Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China...

39
Models of GRB GeV-TeV emissio Models of GRB GeV-TeV emissio n and GLAST/Swift synergy n and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo L i (PKU), Hao-ning He (NJU) TeV Particle Astrophysics IV Sept. 24-28, 2008; Beijing, China

Transcript of Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China...

Page 1: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergyGLAST/Swift synergy

Xiang-Yu WangNanjing University, China

Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning He (NJU)

TeV Particle Astrophysics IV Sept. 24-28, 2008; Beijing, China

Page 2: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Outline

GRB high-energy observations Models for GeV-TeV emission from GRBs Swift new discoveries and high-energy predictions with G

LAST

Page 3: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

I. GRB high-energy observations

GRB930131

GRB940217

EGRET on CGRO 1) Prompt 2) Delayed

Page 4: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

GRB941017

−18 s – 14 s

14 s – 47 s

47 s – 80 s

80 s – 113 s

113 s – 211 s

High-energy emission lasts longer than KeV-MeV emission

Page 5: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

A recent burst detected by AGILE GRB080514B

Similar to GRB941017, common phenomena?

Page 6: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

GCN reports on GLAST Obs.

GRB080825C: LAT detection, photons with energy lower than 1 GeV (GCN No.8183)

GRB080916C : LAT detection, more than 10 photons are observed above 1 GeV (GCN No.8246)

Page 7: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

E>100GeV: only upper limits

Magic: upper limits for several Swift bursts (Albert et al., 06)

Whipple: upper limits (Horan et al. 07) Milagro: upper limits fro short GRB (Abdo et a

l. 07) ARGO-YBJ array find only upper limits (Di Sc

iascio, et al., 06) HESS: upper limits of GRB060602B (Aharoni

an et al. 08)

Page 8: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Example: HESS GRB060602B

very soft BAT spectrum and proximity to the Galactic center

More likely to be a Galactic X-ray transient

Page 9: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

GRB model: Internal and External shocks

Credit P. Meszaros

Rees & Meszaros 92; Meszaros & Rees 1994

Page 10: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Electrons- Shock acceleration: ~10 TeV

Protons (or nuclei)-1) Shock acceleration (e.g. Waxman 1995; Vietri 1995)

Candidate source of ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs)

2) Neutrinos from photo-meson and pp processes (e.g. Waxman & Bahcall 1997; Bottcher & Dermer 1998)

Particle acceleration in GRB shocks

eV10~ 20

7, 10~ Maxeacccool tt

5, 10 Maxe X-ray afterglows modeling e.g. Li & Waxman 2006

Page 11: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Two basic processes for high-energy gamma-ray emission1. Leptonic inverse-Compton scattering

2. Hadronic processes: 1)proton synchrotron; 2) p-γneutral pion decay; 3)secondary electrons synchrotron & IC

Prompt phase Internal shock, leptonic: electron synchrotron & SSC Internal shock, hadronic: proton synchrotron & p-γ interaction

Early afterglow phase External, leptonic: forward, reverse and cross shock SSC External, hadronic: proton synchrotron & p-γ interaction

Page 12: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Efficiency comparison for the two processes (I)

Prompt gamma-ray emission (Gupta & Zhang 2007)

-- Proton syn.-- synchrotron radiation produced by secondary positrons

**high energy emission is dominated by the leptonic component if є_e>0.01**

neutral pion decay

Page 13: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Efficiency comparison for the two processes (II)-mildly relativistic outflow

Ando & Meszaros 08

Page 14: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

GRB high energy emission: IC processes

central internal external shocksengine (shocks) (reverse) (forward)

Internal shock IC: e.g. Pilla & Loeb 1998; Razzaque et al. 2004; Gupta & Zhang 2007

External shock IC reverse shock IC: e.g. Meszaros , et al. 94; Wang et al. 01; Granot & Guetta 03

forward shock IC: e.g.Meszaros & Rees 94; Dermer et al. 00; Zhang & Meszaros 01

Page 15: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Typical energies of SSC emission

Page 16: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

(1) IC emission from very early external shocks

Shocked shell

Shocked ISM

Cold ISM

Coldshell

pressure

FSRS

CD

1) (rr)2) (ff)3) (fr)4) (rf)

Four IC processes

(Wang, Dai & Lu 2001 ApJ,556, 1010)

At deceleration radius, T_obs~10-100 sForward shock---Reverse shock structure is developed

Page 17: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Energy spectra---

1

0

max

min

'3 xfxdxgNdrf TIC

;1,5.2,01.0,6.0,10E a) 53 nperg Be

f

At sub-GeV to GeV energies, the SSC of reverse shock is dominant; at higher energies, the Combined IC or SSC of forward shock becomes increasingly dominated

Reverse shock SSC (r,f) IC

(f,r) ICForward shock SSC

Log(E/keV)

GLAST 5 photons sensitivity

(Wang, Dai & Lu 2001 ApJ,556, 1010)

Page 18: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

One GeV burst with very hard spectrum- leptonic or hadronic process?

−18 s – 14 s

14 s – 47 s

47 s – 80 s

80 s – 113 s

113 s – 211 s

Gonzalez et al. 03: Hadronic model

Leptonic IC model:

Granot & Guetta 03 Pe’er & Waxman 04 Wang X Y et al. 05

GRB941017

Wang X Y et al. 05, A&A, 439,957

Reverse shock SSCISM medium environment

Page 19: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

(2) afterglow IC emissionZhang & Meszaros 01

May explain delayed GeV emission

Page 20: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Swift/GLAST synergy

1) X-ray flares 2) early shallow decay 3)low-luminosity GRBs 4)prompt emission

Page 21: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Swift: A Canonical X-ray Lightcurve(Zhang et al. 2006; Nousek et al. 2006; O’Brien et al. 2006)

~ -3

~ -0.5

~ - 1.2

~ -210^2 – 10^3 s

10^4 – 10^5 s

prompt emission

Page 22: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

~30%-50% early afterglow have x-ray flares, Swift discovery

Flare light curves: rapid rise and decay

<<1 Afterglow decay consistent with

a single power-law before and after the flare

(1) High-energy photons from X-ray flares

Burrows et al. 2005Falcone et al. 2006

amplitude: ~500 times above the underlying afterglow

GRB050502B

X-ray flares occur inside the decelerationradius of the afterglow shock

X-ray flares: late-time central engine activity

Page 23: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

IC between X-ray flare photons and afterglow electrons (Wang, Li & Meszaros 2006)

Cnetral engine

X-ray flare photons

Forward shock region

Cartoon

X-ray flare photons illuminate the afterglow shock electrons from inside

also see Fan & Piran 2006: unseen UV photons

Page 24: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

IC GeV flare fluence-An estimate So most energy of the newly shock electrons will be lost into IC emi

ssion

X-ray flare peak energy

Page 25: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Temporal behavior of the IC emission Not exactly correlated with the X-ray flare light curves. IC

emission will be lengthened by the afterglow shock angular

spreading time and the anisotropic IC effect

Self-IC of flares, peak at lower energiesWang, Li & Meszaros 2006In external shock model for x-ray flares

Page 26: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

IC emission from X-ray flares at VHE

Page 27: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

(2)High-energy emission during shallow decay phase-energy injection model (Fan et al. 2008)

Page 28: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

(3)High-energy emission from low-luminosity GRBs

Page 29: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

GRB980425: first low-luminosity GRB identified sub-energetic GRB—GRB980425: E~1e48 erg, at d=38 Mpc Radio afterglow modeling: E>1e49 erg, \Gamma~1-2 X-ray afterglow: E~5e49 erg, \beta=0.8 (Waxman 2004)

Mildly relativistic ejecta component

In the error box of GRB980425

Page 30: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

GRB060218/SN2006aj –Swift discovery

An unusually long, smooth burst

Low luminosity, low energy

z=0.033, second nearest GRB

Campana et al. 2006

Page 31: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Thermal x-ray emission from low-luminosity GRBs

SN2006aj/GRB060218

prompt thermal x-ray emission— mildly relativistic SN shock breakout from stellar wind

Campana et al. 06

Waxman, Meszaros, Campana 07

Page 32: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Three low-luminosity supernova-GRBs

1) Low-luminosity 2) Smooth light curves 3) Spectrum: a simple power-law with a high energy cutoff

So why they are so unusual?

Mildly relativistic hypernova?

Page 33: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

High-energy emission from mildly-relativistic hypernova ejecta

Ando & Meszaros 08

at deceleration time ~1d

Page 34: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

High-energy emission from mildly-relativistic hypernova ejecta

He & Wang, in preparation

Page 35: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Compared with relativistic jet case

Page 36: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

(4)Prompt multi-band study by Swift/GLAST Swift can detect optical

to KeV-MeV emission GLAST can detected G

eV-TeV emission

One natural scenario: optical from syn,MeV from IC, Y>=10

2nd IC at GeV-TeV?

Naked eye burst GRB080319B

Page 37: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

IR, opt, UV ~500keV ~500GeV

YL

YH=YL

Page 38: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Swift/GLAST can distinguish … SSC model or double syn. model for prompt

optical and MeV emission

Page 39: Models of GRB GeV-TeV emission and GLAST/Swift synergy Xiang-Yu Wang Nanjing University, China Co-authors: Peter Meszaros (PennState), Zhuo Li (PKU), Hao-ning.

Xiang-Yu Wang TeVPA08

Summary Leptonic vs. Hadronic

Leptonic component dominate at GeV-TeV for typical parameters Only for very inefficient bursts (may be diagnosed by coordinated GLAST/Swift obs

ervations), would one expects a significant hadronic contribution in the high energy spectrum

Prompt emission: SSC or double synchrotron model fro prompt optical and MeV emission Forward shock SSC would give extended GeV-TeV emission

Fluence peaks at hours GeV-TeV flares will accompany X-ray flares

Broader Delayed in time

Low-luminosity GRB afterglow Detectable at 30MeV-10 GeV at the peak time for e_e>0.1 Can be used to distinguish high \Gamma or low \Gamma with GLAST observations

of the light curves