MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

download MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

of 8

Transcript of MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    1/8

    WWW.MROMANAGEMENT.COM

    PW100family

    No end to turboprops

    Line maintenanceRamping up

    Boeing 737NGHeading for growth

    Composite repairsSurprises in store?

    MARCH 2012|VOLUME 14 ISSUE 1

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    2/8

    www.mromanagement.comMarch 201230 MRO Management

    Line maintenance

    Ramping upLine maintenance seems to have been a growth sector of the MRO marketin the last year. Ian Harbison asked a number of specialists for their view of

    why the situation has changed

    EWFOJOEJDVMUFDPOPNJDUJNFTPS

    QFSIBQTCFDBVTFPGUIFNBJSMJOFTIBWFDMFBSMZCFFODBMMJOHPONPSF

    PVUTJEFIFMQUPMPPLBGUFSUIFJSBJSDSBGUEVSJOH

    PQFSBUJPOT8FBTLFEGPSFYQFSUBEWJDFGSPN

    3PHFS.FFMT5FDIOJDBM%JSFDUPS%JSFDU.BJOUFOBODF"MUGSJFE/FTTFM$IJFG

    $PNNFSDJBM0DFS-VGUIBOTB5FDIOJL

    .BJOUFOBODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM*BO#BSUIPMPNFX

    4BMFT.BSLFUJOH%JSFDUPSPG.POBSDI"JSDSBGU

    &OHJOFFSJOHBOE1BUSJDL.PSDVT.BOBHJOH

    %JSFDUPS/BZBL"JSDSBGU4FSWJDF/FUIFSMBOET

    There seems to have been a signicant

    increase in the number of third-party line

    maintenance contracts being awarded.

    What are the reasons behind this?

    RM:8FMMGSPNUIFTUBUJTUJDTSFMFBTFECZCPUI"JSCVTBOE#PFJOHXFDBOTFFUIBUUIF

    DPNNFSDJBMBWJBUJPOTFDUPSPGXFTUFSOCVJME

    BJSDSBGUJTTFUUPEPVCMFJOUIFOFYUZFBST

    *SSFTQFDUJWFPGXIBUUIF0&.TXJMMTBZBMM

    UIFTFBJSDSBGUXJMMSFRVJSFMJOFNBJOUFOBODFBTXFMMBTCBTFNBJOUFOBODFFOHJOFTBOE

    DPNQPOFOUT*EPOPUCFMJFWFUIJTJTDPOOFDUFEUPUIFDSJTJT:FTPGDPVSTFBJSMJOFT

    BSFAFYUSBDPTUDPOTDJPVTJOUJNFTPGDSJTJTCVU *EPOPUTFFNBOZBJSMJOFTQVMMJOHCBDLGSPN

    UIFJSTUSBUFHZBOEQVMMJOHCBDLGSPNMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFJOGBWPVSPGPVUTPVSDJOH8FIBWFTFFOBOJODSFBTFJOPVSCVTJOFTT

    TJODFBTBJSMJOFTBSFNPSFGPDVTTFEPO

    TVQQMJFSTUIBUDBOPFSSFBMWBMVFGPSNPOFZ

    %JSFDU.BJOUFOBODFCFJOHBTNBMMFSBOE

    JOEFQFOEFOUQSPWJEFSXBTBMPHJDBMDIPJDFJO

    TVDIDBTFTBOEXFIBWFNBOBHFEUPDBQJUBMJTF

    POUIBUUPTFFEPVCMFEJHJUHSPXUIGPSUIFQBTUZFBSTXIJMFPUIFSTBSFTUSVHHMJOH

    AN: *ODSFBTJOHDPTUQSFTTVSF*UJTPGUFOOPU

    DPTUFFDUJWFGPSBOBJSMJOFUPQFSGPSNMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFPOPVUTUBUJPOTKVTUGPSUIFJS

    PXOBJSDSBGU"UNBOZIVCTUIFSFBSF

    TQFDJBMJTFE.30DPNQBOJFTMJLF-5.*JO

    'SBOLGVSUXIJDIDBOPFSMPXFSDPTUTEVFUPTZOFSHJFTGSPNTFSWJOHNBOZPUIFS

    DVTUPNFSTCVUBMTPPOPVUTUBUJPOTUIFSFJT

    BOJODSFBTJOHOVNCFSPG.30TTQFDJBMJTJOH

    JOMJOFNBJOUFOBODF*OBEEJUJPOUIFSFJTBMTP

    BOJODSFBTJOHUSFOEPGBJSMJOFTPVUTPVSDJOH

    UIFDPNQMFUF.30CVTJOFTTJODMVEJOHMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFBUUIFJSIPNFCBTF5PBOTXFS

    UIFUSFOEOPUPOMZ0&.TPFSTFSWJDFTMJLF

    (PME$BSF#PFJOHPS')4"JSCVTCVUBMTP

    .30TMJLF-5.*XJUI5PUBM5FDIOJDBM4VQQPSU

    JODMVEJOH5FDIOJDBM0QFSBUJPOT.BOBHFNFOU

    50.5IJTJTBPOFTUPQTIPQUPUBMDBSFQBDLBHFXIJDI-5.*PFSTGPSOFBSMZBMM

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    3/8MRO Management 31March 2012www.mromanagement.com

    Line maintenance

    "JSCVTBOE#PFJOHNPEFMTJODMVEJOHUIFOFXFTUPOFUIF

    PM:"MUIPVHIXFTFFUIBUBJSMJOFTHFOFSBMMZ

    BJNUPPVUTPVSDFBTNBOZUBTLTBTQPTTJCMF

    UIFZTFFNUPIBWFCFFOMFTTBCMFUPPVUTPVSDF

    UIFEFTJSFEBNPVOUPGXPSLEVFUPPQQPTJUJPO

    GSPNVOJPOTPOUIFSFEVDUJPOPGUFDIOJDBM

    TUBBTXFMMBTQPMJUJDBMQSFTTVSFPOTFDVSJOH

    KPCT"TUIFFDPOPNJDDSJTJTFOEVSFTUIFZBSF

    OPXNPSFFRVJQQFEXJUIBOBEEJUJPOBMTFUPG

    BSHVNFOUTUPPVUTPVSDFBDUJWJUJFT

    5IFJODSFBTFJOUIJSEQBSUZMJOFNBJOUFOBODFDPOUSBDUTTQSFBETBDSPTTBHDBSSJFSTBTXFMMBT

    DBSHPBJSMJOFTBOEMPXDPTUDBSSJFST5IFSFBTPOT

    UPPVUTPVSDFEJFSGSPNPOFBJSMJOFBOENBSLFU

    TFHNFOUUPUIFOFYUIPXFWFSBTBSFTVMUPG

    EJFSFOUNBSLFUEZOBNJDT8JUIJOPVS

    PSHBOJTBUJPOXFSFOPUJDJOHJODSFBTFEEFNBOE

    GPSPVUTPVSDFEMJOFNBJOUFOBODFQSJNBSJMZGSPN

    BHDBSSJFSTBOEMPXDPTUBJSMJOFT$BSHP

    PQFSBUPSTBSFOPUPVUTPVSDJOHNPSFPSMFTT

    UIBOCFGPSF.PTUIBWFBCVTJOFTTNPEFMJO

    XIJDIUIFZBSSBOHFUIFJSTVQQPSUUISPVHIB

    NJYPGJOIPVTFBOEUIJSEQBSUZNBJOUFOBODF-PXDPTUDBSSJFSTIBWFOPUSFBMMZDIBOHFEUIFJS

    NBJOUFOBODFUBDUJDTJOUIFQBTUZFBST5IFZIBWFBMXBZTPVUTPVSDFEBMBSHFRVBOUJUZPGMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFXJUIUIFJSJODSFBTFEFFUTJ[F

    BOEOVNCFSPGEFTUJOBUJPOTUIFJSEFNBOEGPS

    PVUTPVSDFEMJOFNBJOUFOBODFBMTPJODSFBTFE

    Do you expect this trend to continue?

    RM::FT*CFMJFWFBJSMJOFTXJMMCFMPPLJOHNPSF

    BOENPSFBUBMUFSOBUJWFTSBUIFSUIBOEPJOH

    FWFSZUIJOHCZUIFNTFMWFTQFSTF7BMVFGPS

    NPOFZJTLFZTPJTDBTI

    AN::FT"JSMJOFTXJMMUFOEUPDPODFOUSBUFPO

    UIFDPSFCVTJOFTT5IFZIBWFUPCFWFSZ

    FYJCMFJOJODSFBTJOHEFDSFBTJOHPQFOJOH

    DMPTJOHEFTUJOBUJPOTBOEDIBOHJOHBJSDSBGU

    GSPNPOF"0$UPBOPUIFS5IFSFGPSFBO

    JOIPVTFNBJOUFOBODFPSHBOJTBUJPO

    DPNQMJDBUFTUIFEFDJTJPOQSPDFTT

    PM:5IFUSFOETXFJEFOUJFEIBWFWBSZJOH

    ESJWFSTJODMVEJOHNPSFFYJCJMJUZBHBJOTUMPXFS

    DPTUTXJUIJODSFBTFEQFSGPSNBODFXJUI

    NFBTVSBCMFUBSHFUTDIBOHFPGPXOTVQQPSU

    OFUXPSLBOEUJHIUFSSFHVMBUJPOT5IFTFBSFEFQFOEFOUPOBJSMJOFNBOBHFNFOUOBODJBM

    BOEPQFSBUJPOBMQFSGPSNBODF5IFBHDBSSJFSTXJMMDPOUJOVFUPCFSFTJTUBOUUPPVUTPVSDJOHMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFXIFOBJSMJOFNBOBHFNFOU

    MFBWFTUIFEFDJTJPONBLJOHUPUIFMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFPSUFDIOJDBMEJSFDUPS5IFZXJMM

    DPOUJOVFUPLFFQUIFJSNBJOUFOBODFJOIPVTF

    BTUIFZQFSDFJWFUIJTQSPWJEFTUIFNXJUI

    JODSFBTFEDPOUSPM$PTUTBSFTUJMMOPUUPQQSJPSJUZ

    JOUIFEFDJTJPONBLJOHQSPDFTTDPODFSOJOH

    MJOFNBJOUFOBODF*GBJSMJOFNBOBHFNFOUJT

    PQFOGPSJOOPWBUJWFTPMVUJPOTUIFZXJMMTUBSUUP

    PVUTPVSDF.ZFYQFDUBUJPOJTUIBUBHDBSSJFST

    XJMMMJNJUUIFPVUTPVSDJOHPGMJOFNBJOUFOBODFJOUIFDPNJOHZFBST*FYQFDUMPXDPTUDBSSJFST

    XJMMDPOUJOVFPVUTPVSDJOHXJUITUSBUFHJD

    QBSUOFSTJOMJOFNBJOUFOBODFBOEDBSHPXJMM

    DPOUJOVFJUTDVSSFOUTUSBUFHZ

    Are there more contracts at hub airports

    or at outstations?

    RM:/P*EPOPUCFMJFWFTP8JUIUIFDSJTJT

    BJSMJOFTIBWFUPCFDPNFNPSFFYJCMFBOE

    Direct sees costs as a concern to many airlines, whichmay lead to them opting not to make local arrangements

    with a line maintenance provider at destinations, evenfor widebody aircraft (photo: Direct Maintenance)

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    4/8

    www.mromanagement.comMarch 201232 MRO Management

    Line maintenance

    TFBSDIIBSEFSGPSOFXDPNNFSDJBMEFTUJOBUJPOT

    TPNFPGXIJDIUIFZXPVMEOPUZUPCFGPSF "TBSFTVMUUIFSFBSFNPSFQPJOUUPQPJOUSPVUFT

    BUEFTUJOBUJPOTXJUIMJNJUFETVQQMJFSBWBJMBCJMJUZ

    PSXJUIMBDLPGUIFSJHIURVBMJDBUJPOT

    PM:8IFOMPPLJOHBUSFWFOVFPXTXFDBO

    TFFUIBUUIFSFBSFNPSFPVUTPVSDJOHDPOUSBDUT

    BUPVUTUBUJPOTIPXFWFSUIFWPMVNFTPG

    DPOUSBDUTBUIVCBJSQPSUTBSFMBSHFS

    What are the factors that aect this?

    AN:/FXFSBJSDSBGUUZQFTOFFEMFTTBOEMFTT

    SPVUJOFNBJOUFOBODF.BOZTIPSUSBOHF

    BJSDSBGUBMSFBEZZXJUIBOPONBJOUFOBODF

    DPODFQUPOPVUTJEFTUBUJPOTOPBJSDSBGU

    NFDIBOJDBWBJMBCMFEVSJOHUSBOTJUCVUBJSMJOFT

    XBOUUPFOTVSFUIBUUIFSFJTTVQQPSUJODBTF

    TPNFUIJOHHPFTXSPOH&WFOJGJUJTBCJHHFS

    QSPCMFNUIFYTIPVMECFRVJDL5IFSFGPSF

    BJSMJOFTMPPLGPSTVQQPSUGSPNPSHBOJTBUJPOT

    XIJDIIBWFBDFSUBJOQSFTFODFBUUIFTUBUJPO

    IVCBOEDBOIFMQRVJDLMZXJUILOPXIPXFYQFSJFODFNBOQPXFSBOEFRVJQNFOU(4&

    IBOHBSBOETPPO

    PM:$BSSJFSTIBWFUIFJSPXOUFDIOJDBM

    EFQBSUNFOUBUIVCBJSQPSUT$IPPTJOHGPS

    PVUTPVSDJOHXPVMENFBOSFPSHBOJTJOHMFUUJOH

    HPPGTUBBOETPGPSUI"OFXUSFOEJOMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFJTUIBUUIFTDPQFPGXPSLJT

    FOMBSHJOH/FXBJSDSBGUUZQFTBSFPSHBOJTFEJO

    TVDIBXBZUIBUNBJOUFOBODFVQUP$DIFDL

    MFWFMJGQSFTFOUJTTQMJUBSPVOEUIFOFUXPSL

    5IJTNFBOTUIBUTUBOEBSEXPSLJOMJOFNBJOUFOBODFEBJMZXFFLMZJTDIBOHJOHPWFS

    UPTNBMMXPSLQBDLBHFTXIJDIDBOCF

    QFSGPSNFEPOUIFBQSPOJOTUFBEPGHPJOHJOUP

    UIFIBOHBS5PEBZGFXBJSMJOFTDBOPSHBOJTF

    UIJTCVUTPNFBJSMJOFTBSFOPXTQSFBEJOHMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFXPSLBSPVOEUIFJSOFUXPSL

    TUFQCZTUFQ&OIBODFEMPHJTUJDT*5TZTUFNT

    BOEJODSFBTFEQSFQMBOOFENBJOUFOBODFXJMM

    GVSUIFSESJWFUIJTEFWFMPQNFOU5IFOFX

    BQQSPBDIFOIBODFTHSPVOEUJNFGPS

    NBJOUFOBODFJOTUFBEPGQVMMJOHUIFBJSDSBGU

    PVUPGTFSWJDFGPSBIBOHBSJOQVUBTJUJTUPEBZ

    IB:.POBSDI"JSDSBGU&OHJOFFSJOHJT

    TUSBUFHJDBMMZGPDVTJOHPOEFWFMPQJOHJUTMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFCVTJOFTTUPDPNQMJNFOUUIF

    FOPSNPVTTVDDFTTFTJUIBTNBEFXJUIJUT

    IFBWZNBJOUFOBODFEJWJTJPO"TBSFTVMUPGUIJT

    JOWFTUNFOUIBTCFFONBEFJOTFDVSJOHOFX

    DPOUSBDUTXIJDIXJMMDPOUJOVFBDSPTTB

    OVNCFSPGOFXMPDBUJPOTBOESFHJPOT

    New bases

    What about the investment in equipmentand tooling to set up a new base?

    RM: *OHFOFSBMUFSNTMJOFNBJOUFOBODFJTB

    QFPQMFPSJFOUFECVTJOFTTZPVSTUBNBLFPS

    CSFBLBMJOFTUBUJPOJOUFSNTPGSFDVSSJOH

    DPTUTBTXFMMBTPQFSBUJPOBMQFSGPSNBODF:FT

    UIFSFJTUPPMJOHBOEFRVJQNFOUSFRVJSFECVU

    UIFTFBSFOPOSFDVSSJOHDPTUTJONPTUDBTFT

    AN:'PSTJNQMFMJOFNBJOUFOBODFEVSJOH

    USBOTJUJUJTOPUBCJHJOWFTUNFOUJOUPPMJOH

    8JUIUIFUPVHISFRVJSFNFOUTCZ&"4"UIF

    JOWFTUNFOUJOUSBJOJOHGPSBOFXBJSDSBGUNPEFMOFFETUPCFDPOTJEFSFEFTQFDJBMMZXIFO

    BJSMJOFTUFOEUPRVJDLMZBEBQUUPNBSLFU

    EFNBOECZGSFRVFOUMZDIBOHJOHUIFUZQF

    ZJOHUPBEFTUJOBUJPO

    PM: *OWFTUNFOUTJOUPPMJOHBOEFRVJQNFOUGPS

    PMEFSHFOFSBUJPOBJSDSBGUBSFSFMBUJWFMZMPXFTQFDJBMMZXJUISFHBSETUPTUBOEBSEXPSL

    )PXFWFSOFXHFOFSBUJPOBJSDSBGUSFRVJSFUFTU

    CPYFT*5JOGSBTUSVDUVSFBOETPGPSUIESJWJOH

    VQJOWFTUNFOUEFNBOETTJHOJDBOUMZ

    Is there a critical mass of customers

    required to make investment in an

    outstation viable?

    RM::FTPOFDBODBMDVMBUFFYBDUMZXIBUUIF

    DPTUTJOWPMWFEJOTFUUJOHVQBOFXCBTFXJMMCF

    #BTFEPOUIFBOUJDJQBUFEMFWFMPGZJOHUIF

    DPTUTQFSJHIUDBOCFPCUBJOFE"TPOFSFRVJSFTBSFBTPOBCMFSFUVSOPOUIF

    JOWFTUNFOUBDIBSHFQFSJHIUUPNBLFB

    TUBUJPOWJBCMFDBOCFFTUBCMJTIFEGSPNUIJT

    AN: *UEFQFOETPOUIFTJ[FPGZPVSPFSJOH*GZPVXBOUUPQFSGPSNMJOFNBJOUFOBODFVQUP"DIFDLBOEBMTPOFFEIBOHBSTQBDFUIFDSJUJDBMNBTTJTPGDPVSTFIJHIFSUP

    EJTUSJCVUFJOWFTUNFOUBOESFOUPWFSNPSFTPMENBOIPVST

    PM:/BZBLTDSJUJDBMNBTTUPTUBSUBOPVUTUBUJPO

    JTUXPBJSMJOFDVTUPNFSTCSJOHJOHJOPOF

    BJSDSBGUQFSDVTUPNFSQFSEBZGPSTDIFEVMFE

    MJOFNBJOUFOBODF

    How much investment is needed to

    introduce a new aircraft type?

    RM:5IBUJTSFMBUJWFUPUIFOVNCFSPGTUBPOF

    XJTIFTUPUSBJO%JSFDU.BJOUFOBODFOPXIPMET

    BJSDSBGUFOHJOFDPNCJOBUJPOTPOPVS4DPQF

    PG8PSLTPXFIBWFBHPPEQJDUVSFPGUIJT5IF

    NBJODPTUFMFNFOUTBSFUIFSFQMBDFNFOU

    DBQBDJUZXIJMFZPVSPXOTUBJTBXBZPOUSBJOJOHQMVTZPVSUSBJOJOHDPVSTFBOEJTTVFT

    MJLFQFSEJFNTBOEIPUFMT"HBJOJGBDMJFOU

    XJTIFTUPZJOUPZPVSTUBUJPOPODFBXFFLJU

    NBZUBLFZFBSTUPIBWFZPVSDPTUT

    SFDPWFSFE*UIBTUPXPSLGPSCPUIQBSUOFSTBOE

    DBSFGVMQMBOOJOHJTSFRVJSFETPUIBUCPUI

    QBSUJFTIBWFBAXJOXJOTJUVBUJPOBUUIFFOEPG

    UIFEBZ8FBSFDVSSFOUMZXPSLJOHIBSEBOE

    JOWFTUJOHUPFYUFOEPVSTDPQFXJUIBEEJUJPOBM

    BJSDSBGUUZQFT

    PM:$PNQBSFEXJUIUPPMJOHBOEFRVJQNFOUUIFJOWFTUNFOUJOUSBJOJOHFOHJOFFST

    Line maintenance is one of five key strategic business units at Monarch. Being part of a large travel group and

    with an airline as a sister company, Monarch Aircraft Engineering reckons it has an edge as an MRO because it

    understands the pressures airlines face (photo: Monarch Aircraft Engineering)

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    5/8

    www.mromanagement.comMarch 201234 MRO Management

    Line maintenance

    JTUIFCJHHFTUXIFOJOUSPEVDJOHBOFX BJSDSBGUUZQFPOPVS1BSUBQQSPWBM8FFTUJNBUFBSPVOEJO

    USBJOJOHDPVSTFTBOEBTJNVMBUPSBTXFMMBT

    POUIFKPCUSBJOJOH0+5BOEBOJOWFTUNFOU

    GPSIBWJOHFOHJOFFSTUFNQPSBSJMZOPOQSPEVDUJWF

    Are new technology aircraft proving more

    expensive to set up for?

    RM:5IFQPJOUJTUIBUUSBJOJOHPQUJPOTBSFWFSZ

    MJNJUFEPGUFODPOUSPMMFECZUIF0&.*G

    USBJOJOHJTBWBJMBCMFUIFDPTUTBSFIJHIEVFUP

    MBDLPGBOPQFONBSLFU0&.TTIPVMESFBMJTF

    UIBUIBWJOHTVDJFOURVBMJFETUBBSPVOEBU

    TFSWJDFQSPWJEFSTXJMMCFOFUBMMTUBLFIPMEFST

    PM:5IFTFBSFTJHOJDBOUMZNPSFFYQFOTJWF

    FTQFDJBMMZXIFOJUDPNFTUPUSBJOJOH5SBJOJOH

    DPVSTFTBSFPOMZBWBJMBCMFWJBUIF0&.PS0&.QBSUOFSTBOEUSBJOJOHGFFTBSFBUMFBTU

    UXJDFBTFYQFOTJWFDPNQBSFEUPPUIFSBJSDSBGU

    UZQFUSBJOJOH

    Are new technology aircraft proving easier

    to handle?

    RM:5IBUTUJMMSFNBJOTUPCFTFFO/FX

    UFDIOPMPHZBJSDSBGUXJMMDPNFXJUIJOJUJBM

    DIJMEIPPEEJTFBTFTUIBUOPCPEZUIPVHIUPG

    EVSJOHUIFEFTJHOQIBTF:PVOFFEDPNNJUNFOUGSPNUIF0&.UPFOTVSFUIBU

    RVJDLBOERVBMJUZSFTQPOTFTBSFHJWFOUPBOZ

    JOJUJBMJOTFSWJDFJTTVFTBTTPPOBTUIFZBSSJWF

    PM:/FXUFDIOPMPHZBJSDSBGUBSFFBTJFSUP

    IBOEMFGPSTDIFEVMFENBJOUFOBODFUBTLT

    )PXFWFSXIFOBJSDSBGUBSFIBWJOH

    VOTDIFEVMFENBJOUFOBODFEFGFDUSFDUJDBUJPO

    DBOCFNPSFEJDVMUUPBTTFTT*5TZTUFNTJO

    UIFBJSDSBGUQSPWJEFSFDPNNFOEBUJPOTBOE

    HVJEBODFCVUUIFZTPNFUJNFTSFRVJSF

    UFDIOJDJBOTUPGPMMPXBMFOHUIZTFRVFODFPGTUFQTXIJDIDBOUBLFNPSFUJNF8JUIPMEFS

    UFDIOPMPHZBJSDSBGUPVSFOHJOFFSTPXO

    FYQFSUJTFPGUFOQMBZTBQPTJUJWFSPMFJO

    TIPSUFOJOHUIFSFDUJDBUJPOQSPDFTT

    IB:8FMPPLBUFBDIOFXPQQPSUVOJUZPOJUT

    PXONFSJUT8FIBWFUPDPOTJEFSUIFDPTUPG

    TFUUJOHVQBOESVOOJOHBTUBUJPOPGDPVSTFCVU

    XFBMTPUBLFJOUPDPOTJEFSBUJPOPUIFS

    PQQPSUVOJUJFTUIBUQBSUOFSJOHXJUIBOFX

    PQFSBUPSNBZUISPXVQBOEUIJTJOWFTUNFOU

    BQQSBJTBMJTSFMFWBOUGPSCPUIPMEBOEOFXUFDIOPMPHZBJSDSBGU

    SeasonalityMany contracts seem to be seasonal, how do

    you redeploy people for the rest of the year?

    RM:5IBUNBZCFUIFDBTFGPSTPNFUZQJDBM

    IPMJEBZDIBSUFSEFTUJOBUJPOTOPUBTNVDIGPS

    UIFMBSHFSIVCT8FIBWFUIJTBTXFMMXJUIIJHIQFBLTBOEEFFQWBMMFZT5IFTFBSFUIFUZQJDBM

    XJOEPXTUPQFSGPSNBEEJUJPOBMUZQFUSBJOJOH

    PSGPSTUBUPUBLFUIFJSBOOVBMMFBWF

    AN:8JUIBCJHOFUXPSLZPVBSFBCMFUPDPWFS

    TFBTPOBMWBSJBUJPOTJOCFUXFFOUIFTUBUJPOT

    -5.*BMTPIBTBUFBNPGFNQMPZFFTXIPBSF

    HFOFSBMMZCBTFEJO'SBOLGVSUCVUXJMMCFVTFEGPS

    TIPSUUFSNBTTJHONFOUTPOTUBUJPOTUPDPWFS

    QFBLTPSPEBZT:PVBMTPIBWFUPDPOTJEFSUIF

    EFNBOEGPSUSBJOJOHXIJDITIPVMEPGDPVSTFCFQMBOOFEJOUIFMPXTFBTPO

    PM:4FBTPOBMFFDUTJOMJOFNBJOUFOBODFBSF

    WFSZMJNJUFE0OMZBTNBMMOVNCFSPGDBSSJFSTBSF

    NBLJOHDIBOHFTBOEHFOFSBMMZPOMZUIFMFJTVSF

    BJSMJOFT$IBOHFTBSFHFOFSBMMZBOOPVODFEB

    DPVQMFPGNPOUITJOBEWBODF5IJTBMMPXTVTUP

    QSFQBSF5PSFNBJOFYJCMFXJUIJO/BZBLXF

    FYQFDUPVSTUBUPUSBWFMBOEQSPWJEFTVQQPSU

    XIFSFDVTUPNFSTOFFEUIFN8FBMXBZTIBWFBTUBUJPOUIBUTHSPXJOHBOESFRVJSFTBEEJUJPOBM

    TUBGSPNBOPUIFSPOF0OFTPMVUJPOXFIBWF

    FNCSBDFEJTUPXPSLXJUIMPDBMPODBMM

    FNQMPZNFOUDPOUSBDUTXJUIMPDBMTUBBUBO

    BJSQPSUEVSJOHQFBLNPNFOUT5IFFYUFOUUP

    XIJDI/BZBLHSPVQSFMJFTPODPOUSBDUPSTJT

    MJNJUFE8FQSFGFSUPXPSLXJUIPVSPXO

    FNQMPZFFTUPFOTVSFBTVTUBJOBCMFMPOHUFSN

    TFSWJDFUPBJSMJOFDVTUPNFSTBOEFOTVSFUIBUPVS

    MFWFMPGTFSWJDFJTNBJOUBJOFEUPPVSTUBOEBSET

    Can you use temporary labour?RM::FTZPVDBOQSPWJEFEUIFUFNQPSBSZ

    MBCPVSSFNBJOTCFMPXPGZPVSUPUBMIFBE

    DPVOUBUBOZMPDBUJPO

    Nayak is noticing increased demand for outsourced line maintenance primarily from flag carriers and low-cost

    airlines (photo: Nayak Aircraft Service Netherlands)

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    6/8

    The BT Series of Battery-Hydraulic Hand Tool Kits is designed to provide

    the ultimate in flexibility, modularity, and powered efficiency in a lightweight,

    ergonomic crimp unit, making it ideal for maintenance, repair and overhaul in

    the Aerospace Industry, plus its powered by a superior Lithium-ion Battery.

    The BT Series flexibility begins with the availability of 2 different power units

    (BT 1900 and BT 3500), 9 different heads and adapters, and various user

    options. The kit comes with a shoulder strap that can be used on the kits case

    or directly on either power unit.

    Call your TE Connectivity sales professional at 888-777-5917 or 1-717-810-2080

    for a demonstration of TEs Battery-Hydraulic Hand Tool and see how your

    maintenance and repair process can improve with its use.

    Learn more at tooling.te.com/bt3500.asp

    EVERY CONNECTION COUNTS

    MORE THAN 1.5 TONS OF POWER

    IN THEPALM OF YOURHAND

    TE Connectivitys only obligations are those stated in TEs General Terms and Conditions of Business (http://www.te.com/aboutus/tandc.asp) TE expressly disclaims any implied warranty

    regarding the information contained herein, including, but not limited to, the implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose.

    2012 All rights reserved. TE Connectivity (logo), TE Connectivity and EVERY CONNECTION COUNTS are trademarks.

    MRO Management 35March 2012www.mromanagement.com

    Line maintenance

    AN:0OPVUTUBUJPOTXJUIBTNBMMOVNCFS

    PGQFPQMFJUJTEJDVMU%VSJOHCJHHFSMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFFWFOUTMJLFBO"DIFDLJU

    JTQPTTJCMFBOE-5.*NBLFTVTFPGJUJOUIF

    SBOHFPG

    PM::FTXFDBO

    Is there a risk to quality if you do?

    RM:/POPUGPSVT'SPNBRVBMJUZBTTVSBODF

    QPJOUPGWJFXXFDPOTJEFSBQFSTPOUIBUKPJOT

    VTPOBOFRVBMCBTJTXIFUIFSIFJTQFSNBOFOU

    PSUFNQPSBSZTUB5IFFOHJOFFSJORVFTUJPO

    XJMMIBWFUPNFFUUIFFYBDUTBNFQSFSFRVJTJUFT

    AN:/PUIFSFJTOUJGZPVGPMMPX&"4"SVMFT

    UBLFTQFDJBMDBSFXIJDIQFSTPOOFMZPVTFMFDU

    BOEFOTVSFHPPEDPNQMJBODFXJUIZPVSPXODPNQBOZQSPDFEVSFT

    PM:5IFRVBMJUZPGTFSWJDFJTEJSFDUMZSFMBUFEUP

    UIFNJOETFUPGTUB5IJTJTBWFSZEJTUJODU

    EJFSFOUJBUPSGPS/BZBL8FPOMZFNQMPZ

    QFPQMFXIPBSFFBHFSUPEFMJWFSQSPNQUBOE

    POUJNFTFSWJDFTUIBUHVBSBOUFF

    TBUJTGBDUJPOGSPNBJSMJOFDVTUPNFST%FMJWFSJOH

    POUIJTBNCJUJPOSFRVJSFTTUBUIBUDBOIBOEMF

    UIFUJNFQSFTTVSFPGMJOFNBJOUFOBODFXBJUJOH

    QBTTFOHFSTSFDUJGZJOHEFGFDUTBOETUBZJOH

    QPMJUFUPBJSMJOFDVTUPNFSTXIPDPOUJOVPVTMZDIBMMFOHFVTUPIBWFUIFBJSDSBGUJOPQFSBUJPO

    BTRVJDLMZBTQPTTJCMF0VSUFBNIBTUIJTWFSZ

    NFOUBMJUZCFDBVTFJUJTTPNFUIJOHXFBMM

    DVMUJWBUFFWFSZEBZ5IJTJTOPUBMXBZTBTFBTZ

    UPBDIJFWFXJUIUFNQPSBSZMBCPVS

    IB:.POBSDI"JSDSBGU&OHJOFFSJOHIBTCPUI

    ZFBSSPVOEBOETFBTPOBMDPOUSBDUTBUCPUIJUT

    CBTFBOEMJOFTUBUJPOTUIFTFHJWFVTUIF

    FYJCJMJUZUPNPWFPVSTUBBSPVOEPVSOFUXPSL

    UPFOTVSFXFIBWFUIFSJHIUQFPQMFJOQMBDFUP

    TVQQPSUPVSQBSUJDVMBSDPOUSBDUT8FIBWFBWFSZSFMJBCMFBOEFYJCMFXPSLGPSDFTPUIFUSBOTJUJPO

    CFUXFFOTUBUJPOTJTOPUBOJTTVF0OWFSZGFX

    PDDBTJPOTXFEPVUJMJTFDPOUSBDUMBCPVSXIJDIJT

    NBOBHFEGPSVTUISPVHIPVSDPOUSBDUMBCPVS

    DPNQBOZ.POBSDI5FDIOJDBM4VQQPSU5IFLFZ

    BEWBOUBHFPGEPJOHUIJTJTUIBUXFIBWFEFUBJMFE

    LOPXMFEHFPGUIFTUBBOEUIFJSDBQBCJMJUZ

    Overseas operationsWhat are the advantages of operating

    overseas line maintenance bases?

    RM::PVCVJMEBTUSPOHFSSFMBUJPOTIJQXJUIZPVSDVTUPNFSCZGPMMPXJOHBOBJSMJOFJOUPOFXBSFBT

    PM:8FPOMZPQFOVQPWFSTFBTMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFCBTFTBUUIFSFRVFTU

    PGPVSBJSMJOFDVTUPNFST5IJTRVFTUJPO

    JTQSPCBCMZNPSFTVJUFEUPUIPTFDVTUPNFST

    BTUPXIZUIFZXPVMEMJLFUPEPJUJO

    UIJTXBZ

    What are the challenges of operating

    overseas line maintenance bases?

    RM:5IFSFBSFNBOZBOEXFIBWFDPNFVQ

    BHBJOTUUIFN8FXFSFUIFSTUDPNQBOZ

    UPFWFSFTUBCMJTI1BSUBQQSPWFE

    UIJSEQBSUZMJOFTUBUJPOTJOTFWFSBMMPDBUJPOT

    JODMVEJOH5SJQPMJ#FOHIB[J.PNCBTB

    BOE"EEJT"CBCB5IFDIBMMFOHFTBSFIVHF

    CVUTPJTPVSQFSTJTUFODF

    PM:'PS/BZBLBOPWFSTFBTTUBUJPOJT

    OPUNPSFEJDVMUUIBOBOZPUIFSTUBUJPOBXBZGSPNPVSIPNFCBTF5SBWFMUJNFJT

    QFSIBQTMPOHFSCVUBMMPUIFSDIBMMFOHFT

    TVDIBTOEJOHUIFSJHIURVBMJFE

    FOHJOFFSTJOUFSFTUFEJOHPJOHUIFSF

    BJSQPSUBDDFTTEJDVMUJFTXPSLJOH

    QFSNJUTBOETFUUJOHVQMPDBMCSBODIFT

    SFNBJOUIFTBNF

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    7/8

    www.mromanagement.comMarch 201236 MRO Management

    Line maintenance

    Is there a need to keep European

    management at non-European line stations?

    RM:/P8FBSFWFSZQSPVEUPFNQMPZBHSFBU

    UFBNPGTUBBOEXFEPOPUDPOTJEFSUIF

    OBUJPOBMJUZBTBDSJUFSJPO*OGBDUXF

    FODPVSBHFMPDBMIJSFTBTNVDIBTQPTTJCMFUPDSFBUFKPCTBOEUPJOWFTUJOUSBJOJOH*BNWFSZ

    QMFBTFEUPNFFUWFSZRVBMJFEBOENPUJWBUFE

    TUBJOQSPTQFDUJWFPVUTUBUJPOTXIPBSFLFFO

    UPKPJOPVSUFBN

    PM:8IFOXFPQFOVQBOFXTUBUJPO

    XIFSFWFSJUJTXFBMXBZTTUBSUXJUIBYFE

    UFBNPGFYQFSJFODFEFOHJOFFSTDPNJOHGSPN

    EJFSFOUTUBUJPOT5IFZTFUVQBOEJOJUJBMMZSVO

    UIFPQFSBUJPOBOEUIFOJOUJNFXFMPPLGPS

    MPDBMFOHJOFFSTUPSFQMBDFUIFN*OUIJTXBZ

    XFFOTVSFUIBUPVSTFSWJDFUPPVSBJSMJOFDVTUPNFSTJTBUUIFMFWFMXFHVBSBOUFF

    IB:8FIBWFBOVNCFSPGPWFSTFBTMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFPQFSBUJPOTCPUIZFBSSPVOE

    BOETFBTPOBM5IFCFOFUTGPSPVSTJTUFS

    DPNQBOZ.POBSDI"JSMJOFTBSFDMFBSUIFZHFU

    BRVBMJUZQSPEVDUGSPNBUFBNPGJOEJWJEVBMT

    XIPLOPXUIFJSBJSDSBGUBOEUIFJSPQFSBUJPO

    BOEXIPHFOVJOFMZDBSFBCPVUUIFQBTTFOHFS

    FYQFSJFODF5IJTJTUIFOUSBOTGFSSBCMFUPPUIFS

    DPOUSBDUFEDVTUPNFSTXIPXFXPSLGPS5IF

    PWFSTFBTTUBUJPOTBSFSFTPVSDFECZCPUI6,

    BOEMPDBMTUB

    How does line maintenancet into a

    companys business which is dominated by

    base maintenance?

    AN: *GZPVPQFSBUFBCBTFNBJOUFOBODFVOJUBUUIFTUBUJPOZPVVTVBMMZIBWFB

    TJHOJDBOUOVNCFSPGQFSTPOOFMCBDLTIPQT

    TVDJFOUFRVJQNFOUUPPMJOHBOEBIBOHBS

    8JUIUIJTTFUVQZPVBSFNPSFFYJCMFUPSFBDUUP"0(TPSTFBTPOBMDIBOHFT4PZPVDBOPFSUIFDVTUPNFSTBGVMMSBOHFPG

    TFSWJDFT#VUUIFFYDIBOHFCFUXFFOMJOF

    BOECBTFTIPVMECFBWFSZDPOUSPMMFEBDUJPOUPFOTVSFUIBUCPUIQSPDFTTFTBSFSVOOJOHTNPPUIMZ

    PM:#BTFNBJOUFOBODFBOEMJOFNBJOUFOBODF

    OFFEFOHJOFFSTXJUIUXPUPUBMMZEJFSFOU

    NJOETFUT#BTFNBJOUFOBODFDBOCFQMBOOFE

    BOEUJNFQSFTTVSFDBOCFNJOJNJTFE8IFO

    MPPLJOHBUMJOFNBJOUFOBODFUJNFJTPGUIF

    FTTFODFBOEUIFQSFTTVSFJTPOBMNPTUBMMUIF

    UJNF5IFSFGPSFBU/BZBLXFIBWFBTQMJUJOMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFBOECBTFNBJOUFOBODF

    Does it provide a training ground?

    AN:/PUOFDFTTBSJMZCFDBVTFUIFGPDVTPOMJOF

    BOECBTFJTEJFSFOU-JOFNBJOUFOBODF

    DPODFOUSBUFTPORVJDLUVSOBSPVOETBMTPCZVTJOHUIF.&-BOEUFNQPSBSZTPMVUJPOT

    #BTFNBJOUFOBODFDPODFOUSBUFTPOBOJOUFOTF

    DIFDLBOEPOMPOHMBTUJOHYFT#VUPGDPVSTF

    JUIFMQTXIFOZPVIBWFTFFOUIFBJSDSBGU

    TUSJQQFEJOTJEFXIFOZPVUBDLMFBQSPCMFNJO

    MJOFNBJOUFOBODFGPSFYBNQMFPOBJS

    DPOEJUJPOJOHPSUIFXBUFSXBTUFTZTUFN:PVDBOGPSJOTUBODFNPSFFBTJMZMPDBUF

    DPNQPOFOUTMJLFEVDUTBOEZPVNBZCF

    RVJDLFSJOSFNPWBMJOTUBMMBUJPO

    PM::PVDPVMEQSPWJEF0+5GPSZPVSMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFFOHJOFFSTJOUIFCBTF

    NBJOUFOBODFCVUEPJOHTPJTHFUUJOHNPSF

    EJDVMU5IFWBSJFUZPGBJSDSBGUUZQFTJOMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFJTOPSNBMMZTJHOJDBOUMZMBSHFS

    DPNQBSFEUPCBTFNBJOUFOBODFDBQBCJMJUJFT

    5IFSFGPSFXJUIJO/BZBLXFJODSFBTJOHMZ

    DIPPTFUPSFMZPOPUIFSQSPWJEFSTXIFOJUDPNFTUP0+5USBJOJOH

    Is it a marketing tool to attract customers

    for additional work?

    AN:4FFUIFRVFTUJPOBCPVUCBTF

    NBJOUFOBODF5IFBWBJMBCJMJUZPGBEEJUJPOBM

    NBOQPXFSUPPMJOHBOEBIBOHBSDBOCFBO

    BSHVNFOUUPBUUSBDUDVTUPNFST

    PM:/PUSFBMMZ5IFPVUTPVSDJOHPGCBTFNBJOUFOBODFJTHFOFSBMMZBSSBOHFECZUIFQVSDIBTJOHEFQBSUNFOUPGBOBJSMJOF

    5IFMJOFNBJOUFOBODFEFQBSUNFOUJT

    HFOFSBMMZOPUJOWPMWFE3FGFSSJOHCBDLUPPVSFBSMJFSTUBUFNFOUSFHBSEJOHUIFTDPQFPGXPSLDIBOHJOHUIFSFJTMFTTOFFEGPSCBTFNBJOUFOBODFDBQBCJMJUJFTBOEBSFMBUFEIBOHBSBTNPSFXPSLJTEPOFJOMJOFNBJOUFOBODF

    RM:-JOFNBJOUFOBODFJTBTQFDJBMJTUBSFB*DBOTFFUIFMBSHFS.30BCMFUPPFSBUPUBM

    DBSFQBDLBHFJODMVEJOHMJOFCBTF

    DPNQPOFOUTBOEFWFO.$$*OUIBUDBTF

    IBWJOHZPVSPXOCBTFNBJOUFOBODFTFUVQ

    OFYUUPZPVSMJOFNBJOUFOBODFJOGSBTUSVDUVSF

    JTJNQPSUBOU)BWJOHZPVSPXOCBTF

    NBJOUFOBODFTFUVQXJMMBMMPXGPS

    PQQPSUVOJUJFTUPQFSGPSNBCJOJUJPCBTJD

    USBJOJOHBTXFMMBTUIFQSBDUJDBMFMFNFOUTPG

    UZQFUSBJOJOHGPSTUBPOFXJTIFTUPVTFJOB

    MJOFFOWJSPONFOUMBUFSPO8FXPVMEQSFGFSUPUSBJOPVSTUBJOBSFBMUJNFMJOFNBJOUFOBODF

    FOWJSPONFOU*UDFSUBJOMZDBOCFBNBSLFUJOH

    UPPMJGZPVBJNUPPFSBUPUBMDBSFQBDLBHF

    5IFGBDUJTUIBUXFEPOPUVTFBIBOHBSBOE

    UIJTJTBNBSLFUJOHUPPMGPSVT0VSTUBXJMMEP

    XIBUFWFSJUUBLFTUPBWPJEUIFBJSDSBGUIBWJOH

    UPHPJOUPBIBOHBSQSPWJEFEPGDPVSTFUIJTJT

    TBGF8FIBWFIBETJHOJDBOUKPCTEPOF

    PVUTJEFXIFOUIFSFXBTOPIBOHBSBWBJMBCMF

    MJLFFOHJOFDIBOHFT(&OPTFDPXM

    SFQMBDFNFOUPSNBJOMBOEJOHHFBSTFBM

    SFQMBDFNFOUT8FBSFGPSUVOBUFXJUIPVSEFEJDBUFEUFBNXIPHPUIBUFYUSBNJMFGPS

    PVSMPZBMDVTUPNFST

    IB:-JOFNBJOUFOBODFJTPOFPGPVSWFLFZ

    TUSBUFHJDCVTJOFTTVOJUT#FJOHQBSUPGBMBSHF

    USBWFMHSPVQBOEXJUIBOBJSMJOFBTBTJTUFS

    DPNQBOZHJWFTVTBOFEHFBTBO.30

    CFDBVTFXFVOEFSTUBOEUIFQSFTTVSFTBJSMJOFT

    GBDF5IFDPTUPGBMBUFEFMJWFSZGSPNBIBOHBS

    JOQVUPSPGBUFDIOJDBMEFMBZXIJMFUIFBJSDSBGUJTJOPQFSBUJPOJTIJHI'PSVTUIJT

    VOEFSMJOFTUIFWBMVFPGQSPWJEJOHUIFPQFSBUPSXJUIBSFMJBCMFQSPEVDUGSPNUIF

    To cover seasonal variations in between the stations,

    LTMI has a team of Frankfurt-based employees, who

    are used for short-term assignments on stations tocover peaks or off-days (photo: Lufthansa Technik)

  • 7/28/2019 MRO Magazine March 2012 - Line Maintenance growth and preparing for the future

    8/8MRO Management 37March 2012www.mromanagement.com

    Line maintenance

    RVBMJUZPGUIFXPSLDBSSJFEPVUUPUIF

    TVQQPSUPGUIFBJSDSBGUXIJMFJOPQFSBUJPO

    *UBMTPQSPWJEFTPQQPSUVOJUJFTGPSIBOHBS

    NBJOUFOBODFTUBUPHBJOWBMVBCMF

    PQFSBUJPOBMFYQFSJFODFBOEWJDFWFSTBBOE

    EPFTFOBCMFVTUPBUUSBDUOFXDVTUPNFSTUPPVSPUIFSTFSWJDFPFSJOHT

    Can line maintenance be a vehicle to

    introduce other services such as cleaning

    or engine washing?

    RM::FTJUDBOCF-JOFNBJOUFOBODFIBTJUT

    QFBLTBOEBEEJUJPOBMTFSWJDFTDBOTUSFBNMJOF

    ZPVSQSPEVDUJPOQMBOOJOHBOENBLFCFUUFS

    VTFPGZPVSTUB

    AN::FTJUDBOFTQFDJBMMZXIFOUIFDVTUPNFS

    JTMPPLJOHGPSBOJOUFHSBUFETPMVUJPO-JOFNBJOUFOBODFJTLFZUPUIBU5IJTJTXIFSFUIF

    CBUUMFGPSHPPEBJSDSBGUSFMJBCJMJUZJTOBMMZ

    XPO1SFWFOUJWFNBJOUFOBODFHPPE

    USPVCMFTIPPUJOHHPPEQMBOOJOHBOERVJDL

    SFBDUJPOJOMJOFNBJOUFOBODFBSFJNQPSUBOU

    GBDUPSTUPFOTVSFUIBUBMMFMFNFOUTPGBGVMM

    TVQQPSUQBDLBHFXPSLUPHFUIFSUPBDIJFWF

    IJHIBJSDSBGUBWBJMBCJMJUZGPSUIFBJSMJOF

    PM:/BZBLJTPFSJOHUIF1SBUU8IJUOFZ

    &DP1PXFSFOHJOFXBTI6OUJMOPXXFIBWF

    IBEMJNJUFETVDDFTTXJUIBEEJUJPOBMTFSWJDFTBTBJSMJOFPSHBOJTBUJPOTBSFDPOUSPMMJOHWBSJPVT

    BDUJWJUJFTUISPVHIEJFSFOUEFQBSUNFOUTBOE

    JUJTBDIBMMFOHFUPDIBOOFMUIFTFBOEHFU

    UIJOHTEPOFJOPOFQMBDF0VSTFSWJDFTBSF

    NBJOMZBJNFEBUGBDJMJUBUJOHUIFFDJFODZPG

    PVSDVTUPNFSTCVTJOFTT$POTJEFSJOHUIJT

    JOTJHIUTJOMPHJTUJDTBOENBJOUFOBODFBSFUIF

    NPTUJNQPSUBOUGBDUPST

    IB::FTXFBSFBMXBZTMPPLJOHUPJODSFBTFPVS

    TFSWJDFPFSJOHBOEXFBSFOPXCSBODIJOH

    PVUJOUPBSFBTTVDIBTFOHJOFXBTIJOHBOEJOUFSJPSNBJOUFOBODF#FJOHBCMFUPQSPWJEF

    UIFXIPMFQBDLBHFNBLFTVTMPPLMJLFBNPSF

    BUUSBDUJWFQSPQPTJUJPOUPUIFDVTUPNFS

    Are there any other points you would like

    to raise?

    RM:$PTUTBSFBDPODFSOUPNBOZBJSMJOFTNPSF

    UIBOFWFSCFGPSF*DBOTFFBJSMJOFTNPWJOHUPUIF

    DPODFQUPGIBWJOHOPMPDBMBSSBOHFNFOUT

    XJUIBMJOFNBJOUFOBODFQSPWJEFSBU

    EFTUJOBUJPOTFWFOGPSXJEFCPEZBJSDSBGU*O

    GBDUXFBSFUBMLJOHAQFBOVUTMPPLJOHBUUIFDPTUTPGBMJOFNBJOUFOBODFBSSBOHFNFOU

    BHBJOTUUIFWBMVFPGBOBJSGSBNFPSUIFDPTUTBO

    BJSMJOFXJMMCFGBDFEXJUIEVFUPUIFQBTTFOHFS

    DPNQFOTBUJPOSVMFT"O"0(PGBOZ

    TJHOJDBODFXPVMEIBWFQBJEGPSBMJOF

    NBJOUFOBODFDPOUSBDUGPSUIFOFYUGFXZFBST

    *OPSEFSUPFOTVSFUIFPQFSBUJPOTPGBOBJSMJOFHPTNPPUIMZBOEBRVJDLJOUFSDFQUJPOPG

    VOTDIFEVMFEUBTLTUBLFTQMBDF*FODPVSBHF

    PVSDVTUPNFSTOPUUPDIPPTFTVDIBDPODFQU

    8FXPVMEOPUCFBCMFUPEPUIFMFWFMPG

    JOWFTUNFOUXFEPUPEBZJGPVSBJSMJOFTXPVME

    POMZDBMMVQPOVTXIFOUIFSFJTBOJNNFEJBUF

    OFFEGPSIFMQ

    PM:/BZBLIBTCFFOJOUIFBJSDSBGUNBJOUFOBODF

    CVTJOFTTGPSZFBST0WFSUJNFXFIBWFBMXBZT

    EJFSFOUJBUFEPVSTFSWJDFTUISPVHIPVSBCJMJUZ

    UPSFTQPOEUPPVSDVTUPNFSTOFFETXJUIJOUIF

    FWFSDIBOHJOHEZOBNJDTPGUIFNBSLFU0VS

    HPBMJTUPHJWFUIFNNPSFFYJCJMJUZIJHIFSUFDIOJDBMQVODUVBMJUZJODSFBTFEFFU

    BWBJMBCJMJUZIJHIFSQBTTFOHFSDPNGPSUGFXFS

    QFOBMUJFTGPSEFMBZTBOENPSFDPOUSPMPWFS

    DPTUT/BZBLDVSSFOUMZQBSUOFSTXJUIUIF

    6OJWFSTJUZPG"NTUFSEBN6W"UPEFWFMPQ

    BLFZQFSGPSNBODFJOEJDBUPSUIBUXJMMBOBMZTF

    UIFQSPDFTTFTBOEBSUJDVMBUFUIFCFOFUT