NATIONAL GREEN TRIBUNAL SOUTHERN ZONE KALAS MAHAL, …
Transcript of NATIONAL GREEN TRIBUNAL SOUTHERN ZONE KALAS MAHAL, …
1
NATIONAL GREEN TRIBUNAL SOUTHERN ZONE
KALAS MAHAL, CHENNAI.
CAUSE LIST OF COURT NO 1 & 2
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE K. RAMAKRISHNAN Date : 09-06- 2021 JUDICIAL MEMBER Time: 10:30 AM
HON’BLE Dr. K. SATYAGOPAL
EXPERT MEMBER
SR.NO. 1 TO 14 WILL BE TAKEN UP THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCE
S.NO CASE NO.
PARTIES
COUNSEL FOR PARTIES
ADJOURNED ADMISSION
1 Appeal No.06/2021(SZ) [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 25.03.2021]
M/s. Aurobindo Pharma Limited (Unit XVI)
Vs. The State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. P.Venkaiah Naidu Associates Counsel for Appellant
2 Appeal No.07/2021(SZ) M/s. APL Health Care Limited Vs.
The State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. P.Venkaiah Naidu Associates Counsel for Appellant
3 Appeal No.08/2021(SZ) M/s. Amneal Oncology Pvt.Ltd., Vs.
The State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. P.Venkaiah Naidu Associates Counsel for Appellant
4 Appeal No.09/2021(SZ) M/s. Aurobindo Pharma Limited (Unit VII)
Vs. The State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. P.Venkaiah Naidu Associates Counsel for Appellant
FOR TAKING STEPS
5 Original Application No.
118/2021(SZ)
&
I.A No.83/2021(SZ)
[FOR IMPLEADING]
&
84/2021(SZ)
[FOR DELETION OF R6]
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO
CONFERENCING ON
03.06.2021]
D.Sakthivel, Periyasemur, Erode Vs
The District Collector, Erode and others
V.B.R. Menon Counsel for the Applicant/ Counsel for I.A [FOR TAKING STEPS]
AFTER NOTICE
6 Original Application No.
18/2021(SZ)
Mr.R.Swaminathan, Nagapatinam.
Vs.
The Distrct Collector, Nagapattinam and Ors.
M/s. M.K.Subramanian,
M.R.Gokul Krishnan,
K.Sankar Vignesh, N.Shrivatsav
Counsel for Applicant
2
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO
CONFERENCING ON
25.01.2021,24.02.2021, 22.03.2021,]
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R1 to R3,R5,R8
M/s. P.Srinivas for R4
M/s. Abdul Saleem for R6
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R7
M/s. K.M.Subrahmanian,
A.Udayachandiren for R9
[AFTER NOTICE,COMPLETION OF PLEADINGS AND CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES 7
Original Application No. 250/2020(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 04.12.2020,01.03.2021, 15.03.2021]
S.Sekar,
Tirupathur District and Ors.
Vs.
The Secretary, Environment and Forests Department, Government of Tamil Nadu
and Ors.
M/s. S.Muthu Vairam, D.Ponventhan, M.Navin Kumar Counsel for Applicant
M/s. V.R.Thiru Narayanan
for R1,R3,R6
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R2,R4,R5
M/s. G.Sugumaran,
R.Vinoth Kumar for R7 [FOR COMPLETION OF PLEADINGS ANDCONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
8 Original Application No. 260/2020(SZ) [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 17.12.2020]
Beerla Ilaiah Vs.
State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. Sravan Kumar, R.Balaji, Ms. Kothai Muthu Meenal
Counsel for Applicant
M/s. H.Yasmeen Ali for R1 to R6 [FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES AND FOR CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
9 Original Application No.
26/2021(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 05.02.2021]
Tribunal on its own motion SUO MOTU based on the News
Item in The New Indian Express Newspaper, Chennai Edition
dt: 23.01.2021, “Biomedical waste dumped near Chennai’s Thiruneermalai Lake not removed even after a week”.
Vs.
The Chief Secretary to Govt. of Tamil Nadu, Chennai and Ors.
Dr.Thirunarayanan
for R1 to R4,R6
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R5
M/s. P.Srinivas for R7
M/s. Abdul Saleem ,
S.Saravanan for R8
[FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES AND CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
10 Original Application No. 71/2021(SZ)
Tribunal on its own motion SUO MOTU based on the News Item in The New Indian Express Newspaper, dt: 10.02.2021, “Oil leak from titanium factory hits Thiruvananthapuram coast, public barred from affected stretch”. News Item in
M/s. E.K.Kumaresan
for R1 to R4,R7,R8
M/s. VK.Rema Smrithi for R5,R6
M/s. D.Kamachi for R9
3
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 17.02.2021]
The Hindu, dt: 10.02.2021, “Furnace oil from Titanium factory spills in to sea”. News Item in Mathrubumi, English edition dt: 10.02.2021, “ Glass furnace pipe bursts at Titanium factory in TVM, oil leaked to sea”.
Vs. The Chief Secretary, Government of Kerala, Thiruvananthapuram and Ors.
[FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES AND CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
FOR COMPLETION OF PLEADINGS
11 Original Application No.
182/2020(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 24.09.2020,06.10.2020, 22.01.2021,18.03.2021]
Dr. Nagam Janardhan Reddy, Telangana And Ors.
Vs. State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. Sravan Kumar,
Ramaswami Balaji,
SM.Kothai Muthu Meenal
Counsel for Applicant
M/s. H.Yasmeen Ali
for R1,R2,R4,R5 to R7
M/s. T.Saikrishnan for R3
M/s. V.Suthakar&
K.S.Viswanathan for R8,R9,R10
[FOR COMPLETION OF PLEADINGS AND CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
FOR REPORT
12 Original Application No. 179/2020(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 22.09.2020,22.02.2021]
P.Gengaiyan,
Thiruvallur Taluk and District
Vs.
The District Collector,
Thiruvallur and Ors.
M/s. R.Selvakumar, A.Athimoolam Counsel for Applicant
Dr.Thirunarayanan
for R1 to R3,R5 to R7
M/s. G.M.Syed Nurullah Sheriff
for R4 [FOR CONSIDERATION OF REPORT AND FOR FILING THEIR RESPONSE]
13 Original Application No.
183/2020(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 28.09.2020,03.03.2021]
Tribunal on its own motion
SUO MOTU based on the News
Item in Tamil Hindu
E-magazine, Chennai edition
dt: 07.09.2020, “Setting up on ecological park by destroying mangrove forests with destruction of environment ? –Environmental activists torment”.
Vs.
The Secretary to Govt. of
Tamil Nadu,
Department of Environment, Govt. Secretariat,
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R1 to R3,R5 to R8
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R4
[FOR CONSIDERATION OF REPORT AND COMPLETION OF
PLEADINGS]
4
Chennai, Tamil Nadu and Ors.
14 Original Application No. 191/2020(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 01.10.2020,09.11.2020, 03.12.2020,25.01.2021, 16.03.2021, 15.04.2021]
Tribunal on its own motion SUO MOTU based on the News
Item in The Times of India Newspaper, Chennai edition
dt: 24.09.2020, “In Pallavaram, the road is a dump yard”.
Vs.
The Principal Secretary to Govt. of Tamil Nadu, Health and Family Welfare Department, Chennai,
Tamil Nadu and Ors.
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan for R1 to R3,R5,R6
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R4
M/s. P.Srinivas for R7
[FOR CONSIDERATION OF FURTHER REPORT]
SR.NO.15 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 08.07.2021
15 Original Application No. 24/2021(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 04.02.2021]
O.A.Ninan
Vs.
The State of Kerala and Ors.
M/s. A.Yogeshwaran
Counsel for Applicant
M/s. E.K.Kumaresan for R1,R4,R5
M/s. Vidhyalakshmi for R2
M/s. Rema Smrithi for R3
[FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES AND FOR FILING OF THEIR RESPONSES AND ALSO FOR CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
SR.NO.16 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 15.07.2021
16 Original Application No.
29/2021(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 05.02.2021]
Ram Kumar
Vs.
The District Collector, Cuddalore District and Ors.
M/s. V.Neethidurai,
M. Gajalakshmi Counsel for Applicant
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R1 to R7
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R8
[FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES AND CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
SR.NO.17 & 18 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 20.07.2021
17 Original Application No. 103/2021(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 19.05.2021]
C. Ramu, Devampattu Village, Ponneri Taluk, Tiruvallur
District and another.
Vs The District Collector, Thiruvallur and Ors.
S. Rathi
Counsel for Applicant
[FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES
AND FOR CONSIDERATION OF
REPORT]
18 Original Application No. 105/2021(SZ) IA No.77/2021(SZ) [For Exception the Stipulated Court Fee] [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 20.05.2021]
Yanati Srinivasulu Reddy, Muthukur Mandal, Nellore and
another Vs
The Chief Secretary, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, Amaravathi
and others
M/s. Rayasam. N. Suneetha
Counsel for Applicant
M/s. Madhuri Donti Reddy for R1,R5,R6,R8,R9,R10 [FOR APPEARANCE OF PARTIES & CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
5
SR.NO.19 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 22.06.2021
19 Appeal. No. 24/2020(SZ) [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 21.09.2020,06.01.2021, 04.03.2021]
Mr.Michael Lambert Jehan, Chennai.
Vs.
Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board, Chennai and Ors.
Mr.Michael Lambert Jehan
Appellant In Person
M/s. C.Kasirajan for R1,R2
M/s. K.S.Viswanathan for R3 [FOR COMPLETION OF PLEADINGS]
SR.NO.20 TO 23 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 08.07.2021
20 Original Application No. 85/2015(SZ)
& [MA.NO.174/2016 & 232/2016] [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 09.06.2020,18.08.2020, 21.08.2020,25.08.2020, 14.09.2020,28.01.2021]
Dr.LubnaSarwath
Vs.
The State of Telangana and Ors.
M/s. Rema Smrithi
Counsel for Applicant
M/s. H.Yasmeen Ali for R1
M/s.D.Srinivasan for R2
M/s. T.Sai Krishnan for R3 & R4
[FOR CONSIDERATION OF
FURTHER REPORT]
21 Original Application No. 82 of 2016(SZ)
& M.A No. 141/2016(SZ) [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 29.05.2020,11.08.2020, 24.09.2020,13.10.2020, 06.01.2021,08.03.2021] WITH
Mr.A. Paramasivan Vs.
TNPCB, Chennai and ors
M/s.G.Stanly hebzon Singh Counsel for Applicant M/s. C.Kasirajan for R1 & R2 Dr. V.R. Thirunarayanan for R3 to R6,R8 R9 M/s. Abdul Saleem, S.Saravanan for R7 M/s. M.Gnanasekar for R10 to R12
M/s. M.R.Gokul Krishnan for R13
M/s. B. Sudhir Kumar for R14 M/s. Vijay for R15 M/s. L.G.Sahadevan for R16 [FOR CONSIDERATION FURTHER REPORT]
22 Original Application No.
173 of 2016(SZ)
&
M.A. No.139 &140/2017(SZ)
WITH
K.M Raji
Vs.
TNPCB, Chennai and ors.
M/s. R.Saravanakumar Counsel for Applicant M/s. C.Kasirajanfor R1 & R2
Dr. V.R. Thirunarayanan for R3 to R5 M/s.R.Shanmugham for R7 to R12 M/s.Vijay for R13
[FOR CONSIDERATION FURTHER REPORT]
23 Original Application No.
175 of 2016(SZ)
&
M.A.No.141/2017(SZ)
S.Srinivasan
Vs.
TNPCB, Chennai and Ors.
M/s. R.Saravanakumar
Counsel for Applicant
M/s. C.Kasirajanfor R1 & R2
Dr. V.R. Thirunarayanan for R3 to R5 M/s.R.Shanmugham for R7 to R12
M/s.Vijay for R13
[FOR CONSIDERATION FURTHER REPORT]
6
SR.NO.24 & 25 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 07.07.2021
24 Original Application No. 131/2016(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 09.06.2020,20.08.2020, 05.03.2021]
B.R Lakshmanan
Vs.
The District Collector,
Ooty and Ors.
Mr. B.R.Lakshmanan
Party in Person
Dr.V.R.Thiru Narayanan
for R1,R3 to R6
M/s.Paul & Paul for R2
[FOR CONSIDERATION OF REPORT]
25 M.A.No.38/2017(SZ)
IN
Original Application No.
155/2016(SZ)
(Original Application
Disposed on 23/12/16)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 08.07.2020,09.09.2020,
15.09.2020,30.09.2020, 27.10.2020,02.11.2020, 18.02.2021,22.03.2021]
Mr. Rajiv Chekuri
Vs.
The Special Officer,
Sithalapakkam Panchayat office,
Kancheepuram Dist andOrs.
Mr.RajivChekuri
Party in Person
Dr.Thiru Narayanan
for R1 to R6
[FOR CONSIDERATION OF FURTHER REPORT & COMPLIANCE REPORT]
SR.NO.26 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 15.07.2021
26 Original Application No. 268/2017(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO
CONFERENCING ON
19.06.2020,30.09.2020,
08.10.2020,16.02.2021]
Sri. A P Mathew, Vs.
Chief Conservator, Forest Dept.,
Kerala and Ors.
M/s. Sheeja P D Counsel for Applicant M/s. E.K.Kumaresan for R1,R5 to R8,R9,R10,R13,R14,R15 M/s. Rema Smrithi for R4
M/s. Raju Sebastian for R11,R12
[FOR CONSIDERATION OF
FURTHER REPORT]
SR.NO.27 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 19.07.2021
27 Original Application No. 147/2020(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH
VIDEO CONFERENCING
ON
13.08.2020,05.01.2021,
22.03.2021]
Smt.R.Prabha
Vs.
Tamil Nadu Pollution Control
Board and Ors.
M/s. Yogeshwaran.A Counsel for Applicant M/s. C.Kasirajan for R1 Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan for R2,R3,R5 M/s. Sarvabhauman Associates for R4 M/s. P.Jayalakshmi for CPCB M/s. D.Ramesh Kumar for R6 [FOR CONSIDERATION OF FURTHER REPORT AND COMPLETION OF PLEADINGS]
SR.NO.28 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 07.07.2021
28 Appeal. No.24/2017(SZ)
P.J. Devasia
Vs.
Ministry of Environment,
M/s. RajanVishnuraj and Harish Vasudevan Counsel for Appellant
M/s.M.Sumathi for R1
7
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 10.06.2020,04.11.2020, 17.03.2021]
Forests & Climate Change
New Delhi and Ors.
M/s. Vidyalakshmi Vipin for R2
M/s.E.K.Kumaresan for R3,R4
M/s. Taarus Associatesfor R5
[FOR HEARING]
SR.NO.29 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 30.06.2021
29 Original Application No.
231/2016(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 17.06.2020,09.09.2020, 28.10.2020,04.01.2021, 09.03.2021]
Voice of Nature
Vs.
The Government of
Tamil Nadu
Department of Environment And Forest, Chennai and Ors.
M/s. C.S.Monica Counsel for Applicant Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan for R1, R6 M/s. C.Kasirajan for R2,R3 M/s. Madhuri Donti Reddy for R5,R7 M/s. V.Sanjeevi & K.Muthukumaraswamy for R4 M/s. M.R.GokulKrishnan for R9 M/s. Abdul Saleem for R10 [TANGEDCO] [FOR HEARING]
SR.NO.30 & 31 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 14.07.2021
30 Original Application No.
78/2017(SZ)
&
M.A.No.02/2018(SZ)
[HEARD THROUGH VIDEO
CONFERENCING ON
12.06.2020]
WITH
Suo Motu Proceedings initiated based on the news item Published in “Mathrubhumi News Paper” – Malayalam Edition dated 25.03.2017 on the caption
“SAVE MUNNAR”
Vs.
Secretary to Government
Kerala and ors.
M/s.E.K.Kumaresan
for R1, R3 & R4,R7,R8
M/s. Rema Smrithi for R2
M/s. K.R.Harin for R6 M/s. Dr.Vincent Panikulangara Jaisjohn G.Stanley Hebzon Singh for R9 M/s. Taaurs Associates for R10 M/s. W.M.Abdul Majeed for R11 M/s. Babu Joseph Kuruvathazha for R12,R15,R20 M/s. Bharadwaj for R13 M/s. Vada Kedom for R14 M/s. Sajeev Kumar for R16 M/s. Rathina Asohan
for R17,R18,R19, R21 to R24
31 Original Application No.
248/2017(SZ) [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 12.06.2020]
P. Prasad
Vs.
Union of India and ors.
M/s. K.Varsha Counsel for Applicant M/s. M.R.Gokul Krishnan for R1 M/s.E.K.Kumaresan for R2 to R6,R8 M/s. Rema Smrithi for R7 M/s. Jayalakshmi for R9
SR.NO.32 TO 36 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 23.06.2021
32 Original Application No. 21/2020(SZ) (Transferred W.P.No.13433 of 1996 from High Court, Madras)
[ADJOURNED THROUGH
VIDEO CONFERENCING
ON 14.07.2020]
[HEARD THROUGH
VIDEO
CONFERENCING ON
Vellore Citizens Welfare Forums, Vellore
Vs. Union of India and Ors.
M/s. G.M.Syed Nurullah Sheriff
for R1
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R2 M/s. C.Kasirajanfor R3
8
25.03.2021]
WITH
33 Original Application No. 22/2020(SZ)
& M.A.No.173 & 174/2017 (Transferred W.P.M.P.No.11/2015 IN W.P.No.39722 /2005 from High Court, Madras)
WITH
K.M.Santhanagopalan (substituted as L.R. in the place of the deceased petitioner as per order dt:09.09.2014 in W.P.M.P.No.187 of 2017)
Vs. Union of India and Ors.
M/s. M.S.Subramanian Counsel for Applicant M/s. Syed Nurullah Sheriff
for R1
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R3 M/s. C.Kasirajanfor R4
34 Original Application No. 23/2020(SZ) (Transferred W.P.No.24595 of 2005 from High Court, Madras)
WITH
K.Narayanasamy, Tiruppur Vs.
The Loss of Ecology, Chennai and Ors.
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R2
35 Original Application No. 24/2020(SZ) (Transferred W.P.No. 29246 of 2006 from High Court, Madras)
WITH
Govindasamy and Ors. Vs.
The Chairman, Loss of Ecology,
Chennai and Ors.
M/s. C.Kasirajanfor R2
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R3
36 Original Application No. 25/2020(SZ)
(Transferred W.P.No. 29275 of 2006 from High Court, Madras)
Jayaraman, Vellore and Ors. Vs.
The Chairman, Loss of Ecology,
Chennai and Ors.
M/s. C.Kasirajanfor R2
Dr.V.R.Thirunarayanan
for R3
SR.NO.37 WILL BE TAKEN UP ON 25.06.2021
37 Original Application No. 130/2020(SZ) [ADJOURNED THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 29.07.2020] [HEARD THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCING ON 31.07.2020,04.01.2021]
G.Joseph,
Ramanathapuram.
Vs.
Union of India and Anr.
M/s. Yogeshwaran.A Counsel for Applicant M/s. M.R.Gokul Krishnan for R1
M/s. Abdul Saleem for R2 [TANGEDCO]
For further details, please log on to our website https://greentribunal.gov.in/
For detailed Standard Operating Protocol for Virtual Video Conferencing in NGT, SZ, CHENNAI. Please visit our link: https://greentribunal.gov.in/sites/default/files/office_orders/Office%20Order%20dated%2001.10.2020.pdf
For sending VC request & for any technical/connectivity issues – email at [email protected] For filing of reports/documents & other communications etc – email at [email protected]
REGISTRAR