Nagarjuna on Skillful Means

7/28/2019 Nagarjuna on Skillful Means

1/25

xe qe txe exh ri hy g sxi y p

usvvpv wiex99

tohn hroederF w9 goll o wlnd

elo nm o fdd ol mnd don o kllEnEmn99 @yEklyAn wn fdd lD n no on dlod mon on n lon o xjnF qn y nl don n l wn D nd n xjn nl loo o donD non ol ll nono o y nlnd xjn9 oF wl 9 kll wn

onl nn d oy o dD nd no o ol onnl oElook monX

xn

9D od9D mn9 @kF nyA nd o on ll n ondd n

nd D om oonl n nd dnon kll

mn9 l n ndd o llF e on n d o ln

n o fddm nonn lo m dmnd lo nE

onF @ IWUVD F PA

lk o non o y nl l o xjnD o lldd n omon nd n ml dF eodn o

mo n olD xjn no onl do m ll l lon dnd on F dd onnonlD n oElD nlD o dononD nd o no dl o mEn99 @ nyA ndmn ll o lool oonD ommonlmd xjn dln mon ml olm nd nk fdd omo noml o F

s d xjn ml onnd yD oD n o mn oj mknF nn o y ll n ommon donl n mX no onnd

n o nd mD lD onl dnD o ononD nd ndn o onlz lon om fdd F o nk oE o m hm n d om oolol ndol on nd fddm n d o n l dEn n mndF wo onmo n xjn ol do nkllloon ln m o nd lln lon o ndndn o n ml olmF qn fdEd nn on ndnl n o D oD nd n xE

jn9 on oon n wn donD l nlkl n donl ml onD nd n mo nlkl nk

fdd oolo dnd on F

loo i 8 olm SHD xm R yo PHHH SSWSVQ SSW> PHHH n o r


2/25

o o lD nD o o dn on o xjn om on ond n onmo n olF l mo oll xjn o m nd ond o mn99 ndmn ll Edonl lool nd donD klll mn99 dn ll l

xjn9 loo oll o o fdd F s ll no k mn o lD D lD o onon o m99 n nlnD o mn99 l o oolol o fddm nd mn o o o m99 o nn nF

gon o on m nkD do no n xjn no nonElooF kllEnEmn99 looD l n dn n om donll ondF n loo donll o ol Elon o nd do mo o nlll o o oln mlolmD on mon olm nd o old n odo l mnnl lF dn don o y @nd

n fdd donA om o n n m o ndEnd fddm om F kn om fdd9 l ol on nonEoolol olmD y j d md o lon ol lonF s ooondl lool nd n lD lEl momn n fdd donF

xjn nd klll wn

qn kno ll o xjn9 lD nd n dol o ll on d o mD m o mkn ndn onnon n o nd don o yF gF vndn on o n ol o d n l lll n xjnnd yX

sn m D d on o o xjn9 n o o

n o9 dD fddD o dd ml o o dn o

ll nd om o F mo old o o onn

wn dl o ykly @klll mnAF D wlmdymkkkD

nynd yn nndd o dd looll

mndd monkF dlykn n lln o xyykF kkD xyddD nd ymddykk ll

onon o fdd F g domn onn o9

onl n fdd9 donD l myD fodnD

fodm@kAD llkD nd nlon ol dd ml

o d fdd dnD monk ll lmnF @vndn IWVTD F IRA

l no oo xjn o ll D ndndEl vndn old onn xjn9 loo o kllEnEmnF99 e fddD xjn n o ommn o dnD nd

o do dn n lF l n om onl doonl

STH loo i 8


3/25

mnD ond n g

D o looll dnD ondn ukD nd dd d n o dn nldn fddmonkD olnD oodo rndD nd lolF ol d ld vndn o no onl xjn9 mno99 okD

dd od dnD n looll oo wdymkkk nd ynFs om mo ll xjn o y n mnd n

mn n o F sn fodm

@kAD o mlD X

jnm mo o fodD kllEnEmn D nd omE

on dF

en D n hmD lnn o n o hmD nd

lo n o n o o klll mn o n

@oAF

l nn ln n o n nd o lnD @ odA

on o nlnmnX o n o o n onl3

v no d ln n3 sn od o n ln nD n d

nd n om o o o doo o lonF @vndn IWVTD F IPUA

end n fodn

D o mdnl l o fdd9n dd o l km ll o nn nX

n o oo o old od @nA ol o ln

nF fdd mlo l o klll mnD k mn oldl omF

@vndn IWVTD F TSA

xjn ml n om vo D on odom D nd mlkndD ll o o y on onnlF yn onD on mn ll nl n on xjn9loo dd yF yn on m ond odd mool xjn dln donl n ml nd kn m lool ln unD rmD nnD tmDnd hdF s ll ond odd o no n n dEon llF xlD j on o d ll dloF

nn o n wyn fddm

sn loo wD99 om ul d om o loollon dod ll o olm ondn n nd E o lo @ul IWWPAF ul ll om o lon mED99 nd nd o dn om o o loollon m olmz nd nd o olo F ml lon d od nl

ondn n o nD lnD ononD nd D mE

ton od STI


4/25

l lon d od o lo X o nl D o okD nd don joX

lo nll o o nom nonF s E

nD o dol yo9 mD nmnoF99 s nom n mon

on o ommn n om l @nD lnD onlnD oE

nD nomnD nd o onAF wl lon n no o nd

o n m o o nd nom nonF omn

nD o l od o nD n nd o lo F w

nlz nd l nnF do nc s omn

mmdc ndc imodc s oD l o do okc end old o donl mo n noc @ul IWWPD

F IUVA

ul9 don o m n l ndnd nn o

y nd o l o xjnF don o y dlod wn fdd o oo on o n oo nd o nEdn o onn no n ol oolol @mAF ilwn jnmD vo D nd mlknd fddm o n nn nm o D99 mdD99 nd mdnld99 o l oD nd mk o nk onl on mdEnl o ll nn nF fdd n ml n99 n l kno dn o lln o nn nD nd kno o o dmn o mdnF99 r kno o Dn o mn lnD nd n o F99 o fddm

o nD oldD d mdnF99en oo ml o klll mn99 n Ewn l non

ond n wjjmEnkyF sn mo on o D fdd d n 99 d o nn n o ln om

D nd on old n om n n mo

n ll dX s o ln o D o ondl D o D o d o D99 fddD n o do no ndnd n ml o D o on oD nd no o n old o99 @gonz IWSRDF VUAF wn don nd 99 mo no don o

kllEnEmn99 @yEklyA nd l lond dom @jnAF nkllEnEmn99 nd domD fdd nd od k o l onl nd n mn n o l nnnD n mn kn mon o o on n lddonF mo nn oyD oD l o ondomonl o lon do no dnd on ml nlo oldF

sn vo D o mlD mn l ldn om nno omn m mn @un IWVWD F WRAF donllD on lm o dlon nd nonD mn fdd9

n lD nd ond99 od o lm o nlnE

STP loo i 8


5/25

mnF mlonD o oD m no n o nlnEmn n ldn ld o klll dF99

mlknd ml n n o o fdd don ll o ll nn nF ondd d

mdn99 m on om m olm nd on n d m mdnF99 f hmD mlkD no 99 @mn IWVTD F SIAD mnn no d nlo lD nd o mnn l l o ln n on nond o o o ond99 @mn IWVTD F PVAF n fddk dl n o o mlk nd n o llnD o mElD ond ollon oX

vodD s m ndd ln o o o ood mn o n o llnF c vodD

s mm on dD n s n hm o om on monk n

oD v mlk m nd d o mD nd nD onE

n olD d mnd o on kD nd n m

hm399 @mn IWVTD F PVA

ndndlD n l dl nd od ln o mlk n on on o on o o ml fdd don o nn o klll mnF99

olm o l wn fddm d o n l o k no on o o lln nd n onn nD n n nd omon F fdd mEl o l on donnd om km ll

o nn nF sndD ond o on nd nd doon oo o F r nllnn o n n ono mlD old nl o no nlD nn o no nnD nd o o klll d99 n n n o on old no l o oolol o l onF pom klll mn99 D n fdd9 ln o l o nd nd doon o l dnD nd mndd no o fdd9n om ol nd dol onF

l don o y dn wn om l eEdm donD old on o nk o don no dn ml oonF kllEnEmn99 no ml Fs no kn o l on n o lD o ononDo lD kn o l on fdd nd o loF e D mo kn o ul ll m99 n mDnd dn m nd n d n fdd oF el llm noX

ool nd don m d on donl mD nd o o donl dE

n m m odD old n dn

o omdF xlD dn o don onl mF

sn oD mon old l onn monk oldn dn don o

ton od STQ


6/25

lon d n m llD o lon dd o m

mon odF @llm IWVWD F RA

e wn fdd nd n d edm fddDxjn l onnd o llF f dd m om edm fddD nd o hm nk mndoodc e l onon o lc e llo mEc wo n ol edm fdd onnd donl ml D nd xjn kn m on ondF eodn o g qdmnnD o mlD edm Elln loo onnd oln n d nd ondn o od o lol o n @qdmnn IWUUAY o wk d molol l99 on oondn o o @d IWVVAYo xn uz dnoon o99 @uz IWVIAY o t qld

nl99 nlln o onnonl n o nomn @qldIWWSAY nd o nk lk hd vo nd rold god edm oon ml o ln @vo IWVU nd god IWWHAF

s l n m xjn9 dn onnd o n ollo xjn dln m llF D edm ml o vol eomD molol lD mnD o loo o lnD nD n xjn kEn D m n n don llF f o mkn nd o l on edm don ll donF

edm fddm

e l dn o edm l D mjo fdddonD nl on o F dld l o mD99 nl o n no dmD mnon o l ondonnD nd m on dnn99 nd n99 lo o mmnn nomn lon on n o md nd o l o lonF od o l lld edmEk dlod o md Dnd dn 99 o ool o om l dn

lon on F d n dn ool lml o donl o o o mdF ro mndm do on nd o dn99 n md c ro old on lo o nomn n m o ononc n on oolol nd l nd o o onn o E o nd n edm lF

gnl o ll mjo edm don lon o dm nol99 o m99 @m

kA o o o mdonF l don dE

d o nm om

k nd nm odm on nd o mdonD ommon m o dd dm no mjo oX

D l o ononD nd n lmnF m

STR loo i 8


7/25

llod o k onon o mjo o o nD oldn ddd o lo nlF om99 @AD o nnD nld n on nd n ojD ddd no dn o nl nD oloD ondD D mllD nd o onD

o ddd no o oloD ondD D nd mll on nF o n nlD edm ool od ol dn o md n nd o l od n omndlnF

l edm don dd o on ndd oo o o n lmnon o dlmn99 @klAD nlld oon o n on nd om m mdnl odm o dom @jnAd on on99 odmF

sn dn donD o mlD o 99 dddno llF pD lmn D99 dl E

l nd mnl onY ondD n o D99 onml o mdon on po xol Y nd dD n d o 99 n on o dlmn99 nd lz on99 nd nD o d mdonD om ll ld F

sn d donD ll o ddd no n oonF99 yn mo ol o on o molD mndDD doD knold o o D knold o o modDndD nllD 99 o lonF nd l n oolol d on on dn nnknold99 o onon nd onD dolonD donD nD nd

o oD nd on kno o o nd o modEolol mn o ollon F

e mo edm donD o o 99 dEm nl o nD D nd dD m nd99 nod o onF99 f dm dld99 dD lDnD dD nonD nd o oD m d nd lmndF D on o o dn o mdonD l n@ynA lmn dlmn99 ndD on omldDn oml mnonF

o lon nd n edm don ul llmlF99 s ll onnd o mdon on dm llld o lonF n nn ll o on9 n dm no lon c99 ro m o mnl n o o lo md c99 lon n on9 odmnd lonc99 on dn om o ml nd n donl n loo nd old mk klo lm edm don don m o on o o ln nD lol ommD o lmF s old mk n mo kl o lm xjn kn edm

fdd on ml ond llF

ton od STS


8/25

do mk edm olmD ond wn don dlod don oy n l lon nl ollon md F o mdn on odm nd D o ondon o nD nd o ld

o l l o nd D on nno n lonF ndl onon n ollonX

f no mn o n on o lo non o E

nD nd on old o nd n on o

nmonD o mn fddok

m md lo mnon o nF po dn no l o loln n o n n donF @dn IWVVD F SUA

lo non99 nd o o do mdEon on n o dmD mdon mndl o mmnnD

lD nd ll F nd lo ml o mdn n El @FFD o n99 dn nl o dmA n mol o n lonF sn n D nd ln n ondon o ndD lon mn o edm fddD n n oo o ll fdd o olloF

xjn9 g o gly

sn wdymkkkD xjn k m o olz fdd lzn m o lo o n on o o ol

lnF glld koD on dd n ollon omX

IF s no qFPF s no noEqFQF s no o q nd noEqFRF s no n q no noEqF

xjn oold lo n ol o mn nnom lD lD D odonD donD mnnD mEmnnD D mD moonD nd o oF en l o onDo mlD xjn l

ko

nd onld dm @A no

odd @qAD no nonEoddD no oD nd no nF yD n l o moonD l dl nd onld moon @A no mon@qAD no nonEmonD no oD nd no nF

n xjn lzn om n n onon o El n ollon mk om nnn on o ukX

x om l no om noD

xo om oD

xo o D

ho nn D n F

@qld IWWSD F QA

STT loo i 8


9/25

nnn o xjn9 k on lF n dom mlD om omn lD om oD o om no oFxjn dn ll o lnD odl on n onEon o l mknF

r do n n ndndn o EndE lon n dd o n o dnn dnF sn o odD dnl o D dn om D oD o nF n dnl dD do ln o nd Eo omn nd o om dn om onF f nd dnlD no n n om o F oD xjn non n om lF

ho mn nd lon n o dn n@n om noAc xjn dn lnD n lollmol o o n o ll ldD n o

dn n ld n onn m d n ondEond nomnF t o o l dn dn n lonE n nd D o n nn on dn ld o oml n o n od o ldF D odn oxjnD m dndD nd mnn o l lnF on @o dnAD99 gndkD mon o no ll99 @nIWUWD F RPAF

l l o lnD lo dnd xjn o n ondo nd ond o no mkn lol nF n nd o dnl nd nondnl ondonX

@ qA99 nd no @ qAF99 end n om no no onlloll mol @o n non n omn no ncA ml n n om n o oF e fddl X

n nno o D old nl nn old

n mD nF @n IWUWD F RQA

onlon o o d om xjn9 dl l m99X no nD no d o nl nD nondln mF f do mn o l mD99 nd

xjn o onnd kn o o on n docwo onmo n on xjn kn mE

l o onF po mlD om ood xjn9 oon n o dnl o n lo @ood IWWRAY FFF wnd hd vo n m o m nndnl n ondln nd onlzon @w IWSS nd vo IWVUAY d nk on lm99 @d IWVVAY hd uln ml o voEl o9 jon o m @uln IWVTAY nd qld n o onnonl99 n o on @qld IWWSAF ol

lo m no m o l o l o l

ton od STU


10/25

n nD ll n n oml mnon nl ll dono ml mnF qld mk l n X

s nno omzd xjno n o wn fdd

looD o m onndD n nd o

onD o n llD do o nnl on

n nn mnon nd no od o od lool oF

D nl nd oll k n nlF D xjn llD nd fdd ml dD oo dlon l o ll

mn nF @qld IWWSD F VVA

qld9 nlzon o ll wn fdd loo zzlnDll nD l om wn D olm edm fdd no od ml m o

j on o oolol o ll oF ll wn loE

o onnd m nl no ooY no oo ll mn n d kn n nlF99 nnlzon n d on o fdd loo nd m mn n n lnd n olzn F s xjn n qld nk doD n l o on o oono md99 jd klll mnF99

s d xjn kllEnEmn99 nkD oD n ll no onlonF o do oD nd o mm xjn kn d o F po mo edm donD lon dnd on o99 mdon o dmD on o nd D o onE

dondD nd o nF xjn k o on o d odm ond fdd o onF

sn dn donD o mlD d ndln momn99 o mdon n nnn nD D onn oo n oF ndln n lld dm9 l n99 nd l o md F o md on dm9l n99 ood o m momn99 mn on no lon o ld ln99 nd ll o nD on no lon do ln n o l n nd n n

o lm99 nd l99 D nnF l o dn En odm o nmon o lonFxjn9 olm o ond

on m md on l n od o n lonF s dm mn no d ll n nY nd lEd99 n dnl o mlD nd dn don odndn nF99 D o xjnD dn o dm d n on o fdd mdonD n dm nd dndnn ond oF

nk lo jd dn oon ood nd

d mdon omod o onno ln99 o on o

STV loo i 8


11/25

momn99 no ononX dm nd momnY omom noD l99 o n nnD nd n nF o oo99 ol o md odl nd n lonF

po xjnD oD o om nonn ml

o dn F s od o md on dm onEnn no onn n on momn nd nD n n o l o od o l o fdd c sdm non mo n dn momn99 n md lmD n onnon n on dm nd nc n m o no onnon oD n o n mk n o dndn n99c on xjn mkn D lk dnD nk oon nonn o X on m md on ln od o ldD n dn l n on m md onn momn @dmA nonlF

xjn9 on o nn nonn o do fdd lnn md F dn lm md on nl n o dm l nk lm md on dm momnD99 nd o nk onl nd o E @mAF o lnon ll l99o mll o m o m on nd m onln o don dn ml FroD odn o fddmD no 99 @d

A ml onlD o mn o F99 sn mlD 99 ll nEnooX l nd m n om o lnd n99 n

mo fddF fdd ml nll d o n l99 ol o lokd99 n l ndnD99 nd kd Eo99ln lool m n snd no mllno ol o od m n n99 omnF

s nl ommon o mk xjn9 ml dln mn o fdd m edm loo n ml jon o F e s d o n dn onD oD dol

onl n edm don n md n n 99 nl lnkd o X no on 99 o l n 99 o md F D l n 99 o lD nd 99 jon o D no o n dod om md o edm donF edm don kn o o n lonD o o mdD nd o o nk o fddF

don n o wdmk ool ollod xjn nk nd nk d ml o D nd

o mmd n klll mn99 dF m

ton od STW


12/25

o ommn mn99 o o fdd nd nonEfdd ool n sndF nk loo fkD o mlDo o mn99 o mn onomo d mod o mnonF f ln on n ndndn llom

@nEnmnAD l wdmkn loo old mo n ndn n ndndn o mn99 old n nnl nom d o F eodn o gndkD oD wdmk m n onl nd on o o on nddo no l on n ndndn nnF s dm onl oonll mno oonn nd n oD o do d dm @nEkyAnnl o oon n dndF e hll nn noD o nk no n mn nnll ll ok oolollX

dm ond o inlnd yn o mn o

o mn d nonF sn onD ld o n mn

md D no onom o nl o oml lo nd E

moloF @hll nn IWVTD F TWA

pom ml D d n o wdmkool d o n nd o fdd m nd ll o do l ml o lol F xjn9 d edm loo old n n ml lX no kn oon ol llD o lool o mo lD edm nk n o l o D nd

nk n oolol dom o fddF

xjn9 g o hm

sn s o ukD xjn onn k on edmloo nlzn po xol D nd lk lDmmnnD nD nd ondD ooD mF99 olm o nd o n n kond o dn onF s edm o l mD99 xjn D nd l nl o fdd D n xjn m o ndmn

n l o fddmF r n s n edm oon n ollon X

s ll o mD

x n no nD

n o oD ollo

po xol do no F

s po xol do no D

n knoldD ndonmnD

wdon nd mnon

ll omll molF

SUH loo i 8


13/25

s n do no D

o ll no F

o o D ll no n o F

xo ll lF

s oD l ommn ll no Fxo ll knd o onF

s po xol do no D

ll no hmF

s no don nd l ommnD

ro n fddc

s mn ond n D

jl onddF

@qld IWWSD F TUA

sn oD edm oonn n xjn o mnD99 n mk fddm oolollo ll dodF D po xol mD99 n no n fddD hmD nd nDno n mmnnD nonElD99 nd nn

D nd

odl ld o lon ll dodF xjn ond o oonn n mndood mn99X

ndndn o o

y mn nd o o mn

end o nn o mn noF

e onn o md F@qld IWWSD F TVA

f oonn kn mn99 o n nonn o po xol D md 99n o odD mn99 dF f on o nkn o mn99 n nk o99 mdon on lD D nd po xol n o lonF

xjn ond o mon n l nd nD nD no mn99 do D d n lD D nd po xol nnD99 EnlD o nX

s o n o ll n

sn m oD

n on o ll n

ll o on o nd ondonF

i nd

end n nd on

end ondon nd n nd n

end ll ndd molF

@qld IWWSD F TWA

ton od SUI


14/25

xjn o on o on n ml n l onEdonD nD nD nD nd o o d o n nlndndnD nd n n ndndn n mol o mo n llF s n no dndn nD99 nd o

dndn n99 mol o mk n o l o l Eo lF sn o odD o o o n ol d o ln 99 o fdd l ndd nonnlF xjn ond n fdd m m99 o mk n n o po xolX

s dndn n dndD

imn l jdF

old ond

ell o oldl onnonF

s mn jdDxo on ll oF

old on dd no nD

end old n o onF

s D ol old

ll nnD nnD

end F n nomnl old

old mmlF

s @ oldA no mD

n on old o oF o ndn n nd

endonn m nd dlmn old no F

@qld IWWSD F UPA

xjn d dF edm nk n mon o99 mdon on hm n E o lonD xjn nd n on k hm nlD D nD n n o fddm ndmndF vk on onD xjn mndn eE

dm loo o nonmnF po xol odo mdnl 99 l nn n oom EmnD on om d o o nonmn n on md n on o fddmF D xjn hmnld onD mmnnD nD ondD nd lon mF99

o ndnd xjn mn n z donl fdddonD m ll o mn no kllEnEmn99 D vnE vF nn o gn g9n D lk mn o xjn9D kn o ol o om d o fddmD nd oo nk n ol o lonF l no l o

SUP loo i 8


15/25

o n nEd nl o vnE vD o mn on ll l o l o xjnF

vnE9 doy

vnE v mll olm o olld n99 o do99 o nnEn gn g9n m vnE sE nF l nm o o on k o fdd do D nnl noD nood o n lool on n o mnD99 nlnEmnD dndn nD o l ondonnD on o nm non n g9n m nd dnF

e mon m ld o vnE9 l o n d lnonF pD vnE onl j mon o dn fdd don lln dn non n nd ln on fddD

n o nlnmnD o nn l n o do fdd nonF snD vnE ll dn D mlD fdd don m99X

pollo o D no fdd o ndD nd lD

nD n o nd mmd nlnmn ll ml mdE

n o d o momnF xon n lF in dD

old ll ll m mD ld olmn l mD o mn od

lnd D ononmn o kndF @on IWWQD F UTA

vnE nmn o dn oo D lln m n o fdd nd no l mnnD99

no nm o nl o dD99 n onndn ml oon o mD99 nd n on olddo om l mnn99 n ll fdd n oD old ll nmD odD D mdn o l o ll o ll ldno l mD od dln m m99 @on IWWQD F UPAFelo m vnE ddn donl fdd don ol on lool oonD no D o ll do no l o hm o o non99 @on IWWQD F SQAF

o k ommn ol mn old o o

nn vnE9 oj mllX D lll no hmD nolool donD nd no ml n o o dnF iEn s m n o oD99 ll mD o momn onlD mdn o d99 @on IWWQD F QRAF

qn vnE d g9n mD oD n D llDdo c sn n o n on nd ol mold n ono n g9n ol ll no ld F f n ndo dF vnE ll dn n no donl o non o do od nd 99 nd omd od F99 po mn ol vnE9 n oD

ton od SUQ


16/25

nondD nd ond kn o loF D vnE do no n odnd 99 onz nn lmon o ln nd onEl D nd jo o ok dn o o dl99nkn n nononlD onlD nd dol mnF l

on ol non o D lo ld om d om odo vnE modF o ndnd on m ll omn ml o loo oo o lk no l on d on nnon o n od o o o looD mD EmoloD o loD nd ll dn o noook no on o nn o looF99 D ll no don onunD loD rmD ooonl loD o n o onon D D donl dlomn non o do oF yolondD dn k n on o doc99

xoD l l loo D nldn mlD old om

l no n onD l o nonmn vnE n nd mk do o nF r no on o ndon99 l nomon k l o d ononEon n m nd dlF honD99 nd omod l olmD ml onD99 ldD99 nd o mn od lnd 99 md d om o do vnE l o nomonF

vnE9 dn ool dn om oll dnD ndo n on o od nd 99 ol no n n loo lF nlk mo oll dnD vnE9 dl ln n mon ommn nd n o l nlnmnF vnE9 mnn o

ddn onn o ond o on onD o o nddlD nd o nn nd nonmnF n omon om omD99 vnED s n ll l lkF mn m om omF99

s lml n m D nd n ollo o om o n nD s

o m llF ro do s do c f m o lookn m dnF s

don9 o on od ommon mol o D o oddon n knd o n ndF s j ll o m nd

n mk n oF @on IWWQD F QHA

e vnE noD l o o doon o dndo no l on nn lY no n nn ml nd no onnd nn nF r ml mn o D D nd o on mD nd n ond n mo o X

s dn o l n mddln l om o mD s n nonmn

l m nF s dn o n mddln l om o mD s n o nonmn nd nF s dn o l o l om o mD s

do no n nnD n nonmnD no nD no onF s dn

o ndndn ll oD n s dl m m

ol od nd k no on o lF @on IWWQD F SVA

SUR loo i 8


17/25

vnE D oD dnd on nk dn omF s d99 d onF r dol l n nlon o dnD nd o o o lool ndlo ndon oD vnE D o o99X ln

oD noE oD od oD nn oD oD fdd oF99 f ll o D D ml ondD nmD odD F F F non n o o99 @on IWWQD F THAF n omldon ll o do dn9 on nD vnE mold dol l no ol oolol ool ononn dndlF

D o oD on l d99 vnE n o n dnD nd mz no n hmD fddD nlnmnD nn

D D nd o oF d99 o do

dn kn n nd don o o g9n m E

nn mo n oonl dF D om d o hm n om l dk mnn99 ndD nD nno do mnF k donl on mnn o fddmc99 dd foddm om om c99nd n o domc99 nd nk lon dnd on n nn o onF

ol dn d z on od nd om ndE

ndn on F sn noook o don n o om ol

old lloD n n lD l o n loD no ln

non l D lln hk wnn99 nd dn omn oF mk3 flnd oolD o o j do o o o old dd

onc F F F pllo lD o ond nll on l nd no

o lookn oD mn ll ol o o d lc no

fdd o oD no o d oD no hm o ndF @on IWWQD

F TIA

o dD vnE o o ll o m99 m o vnEGnz donX m lD kkD nDonl99 mD nd dol onF sn vnE v

m o l dn on 99 nd no lon o mo olon o fdd donF vnE9 l o ookn n99 n dn do no dnd on ml dono oldD oF r ml ond o nonmn99 n n mmdF

e n om vnE9 l o nD o klll mn99 lon on n o fdd F r ml onnd olmo lo modolo nd mnD nd k o mo n ol nn nF e d o vnE v no kd o l on n o lD ondD mn nD o nn

on o mn o

fddm n o lonF

ton od SUS


18/25

xjn nd vnE

e k ml n vnE nd xjn d l nonFpD vnE9 mk no fddD no hmD no xn

D nd no

inlnmn99 odod n XPR o xjn9 wdymkkkn X

xo hm fdd

e n mD n n lD o n onF

@qld IWWSD F UTA

ml n vnE nd xjn om mo n n mm wdymkkk n k on donl fddmF sn ukD xjn nknl o mjo o n fdd looED nnn l nd n mon o D n o

ondond nD n nd nD nd mD omn nd dEonD l vnkD po xol D nd D nd onld ll o m mD99 lk dm99 nd llonD lk o qndF99yn o D D rn zd fddD on onl onF99 ommn mkl mlo vnE9 D n X

s ll oD no fddD no hmD no D no nlnmnF o o o lk

on d odD n o nd omnF flnd pool3 @on IWWQD F SQA

ondD vnE9 on n do no l o hm

o non99 nloo o xjn9 mo n on PW o yn n no lool ooonoF en mnl n x lm xjn n ll n m99 n m l o on on llD Xs s d ooon @jnAD d old o mF f s noooonF o s m no lF99 l mnn o dd mon wdmk olD l o momn o D lkvnED xjn no dnn n ml o oF

dD n o vnE do no l o hm o

nonD99 do mk nmo mk m ond mEllD n o on99 D lmnn mnd o n don99 @on IWWQD F QRAD nd n o nndD n o donn99 @on IWWQD F SHAF l omEmn ool ond mlD nd on nd n D vnEdmon dl no o mon n in s mn o o o momn onlD mdn o dF99 nd n n o n ml nn o onD o oD on o m d o o F e vnE Dpollo o D no fdd o ndD nd lD

nD n o nd mmd nlnmn ll ml

SUT loo i 8


19/25

mdn o d o momnF in dD old ll ll m mD ldD olmn l mD o mn od lnd Dononmn o kndF99 yD xjn old D fdd n mD99 nd n mn99 m99 o n n o ndndn

ld om n oolol onFxjn n n nn don o mn99 n mEl mnn n ssXII o wdymkkkX

imD99 nonEmD99 o99 o n99 old no dldF

s d onl o o o ommnonF @uln IWVTD F QHUA

sn o odD xjn nn n n m mn99no mF on o n n mD99 j on o n noElD o ll nomn dndnl

nD nd non o do ml don o nF e D on o n n onl o o o ommnonD99nd ommnon n mnd lnd l o oololndF e om D mn99 mnnl mF uln on n m d onl o k o ommnn on n n D n dndn@ymnnAD no lEn @AD nd nno dmd nd d99 @ulnIWVTD F QHVAF

vk vnED nD xjn n n ml mn omn99 n non mdn o dX

lm n n o onEnF nE

d mdn o o onmd oF @vndn IWVTD F PWA

l o lm 99 m mld no nkn mn99 dn n o lD xjn n wdymkkk sXIV mnD dd fdd n lm99 D D n D dndn dnon99X

dndn nD mnF dndn on

onnonF l mddl F @uln IWVTD F QQWA

n mn99 dnd on onnon mn d d o dF o d mll m don o mn99 F wn n ol xjn9 o lm 99 n nml oon D lmlD n o n nd nonEnlF l ll D nd o mmd mn99 xjn lm 99dld n nmo l wn non mo n kllEnEmn99dd fddF wooD dnon n lm99 nd onEnonl99 n l fddm no nl o molol o

ml o D om ol noD o dn o n

ton od SUU


20/25

nd ommnn hm @tllk IWTQAF D l xjn mn99 lm D99 nd l lo 99 nd mdn99 o d o D no oo oD o mD n o edm don nkn

o n ml Fend oD j vnE9 dol mod dnd on ondo99nD o xjn on m lk dol mnF sn wdymkkk @IVX T nd IV X VAD o mlD ollonX

fdd md knon onon o l nd don o noElF

e m mD no okn o omn l o nonElF

@uln IWVTD F PTUA

in D no D o nd no D nd n nd no X

fdd9 dmononF @uln IWVTD F PTWA

ondo99 n no nlk vnE9 lD D dndnon dnD ll n onD99 nonmnD99 oD onD nd l lz o lool nd lo oF99nlk xjnD o oD vnE on o o mo m99 mX

s om d ndD s d ndD om mon omnD s

m n moD om mkn moon D s m n F

@on IWWQD F SQA

xo old lld vnE on o ln o dol oF99 D n mkn ommn don

omn dn om ln omon n F r ommn mo l n om lln dl o mod o nF f on o don dn kn mod o omn dD omn mo mo nd mlll n ll F m o lln m o n fdd modolo j X no mo mo n lno o n o ondo99 F end on o n 99 mD ll mD o n99 omn om mD o dEll onon nonmn99 ndD lk D l om mF

xjn9 omln edm don old n n mEl lF vk vnE9 D99 xjn n o l99 omn om edm looF sn d o lon om do n nd o md mo nn n n fdEdmX nonmnF o onon llnD99 xjn o o kllEnEmn99 nd on o kn nd on n mFl l vnE nd xjn d d llD loDnd lool dnD o kn ml o mnnd ln lonEndn olm n fdd oX olm o Eomn d o o nonmnF o on olmD

xjnlon n wn don mn

SUV loo i 8


21/25

nd mdn99 o fddm @vndn IWVTD F PWAD nd n mn99 mF99 old ndnd ml m o m onF

gonlon

jd o o s zd n l o do jdn l o fddm om y olF xln l o fdd lD don o mnD99 nonElD99 nd dndnn99 om fdd F xjn9 mn o mnD99 omlD nll n ml mnX don moElol lmD nlmD mD lD nd nl o lnEF s ll omn o o mnd o ddn99 n nd oD99 o ln old no jGoj dlD o

o onon on n llo old o n99 nn n99 nd mF f l ml mo klll mn99 j o o nk o fdd n n D omn n d om ol nd dol onF

in mo olm mn o ol s z nEon o xjn yF mjo o wdmk ol s dEd ll no onl xjn9 o d od mE lon dnd on ndndn o okF eodn owD o mlX

dlD nD n o dD non o ndonD nl non o l nll ndmnF gol ndoodD n no nnlonD non o nonY ono oon o n nl

nono lon o lF @w IWSSD F PUIA

w no onl xjn dnon ndmnl olm n mnnD lo nk dll mod ll 99 F olm ll ml n nD nd on o on99 l onEl oD odn o wD mon o n nono non oF99 D old o @n nonAD n old

n lonF nn o w9 nl odlo n yX mn99 mn99 o on lon o lF99

pdk n lo d xjn n n yF imnD99 D mn o lln n ond n nl omn9 l omlonn n nl ndd n99 @n IWTUD F IRWAF l w ll xjn donn onl n onD99 n ll xjn kn nl o lnF f ndndn ll lonl nom o mnnD99 D od mnnl onl n Elon o o odD ll d99 o lonn o n nl ndd

nF99 gF F rnnonD tFD ml X

ton od SUW


22/25

onon o l onl o m nn o o nd

oj ol o mnl nd ml old nd mnnl n o

nndnl ond nd nomnF F F F mmdl n n

d n ndd ll D o nnl ndndn n o

omonn o n o mnnX o mn o

ol @mY yAnd ol l @nn

AF @rnnon IWVWD F RHA

po qldD yn o xjn9 loo l n on n o ll onD99 o ndn o k onnonl oomn nlX

on oo o n nd n nd n o ll nF end E

l nlD d nonF xjn nnd on o k nd

oo o nF F F F ynl mlno lzon o mE

nD onnonl lD o nomn nd o mn o mnD

xjnD n n oll oodF @qld IWWSD F QIRA

eodn o qldD xjn9 dl oo ndn o 99 old on no onl ll nomn m99 mn99 l mD99 oD qld D D ooD ml onnEonl dnonF

qn ll nk o do xjn9 dl n n yDo n s lm o o fddm D n D nonEyc mnon o o do o m olmF eodn o onD xjn ld kno n dn on9 olm D ndo o ol F olm ln lD99 nl o

lnD99 nlmD99 o onD99 xjn dd kn nEllY no onl dno n nn kn99 n mn nD n mdX nmlD mnF99 roD o olm nd on on nd nlF ed ndndnl o nol on nd om km doon o nddlD d mon nl o ll mn n nd nl F s xjn kn n D nd dono mn99 od o ll ll99 no m mD lD o lEl onD n dl j o y loo ll F qn

y j n nlzon o mn n nd nD old n om lln99 klll mn99 n o FroD s d o n o xjn on o

mn99 klll mn99 d n edm fddD nd o mkn lm o fdd F sn nD ny no n llD n k on ndn o nk n F

e n kd o mn o o nn fddm no d mdnD99oD nd n dod l o lnn o mol omk n o klll mn99 om on nd nd km doEon o n dnD oon o m on mn ool olmF s

d n ycs ondd n l o oD l d o 99

SVH loo i 8


23/25

od lonc s klll mn99 l dD nd nkn o om lo o fddm ll oD n s no ommd o on n on o yc

on o m mn k onF l no

99 o od lonF s no ondd n fdd l o Dno mdon dF o D ooD l o kn o fddm om D nd om olm o lnn nl d @FFDyA om o non n l o fdd onF sn D l ld lln99 fddD mlkD vnEDnd xjn n nF

yn o ndD dn m mn om o s z sm no on o lonF s no dmnd n dn n o d on old do n od o n lonF yn onD s d o mn l o don o n y nd o l o n

dnnd o o knon o on9 dn o lon old dF s l m mn d mo om o s EzF po mo n olD xjn9 mn99 nD mdn ll on dl o dD nd non lldod o lln o olm nd o o F end ll o D oddlnoD o n knon o F s ml d o o o nd no o donF99

xo

s old lk o nk om ul nd o n o IWWU xirmm mn on n fddm o n m o nk d o dono yF s m lo l o hon v om n o yon nd rnomonD tFD om F w9 goll o wlnd o ll ommn ndonF

n

gnD rElF IWVPF l q F foonX hF dlF

gonzD iddF IWSRF fdd o eF x okX loolvF

godD roldF IWWHF hd nd sndn looyF x okX no x ok F

hll nnD F IWVTF wdymk ool n sndF x hlX wollfndF

qldD t vF IWWHF io nd nyXkm i nd F99 looy

i nd RH @QA @tlAX PVSQHUF

ton od SVI


24/25

F IWWSF pndmnl dom o wddl yF yodX yod nE F

qdmnnD gF IWUUF nn nd fddmF x okX wmlln vdF

rkD ekF IWWHF e roy o sndn fddmF ronollX n or F

rnnonD gF FD tF IWVWF imn o imnF ronollX n or F

tllkD uF xF IWTQF ily fdd oy o unoldF vondonX qo ellnnd nnF

ulnD hdF IWVTF xjnX looy o wddl yF elnX n o x ok F

ulD om F IWWPF loo wF99 sn ho nd Ddd pnk nold nd hd F elnX n o xok F

uzD xnF IWVIF xjn nd nn on ioF99 sn uzD fdd ndn looyF x hlX lnF

unD rF IWVWF ddmEndk o vo o vF x hlXwoll fndF

vndnD gF IWVTF w o domF fklX hm lnF

voD hdF IWVUF glo o hononX e wn g o hdF99snnonl lool lyPUXSWVHF

wD xnlokF IWVQF qd o edmmEkF undXfdd lon oF

wllD fF uF IWVTF onX en iy n gll sndn o o unoldFyodX yod n F

wD FFF IWSSF gnl looy o fddmF vondonX qo elln ndnnF

dnD vo wF IWVVF edmkoymF fklX en rmnF

D wlF IWUVF kll wnX e gon n wyn fddmF vondonXhkoF

ononD d rF IWUPF hd xjn ll ell loolc99 looy i nd PP @QA @tlAX QPSQQIF

dD wkF IWVVF xjn enElF99 tonl o sndn looy ITF

F IWVWF nkn on imX wdmk enElm nd gnon o

SVP loo i 8


25/25

onlF99 sn only n onD dd lomo fdmnF vdnX iF tFfllF

nD wnF IWUWF vd ioon o wddl yF foldX jn F

nD pdkF IWTUF imnX e dy n lo wnnF xllXendon F

mnD oF IWVHF lool xononm n nn nd gnEdk n mn o vn olmF99 looy ind QH @QA @tlAX QPTQPUF

F IWVTF mlkndX roly n o mlkF n kXnnln n F

onD fonF IWWQF n n o w vnEF foonX mllonF

llmD lF IWVWF wyn fddmX honl pondonF vondonXoldF

oodD omF IWWRF xjnn honX e lool tony on sndn vooknEqlF ronollX n o r F

t d

Nagarjuna on Skillful Means

Documents

Transcript of Nagarjuna on Skillful Means