950 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/21/2012 NYS OPTOMETRIC ASSOCIATION PAC $750 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/27/2012 NYS PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS ASSOC. $350 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 NYS RESTAURANT ASSOC. PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/21/2012 NYS RETAILERS FOR EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/22/2012 NYS RIFLE & PISTOL ASSOCIATION PVF $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/30/2012 NYS VETERINARY POL. ED. COMMITTEE $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/20/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $3,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/10/2012 NYSCOPBA PAC $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/3/2012 NYSFD PAC $700 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NYSFDA PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 NYSNA PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/17/2012 PASSENGER BUS CORPORATION $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

11/4/2012 PCPC NY CGR PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 PFIZER PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 PHARMACY PAC OF NYS $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/27/2012 PLUMBERS & STEAMFITTER LOCAL 267 PAC $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

6/17/2012 PLUMBERS & STEAMFITTERS LOCAL 267 PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/26/2012 PLUMBERS & STEAMFITTERS LOCAL 267 PAC $300 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/13/2012 PLUMBERS & STEMFITTERS LOCAL 267 PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/3/2012 PLUMBERS LOCAL UNION #1 NYC PAC $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 POLICE BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 RPAC OF NEW YORK STATE $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/27/2012 RPAC OF NYS $350 VALESKY FOR SENATE

Page 33: NYPIRG report: Albany's Pay to Play Culture

33

7/26/2012 SEIU 200 UNITED $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/12/2012 SEIU 200 UNITED $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

11/27/2012 SL GREEN MANAGEMENT LLC $5,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/10/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/18/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $400 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/30/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 SYRACUSE TOMORROW PAC $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

6/7/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCAL 317 PAC $1,000 VALESKY FOR SENATE

8/27/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCAL 317 PAC $350 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/18/2012 TEAMSTERS LOCAL UNION NO. 1149 $100 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 THE AMERICAN INSURANCE ASSOCIATION PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 THE BUSINESS COUNCIL PAC, INC. $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

10/29/2012 THE HARTFORD ADVOCATES FUND MULTI CANDIDATE COMM. $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 THE LIFE INSURANCE COUNCIL OF NEW YORK PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NEW YORK PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/26/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NEW YORK PAC $150 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/12/2012 TIME WARNER CABLE NEW YORK PAC $100 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 U.R.H.T. ASSOCIATION OF NEW YORK STATEWIDE PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

3/21/2012 UHAP PAC $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/10/2012 UHAP PAC $350 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/13/2012 UHAP PAC $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/26/2012 UHAP PAC $150 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 UNIFORMED FIRE OFFICERS ASSOC. FIRE DEPT. OF NY LO $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/6/2012 UNIFORMED SANITATIONMEN'S ASSOC. LOCAL 831-I.B.T. $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/12/2012 UPSTATE NEW YORK PAC REGION 9 UAW $500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

2/21/2012 VOTE/COPE COMM. ON POL. ED OF NYS UNITED TEACH $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

9/3/2012 VOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON PUB. ED. OF NYS UNITED TEAC $1,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

7/23/2012 VOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON PUB. ED./NYS UNITED TEACH $300 VALESKY FOR SENATE

1/12/2012 VOTE/COPE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ED NYS UN. TEACHERS $2,500 VALESKY FOR SENATE

5/7/2012 WELCH ALLYN, INC. $250 VALESKY FOR SENATE