Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing...

22
(Seal of the President of the United States, Graphic Obtained from Wikipedia) Modern Presidential Communication Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World Rahul Singh Modern United States Presidency, Spring 2013 Ambassador Paul Russo, Former 4/29/2013

description

Want to be President of the United States of America? Want to launch a product that puts a "dent in the universe?" These things don't just happen. You will need to be a master of rhetoric and understand how to persuade the masses using proven campaign techniques from both political and commercial marketing campaigns. This review on modern presidential rhetoric combines ideas used in presidential campaigns from FDR, Reagan, Obama, JFK, and more.

Transcript of Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing...

Page 1: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

 

 

 (Seal  of  the  President  of  the  United  States,  Graphic  Obtained  from  Wikipedia)  

 

Modern   Presidential  Communication  Communicating  Presidential  Rhetorical  Vision  in  a  Changing  World  

Rahul  Singh  

Modern  United  States  Presidency,  Spring  2013  Ambassador  Paul  Russo,  Former  4/29/2013  

Page 2: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

Modern  Presidential  Communication   ii    

Table  of  Contents  

Modern  Presidential  Communication  .............................................................................................................  1  

Communicating  Presidential  Rhetorical  Vision  in  a  Changing  World  ..........................................  1  Introduction  ..........................................................................................................................................................................................  1  Hypothetical  Strategic  Design  of  a  Campaign  .........................................................................................................................  3  Create  a  singular  rhetorical  vision  for  the  target  audience  ..............................................................................................  4  Build  a  community  from  and  of  the  target  audience  ...........................................................................................................  6  Listen  to  and  learn  from  the  community  ..................................................................................................................................  8  Create  actionable  content  around  the  singular  rhetorical  vision  ..................................................................................  9  Spread  and  propagate  the  message  .........................................................................................................................................  12  Activate  community  members  to  participants  ...................................................................................................................  13  Measure  to  improve.  Improve  to  succeed.  Repeat.  ...........................................................................................................  14  Change  is  the  only  constant  .........................................................................................................................................................  16  

 

 

Page 3: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

Rahul  Singh  

Modern  United  States  Presidency,  Spring  2013  Ambassador  Paul  Russo,  Former  

4/29/2013  

Modern  Presidential  Communication   1    

Modern  Presidential  Communication  Communicating  Presidential  Rhetorical  Vision  in  a  Changing  World    

Introduction  The  modern  president  must  manage  communications  with  different  groups  of  

people  in  different  parties  and  professions,  in  different  cities  and  states,  and  in  different  

socio-­‐economic  stations  in  life  using  a  variety  of  tools  and  resources  in  the  new  world  of  

media  that  is  fragmented  across  several  different  platforms.  How  does  the  Office  of  the  

President  strategically  manage  its  communications  so  that  its  agenda  is  pushed  forward?  

How  does  the  President  speak  to  the  People  to  get  them  to  push  their  Representatives  and  

Senators  to  back  certain  decisions  that  are  in  line  with  the  White  House's  agenda?  How  

does  a  Presidential  candidate  prove  that  he  or  she  can  communicate  with  the  people  well  

enough  to  be  President?  

Political  scholars,  especially  those  that  study  the  President,  have  drawn  several  

theories  about  presidential  communication.  Jeffrey  Tulis  explains  how  the  Presidency  has  

‘transformed’  over  the  years  to  keep  up  with  or  in  sometimes  lead  in  the  modes  of  

communication  available  to  them.  From  the  beginning  of  the  American  Republic,  rhetoric  

has  been  a  substantial  element  of  politics.  Rhetoric  has  been  part  of  politics  from  the  

Page 4: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   2    

beginning  of  democratic  rule,  and  any  time  in  history  where  a  leader  convinces  followers  to  

motivate  them  to  take  action.  The  leader  of  a  nation  leads  through  persuasion  to  influence  

those  that  make  decisions  and  take  actions.  They  gather  followers  with  influence,  from  the  

beginning  of  the  campaign  to  run  for  office  to  the  day  they  leave  office  and  continue  their  

legacy  in  the  public  sphere.    

The  President  of  the  United  States  leads  by  first  convincing  the  nation  to  elect  him  

or  her,  and  then  later  by  convincing  the  legislators  in  government  to  enact  laws  that  push  

the  advertised  agenda.  Many  would  argue  the  role  of  the  Executive  Department  hasn’t  

changed,  and  that  only  the  communications  strategies  and  tactics  need  to  change  in  order  

for  it  to  fulfill  it’s  duties.  Although  there  are  elements  of  national  leadership  that  can  be  

considered  core  elements  of  governance  in  any  nation  and  in  any  type  of  nation,  the  role  of  

the  Executive  has  changed  in  America  and  will  continue  to  change  into  the  future  because  

of  the  way  that  technology  impacts  people,  their  daily  lives  and  activities,  and  of  course  

their  knowledge  of  world  they  live  in.      

Modern  media  has  transformed  in  the  last  30  years  with  the  advent  of  the  public  

Internet,  the  continued  ubiquity  of  television  and  radio,  and  an  abundance  of  content  

creators  and  distributors.  Regardless  of  the  technological  changes,  the  importance  of  

proper  rhetoric  in  the  President’s  message  is  as  important  as  the  strategic  design  of  a  

communications  plan  and  it’s  tactical  execution.  With  each  technological  advance,  masters  

of  messaging,  advertising,  marketing,  communication,  and  public  relations  have  cultivated  

general  processes  to  maximize  the  distribution  of  messages.  Distributing  the  message  alone  

Page 5: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   3    

is  not  good  enough.  As  with  any  good  marketing  campaign,  the  result  must  be  an  action  to  

eventually  buy  the  product.  A  President’s  wish  to  move  the  country  in  a  particular  way  is  

not  too  different  from  a  campaign.    As  with  any  campaign  whether  political,  marketing,  or  

governmental,  success  is  measured  in  results:  people  understanding  the  message;  people  

spreading  the  message;  and  people  taking  action  because  of  their  understanding  of  the  

message.  

Hypothetical  Strategic  Design  of  a  Campaign      The  jury  is  still  out  on  what  is  the  best  way  to  run  a  new  media  campaign  as  evidenced  

by  thousands  of  blog  posts  about  the  best  ways  to  market  online  that  are  in  constant  flux  as  

technologies,  platforms,  and  social  networks  come  and  go.1  As  with  television  and  radio,  

most  campaigns  remain  the  same  but  change  due  to  the  cultural  make  up  and  public  

consciousness  to  get  people  to  take  action  from  a  message.  An  advertising  campaign  and  a  

political  campaign  are  differently  only  in  the  desired  results.  The  approach  and  strategies  

are  similar,  and  the  methods  and  tactics  are  almost  identical.  There  are  certain  patterns  in  

the  processes  across  media  that  have  been  seen  numerous  times  and  have  been  validated  

by  several  practitioners.2  

• Create  a  singular  rhetorical  vision  for  the  target  audience.  

• Build  a  community  from  and  of  the  target  audience.  

• Listen  to  and  learn  from  the  community.  

                                                                                                               1  A  search  on  Google  for  “online  marketing  strategies”  results  in  new  articles  every  day,  2  (Singh)  Referencing  presentation  made  by  author  regarding  executing  internet  strategy.  

Page 6: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   4    

• Create  actionable  content  around  the  singular  rhetorical  vision.  

• Spread  and  propagate  the  message.  

• Activate  community  members  into  participants.  

• Measure  to  improve.  Improve  to  succeed.  Repeat.  

This  paper  sets  out  to  show  how  certain  presidents,  primarily  Reagan  and  Obama,  have  

elements  of  success  in  communicating  presidential  rhetoric.  

Create  a  singular  rhetorical  vision  for  the  target  audience  In  his  treatise  On  Rhetoric,  Aristotle  defines  the  three  elements  of  rhetoric  as  ethos,  

pathos,  and  logos.3  In  very  general  terms,  ethos  is  the  ability  to  establish  credibility,  pathos  

is  the  ability  to  inspire  or  motivate  the  audience  with  their  self-­‐interest,  and  a  logos  is  the  

truthfulness  of  the  argument.4  Rhetoric  is  the  art  of  persuasion,  and  President  and  the  

Office  of  the  President  must  master  it.  As  a  prerequisite  to  being  President,  the  person  must  

get  elected  President.  They  utilize  rhetoric  to  get  to  the  top,  and  must  utilize  it  to  do  their  

job.  Jeffrey  Tulis,  The  Rhetorical  Presidency,  argues  that  the  President’s  use  of  rhetoric  has  

been  a  part  of  American  governance  since  George  Washington.  He  also  says  that  rhetorical  

leadership  is  fundamental  to  political  leadership:  

                                                                                                               3  (Insert  reference  to  Rhetoric)    4  (Aristotle)  

Page 7: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   5    

Beneath  the  differing  policies  of  Democrats  and  Republicans  and  varying  abilities  to  

secure  partisan  objectives  lies  a  common  understanding  of  the  essence  of  the  

modern  presidency  –  rhetorical  leadership.5    

Good  rhetoric  leaves  the  audience  persuaded  into  a  different  state  of  mind.  In  order  for  an  

audience  to  be  moved,  the  message  itself  must  be  clear.  Some  of  the  most  popular  

presidents  have  utilized  a  singular  message  to  move  the  country  to  elect  them  and  later  to  

listen  to  them  while  in  government.  

Reagan  Ronald  Reagan,  known  widely  as  the  Great  Communicator,  was  deeply  involved  in  

the  construction  of  speeches  that  not  only  sounded  good,  but  also  were  easy  to  read.6  

Although  Tulis  notes  his  mistakes  in  the  Iran-­‐Contra  affair,  he  highlights  that  Reagan’s  

ability  to  persuade  people  and  shift  policy  was  so  good,  that  Democrats  (in  1987)  talked  

like  Republicans.  Ambassador  Paul  Russo,  who  worked  in  the  Reagan  administration,  

mentions  that  Reagan’s  speeches  throughout  his  campaigns  and  his  tenure  as  President  

contained  ‘basically  the  same  message.’7  Reagan’s  determination  to  stick  to  specific  topics  

that  he  had  internalized  made  him  a  genuine  rhetorical  leader.  Whether  he  was  talking  

about  anti-­‐communism  or  a  smaller  government,  the  message  was  singular  and  because  he  

                                                                                                               5  (Tulis,  p4)  Tulis  sets  the  stage  for  his  book  “The  Rhetorical  Presidency”  by  explaining  that  presidential  rhetoric  has  transformed  from  age  to  age  in  America,  building  upon  old  methods  rather  than  changing  completely.    6  (Tulis,  p191)  Reagan  is  profiled  under  “Dilemmas  of  Governance.”    7  (Russo)  Class  lectures  on  President  Reagan  by  Ambassador  Paul  Russo    

Page 8: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   6    

was  able  to  describe  his  vision  through  years  of  practice  at  G.E.  and  as  a  sports  announcer,  

his  “doctrine”  became  clear  to  people.8    

Obama  Obama’s  campaigns  contained  a  singular  rhetorical  vision:  one  America  with  hope  to  

change  for  the  better.  He  began  this  when  he  became  recognized  as  an  extraordinary  orator  

at  the  Democratic  National  Convention  in  2004  when  he  spoke  for  John  Kerry.  The  same  

message  stayed  with  him  throughout  the  2008  election  campaign.  He  believed  in  and  

spread  the  message  that  is  exemplified  by  this  quote:    

Well,  I  say  to  them  tonight,  there  is  not  a  liberal  America  and  a  conservative  America  

—  there  is  the  United  States  of  America.  There  is  not  a  Black  America  and  a  White  

America  and  Latino  America  and  Asian  America  —  there’s  the  United  States  of  

America.9  

Many  subsequent  speeches  echoed  his  sentiments  of  the  ‘hope’  that  Kerry  and  Edwards  

were  offering  near  the  end  of  the  2004  speech.  With  this  speech,  Obama  had  created  the  

‘singular  rhetorical  vision’  that  would  be  then  used  for  the  rest  of  his  campaigns,  both  

senatorial  and  presidential.    

Build  a  community  from  and  of  the  target  audience  John  Maxwell,  in  many  of  his  books,  describes  a  common  pattern  of  great  leaders.  

Good  leaders  create  a  community  of  people  through  their  influence.  Without  influence,  they                                                                                                                  8  (Kaufman)  Heritage  Foundation  talk  on  Ronald  Reagan’s  “first  principles  of  foreign  policy.”  9  (Obama)  Obama’s  debut  speech  at  the  2004  DNC.    

Page 9: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   7    

are  not  leaders.  Great  leaders  are  able  to  inspire  and  develop  people  into  leaders  in  a  

community  that  then  inspire  others  to  follow.10  They  inspire  others  to  become  great  

leaders  and  live  the  message  they  preach.  Bill  Drayton,  CEO  of  Ashoka  Foundation,  

describes  “social  impact”  in  four  levels.  He  says  that  the  first  level  of  impact  is  direct  

service,  the  second  level  is  scaling  the  service  with  more  people  in  a  group,  the  third  level  is  

causing  a  pattern  change  that  people  outside  the  group  start  to  do  the  same  thing,  and  the  

fourth  level  is  causing  a  framework  change  that  changes  lives  across  the  nation  or  the  

world.11    

Obama  Barrack  Obama’s  campaign  for  the  Presidency  in  2008,  and  then  in  2012  evidenced  

his  ability  to  create  a  singular  rhetorical.  The  message  of  “Hope,”  “Change,”    “Change  we  can  

believe  in,”  “Yes  we  can,”  and  most  importantly  “Vote”  were  clear  and  easy  to  digest.  Even  if  

people  didn’t  agree  with  him,  they  knew  that  he  was  running  and  for  what.    

The  message  of  the  singular  rhetorical  vision  alone  is  not  enough.  Without  an  audience  the  

message  is  useless.  The  reason  that  Obama’s  messages  were  received  so  well  is  because  he  

utilized  several  mechanisms  to  develop  leaders  within  his  campaign  organization.    Obama’s  

election  was  more  than  election;  it  was  a  movement.    Obama’s  group  of  young  innovators  

created  a  pattern  and  framework  change  in  the  way  to  cultivate  leaders  and  followers  for  

their  movement.    

                                                                                                               10  (Maxwell)  Describes  great  leadership  as  level  5  leadership:  leaders  that  develop  leaders.  11  (Drayton)  Small  group  discussion  with  Bill  Drayton  at  the  McDonough  School  of  Business  with  other  students.  

Page 10: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   8    

As  FDR  with  radio,  and  JFK  with  television,  Obama  utilized  social  media  as  the  technology  

of  the  time.12  Obama’s  campaign  created  a  website  that  allowed  supporters  to  become  

active  participants  by  recruiting  further  donors  and  supporters.  The  one  of  the  many  

pattern  changes  that  Obama’s  team  implemented  was  the  use  of  social  media  for  organizing  

people  for  citizen  action.  They  utilized  existing  ideas  in  social  network  software  to  create  

My.BarackObama.com  that  then  became  the  central  hub  for  the  Obama  election  movement  

for  people  around  the  country.    They  created  was  utilizing  social  media  to  connect  to  the  

masses  into  a  community.13  FDR  and  JFK  may  have  utilized  their  communications  

infrastructure  well,  but  Obama’s  team  created  their  own.14  Obama’s  campaign  first  created  

a  pattern  change  in  the  management  of  political  movements  in  the  Democratic  Party.  By  

influencing  McCain  and  Romney  to  follow  suit,  they  created  a  framework  change  by  

changing  the  way  Republicans  do  business.    

Listen  to  and  learn  from  the  community  When  McCain  mimicked  Obama’s  social  network  in  2008,  it  was  too  late  in  the  

game.15  Romney  mimicked  Obama’s  use  of  social  media  and  email  in  2012,  but  lacked  an  

important  element.  They  may  have  been  trying  very  hard  to  keep  up  with  the  technology  

and  creating  a  community,  but  they  weren’t  listening.  Their  data  was  coming  from  Gallup  

                                                                                                               12  (Nations)  Collection  of  notes  on  About.com  regarding  web  2.0  tendencies  by  the  Obama  campaign.  13  (Nations)  ibid.  14  (Smith)  Article  that  explains  how  the  technology  from  the  2008  election  was  being  used  in  Georgia  by  the  democrats.  15  (Ostrow)  Article  on  the  re-­‐launch  of  the  McCainSpace.com  website.  

Page 11: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   9    

polls.  In  this  day  and  age,  Gallup  is  just  one  among  many  equally  good  sources  for  public  

opinion  and  direction.      

Obama  Gray  Keller’s  framework  for  servant  leadership  includes  a  very  simple  mnemonic  

device  for  understanding  how  to  truly  engage  people  as  a  leader.  It  claims  that  good  

leadership  is  about  loving  people,  listening  to  them,  learning  from  them,  liberating  them  

from  their  struggle,  and  living  rather  than  leaving  a  legacy.16      

One  of  the  major  innovations  in  the  2012  election  by  Obama’s  campaign  was  their  

ability  to  listen  and  learn  to  their  constituents.  By  creating  a  social  network  platform  for  

their  political  movement,  they  then  gave  it  to  the  Democratic  Party.  During  the  2008  and  

the  2012  elections,  the  platform  continuously  improved  to  do  more  than  just  organize  

people  on  a  website.  The  platform  was  collecting  information  in  various  ways  to  

understand  the  actions  people  were  taking:  logging  on  to  their  site;  the  people  opening  the  

emails;  sharing  the  message  on  a  social  network;  and  countless  other  activities.17    This  

trend  is  known  elsewhere  in  the  industry  as  utilizing  “analytics”  to  measure  “key  metrics”  

and  “leveraging  Big  Data”  to  make  intelligent  decisions  and  take  intelligent  actions.  

Create  actionable  content  around  the  singular  rhetorical  vision  The  best  visionaries  are  able  to  communicate  their  ideas  in  such  a  way  that  others  

can  understand,  own,  and  help  carry  the  vision  to  fruition.  Once  the  President  or  

                                                                                                               16  (Keller)  Class  lecture  /  Presentation  by  leadership  expert  in  “Character  Conscience  and  Courage”  class.  17  (Levinthal)  Article  on  the  amount  of  data  that  BarackObama.com  is  collecting  on  users.  

Page 12: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   10    

Presidential  candidate  has  a  solid  community  to  speak  to,  the  singular  rhetorical  vision  

must  be  created  as  actionable  content.  Although  collecting  data  from  the  community  has  

been  a  part  of  every  presidential  campaign  since  Reagan,  recently,  it  is  the  ability  to  create  

personalized  actionable  content  that  differentiates  the  winners  from  the  losers.    

Reagan    Although  Reagan  himself  was  a  great  rhetorician,  his  team  hired  the  right  folks  to  

help  advertise  him  in  the  1984  election.  Utilizing  simple  yet  powerful  ads  that  struck  the  

nerve  of  the  American  people,  they  were  able  to  motivate  people  to  keep  Reagan  as  

President.18    

The  “Bear  in  the  Woods  “  commercial  that  aired  during  Reagan’s  election  campaign  

against  Walter  Mondale,  was  created  using  data  collected  from  focus  groups.  Specific  issues  

that  were  “problem  areas”  for  Reagan  against  Mondale  were  analyzed.19  One  of  the  major  

issues  was  “world  peace.”  When  the  “Bear  in  the  Woods”  ad  was  tested  in  a  focus  group,  it  

was  validated  to  bring  up  thoughts  of  “peace  through  strength.”20  

By  listening  to  the  people  and  what  their  concerns  were,  Reagan’s  team  was  able  to  

create  content  crafted  to  alleviate  their  concerns.    

                                                                                                               18  (Raine)  Article  on  Riney,  one  of  the  folks  that  helped  create  Reagan’s  image  in  1984.  19  (Merrin)  Conversation  with  marketing  expert  that  told  me  how  focus  groups  were  used  to  understand  the  concerns  of  the  American  people  and  the  “gateway”  issues  which  would  make  or  break  the  election.    20  (Wikipedia)  Article  regarding  the  “Bear  in  the  woods”  commecial.  

Page 13: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   11    

Obama  As  far  back  as  the  2008  and  as  recently  as  the  2012  elections,  Obama  and  now  the  

Democratic  Party  has  been  utilizing  advanced  tools  to  create  personalized  actionable  

content  to  “activate”  people  from  passers  by.  The  viral  nature  of  social  networks  allowed  

the  Obama  campaign  to  recruit  millions  of  people  across  several  social  networks  including  

their  own.  The  data  that  they  collected  on  My.BarackObama.com  was  then  used  to  create  

personalized  email  campaigns  that  sent  the  users  to  personalized  landing  pages  that  asked  

them  to  take  relevant  actions  on  the  website  depending  on  what  they  clicked,  where  they  

were  from,  or  what  information  was  stored  about  them.21  Obama’s  vision  of  change  

included  the  people  that  were  supporting  him  and  by  including  them  in  the  campaign,  he  

gave  them  a  part  in  the  new  vision  of  America  of  ‘Change’  and  ‘Hope’  that  he  was  trying  to  

bring  to  light.    

My.BarackObama.com  trained  its  users  to  personalize  their  home  pages  on  the  site  

and  then  empowered  them  to  create  personalized  sub-­‐campaigns  to  recruit  supporters.  

Language  on  the  site  included  calls  to  action  such  as  “Four  Steps  to  Raising  Money  from  

your  Friends”22  and  politely  motivated  them  to  “Reach  out  to  Voters”  by  asking  them  to  

“Make  Calls”  and  “Knock  on  Doors”.23    

                                                                                                               21  (Ciotti)  Article  on  industry  blog  on  metrics  measurement  and  anlaysis  regarding  5  email  lessons  gained  from  Barack  Obama’s  campaigns  22  (Organizing  for  Action)  Document  from  the  old  My.BarackObama.com  23  (Organizing  for  Action)  Document  from  the  old  My.BarackObama.com  

Page 14: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   12    

Spread  and  propagate  the  message  Regardless  of  whether  the  content  of  the  message  is  a  call  to  recruit  more  people  to  

bombard  their  representatives  to  vote  a  certain  way,  raise  money  for  a  campaign,  or  to  

create  a  local  chapter  to  grow  the  vision,  the  message  must  be  spread  in  a  way  that  people  

listen.    

The  challenge  for  the  modern  President  or  the  Presidential  candidate  is  to  

understand  what  is  the  best  communications  infrastructure  to  use  and  when  to  use  it.    As  

mentioned  before,  FDR  pioneered  the  use  of  radio  for  politics,  JFK,  the  television,  and  

Obama,  the  social  networks.  Each  media  outlet  is  necessary  but  not  sufficient.  Up  until  FDR,  

other  media  continued  to  exist  in  the  form  of  newspapers.  By  JFK’s  time,  radio  was  

widespread  in  addition  to  the  newspaper.  If  the  singular  rhetorical  vision  is  to  be  spread  to  

call  to  action  the  populace  to  take  civic  action  whether  by  their  vote,  their  call  to  their  

elected  official,  or  to  grow  the  movement,  it  must  be  spread  with  and  by  all  tactical  

methods  possible.    

Today,  there  are  growing  numbers  of  online  marketing  and  campaign  strategies  that  

should  be  utilized  in  conjunction  with  traditional  marketing  and  campaigning.  These  

“strategies”  have  recently  started  to  coalesce  into  books  such  as  The  Ultimate  Web  

Marketing  Guide  that  define  the  different  types  of  “new  media”  and  how  to  utilize  them.24  

These  online  strategies  are  in  some  ways  tactical  methods  for  a  higher  order  strategic  

communications  process  such  as  the  one  this  paper  proposes,  and  in  some  sense  strategies                                                                                                                  24  (Miller)  One  of  the  many  books  on  online  marketing  today  that  covers  several  online  strategies.  

Page 15: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   13    

that  need  to  be  designed  for  specific  audiences.  Since  these  technologies  will  continue  to  

change  in  the  future,  the  approach  matters  more  than  the  method.  Romney  and  Obama  

both  used  email,  but  Obama’s  team  was  able  to  engage  and  activate  more  people  because  

they  “listened”  to  their  constituents  and  re-­‐propagated  more  finely  tuned  messaging.    

Activate  community  members  to  participants  The  President  is  the  leader  of  the  United  States  but  should  not  assume  that  all  

community  members  are  listening.  Neither  the  President  nor  the  Presidential  candidate  

has  any  guarantee  that  those  that  are  listening  to  the  message  are  acting.  Activation  and  

active  engagement  is  the  key  to  any  campaign.  Activation  and  engagement  are  not  a  simple  

linear  process.  They  are  components  of  a  continuously  cyclical  process  that  strives  to  raise  

the  most  in-­‐active  members  in  the  community  to  the  most  active  members  in  the  

community.  If  the  message  of  the  singular  rhetorical  vision  is  good,  if  the  community  is  

strong,  if  the  message  is  tuned  according  to  what  the  masses  are  saying,  if  the  content  has  

been  personalized  for  the  community  member,  if  it  has  been  spread  across  several  forms  of  

media,  then  there  is  a  likely  hood  that  it  has  been  received.    

The  reception  of  the  message  should  then  trigger  an  action,  however  little  and  

insignificant.  It  may  take  several  cycles  of  communication  in  order  to  convince  someone  to  

take  physical  action.  This  has  been  known  in  the  business  practices  of  Sales  and  Marketing  

for  years.  It  may  take  several  touch-­‐points  to  get  someone  to  “buy,”  and  continue,  “using”  to  

Page 16: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   14    

create  a  meaningful  “customer  experience.”25  A  successful  series  of  campaigns  keeps  a  

‘customer  for  life’  with  a  high  customer  lifetime  value.    

Each  communications  cycle  may  result  in  higher  order  activation  from  the  one  

before,  but  no  matter  how  insignificant,  it  builds  mindshare  in  the  person  and  starts  to  

make  them  loyal  to  the  message.  For  example,  a  sample  “supporter  journey  map”  for  a  

citizen  that  becomes  a  registered  voter  through  a  campaign  might  look  like  this:  citizen;  

reader  of  forwarded  campaign  email;  visitor  of  campaign  website  landing  page;  subscriber  

to  email  list  with  some  personal  information;  receiver  of  personalized  email;  forwarder  of  

email  to  friends;  receiver  of  email  to  register  to  vote;  registered  voter.  A  journey  map  from  

a  registered  voter  to  a  voter  that  votes  for  a  candidate  is  much  more  complicated  and  

requires  a  complicated  set  of  machinery  to  measure  and  ensure  success.  Each  person’s  

ability  to  impact  others  is  magnified  because  of  the  interconnectedness  of  the  Internet.  

Obama’s  campaigns  created  ‘lifetime’  followers  in  “Obama  for  America”  that  elected  him  to  

office,  and  wanted  to  support  his  initiatives  with  what  is  now  the  “Organizing  for  Action”  

because  they  strove  to  activate  and  actively  engage  people  to  become  active  and  engaged  

citizens,  not  just  voters  for  a  presidential  term.    

Measure  to  improve.  Improve  to  succeed.  Repeat.  In  the  technology  startup  community,  several  schools  of  thought  have  convened  on  a  

few  principles  of  success  for  Internet  companies.  Some  books  such  as  Eric  Reis’  Lean  

                                                                                                               25  (Richardson)  HBR  Blog  article  about  the  importance  of  touchpoints  in  creating  customer  experience.  

Page 17: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   15    

Startup  Method,  reiterate  ideas  from  the  Toyota  Engineering  Method  and  Steve  Blank’s  

Four  Steps  to  the  Epiphany.  One  such  principle  is  the  idea  of  “Build  –  Measure  –  Learn”  that  

says  that  after  all  action  is  validated  and  accounted  for,  the  team  must  build,  measure,  and  

learn  through  a  virtuous  cycle.26  The  exact  metrics  that  need  to  be  measured  depends  on  

the  vision,  strategy,  and  whatever  happens  to  be  the  “product.”  The  vision  rarely  changes.  

The  strategy  may  change  as  part  of  a  “pivot”  in  thought  of  how  to  do  something.  The  

product  changes  frequently  with  build,  measurement  of  user  activity,  and  learning  what  the  

users  want.    

Thus  far,  others  in  the  startup  community  have  also  created  a  canon  for  core  metrics  

that  every  “internet”  presence  should  measure  including  online  campaigns  that  wish  to  

activate  citizens  into  actively  engaged  citizens.  These  include  “Acquisitions,”  “Activations,”  

“Referrals,”  “Retention,”  and  “Revenue.”  Surprisingly,  these  correlate  fairly  well  with  the  

metrics  that  the  President’s  or  the  Presidential  candidate’s  team  should  be  measuring  to  

tune  their  communications  cycle.      

Obama  Obama’s  campaigns  in  2008  and  2012  both  utilized  the  data  they  collected  on  users  

to  understand  user  behaviors  as  well  as  how  to  maximize  metrics  similar  to  those  

                                                                                                               26  (Reis)  The  Lean  Startup  Method  has  popularized  the  “kaizen”  method  used  by  Toyota  for  years.  

Page 18: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   16    

mentioned  earlier  and  others  that  were  more  specific  to  the  type  of  media  that  was  

utilized.27    

Obama’s  campaign  utilized  metrics  to  maximize  metrics  across  all  media  channels  

available  to  them.  They  utilized  targeted  method  of  advertising  to  acquire  users  on  several  

platforms  such  as  Twitter,  Facebook,  and  YouTube  in  addition  to  their  own.  They  continued  

to  fine-­‐tune  their  broadcast  mechanisms  and  used  various  methods  to  see  what  methods  

acquired  the  most  users.  Once  they  had  people’s  attention,  they  utilized  and  measured  the  

different  methods  for  activating  these  users  into  more  active  participants.  Once  they  had  

participants,  they  then  empowered  them  to  refer/recruit  others  all  the  while  continuously  

improving  to  retain  them  on  their  various  platforms  to  build  community,  mindshare,  and  a  

movement.    

The  differentiating  factor  for  Obama’s  campaign  engine  is  that  they  followed  simple  

processes  to  create  a  feedback  loop  from  the  people  they  were  trying  to  motivate  into  

action.  With  the  help  of  technology,  they  were  able  to  “listen”  better.  They  were  able  to  

“build  –  measure  –  learn”  like  the  modern  technology  startups  and  keep  changing  with  the  

times.    

Change  is  the  only  constant  The  world  is  changing.  People,  processes,  and  information  are  continuously  self-­‐

organizing  into  new  patterns  and  frameworks,  led  by  change  makers  and  leaders  that  

                                                                                                               27  (SocialMedia8)  Slideshow  showing  aspects  of  the  Barack  Obama  Strategy  

Page 19: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   17    

understand  that  change  is  elemental.  Modern  presidents  need  to  embrace  each  new  

technology  that  comes  with  the  accelerated  pace  of  a  globalized  inter-­‐connected  world.    

In  the  corporate  world,  the  role  of  information  and  technology  have  transformed  the  

way  businesses  are  structured,  run,  grow,  and  communicate  with  their  customers.    As  the  

role  of  the  Chief  Information  Officer  and  the  Chief  Technology  Officer  are  elevated,  the  Chief  

Marketing  Officers  are  prioritizing  customer  loyalty  as  their  biggest  digital  concern.28        

The  President  and  the  presidential  candidate’s  job  are  different  from  a  CEO’s.  The  

role  of  the  government  and  that  of  a  campaign  is  different  from  what  a  business  does.  

Though  these  systems  are  different,  the  communications  cycles  are  similar.    The  elements  

of  rhetoric  are  as  relevant  as  they  were  in  Aristotle’s  time.  The  idea  that  great  leadership  is  

an  act  of  empowering  leaders  is  as  relevant  as  in  any  organization.  The  President  leads  by  

communicating  rhetorically,  by  persuading  the  population  to  move  a  certain  way.  They  get  

there  by  convincing  the  masses  with  the  same  rhetorical  skills.  The  times  are  different,  but  

the  job  of  communicating  is  the  same.    

From  the  examples  of  FDR,  JFK,  Reagan,  and  primarily  Obama,  we  can  see  an  

example  of  a  rhetorical  president  that  not  only  uses  the  communications  infrastructure  

available  but  also  innovates  new  ones  because  that  is  the  change  that  is  required.  Although  

Obama’s  rhetoric  was  communicated  using  pattern  and  framework  changes  in  the  

communications  systems,  Obama  advertised  his  agenda  as  a  pattern  and  framework  

                                                                                                               28  (IBM)  Study  of  trends  of  Chief  Marketing  Officers  

Page 20: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   18    

change.  He  embraced  the  idea  that  change  is  necessary  to  move  forward.  He  established  his  

credibility  (ethos)  through  speeches  that  struck  at  the  heart  of  people’s  lives  (pathos)  and  

showed  them  that  a  system  change  was  necessary  (logos).  His  team  took  this  singular  

rhetorical  vision,  created  a  community  of  followers  and  burgeoning  leaders,  and  together  

propagated  the  message  across  the  country  while  improving  how  they  were  doing  it.    

Page 21: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   19    

Bibliography  

Aristotle.  On  Rhetoric.  Trans.  George  Kennedy.  n.d.  

Ciotti,  Gregory.  5  Email  Marketing  Lessons  From  The  Obama  Campaign.  1  November  2012.  28  April  2013  <http://blog.kissmetrics.com/email-­‐marketing-­‐lessons-­‐obama/>.  

Drayton,  Bill.  Conversation  with  Georgetown  University  Students  before  SIPS  Fund  Lecture  Rahul  Singh.  23  April  2013.  

IBM.  "From  Stretched  to  Strengthened,  Insights  from  the  Global  Chief  Marketing  Officer."  25  October  2011.  Slideshare.net.  28  April  2013  <http://www.slideshare.net/ikinser/ibm-­‐cmos>.  

Kaufman,  Robert  G.  The  First  Principles  of  Ronald  Reagan's  Foreign  Policy.  1  November  2011.  28  April  2013  <http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2011/11/the-­‐first-­‐principles-­‐of-­‐ronald-­‐reagans-­‐foreign-­‐policy>.  

Keller,  Gray.  Lecture  to  Character,  Conscience,  and  Courage  Class  Rahul  Singh.  23  March  2013.  

Levinthal,  Dave.  Obama's  2012  campaign  is  watching  you.  16  March  2013.  28  April  2013  <http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0312/74095.html>.  

Maxwell,  John.  The  Five  Levels  of  Leadership.  New  York:  Center  Street,  2011.  

Merrin,  Mary  Beth.  Conversation  with  DMR  CEO,  Mary  Beth  Merrin  Rahul  Singh.  10  March  2010.  

Miller,  Michael.  The  Ultimate  Web  Marketing  Guide.  Indianapolis:  Pearson  Education,  Que  Publishing,  2011.  

Nations,  Daniel.  How  Barack  Obama  Is  Using  Web  2.0  to  Run  for  President.  12  December  2012.  28  April  2013  <http://webtrends.about.com/od/web20/a/obama-­‐web.htm>.  

Obama,  Senatorial  Candidate  Barack.  "Barack  Obama's  Inspiring  2004  Democratic  Convention  Speech."  27  July  2004.  About.com  -­‐  U.S.  Liberals.  28  April  2013  <http://usliberals.about.com/od/extraordinaryspeeches/a/ObamaSpeech_3.htm>.  

Page 22: Modern Presidential Communications - Communicating Presidential Rhetorical Vision in a Changing World

 

Modern  Presidential  Communication   20    

Organizing  for  Action.  Neighbor  to  Neighbor:  Voter  Contact  Host  Guide.  2008.  28  April  2013  <https://my.barackobama.com/page/content/n2nhostguide>.  

—.  Using  the  My.BarackObama.com  Personal  Fundraising  Tool.  2008.  28  April  2013  <https://my.barackobama.com/page/content/personalfundraisinghowto/>.  

Ostrow,  Adam.  John  McCain  Relaunches  His  Social  Network.  It’s  Surprisingly  Good.  27  August  2008.  28  April  2013  <http://mashable.com/2008/08/27/mccainspace-­‐social-­‐network/>.  

Raine,  George.  Creating  Reagan's  image  /  S.F.  ad  man  Riney  helped  secure  him  a  second  term.  9  June  2004.  28  April  2013  <http://www.sfgate.com/business/article/Creating-­‐Reagan-­‐s-­‐image-­‐S-­‐F-­‐ad-­‐man-­‐Riney-­‐2715098.php>.  

Reis,  Eric.  The  Lean  Startup:  How  Today's  Entrepreneurs  Use  Continuous  Innovation  to  Create  Radically  Successful  Businesses.  New  York:  Crown  Publishing,  2011.  

Richardson,  Adam.  Touchpoints  Bring  the  Customer  Experience  to  Life.  2  December  2010.  28  April  2013  <http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2010/12/touchpoints_bring_the_customer.html>.  

Russo,  Ambassador  Paul.  Class  Lectures  on  Ronald  Reagan  Rahul  Singh.  April  2013.  

Singh,  Rahul.  "Selling  to  Chiefs  :  Executing  Internet  Strategy  for  Business  to  Business."  25  July  2011.  Prezi.com.  28  April  2013  <http://prezi.com/1rhrv7ak78us/selling-­‐to-­‐chiefs-­‐executing-­‐internet-­‐strategy/>.  

Smith,  Ben.  Dem  campaigns  use  new  software  to  tally  hard  numbers.  21  June  2011.  28  April  2013  <http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0611/57443.html>.  

SocialMedia8.  "Case  Study:  The  Barack  Obama  Strategy."  5  February  2009.  SlideShare.net.  28  April  2013  <http://www.slideshare.net/socialmedia8/case-­‐study-­‐the-­‐barack-­‐obama-­‐strategy-­‐993931>.  

Tulis,  Jeffrey  K.  The  Rhetorical  Presidency.  Princeton:  Princeton  University  Press,  1987.  

Wikipedia.  Bear  in  the  Woods.  13  August  2006.  28  April  2013  <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bear_in_the_woods>.