7/31/2019 Negros Oriental Electric Corp vs Sec of Labor

1/3

PFH\@ @H^H[HDM

YO-\- Md- 10;>1>- Eax 8'

7/31/2019 Negros Oriental Electric Corp vs Sec of Labor

2/3

_c nhm` md kdocmp bs{phnhkaphdm pd |c~c|{c pfc nhm`hmo dmpfc la{h{ dn pfc |ckd|`{ lcnd|c s{-

Pfc {ckdm` a|osecmp zd{hpc` lx zcphphdmc| h{ ag{dwhpfdsp ec|hp- Zcphphdmc| hm~dic{ A|phkgc Uwfhkf`ckga|c pfc hmcghohlhghpx dn eamaoc|hag d| {szc|~h{d|xcezgdxcc{ pd bdhm amx gald| d|oamhraphdm kdm{h{phmo dn |amiam` nhgc cezgdxcc{ nd| pfc |ca{dm pfap pfc kdmkc|m{ wfhkfhm~dg~c chpfc| o|dsz a|c md|eaggx `h{za|apc amkdmp|a`hkpd|x- Zcphphdmc| kgahe{ pfap hp kfaggcmoc pfc

kdezd{hphdm dn pfc smhdm ap pfc ca|ghc{p zd{{hlgc phec anpc| pfc`ckh{hdm dn pfc Ec`%A|lhpc| wa{ {cp a{h`c lx pfc @DGC9 am`pfap pfc gh{p dn pfc maec{ dn {szc|~h{d|x d| kdmnh`cmphagcezgdxcc{ wa{ {slehppc` whpf pfc zcphphdm nd| kc|phd|a|h nhgc`hm pfc Kds|p dn Azzcag{' wfhkf `h mdp kdm{h`c| pfc{aec- Zcphphdmc| ns|pfc| a|osc{ pfap pfc nahgs|c dn pfc[ck|cpa|x dn Gald| am` pfc Kds|p dn Azzcag{ pd |c{dg~c pfh{qsc{phdm kdm{phpspc` a `cmhag dn hp{ |hofp pd `sc z|dkc{{-

Pfc kdmpcmphdm{ a|c smec|hpd|hds{-

Pfc h{{sc wa{ |ah{c` nd| pfc nh|{p phec hm zcphphdmc|{Edphdm nd| \ckdm{h`c|aphdm dn pfc @ckh{hdm dn pfc [ck|cpa|x dnGald| `apc` Bsgx 1;' 1886 wfhkf {cp a{h`c pfc D|`c| dn pfcEc`%A|lhpc| `apc` @ckcelc| 3 [K\A ?

7/31/2019 Negros Oriental Electric Corp vs Sec of Labor

3/3

fhe{cgn- Fdwc~c|' pfc zcphphdmc| nahgc` pd ecmphdm pfap pfc[sz|cec Kds|p fa{ ag{d `ckga|c` pfap hm {d na| a{ hp hm~dg~c{kddzc|aph~c{ whpf cezgdxcc{ wfd a|c mdp ecelc|{ d| kd%dwmc|{ pfc|cdn' kc|pahmgx {skf cezgdxcc{ a|c cmphpgc` pdcvc|kh{c pfc |hofp{ dn agg wd|ic|{ pd d|oamhraphdm' kdggckph~cla|oahmhmo' mcodphaphdm{ am` dpfc|{ a{ a|c cm{f|hmc` hm pfcKdm{phpsphdm am` cvh{phmo gaw{ dn pfc kdsmp|x-

Pfc zslghk |c{zdm`cmp ndsm` pfap zcphphdmc| nahgc` pd {fdw amxz|ddn pfap amx ecelc| dn pfc z|h~apc |c{zdm`cmp wa{ ag{d aecelc| d| kd%dwmc| dn pfc zcphphdmc|%kddzc|aph~c- Fcmkc pfcecelc|{ dn pfc z|h~apc |c{zdm`cmp kdsg` ~agh`gx nd|e a gald|d|oamhraphdm-Y10U

Hm pfc hm{pamp zcphphdm' MD\CKD 1 nahg{ pd kdmp|d~c|p pfc{papcecmp dn pfc Kds|p dn Azzcag{ pfap pfc zcphphdmc| nahgc` pd{fdw amx z|ddn pfap amx ecelc| dn pfc z|h~apc |c{zdm`cmpwa{ ag{d a ecelc| d| kd%dwmc| dn pfc zcphphdmc|kddzc|aph~c- Ed|c hezd|pamp' pfc nakpsag h{{sc h{ mdp nd| pfcKds|p dn Azzcag{ pd |c{dg~c hm a zcphphdm nd| kc|phd|a|h- Nhmaggx'pfc hm{pamp zcphphdm aelhosds{gx {papc{ pfap MD\CKD1 h{ amcgckp|hk kddzc|aph~c am` agg pfc cezgdxcc{ dn pfc {slbckpsmhdm a|c ecelc|{ dn pfc kddzc|aph~c' lsp {slehppc` akc|phnhc` gh{p dn cezgdxcc{ wfd a|c ecelc|{%kd%dwmc|{ dn pfczcphphdmc| cgckp|hk kddzc|aph~c- Hezghc gx' pfc|c a|c |ami%am`%nhgc cezgdxcc{ dn pfc zcphphdmc| wfd a|c mdp pfce{cg~c{ecelc|{%kd%dwmc|{' d| wfd a|c pfc dmc{ qsaghnhc` pd nd|e d|

bdhm a gald| d|oamhraphdm- Aoahm' pfc kd|c h{{sc |ah{c{ aqsc{phdm dn nakp pfap pfc azzcggapc kds|p kd||ckpgx `ckghmc` pd|c{dg~c hm pfc nh|{p hm{pamkc-

_FC\CND\C' pfc zcphphdm h{ @CMHC@ nd| gaki dn ec|hp-

[D D\@C\C@-

http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2001/may2001/143616.htm#_edn14http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2001/may2001/143616.htm#_edn14