NIST Priority Action Plan 9

Demand Response and Distributed Energy Resource Signal Semantics

Meeting 20090929-30

Presentation to Energy Interoperation TC 20091007

Overview

• PAP09 Workshop August 3-4– Unanimous agreement on plan– Execution under way

• Update and review September 29-30 PAPs 3, 4, 9, 10– Broad discussion– Issues arising from work in progress

• Summary output– No present work is invalidated– Coordination goals and approach to IEC TC57 Common

Information Model– Deeper understanding

2EITC 20091007

Slides from Meeting

• Following are slides from the meeting.• Full notes are at

– http://collaborate.nist.gov/twiki-sggrid/bin/view/SmartGrid/PAP34910MeetingPage

• Socialized approach among stakeholders• Broader context for work

– EnergyInterop, ZigBee work in parallel– Feedback to IEC CIM

• Requirements input from utility industry and ISOs through NAESB– Review of high level NAESB document in progress

3EITC 20091007

Requirements Capture Process

OpenH

AN

SR

S

Ope

nAD

R

AS

HR

AE

S.E. M.R.D.

S.E. T.R.D

Use

Cas

es

S.E. 1.0

NAESB / UCAIug Requirements

From NIST Workshop 20090929-304EITC 20091007

Multipath Approach61968 Based Root

(61850 Harmonized Externally)

Zigbee SE OASIS

61968 Based Solution

PAP 09 Process

“Fast Track”Supporting Initial

Utility Deployments

From NIST Workshop 20090929-305EITC 20091007

PAP 9 Responsibility Breakdown

EITC 20091007 6From NIST Workshop 20090929-30

EITC 20091007 7

Consensus• IEC 61968 CIM alignment

• Reuse where appropriate from published DR components with IEC 61968 CIM family for PAP9 work

• If someone is developing extensions, submit them to IEC (TC57) for approval (loopback)

• Incorporate where appropriate from OpenADR-OASIS• Common semantic model for inter-domain interfaces

• Scope boundaries fuzzy (need to solve)• How deep do the definitions (semantics vs. syntax) go? (need to

solve)• Utility commitment to IEC 61968 CIM family becomes a boundary

requirement• Tactical: Need a mechanism for a joint TF to allow parties from each

organization to participate in effort and share work products

From NIST Workshop 20090929-30

EITC 20091007 8

PAP 9 Tasks Identified [AGREED]Task Responsible Date Notes

Define proper DER Interaction, Scope Lunch table discussion; later readout to Action Team List

Input before 2009-10

x2G DEWGs, IEC TC57. Storage Models IEEE1547.3, NAESBPAP07 Outcome, PAP11 Elec Trans

Collect, Analyze, and Consolidate Use Cases and deliver UML (inc DER)

UCAIug, NAESB 2009-10 Incorporating OpenADR (Starting point for OASIS EITC). No Magic.

For Residential ApplicationsMessage Semantics Work DR, DER, Calendar, Price

IEC/ZigBee Underway

For C+I ApplicationsMessage Semantics Work DR, DER, Calendar, Price

IEC/OASIS Underway Starting from OpenADR. Review by UNCIug, , 1377, NAESB, BAE, SEP, TC57, MultiSpeak, others

Coordinate and merge residential and C+I development tracks

NAESB Loop back to IEC process

Send residential and C+I task outputs to IEC TC57 OASIS/ZigBee

Downstream user requirements/engagement LonMark, BACnet, ZigBee SEP2

2009-10 BACnet, LonMark, HES, x2G, UPnP, OpenHAN, ZigBee, SEP, oBIX, AHAM, UCAIug, NEMA

Additional message requirements for Distribution MultiSpeak 2009-10

Resale and process for safety and interconnection and resale

NAESB 2009-10 UL

Vocabulary NAESB, UCAIug, BACnet, LonMark

TWIKI ASAP2009-09 to [UML]

Normalize OpenADR, NAESB, UCAIG, Place on TWIKIDeliver to OASIS EITC

From NIST Workshop 20090929-30

EITC 20091007 9

PAP 4/3 Tasks Identified [AGREED]Task Responsible Date Notes

Develop high level scoping operations document

NAESB Bill Cox and others can contribute. DEWGs, No Magic, Ron Melton

--Develop high level use cases BAE (volunteer) 11/09 BAE, et al have already completed. Submit to NAESB and review operational definitions.

--Develop price requirements NAESB FIX, JPM, FISD, NARUC/NAESB, ISO/RTO CTO?, EEI, AHAM, ZigBee, OpenHAN, OASIS

--Data model OASIS, ZigBee Ongoing EMIX; FIX; IEC/CIM coord (Saxton)

--Draft pricing specification (to multiple locations)

OASIS, ZigBee 4/10 OASIS, ZigBee to submit to IEC (TC57, SG3 and others) after NAESB review. data model, XML expression?, No Magic. Review by FIX, CalConnect, FIATECH, NIBS, DEWGs, others

Import material from PAP4 where appropriate

IETF 12/09 draft

DEWGs, FIATECH, others

Meet and present deliverables at GRID-INTEROP

NAESB 11/09

From NIST Workshop 20090929-30

Members of Energy InteroperationTC Attending

• These members of the EITC attended the NIST meeting:– Ed Cazalet– Toby Considine– William Cox– Girish Ghatikar– David Holmberg– Jeremy Roberts

• OASIS Staff– James Bryce Clark

10EITC 20091007

Affect on Energy InteroperationTC Planning

• Requirements– Better and broader input (ISO, UCA, utilities)– Better focus– Not universal

• Need facility input (have from membership)• Need industrial, home, other input (limited)

– Need appropriate level• Review current draft (elsewhere in the agenda)

11EITC 20091007

Action Plan Explanation• The phrases “residential” and “C&I” are shorthand for what

Toby and others call “Managed” and “Collaborative” energy

• “Managed Energy” refers to a direct load control-type approach, as exemplified in OpenHAN and ZigBee Smart Energy Profile– Though there are information aspects as well

• The EITC is doing Collaborative Energy• The responsibilities listed are EITC; target for work and

review is the IEC CIM team. • The EITC is doing more than just the work in PAP09

– That work is also in liaison process with IEC TC57 and other TCs

12EITC 20091007

Other Action Items

• Vocabulary– Under way, need to work with NAESB and other

vocabulary efforts• “Downstream user requirements” are not

well-represented in NAESB Requirements Process– Action on EITC members to engage– Action for I2G DEWG and others to engage– Separate slides on NAESB draft input

13EITC 20091007