New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods...

83
North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon USA [email protected]

Transcript of New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods...

Page 1: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

North American Tools for

Communities & Existing Neighborhoods

Module 2

Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND

Criterion PlannersPortland Oregon USA

[email protected]

Page 2: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Module 2 Topics

• North American tools for communities &

existing neighborhoods

• Other notable tools

• Current prospects & future trends

Page 3: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Community & Existing Neighborhood Tools

STAR

Community

Living

Community

Challenge

EcoDistrict

Protocol

Page 4: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Comparative Qualities

STAR

Community

Living

Community

Challenge

EcoDistrict

Protocol

Outcome rating Outcome rating Process-basedassessment

City or county Neighborhood Neighborhood

Present, future Past, present, future Past, present, future

Geographic scale

Temporal scale

Appraisal type

Page 5: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Comparison Continued

STAR

Community

Living

Community

Challenge

EcoDistrict

Protocol

Top down, rigid Top down, rigid Bottom up, adaptable

framework

Elective MandatoryMandatory scope, user

selected criteria

Every 3 years Every 3 years Every 2 years

Assessment criteria

Recertification

Approach

Page 6: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 7: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Appraisal Scale & Type

Physical scale

• Entire municipality or county

Appraisal type

• Certification of point-based rating that awards

“stars”

Page 8: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Scope – Goal Areas

• Built environment

• Climate & energy

• Economy

• Education & arts

• Equity & empowerment

• Health & safety

• Natural systems

• Innovation

Page 9: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Local Government Motivations

• Demonstrate commitment

• National recognition

• Competitive advantage

• Improve transparency

• Fiscal strength

• Build partnerships

Page 10: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Certification Levels

5-STAR 600+

4-STAR 400-599

3-STAR 200-399

Reporting STAR <200

Total Points - 750Certification Levels

Page 11: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

STAR Rating Points Allocation

Built environment 15%

Climate & energy 15%

Economy & jobs 15%

Equitable empowerment 15%

Health & safety 15%

Natural systems 15%

Education & arts 10%

Page 12: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Who is Using STAR?

50+

certifications

Page 13: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

STAR Framework

7 Goals

44 Objectives

108 Outcomes

408 Actions

Built environment

Affordable housing

Document 10% of units are

affordable

Require affordable units in

new projects

Example

Page 14: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 15: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Notable Objectives

• Quality jobs & living wages

• Workforce readiness

• Community cohesion

• Education opportunity & attainment

Page 16: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Action Types

• Education & outreach

• Plan development

• Policy & code adjustment

• Partnership & collaboration

• Practice improvements

• Inventory & survey

• Enforcement & incentives

• Programs & services

• Facilities & infrastructure

Page 17: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Rating Procedure

• Self-assessment checklist - preliminary examination

• 2nd party certification review by STAR staff

• Recertification required every 3 years

• No public engagement in rating process

Page 18: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

User Skill Requirements

• Familiarity with subject matter principles/practices

• Inter-departmental collaboration

• Data management & quantitative analysis

• No associated credential – relying on ISSP credential

Page 19: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Rating Timeframe & Cost

• Data collection & submission preparation – minimum 1 year

• Certification - 2-3 months

• Cost – approximately $10,000 fees, plus staff labor

Page 20: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Summary of STAR Community

• Only tool available for certifying entire jurisdiction

• Institutionalize “sustainability” in local government

• Relies on extensive tool provider support

• Valuable catalog of social, economic, environmental measures

• Difficult to scale-up for greater impact

Page 21: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Group Question 5:

How are Japanese municipalities rating

their sustainability?

Page 22: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 23: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Appraisal Scale & Type

Physical scale

• Neighborhood – increment or entirety

Appraisal type

• Two tiers of certification: 3 or more prerequisites,

or all 7

• Two certification stages: master plan & operating

Page 24: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Scope – Performance Areas or “Petals”

• Place

• Water

• Energy

• Health & happiness

• Materials

• Equity

• Beauty

Page 25: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Who is Using Living Community Challenge?

Test sites

• Seattle

• Washington DC• San Francisco

• New Orleans

• Normal, Illinois

Page 26: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Rating System Structure

• 7 performance areas or ‘petals’

• 20 imperatives – all mandatory

• 6 zones on a “living transect”

Page 27: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 28: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Notable Rating Criteria

• Net positive water, energy, waste

• Embodied energy – 1-time off-set

• 1:1 habitat protection off-site

• 100% of population within 3.6 km of shop, meet, work, learn

Page 29: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

% of Neighborhood

for Food

Production

Page 30: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Off-Street

Parking

Streets &

Intersections

Page 31: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

2 Firms on

Team Must be

JUST-certified

Page 32: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Notable Criteria Cont.

• Sharing programs – tools, books

• Equity off-set to nonprofit – ½ cent per project cost dollar

• Public art

• Health & wellbeing plan for each resident

Page 33: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Disaster Preparedness Criteria

• Emergency back-up power - all buildings except single homes

• 1 week of energy storage

• Safe gathering location – 100% of population

• 2 block captains/500 persons

• Emergency response plan to each resident

Page 34: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Rating Procedure

• Significant public engagement in planning process

• 1 year of performance data

• 3rd party certification review by independent assessor

Page 35: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

User Skill Requirements

• Technical knowledge of subject matter & “Living Building

Challenge” rating system

• Data management & quantitative analysis

• Optional credential – ILFI Accreditation

Page 36: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Rating Timeframe & Cost

• Data collection & submission preparation - 1,000+/- person hours

• Certification - 2-3 months

• Cost - $10,000-$36,000 fees, plus labor

Page 37: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Summary of Living Community Challenge

• Aspirational rating criteria, all mandatory

• Beauty, disaster preparedness, equity criteria

• Performance data required for certification

Page 38: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Group Question 6:

Would Living Community Challenge be

suitable for Japanese neighborhoods?

Page 39: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 40: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Appraisal Scale & Type

Physical scale

• Neighborhood

Appraisal type

• Formative, process-based self-assessment

• Certification of process completion &

performance reporting

Page 41: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

ScopeImperatives

• Equity

• Resilience

• Climate

Priorities

• Place

• Prosperous

• Health & Wellbeing

• Connectivity

• Living Infrastructure

• Resource Restoration

Page 42: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Imperatives Woven Into Priorities

Priorities

Imperatives

Equity

Resilience

Climate Protection

PLC PRS HWB CON LIV RES

Page 43: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Primary Users

Government

Redevelopment Authorities

Planning Agencies

Transportation Departments

Housing Authorities

Developers

Real Estate Developers

Business Improvement Districts

Campuses/Institutional Developers

Civic-Led Organizations

Community Development

Corporations

Non-Profit Groups

Community-Based Organizations

Page 44: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Operating EcoDistricts

Emerging Districts• Atlanta• Austin• Cambridge• Denver• Detroit• Los Angeles• Washington DC

Seattle

Portland

San Diego

Saint Paul

Ottawa

Washington DC

Atlanta

Page 45: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Protocol Framework

3 IMPLEMENTATION PHASES

6 PRIORITIES

3 IMPERATIVES

Page 46: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

• Pledge to pursue equity, resilience, climate protection

• Must commit before starting certification of

implementation phases

Imperatives Commitment

Page 47: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Equity Imperative

“Cities that embrace equity identify and acknowledge the

populations most vulnerable to change. These cities experience

stronger and longer-lasting growth.

District teams must ensure their population has the opportunity

to meaningfully participate, lead, and thrive.”

Page 48: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Types of Equity

• Procedural

• Structural

• Distributional and cross generational

Page 49: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Resilience Imperative

“Resilience is the capacity of cities to function so that all people

are able to withstand the stresses and shocks they encounter.

Districts must address resilience with a broad lens that prepares

for social, economic, and environmental stresses and shocks.”

Page 50: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Resilience Assets

• Knowledge & expertise

• Organizations & networks

• People

• Place

Page 51: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Climate Protection Imperative

“Cities are responsible for a majority of global carbon dioxide

emissions, the dominant greenhouse gas contributing to climate

change.

District teams must build a pathway to carbon neutrality.”

Page 52: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Collaborative Governance

Commit to

collaborate

Co-define

dilemma

Co-deliver

actionsCo-create

solutions

Co-design

process

Increasing trust ->

Building relationships ->

Enhancing capability ->

Requires appreciative mindsets

Embraces deliberative processes

1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

Page 53: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Declaration of collaboration:

• Decision-making body & procedures

• Backbone organization

• Committed stakeholder resources

Formation Phase

Page 54: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Each Priority:

• Objectives

- Indicators

- Current baseline

- Future targets

- Strategy to achieve targets

Roadmap Phase

Page 55: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Assessment Method

• All imperatives & priorities must be addressed,

extent is up to district

• District establishes baseline, sets targets, reports progress

• Certification using 3rd party verifiers is pass/fail completion of

process - no points or scoring

Page 56: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Notable Assessment Criteria

• Stakeholder engagement & inclusion

• Cultural celebration

• Active living

• Digital connectivity

• Nature connection

Page 57: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Performance Certification – Biennial Progress Reports

Capitol Hill EcoDistrict Seattle WA

Page 58: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

User Skill Requirements

• General familiarity with subject matter

• Public outreach, process facilitation, leadership

• Optional credential – EcoDistricts Accredited Professional (AP)

Page 59: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Summary of EcoDistricts Protocol

• Neighborhood regeneration through equity,

resilience, & climate protection

• People-centered, multi-year process

• Assessment framework, locally calibrated

• Performance data required to maintain

certification

Page 60: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Group Question 7:

Would the EcoDistricts Protocol be

suitable for Japanese neighborhoods?

Page 61: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Other Notable Tools

Page 62: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Other Notable U.S. Tools for Neighborhoods

• Enterprise Green Communities - affordable housing

• Envision - infrastructure

• LEED-ND - green neighborhood

• SITES - landscape

Page 63: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Other Notable Neighborhood Tools Internationally

• BREEAM Communities – UK

• DGNB Urban Districts - Germany

• Green Star Communities - Australia

• HQE for Urban Planning & Development - France

Page 64: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Group Question 8:

Other Notable Tools?

Page 65: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Current Prospects & Future Trends

Page 66: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Prospects

Sectors with planned green activity next 3 years

Global Average

Page 67: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 68: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Trends

• Globalization of tool marketing & brands

• Consolidation of tool providers

• Big data & the Internet of Things

Page 69: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 70: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

LEED Dynamic

Plaque

Page 71: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Environmentaldashboard.org

OBERLIN, OHIO

Page 72: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

We Cannot Afford to Not Appraise Urban Sustainability

Sustainability Savings

SocialEnvironmental Economic

Vitality Gains

Prosperity Improvements

Page 73: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

International Mandate – New Urban Agenda

• “We will put in place…mechanisms for cooperation, consultation, and review

processes that create ownership among different stakeholders, for the

elaboration, monitoring, and continuous review of urban policies…”

• “We will foster the creation, promotion, and enhancement of open and

participatory data platforms using technological and social tools…to transfer

and share knowledge among…local governments and other

stakeholders…to enhance effective urban planning and management…”

Page 74: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

National Mandate – Japan Future Cities Initiative

Page 75: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 76: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Neighborhood

Accounting of

Sustainability

Transactions

Page 77: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Neighborhood Accounting of Sustainability Transactions

Capacity Credit Payments• Less traffic• Less energy• Less water• Less waste

Ecosystem Service Revenues• Stormwater mgmt.• Urban forestry• Wastewater treatment• Pollination

NeighborhoodRegeneration

Funds

Continuous ImprovementSocial &

EconomicImprovements

Page 78: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Improving Appraisal Tools

• Bottom-up approach, greater relevance to daily life

• Affordable cost & simplicity

• Dynamic

• Monetize & account for benefits - GHG, water, waste,

transportation, health

Page 79: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 80: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon
Page 81: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Taking Appraisal Tools Into the Future

• People-centered - relevant to daily life

• Simple, affordable, efficient

• Dynamic, sensor-based

• Transactional – benefits accounting

Page 82: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Group Question 9:

What Are Other Future Prospects for Tools?

Page 83: New Module 2 · 2016. 8. 30. · North American Tools for Communities & Existing Neighborhoods Module 2 Eliot Allen, Principal, AICP, LEED AP-ND Criterion Planners Portland Oregon

Thank You

Eliot AllenCriterion Planners

Portland Oregon [email protected]