Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl...

48
Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron sputtering for trace chemical analyses Noppadon Nuntawong, Ph.D. National Electronics and Computer Technology Center (NECTEC)

Transcript of Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl...

Page 1: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron sputtering for trace chemical analyses

Noppadon Nuntawong, Ph.D.

National Electronics and Computer Technology Center (NECTEC)

Page 2: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Raman

Rayleigh

Photoluminescence

Atomic emission

http://www.photonics.com/Article.aspx?AID=45231

Photon interactions with substances

Page 3: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Vibrational modes for ‐CH2 group

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrared_spectroscopy

Symmetricalstretching

Antisymmetricalstretching

Scissoring

Rocking Wagging Twisting

Page 4: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Vibrational Spectroscopy

Infrared spectroscopy

Raman spectroscopy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrared_spectroscopywww.andersonmaterials.com

In the field of spectroscopy, two main techniques are applied in order to detect molecular vibrational motions: Infrared spectroscopy and Raman spectroscopy.

Page 5: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

What is Raman scattering?

Raman

Rayleigh

Fingerprint spectrum

Wavelength shift

C. V. Raman (1888-1970)

It is the inelastic scattering of a photon !

A Raman spectrum can therefore be used as a fingerprint for chemical substances

Page 6: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Raman chemical fingerprints

Page 7: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Molecular vibration

7

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_vibration‐ir-‐2.html

Perhaps surprisingly, molecularvibrations can be treated usingNewtonian mechanics tocalculate the correct vibrationfrequencies. The basic assumptionis that each vibration can betreated as though it corresponds toa spring. In the harmonicapproximation the spring obeysHooke's law: the force required toextend the spring is proportional tothe extension.

Page 8: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Hooke’s law

8

www.chem.ucalgary.ca/courses/350/Carey5th/Ch13/ch13-‐ir-‐2.html

Page 9: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Hooke’s law

9

www.chem.ucalgary.ca/courses/350/Carey5th/Ch13/ch13-‐ir-‐2.html

Page 10: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raman_spectroscopy/

Non-destructive and non-invasive method No need of sample preparation Vibrations inactive in IR spectroscopy may be

seen in Raman spectroscopy No problem with aqueous solution Detailed chemical/molecular analysis Spectral information can be used of future

analyses

Classical system Modern Raman imaging system

Handheld Raman

Raman spectroscopy advantages

Page 11: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Raman spectroscopy disadvantages

CRC Press 2009/

The Raman effect is very weak; only 1 in millions of

total scattering

Very low sensitivity

Difficult for fluorescent sample

A trace analysis is almost impossible

Page 12: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Surface-enhanced Raman scattering

EnhancedRaman out

Molecules in plasmon field

Laser in

Au or Ag nanostructure

Improve sensitivity of Raman Spectroscopy!

The Raman effect is very weak; only 1 in a million of total scattering A trace amount of samples may be undetectable

Page 13: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

SERS Substrate

Typical substrates

Aggregated colloids (silver or gold)

Roughened silver (gold) surface

Patterned silver (gold) surface

Pros. Cons.

Large enhancement factor

Low enhancement factor

Large enhancement factor

Inexpensive

Low stability, productivity

Expensive

substrate

substrate

Page 14: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

OTL Facilities: PVDs

Evaporator Sputtering

Sputtering Sputtering

Page 15: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Self assembled Nano-structural Films

Page 16: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Nano-Structured film

Shadowed region Adatom diffusion

Slanted columnar film

structure

Key Technique; Glancing-Angle Deposition (GLAD)

Page 17: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Compared with commercial SERS chip

Page 18: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

OnSpec: NECTEC SERS Chips

Page 19: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:
Page 20: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Gold Medal Award from INST2017

Page 21: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Some applications of ONSPEC

I. Toxic substances

IV. Narcotics

II. Explosives

www.allfraud.com

III. Fraud documentary

,http://agriculturewire.com

Page 22: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Recent method using GC-MS scan takes > 2 days!

Application I: Toxic substances

SERS takes about 10 minutes!

Page 23: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Trace detection of organophosphates

Page 24: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Orange juice

Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm)

Demostration of trace detection in orange juice

Page 25: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Application II: Investigating explosive substances

Page 26: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Explosive components

nitrogen-based fertilizerIEDs

Military explosives

Industrial explosives

Page 27: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Trace explosive detections

Page 28: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Trace explosive detections

Page 29: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Explosives analysis (Industrial explosives)

Samples collected from southern provinces1. Buster2. Dyno3. Emalex4. Megablast5. Power Gel6. Origa7. Super Power

Results from ion chromatography indicated some contain perchlorate trace

Page 30: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Trace perchlorate detection by SERS

Forensic Science International, Volume 233, Issues 1–3, (2013), Pages 174-178

Just burn it!

Page 31: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Post-blast experiments

Page 32: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

By collecting evidences from witness materials

Goal : Explosive types identified by SERS spectroscopy

Steel

Concrete

TNT ANFORDX

Chlorate

Tetryl

Black powder Power gelPower gel+Chlorate

keep trace evidenceCotton

Vial

SERS spectroscopy

LaserDetector

Post-blast experiments

Page 33: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Post-blast experiments

Page 34: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Post-blast experiments

Using mapping capability of confocal Raman microscope

SERS Mappings technique

Select peaks

Target molecules mapping

Page 35: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Post-blast experiments

Detection of black powder-explosive in acetone at concrete area !

1049

712

Mapping method

Page 36: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Post-blast experiments

5 out of 8 post-blast can be detected by SERS mapping technique

Page 37: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Application III: Fraud documentary

Page 38: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Ram an sh i ft (cm -¹)

Inte

nsity (

co

un

ts)

500 1 000 1 500

0

5 000

10 000

15 000

Ram an shi ft (cm -¹)

Inte

nsity (

co

un

ts)

500 1 000 1 500

0

5 000

10 000

15 000

Ram an sh i ft (cm -¹)

Inte

nsity (

co

un

ts)

500 1 000 1 500

0

5 000

10 000

15 000

Normal Raman spectra of inks on a paper

Page 39: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

M. Claybourn, M. Ansell, Using Raman spectroscopy to solve crimes: inks questioned documents

and fraud, Sci. Justice 40 (2000) 261–271

Difference of Raman and fluorescence response indicates modified documentary

Case study: Using Raman spectra to investigate document

Page 40: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Raman shift (cm-¹)

Inte

nsity (

cou

nts

)

500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500

2 000

4 000

6 000

8 000

10 000

12 000

14 000

16 000

18 000

20 000Spectrum : Parker 0.8 mm

Allianz c.p.Cross 0113EFaber castel 0.5 mmParker 0.7 mm gelParker 0.8 mmRamy M63Yellow duck

Conventional Raman spectra from blue pen samples collected from local stationery store

Page 41: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Raman shift (cm-¹)

Inte

nsity (

counts

)

500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500

10 000

20 000

30 000

40 000

Spectrum : Parker 0.8 mm SERS

Parker 0.8 mmParker 0.8 mm SERS

Raman shift (cm-¹)

Inte

nsity (

counts

)

500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500

10 000

20 000

30 000

40 000

50 000

60 000Spectrum : Parker 0.7 mm gel SERS

Parker 0.7 mm gelParker 0.7 mm gel SERS

Raman shift (cm-¹)

Inte

nsity (

counts

)

500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500

5 000

10 000

15 000

20 000

Spectrum : Ramy M63 SERS

Ramy M63Ramy M63 SERS

Raman shift (cm-¹)

Inte

nsity (

counts

)

500 1 000 1 500 2 000 2 500

5 000

10 000

15 000

20 000

25 000

Spectrum : Yellow duck SERS

Yellow duckYellow duck SERS

Comparing SERS and conventional Raman spectra

Page 42: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Improved discrimination power for pen ink

Ink colors

Samplenumber

Ink Type Raman active (%) DP

Oil-

based

Water

based gel

Water

based

RS SERS RS SERS

Black

49 65 28 7 20.40 87.75 0.36 0.79 Blue

46 24 54 22 0.00 86.95 0.00 0.95

Red 50 44 42 14 20 98 0.36 0.81

Total 145 133 124 43

Page 43: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Application IV: Narcrotic drugs

Page 44: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Real case: Yabah mixed with an energy drink

sample

methamp

caffeine

Page 45: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Ongoing researches

CRC Press 2009/

Detection of 2-Methylisoborneol (2-MIB) that is

responsible for the unpleasant odor in water

Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (TB)

Dengue virus (DV)

Page 46: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Product Roadmap

Page 47: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II:

Researchers

Page 48: Nanostructured Ag thin film SERS substrate by magnetron ... · Orange juice exposed with Methyl parathion (3 ppm) Demostration of trace detection in orange juice. Application II: