7/29/2019 Nicholson_a_2011 Review Sinister Yogi, White

1/3

277R B

pad, , paddharma p

, , , I.

Donald R. Davis, Jr.

University of Wisconsin, Madison

Sinister Yogis. B David Gordon White. C: University of Chicago Press, 2009. Pp. xx

+ 352.

I p b, The Alchemical Body Kiss of the Yogin, D G W b-

I p, b

b b p p- I

p- . W b b, Sinister Yogis,

, b b b. H

Y, I p Pj Yoga Stras p p . T

, W , p . I

- pp x b p

p x p : p p; S, P, H p x

; b I; . Ep ,

W p p b

b.

T - , b -

, , b M E

Yoga: Immortality and Freedom. W , p

Sinister Yogis p b J Fz, p

Mokadharma Parvan Mahbhrata. T p W b .

H - Pp Mj-D b p S p. H S V - rja ()

. (B, pp , - , px -

b xp b b Ezb D M, Jp A, M S.)

A p, W . F ,

p V B ( ., - . ). I p , p V B p (trimrti) , b V B p (pp. 18889,. Krma Pura 2.4.2123).

Ib, . O

p b pp -

Pj , p. A x S A , p

b I pp , p b

Bhagavad Gt p bhakti yoga p pp p-

jna yoga. Dp W ,

pb b pp :

7/29/2019 Nicholson_a_2011 Review Sinister Yogi, White

2/3

278 Journal of the American Oriental Society 130.2 (2010)

S b I W p , b b

pp b p p

, j, j p pp, viyoga,

p, , j. (p. 38)

H p , p b Pj J . S Sb, bSamdhi: The Numinous and the Cessative in Indo-Tibetan Yoga, ,

b , , p Yoga Stras.

A Pj p YS1.2 j (nirodha, ), p p ( vibhti)

p b p p. W

b p b j x

p- I, b b Pj Yoga Stras, p .

M pb W b, Sinister Yogis. A

I b xp W b (

L, -). A x p , , , W b b . I , pp

p q p. W

b , . W

p ( p b ) p

b b:

L b . . . b . . . W

b b, , b

mutualism. W b , b b

(.., ) Sn b A commensalism. W, , b ,

xp ( ) , parasitism. (p. 47)B bSinister Yogis, W p p

. I , b . T j x p-

p p p p (vibhti) p p, b

p xp p. A

M B b p

b, x siddhas p p b , j

. A pp pb

I, W b p-

b b: b

, b p b .

Sinister Yogis b p b , b p-p pp . I p, W p b

N-V pp x b p - b b. A W , p N-V pp- pp b Pp . T pp b p b p pj pp -

bj pp (p. 125). A

bj, p bj. I

, pp

bj . T pp p p- I. G

p b pb b, p b p-

p -- p b b b b. A

b x , p b, V Brahma Stra 4.4.15. I x p

7/29/2019 Nicholson_a_2011 Review Sinister Yogi, White

3/3

279R B

p p b p. A -

-p Gp Kj xp, b b b

p p p : T pp b b

b b, b [ b] b p

b , b b - (kriy-akti)

, -p (p. 166).

D G W Sinister Yogis b, , -, b z

b p p . W

b . I b

pp p . Sinister Yogis

p -p

. T b b , I b b b b ,

M E Yoga: Immortality and Freedom b p .

Andrew J. Nicholson

State University of New York, Stony Brook

The Culture of the Book in Tibet. B Kurtis R. Schaefer. N Y: Columia University Press,2009. Pp. x + 244.

E Tb S p b Tb

. T b, , p p x

Tb b p, b , , , p.

T p p p. B

Tb , bp- B , K S b

Tb , p p x . H

b b b , xp Tb

, b, bj, b. I

, b Tb b b

, p, b

b (p. 17).

T p p p , b

b, b . T b x p xp

b Tb. I p b

Tb , x b .T p b p. I b b-

Tb, b pp , b , p , p b. T

xp Tb S, b b b-

Tb . T p p p q

p p Tb p- , b

x, p p .

I x p S xp p p Tb b,

, b b

p p. T xp Tb , S z

p (p. 12), B-, -

b Kanjurp. S

, b p p b x, b p ,