Nuclear Structure studies using -...

77
Nuclear Structure studies using Advanced-GAmma-Tracking techniques Caterina Michelagnoli [email protected] École Joliot-Curie 2015 ‘’Instrumentation, detection and simulation in modern nuclear physics’’

Transcript of Nuclear Structure studies using -...

Page 1: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Nuclear Structure studies using Advanced-GAmma-Tracking techniques

Caterina Michelagnoli [email protected]

École Joliot-Curie 2015

‘’Instrumentation, detection and simulation in modern nuclear physics’’

Page 2: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

World-wide projects for g-ray spectroscopy

AGATA (Advanced-Gamma-Tracking Array)

GRETA (Gamma-Ray

Energy Tracking Array)

Use highly segmented Ge detectors

+ digital electronics to reconstruct the path of g rays

in the detector medium

Page 3: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

World-wide projects for g-ray spectroscopy

Legnaro National Lab. (2009-2012) Demostrator phase

GSI, Germany (2012-2014) @ fragment separator

AGATA (Advanced-Gamma-Tracking Array)

GRETA (Gamma-Ray

Energy Tracking Array)

Grand Accelerateur National d’Ions Lourdes (GANIL) France (2014 – at present)

Use highly segmented Ge detectors

+ digital electronics to reconstruct the path of g rays

in the detector medium

Page 4: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

PART 1 (September 28th 2015) General Introduction: Physics Motivation 1. Nuclear structure and g-ray spectroscopy 2. Structure of neutron-rich fission fragments

g-ray tracking: Motivation and Concept 1. In-beam γ-ray detection: requirements 2. From conventional germanium detector arrays to g-ray tracking 3. g-ray tracking (‘’philosophy’’, approximations, open questions)

Pulse Shape Analysis (PSA) 1. Principle 2. Position resolution and Compton imaging

Outline

(be aware … personal selection of topics!)

Page 5: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

(be aware … personal selection of topics!)

PART 2 (September 29th 2015) Pulse Shape Analysis (PSA) 1. Signal bases calculation 2. Signal decomposition Some results from Ge position sensitive mode operation and γ-ray tracking

The AGATA array of segmented HPGe detectors 1. Implementation of Pulse Shape Analysis and Tracking concepts 2. The AGATA detectors and preamplifiers 3. The structure of electronics and data acquisition 4. Digital signal processing (at high counting rate) 5. (AGATA data processing)

AGATA+VAMOS (magnetic spectrometer) at GANIL

Outline

Page 6: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

nu

mb

er o

f p

roto

ns,

Z

number of neutrons, N

The Atomic Nucleus

Z

N

J. Hans D. Jensen (1907 – 1973) PR75, 1766 (1949)

Maria Goeppert Mayer 1906 - 1972 PR75, 1969 (1949)

NOBEL PRIZE 1963

The Nuclear Shell Model

1

Page 7: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Nuclear Excitations

Z

N

Shell Model

Cooper Pairs

Collective Excitations

Need to tune model parameters collecting nuclear experimental

information

2

Page 8: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Nuclear Excitations

Z

N

Shell Model

Cooper Pairs

Collective Excitations

Need to tune model parameters collecting nuclear experimental

information

Test of nucleon-nucleon interaction by comparing the experimental results to model prediction

What is the effective nucleon-nucleon interaction? What are the limits of existence for bound nuclei (driplines) ?

2

Page 9: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

The Structure of the Nucleus

Observables:

energy levels (Ei)

spin (Ji)

parity (pi)

lifetime (transition probabilities) (ti)

nuclear moments (g-factors)

Ei Ji pi

ground state

Ener

gy

systematics (e.g. shape transitions) benchmarks for nuclear models (e.g. Nuclear Shell Model)

3

Page 10: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

The Structure of the Nucleus

Observables:

energy levels (Ei)

spin (Ji)

parity (pi)

lifetime (transition probabilities) (ti)

nuclear moments (g-factors)

systematics (e.g. shape transitions) benchmarks for nuclear models (e.g. Nuclear Shell Model)

Ei Ji pi

ground state

populate in excited state(s) and observe g ray de-excitation radiation

g ray spectroscopy is an approach for the study of nuclear structure Ener

gy

Measuring g-ray:

energy

angular distribution

linear polarization

energy Doppler shift (for example)

angular distribution vs t 3

Page 11: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Level schemes vs Energy spectra

152Dy

What we want ...

4

Page 12: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Level schemes vs Energy spectra

152Dy

What we want ...

What we get ...

Analysis of complex spectra with many lines close in energy

“Allegoria della pazienza” G. Vasari

4

Page 13: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Nuclear deformation in the A~100 region fi

rst

2+

stat

e e

n [

keV

]

B(E

2; 2

+

0+)

[e

2fm

4]

0+

2+

4+

Z=36 Z=34

Z=38 Z=40 Z=42 Z=44

M. Albers et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 062701, “Evidence of a smooth onset of deformation in the neutron-rich Kr isotopes”

Z, n

um

ber

of

pro

ton

s

N, number of neutrons

half-life stable nuclei

Z=36, towards N=60

Nuclear shape evolution in the neutron-rich Kr isotopes

5

Page 14: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

γ-ray spectroscopy of neutron-rich isotopically-identified fission fragments

238U + 9Be

6

Gamma ray detector + mass spectrometer

Page 15: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

GANIL

Intense 238U beam to induce fission in inverse kinematics

7

Page 16: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

238U beam (@ 6.2 MeV/A) on 9Be target

Isotopic identification event-by-event in the magnetic spectrometer

Courtesy of M. Rejmund

A. Navin et al.,

Phys. Lett. B 278, 136 (2014)

Id. of the element Id. of the isotope

8

Page 17: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Collectivity in neutron-rich Zr nuclei

A. Navin et al.,

Phys. Lett. B 278, 136 (2014)

Z=40

Z=42

Z=44

Z=46

Z=48

9

Page 18: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Collectivity in neutron-rich Zr nuclei

A. Navin et al.,

Phys. Lett. B 278, 136 (2014)

Z=40

Z=42

Z=44

Z=46

Z=48

9

How we can do better? Low energy gamma rays Resolution (EXOGAM: 8 keV at 1.2 MeV) Gamma linear polarization measurements ...

Page 19: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

In-beam g-ray spectroscopy: requirements Energy resolution (Eg ̴10 keV -10 MeV ), in order to disentangle complex spectra germanium detectors

Peak to Total ratio (large continuous Compton background), in order to maximize “good events” Compton background suppression

10

Page 20: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

In-beam g-ray spectroscopy: requirements Energy resolution (Eg ̴10 keV -10 MeV ), in order to disentangle complex spectra germanium detectors

Peak to Total ratio (large continuous Compton background), in order to maximize “good events” Compton background suppression Doppler correction capability, energy resolution dominated by Doppler broadening if the velocity vector and the emission angle of the g-ray are not well known (b ~ 5-10%, up to 50%)

10

Page 21: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

In-beam g-ray spectroscopy: requirements Energy resolution (Eg ̴10 keV -10 MeV ), in order to disentangle complex spectra germanium detectors

Peak to Total ratio (large continuous Compton background), in order to maximize “good events” Compton background suppression Doppler correction capability, energy resolution dominated by Doppler broadening if the velocity vector and the emission angle of the g-ray are not well known (b ~ 5-10%, up to 50%)

Good solid angle coverage (ideally 4p), in order to maximize efficiency

Good granularity , in order to reduce multiple hits on the detectors for high g-ray multiplicity events

Avoid dead materials that could absorb radiation (preserve low energies)

10

Page 22: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

In-beam g-ray spectroscopy: requirements Energy resolution (Eg ̴10 keV -10 MeV ), in order to disentangle complex spectra germanium detectors

Peak to Total ratio (large continuous Compton background), in order to maximize “good events” Compton background suppression Doppler correction capability, energy resolution dominated by Doppler broadening if the velocity vector and the emission angle of the g-ray are not well known (b ~ 5-10%, up to 50%)

Good solid angle coverage (ideally 4p), in order to maximize efficiency

Good granularity , in order to reduce multiple hits on the detectors for high g-ray multiplicity events

Avoid dead materials that could absorb radiation (preserve low energies)

High counting rate capability (frequently background much stronger than channel of interest)

Time resolution (prompt events selection, lifetimes) 10

Page 23: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Energy resolution

From Sodium Iodide

to

Germanium detectors

104Ag and 106 Ag

Response function = differential spectrum obtained with a detector when

hit by monochromatic radiation

60’s Use of Ge(Li) detectors marks the beginning of high-resolution in-beam g-ray spectroscopy

70’s Only few detectors , operated in g-g coincidence. Development of the HP-Ge detector.

Use of Germanium detectors = breakthrough in nuclear structure

FWHM = 2 keV at 1.3 MeV

11

Page 24: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

v

q

θ cosβ1

β1E)θ(E

2

CM

γ

Lab

γ

-

-

b=v/c

Doppler broadening: effective energy resolution

b

d

Small d

Large d

Large W

Small W

High eff

Low eff

Poor FWHM

Good FWHM

Efficiency vs Resolution:

q

g-ray

detector

DqD

Source at rest intrinsic energy resolution

12

Page 25: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

2

Lab

γ

Lab

γ

2

2

Lab2

Lab

2

2

Lab

Lab

2

CM

γ

CM

γ

2Lab

γ

2

Lab

γ

CM

γ2

2CM

γ2Lab

2

Lab

CM

γ2CM

γ

2

Lab

Lab

γ

CM

γ

Lab

2

CM

γ

Lab

γ

E

ΔE

Δβ

θcosβ1β1

θcosβ

Δθ

θcosβ1

sin θβ

E

ΔE

ΔE

E

E

Δβ

β

E

Δθ

θ

E

ΔE

β1

θcosβ1EE

θcosβ1

β1EE

--

-

-

-

-

-

-

Intrinsic

Opening

Recoil

Eg 1 MeV DElab √(1.2+0.003*Elab) b% 5±0.01 20±0.005 DQdeg 8 2

DE g

/Eg %

Doppler broadening: effective energy resolution

g

b

qLAB

13

Page 26: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Photon interaction with matter

~ 100 keV ~1 MeV ~ 10 MeV

Photoelectric Compton Scattering Pair Production

g ray energy

cos θ1

cm

E

1

E

E

2

0

γ

γ

γ'

-

Ee1=Eg-Eb

54,5.3

n

E

zn

g

(Eg > 2mec2)

2

Z

14

Page 27: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Compton scatt.

l(10 keV) ~ 55 mm l(100 keV) ~ 0.3 cm l(200 keV) ~ 1.1 cm

l(500 keV) ~ 2.3 cm l(1 MeV) ~ 3.3 cm

Mean free path: l(E) = MA/(NAV.r) . 1/SE

Photoelectric

Pair prod.

Cross Sections in Germanium

15

Page 28: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

1

2

3 source

q1

q2

e1

e2

e3 Eg0

assuming that the e- is at rest, from conservation of energy and momentum:

Eg1 Eg2

0

iii

i

i

i

iEEe

cm

E

E

Egg

g

g

g

q

-

-

-

-

-

1

2

0

1

1

cos11

Energy of scattered g Energy of scattered e-

Compton Scattering (1)

Arthur Holly Compton Nobel prize 1927

16

Page 29: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

-

-

-

W qq

qq

q

cos11cos1

cos11

2

cos1

cos11

1

d

d

2

2222

2

erz

The angular distribution of the scattered photon is described by the Klein-Nishina formula:

=Eg/mec2

and re is the classical electron radius

For Eg > few 100 keVs the angular distribution is highly anisotropical and peaked to small forward angles. It strongly ``focuses’’ with the increasing photon energy.

Compton Scattering (2)

17

Page 30: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

-

e

e

e

e

eEEE

E

Ef

Ef

E

N

gg

2

2

2

1

11

2

1

d

d

The spectrum of the scattered electrons can be deduced from the Klein-Nishina formula:

e

ee

e

EE

E

E

cmEf

-

-

gg

2

1

Since the actual energy deposition is performed by the electrons, photons interacting via Compton scattering will produce a continuum.

Corrections are needed since electrons are not free, rather bound in materials, producing a

smoothening of the actual spectrum

(Compton profile)

1332 keV photons

Compton shoulder

Continuum Compton

Electron Energy [keV]

Dif

fere

nia

l cro

ss s

ect

ion

(a.

u.)

18

Page 31: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Compton continuum

Full-energy peak

Double-escape peak

Single-escape peak

HPGe detector used with the GASP array

(LNL)

Shape of the g spectrum for a typical size Ge detector

High probability that the incoming photons are only partially absorbed. Response function: full-energy peak, continuum generated by photons which underwent Compton scattering and, if the photon energy is larger than 1.022 MeV, peaks due to the missed detection of one or both the annihilation photons (single and double escape peaks).

Eg=3 MeV

19

Page 32: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

For large-volume Ge crystals the Anticompton shield (AC) improves the

PeakToTotal ratio (P/T) from ~20% to ~60%

60Co

keV

cou

nts

Escape-suppressed Ge detectors

(Compton suppression)

In a g-g measurement, the fraction of useful peak-peak coincidence events

grows from 4 % to 36%

For high fold (F) coincidences the fraction of useful coincidences is P/T F

g1 \ g2 P B

P PP PB

B BP BB

BGO

The cross section for Compton scattering in germanium implies quite a large continuous

background in the resulting spectra

20

Page 33: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

GASP @ Legnaro Nat. Lab.

• 40 HPGe + AC (config. II)

• dtarget-det. = 22 cm

• eph~ 5.8% @ 1332.5 keV

• Pb collimator (6 cm thick)

• inner space Rint = 15 cm

Lifetime measurements with Doppler Shift Techniques 7 rings @ 35O, 60O, 72O, 90O, 108O, 120O, 145O 6 6 4 8 4 6 6

C. Rossi-Alvarez, Nucl. Phys. News Europe 2 (1993) 10

D. Bazzacco, in: Proc. Conf. On Physics from Large g-ray detector arrays, 1992, p. 376 21

Page 34: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

GAMMASPHERE EUROBALL

15 Clusters (7-Ge); 26 Clovers (4-Ge); 30 single Ge 71 CS-systems 239 Ge crystals

up to 110 Compton-Suppressed Ge detectors

Efficiency ep ~ 10 — 5 % Peak/Total PT ~ 55 — 40 % ( Mg=1 — Mg=30)

Solid angle covered by Ge 40-50 %

I.Y. Lee, NPA 520 (1990) 641

22

Page 35: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Spectroscopic history of 156Dy

The “spectroscopic history” of 156Dy is a notable example of how the

progress with the acceleration and detection techniques leads to better insight on the nuclear

structure.

156Dy

23

Page 36: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

The nucleus is always full of surprises

Instrumentation advances New Science 24

Page 37: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Advances in g-ray spectroscopy: sensitivity vs year

cou

nts

Sensitivity = inverse of the weakest channel

reaction cross-section that can be measured over total cross section

Ge detector system sensitivity vs year

new eyes for new phenomena:

super-deformation in 156Dy major/minor axis = 2:1

25

Page 38: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Advances in g-ray spectroscopy: sensitivity vs year

cou

nts

Sensitivity = inverse of the weakest channel

reaction cross-section that can be measured over total cross section

Ge detector system sensitivity vs year

new eyes for new phenomena:

AGATA (EU) and GRETA (US) will allow unprecedented gamma detection sensitivity, by using

the germanium detectors in position sensitive mode

(Pulse Shape Analysis and Tracking)

super-deformation in 156Dy major/minor axis = 2:1

25

Page 39: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

The g-ray spectroscopy dream

Cover the whole detection solid angle by germanium and track the path of the g rays inside the detector medium

• segmented detectors

• digital electronics • timestamping of events • analysis of pulse shapes • tracking of γ-rays

4 time more efficient than standard arrays, also for high γ multiplicity (28 % Mγ=30)

High count rate capabilities (100s KHz)

Study of nuclei in extreme conditions of angular momentum and neutron/proton asymmetry

“perfect” Doppler correction (6 keV @ 1 MeV, β=50%)

new accuracy and sensitivity for nuclear level lifetimes γ linear polarization

γ source

“continuous” angular distributions of the γ interaction points (θ~1o)

26

Page 40: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Position resolution used to limit Doppler broadening of gammas emitted in flight -- Benefits of the g-ray tracking

scarce

good

Def

init

ion

of

the

p

ho

ton

dir

ecti

on

Do

pp

ler

corr

ecti

on

ca

pab

ility

Detector

Segment

Pulse shape analysis

+

tracking g Energy (keV)

v/c = 20 %

27

Page 41: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Tracking of radiation

in High Energy Physics in Nuclear Spectroscopy

“continuous tracks” from very energetic particles

huge detectors for “one” experiment

Physics the study of “complete” events

“many” low energy (0.01 -- 10 MeV) neutral transitions

with low density of energy deposition

“general-purpose” detectors for a large variety of experiments

Physics large number of incomplete events

28

Page 42: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Position-sensitive operation mode and g-ray tracking

highly segmented HPGe detectors

Event by event: how many gammas,

for each gamma: energy, first interaction point, path

29

Page 43: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

highly segmented HPGe detectors

Event by event: how many gammas,

for each gamma: energy, first interaction point, path

digital electronics to record sampled

waveforms

Position-sensitive operation mode and g-ray tracking

29

Page 44: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Position-sensitive operation mode and g-ray tracking

highly segmented HPGe detectors

Event by event: how many gammas,

for each gamma: energy, first interaction point, path

digital electronics to record sampled

waveforms

Pulse Shape Analysis of the recorded waves

29

Page 45: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Position-sensitive operation mode and g-ray tracking

highly segmented HPGe detectors

Event by event: how many gammas,

for each gamma: energy, first interaction point, path

digital electronics to record sampled

waveforms

Pulse Shape Analysis of the recorded waves

Identified interaction points

(hits)

(x,y,z,E,t)i

29

Page 46: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Position-sensitive operation mode and g-ray tracking

highly segmented HPGe detectors

Event by event: how many gammas,

for each gamma: energy, first interaction point, path

digital electronics to record sampled

waveforms

Pulse Shape Analysis of the recorded waves

Identified interaction points

(hits)

(x,y,z,E,t)i

reconstruction of g-rays from the hits

(tracking)

29

Page 47: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Aim of gamma-ray tracking

e1, x1, y1,z1

e2, x2, y2,z2

…………………..

en, xn, yn,zn

E1, (q,f)inc,1,(q,f)sc,1. …

E2, (q,f)inc,2,(q,f)sc,2. …

………………………………

Ei, (q,f)inc,i,(q,f)sc,i

deposited energies and the positions of all the interactions points of an event in the detector

reconstruct individual photon trajectories and write out photon energies,

incident and scattering directions

discard events corresponding to

incomplete energy release e1

e2

30

Page 48: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Aim of gamma-ray tracking

e1, x1, y1,z1

e2, x2, y2,z2

…………………..

en, xn, yn,zn

E1, (q,f)inc,1,(q,f)sc,1. …

E2, (q,f)inc,2,(q,f)sc,2. …

………………………………

Ei, (q,f)inc,i,(q,f)sc,i

deposited energies and the positions of all the interactions points of an event in the detector

reconstruct individual photon trajectories and write out photon energies,

incident and scattering directions

discard events corresponding to

incomplete energy release e1

e2

30

Doppler correction

Linear Polarization

Page 49: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Tracking of Compton Scattered Events

Source position is known

Questions :

1) Is the event complete?

2) What is the right sequence?

31

Page 50: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Tracking of Compton Scattered Events

Source position is known

Questions :

1) Is the event complete?

2) What is the right sequence?

31

Page 51: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Tracking of Compton Scattered Events

-

-

-

-

-

1N

1 n

2PE

P

2

0

E

E

P

'

P

1

1

E

'

1

E

22EE2

cos θ1

cm

E

1

E

E

1201

1201cos θ

EE

γ'γ '

nn

ee

N

ni

i

N

ni

i

g

g

g

gg

Source position is known

Questions :

1) Is the event complete?

2) What is the right sequence?

From source + interaction positions

From energy deposition + incident energy

Track order = permutation with best 2

31

Page 52: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Find 2 for the N! permutations of the

interaction points

Fit parameter is the permutation number

Accept the best

permutation if its 2 is below a predefined value

0.01

0.1

1

10

100

0 24 48 72 96 120

Permutation number

Two 5-point events

2

Tracking of Compton Scattered Events

32

Page 53: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Identification is not 100% sure spectra will always contain background

The acceptance value determines the quality (P/T ratio) of the spectrum

Often we use the R = Efficiency•PT to qualify the reconstructed spectra

Full energy deposition or not?

33

Page 54: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Reconstruction of multi-gamma events

• Analysis of all partitions of measured hits is not feasible: Huge computational problem (~1023 partitions for 30 points) Figure of merit is ambiguous the total figure of merit of the “true” partition not necessarily the minimum

• Forward peaking of Compton scattering cross-section implies that the hits of one gamma tend to be localized along the emission direction

• The most used algorithm (G.Schmid et al. NIMA 430 1999, GRETA) starts by identifying clusters of points which are then analyzed as individual candidates gammas

-

θ

E

E

E

E

E

ErZ

d Ω

d σ

'

''

KN 2

22

0sin

2

34

Page 55: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

1. Create cluster pool => for each cluster, Eg0 = depositions in the cluster

Forward tracking implemented for AGATA (D.Bazzacco, Padova - A. Lopez-Martens, Orsay [NIMA 533 (2004) 454])

35

Page 56: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

1. Create cluster pool => for each cluster, Eg0 = depositions in the cluster

2. Find most probable sequence of interaction points, test the 3 mechanisms

1. do the interaction points satisfy the Compton scattering rules ?

2. does the interaction satisfy photoelectric conditions (e1,depth,distance to other points) ?

3. do the interaction points correspond to a pair production event ?

E1st = Eg – 2 mec2

-

-

1N

1 n n

γ

Pos

γ'

n

2

E

EE

W

2γ'

Forward tracking implemented for AGATA (D.Bazzacco, Padova - A. Lopez-Martens, Orsay [NIMA 533 (2004) 454])

35

Page 57: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

1. Create cluster pool => for each cluster, Eg0 = depositions in the cluster

2. Find most probable sequence of interaction points, test the 3 mechanisms

1. do the interaction points satisfy the Compton scattering rules ?

2. does the interaction satisfy photoelectric conditions (e1,depth,distance to other points) ?

3. do the interaction points correspond to a pair production event ?

E1st = Eg – 2 mec2

3. Select clusters based on 2

-

-

1N

1 n n

γ

Pos

γ'

n

2

E

EE

W

2γ'

Forward tracking implemented for AGATA (D.Bazzacco, Padova - A. Lopez-Martens, Orsay [NIMA 533 (2004) 454])

35

Page 58: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

~40 keV X-rays

Examples of tracked source spectra

152Eu 12 AGATA detectors

36

Page 59: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Performance of the Germanium Shell Idealized configuration to determine maximum attainable performance.

1.33 MeV Mg = 1 Mg = 30

eph (%) 65 36

P/T(%) 85 60

27 gammas detected -- 23 in photopeak 16 reconstructed -- 14 in photopeak

Eg = 1.33 MeV Mg = 30

A high multiplicity event

Reconstruction by Cluster-Tracking Packing Distance: 5 mm Position Resolution: 5 mm (at 100 keV)

37

Page 60: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0.1 1 10 100Position resolution (mm)

Pe

ak

Eff

icie

nc

y (

%)

M = 2

M = 5

M = 10

M = 20

M = 30

Standard shell; Eg = 1.33 MeV; Packing=Smearing;

Energy independent smearing

The biggest losses are due to multiplicity (mixing of points) not to bad position resolution

5 mm is the standard “realistic” packing and smearing assumption

Efficiency of Standard Ge Shell vs. Position Resolution and g Multiplicity

If positions inside segments are not known, performance

is a factor 2 worse

38

Page 61: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0.1 1 10 100Position resolution (mm)

Pe

ak

Eff

icie

nc

y (

%)

M = 2

M = 5

M = 10

M = 20

M = 30

Standard shell; Eg = 1.33 MeV; Packing=Smearing;

Energy independent smearing

The biggest losses are due to multiplicity (mixing of points) not to bad position resolution

5 mm is the standard “realistic” packing and smearing assumption

Efficiency of Standard Ge Shell vs. Position Resolution and g Multiplicity

If positions inside segments are not known, performance

is a factor 2 worse

Sub-segment position resolution is needed

38

Page 62: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Pulse Shape Analysis (PSA)

8 AGATA Triple Clusters (24 detectors)

@ GANIL “captured” during an

experiment

Reconstruction of the interaction points

(hits)

39

Page 63: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Pulse shapes in a coaxial Ge detector

40

Radiation carriers in the bulk,

swept out by electric field signal

Reverse bias (-HV on p+ contact) depletes

bulk and generates high electric filed

On “true” coaxial detectors, the shape depends on initial radius

Page 64: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Segmented detectors • When one of the electrodes is (electrically) segmented, the motion of

charges within one segment induces a transient signal also in the neighboring electrodes

• Contrary to the segment where the interaction takes place (the charge is released), the total collected charge in the neighboring electrodes is null

• The amplitude of the induced transient signals provides a convenient way to locate the interaction with sub-segment precision

Segmentation of an AGATA detector

41

Page 65: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Pulse Shape Analysis concept Interaction occurred in segment 4

(net charge signal)

Interaction is closer to segment 3 (larger amplitude than segment 5)

42

Page 66: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Pulse Shape Analysis concept Interaction occurred in segment 4

(net charge signal)

Interaction is closer to segment 3 (larger amplitude than segment 5)

42

Sub-segment precision … but not enough to efficiently perform tracking! Pulse Shape Analysis

Page 67: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured

43

Page 68: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

C4

D4

E4 F4

A4

B4

x

y

z = 46 mm

(10,10,46)

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured calculated

43

Page 69: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

C4

D4

E4 F4

A4

B4

x

y

z = 46 mm

(10,15,46)

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured calculated

43

Page 70: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

C4

D4

E4 F4

A4

B4

x

y

z = 46 mm

(10,20,46)

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured calculated

43

Page 71: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

C4

D4

E4 F4

A4

B4

x

y

z = 46 mm

(10,25,46)

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured calculated

43

Page 72: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

C4

D4

E4 F4

A4

B4

x

y

z = 46 mm

(10,30,46)

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured calculated

43

Page 73: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Result of Grid Search Algorithm B4 B5 B3

C4 C5 C3

CORE

A4 A5 A3

C4

D4

E4 F4

A4

B4

x

y

z = 46 mm

(10,25,46)

Pulse Shape Analysis concept

791 keV deposited in segment B4

measured calculated

43

Page 74: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Position resolution of AGATA

F. Recchia et al., NIMA 604 (2009) 555

P-A. Soederstroem et al., NIMA 638 (2011) 96

Method = Doppler correction capability in an in-beam experiment

Energy [channel]

Simulation of reaction + detector response

F. R

ecch

ia e

t a

l., N

IMA

60

4 (

20

09

) 5

55

P

-A. So

ederstro

em et a

l., NIM

A 6

38

(20

11

) 96

44

Page 75: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Imaging of Eg=1332 keV gamma rays AGATA used as a big and exspensive Compton Camera

F. Recchia et al., NIMA 604 (2009) 60

Far Field Backprojection

Near Field Backprojection

All 9 detectors One detector

All 9 detectors One detector 2

0

111cos cm

EE

-

gg

q

Source at 51 cm Dx ~Dy ~2 mm Dz ~2 cm

45

Page 76: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

Doppler correction capabilities

F

O

N

C

B

Be

Li

No Dopp Corr Crystal Centers Segment Centers PSA+Tracking

16O

TKE (MeV)

dE

(MeV

)

Inelastic scattering 17O @ 20 MeV/u on 208Pb

F.Crespi, Milano

AGATA Demonstrator at LNL

46

Page 77: Nuclear Structure studies using - Sciencesconf.orgejc2015.sciencesconf.org/conference/ejc2015/pages/Michelagnoli1.pdf · 104Ag and 106 Ag Response function = differential spectrum

(be aware … personal selection of topics!)

PART 2 (September 29th 2015) Pulse Shape Analysis (PSA) 1. Signal bases calculation 2. Signal decomposition Some results from Ge position sensitive mode operation and γ-ray tracking

The AGATA array of segmented HPGe detectors 1. Implementation of Pulse Shape Analysis and Tracking concepts 2. The AGATA detectors and preamplifiers 3. The structure of electronics and data acquisition 4. Digital signal processing (at high counting rate) 5. (AGATA data processing)

AGATA+VAMOS (magnetic spectrometer) at GANIL

Outline