NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE...

43
NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis

Transcript of NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE...

Page 1: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

NASSER DAVARZANI

DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS

22 OCTOBER 2012

Introduction to Survival Analysis

Page 2: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Contents Introduction to Survival Analysis

Censored DataTerminologies and NotationsKaplan-Meier Method Modeling in Survival DataParametric Regression

ModelsCox Proportional Regression

Model

2

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 3: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Contents Introduction to Survival Analysis

Censored DataTerminologies and NotationsKaplan-Meier Method Modeling in Survival DataParametric Regression

ModelsCox Proportional Regression

Model

3

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 4: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

What is survival analysis?

Outcome variable: Time until an event occurs

Time: years, months, weeks, or days

Start follow-up Event

Event: death, disease, relapse, recovery

TimeTime

4

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 5: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Time ≡ survival time

It gives the time that an individual has survived over some follow up period

Event ≡ failureThe event of interest usually is death, disease or any other negative individual experience.Maybe failure is a positive event

5

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 6: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Examples

1) Leukemia patients/time in remission (weeks) Event: Going out of remission Outcome: Time in weeks until a person goes out of remission

2) Disease-free cohort/time until heart disease (years) Event: Developing heart disease Outcome: time in years until a person develops heart disease.

6

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 7: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Examples

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

7

3) Elderly (60+) population/time until death (years) Event: Death Outcome: Time in years until death

4) Parolees (recidivism study)/time until get rearrested

Event: Getting rearrested Outcome: Time in weeks until rearrest

Page 8: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Contents Introduction to Survival Analysis

Censored DataTerminologies and NotationsKaplan-Meier Method Modeling in Survival DataParametric Regression

ModelsCox Proportional Regression

Model

8

?April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 9: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Censored data

We don’t know the survival time exactly.

9

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 10: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Why censoring may occur?

1) A person does not experience the event before the study ends.

2) A person is lost to follow-up during the study period.

3) A person withdraws from the study because of death (if death is not the event of interest)

or some other reason.

10

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 11: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Examples

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

11

Page 12: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Table of Survival Time

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

12

Page 13: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Right Censored Data

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

13

Page 14: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Contents

Introduction to Survival Analysis

Censored DataTerminologies and NotationsKaplan-Meier Method Modeling in Survival DataParametric Regression

ModelsCox Proportional Regression

Model

14

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 15: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Terminology and Notation

T = Survival time (T ≥ 0)t = Specific value for TSurvives > 5 years?T > t = 5

15

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 16: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Survival Function16

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 17: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Survival Curve

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

17

Page 18: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Hazard function

The hazard function gives the instantaneous potential per unit time for the event to occur, given that the individual has survived up to time t

Hazard function focuses on failing

18

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 19: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Different type of hazard functions

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

19

Page 20: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Relationship of S(t) and h(t)

If you know one, you can determine the other

20

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 21: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

21

Page 22: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Appropriate Distributions

Some popular distributions for estimating survival curves are:

WeibullExponentiallog-normallog-logistic

22

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 23: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

23

2: To compare survivor and/or hazard functions.

1: To estimate and interpret survivor and/or hazard functions from survival data.

3: To assess the relationship of explanatory variables to survival time.

Page 24: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

How to Draw the Survival Curves?

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

24

Page 25: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Contents

Introduction to Survival Analysis

Censored DataTerminologies and NotationsKaplan-Meier Method Modeling in Survival DataParametric Regression

ModelsCox Proportional Regression

Model

25

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 26: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Kaplan – Meier Method

The Kaplan – Meier (KM) estimator is the most widely used for estimating survival function

product-limit estimatornonparametric maximum likelihood

estimator.When there are no censored data, the KM

estimator is simple estimator

26

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 27: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Practical Example

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

27

Page 28: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

How to estimate Survival Curve?

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

28

Suppose there are k distinct event times

At each time there are individuals who are said to be at risk of an event.At risk, means they have not experienced an event nor have they been censored prior to time .

Page 29: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Lifetime Table

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

29

Page 30: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

KM Estimator

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

30

The KM estimator is defined as

Where number of failures at time jm

Page 31: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Lifetime Table

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

31

Page 32: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Are KM curves statistically equavalent?

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

32

Page 33: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

H: Survival functions of all groups are the same

Log-Rank testWald testScore testLR testWilcoxon testPeto testTaron-Ware test

33

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 34: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Weakness of KM method

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

34

Teatment V.S Placebo

Continuous variablesEffect of several variables

0

1

TreatmentRx

Placebo

Page 35: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Contents

Introduction to Survival Analysis

Censored DataTerminologies and NotationsKaplan-Meier Method Modeling in Survival DataParametric Regression

ModelsCox Proportional Regression

Model

35

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 36: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Modeling Survival Data with Regression

36

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 37: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Parametric Regression Models

are the regression coeffcients of interest.

is a scale parameter

is the random disturbance term

37

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 38: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

The Cox Proportional Hazard Model38

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 39: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Semi parametric Model

is unspecified

39

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

Page 40: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

Proportional Hazard40

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

bb

h1

h2

Page 41: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

41

Page 42: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

42

Page 43: NASSER DAVARZANI DEPARTMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY, 6200 MAASTRICHT, THE NETHERLANDS 22 OCTOBER 2012 Introduction to Survival Analysis.

April 19, 2023Survival Analysis (N. Davarzani)

43