Mukesh Document
Transcript of Mukesh Document
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
1/24
Title
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
2/24
Acknowledgement
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
3/24
Abstract
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
4/24
Table of Content
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
5/24
Chapter 1: Introduction
1.1 Introduction:
E-commerce or e-business is one of the common and most happening topics of discussion
in current competitive world. E-commerce is defined as the process of selling and buying
the goods and service over internet and without making any physical visit to stores. Use
of computer in business has reshaped the relationship between the supplier and customer,
streamline the business process, restructure the whole industry and optimize the supply
chain. An internet based e-commerce solution is conducted by using World Wide Web
application for the purpose of performing more than one business activities and functions
at one point of time. These business activities and functions include buying and selling of
goods, distribution of goods, supply chain management, communication, and delivery of
payment among the suppliers, producers and customers. Use of e-commerce system in a
typical organization system makes the products and service available on internet and the
customers can buy them without making any physical visit to store or without any human
assistance. In banking sector, online service has played an important role. Customer can
do a wide range of activities online such as securing a loan, changing the address,
application for credit card and developing a personalized service level agreement without
getting help from any individual. Hence e-commerce is an innovative way of conducting
the business activities and executing the business transaction using computer. This
research study has been conducted to understand the relationship between online service
quality and customer satisfaction. The aim of this chapter is to provide background
knowledge to the reader about the topic and help the reader to understand the insights of
research area. This chapter also includes the problem discussion, research questions and
research objective.
1.1.1 E-Commerce Activities and Its Role:
Increasing penetration across the world has provided a tremendous opportunity for the
companies to reach maximum target customers with the minimal cost. The World Wide
Web users are spreading out at a significant rate. The most popular and common aim of
using e-commerce is to replace the traditional mode of business channels by initiating the
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
6/24
web based store front. In such type of e-commerce generally company offer its products
and service online and it is called business to e-consumer selling. At present there are the
four common e-commerce activities undertaken by the users such as banking, investing,
shopping and electronic payment for internet services. In past few years, it has been
observed that there has been substantial growth for internet based services in both from
the traditional companies and internet based business which is also developing the online
services. The incredible growth of internet is changing the way of businesses to serve its
customers. A significant change in the way of conducting the business is observed in
banking industry where the banks are offering transactional and financial service to its
customers over internet. In last two decades banking industry has been moved up towards
the internet. There have been more than 500 conventional banks in US that has adopted e-
commerce for maintain their competitiveness in the current market place. Some of the
major banks are Well Fargo, Bank of America that has offered a range of services
including loans, fund transfer and credit cards. If look at the customer perspective, then
online banking is a convenient way of accessing the retail banking service in a time
saving manner. On one hand internet is currently improving the banking services some of
the banks are still lagging to meet the customers expectations and demand. Hence it is
important to provide expected and desired level of satisfaction and also essential while
banks are introducing the online services.
1.1.2 E-Commerce and Customer Satisfaction:
In any of the business customer satisfaction is a critical issue either it is traditional or
online. Therefore banks which are currently using internet needs to understand the how to
satisfy the customers along with maintaining the market share, sustaining the business
growth and competitiveness. Customer satisfaction is important for maintaining the long
term relationship with the customers. Also it has been evident that number of financial
institutions and banks regularly conduct customer satisfaction survey. It provides the
fundamental understanding of key drivers of satisfying the customer needs. Therefore to
understand the customer satisfaction with the e-commerce it is important to understand
first about the customer satisfaction in general. Customer satisfaction is defined as the
cognitive and affective evaluation of comparative standards in relation to the perceived
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
7/24
performance. Also it can be understood by means of difference between the expected
level of service quality and what exactly is delivered by the company. for example if the
perceived level of service or product quality is less than the delivered level of quality
then the customer will be satisfied. On the other hand if the expected level of service
quality is higher than the delivered quality then the customer will be dissatisfied.
1.1.3 Relationship between Customer Satisfaction and Service Quality:
Key measure of user satisfaction is service quality. Past researches in this context
identified that there are certain dimensions of quality and they have also listed out the
various aspects of online service and its relationship with the customer satisfaction.
Another instrument of measuring the customer satisfaction is SERVQUAL where the
researcher has given much attention to understand the close relationship between the
online service quality and customer satisfaction.
1.2 Research Problem:
In the current competitive world the customer needs are essential to consider for every
business. Specifically in financial service industry, there are number of players and each
player is providing innovative solution to its customer in many ways. Therefore for some
banks it is essential to maintain their service level standards which provide the complete
satisfaction to the customers and fulfill their needs. It is considered that the internet
business provide more value to the customer rather than businesses which provide the
services in a traditional way. It is perceived that internet based businesses provide more
convenience to the customers, more interactivity and relatively low cost with a high
degree of customization. There is a very little understanding of factors which impacts on
the overall customer satisfaction even with internet based services. A rapid development
in the information and communication technologies enabled many businesses to provide
high tech service with minimal time and low cost to take care of the customer need in a
more effective way. For banks, the internet based home banking brings in the dramatic
change where they can have more substantiate relation with its customers and meet their
expectations and needs. With a rapid change in the technology, the service quality has
become an important issue for the banks to satisfy the customer needs. Number of
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
8/24
researches has been conducted so far which provide the key dimensions of service quality
but no research provide the key attributes of service quality and its relation to the
customer satisfaction. The research problem can be formulated as to determine the key
attributes of service quality and its relative impact on customer satisfaction in
financial/banking sector.
1.3 Research Aim and Objectives:
The aim of this research is to determine the key attributes of service quality and its
relative impact on customer satisfaction. In order to achieve this aim, the following
research objectives have been achieved by the researcher:
o To understand the service quality and customer satisfaction in banking sector
o To determine the service quality dimension in banking sector in relation to e-
commerce and its impact on customer satisfaction
o To explain the importance of service quality dimension in relation to the customer
satisfaction in the context of internet banking
o To provide the recommendation to banks in improving the service quality and
achieve highest level of customer satisfaction
In order the above research objectives; researcher has answered the following research
questions.
Research Question 1: How service quality and customer satisfaction is interrelated in
internet banking?
Research Question 2: What are the dimensions of service quality in internet banking and
how it impacts on customer satisfaction?
Research Question 3: How important the service quality dimensions are in relation to
the customer satisfaction?
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
9/24
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
10/24
commerce system in a typical organization system makes the products and service
available on internet and the customers can buy them without making any physical visit
to store or without any human assistance. A rapid development in the information and
communication technologies enabled many businesses to provide high tech service with
minimal time and low cost to take care of the customer need in a more effective way. The
next chapter includes the detailed literature where researcher has discussed various
theories related to service quality and customer satisfaction for gaining the better
understanding of both the factors which has also worked as a base for carrying out the
research further.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
11/24
Chapter 2: Literature Review
2.1 Introduction:
Customer satisfaction from the view of past research is defined as post evaluation of
customer behavior after purchase of a specific product or service. Most of the researchers
also stated that satisfaction is an attitude of customers which can be evaluated by
differentiating it pre purchase and post purchase of products and services. The aim of this
chapter is to provide the detailed view of literature in the context of service quality and its
relationship with the customer satisfaction.
2.2 Service Quality and Internet Banking:
Service quality is a tool which companies are using to develop the competitive advantage
and considering its importance, in past two decades the research have been undertaken to
understand how it is changing and in what ways it provides the overall customer
satisfaction. According to Bitner et al (2003), service quality is the consumption of
services by the customer to give the overall impression relatively superiority or inferiority
of services. In broader terms service quality can be defined as a difference between the
expected level of customer and perception of received service. On the other way
Parasuraman et al. (2008) defined service quality as the how well the service is delivered
to the customer to match its expectations. Service quality in internet banking has its own
place where competition in banking industry is very high. Service quality in online
banking therefore works as a competitive advantage. Internet has been emerged as a key
competitive area where future of financial service exists. Online banking offers a range of
services to the customer with interactive feature at lowest cost of service than the
traditional banking service (Cronin, 1998). The internet banking website was first
launched by Security First Network Bank (SFNB) with more than 1,000 financial
institution plans were made to offer online banking services. The new banking prodicyts
are utilized with the launch of advanced technology such as electronic money and smart
card via Internet. In early 80s internet banking proved to be a revolutionize system where
it offers more convenient and a wide range of service than the traditional banking
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
12/24
services. At that time the response of customer for internet banking system was
appreciated though it is different from the home banking due to easy access. With the
launch of internet banking, the customer can access its account anywhere in the world at
any point of time and can make the necessary transaction with out actually visiting the
bank branch. In order to retain the customers and secure their loyalty, number of banks
has provided a unique online experience to its customers which were not accessible
through offline mode of banking channels. A significant investment was needed to
initiate the online banking service therefore it was critical for the banks to maintain the
service quality through online banking system. However change in technology has
reduced the burden of cost and banks are capable enough to meet the customers
expectations and maintain high quality of their online banking service.
2.3 Customer Satisfaction and Its determinants:
According to Kotler (2003), customer satisfaction is a type of feeling of an individual for
either a pleasure of disappointment from the performance of product or service
purchased. Yi (1990) defined customer satisfaction as the collective outcome of
evaluation, psychological reaction and perception from an experience of consuming
goods and services. On the other hand Hunt (1991) stated that customer satisfaction is
the function of customer belief towards the product and services purchased by them. As
per the literature of marketing Oliver (1980) stated that disconfirmation theory has been
emerged as preferable foundation of customer satisfaction model. A discrepancy between
the perceived level of performance and cognitive performance is provided the measure of
satisfaction under the theory of disconfirmation. A partial belief about the product and
service for a customer is known as the satisfaction. Customer expectation on the other
hand is viewed as the prediction of customers about what he thinks and what needs to
happen during the transactional exchange. On the other hand perceived performance is
explained as the customer view of what should be the performance of a particular product
and services. Oliver (1980) has given the process of satisfaction and its judgment in
disconfirmation and expectancy framework.
Expectation
PerceivedQuality
DisconfirmationSatisfaction
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
13/24
The above figure presented the formation of satisfaction among the customers
where an arrow drawn from expectations to perceived quality indicates that the
expectations are directly proportional to the perceived quality. There is a positive impact
on the satisfaction from expectations and also the perceived level of disconfirmation.
Hence both the perceived quality and disconfirmation has greater impact on the customer
satisfaction. There are certain determinants of customer satisfaction and several authors
have provided the number of models which list out the customer satisfaction and its
determinants. For online shop[ping internet, there are five antecedents of customer
satisfaction as identified by Hi and Wu (1999) such as technical characteristics, logistics
support, informational characteristics, product characteristics and presentable view of
home page.
From the above model it can be seen that each antecedent tends towards the customer
satisfaction. Logistics support refers to the quick response of delivery of goods to the
customer through communication channel and providing better after sales service
support. Technical characteristics include the technical factors such as modern computer
network facility and structures information system to provide up-to-date information.
This also concern with the secure and reliable information. Home page presentation
includes the use of interface and detailed out the information about the goods. It also
includes the layout of the home page and presentation of information about the goods and
TechnicalCharacteristics
Home PagePresentatio
n
Customer
Satisfaction
LogisticsSupport
InformationalCharacteristics
ProductCharacteristics
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
14/24
services. Product characteristics include the range of products and services and low price
products covering all the SKUs.
2.3.1 Success Model Developed by DeLone and McLean for End Users:
DeLone and McLean have provided the success model which is based on the role of
information management system and it explained how the challenges in the adoption of
e-commerce can be explained. In e-commerce enabled business, the prime users of
information system are the customers only rather than the manufacturer or supplier. Both
the suppliers and customers are the main users of system to make selling and buying
decision and taking the business transaction. The decisions made on e-commerce based
business transaction than have major impact on industries, individual users and national
economies. As per the success model, there are the six dimension of customer satisfaction
such as system quality, information quality and service quality, use of system, user
satisfaction and net benefits. In the internet environment, system quality refers to the
characteristics of e-commerce system. The value of e-commerce system quality includes
adaptability, reliability, response time and availability. Information quality refers to the
web content which should be precise, crisp and easy to understand so that customer can
quickly grab the knowledge about the product and service and purchase them online.
Service quality in this sense also refers to the overall support provided to the customer
after sales. It should include the delivery of information by the service center. some of the
critical points of information need to be pasted on the website itself such as frequently
asked questions, news blogs, customer feedbacks and other critical points which ensure to
provide better and superior customer satisfaction. Poor information support in the website
leads to the loss of customer and loss of sales. Usage refers to the visiting of website and
navigating the website to retrieve the information and use of information. Customer
satisfaction with the website is an essential means of measuring the customer opinion and
should also cover the experience cycle starting from retrieving the information, purchase
of product to make the payment and receiving the receipt. Net benefit refers to the over
all satisfaction of customer with the service quality since it is the success measure of
system quality, information quality and technical aspect of the website.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
15/24
2.3.2 Customer Satisfaction and E-Commerce Success Model:
An e-commerce success model was proposed by Molla and Licker (2001) which is based
on the model developed by DeLone and McLean as discussed in the previous section.
The point of differentiation between these models is replacement of information quality
and system quality components from DeLone and McLean model by content quality and
e-commerce system. In the traditional quality system and information quality
measurement, the constructs of content and e-commerce system cannot be captured
which is required in e-commerce success model. Customer e-commerce satisfaction has
replaced the user satisfaction. Trust and service are the two additional factors which
require capturing the custom and transactional support components in the e-commerce
system. Further it provides the relationship between the customer satisfaction and usage.
Different dimensions of measuring e-service quality have different consequences and
varying effects on customer satisfaction (Wilfinbarger and Gilly, 2002).
2.4 E-Commerce Activities:
According to Eastin (2006) there are the four activities performed by the user in e-
commerce such as online banking, online investing, online shopping and payment to be
made electronically for internet service. There are the six attributes of the e-commerce
model such as self efficacy, financial benefit, and previous use of telephone, risk and
perceived convenience.
All of the six attributes of e-commerce system together combines the adoption of e-
commerce system in the banking sector and bring in the tremendous experience of
service quality and customer satisfaction.
2.5 Online Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction:
Prior Use of Telephone
Self EfficacyRisk
Financial BenefitPerceived Convenience
Internet Use
Adoption of E-commerce
BankingShopping
Online ServiceInvesting
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
16/24
In banking sector service quality is an essential component since there is a lot of
competition in the industry and each player has unique resources and strategy to attract
the customers. In such a competitive business scenario if the customers of any bank are
dissatisfied then it eventually helps the competitors to attract them. Service quality is
therefore a subject of considerable interest for both the researchers as well as the
practitioners. Service quality has a beneficial impact on the bottom line of the business
performance of the firm which has created the interest among the practitioners. In
academic perspective the customer satisfaction from service quality is recognized as
being a distinct in the industry and develops fairly independent lines of service quality.
Hence service quality leads the better customer satisfaction with on time process.
According to Caruana & Malta (2002), customer satisfaction is perceived to be an
important output from the service quality. Authors have hypothesized that the customer
satisfaction is an antecedent of service quality and it assumed to be one service factor
which contributes in measuring the customer satisfaction judgment. Few researchers in
past have tried to identify the key determinants by which the customers evaluate the
service quality. Further these researchers have analyzed whether it leads to the
satisfaction or not. According to Jayawardhan & Foley (2000) the feature of service
quality in the website of internet banking is critical and so for the customer satisfaction.
There are two key driving forces which lead to the higher level of satisfaction and
attracting new customers namely unlimited access to variety of financial services and
quality information about products and services offered by the banks. there are two well
known measures which enable the researcher to determine the impact of service quality
on customer satisfaction such as technical or the functional quality and SERVQUAL.
Laser et al (2003) has tried to compare these two models to understand the dimensions of
service quality and its impact on customer satisfaction. Based on the findings it was
observed that functional quality is more important and complex than what it is perceived.
Further the functional quality has significant influence on the customer satisfaction. In
order to measure the information quality of service product, Pather, Erwin and Remeyi
(2003) provided the model which also explains the relationship between the service
quality and customer satisfaction. This model provides the measurement learning of both
the customer satisfaction and online service quality.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
17/24
According to Laser et al (2003), the above model explain the measurement of service
quality and customer satisfaction by evaluating the five dimension of SURVQUAL
including reliability, responsiveness, tangible, empathy and assurance. Therefore to better
understand this, some of authors have provided the definition of service quality as the
subjective comparison of which a customer make between what is perceived or expected
and what actually they receive. Past researches suggested that all the dimensions do not
have equal impact on the consumers perception towards the service quality. Therefore it
is essential to understand which service quality dimensions are more critical to encourage
the greater level of customer satisfaction. In online business, every individual who visit
website is a customer and end user of both the network system and information. A 12
item scale was proposed by Doll and Torkzadeh (1988) to determine the satisfaction level
of customers with information system. There are five key dimensions that were proposed
Measuring E-commerce Effectiveness and Quality of Service
AMeasurement of
User Satisfaction
BMeasurement of
Service Quality
+
CCustomers has
expectations of service
through use of E-
commerce system
DService is delivered viainternet and supported
through call center
E-businessWebsite
Measuring the gap ofindicative level of service
quality through satisfactionuse
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
18/24
to test using this scale to assess the satisfaction level of end users and these dimensions
are accuracy, content, timeliness, ease of use and format. Validity and reliability of this
scale has been tested by many researches in the past and concluded that it provides the
substantial results. In online retailing, traditional service quality dimensions are not at all
relevant however there are some factors which are critical for the success of online
business such as credibility, communication, appearance and accessibility. The following
section discusses the difference between traditional and online service quality dimensions
in more detail in the context of internet banking.
2.6 Service Quality Dimensions Traditional Vs. Online:
Service quality is the consideration of both the parishioners and researchers. Also from
the definition of service quality, it is described as the difference which a customer makes
between the expected or perceived level of service and what exactly they receive from the
provider. Customers who buy online demands more services which are available in
traditional mode of channel even if they are purely internet based. In a research
conducted by parasuraman et al (1985), the key findings of the research stated that there
are the ten determinants of service quality such as reliability, tangibles, responsiveness,
competence, courtesy, access, communication, security, knowledge to the customer and
credibility of information. These dimensions were further refined and concluded to five
such as reliability, tangibles, responsiveness, empathy and assurance. On the other hand
online service quality dimensions are four such as privacy, fulfillment, reliability and
efficiency. Based on these dimensions, it has been observed that the customer perception
is directly linked with the banking service product quality and it plays an important role
in overall customer satisfaction. In internet banking, there are the ten dimensions
identified by the Jun and Cai (2000) as courtesy, credibility, competence,
communication, access, responsiveness, reliability, continuous improvement, customer
and collaboration. Six dimensions of service quality as perceived by customers are
identified by Yang, Peterson and Huang (2001) as listed below:
Website contents which matches with the need of customers
Content accuracy
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
19/24
Response to the queries of customers
Privacy of information
Ease of using friendly navigation, search on the website, speed and sitemap
Layout and interface of the website
Few banks have developed their own methods to evaluate the service quality. For
example Bizrate.com is a scale where the service quality is assessed on these ten
dimensions. Another evaluation method is Gomez.com which is an alternative solution of
Bizrate.com. The point of differentiation of Gomez.com is difference of 5 dimensions
such as ease of use, web contents, product pricing, confidentiality and security of
information.
2.7 Conceptual Framework:
Based on the literature discussion on service quality dimensions, researcher is covering
five important dimensions which are common across all the authors to test the service
quality of internet banking such as efficiency, reliability, responsiveness, privacy and
fulfillment. Customer satisfaction is an important output from online service quality.
Based on the five dimensions the online service quality of internet banking is assessed to
determine the overall customer satisfaction. Efficiency refers to the interface of the
website and web content which provide the product information for the desired products
covering all the aspects to buy it. Reliability refers to the technical aspect of website and
information which is provided in the website should be accurate. Responsiveness refers
to the response to customers within the appropriate time frame and provides support to
the customers with prompt response if in case any problem occurs. Fulfillment refers to
the delivering everything which is promised to the customer along with the accuracy of
information. Privacy refers to the security of customer information while logging into the
website and should be shared with any one else such as credit card information, debit
card information, password, internet banking pin etc.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
20/24
2.8 Summary:
Online service quality has its own importance since consumers are becoming more
conscious and they need every thing at par quality even if they dont mind to pay more
for such quality. A significant increase in the penetration has also increased the online
population and people are willing to purchase or consumer service more over the internet.
In such a way every transaction to be done over the internet is self explanatory there is
not physical support provided by the company. In this way it is essential for the
companies to maintain the service quality level up to the mark and ensure a high level of
satisfaction among customers. There are certain dimensions of online service quality
which is explained and discussed in the above literature however none all but few of
them are of great importance. Customers who buy online demands more services which
are available in traditional mode of channel even if they are purely internet based. Past
researches suggested that all the dimensions do not have equal impact on the consumers
perception towards the service quality. Therefore it is essential to understand which
service quality dimensions are more critical to encourage the greater level of customer
satisfaction.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
21/24
Chapter 3: Research Methodology
3.1 Introduction:
A research methodology is a process and steps taken by the researcher for undertaking
the research work. A research methodology consists of various components which can be
selected through suitability and relevance of research aims and objectives. This chapter
includes the detailed explanation of research methodology that has been used by the
researcher for conducting this research study.
Research Methodology:
Before proceeding towards the research methodology design it is essential for the
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
22/24
Chapter 5: Conclusion and Recommendation
5.1 Introduction:
If an enterprise is managed a little better than customers expect, and if this is done in a
slightly better than competitors can manage, then the enterprise should be successful.
There are several factors which have contributed to this, a number of which are referred
to in our discussion of the strategic challenges facing organizations and the dimensions of
the new customer and the new forms of competition. Together, these have put pressures
on mangers to develop strategies which not only are far more clearly focused upon the
market, but which are also infinitely more proactive, flexible and innovative. However,
for many mangers, the problem is not necessarily that of identifying or gaining an
advantage initially, but of sustaining is over any length of time.
5.2 Conclusion:
Marketing strategy is concerned with matching the capabilities of the organization with
the demands of the environment. There is therefore a need for the strategist to monitor the
environment on an ongoing basis so that opportunities and threats facing the organization
are identified and subsequently reflected in strategy. The environmental conditions faced
by an organization are capable of varying greatly in their complexity and need to be
reflected both in the ways in which environmental analysis is conducted and in the ways
in which strategy is subsequently developed. The consequences of failing to take account
of a changing environment have, as we discussed, been illustrated by a wide variety of
organizational experiences, including those of the Swiss watch industry in the 1970s. It is
widely recognized that the pace of environmental change is increasing and that the need
for organizations to develop a structured approach to environmental analysis with the
results then being fed into the strategic marketing planning process is greater than every.
Despite this the evidence suggests that in many organizations environmental scanning
systems are only poorly developed. If this is to change, top management commitment
both to the development of a scanning system and to be incorporation of the results into
the planning process is essential.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
23/24
Businesses that survive the shakeout face new challenges as market growth stagnates. As
a market matures, total volume stablizes; replacement purchases rather than first-time
buyers account for the vast majority of that volume. A primary marketing objective of all
competitors in mature markets, therefore, is simply to hold their existing customers to
sustain a meaningful competitive advantage that will help ensure the continued
satisfaction and loyalty of those customers. Thus, a products financial success during the
mature life cycle stage depends heavily on the firms ability to achieve and sustain a
lower delivered cost or some perceived product quality or customer-service superiority.
Some firms tend to passively defend mature products while using the bulk of the
revenues produced by those items to develop and aggressively market new products with
more growth potential. This can be shortsighted, however. All segments of a market and
all brands in an industry do not necessarily reach maturity at the same time. Aging brands
such as Jell-O, Johnsons baby shampoo, and Arm & Hammer baking soda experienced
sales revivals in recent years because of creative marketing strategies. Thus, a share
leader in a mature industry might build on a cost or product differentiation advantage and
pursue a marketing strategy aimed at increasing volume by promoting new uses for an
old product or by encouraging current customers to buy and use the product more often.
Therefore, in this chapter we examine basic business strategies necessary for survival in
mature markets and marketing strategies a firm might use to extend a brands sales and
profits, including the strategies that have been so successful for Johnson Controls. Most
products eventually enter a decline phase in their life cycles. As sales decline, excess
capacity once again develops. As the remaining competitors fight to hold volume in the
face of falling sales, industry profits erode. Consequently, conventional wisdom suggests
that firms should either divest declining products quickly or harvest them to maximize
short-term profits. Not all markets decline in the same way or at the neither same speed,
however, nor do all firms have the same competitive strengths and weaknesses within
those markets. Therefore, as in most other situations, the relative attractiveness of the
declining product-market and the businesss competitive position within it should dictate
the appropriate strategy.
-
8/7/2019 Mukesh Document
24/24
5.3 Recommendation:
It has long been recognized that competition between organizations can be seen in much
the same way as a game, in that the outcome in terms of an organizations performance is
determined not just by its own actions but also by the actions and reactions of the other
players, such as competitors, customers, governments and other stakeholders. However,
as the pace of environmental change increases and the nature, sources and bases of
competition alter, markets become more complex and the competitive game consequently
became more difficult to win.
It follows from this that the need to manage competition and the competitive process,
while often difficult, is essential. Although there are no hard and fast rules, it is possible
to identify a number of very broad guidelines which companies might follow. These
include:
Never ignore new competitors, particularly those who enter at the bottom end of
the market since, almost inevitably, once a firm gains a foothold it will start
targeting other segments of the market. Examples of this include the early
manufacturers of calculators who ignored Casio; IBM, which ignored a series of
initially small players such as Apple, Dell and Compaq; the UK motorcycle
manufacturers who underestimated the Japanese such as Honda, Yamaha,
Kawasaki and Suzuki; and Xerox, which was hit hard by Canon. Always exploit competitive advantages and never allow them to disappear unless
they are being replaced by an advantage which, from the customers point of
view, is more powerful and meaningful.
Never launch a new product or take a new initiative without working out how the
competition will respond and how you will be affected by this.