MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have...

8
In this op-ed, Fariha Róisín tackles Hollywood's obsession with white-savior narratives and how this sidelines people of color from their own stories. Within the first few minutes of this year’s Oscar-nominated Lion, (starring Dev Patel and based on the book written by Saroo Brierley), the audience was completely enraptured. The story centers on Saroo, a young Indian boy who loses his family. After months of loneliness, he is adopted by Australian parents — and then later finds his biological family through Google Maps. MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an Extension of Colonialism From “The Blind Side” to “The Help.” Fariha Róisín SEP 14, 2017 1:00PM EDT

Transcript of MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have...

Page 1: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATIONDo not receive FA if you are allergic tobenralizumab or any of the ingredients inFASENRA.

Do not use to treat sudden breathing problems.

SENRA

PRESCRIBING INFORMATION PATIENT INFORMATION

In this op-ed, Fariha Róisín tackles Hollywood's obsession withwhite-savior narratives and how this sidelines people of color fromtheir own stories.

Within the first few minutes of this year’s Oscar-nominated Lion,(starring Dev Patel and based on the book written by SarooBrierley), the audience was completely enraptured. The storycenters on Saroo, a young Indian boy who loses his family. Aftermonths of loneliness, he is adopted by Australian parents — andthen later finds his biological family through Google Maps.

MOVIES

Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is anExtension of Colonialism

From “The Blind Side” to “The Help.”

Fariha Róisín

SEP 14, 2017 1:00PM EDT

THE FIRST AND ONLY HA FILLERFDA APPROVED TO TREAT

1. Restylane® Lyft. Instructions for Use. Galderma Laboratories, L.P., 2018.2. U.S. Food & Drug Administration. Medical Devices, Restylane® Lyft with Lidocaine - P040024/S099.

https://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedical Procedures/DeviceApprovalsandClearances/Recently-ApprovedDevices/ucm609592.htm. Accessed May 18, 2018.

Complete Instructions for UseThe most commonly observed side effects are swelling, redness, pain, bruising,

headache, tenderness, lump formation, itching at the injection site, and impairedhand function. To learn more about serious but rare side effects and full Important

Safety Information, visit www.RestylaneUSA.com. USMP/LYF/0093/1018

Page 2: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

It’s a profound story. But knowing that it was true, I couldn't helpbut wonder whether the film would be eclipsed by Nicole Kidman,who plays Saroo’s adoptive, white Australian mother. And though itwasn’t so obvious, her presence within the narrative was feltthroughout the movie: She was ever-present, her whiteness all-seeing, all-knowing, omnipresent.

Hollywood has a trend when it comes to these films in general. It’smost commonly seen in Oscar-bait movies; the white savior complexis a constant leitmotif. Hollywood supposedly inserts these roles forcomplexity, for drama. But what ends up happening is that theyperpetuate an idea that is essentially a historical banner ofcolonialism: People of color need white people to save them. To thisday, some people still latently believe what imperialists such asRudyard Kipling said, that colonialism was important for everyone:the conqueror and, most importantly, the conquered. That withoutthe colonizers, the colonized had no hope of survival. And byconstantly churning out movies with plots in which white people"save" people of color, Hollywood reinforces colonialist dictum.

10 Best Riverdale Gifts And Holiday Ideas

Lion

©Weinstein Company/Courtesy Everett Collection

TRENDING VIDEO

ENTERTAINMENT

7 TransPerformersShare theChallengesThey Still …

NEWS AND

POLITICS

What the"WorkingClass" Is, andHow It's…

ENTERTAINMENT

BTS'sJungkookStruttingDown aRunway IsNow a Hil…

RELATED

Page 3: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

Many white people in films based on the stories of POC are oftensubliminally depicted as godlike saviors, heroes who are rationaland judicious to the core. They are usually deified men or women —glorified and righteous — like scripture out of a Holy Book. Look atHillary Swank in Freedom Writers. The white savior somehowalways ends up usurping the narrative. And in this centering ofwhiteness and white characters, the POC characters end upbecoming props, which only perpetuates ideas of our otherness andunimportance, which then establishes a status quo of racism.Whiteness is again normalized, and POC are decentralized. This isparticularly problematic because whiteness is not only favored inHollywood but also in society at large; white privilege is ever-present and ubiquitous.

SPONSOR CONTENT

Custom Design Your Own DualDegree—and Prepare for Your DreamFuture—at The New School

The 5-Year BAFA program lets you combinethe best of both worlds: creative arts andcritical thinking.

DECEMBER 17,

2018

By constantly churning out movies with plots in which white people'save' people of color, Hollywood reinforces colonialist dictum.

The stories of children of color, in particular, are often used as filmfodder in a bid to invoke a sympathetic appeal to a narrative — justlook at Angelina Jolie’s forthcoming film First They Killed MyFather, as well as Lion. Or The Blind Side, which in 2010 wonSandra Bullock the Academy Award for Best Actress. The movie wasabout a white mom who adopts Michael Oher, a young black boywho goes on to be an offensive lineman who played for theBaltimore Ravens, Tennessee Titans, and Carolina Panthers in theNFL. Though there are some endearing moments throughout the

Page 4: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

NFL. Though there are some endearing moments throughout thefilm, it is, in a roundabout way, about how a white family’s belief ina black boy allowed him to become who he truly was. Without them,his full potential would never have been realized. Therefore, it stillemploys exploitative power dynamics of someone needing to be“saved.”

And sometimes this happens even in POC-helmed films. Take 12Years a Slave; in it, a Canadian carpenter, played by Brad Pitt, is sounsettled when he hears the details of Solomon Northup’s story ofenslavement that he risks his life to free him. It’s momentary —there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt — but hispresence is known and made a significant plot point within the film.There’s a sigh of relief when you see him, because, in some way,psychologically you understand his purpose in the narrative arc.Especially against the lunacy, brashness, and pure evil of the otherslave owners, Pitt’s existence in the film is light. He ushers in goodtidings, and, most importantly, he is vital to the plot of Northup’sfreedom. He is a classic white savior.

The film was written by John Ridley (who is black), who won a BestAdapted Screenplay Academy Award for it — and the film itself alsotook Best Picture. A few months beforehand, in response to aninterviewer at the BBC, Steve McQueen, the director of 12 Years aSlave, explained, with no hesitation, “I don’t make films for whitepeople . . .” Though that may be true, it’s clear that even with Pitt’scharacter being a secondary one in the film, the fact that the storydepended on him for Solomon to ultimately find freedom shifts the

The Blind Side

©Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection

Page 5: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

entire lens of the film. For me, as a viewer, Pitt’s existence in thenarrative of the film was memorable in a way I don't want toremember a white character in a film about a black man’s survival.

Perhaps one of the most offensive of all depictions of white savior-ness is the Oscar-winning hit The Help. It had a considerable, hefty,and talented POC cast. The film interacts with the burdens of POCin the South by glorifying the liberal journalist who endows twoblack maids — Aibileen Clark (Viola Davis) and Minny Jackson(Octavia Spencer, who won Best Supporting Actress for this role) —with strength during the Civil Rights Movement. A “liberal” in thissense is the confluence of a person with white guilt — someone whoclaims to be invested in not being racist — who doesn't engage inhow they might profit off of racism and also how they mightperpetuate it. The Help centers on a white journalist’s verve forjustice for two working-class black women during the civil rightsera; it's the main narrative of the film. Clearly, the Civil RightsMovement didn’t have enough inspirational black folks to encouragethe need for self-determination.

There are many ways that Hollywood could do better. First, it couldhire more diverse writers. Representation comes through hiringtrans and nonbinary writers, black and brown writers, queer anddisabled writers; it’s about engaging in the problematics of a systemand not hiding from the reality that perpetuating whiteness as anorm hasn’t got us anywhere, ahem. The most damning part of thewhite savior complex is that Hollywood is making content for us, but

The Help

©Walt Disney Co./Courtesy Everett Collection

Page 6: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

without us in mind, usurping our stories with a white person’s guilt.If we want stronger storytelling, we have to be willing to invest inthose who have that lived experience and nurture their voices, too.Because Hollywood is reliant upon us both to make money and tosurvive.

Related: #OscarsSoWhite? New Study Finds That#HollywoodSoWhite

WATCH

The Racist & Misogynistic History ofProm

RACE 1 / 14

The Racist & MisogynisticHistory of Prom

Naomi Wadler On Black GirlMagic: 'Our Mela...

The Politics of Hair | TeenVogue Take

How Close Are We To APost Racial Hollywood...

FOLLOW US

SPONSORED STORIES

[Photos] ThesePhotos Taken inWalmart Will MakeYou Blink.COOLIMBA

Turn Your DaydreamInto Reality With ADiscover CDDISCOVER

Video: Watch peoplediscover what itmeans to be JewishBIRTHRIGHT ISRAELFOUNDATION

Powered by

Page 7: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

SITE MAP CONTACT US NEWSLETTER SIGNUP IN THIS ISSUE

CAREERS CONDÉ NAST STORE REPRINTS/PERMISSIONS PARSONS X TEENVOGUE

December Is a HugeMonth for Netflix:Here's Every SingleNew ThingREFINERY29

Successful CarAccident Attorney inPhiladelphia. See thelistATTORNEY - SPONSOREDLISTINGS

What Pot Stocks WillSkyrocket? FormerPolitician Has a…STRATEGIC TECHINVESTOR

Powered by

STORY

I Don't Even Recognize Kendall Jennerin Her Latest Picture

STORY

Fashion Nova Jumped on Copying KylieJenner’s Birthday Outfits and My…

STORY

Ariana Grande Wore Body Paint as aTop, and Pete Davidson Is Beside…

STORY

Kylie Jenner Shaved Her Head and It'sSurprisingly Chic (We Swear)

STORY

Here’s Exactly How Lucy Hale DealsWith Her Cystic Acne

STORY

Kylie Jenner Deletes Photo After FansComment on Her Looking Like Khloé…

RECOMMENDED for YOU

Condé Nast Websites

Page 8: MOVIES Why Hollywood’s White Savior Obsession Is an ... · his full potential would never have been realized. ... there’s really just a hop, skip, and a glimpse of Brad Pitt —

CAREERS CONDÉ NAST STORE REPRINTS/PERMISSIONS PARSONS X TEENVOGUE

ACCESSIBILITY HELP

© 2018 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement(updated 5/25/18) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated 5/25/18). Teen Vogue may earn a portion of sales from products that arepurchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. Your California Privacy Rights. The material on this site may not bereproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Ad Choices

CNWN Collection

Condé Nast Websites