Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
-
Upload
anonymous-3hf2txf -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
1/7
NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS LAW
Compilation of Digested Cases
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I Int!od"#tion
Applicability of the Negotiable Instruments Law
Kauman vs. PNB, ! Phil "#!, $eptember !%, "%!"
&$I$ vs. 'A, "() $'*A +, -ebruary !, "%#%
'oncept of Negotiable Instruments
o iba/ia vs. 'A, !! $'*A "0
o PAL vs. 'A, &*. %"##, 1an. ), "%%)
Negotiable Instruments 'ompare2 with other Papers
*ea23 $esbreno vs. 'A, &* #%!+!, 4ay !, "%%
$ome Non5Negotiable Instruments
Philippine 62ucation 'o. vs. $oriano, &* L5!!)+, 1une ), "%("
4etropolitan Ban7 vs. 'A, "% $'*A "0% 8"%%"9
II Fo!m and Inte!p!etation of Negotia$le Inst!"ments
". :ow Negotiability is ;etermine2
'alte< 8Philippines9 vs. 'A, !"! $'*A #, Aug. "), "%%!
!. 6ect of 6stoppel
Banco 2e =ro vs. 6>uitable Ban7ing 'orp.? "+( $'*A "## 8"%##9
Phil. Ban7 of 'ommerce vs. Aruego, ")! $'*A +), 1an. ", "%#"
. *e>uisites of Negotiability 8$ec. ", NIL9
*ea23 4etropolitan Ban7 vs. 'A, "% $'*A "0%, -eb. "#, "%%"
Pay vs. Palanca, +( $'*A 0"#
*ea23 Ang e7 Lian vs. 'A, #( Phil #, $ept. !+, "%+)
III T!ansfe! and Negotiation
". Issuance@;elivery of Negotiable Instruments
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
2/7
;ela ictoria vs. Burgos, !+ $'*A (, 1une !(, "%%+
. Assignment an2 Negotiation ;istinguishe2? Liability of Assignor
'asabuena vs. 'A, !#0 $'*A +%
. :ow are Negotiable Instruments an2 Non5Negotiable Instrumentsransferre2
$esbreno vs. 'A, !!! $'*A 00, 4ay !, "%%
'onsoli2ate2 Plywoo2 vs. I-' Leasing, "% $'*A #, April ), "%#(
ra2ers *oyal Ban7 vs. 'A, !0% $'*A "0, 4arch , "%%(
+. :ow Negotiation a7es Place
4anuel Lim vs. 'A, !+" $'*A )%, ;ec. "%, "%%+
;ela ictoria vs. Burgos, !+ $'*A (, 1une !(, "%%+
;evelopment Ban7 of *ial vs. $ima Cei, !"( $'*A (, 4arch %, "%%
%. =ther *ules on In2orsement 8$ec. ", !, )5#, %, NIL9
6nri>ue 4ontinola vs. PNB, 0# Phil "(#, -eb. !0, "%+"
Ang e7 Lian vs. 'A, &* L5!+"0, $ept. !+, "%+)
"). Kin2s of In2orsement
4etropol 8Bacolo29 -inancing vs. $ambo7 4otors, "!) $'*A #0,
-eb. !#, "%#
&empesaw vs. 'A, !"# $'*A 0!#, -eb. %, "%%
Chat 'onstitutes alue 8$ec. !+, NIL9
Bibiano Banas vs. 'A, !+ $'*A !+%, -eb. "), !)))
I% &olde!s
". Chat is a hol2er 8$ec. "%", NIL9
'han Can vs. an Kim, ")% Phil ()0, $ept. ), "%0)
Atrium 4anagement vs. 'A, " $'A; %), -eb. !#, !))"
4arcelo 4esina vs. 'A, "+ $'*A %(, Nov. ", "%#0
!. :ol2ers in ;ue 'ourse 8$ec. +!, +, +, ++, +0, ##, NIL9
6>uitable Ban7ing vs. $pecial $teel, &* "(++), 1une ", !)"!
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
3/7
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
4/7
o
%I Defenses
". *eal an2 Personal ;efenses ;istinguishe2
!. *eal ;efenses
;efense of 4inority not otal 8$ee Art. "", New 'ivil 'o2e9
Atrium 4anagement 'orp. vs. 'A, &* ")%%", -eb. !#, !))"
'risologo51ose vs. 'A, &*. #)+%%, $ept. "%#%
-orgery of Bearer Instrument
Associate2 Ban7 vs. 'A, &* ")(#!, 1an. ", "%%0 82octrine of
comparative negligence9
&empesaw vs. 'A, !"# $'*A 0#!, -eb. %, "%%
*epublic vs. 6bra2a, &* L5)(0%, 1uly ", "%(+
4C$$ vs. 'A
Persons Preclu2e2 from $etting Ep -orgery
4C$$ vs. 'A, &* L50!%, 1uly ", "%#0
4etropolitan Ban7 vs. 'A, "% $'*A "0% 8"%%"9
$amsung 'onstruction vs. -ar 6ast Ban7, &* "!%)"+, Aug. "+, !))
PNB vs Fuimpo, "+# $'*A +#!, 4arch ", "%##
Banco 2e =ro vs. 6>uitable Ban7ing, &* (%"(, 1an. !), "%##
Cestmont Ban7 vs. 6ugene =ng, &* "!!+), 1an. ), !))!
Ilusorio vs. 'A, &* "%"), Nov. !(, !))!
ra2ers *oyal Ban7 vs. *PN, &* "#+"), =ct. "), !))!
BPI vs. 'A
Ban7 of America vs. Associate2 'itiens Ban7, 4ay !", !))%
4aterial Alteration Gpartial 2efenseH 8$ec. "!, "!+, NIL9
PNB vs. 'A, !+0 $'*A %", April !+, "%%0
4ontinola vs. PNB, ## Phil "(#, -eb. !0, "%+"
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
5/7
6
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
6/7
o Asia Ban7ing vs. 1avier, &* "%)+", April "%!
o &ullas vs. PNB, &* "%", Nov. ", "%+
o Nyco $ales vs. BA -inance, !)) $'*A 0(, "%%"
o &reat Asian $ales vs. 'A, &* ")+((, April !+, !))!
o Luis Cong vs 'A, &* ""(#+(, -eb. !, !))"
%III Dis#)a!ge of Inst!"ments
$urren2er of Instrument upon ;ischarge
$tate Investment :ouse vs. 'A, &* ")""0, 1an. "", "%%
I+ C)e#,s
a. 'hec7s 2ene2 8$ec. "#+, "#0, "#%, NIL9
Banco 2e =ro $avings vs. 6>uitable Ban7ing 'orp., "+( $'*A "##
8"%##9
b. ;istinguishe2 from ;rafts
*P vs. Philippine National Ban7, &* L5"0")0, ;ec. ), "%0"
c. *elationship between ;rawer, ;rawee, an2 Payee
2. Kin2s of 'hec7s
certie2 chec7 8$ec. "#(5"#%, NIL9
New Pacic imber vs. :on. $eneris, ;ec. "%, "%#)
PNB vs. National 'ity Ban7 of New Dor7, 0 Phil (""
eects of crossing a chec7
Associate2 Ban7 vs. 'A, !)# $'*A 0# 8"%%!9
Bataan 'igar vs. 'A, !) $'*A 0#, 4arch , "%%
&empesaw vs. 'A, !"# $'*A 0#!, -eb. , "%% $tate Investment :ouse vs. 'A "%#%
memoran2um an2 travellerJs chec7
People vs Nitafan, &* (+%+, =ct. !!, "%%!
*elationship between, Payee, ;rawer, ;rawee
-
7/24/2019 Nego Cases_atty. Reyes (Ausl)
7/7
$pouses 4oran vs. 'A, &* ")+#0, 4arch (, "%%
&empesaw vs. 'A
:ong7ong an2 $hanghai Ban7 vs. 'atalan, =ct. "#, !))
iron cla2 rule for cashierJs chec7s 4esina vs. IA'
'rimes Involving 'hec7s
BP !!
;omangsang vs. 'A, ( $'*A (+ 8!)))9
'hec7 Kiting GArt."+ 8"b9, *P'9
*amos vs. 'A, !) $'*A 0+(