NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
Transcript of NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
1/22
10th
National Convention on Statistics (NCS)EDSA Shangri-La Hotel
October 1-2, 2007
Statistics on Filipinos International Migration:Issues and Steps Towards Harmonizing the Databy
Jeremaiah M. Opiniano
For additional information, please contact:
Authors name : Jeremaiah M. OpinianoDesignation : Executive DirectorAffiliation : Institute for Migration and Development IssuesAddress : 653 Sanggumay ST., Mandaluyong CityTel. no. : (0632) 532-2519 / (063917) 823-8260
E-mail : [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
2/22
Statistics on Filipinos International Migration:Issues and Steps Towards Harmonizing the Data
by
Jeremaiah M. Opiniano1
ABSTRACT
This policy paper is intended to present what is perhaps the state of internationalmigration statistics in the Philippines, with statistics on this overseas movement by Filipinoscurrently patchy and scattered. The paper also presents a snapshot of an integrated set ofstatistics on the international migration of Filipinos, that which has not been done before. Fromthere, some of the issues and concerns on the system of international migration statistics havebeen identified. This policy paper hopes to enlighten concerned stakeholders of the necessityto support efforts to improve the harmonization of international migration statistics. If thissituation happens, the Philippines will be ready to juxtapose international migration statisticswith usual Philippine socio-economic and demographic data so that steps can be determinedto harness the development potential of international migration.
I. Introduction
International migration is a very fluid phenomenon. In the case of the Philippines, the
fluidity of these cross-border population movements covers 193 countries and territories, as
well as ocean-plying vessels. These overseas migration movements by Filipinos are also
economic in nature, whether the movement is for overseas work (thus, temporary in nature),
permanent settlement, or unauthorized or clandestine migration. A publication on
demographic concepts2even mentions that migration (both internal and international) is a
demographic process that is difficult to measure because these movements are not
normally recorded. International migration is even more difficult to measure because most
countries do not have reliable data on foreigners and migration movements (Commission on
Population, undated). On a global level, the United Nations Statistics Division is
implementing measures to address the data gaps on international migration statistics.
The Philippines, though, is lucky: for having a well-placed government structure that
facilitates the international movement of people, statistics on Filipinos international migration
is fairly developed (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007a, 2007b). Gaps are expected from these, but
the basic socio-economic and demographic variables of these international migration
statistics are spelled out.
1It is to note that the author is not a demographer or a statistician by training. This paper is presented in the context that the
author is versed with international migration dynamics and movements in the Philippines, has ground-level experiences withFilipinos abroad and with their families in the Philippines, and has personally initiated efforts to put together internationalmigration statistics from various sources. He belongs to a nonprofit organization, the Institute for Migration and DevelopmentIssues (IMDI). It is a nonprofit thinktank that is involved in analyzing the development implications of Filipinos internationalmigration through research, advocacy, networking, and development journalism. Views of a data user prevail in this paper.2
Even within the field of demography, international migration is the least studied demographic process compared to fertility andmortality.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
3/22
As early as 1989, some international migration scholars have called for the
harmonization of international migration statistics (Benjamin Carino 1989). Now that Filipinos
abroad number to an estimated 8.2 million as of the year 2006, the clamor to harmonize
such datasets is all the more important. The pursuit of harmonization of international
migration statistics comes at a time when global development experts and international
migration analysts have noted the immense economic contributions of migrants, especially
to developing countries (World Bank 2003).
More than ever, this time necessitates the beginning of steps to harmonize
international migration statistics (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007b). In recent months,
stakeholders of the countrys international migration sector (especially government agencies)
have begun reflecting their data capturing mechanisms on international migration. The steps
at analyzing migration data are ongoing.
This policy research intends to basically outline the state of international migration
data collection in the Philippines, and present the gaps and issues in this periodic effort. The
general context here is that international migration is a phenomenon so difficult to track, that
relies on multiple sources (both in the Philippines and in host countries), and that is also a
fairly new statistical arena to be developed by people in the fields of demography and
statistics in the Philippines. This policy research is also an offshoot of previous work as
technical editor of a forthcoming government publication on the population and development
implications of Filipinos international labor migration3.
II. Framework
This paper will be guided by a framework on the interaction between population anddevelopment as a means to organize the presentation of existing datasets on Filipinos
international migration (see Figure 1). This population and development framework,
developed by Dr. Alejandro Herrin (in NEDA-IPDP, 1993), was a useful guide in segregating
these international migration statistics by type of overseas Filipino, and by identified socio-
economic and demographic variables.
3 This report, called the Fourth State of the Philippine Population Report, covers only one aspect of international migration labor migration that pertains to one type of overseas Filipino in temporary contract workers. These temporary contract workersare also prominently referred to as overseas Filipino workers (OFWs).
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
4/22
The PopDev framework basically shows how the three demographic processes
(fertility, mortality, and migration) lead to population outcomes such population size, the
distribution of the population by age and sex, that all affect various development processes
in many ways (NEDA-IPDP, 1993). The end result here is the enumeration of development
outcomes and how these affect the population, as well as determining the extent to which
the country achieves its development objectives. These outcomes are expressed in terms of
measures such as income distribution, levels of employment, education, health and
nutritional status, among others. In turn, these socio-economic outcomes also affect the very
processes of fertility, mortality, and migration (NEDA-IPDP, 1993; see Figure 1).
The framework for this paper also serves as a jump-off point to analyze the gaps in the
current system of international migration statistics and data capturing.
Figure 1: Framework on population and development inter-relationships
(NEDA-IPDP, 1993)
III. Terminologies and available statistics
Types of overseas economic migration by Filipinos. This paper begins with
distinguishing the types of Filipinos going abroad. Filipinos emigrating overseas are, in the
majority, land- workers and residents. But contract workers who ply ocean-going vessels
otherwise called as seafarers are considered overseas workers. This classification system
comes from the Commission on Filipinos Overseas, a government agency that releases an
annual stock estimates on overseas Filipinos.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
5/22
Filipinos abroad are primarily classified into three when pertaining to their immigration status.
This classification is what an inter-agency government group is using when determining
annual stock estimates of the Filipino presence abroad (in Commission on Filipinos
Overseas, 2006):
Permanent migrants These refer to Filipino migrants and legal permanent residents
abroad. Permanent migrants may be Filipinos who are Filipino citizens, who are
Philippine passport holders, or who have been naturalized citizens in the host country.
Popular labels to these kinds of migrants are immigrants and emigrants;
Temporary migrants These refer to Filipinos whose stay overseas, while regular
and properly documented, is temporary. This is owed to the employment-related
nature of their status in the host country. Temporary migrants include contract
workers, intra-company transferees, students, trainees, entrepreneurs, businessmen,
traders, and others whose stay abroad is six months or more, as well as their
accompanying. These migrants are popularly referred to as overseas contract
workers (OCWs) or overseas Filipino workers (OFWs); and
Irregular migrants These are migrants whose stay abroad is not properly
documented. They also do not have valid residence and work permits; they can also
be overstaying workers or tourists in a foreign country. These migrants falling into
this category shall have been in such status for six months or more. A non-discriminatory label for these migrants is undocumented migrants. In Filipino
international migration parlance, these migrants are called TNTs (tago ng tago or
always in hiding).
This classification system is relevant for international migration statistics in the
Philippines since these reflect the types of overseas migration movements by Filipinos. We
can say that almost all international migration movements by Filipinos are economic innature, unlike in other countries where there are refugee movements and asylum seeking
situations.
One should also take note that many of the socio-economic consequences of
Filipinos international migration overlap with the types of overseas migration movements.
Ground-level experiences with overseas Filipinos and their families in the Philippines reveal
such observation, even as studies and literature on international migration have documented
much the consequences of temporary migration or international labor migration (which
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
6/22
remains the popular mode of overseas migration movement, especially given the demand for
unskilled and skilled Filipino workers by developed and developing countries). An example of
an overlapping consequence that covers all these types of overseas migration movements
by Filipinos is remittances. Bank data from the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas have no way of
determining that this money (which is sent as a deposit to a recipients account) comes from
which type of overseas Filipino4.
It is thus relevant that data capturing agencies and analysts of international migration
analysts should always look at this broader picture of international migration movements by
Filipinos. It is difficult to focus on just one type of migration movement and isolate the rest.
For example, migration stock estimates by CFO will reveal the rising number of Filipinos
permanently settling in overseas countries, with some of them first becoming temporary
contract workers then they availed of immigration and citizenship opportunities of the host
countries. Unfortunately, seeing existing studies on Filipinos international migration, the
emphasis has been more on temporary migration and there is some tendency to generalize
that international labor migration is international migration per se. A look at international
migration statistics should not disregard other types of migration flows especially if these
other types of migration bring forth positive and negative socio-economic consequences to
the Philippines. Pertaining to remittances, a rural banker himself said Filipinos abroad may
have become American, German, or Australian but the money they send comes from the
Filipino pocket.
Statistics available. International migration statistics in the Philippines, generally speaking,
come from the home country and fro host countries. It has been challenging to make sense
of these statistics coming from various sources:
Home country
1. One data source is the actual registers of people migrating overseas (including those
migrating once again), especially if these people pass through the relevant
government agencies that process their overseas migration. This is the major source
4Revisions to the reporting of migrants remittances data in the countrys Balance of Payments (which summarizes a countrys
financial transactions with the rest of the world) were made in 2005. Nevertheless, even if the flows of money are juxtaposed tothe countries where overseas Filipinos are, there is no way that Balance of Payments data can determine that these moniescome from temporary migrants and permanent residents. If by undocumented migrants, these monies pass through non-banking channels.
For example, Bangko Sentral data show that the United States is the top source of remittances and it is the countrywith the most number of permanent residents, though with some tens of thousands of temporary migrants and undocumentedmigrants. However, BSPs monthly public updating of remittance figures reveals that these monies are labeled as OFWremittances, with reference to temporary contract workers or temporary migrants. This example reveals the overlaps ininternational migration statistics, which are difficult to untangle.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
7/22
of statistics for overseas Filipinos, although one should take note of Filipinos who
have migrated either legally or illegally, and who did not pass through these
government agencies in the home country;
2. Another source is surveys done by the countrys official statisticians. The Philippines
has also developed a means in which its five- or ten-year census of the population
covers households with dependents or relatives overseas, as well as the Filipinos
abroad who have not given up their Filipino citizenship; and
3. A special dataset in the countrys international migration statistics system covers
bank receipts, reflecting the flows of remittances to the country. These data on
money flows cannot be segregated by socio-demographic variables (especially by
gender) that usual data capturing instruments do. At the same time, the countrys
Bank Secrecy Law prohibits the revelation of the details of these remittance flows
even as banks follow strict know-your-customer (KYC) policies when dealing with
customers such as remitters.
Host countries
In general, international migration statistics in host countries come from population
registers, immigration and/or border statistics, and residence permits (United Nations
Statistics Division 2006). For undocumented migration, some host countries have
surveys or reports designed to determine the number of these undocumented (or
what host countries call illegal) migrants. The Philippiness 86 embassies and
consulates have been tasked by the homeland government to annually get data from
these sources so that they will be able to provide an annual estimate of how many
documented and undocumented Filipinos are in the said host country or countries.
Tables 1 to 3 outline existing international migration statistics, and the sources ofthese data. The data have been segregated by type of migration movement or type of
overseas Filipino since the dynamics of each type of movement differ, and are presented in
accordance with the PopDev framework of Alejandro Herrin (NEDA-IPDP 1993). Noticeably,
most of the data available cover temporary migrants, with the data reinforced by surveys by
the National Statistics Office (of which the respondents are predominantly temporary
migrants or what it calls overseas Filipino workers).
Remittances data are part of the international migration statistical compendium in the
Philippines. However, Table 4 here reflects the purposive segregating of these datasets, and
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
8/22
not linking these to any type of overseas Filipino. This is owing to the difficulty of
ascertaining which type of overseas Filipino is responsible for such flows of money.
Nevertheless, tables 1 to 4 (updated as of September 2007) represent what is
perhaps an attempt at a harmonized set of international migration statistics coming from
various data capturing sources. This attempt at harmonization can give us ideas of what
variables are missing from the existing data capturing mechanisms. This harmonized set of
statistics is packaged into a Migration and Development Databank5 which the Institute for
Migration and Development Issues (IMDI), a nonprofit thinktank, put together.
5This Migration and Development Databank is available at the Philippine Diaspora Philanthropy Portal
(www.filipinodiasporagiving.org), an online resource center about philanthropy and development aid by overseas Filipinos.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
9/22
Table 1: Available statisticstemporary contract workers or temporary migrants
PopDev framework
element
Data available Data source
Population Outcomes
Population size Deployed overseas contract workers (1984 to 2005) POEAAge structure Median age of overseas workers, (2000 Census) NSO
Annual Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
OFWs by age group (1988 to 2004), Labor Force Survey NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Sex structure / gender 2000 Census NSO
Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
Deployment of newly-hired temporary contract workers, 1992-2005 POEA
Share of OFWs, by sex (1988-2004), Labor Force Survey NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Marital status Share of OFWs, by marital status (1988-2004), Labor Force Survey NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Spatial distribution
Philippines
Overseas workers regional origins, 2000 Census NSO
Regional origins of deployed temporary contract workers, 1998-2002 POEA
Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
Number of OFWs, 2000 Census (regional and per municipality [the latter if
purposively processed])
NSO
Spatial distribution
overseas
Countries with most number of temporary migrants, Stock Estimates on
Overseas Filipinos
CFO
Total deployed contract workers, 1988-2005 POEA
Seafarers deployed, 1984-2005 POEA
Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
Spatial distribution
migrant households
based in the Philippines
Households with overseas workers, 2000 Census NSO
Households with overseas dependents, 2000 Family Income and
Expenditures Survey
NSO
Number of OFW households, 2000 Census (regional and per municipality
[the latter if purposively processed])
NSO
OFWs by relationship to household head (1988-2004), Labor Force Survey NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Development processes
Occupations abroad Deployment of newly-hired contract workers per skill category, 1992-2005 POEA
No. of OFWs by occupation, Annual Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
Remittances Annual Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
Survey of Filipino Remitters and Households Receiving Remittances Asian Development
Bank study, 2005
Household amenities and ownership of durables, 2000 Census NSO
Development outcomes
Domestic employment
and overseas migration
Employment, unemployment, underemployment, and overseas migration
data (temporary contract workers and immigrants)
NSOs Labor Force
Survey, POEA
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
10/22
deployment data, CFO
emigrants data
Educational attainment Educational attainment of temporary contract workers and emigrants
(though these are 1995 data)
Processed by an ILO
study, with data coming
from NSO, POEA and
CFO
Share of OFWs by educational attainment (1988-2004), Labor Force Survey NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Household per capita
income
Share of OFWs by household per capita income (19989, 1992, 1995, 1998,
2001, 2004), citing the Labor Force Survey and the Family Income and
Expenditures Survey
NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Labor force participation Labor Force Participation Rate of OFWs in domestic employment NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Unemployment Unemployment rate, to include OFWs among employed (1988-2004), labor
Force Survey
NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Unemployed by reason of unemployment of the households with OFWs
(1988-2004), Labor Force Survey
NSO
(cited by an ILO study)
Table 2: Available statisticspermanent residents or permanent migrants
PopDev framework
element
Data available Data source
Population Outcomes
Population size Registered Filipino emigrants (1981 to 2005) CFO
Age structure Filipino emigrants by age, 1988-2005 CFO
Sex structure / gender Registered Filipino emigrants, 1981-2005 CFO
Civil status Registered Filipino emigrants CFO
Registered Filipino/a spouses of foreigners (also segregated by age,
sex, education, employment at the time of their departure, and countries
of destination)
CFO
Spatial distribution
Philippines
Regional origins of emigrants and permanent residents CFO
Spatial distribution
overseas
Destination countries of permanent residents, Stock Estimates on
Overseas Filipinos
CFO
Spatial distribution
migrant households
based overseas
Census data of host countries Host countries
(e.g. United States
Census)
Development processes
Occupations prior to
migration
Registered emigrants (the employed and unemployed prior to migration) CFO
Survey of Filipino Remitters and Households Receiving Remittances Asian Development
Bank study, 2005
Development outcomes
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
11/22
Domestic employment
and overseas
migration
Employment, unemployment, underemployment, and overseas
migration data (temporary contract workers and immigrants)
NSOs Labor Force
Survey, POEA
deployment data, CFO
emigrants data
Educational attainmentof overseas Filipinos
Educational attainment of temporary contract workers and emigrants(though these are 1995 data)
Processed by an ILOstudy, with data
coming from NSO,
POEA and CFO
Table 3: Available statisticsundocumented migrants
PopDev framework
element
Data available Data source
Population Outcomes
Spatial distribution
overseas
Countries with most undocumented migrants, Stock estimates on
overseas Filipinos
CFO
Table 4: Statistics on remittances
PopDev framework
element
Data available Data source
Development processes
Remittances Remittances through formal banking channels (1975-2005) and informal
banking channels (2001-2005)
BSP
Annual Survey on Overseas Filipinos NSO
Survey of Filipino Remitters and Households Receiving Remittances Asian Development
Bank study, 2005
Household amenities and ownership of durables, 2000 Census NSO
It will be interesting to find out how statisticians and demographers treat the migration data
that are available. In the context of demography for example, the type of migration
movement is linked to migrating Filipinos continued count in the Philippiness population
system. In this case, temporary migrants (even those who stay for over 10 years as if their
stay seems permanent already) remain part of the Philippine population system 6 while
permanent residents have thus been part of the counts of host countries population
6 Maruja Asis (in United Nations Population Fund, 2005) explains that since many host countries have policies that do notwelcome family reunification, the foreign worker is thus a temporary migrant. The foreign worker, thus, will be forced to return tothe Philippines and remit earnings to the family left behind and these circumstances substantiate their being temporarymigrants. Asis even thinks policies make this kind of migration movement temporary.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
12/22
registers. But given the transnational nature of international migration movements, and even
circular migration movements by both temporary and permanent migrants to their home and
host countries, these developments will challenge how international migration is looked at by
demographers and by statisticians. Permanent residents, for example, remit money
periodically (though less in number than temporary migrants). Yet the Philippine System of
National Accounts only includes remittances from sea- and land-based Filipino migrant
workers (thus temporary migrants). The recording system for the PSNA is still being
improved, although a proposed framework for overseas Filipinos (see Figure 2) shows that
the stress is more on temporary migrants. The annual stock estimates on overseas Filipinos
shows that permanent residents are increasing in number (see Table 5).
Figure 2: Proposed framework for overseas Filipinos (Raymundo Talento 2004)
Table 5: Stock estimates of overseas Filipinos (multiple years)
Year Permanent Temporary Irregular TotalGap between permanent
and temporary migrants
2006 3,556,035 3,802,345 874,792 8,233,172 246,310
2005 3,391,338 3,651,727 881,123 7,924,188 260,389
2004 3,187,586 3,599,257 1,297,005 8,083,848 411,671
2003 2,865,412 3,385,001 1,512,765 7,763,178 519,589
2002 2,807,356 3,167,978 1,607,170 7,582,504 360,622
2001 2,736,528 3,049,622 1,625,936 7,412,086 313,094
2000 2,551,549 2,991,125 1,840,448 7,383,122 438,576
1999 2,482,470 2,981,529 1,828,990 7,292,989 499,059
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
13/22
1998 2,333,843 2,961,254 1,913,941 7,209,038 627,411
1997 2,153,967 2,940,082 1,880,016 6,974,065 786,115
Source: Commission on Filipinos Overseas, 2006
Data capturing agencies (in Jeremaiah Opiniano, 2007a). There are agencies
responsible for facilitating Filipinos overseas migration, and these are also the countrys
major data capturing agencies on international migration. The government bodies involved
are part of the countrys bureaucracy in the management of overseas migration flows.
The Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) is one of these agencies, and
under its aegis is the Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (POEA). Temporary
contract workers (both newly-hired and re-hired, in the case of overseas workers who
returned to the motherland) are the jurisdiction of the two agencies. A related agency, the
Overseas Workers Welfare Administration (OWWA, the welfare-focused agency for
temporary contract workers), has some databases of temporary contract workers who paid
their per-contract membership fee of US$25. Meanwhile, the Commission on Filipinos
Overseas (an attached agency under the Office of the President) handles and registers
permanent residents and immigrants leaving the country (including Filipino spouses of
foreigners). CFO is also responsible for the release of the annual stock estimates of
overseas Filipinos, covering all the types of overseas Filipinos mentioned earlier. Both POEA
and CFO have detailed statistics on the profiles of the temporary contract workers and
permanent residents who registered with their respective agencies prior to overseas
departure.
The Department of Foreign Affairs plays a crucial role in the gathering of international
migration statistics. This function is done through the 86 embassies and consulates
overseas since these diplomatic offices gather data on the number of Filipinos in the said
host countries7. These pieces of information are then sent to DFA headquarters and to the
CFO.
Another agency, the Bureau of Immigration and Deportation (BID), handles records
of Filipinos and foreigners who pass through Philippine air and sea ports. Some government
officials involved in harmonizing international migration data have mentioned that BID cannot
use embarkation and disembarkation cards to record the number of exiting and returning
Filipinos (especially in airports). But raw data on departing and returning foreigners and
7 Some of these host countries, especially developed countries, have sophisticated Census datasets and data ferretingsoftware. The websites of the United States Census and Statistics Denmark website are good examples. Among the variablessuch websites have is the number of foreigners (e.g. foreign workers, foreign-born population, the population born to families ofmixed races). (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007).
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
14/22
overseas Filipinos are available at the BID (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007a), even as the agency
has yet to systematize its data on departing and returning overseas Filipinos.
The National Statistics Office is the main agency under the National Economic and
Development Authority (NEDA) that gathers relevant data on overseas Filipinos. NSO uses
three sets of household and income surveys related to Filipinos abroad: the quarterly Labor
Force Survey or LFS, the annual Survey on Overseas Filipinos or the SOF (which is a rider
to the October round of the LFS), and the triennial Family Income and Expenditures Survey
or FIES. The SOF is the most important survey instrument for NSO in regard to getting data
on overseas Filipinos, data particularly on their demographic information and remittance
behavior. The SOF is perhaps the only survey directly covering overseas migration by
Filipinos, even if it stresses on international labor migration largely. The strength of the SOF
is that it is done annually, even as the period of coverage is from April to September.
The Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, the main regulator for the countrys financial sector,
records the flows of remittances from overseas Filipinos. It releases monthly remittance
figures for public consumption. These remittance data, in addition, are being monitored in
accordance with certain reporting regulations in the Balance of Payments (BoP), which
summarizes the countrys financial transactions with the rest of the world. These data also
represent actual cash flows from overseas Filipinos, particularly those that pass through the
countrys formal banking system. At the same time, these remittances are also being
monitored vis--vis the gross international reserves (GIR) of the country. The GIR is an
indicator of the countrys ability to make credit payments based on its reserve of foreign
currencies and gold (the former largely buoyed by migrants remittances).
Other related agencies are also part of the system of international migration statistics.
One is the Philippine Retirement Authority, which records the number of returning Filipinos
who have availed of what are called the special retirement retirees visa. Another relevantagency is the Department of Tourism, which records foreigner and overseas Filipino tourists
arriving in the country and in the countrys different regions.
The National Statistical Coordination Board or NSCB convenes the migration data
capturing agencies as an inter-agency network. NSCB is even lead convenor of a Task
Force on Overseas Filipinos Statistics that which provides a framework and a set of
indicators to determine those belonging to the statistical measurement8 of overseas Filipinos
8 The following types of overseas Filipinos are part of the proposed NSCB framework on international migration statistics: a)migrant workers; b) Permanent residents or immigrants; c) Former Filipino citizens; d) Holders of non-immigrant visas liketourists, visitors, students, medical patients, those on official missions, and others; e) Descendants of Filipino nationalsoverseas; and f) Undocumented Filipinos (Lina Castro 2006).
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
15/22
(Lina Castro 2006). In regard to overseas Filipino statistics, the NSCB also includes migrant
workers (thus, referring to temporary contract workers) in the Philippine System of National
Accounts (Raymund Talento 2004). While this measurement system of migrant workers in
the PSNA is currently being improved, this endeavor is important especially in terms of
determining the contribution of overseas Filipino workers to the net factor income from
abroad, which is one part of the gross national product. Remittances are among those that
are part of NFIA, which is being added up to the gross domestic product figure to come up
with the GNP.
Compared to other countries, the Philippines has the machinery of these government
agencies involved in international migration statistics and is a global model of such
(Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007b). At the same time, government agencies involved in the
systematic capturing of international migration statistics ought to be lauded for their efforts,
even if some observe the Philippines has proxy international migration data (Jeremaiah
Opiniano 2006).
IV. Issues and recommendations
This paper, while not statistical and mathematical in nature, is an attempt to survey the
system of international migration statistics in the Philippines. Given the exercise done, we
outline the following issues:
There are technical issues involved in the statistics themselves. Perhaps the most
important of these covers definitions: who is the overseas Filipino? There has been
much loose usage of the phrase overseas Filipino workers (and the acronym
OFWs) in the public realm, and this influences the way stakeholders view who these
overseas Filipinos are. To be fair with the government data capturing agencies, they
are addressing such concerns with regard to terminologies. In this regard, theyshould consider the international migration situation of the Philippines, as well as how
statistics and migration management agencies worldwide are formulating a
framework to set standards on international migration statistics. This pursuit of so-
called standards on international migration statistics attempt to cover all types of
international migration movements.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
16/22
Nimfa Ogena and Josefa Zafra (1998), in their paper9 during the 1998 National
Convention on Statistics, have made an observation regarding migration statistics (to
include internal migration10) that remains relevant today: A general holistic scheme
for the optimal collection of population and migration data is critically needed; this
observation includes internal migration, which is a demographic process that has
patchy data available. The outdated data is also an issue to contend with, especially
for internal migration, since it will be difficult then to determine the net migration rate 11
of a certain area (province, city, town) this covering both internal and international
migration movements by Filipinos. Determining the net migration rate of areas in the
country is a prospect for the future, especially if our data are updated (which is why
there is anticipation over the results of the ongoing Census of the Population).
Nevertheless, the general holistic scheme for population and migration data
collection remains wanting; meanwhile, international migration statistics also need to
understand that holistic look at the various datasets, and also consider how Filipinos
migrate overseas. Then the careful examination of data collection and methods, as
well as the management of data quality concerns, of international migration statistics
will follow.
It also makes sense that a resources-supported NSO finally conduct a National
Migration Survey (also in Nimfa Ogena and Josefa Zafra 1998), that survey
representing an effort to systematically and regularly monitor the internal and
international migration movements of Filipinos. The regular conduct of this survey will
hopefully address the scanty migration data of the Philippines (Ogena and Zafra
1998). This survey may also finally determine more socio-economic and
demographic characteristics of these people on the move, including overseas
Filipinos. Unfortunately, governments policy-makers and budget managers have yet
to realize the importance of this kind of a survey given that Filipinos have a strong
migration culture.
The technical issues surrounding international migration data will, hopefully,
understand the fluidity of international migration movements. These movements are
one-way (from the Philippines to overseas countries) and two-way (to include return
9The paper of Ogena and Zafra looked at both internal and international migration, as they sensed there seems to be
underestimation from the data. The two demographers also looked at how the National Statistics Office defines householdmembers in its five-year or ten-year censuses. As for international migration, data from the POEA were analyzed.10
Internal migration remains a demographic process that is difficult to track down and record. There have been some attempts,such as by the Population Commission when it released a report titled Filipinos on the Move: Who are They?The data source
for such is the 2000 Censuss 10 percent sample data.11Net migration rate shows the net effect of in-migration and out-migration on an areas population, expressed in an increase
or decrease per 1,000 population of the area in a given year (Population Commission, undated).The formula to compute NMR is as follows:
NMR = Number of in-migrants number of out-migrants for two periodsPopulation at end of period (in-migrants out-migrants) 0.5 x 1,000
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
17/22
migration or circular migration that covers overseas Filipinos who go home to the
Philippines for a vacation).
The growing permanent residency of Filipinos vis--vis international migration
statistics is an issue that represents such fluidity of international migration
movements. Permanent settlement overseas will, all the more, blur international
migration data capturing mechanisms, making it difficult to track down the
international migration path of the overseas Filipino. Permanent settlement might
even be the next wave of increased overseas migration by Filipinos in the next
decade. There are some countries that need workers and are willing to offer
immigration opportunities so as to address the labor shortfalls and aging populations
of their countries. At the same time, marriage migration is steadily rising
(Commission on Filipinos Overseas 2006).
The changing citizenship of the Filipino overseas will also become an issue for
demographers and statisticians. As an international migration scholar, Dr. Filomeno
Aguilar, observes, demography has no established theory on international migration.
Demography has yet to determine how it can handle, in the population count,
Filipinos who have become nationals 12 of other countries, and yet they still
contribute 13 to the economy of the Philippines through their remittances. The
remittances that permanent migrants send also include payments to investments in
the Philippines, since companies such as real estate firms and insurance companies
are luring temporary contract workers andpermanent residents for investments.
What also prevails is transnationalism, and foreigners abroad can easily go back to
the home country and to the host country (some overseas Filipinos may even think of
Germany or Canada as their home country). Given these trends in international
migration, demography cannot just set aside these realities. Even existing datagathering instruments should also find out how the households of permanent
residents, while lesser in number than the temporary migrants or the overseas
Filipino workers, be covered and included in surveys such as the Labor Force Survey,
the Survey on Overseas Filipinos, and the Family Income and Expenditures Survey.
12By virtue that foreigners have become nationals of host countries, thus the host countrys population office includes them in
its population count. When the United States had reached 300 million people in September 2006, immigration was a major
factor for such.13The contribution of permanent residents to the Philippine economy does not only cover remittances, but also donations.
Migrant philanthropy is a multi-million dollar philanthropic resource US$218 million in cash, according to 2003 data of the oldBalance of Payments which comes from both temporary contract workers and permanent residents (Association ofFoundations 2005). These permanent residents may have become American or German citizens, but their philanthropicdonations are for the Philippines owing to their ties to the country of birth.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
18/22
The situation thus goes back to the definition of which type of overseas Filipino is
covered.
But as there is the drive to improve the system of capturing international migration
data, resource limitations of these migration data capturing agencies come up as a
crucial issue. NSO, for example, cannot conduct a full-blown National Migration
Survey even as the lobbying to conduct such a survey is over three-decades old
already. Meanwhile, Republic Act 8042 (or the Migrant Workers and Overseas
Filipinos Act) mandates the government to set up a Shared Government Information
System on Migration (SGISM). No thanks to lack of funds, this shared system never
flew off at a time that this is most needed.
Individual migration data capturing agencies also have their own resource challenges.
A study (Donna Leceta 2002) directed at the POEA found that there is an
overwhelming mismatch between the number of Filipinos applying for overseas work
and the number of personnel recording their applications14. Supporting the work of
records collection departments is crucial to improving the system of international
migration data capturing and recoding.
Policymakers should be made aware that since the countrys economy is largelysupported by overseas Filipinos, and the Philippines is in a position to harness these
supplementary resources from international migration for domestic economic
development (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2004), supporting the system of capturing,
processing, and harmonizing international migration statistics is necessary.
With these at hand, the following next steps can be pursued:
It makes sense that a body of migration data actors (whether formal or informal, andcoming from various disciplines) will regularly discuss and act upon how this holistic
look at international migration data can be improved, and the improvements
operationalized. Such a loose coalition of migration data gatherers, analysts, and
users will seek resources to painstakingly improve international migration data
capturing, harmonization, and public access. This effort is also aimed at regularly
updating these international migration statistics.
14 Donna Leceta (2002) made a simple ratio of the number of personnel in POEAs central records division and the number oftemporary contract workers who passed through POEA. Her 2001 data showed that the ratio is 1 is to 562,814 records. Thedata they record also cover previous years applicants for overseas work, as well as returning overseas working re-applying foroverseas employment.
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
19/22
With resources being a problem, this loose coalition of migration data gatherers,
analysts, and users can find resources to perhaps bankroll the countrys international
migration statistical system. The World Bank, for example, has grants for statistical
capacity building which can be a possible resource that will help to improve our
international migration statistics.
The late demographer Aurora Perez (1997) recommended that a better
understanding of migration as a process necessarily entails an interdisciplinary
approach among scholars of different disciplines(since there is) a yawning gap in
interdisciplinary studies on migration in the Philippines. The same perspective can
be applied to international migration statistics. Collaboration between government,
non-government groups, and academics from various disciplines (economics,
psychology, sociology and anthropology, business, among others) will be helpful so
that harmonized statistical datasets on international migration understand the
technical ramifications of data capturing vis--vis disciplinary theories and the
ground-level experiences and realities surrounding the international migration
phenomenon.
In the next few years, when the country will have a new president, the Philippines
should be prepared to use international migration statistics in national developmentplans, and juxtapose international migration statistics with socio-economic datasets.
Doing this is an initial step to purposively integrate international migration and its
development potential in the countrys next six-year Medium-Term Philippine
Development Plan (MTPDP).
With the data that are available, and since there is much discussion and studies on
how international migration has improved Filipinos socio-economic conditions, it is
interesting to find out how overseas migration has improved or not the Philippinesshuman development standing. Thus, an example of an interesting endeavor will be to
produce an edition of the Philippine Human Development Report whose theme is
international migration and Filipino human development.
V. Conclusion
A June 2007 conference by the Philippine Statistical Association and the Bangko
Sentral ng Pilipinas carried the theme OFWs: Ilan ba Talaga Kayo? (How many you really
are?). The major data capturing government agencies explained the means they gather
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
20/22
international migration data. It also opened the doors to begin next steps toward
collaboration (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007b).
Statistics can only compile so much, especially with a fluid phenomenon such as
international migration. At the very least, the Philippines existing international migration
statistics can help us see trends on immigration flows and conditions, remittances, and other
demographic characteristics of these overseas Filipinos (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007a). There
is much room to improve the system surrounding international migration statistics, and doing
so will be a big help to strategize how international migration can be a supplementary, not a
primary, input to Philippine economic development (Jeremaiah Opiniano 2007c).
-
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
21/22
References
Cario, Benjamin V. (1989). The Philippine National Recording Systems on International Migration.International Migration Review xxi, 4.
Castro, Lina (2006, 4-7 December). Measuring International Migration in the Philippines. Presented
at the United Nations Expert Group Meeting on Measuring International Migration: Conceptsand Methods, United Nations, New York City, USA.
Commission on Population, Philippines (2007-forthcoming). International Labor Migration,Population and Development in the Philippines (The Fourth State of the PhilippinePopulation Report).
Commission on Population (undated). Handbook on Basic Demographic Concepts. Manila:Commission on Population.
Dumont, Jean-Christophe and Georges Lemaitre (2005, 22 June). Counting Immigrants andExpatriates in OECD Countries: A New Perspective. OECD Social, Employment andMigration Working Paper Number 25 (DELSA/ELSA/WD/SEM(2005)4.
Leceta, Donna (2002). Assessment of Records Management System for OFWs at the POEA.Masteral thesis in Public Administration, Polytechnic University of the Philippines.
Opiniano, Jeremaiah (2007a, July). Philippine Migration Statistics: Insights from Europe andBeyond. In Filomenita Mongaya Hogsholm (editor). In de olde worlde: Views of FilipinoMigrants in Europe. Quezon City: Philippine Social Science Council and the PhilippineMigration Research Network.
_________________ (2007b, June 4). Understanding the Mazes: International Migration Statistics inthe Philippines. Reaction paper presented in the 2007 Philippine Statistical AssociationSummer Conference titled OFWs: Ilan ba Talaga Kayo?. Manila.
_________________ (2007c). The Panorama and Drama of International Migration andDevelopment in the Philippines. In Development, Environment and Migration: Analysis ofLinkages and Consequences (forthcoming). Olomouc, Czech Republic: Palacky Universityand the Institute for Migration and Development Research-European Polytechnic Institute.
_________________ (2006, September 7). Data Crunchers Say RP has Proxy Migration Data.OFW Journalism Consortium newspacket, 5,7.
_________________ (2004). Our Future Beside the Exodus: Migration and Development Issuesin the Philippines. Pasig City: Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung Philippines.
Ogena, Nimfa and Josefa Zafra (1998, 2-4 December). Underestimation of Migration Statistics in thePhilippines: What to do Next? Paper presented at the 7
thNational Convention on Statistics,
Mandaluyong City.
Perez, Aurora (1997). Migration Issues in Asia-Pacific: Issues Paper from the Philippines. InBrownlee, Patrick and Colleen Mitchell (editors). Migration Issues in Asia-Pacific.http://www.unesco.org/most/apmrnwp1.htm(accessed 20 January, 2007).
Talento, Raymundo (2004, September 15-16). Measurement of the Migrant Workers in the PhilippineSystem of National Accounts. Presented at the Meeting of the Technical Subgroup of theTask Force on International Trade in Services, Movement of Natural Persons Mode 4, Paris,France.
United Nations Population Fund (2005). International Migration and the Millennium Development
Goals: Selected Papers of the UNFPA Expert Group Meeting. New York: United NationsPopulation Fund.
http://www.unesco.org/most/apmrnwp1.htmhttp://www.unesco.org/most/apmrnwp1.htm -
8/6/2019 NCSB Filipinos Statistics on International Migration
22/22
United Nations Statistics Division (2006). Statistics on International Migration.http://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic/sconcerns/migration/migr2.htm (accessed 18 May2007).
World Bank (2006). Global Development Finance 2003. Washington, DC, USA: The World Bank.
http://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic/sconcerns/migration/migr2.htmhttp://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic/sconcerns/migration/migr2.htm