Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the...

34
Legal Due Diligence presented by Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee

Transcript of Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the...

Page 1: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Legal Due Diligence

presented by

Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee

Page 2: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Due Diligence may be divided into:

• Legal due diligence

• Financial due diligence

• Audit due diligence

• Technical due diligence

• Overlapping between financial due diligence ,

accounting due diligence , legal due diligence and

technical due diligence

Due Diligence

Page 3: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Due Diligence

Legal due diligence or LDD is part of all due diligence.

Page 4: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

LDD for M&A and

JV transactions

Page 5: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

5

Corporate matter

• Affidavit

• Memorandum of association

• Articles of association

• List of shareholders

• Minutes of the board of directors meeting

Page 6: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

6

Corporate matter

• Minutes of the general meeting of shareholders

• Share register

• Share certificate book

• Financial statements and their notes

• Employee securities ownership plan

Page 7: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

7

License

• Foreign business license

• Investment promotion certificate

• Factory license

• Building construction permit

• Building use permit

• Work permit

Page 8: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

8

Agreement

• Memorandum of understanding

• Term sheet

• Head of agreement

• Shareholders agreement

• Joint venture agreement

• Sale agreement

• Advisory agreement

• Share sale and purchase agreement

• Asset sale and purchase agreement

• Lease agreement

• Service agreement

• Loan agreement

Page 9: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

9

Agreement

• Syndicated loan agreement

• Security documents

• ISDA Master Agreement

• Underwriting agreement

• Franchise agreement

• Licensing agreement

• Know-how agreement

• Technical assistance agreement

• Debt restructuring agreement

Page 10: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

10

Employment

• Management agreement

• Employment agreement

• Secondment agreement

• Work rules

• Social security fund

• Provident fund

• Worker compensation fund

• ESOP

Page 11: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

11

IP

• Trade marks

• Copyright

• Patent

Page 12: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

12

Insurance

• all risk insurance

• some risk insurance

• re-insurance

• fire , flooding, theft, riot, terrorism, force majeure

Page 13: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

13

Land Documents

• Land title deed, land possession documents, condominium title deeds

• Building without a building construction permit

Page 14: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

14

Environment

• Environmental impact assessment report (“EIA Report”)

• Approval for a project

Page 15: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

15

Governing law

Arbitration

• Arbitration proceedings

• Recognition and enforcement of

an arbitration award

Litigation

• Court proceedings

• Enforcement of a judgment

• Pending or threatened legal disputes

Page 16: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

16

Legal agreements and taxes

• Withholding tax

• Corporate income tax

• Value added tax

• Specific business tax

• Stamp duty

• Related parties agreements

• Transfer pricing issues

• E-commerce transactions

• Digital service tax

Page 17: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Documents and information for LDD include

Competitor

17

Other material documents and information

• Representations and warranties

• Letter of representations

• Management Discussion and Analysis

Page 18: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Board of Investment (“BOI”)

• Material matters

Frequently asked questions

Red flag issues

Shareholding structure

Share transfer restrictions

Right of first refusal

Tag along provisions

Drag along provisions

Call options and put options

Page 19: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Board of Investment (“BOI”)

• Material matters

Share buy back provisions

Transfer of shares and liabilities

Transfer of properties and tax liabilities

Change of directors

Change of the management

Conditions of a license

Initial mortgage, and subsequent mortgage

Pledge of shares

Page 20: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Board of Investment (“BOI”)

• Material matters

Registration of business collateral

Outright assignment and conditional assignment

Land documents illegally issued

Disclosure of information

Connected transactions

Acquisitions and disposition of assets

Reporting requirement

Tender offer requirement

Page 21: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Board of Investment (“BOI”)

• Material matters

Hidden liabilities

Reserve matters

Personal data protection provisions

Consent and revocation of consent

Change of purchase orders

Change of scope of services

Issues on services and know-how

Franchise rights on exclusive and non-exclusive basis

Page 22: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Board of Investment (“BOI”)

• Material matters

Actual event of default

Potential event of default

Material adverse change

A force majeure event

Enforcement of agreement

Termination of agreement

Page 23: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Board of Investment (“BOI”)

• Material matters

Claim for damages

Actual damages

Special damages

Liquidated damages

Punitive damages

Public interest

National interest

Page 24: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Issues

Page 25: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Issues

Competitor

25

○ Red-flag issues should be pointed out.

○ Solutions to red-flag issues should be provided.

Page 26: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Issues

Competitor

26

○ Should either all provisions of the documents or only important matters

of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ?

○ Should any presumption of a true and correct copy of documents be

stated in a legal due diligence report ?

Page 27: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Issues

Competitor

27

○ Should a threshold amount of money of any agreement be set ?

○ Should financial statements for a certain number of years be clearly set

forth ?

○ Can proxy or grant of power be cancelled ?

Page 28: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Issues

Competitor

28

○ Is an agreement legal , valid and enforceable ?

○ Is it tenable that an agreement is unfair ?

○ Can an agreement be unilateral terminated ?

Page 29: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Issues

Competitor

29

○ How are actual damages and special damages determined ?

○ Are laws and regulations strictly complied with ?

○ Is any provision of any agreement breached ?

Page 30: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

NAME OR LOGO

Issues

Competitor

30

○ Can a defaulting party opt for litigation if it is required to submit a

dispute under an agreement to arbitration ?

○ Will amendment to laws and regulations affect transactions ?

Page 31: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Case study

Page 32: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Chart on sale of assets Chart on LDD and matters

Page 33: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Chart on sale of assets Chart on Group of Companies

Page 34: Mr. Picharn Sukparangsee · technical due diligence Due Diligence . Due Diligence ... of the documents be recorded in a legal due diligence report ? Should any presumption of a true

Picharn Sukparangsee

(66)2 -252-5895 / (66)81-7353160

[email protected],

www.bgloballaw.com

BANGKOK GLOBAL LAW OFFICES LIMITED540, Unit 1705, 17th Floor, Mercury Tower,Ploenchit Road, Lumpini , Pathumwan , Bangkok 10330 Thailand

Thank You