Northstar History

30
Journey to the North Star 2006 - 2013 Transforming behavior support in Hamilton County, Ohio

Transcript of Northstar History

Page 1: Northstar History

Journey to the

North Star2006 - 2013

Transforming behavior support in Hamilton County, Ohio

Page 2: Northstar History

Building Relationships, Changing CultureIn August 2006, an extensive review began at Hamilton County Developmental Disabilities Services (HCDDS) of the ways in which individuals with disabilities are supported in interacting positively with others.

This review started a transformation of the traditionally aversive* beliefs and methods surrounding interactions with individuals who exhibit challenging behavior. The emerging structure driving this transformation – a classic cultural shift - became known as The North Star Initiative.

To start the transformation, several staff joined together to collect and discuss data from customer satisfaction sur-veys, accreditation reviews, incidents, behavior support plans, and observations of those who work most closely with individuals.

Staff who participated in this review represented several departments within Hamilton County DD Services, including Adult and Children’s Services, Quality Assurance, Major Unusual Incidents and Prevention, and Behavior Support.

The need for this review was driven by: • Common knowledge among some staff that individuals with aversive plans were not successfully transitioning off of them and methods in the plans were not positively impacting behavior • Unapproved behavior support techniques happened frequently • The Ohio Department of DD accreditation review in 2006 cited behavior support procedures as needing improvement • A new Superintendent and Adult Services Director at HCDDS had great interest in supporting people with disabilities positively and encouraging increased interaction with their communities

* In 2012, restrictive became the standard behavior support term, replacing aversive. Since the word aversive was operative in the period of time documented by this publication, it will be used throughout this publication.

Building Relationships,

Page 3: Northstar History

Building Relationships, Conclusions from the review led the group to the primary objec-tives of reducing aversive plans and building positive relationships between people with disabilities and those who support them.

Since 2006, The North Star Initiative has grown into a dynamic movement, infusing not only HCDDS but also partner agencies with the philosophy, resources and tools to promote positive behavior support.

As of 2012, 20 agencies supporting more than 500 people have joined with HCDDS in developing and implementing positive be-havior support philosophy and methods.

“It takes a long time to make a cultural shift. It was the first time we took on a project with people who crossed so many departments. It took a long time to

get it off the ground because we had to get so many people together.” Peggy Kurz

Director of Community Services, HCDDS Former Director of Adult Services

Page 4: Northstar History

Reducing Restrictive PlansReducing Restrictive Aversive (restrictive) plans are defined by the Ohio Department of Developmental Disabilities as the use of manual, mechanical or chemical restraints and/or the seclusion or restriction of rights. At the time of the initial data reviews in 2006, 88 aversive plans were in place, with seven of those using time out/seclusion.

Plans that included time out/seclusion were prioritized for elimi-nation. To accomplish this, staff who worked with the individuals and had been using restrictive techniques were re-trained and coached about more positive approaches and implementing them.

Success in aversive plans came gradually over the next two years. Time out/seclusion was soon eliminated from all aversive plans,

and the number of aversive plans in general dropped in half.

The state average for aversive plans is 2.6% of people served per county. HCDDS’s average is .005%.

From data collection and review in 2009 by statewide behavior support advisory committee affiliated with The Ohio Department of Developmental Disabilities

Page 5: Northstar History
Page 6: Northstar History

Developing Training Developing Training Materials and ResourcesOne of the first tasks of the North Star Initiative was to develop training materials and resources for staff to drive a cultural shift away from aversive techniques and toward building positive relationships. Resources included TIP SHEETS and teaching curriculums called TRY THIS and NOW I GET IT.

The TIP SHEETS and TRY THIS provide information about specific mental health and developmental disability di-agnoses and how those co-occurring diagnoses impact how staff respond to individuals.

The Now I Get It curriculum uses video clips to share successful teaching strategies for direct line staff. The curriculum was presented at state and national confer-ences for the National Association of Developmental Disabilities and TASH, an international advocacy and best practice association.

Page 7: Northstar History
Page 8: Northstar History

Promoting PositivePromoting Positive Behavior SupportIn August 2008, partner agencies that support individ-uals throughout the community in residential, work, and other settings were invited to join the North Star movement at Hamilton County DD Services. This pro-gram was named The North Star Advantage.

Provider partner staff spend a majority of time with individuals. Consistent, well-qualified staff are vital to building positive relationships. Embracing positive be-havior support and changing the culture system-wide required offering the most comprehensive training and support to program managers and direct support professionals employed by provider partners.

Key components of North Star Advantage • Prescreening o viewing a DVD of daily interactions o on-site visits• Training before Direct Support Specialists offer direct support o individual rights o Major Unusual Incident reporting o developing positive relationships o crisis prevention o first aid/CPR o support guidelines for the individual • Additional training within the first 90 days o self-determination o overview of positive supports o tips for success o formal crisis prevention• Ongoing training as requested by the agency• Mentoring

33% of unapproved behavior supports at HCDDS are not health and safety related but occurred be-

cause staff did something that escalated behavior

70% of these occurred with residential providers

data collection and review in 2009 by statewide behavior support advisory committee affiliated with The Ohio Department of Developmental Disabilities

Page 9: Northstar History

The video component depicts a realistic day in the life of a direct service provider. It has helped potential employ-ees decide if the job is a good match for them. The tours allow individuals to give input as to their likes and dislikes of a prospective employee. This process has helped participating agencies hire better-suited candidates and has contributed to reducing turnover rates.

The training components are vital to start new employees with important information that helps them be successful with the people they are working with. Assigning a mentor to each new employee has also helped in retaining new staff. Behavior Support Specialists at HCDDS host sessions to train partner agency trainers on all aspects of positive behavior supports. Partner agency trainers take this information back to their agencies to change their own cul-tures.

The average cost of staff replacement is estimated at 50-150 % of the salary of that staff. Through North Star Advan-tage regular meetings, training and mentoring, agencies are guided in reducing staff turnover and accessing HCDDS resources like behavior support consultation and mentoring.

Second year North Star Participant Keith Hammond of Easter Seals TriState (formerly Jewish Vocational Service) credits North Star with inspiring his agency to reorganize processes that have positively impacted behavior support. Keith said that the work floor has been reorganized in ways that support people in performing their work better, and that the agency has seen a decrease in incident reports because of this.

When the first group of North Star Advantage participants completed their work in 2008, members wanted to continue regularly meeting because of the benefits from interactions with peers and colleagues. Now, North Star Advantage groups from all of the combined years meet as a separate group from the current year’s group for addi-tional training.

Page 10: Northstar History

Journey to the North StarJourney to the North Training is an important part of North Star Advantage. It is extensive and ongoing support for provider agen-cies. A series of trainings began in 2010 to teach new and existing Direct Support Staff at each adult center operated by HCDDS about the principles of positive behavior support. This series is called Journey to the North Star.

This value-based training series was designed to initiate conversation with staff to develop empathy for indi-viduals served. Videos, biographical time lines, PATH Plans, and Life Boxes are used.

Timelines guide a person’s team in talking through a person’s life history and capturing it on paper using high-lights and dates. This tool helps show the changes and patterns in a person’s life that impact his or her behav-ior, and often pinpoints where a team needs to change its standards for that person to support them better.

PATH (Planning Alternatives for Tomorrow with Hope) is a team-facilitated planning process that was devel-oped by Marsha Forest, Jack Pearpoint and John O’Brien. PATH is one of the most useful tools for listening, planning and discovering what a person with disabilities wants for his or her future. The plan is captured in graphic form that is more easily understood by many people with disabilities and those who support them.

Life Books or Boxes are three-dimensional graphic depictions of a person’s life history, similar to scrapbooks, though they can be in any form – videos, boxes, books, etc. They are created with the person and his or her team of supporters. Often, in the creation of them, patterns and details emerge that help the team under-stand a person better and why he or she might have different behavior patterns.

Page 11: Northstar History

Navigators

Provider partners involved in North Star each have a navigator who is a staff person at HCDDS. This navigator is the go-to person for that provider who puts them in touch with resources quickly so the provider doesn’t have to spend a lot of time searching for resources.

Mentoring Program

Purpose To provide opportunities to beginning Direct Support Staff (DSS) to develop their professional and personal skills.

RationaleResearch and observation tells us that staff who do not feel supported can develop negative attitudes, poor performance, and leave the field. PATH plan by individual served

Page 12: Northstar History

GoalsMentors will develop the skills to provide as-sistance to beginning direct service staff • Communication • Problem solving • Coaching • Conflict management Beginning Direct Support Staff will develop or enhance skills • Planning, organizing and managing workflow • Relationship building • Keeping accurate documentation • Problem solving • Knowledge and understanding of all rules guiding services • Communication skills

ExpectationsChairperson at each participating agency to coordinate the program • Oversee the selection, training and assignment of all mentors in their agency • Facilitate training for mentors and new employees • Conduct follow-along to monitor success

Mentor • At least one year employment in the field • Ability and desire to have a collaborative relationship with a new employee • Commitment of the time to meet at least 18 hours over the first six months with the new employee

HCDDS • Provide support and training materials to agency chairpersons • Provide training videos for new staff • Facilitate recognition for mentors at the HCDDS annual banquet

Page 13: Northstar History

Expectations, continued...Mentor Responsibilities • Plan and conduct an orientation meeting with the DSS • Orient the DSS to location of forms and supplies • Review the staff procedure manual and answer questions • Review Behavior Support Procedures, MUI rule, and other health and safety information • Maintain confidentiality between the mentor and DSS • Provide and document guidance and coaching

Direct Service Staff Responsibilities: • Participate in professional development opportunities • Meet with mentor as scheduled • Provide feedback on the mentoring process • HCDDS provides free training resources and consultation - through enhanced training and support, provider staff deal more effectively with difficult situations

“Until North Star, we struggled for a formalized way, a structured for-mat, to develop supportive relation-

ships with people served, not just casual relationships. We’ve seen a

decrease in turnover of direct care staff and unapproved behavior sup-port. Mentors have supported new staff with time and attention and caring that supervisors often have

limited time to do.”Steve Koons

Rehabilitation Director, Ohio Valley Goodwill2008 North Star Advantage

Page 14: Northstar History
Page 15: Northstar History

“One of the greatest benefits I’ve received from North Star Ad-vantage is the chance to regu-

larly talk to other provider part-ners and professionals and share best practices. I’ve learned that not everything’s going to work, and that it’s ok to go through

a process of figuring out what’s best for the individual. “

Keith HammondProgram Manager, Easter Seals TriState

(formerly Jewish Vocational Service)2008 North Star Advantage

Page 16: Northstar History

“North Star has engineered a complete 180 degree turn in how we hire and orient new staff. Before hiring, everyone’s on the same page and everything’s written out. You know

who to call and what the processes are.”

Niel HartmanProgram Director, Visionaries & Voices

2008 North Star Advantage

Page 17: Northstar History

“North Star has caused UCP to have a good evolution of growth programmatically and per-sonnel-wise. We’ve experienced better selection of appropriate candidates and less turnover,

and we have a more structured selection and orientation process.”Katie Brenner

Program Coordinator, United Cerebral Palsy (UCP) 2009 North Star Advantage

Page 18: Northstar History

“It’s been a benefit to staff who have not worked with individuals with disabilities before. I think we’ve been a benefit to North Star participants who might not have worked with our popula-

tion before. It’s certainly helped us not be a silo in serving people with disabilities who also have drug

or alcohol issues.”Stephanie Miller

Program Manager, Talbert House2008 North Star Advantage

Page 19: Northstar History

The PresentThe PresentThroughout 2012, the combined North Star group of agencies explored the basics of trauma-informed care. This built upon a two-day training with Tonier Caine* that was held in 2011, and gave agencies a new perspective on supporting people with behavioral concerns. This group also was invited to explore a systematic method of sup-porting people called the “Sanctuary Model.”

Staff in the adult centers of HCDDS continued to learn about North Star through the Journey to the North Star series. A second series is being developed and staff who complete the first series will embark upon the second. Other departments of HCDDS have begun Journey to the North Star. Staff in the Community Services Department and agency schools are interested in participating in the series.

The combined group was invited to spend time with Dr. John McGee, the founder of Gentle Teaching and a national speaker on positive support for people with behavioral concerns. This continued the trend of bringing in people from across the country who have innovative and positive messages for supporting people, such as Tonier Cane and Dr. David Pitonyak.

To improve supports to people with behavioral concerns, the Human Rights/Behavior Support Review Committee (HR/BSRC) of HCDDS reviews Major Unusual Incidents and Unapproved Behavior Supports (UBS) to identify patterns and trends. This committee also debriefs after incidents and reviews timelines. Based on this analysis, behavioral support is offered to the agency involved.

Page 20: Northstar History

The Present, continued...

Another effort to improve supports was collaborative meetings with the Southwest Ohio Developmental Center (SODC) to improve placement outcomes for people transitioning out of SODC. This group also looks at admissions to SODC to ensure that community supports have been exhausted prior to placement there. In addition, planning is underway for the next class of North Star participants as well as for the combined group from previous years.

*Tonier is an internationally sought-after speaker who was featured in the documentary “Behind Closed Doors: Trauma Survivors and the Psychiatric System,” and is the subject of an award-winning film “Healing Neen.” She’s a team leader for the National Center for Trauma-Informed Care, with the National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors, a consumer advocate who speaks world-wide on trauma, incarceration, and recovery; and a case manager and Director of Advocacy Services for a private non-profit in Annapolis, MD. She survived a childhood of unspeakable abuse, unrelenting violence, and betrayal by systems that were charged with helping. She was arrested 83 times and convicted 66 times of crimes related to prostitution, drugs, and alcohol. When she was incarcerated and pregnant in 2004, someone finally took the time to ask “What happened to you?” instead of “What’s wrong with you?” It is at that moment she began her journey to become a survivor and for the first time in her life began to live with more hope than fear. The impact of trauma is realized by every age group, race, ethnicity, socio-economic group, gender, community, and workforce. As Ms. Cain shares her story, audience members find themselves challenging their professional and personal beliefs. Her experience illustrates the consequences that untreated trauma has on individuals and society at-large, including mental health problems, addiction, homelessness and incarceration.

Page 21: Northstar History

The FutureThe FutureFuture plans for North Star focus on spreading this transformative paradigm throughout the agency by increasing the groups of people exposed to its components and driving the concepts deeper by developing additional trainings and conversation around important topics.

To increase the breadth of North Star, staff in the Community Services Department and agency schools will continue the Journey to the North Star Series. Additionally, staff in agency adult centers will finish their first Journey series so that everyone who works in an adult center will share this common approach.

An exciting component of this will be the training of trainers. Assistant Directors from each adult center will join the Journey groups to learn the process of facilitating Journey discussions. The vision is that each adult center will have an in-house North Star expert who will keep the flame alive. A second Journey series will be facilitated at each site where groups have completed the first Journey series.

While the first Journey series focused on self-awareness and personal growth, the second series will focus on care-giving styles and interpersonal effectiveness. Ongoing training will also focus on increasing knowledge and aware-ness of issues that adult center staff and school staff identify. It is anticipated that the HCDDS psychologist will lead these.

Plans for North Star beyond HCDDS involve bringing in yet another new class of provider participants and growing the combined group of providers as the current group finishes. This combined group will identify issues and ideas that they would like to explore during the coming year.

Page 22: Northstar History

North Star Initiative TimelineNorth Star Initiative

2006

• Small group of staff start Internal review of aversive plans, unapproved behavior support o individuals were not transitioning off of aversive plans o plans were not working o unapproved behavior support data collected and studied, included drug interventions o Ohio Department of DD Accreditation review cited behavior support plans as needing improvement

• Change in leadership

• Larger group PATH planning; field trip to Louisville to learn about SPEAK (simi-lar program)

• North Star Big Group holds first meeting in August and creates mission o Our North Star is to eliminate aversive plans o Four sub groups formed to study data and develop action steps - Internal Roles - Training -the Co-Occurring Initiative grew out of this group - External Roles - Transition -schools to adult centers -institutions to community -co-occurring – Dr. Ed Comer – “We don’t understand each other’s worlds” -tip sheets came out of this group

Page 23: Northstar History

• North Star Big Group holds first meeting in August and creates mission o Our North Star is to eliminate aversive plans o Four sub groups formed to study data and develop action steps - Internal Roles - Training -the Co-Occurring Initiative grew out of this group - External Roles - Transition -schools to adult centers -institutions to community -co-occurring – Dr. Ed Comer – “We don’t understand each other’s worlds” -tip sheets came out of this group

2007• External Roles Sub Group plans pilot called North Star Advantage to spread concept throughout Hamilton County by joining with community partners o Adopt HCDDS ideals o Develop tools and resources o Work together to reach our North Star

• Training subgroup developed structure and content for providing comprehensive training to agencies and staff to embrace positive behavior support o Tip sheets o Crisis Prevention Intervention o Self Determination o Positive Behavior Supports o Behavior Support Coordinator position created to work with Behavior Support Specialists

• Mentoring Coordinators developed in each agency; shared experiences and materials with other agencies in North Star

• Navigator roles were formed for Behavior Support Specialists to be liaisons and coaches with provid-er agencies of North Star

Page 24: Northstar History

2008

• North Star Advantage Pilot begins with five agencies - Goodwill, OVRS, Talbert, V&V, RHC

• Best practices presentation at Kansas Neurological Institute annual conference, Kansas City, Mo.

• Training starts to introduce and implement North Star Initiative

• Mentoring training offered to provider reps

•Behavior Support Specialists start quarterly meetings with Service Facilitation Teams

• Behavior Support Specialists start training with staff at Adult Centers

• Six month review of participating North Star Advantage agencies

• Co-Occurring Initiative from transition committee becomes separate initiative o high risk mentoring partnership with Cincinnati Human Relations Commission

• Quarterly review of participating North Star Advantage agencies

• Consultation with Dr. Pitonyak about North Star Advantage

Page 25: Northstar History

2009

• Four agencies from first pilot graduate

• Second set of agencies from North Star Advantage begins – JVS, Starfire, RHC, Total Homecare, Support Care

• Pilot becomes “North Star Advantage”

• Psychiatrist Dr. Morrison hired to work with CRG

• First group of high risk mentees graduate

• TASH Presentation at national conference in Pittsburgh – Peggy Kurz and Matt Briner

• Consultation with Dr. Pitonyak about North Star Advantage

Page 26: Northstar History

2010

• Second set of agencies graduate North Star Advantage - JVS, Starfire, RHC, Total Homecare, Support Care

• Third set of North Star Advantage begins - GMR, CORE, LADD, AMT Group, Empowering People, Premier Providers

• Journey to the North Star Training Series started for direct support professionals in agency buildings o Series of six 30-minute small group activities o Seven or eight staff each time o Goal is to reach all adult center staff o Kidd is first adult center

• Try This curriculum rolled out that includes 10 additional positive approaches to behavior support

• Combined Group of all North Star Advantage Participants starts meeting because previous year’s groups wanted to stay connected

• Co-Occurring Resource Group (CRG) holds first “Coming Together” conference with more than 200 professionals from across the state

• Second group of high risk mentees graduate

• Final plan using time-out/seclusion is discontinued

Page 27: Northstar History

2011

• Third set of North Star Advantage graduates - GMR, CORE, LADD, AMT Group, Empowering People, Premier Providers

• Fourth set of North Star Advantage begins – Reva Supports, Associated Health Care, Stepping Stones, Petermann, Medacare, Wesley

• CRG hosts second “coming together” regional conference with more than 200 participants

• Public school district staff introduced to North Star through tip sheets

• Positive behavior support naturally becoming part of the culture

• Celebration of the North Star Initiative with all previous groups

• Last group of Journey to the North Star at Kidd; other adult centers in various stages

• TASH presentation at national conference in Atlanta – Peggy Kurz, Dawn Freudenberg, Matt Briner

• NADD presentation on the CRG and tools for success

Page 28: Northstar History

2012

• Fourth set of North Star Advantage graduates - Reva Supports, Associated Health Care, Stepping Stones, Petermann, Medacare, Wesley

• Journey to the North Star completed at Kidd and Franks Adult Centers

• Journey to the North Star training begins at agency schools with Direct Support Staff

• Journey to the North Star training begins at agency schools with Direct Support Staff

• Journey to North Star training begins with Service Facilitators

• Service Facilitators moved from regional locations spread throughout the county to one building near downtown in Queensgate

• Fifth set of North Star Participants started in the North Star Advantage - Caring Hearts Home Health Care, Community Supports, Inc., Just For You Supported Living, and ResCare Ohio

Page 29: Northstar History

• Journey to the North Star training begins at agency schools with Direct Support Staff

Page 30: Northstar History

For more information about the North Star Initiative in Hamilton County

http://providers.hamiltondds.orgclick on Northstar Advantage

Matt Briner, Behavior Support [email protected] / (513) 794-3300