NEAUPG NCHRP 9-47A Findings€¦ · Production Field Comp. Production Field Comp. Walla Walla, WA...
23
! !"#$%& ())*+,- !"#$%&'(#$) +, -./012" 33) 3456
Transcript of NEAUPG NCHRP 9-47A Findings€¦ · Production Field Comp. Production Field Comp. Walla Walla, WA...
!
!"#$%&'())*+,-!"#$%&'(#$)*+,-./012"*33)**3456
"
./*0+,)
!7"082./9*:;#<=#/2>!:&'%&22"%&'*7"0?2"/%29!!%2<>*72"@0"$#&.2!A=$$#"B*0@*!%&>%&'9
#
1234*+2, 52/*) 6(#'7)38,202-+)9 :4*)';2,9*<
A/C*D0=%9)*+-* E#<<*A/"22/ :;0/(2"$*:F)*A#901%/)*,9?(#G$%& +#BG344H
I"0&*+/&C)*+I +JK A#901%/ A2?G344H
A%<;2"/(0"&2)*L- IGM4 ,>;2"#)*A#901%/)*:;0/(2"$*N,F ,='G344M
!"#&O<%&)*FP AQ6K ,9/2.*NRS)*,>;2"#)*:;0/(2"$*N,F)* A#901%/ -./G344M
S"#(#$)*FT* UA*VW4* ,9/2.*NRS X=&G344W
S20"'2)*Y,* IGJ4* A#901%/ X=&G344W
Y#<<#*Y#<<#)*Y, UAG53 +#Z#$*,[=#1<#.O ,?"G3454
L2&/"2;%<<2)*\, IGHH* ,9/2.*NRS X=&G3454
Q#?%>*Q%;2")*+I* LQGK5V :;0/(2"$*VS)*#&>*,>;2"# X=&G3454
R#O2")*+F* Q0=/2*V33 :;0/(2"$*N,F ,='G3454
+=&9/2")*IP* L#<=$2/*,;2C :;0/(2"$)*S2&.0"*@0#$)*E2"%/#'2*]#Z A2?G3454
X2@@C*L0C)*!D)* AQ*V4 F2"2Z*@0#$%&'*9B9/2$ -./G3454
^=22&9)*P_* D%//<2*P2.O*7O]B L2.#1#92)*A0&&2Y#"$%Z)*R%/=F2.(*7:Q -./G3454
L#92*S"#&>2)*,` AQ*W6 A#901%/ N2.G3455
!;=5%'>?@A#'%B2C)3*9
Production FieldComp. Production FieldComp.WallaWalla,WA Aquablack 275 270 325 310Centrevil le,VA AstecDBG 288 268 318 294RapidRiver,MI Evotherm3G 269 239 300 255RapidRiver,MI Advera 269 227 300 255
Baker,MT EvothermDAT 262 NA 298 282Munster,IN Wax 268 235 300 249Munster,IN Gencorfoam 277 222 300 249Munster,IN Evotherm3G 256 210 300 249NewYork,NY BituTechPER 279 238 344 299NewYork,NY Cecabase 247 221 344 299NewYork,NY SonneWarmix 262 222 344 299
JeffersonCo.,FL Terexfoam 297 247 336 269CasaGrande,AZ Sasobit 276 257 320 297
Avg.WMATemperature,°F Avg.HMATemp.,°FProjectLocation Technology
MixingandCompactionTemperatures
$
!F"=2*R%&>2"*S"#>29! I&*7<#.2*N2&9%/%29!L0"2*/2&9%<2*9/"2&'/(9!FAQ!!P!E#$1="'!:a
",-+,))B+,- %B2G)B*+)9
!"#"$%"$&#'()*+,#-$%*.%/$012-34*52-3!#+2
TrueBinderGradesDifferences(WMA-HMA)(MixSampledDuringConstruction)
Location WMAConstruction
D HighTemp D LowTempWallaWalla,WA Aquablack -2.6 -1.9Centerville,VA AstecDBG 1.2 -1.8
RapidRiver,MIEvotherm3G -0.9 0.4
Advera 0.7 0.0Baker,MT EvothermDAT -0.1 0.4
Munster,INEvotherm3G -2.7 -2.2
GencorUltrafoam -4.2 -1.8HeritageWax -2.1 0.6
JeffersonCo.,FL TerexCMIFoam -2.1 0.6
NewYork,NYCecabase -5.7 -4.8
SonneWarmix -4.5 -3.3BituTechPER -5.3 -3.5
CasaGrande,AZ Sasobit -2.0 0.6Average -2.3 -1.3
MaximumTemp Difference -5.7 -4.8MinimumTemp Difference 1.2 0.6
TrueBinderGradesDifferences(WMA-HMA)1st and2nd Inspection
Location WMA
1YearCores 2YearCoresD HighTemp
D LowTemp
D HighTemp
D LowTemp
WallaWalla,WA Aquablack 1 -0.1 2.1 1.8Centerville,VA AstecDBG -8.6 -4.2 1.1 2.1
RapidRiver,MIEvotherm3G -1.5 0.7 -3.7 0.0
Advera 3.0 1.9 -1.6 0.0Baker,MT EvothermDAT -1.1 -2.3 -3.9 1.2
Munster,INEvotherm3G -1.1 1.2 -3.5 -0.7
GencorUltrafoam -2.3 -1.3 -1.3 -0.4HeritageWax -2.1 1.1 1.9 4.4
JeffersonCo.,FL TerexCMIFoam -3.0 -1.4 -6.6 -5.7
NewYork,NYCecabase 0.6 -2.0 0.9 -0.6
SonneWarmix 0.1 -1.8 0.3 -1.3BituTechPER 0.5 -3.4 4.4 1.0
CasaGrande,AZ Sasobit 4.2 -1.0 - -Average -0.8 -1.0 -0.8 0.2
MaximumTempDifference -8.6 -4.2 -6.6 -5.7MinimumTempDifference 4.2 1.9 4.4 4.4
%
V,'%043)':),9+*+)9'JXK
67"2-(89(:2#-%67"2-()*.%"-;&"$*.
!
"
#
$
%
&!
&"
&#
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!"
!#$%
&'()*+),*%
-.(/0*10)
!
"
#
$
%
&!
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!
" "
#$%
&'()*+),*%
-.(/0*10
&
7),9+0)'L*B),-*8'IB2F';2B)9'JXK
!
"
#
$
%
&!
&"
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!"
! !
#$%
&'()*
+),*%
-.(/0*1
0
!
"
#
$
%
&!
&"
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!!
!
!
"#$
%&'()
*(+)$
,-'./)0
/67"2-(89(:2#-%67"2-()*.%"-;&"$*.
!'
7L5?##L=7.'(POP'JX'2B'YK
4
4C3
4C6
4CH
4CW
5
5C3,[
=#1<
#.O
,9/2
.*NR
S
:;0/
(2"$
*N,F
A#90
1%/
F2"2
Z*@0
#$
,9/2
.*NR
S
,>;2
"#
:;0/
(2"$
*VS
:;0/
(2"$
S2&.
0"*@0
#$
E2"%/
#'2*
]#Z
R%/=
F2.(
*7:Q
L2.#
1#92
A0&&
2Y#"
$%Z
,9/2
.*NR
S
:;0/
(2"$
*N,F
,>;2
"#*
A#90
1%/
:;0/
(2"$
*N,F
A#90
1%/
:;0/
(2"$
*:F
,9?(
#G$
%&
Y, \, +F ,` !D FT +I +I IP IP IP P_ P_ P_ FP FP L- L- L- +- +- +-
Y+,
E+,
!!
Z02M'!/F[)B'JY2B'XK! F29/*F2$?2"#/="2G
DF77R%&>*;VC5b**K4c**"2<%#1%<%/B*#/*34$$*d9="@#.2*<#B2"9e
! Q2?2#/2>*>2;%#/0"%.*9/"299*0@*WM*?9%dH44*O7#e
!U&.0&@%&2>*.0&>%/%0&9!
"
#
$
%
&!
&"
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!
""
#$%
&'()*
+),*%
-.(/0*10
!"
=(#'Z!'5)9/0*9'N9<';B+*)B+4
7B4II+3\'("L#19
(+,<'Z02M'!2<
fV P,V*/0*f54 KV54*/0*fV4 5J4
g*V4 M64
%B2C)3* 52/*) (+D'=)4*+,- Z!
R#O2")*+F Q0=/2*V33 Q2(2#/2> JW
Q#?%>*Q%;2")*+I LQGK5V Q2(2#/2> 5JJ
L#9#*S"#&>2)*,` AQ*W6 P0 H5
X2@@2"90&*L0C)*!D AQ*V4P0 656
Q2(2#/2> 3V5
^=22&9)*P_ D%//<2*P2.O*7O]B P0 3J5
+=&9/2")*IP L#<=$2/*,;2C P0 KH5
Y#<<#*Y#<<#)*Y, UAG53P0 VV3
Q2(2#/2> 63H
L2&/"2;%<<2)*\, IGHH Q2(2#/2> 5WKK
!"#$%&$'()*+(),$&'!-.$-/*0$<=>(?#@'2(AB9C
!#
6(#'Z!'5)9/0*9'N9<';B+*)B+4
7B4II+3\'("L#19
(+,<'Z02M'!2<
fV P,V*/0*f54 V454*/0*fV4 54K
g*V4 65K
7"082./ Q0=/2 +%Z*E2#/%&' Y+,*,>>%/%;2 !P
R#O2")*+F Q0=/2*V33 QE :;0/(2"$*N,F KW
Q#?%> Q%;2")*+I LQGK5VQE ,>;2"# H4QE :;0/(2"$*VS HK
L#9#*S"#&>2)*,` AQ*W6 P0 A#901%/ 6H
X2@@2"90&*L0C)*!D AQ*V4QE F2"2Z*!0#$ 53MP0 F2"2Z*!0#$ 5KM
^=22&9)*P_ D%//<2*P2.O*7O]B
P0 L2.#1#92 55KP0 A0&&2Y#"$%Z 53VP0 R%/=F2.(*7:Q 53W
+=&9/2")*IP L#<=$2/*,;2CP0 :;0/(2"$*VS 5MMP0 S2&.0"*!0#$ 35MP0 E2"%/#'2*Y#Z V56
Y#<<#*Y#<<#)*Y, UAG53P0 +#Z#$*,[=#1<#.O 344QE +#Z#$*,[=#1<#.O 33M
L2&/"2;%<<2)*\, IGHH QE ,9/2.*NRS 6VJ
&'!-.$1234$")5$6+7)89$'()*+(),
!(
=4F[/B-?##L=7.'7'PO@'JX'2B'YKA?2.%$2&9*@#1"%.#/2>*%&*/(2*@%2<>b*K4hL*]#/2"*1#/(b*54)444*.B.<29
!
"
#
$
%
&!
&"
&#
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!"
#
$%&
'()*+
,*-+&
./)01+2
1
!
"
#
$
%
&!
&"
'()* +,-*. /012*.
!"
#
!
$%&
'()*+,*-+&
./)01+21
!"#$%&'#( )#*+''+,-$.,/0&1#+2,$32+,#
!,,AEF-*77*H5G54*!55*0@*5V*.0$?#"%90&9*(#;2*<0]2"*:a*
@0"*Y+,*@0"*#/*<2#9/*0&2*/2$?2"#/="2*#&>*@"2[=2&.B
:],4F+3'(2E/0/9''Ji2B'X'e
!)
! I&*?<#.2*>2&9%/%29*dje! F2&9%<2*A/"2&'/(*@"0$*.0"29*dje! FAQ*dj*0"ie!E#$1="'**dj*0"*ie! !P*dj*0"*ie! :a*dj*0"*ie
!;=5%'>?@A'#?",-+,))B+,-'%B2G)B*+)9'L/FF4B]'
!*
Z+)0E'%)BI2BF4,3)'"N40/4*+2,'%B23)E/B)
! F("22*344G@00/**92./%0&9*?2"*$%Z*! F("22*Hk*>%#C*.0"29*@"0$*%&*"%'(/*](22<?#/()*#&>*@0="*
Hk*>%#*.0"29**@"0$*%&*12/]22&*](22<?#/(9!L0"29*=92>*/0*>2/2"$%&2*/(2*%&G?<#.2*>2&9%/B*%&>%"2./*
/2&9%<2*9/"2&'/(9)*9?2.%@%.*'"#;%/B)*'"#>#/%0&)*#9?(#</*.0&/2&/)*#&>*/(2*/"=2*1%&>2"*'"#>2*@0"*2#.(*$%ZC
FieldPerformance-ExistingProjectsProject Mix Rutting(mm) Cracking(m)
St.Louis,MO(5years5months)
HMA 2 191Sasobit <1 333
EvothermET 2 255Asphamin-Zeolite 2 399
IronMtn.,MI(4years9months)
HMA 1 1
Sasobit 0 14
Silverthorne,CO(3years2months)
HMA 6 3Advera 4 0Sasobit 6 1
EvothermDAT 6 1
Franklin,TN(3years5months)
HMA 0 9Advera <1 32
AstecDBG <1 18EvothermDAT 0 1
Sasobit 0 96Graham,TX(2years6months)
HMA 0 18
Astec 0 25
FieldPerformance-NewProjectsProject Mix Rutting(mm) Cracking(m)
WallaWalla,WA HMA 5 1MaxamAquablack 0 0
Centreville,VA HMA 3 1AstecDBG 3 1
RapidRiver,MIHMA 0 0
Evotherm3G 0 0Advera 0 0
Baker,MT HMA 1 0EvothermDAT 0 0
Munster,IN
HMA 0 4GencorFoam 0 36Evotherm3G 0 0HeritageWax 0 0
Jeff.Co.,FL, HMA 3 0TerexFoam 3 0
Queens,NY
HMA - 9Cecabase <1 20
SonneWarmix - 5BituTechPER - 5
Casagrande,AZ HMA 3 NASasobit 0 NA
"'
L/FF4B]?",-+,))B+,-'%B2G)B*+)9!Q2.0;2"2>*1%&>2"9*@"0$*?<#&/*?"0>=.2>*$%Z29l /"=2*1%&>2"*
'"#>29*9(0]*/(#/*Y+,*1%&>2"9*(#>*#'2>*9<%'(/<B*<299*/(#&*E+,*1%&>2"9*
!Q2.0;2"2>*1%&>2"9*@"0$*5G3*B2#"*.0"29*G /"=2*'"#>29*0@*E+,*#&>*Y+,*&0/*9=19/#&/%#<<B*>%@@2"2&/)**;2"B*<%//<2*0"*&0*9/%@@2&%&'*@"0$*/%$2*0@*.0&9/"=./%0&
!FAQ*/29/*G W3c*0@*$%Z29*?#992>*/(2*9/#&>#">*4CW*FAQ*."%/2"%0&*G H*$%Z29*@#%<2>m*@0="*Y+,*#&>*/]0*E+,*$%Z29
!!P*"29=</9*@0"*Y+,*$%Z29*<0]2"*/(#&*E+,*d3nV*0@*/(2*.0$?#"%90&9e
"!
L/FF4B]?",-+,))B+,-'%B2G)B*+)9! !P*."%/2"%#*"2.0$$2&>2>*%&*PLEQ7*Q2?0"/*HMV*@0"*E+,*#&>*
PLEQ7*Q2?0"/*HJ5*@0"*Y+,*d%&.<=>2>*&0]*%&*,,AEF-*F7*MJe*922$*#??"0?"%#/2*@0"*2;#<=#/%&'*?<#&/*?"0>=.2>*$%Z29*#&>*<#1*$%Z29
! E#$1="'*/29/9*G KJc*0@*Y+,*$%Z29*(#>*9/#/%9/%.#<<B*2[=%;#<2&/*"=/*>2?/(9*/(#&*E+,*$%Z29)*0/(2"*65c*0@*Y+,*$%Z29*(#>*'"2#/2"*"=/*>2?/(9
! A/#/%9/%.#<*#&#<B929*%&>%.#/2*/(#/*/(2*>B&#$%.*$0>=<%*0@*Y+,*#"2*<0]2"*/(#&*E+,*$%Z/="29* @0"*#/*<2#9/*0&2*/2$?C*#&>*@"2[=2&.B)*@0"*3*?"082./9*"29=</9*#"2*2[=%;#<2&/***
""
L/FF4B]'Z+,E+,-! Y+,*92./%0&9*(#;2*?2"@0"$2>*9#$2*#9*E+,*92./%0&9*]%/(*
"2'#">*/0*"=//%&'*)*&0&2*0@*/(2*@%2<>*?"082./9*(#>*#&B*2;%>2&.2*0@*$0%9/="2*>#$#'2
! D%//<2*."#.O%&'*]#9*0192";2>C*F"#&9;2"92*."#.O%&'*]#9*/(2*$09/*.0$$0&*/B?2*0@*."#.O9C**-@*/(2*?"082./9*]%/(*/"#&9;2"92*."#.O%&')*Y+,*#&>*E+,*92./%0&9*'2&2"#<<B*(#>*9%$%<#"*#$0=&/9
! Y+,*>%>*&0/*#??2#"*/0*(#;2*2@@2./*0&*>2&9%/%29**=&>2"*/"#@@%.C**F(%9*0192";#/%0&*]#9*.0&@0=&>2>*1B*/(2*@#./*/(#/*$#&B*0@*/(2*Y+,*/29/*92./%0&9*.0&9/"=./2>*%&*>%@@2"2&/*<#&29*/(#&*/(2*E+,*92./%0&9
!!!"#$%&"'(
