Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert ...
Transcript of Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert ...
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 1 of 25
Name of the members who were present in the meeting are as follows: -
1. Prof. (Dr.) Sudarsan Neogi Chairman, SEAC
2. Dr. Kalyan Rudra Member, SEAC
3. Dr. Satya Kinkar Pal Member, SEAC
4. Prof. Bhabatosh Biswas Member, SEAC
5. Dr. Arunkanti Biswas Member, SEAC
6. Prof.(Dr) S.R Roychoudhuri Member, SEAC
7. Dr. Amitava Roy Member, SEAC
8. Prof. Jayanta Bhattacharya Member, SEAC
9. D Dr. Anita Chattopadhyay Gupta Member, SEAC
10. Sri P. K. Sarkar Secretary, SEAC & Member Secretary, WBPCB
In the beginning of the 81st meeting of SEAC, which was held on 14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs at the Conference
Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Bidhan Nagar, the Secretary, SEAC welcome all the members. After introductory
session, four cases were discussed under 'Miscellaneous' section. Ten applicants were requested to make their
presentation before the committee. All the ten applicants made their presentations before the committee. Five
cases were placed for reconsideration.
SESSION I
A. Miscellaneous
1. Proposed expansion project for 3x20 MT Induction Furnace with caster and 2000 TPM Wire
Drawing unit by M/s. Gagan Ferro Tech Ltd. at Jamuria Industrial Estate, Vill & PO – Ikra, Dist –
Burdwan.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of 3x20 MT Induction Furnace with caster and 2000 TPM Wire Drawing
unit.
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Existing Proposed
Sponge Iron 4x100 TPD --
Induction Furnace 2x20 MT with CCM 3x20 MT with CCM
Captive Power Plant 12 MW --
Wire Drawing Unit -- 2000 TPM
The SEAC noted that this is an expansion proposal for Category „A‟ project having Sponge Iron > 200 TPD
and as per EIA notification 2006 and its amendment the case may be appraised at MoEF.
The matter was discussed and reviewed in the 80th meeting held on 18.01.2014 and noted that this is an
expansion proposal for Category „A‟ project having Sponge Iron > 200 TPD and as per EIA notification
2006 and its amendment the case may be appraised at MoEF and the SEAC has decided to forward the
same proposal to the SEIAA for the opinion and necessary action.
The SEAC has received a letter from the SEIAA, WB vide No. EN/379/T-II-1/077/2012 dated 11.02.2014
mentioning that “SEAC should examine the proposal and submit recommendations to the SEIAA.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 2 of 25
The matter was put up for consideration. The SEAC reviewed the matter and after detailed discussion,
SEAC has decided to forward the same to the SEIAA for taking necessary action based on the
recommendation on 80th meeting held on 18.01.2014.
2. Proposed expansion project for 0.9 MTPA Coal Washery by M/s. Shakambhari Ispat & Power Ltd.
at Vill – Madandih, PO – Bartoria, Dist – Purulia, PIN – 723 121
Activity:
This is an expansion proposal of 0.9 MTPA Coal Washery.
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Existing Proposed
Sponge Iron 3x100 TPD --
Induction Furnace 2x12 MT with CCM --
Captive Power Plant 12 MW --
Coal Washery -- 0.9 MTPA
The SEAC noted that this is an expansion proposal for Category „A‟ project having Sponge Iron
manufacturing > 200 TPD and as per EIA notification 2006 and its amendment the case may be appraised
at MoEF.
The matter was discussed and reviewed in the 80th meeting held on 18.01.2014 and noted that this is an
expansion proposal for Category „A‟ project having Sponge Iron > 200 TPD and as per EIA notification
2006 and its amendment the case may be appraised at MoEF and the SEAC has decided to forward the
same proposal to the SEIAA for the opinion and necessary action.
The SEAC has received a letter from the SEIAA, WB vide No. EN/379/T-II-1/077/2012 dated 11.02.2014
mentioning that “SEAC should examine the proposal and submit recommendations to the SEIAA.
The matter was put up for consideration. The SEAC reviewed the matter and after detailed discussion,
SEAC has decided to forward the same to the SEIAA for taking necessary action based on the
recommendation on 80th meeting held on 18.01.2014.
3. Proposed expansion of unit for manufacturing of Linear Alkyl Benzene Sulphonic Acid (LABSA)
with the application of new technology by M/s. Advance Surfactants India Ltd. in its existing plant
premises at Dag No. 252 & 432, Vill & PO – Kaswarah, PS – Polba, Dist – Hooghly, PIN- 712102,
West Bengal.
M/s. Advance Surfactants India Ltd. has submitted an application to the WBPCB for production of Linear
Alkyl Benzene Sulphonic Acid (LABSA). As per the proposed manufacturing process sulphur will be
combusted in presence of pure Oxygen to produce Sulpher di Oxide which is converted into Sulpher
Trioxide. Produced Sulpher Trioxide is directly taken into close loop reactor to make LABSA. Heat
produced during combustion of sulphur will be utilised to produce power.
WBPCB seeks opinion of the SEIAA regarding requirement of Environmental Clearance for the above
mentioned project proposal.
SEIAA sent the proposal for examination and recommendation of SEAC.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 3 of 25
During the meeting SEAC recommended that manufacturing of LABSA should require Environmental
Clearance under Sl no. 5(f) of schedule of EIA notification 2006 and its amendment thereafter.
4. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Lingraj Properties Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. at JL No. 48, Mouza –
Kumrakhali, PO – Narendrapur, PS – Sonarpur, Rajpur - Sonarpur Municipality, Kolkata – 700
103, Dist – South 24 Parganas.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 479 flats (7 blocks of B+G+18 storied
buildings).
Chronology:
The SEAC stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance for the proposed project in the 60th
meeting held on 24.10.2011.
Now the unit has submitted the copy of the sanctioned building plan for the proposed project on
09.01.2014.
SEAC also received a notice from Shri Parimal Dey regarding objection against clearance. Applicant also
enclosed the order of the Hon‟ble Calcutta High Court (Case no. 3698-99 of 2013) against Winsome Plaza
Pvt. Ltd. & Others, Anita Agarwal & Others. As per the records of SEAC, Winsome Plaza and Anita
Agarwal also co-developer of the proposed project.
During the meeting, SEAC took note about the court case C.O No. 3698 of 2013 with C.O No. 3699 of
2013 with C.O No. 3742 of 2013 in the High Court at Calcutta Civil Revisional Jurisdiction appellate Side,
related to the land of the proposed project.
During the meeting Committee recommended that as the matter is sub judice, the application will be
considered after final disposal of Court Cases.
The committee shall consider this application only after submission of the status of disposal of court cases.
B. Note on Technical presentations
Industry Sector :-
1. ToR presentation of proposed expansion of Cement Grinding Unit of M/s. Lafarge India Pvt. Ltd.,
Mejia Cement Plant at Jl. No. – 41, Vill. – Amdanga, Mouza – Nandanpur, PS – Gangajalghati, PO –
MTPS (DVC), Dist. - Bankura, Pin – 722183, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for enhancement of production capacity of the existing Cement Grinding unit for increase
in production of Portland Pozzolana Cement from 1.5 to 2.5 MTPA. It is noted that clinker will not be
manufactured at the site. The manufacturing process will involve grinding of Cement Clinker with Flyash
and Gypsum. No additional machinery will be installed. The enhancement in production capacity will be
achieved through upgradation of existing Ball Mill with Roller Press and V-separator.
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are :
i) Location of the Site – Jl. No. – 41, Vill. – Amdanga, Mouza – Nandanpur, PS – Gangajalghati, PO – MTPS (DVC), Dist. - Bankura, Pin – 722183, West Bengal.
ii) Land Area – within the existing plant, 25.19 ha.
iii) Additional raw material requirement – Fly Ash – 330000 TPA, Clinker – 630000 TPA, Gypsum – 40
TPA.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 4 of 25
iv) Enhancement of Production Capacity – Portland Pozzolana Cement from 1.5 to 2.5 MTPA.
v) Emission Sources – no additional emission sources.
vi) Air Pollution Control System – existing system. The stack emission shall not exceed 50 mg/Nm3.
vii) Total Water Requirement – 190 KLD, MTPS supply. No additional water requirement.
viii) Wastewater – domestic effluent to be discharged through septic tank to soak pit.
ix) Additional Power Requirement – 7 MVA.
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. JM Environet Pvt. Ltd. The case is put up for consideration.
After careful consideration of the presentation by the project proponent, SEAC recommended ToR (Annexure -
I) for conducting draft EIA/EMP reports and exempt the project for conducting public hearing as per Clause
7(ii) of EIA notification, 2006 and its amendment thereafter due to expansion of the proposed project involving
energy efficient technology, no clinker manufacturing at site, no additional requirement of land, zero effluent
discharge and no sensitive area within 10 km of the proposed project site.
2. Proposed Palsara-II Blackstone Mine project by M/s. West Bengal Mineral Development & Trading
Corporation Ltd. at Mouza – Palsara, JL No. 121, Plot No. 2681, PS – Kashipur, Dist – Purulia, West
Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for black stone mining of maximum production capacity 200000 tonnes/year and
minimum production capacity 50000 tonnes/year of lease area 8.296 Ha (Command area 7.0786 Ha) in
Mouza – Palsara, JL No. 121, Plot no. 2681, PS – Kashipur, Dist – Purulia, West Bengal by West Bengal
Mineral Development & Trading Corporation. The rock will be excavated by open cast method of mining by
controlled blasting and excavated will be crushed into different size as per requirement. No effluent will be
generated as excavation will be restricted above water table. The top soil will be utilised to fill up the area
adjoining a guard wall to be constructed about 50 meters away from a pucca public road passing through the
west side within the lease area.
Name of the Environmental Consultant not mentioned. The case is put up for consideration. After carefully
considering the submission and presentation during the meeting, the committee recommended the project for
Environmental Clearance.
3. Proposed aerial rope way project by M/s. Damodar Ropeways & Infra Ltd. at plot no. 792, 799, 800,
2746, 807, 819, 820, 821, J.L no. 78, Vill- Paschim Gadadharpur, Amarabati Park, Digha under
DSDA, Dist - Purba Medinipur West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of monocable Jigback Fixed Grip Passenger Ropeway.
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are :
i) Ropeway capacity: 300 Persons per hour (PPH)
ii) Horizontal length: 197 mtrs (approx.)
iii) System: monocable Jigback Fixed Grip Passenger Ropeway
iv) Solid Waste generation :
v) Waste Water generation and treatment :
vi) No. of cabins: 8 nos.
vii) DG set: 1x125 KVA
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 5 of 25
Name of the Environmental Consultant: Not mentioned. The case is put up for consideration. After careful
consideration of the presentation by the project proponent, the committee recommended that the project
proponent should submit the following:-
1) Specific concurrence letter from the competent authority for providing infrastructural support regarding
disposal of municipal solid waste, waste water, supply of drinking water etc.
2) Proper safety / risk management plan.
The committee shall consider this application only after submission of the above mentioned clarifications.
Construction Sector:-
1. Proposal for the proposed 4 lane flyover proposed by the Kolkata Metropolitan Development
Authority (KMDA) from Ramnagar More (Garden Reach Road) to Remount Road (near Katapukur
Morgue).
Chronology:
KMDA has applied for Environmental Clearance for the proposed 4 lane flyover from Ramnagar More
(Garden Reach Road) to Remount Road (near Katapukur Morgue) to the State Environment Impact
Assessment Authority (SEIAA) on 28.01.2014 under Category „B‟ project under item 8(a) which was
forwarded by SEIAA to SEAC for necessary examination by the SEAC.
SEAC also received a letter from KMDA informing that this activity falls under item 7(f) of the schedule as
Highway projects instead of 8(a). However, as the proposed project is neither a national highway nor a state
highway, the project may be exempted from the purview of environmental clearance as per EIA
Notification.
Name of the Environmental Consultant not mentioned. During the meeting project proponent presented their
proposal. After detailed discussions on various provisions of EIA notifications and submission of project
proponent, SEAC recommended to exempt this project from obtaining EC. However Project Proponent should
strictly comply with the following conditions:
i) KMDA shall install Noise Barrier system during construction and post construction phase on the
alignment of the project. Also thick vegetation cover wherever required will be used for attenuation
of noise.
ii) Stationary construction equipment will be placed away from habitation Construction Contract
Specifications should specify use of less noise generating equipment.
iii) Construction Contract Specifications should stipulate levels of maximum noise generation in
various zones (residential, commercial and sensitive) based on CPCB Noise Standards.
iv) High noise generating construction activities like drilling, compacting etc. should be carried out
only during day time in residential areas.
v) Asphalt and hot-mix plants shall not be at site.
vi) Fugitive dust entrainment will be controlled by sprinkling water.
vii) PP shall use the Composite Structures for the construction of the flyover
viii) The Construction material as well as excavated material to be disposed off will be shifted only
during the night time when the traffic will be much less.
ix) For Construction of Super Structure, Pre-cast Segmental construction technology would be adopted,
while for in-situ construction, a movable Scaffold System construction method shall be adopted.
Thus the construction of piles and substructure shall use only a small part of the lane for a few days.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 6 of 25
x) Adequate construction boards, portable traffic signs, Chevron Signs, Road Marker Signs, Central
lights & Blinkers on Barricades, etc. will be put-up everywhere near the construction and
barricading in the effective stretch of the proposed road.
xi) Necessary permission for tree felling from the concerned department shall be obtained before
commencement of the project work.
xii) Construction spoils including bituminous material and other hazardous materials must not be
allowed to contaminate water courses and the dump sites for such materials must be secured so that
they shall not leach into the ground water.
xiii) Borrow pits and other scars created during the road construction shall be properly levelled and
treated.
xiv) No excavation or dumping shall be allowed on wetlands, other ecologically valuable or sensitive
locations.
xv) Adequate provision for infrastructure facilities including water supply, fuel and sanitation must be
ensured for construction workers during the construction phase of the project to avoid any damage
to the environment.
xvi) Adequate precautions shall be taken during transportation of the construction material so that it does
not affect the environment adversely.
xvii) Fly ash should be utilized strictly as per the provisions of Fly ash notification 2009 issued by MoEF
for the proposed project.
xviii) Rain water accumulation to be managed properly. Oil and grease trap shall be provided. Vertical
drain type rainwater outlet structures shall be set up to ensure quick runoff. The Strom water
management at two extreme ends must be taken care. The existing sewer line should be augmented
if required.
xix) Emergency Preparedness Plan and Accident/Disaster Management Plan shall be prepared and
strictly followed.
xx) Detailed study dealing with the effects of the construction on rainwater drainage in the catchment
area and environmental management plan shall be prepared and strictly followed.
xxi) Proper housing, shelter and crèche have to be provided to the contract and wage based workers.
SEAC decided to forward the above recommendation to SEIAA, WB.
2. Proposed construction of State Bank Institute of Management by State Bank of India at plot no.
IIF/2, Action area-II, New Town, P.S-Rajarhat, Dist-24 Pgs (N).
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of residential buildings (B+G+6, B+G+5, G+2), admin/academic blocks
(B+G+7), hostel (B+G+7), guest house (B+G+6) and allied services.
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : Total Land Area: 40468.52 sq.m
Expected Population : 1050 persons (during operation)
Total Water requirement : 170 KLD
Fresh water requirement : 97 KLD (NKDA supply)
Wastewater generated : 120 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater treated : 120 KLD
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 7 of 25
Wastewater recycled : 73 KLD
Wastewater discharged : 47 KLD (to WBHIDCO drain)
Solid waste disposal : 0.63 TPD
Total Built-up Area : 43575.21 sq.m (including parking)
Ground Coverage : 8054.07 sq.m (19.9% of land area)
Exclusive tree plantation area : 8093.71 sq.m (20.00% of land area)
Other green area : 12326.71 sq.m (30.46% of land area )
Total Paved area : 9994.56 sq.m (24.7% of land area)
Proposed water body area : 1999.47 sq.m (4.94% of land area)
No. of plantation proposed : 750
No. of Parking spaces proposed : Covered-203nos., Open-4 nos bus
Total Power requirement : 1473 KW, WBSCDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets ( 1x750 KVA)
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Ghosh Bose & Associates Pvt. Ltd. The case is put up for
consideration. After careful consideration of the presentation by the project proponent the SEAC recommended
stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
3. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Vivek Realty & Resorts Pvt. Ltd. at Mouza – Malancha, JL
No. 131, LR Plot No. 1480(p), 1483(p) & 1496(p), PO – Rakhajungle, PS – Kharagpur (T),
Kharagpur Municipal Ward No. 11 (Old No. 20), Dist – Paschim Mednipur, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex comprising of 8 Blocks of G+3 storied
residential blocks comprising of 273 residential flats. The project to be developed in 2 phases. In Phase II 8
nos. blocks will be vertically expanded upto G+8 storied and having total 728 residential flats for Phase I
and Phase II. Environmental Clearance is sought for the entire project.
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 6.094 acres as per Land schedule / 24661.565 sq.m
Expected Population : 4054 (including residential, floating and staff)
Total Water requirement : 616 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 369 KLD (Kharagpur Municipality supply)
Domestic Water requirement : 554 KLD
Wastewater generated : 443 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 8 of 25
Wastewater recycled : 234 KLD (flushing, landscaping and internal road washing)
Wastewater discharged : 165 KLD (to be discharged to municipal drainage)
Solid waste disposal : 2.38 tonnes per day (disposed off through Kharagpur Municipality)
Total Built-up Area : 73244.77 sqm. (including Phase I & Phase II)
Ground Coverage : 8560.88 sqm. (36.93% of land area)
Road & Pavement Area : 917.79 sqm. (3.96% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 5993.19 sqm. (25.87% of land area)
Green Area for Plantation : 3840.26 sqm. (16.57% of land area)
Soft Area : 5993.19 sqm. (25.87% of land area)
Car Parking Area : 3864.29 sqm. (16.67% of land area)
No. of Parking Spaces proposed : 448 (covered 218, Open 230)
No. of Trees to be planted : 340 nos.
Daily Power requirement : 2800 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (4x320 KVA)
RWH Details : Surface Storage – 4x100 KL storage tank
Subsurface Recharge – 4 recharge wells each having recharging
capacity 8 KL/day. Depth of recharge well – 60m bgl.
CSR Proposed : Rs. 28 lakhs. per year
Present status of the project : Not available
Name of the Environmental Consultant M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was put up for
consideration. After careful consideration of the presentation by the project proponent the committee
recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:-
1) Proposal for onsite compost plant for treatment of biodegradable fraction of MSW and earmarked the
location of the compost plant in conceptual plan.
2) Design of wastewater treatment facilities to be provided for the proposed project (phase I & II).
3) Proposal for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) to be formulated based on specific needs of the
locality.
The committee shall consider this application only after submission of the above mentioned clarifications.
4. Proposed Residential Complex “IDEAL GREENS” by M/s. Calcutta Infrastructure Infotech Projects
Ltd. at 591A, Motilal Gupta Road, KMC Ward No. 122, PS – Thakurpukur, Kolkata – 700008, West
Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of Residential Complex having 10 blocks of B+G+14 / B+G+15 /
B+G+16 / B+G+18 storied buildings with 852 no. of flats and club house of B+G+1.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 9 of 25
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 66060.201 sqm.
Expected Population : Total – 4403 persons (4264 – fixed, 605 – floating)
Total Water requirement : 692.375 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 444.83 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 533.456 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater discharged : 259.2 KLD (to KMC drain)
Wastewater recycled : 247.55 KLD (landscaping, car washing and flushing)
Solid waste disposal : 2.649 tonnes per day
Total Built-up Area : 135733.45 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 8168.75 sqm. (12.37% of land area)
Road Area : 15604.37 sqm. (23.62% of land area)
Open Parking Area : 278.64 sqm. (0.42% of land area)
Other Green Area : 20500.30 sqm. (31.03% of land area)
Swimming Pool Area : 337.25 sqm. (0.51% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 15385.77 sqm. (23.29% of land area)
Waterbody : 5785.12 sqm. (8.76% of land area)
Total no. of plantation
proposed
: 1077 nos.
No. of solar lights proposed : 18 nos.
No. of Parking spaces
proposed
: Total – 765 cars, (covered – 743, open – 22)
Total Power requirement : 3715 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (200 KVA x 8 & 100 KVA x 1)
RWH : Surface storage – 2 nos. storage tank 300 cum capacity each.
Recharge : 2 nos. recharge tube well 150 mm diameter each and depth
in the 90-102 m zone.
CSR proposal : Rs. 48,60,000/-
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Ghose, Bose & Associates Pvt. Ltd. The case is put up for
consideration. After careful consideration of the presentation by the project proponent the committee
recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:-
1) Proposal for onsite compost plant for treatment of biodegradable fraction of MSW and earmarked the
location of the compost plant in conceptual plan.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 10 of 25
2) Design of wastewater treatment facilities to be provided for the proposed project.
3) Proposal for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) to be formulated based on specific needs of the
locality.
The committee shall consider this application only after submission of the above mentioned clarifications.
5. Proposed Residential Complex "CHOWRINGHEE TOWER" by M/s. Chowringhee Residency Pvt.
Ltd. (previously M/s. Diamond Empire Estate Pvt. Ltd.) at 42B, J.L. Nehru Road, KMC Ward No.
63, PS – Shakespeare Sarani, Kolkata – 700071.
Activity:
Earlier this was a proposal for construction of an Office Complex (1 block of B+G+54 storied building and
1 block of B+G+2 storied building) having Offices, Restaurants, Service Block and Multi Level Car
Parking (MLCP).
The SEAC stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance for the proposed project in the 45th
meeting held on 03.08.2010.
Now the unit has submitted the copy of the building plan sanctioned by KMC for the proposed project on
22.02.2013 and placed in the 78th SEAC meeting held on 08.05.2013. During the meeting SEAC
recommended that as the scope of the project has been changed substantially, fresh form 1, form1A and
other relevant documents to be submitted.
The pp has accordingly submitted revised Form1, Form 1A and other relevant documents to the MoEF
which has been forwarded to SEIAA/SEAC for necessary action.
Salient features of the proposed revised project are -
As per SCEC dated 10.09.2010 As per sanctioned plan submitted
on 22.02.2013
Land Area : 3.55 acres (14365.457 sqm.) : 3.55 acres (14365.457 sqm.)
Proposal : Main Building - B+G+68 storied and
Heritage Building - G+2 storied
: Main Building - G+58+2 storied
and Heritage Building - G+2 storied
MLCP & Resident Activity Centre –
2B+G+7
Apartments : 101 : 57
Expected Population : 808 (fixed), 250 (floating) : 662 (fixed), 30 (maintenance)
Total Water requirement : 163 KLD (Operation stage) : 145.5 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 107 KLD (Operation stage, KMC
supply)
: 97 KLD (Operation stage, KMC
supply)
Wastewater generated : 111 KLD (to be treated in STP) : 109 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 56 KLD (to be reused after treatment
in STP)
: 48.5 KLD (to be reused after
treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged : 55 KLD (to be discharged to KMC
sewer after treatment in STP)
: 60.5 KLD (to be discharged to
KMC sewer after treatment in STP)
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 11 of 25
As per SCEC dated 10.09.2010 As per sanctioned plan submitted
on 22.02.2013
Solid waste disposal : 0.53 tonne per day (to be disposed off
through KMC)
: 0.33 tonne per day (to be disposed
off through KMC)
Total Built-up Area : 51776.239 sqm. : 63614.62 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 3211.538 sqm. (22.36% of land area) : 3804.26 sqm. (26.48% of land
area)
Landscaped Green Area : 2873 sqm. (20% of land area) : 3345 sqm. (23.28% of land area)
Other Soft Area : 4698.512 sqm. (32.67% of land area) : 3706 sqm. (25.81% of land area)
Paved Area : 3586.95 sqm. (24.97% of land area) : 3510 sqm. (24.43% of land area)
No. of Parking Spaces
proposed
: 465 (Covered – 209, Open – 256) : 486 (Covered)
Power requirement : 3000 KVA, CESC : 2777 KVA, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (2 x 1500 KVA) : DG Sets (2 x 1250 KVA)
Status : : This project is proposed as Green
Building
Name of the Environmental Consultant M/s. Envirotech East Pvt. Ltd. The case is put up for consideration.
After carefully considering the revised FORM I, FORM IA, Conceptual Plan including sanctioned plan by
KMC and presentation, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
6. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. LORD Real Estates Pvt. Ltd & Others at dag nos. 469, 476,
477, 478, 479, 480(P), 482, 483, 486, 487, 492(P), 493, 494, 495, 496, 547, 548 J.L No. 18, Mouza –
Mahisbathan, P.S – Rajarhat, Dist – 24 Pgs (N).
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 520 flats (6 blocks: Block1&6-
B+G+25, Block2- B+G+23, Block3-B+G+21, Block4-B+G+19, Block5- B+G+17 storied).
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are -
Land Area : 21372.676 sq.m
Expected Population : 3116 (Resident-2600, temporary-260, service-50, community
hall-256 seating capacity)
Total Water requirement : 570 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 310 KLD ((Bidhannagar Municipality supply)
Wastewater generated : 372 KLD
Treated Wastewater : 354 KLD
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 12 of 25
Wastewater recycled : 260 KLD
Wastewater discharged : 94 KLD (Municipal drain)
Solid waste disposal : 1.6 TPD
Total Built-up Area : 79711.529 sq.m as per MoEF
Ground Coverage : 4220.516 sq.m (19.71% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 5341.169 sq.m (24.99% of land area including service area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 4473.301 sq.m (20.92% of land area)
Total Green area : 11810.991 sq.m (55.26% of land area)
Service area : 365.37 sq.m (4.51% of land area)
Swimming pool :
No. of solar street lights proposed : 38 nos.
Total No. of plantation proposed : 315 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 429 nos.
Total Power requirement : 3436 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : 4x750 KVA
Name of the Environmental Consultant: M/s. Ghosh, Bose & Associates Pvt Ltd. The case is put up for
consideration. After careful consideration of the presentation by the project proponent the committee
recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:-
1) Proposal for onsite compost plant for treatment of biodegradable fraction of MSW and earmarked the
location of the compost plant in conceptual plan.
2) Design of wastewater treatment facilities to be provided for the proposed project.
3) Proposal for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) to be formulated based on specific needs of the
locality.
The committee shall consider this application only after submission of the above mentioned clarifications.
7. Proposed Housing Complex along with School by M/s. Tata Housing Development Company Ltd. at
Plot no. – IIG/7, Action Area II, New Town, Rajarhat, Kolkata -700156, 24 Pgs. (N), West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 568 flats [14 blocks: 3 residential
blocks (G+23), 3 residential blocks (G+29), 2 residential town homes(G+4), 2 residential courtyards homes
(G+1), 1school building and canteen (G+7), 1 club block (G+2), 1 podium (G), 1 amenities (G)]
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are -
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 13 of 25
Land Area : 52609 sq.m (13 acres)
Expected Population : 4494 (Residents - 2 990, temporary -1504)
Total Water requirement : 631 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 351 KLD ((NKDA supply)
Wastewater generated : 412 KLD
Treated Wastewater : 354 KLD (STP based on MBBR technology)
Wastewater recycled : 280 KLD (landscaping, car washing, dual flushing)
Wastewater discharged : 132 KLD (HIDCO drain)
Solid waste disposal : 2.26 TPD (Disposed of through NKDA)
Total Built-up Area : 147858.40 sq.m
Ground Coverage (including
beyond & above basement)
: 15868.60 sq.m (30.09% of land area)
Basement area : 16022.66 sq.m (30.46% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 6816.88 sq.m (12.96% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 11110.31 sq.m (21.12% of land area)
Total Green area : 12504.85 sq.m (23.77% of land area)
Service area (beyond basement) : 1396.02 sq.m (2.26% of land area)
No. of solar street lights proposed : 57 nos.
Total No. of plantation proposed : 740 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : Car – 1038 nos.(Covered-968, Open-70 nos) and bus 8
nos.(Open) Total Power requirement : 19050 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : 2x500 KVA, 2X380 KVA, 2X1000 KVA, 2X250 KVA &
2X200 KVA
Name of the Environmental Consultant M/s. Envirotech East Pvt. Ltd. The case is put up for consideration.
After careful consideration of the presentation by the project proponent the SEAC noted that the proposal has
been submitted under GRIHA rating and recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for
the proposed project.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 14 of 25
C. Note on Reconsideration Proposals
Construction Sector :-
1. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Classic Endeavour Pvt. Ltd. at Plot No. – 101(P), 102(P),
Khatian No. – 449, 451, Jl. No. - 2, Mouza – Dabgram, SMC Ward No. – 43, PS – Bhaktinagar, PO –
Siliguri, Dist. – Jalpaiguri.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 116 flats (2 blocks of B+ G+4 storied
buildings).
Chronology:
The SEAC stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance for the proposed project in the 66th
meeting held on 25.04.2012.
Now the unit has submitted the copy of the building plan sanctioned by the Siliguri Municipal Corporation
for the proposed project on 24.01.2014. The modified features of the proposed project are as follows: -
As per SCEC dated 04.06.2012 As per sanctioned plan submitted on
24.01.2014
Total Land Area : 10185.182 sq.m : 10185.182 sq.m
No. of Blocks : 2 nos. : 6 nos.
Expected Population : 680 (Residents: 580; service
staff:40 and floating population: 60)
: 680 (Residents: 580; service
staff:140 and floating population: 60)
Total Water requirement : 84 KLD : 84 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 59 KLD ( borewell supply) : 59 KLD ( borewell supply)
Wastewater generated : 47 KLD (to be treated in STP) : 47 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Treated wastewater from
STP
: 42 KLD (to be partially reused
after treatment in STP)
: 42 KLD (to be partially reused after
treatment in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 18 KLD : 18 KLD
Wastewater discharged : 24 KLD (to be discharged to
municipality drain after treatment in
STP)
: 24 KLD (to be discharged to
municipality drain after treatment in
STP)
Rain water harvesting : Storage - 100 KL & recharge-
1402 KL/annum
: Storage - 100 KL & recharge- 1402
KL/annum
Solid waste disposal : 0.342 TPD (disposed by Siliguri
Municipal Corporation)
: 0.342 TPD (disposed by Siliguri
Municipal Corporation)
Total Built-up Area : 23302.01 sqm. (including
parking)
: 23286.32 sqm. (including parking)
Maximum Height of the
Building
: 14.5 m : 14.5 m
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 15 of 25
As per SCEC dated 04.06.2012 As per sanctioned plan submitted on
24.01.2014
Ground Coverage : 4541.21 sq.m (44.59%) : 4537.56 sq.m (44.55%)
Exclusive Tree Plantation
Area
: 2254.30 sq.m (22.3% of land area) : 2254.30 sq.m (22.3% of land area)
Internal Road & Pavement
Area
: 1777.50 sq.m (17.45% of land
area)
: 1777.50 sq.m (17.45% of land area)
Min. No. of plantation
proposed
:150 nos. :150 nos.
No. of Parking spaces
proposed
: 197 nos.(covered -187, open-10) : 194 nos.(covered -185, open-9)
Min. No. of solar street
lights proposed
: 11 nos. solar operated LED lights : 11 nos. solar operated LED lights
Total Power requirement : 460 KW, WBSEDCL : 560 KW, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (2x 125 KVA) : DG Sets (2x 125 KVA & 1x63 KVA)
The name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case is put
up for reconsideration. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for
Environmental Clearance.
2. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Radiant Nirman Pvt. Ltd. at Jl. No. – 76, Mouza – Kalam, PS
& PO – Matigara, GP – Matigara I, Dist. – Darjeeling, Pin – 734010, West Bengal.
Activity:
This was a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 730 flats (21 nos. of residential
blocks of G+5 storied buildings) alongwith 1 block of G+2 storied Club / Community hall, G+2 storied of
school and Kala Kendra each.
Chronology:
The SEAC stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance for the proposed project in the 77th
meeting held on 26.03.2013.
Now the unit has submitted the copy of the sanctioned building plan for the proposed project on
02.01.2014. The modified features of the proposed project are as follows: -
As per SCEC dated 02.05.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted on
02.01.2014
Land Area : 8.19 acres (33143.478 sqm.) : As per deed 8.19 acres (33143.478
sqm.)
As per site- 8.18 acres(33114.526 sq.m)
Expected Population : 5644 persons (Permanent – 3650 &
Temporary – 1994 nos.)
: 5644 persons (Permanent – 3650 &
Temporary – 1994 nos.)
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 16 of 25
As per SCEC dated 02.05.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted on
02.01.2014
Total Water requirement : 681 KLD : 681 KLD
Fresh water requirement : 536 KLD (source-ground water) : 536 KLD (source-ground water)
Wastewater generated : 487 KLD (to be treated in STP &
discharged to panchayat drain )
: 487 KLD (to be treated in STP &
discharged to panchayat drain )
Waste water discharged : 342 KLD : 342 KLD
Wastewater recycled : 145 KLD : 145 KLD
Solid waste disposal : 2.6 TPD : 2.6 TPD
Total Built-up Area : 69370.13 sqm. (including
parking)
: 68098.55 sqm. (including parking)
Ground Coverage : 12050.02 sqm. (36.36% of land
area)
: 11626.16 sqm. (35.08% of land area)
Open Parking Area : 1603.13 sqm. (4.84% of land area) : 1603.13 sqm. (4.84% of land area)
Total paved area : 8215.778 sq.m (24.78 % of land
area)
: 8215.778 sq.m (24.78 % of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation
Area
: 6755.08 sqm. (20.38% of land area) : 6755.08 sqm. (20.38% of land area)
Other Green Area : 3522.1 sqm. (10.63% of land area) : 3522.1 sqm. (10.63% of land area)
Total Green area : 11581.06 sq.m (34.95 % of land
area)
: 11581.06 sq.m (34.95 % of land area)
Service Area : 878.17 sqm. (2.65% of land area) : 878.17 sqm. (2.65% of land area)
Swimming Pool Area : 386.21 sqm. (1.17% of land area) : 386.21 sqm. (1.17% of land area)
Temple Area : 32.24 sqm. (0.10% of land area) : 32.24 sqm. (0.10% of land area)
Total No. of plantation
proposed
: 500 nos. : 500 nos.
No. of Parking spaces
proposed
: 396 nos. (covered – 242 & Open –
154).
: 396 nos. (covered – 242 & Open –
154).
No. of solar street light : 68 nos. : 68 nos.
Total Power requirement : 1150 KVA, WBSEDCL : 1150 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (5x125 KVA) : DG Sets (5x125 KVA)
No. of storied 21 nos. of residential blocks of G+5
storied buildings) alongwith 1 block
of G+2 storied Club / Community
hall, G+2 storied of school and Kala
Kendra each.
21 nos. of residential blocks of G+5
storied buildings) alongwith 1 block of
G+2 storied Club / Community hall.
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Envirotech East Pvt. Ltd. The case is put up for
reconsideration. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental
Clearance.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 17 of 25
3. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Swastik Projects Pvt. Ltd. at Premises No. 46A/1, Biplabi
Barin Ghosh Sarani (formerly an apportioned portion of Premises No. 46A, Biplabi Barin Ghosh
Sarani), PO – Ultadanga, PS – Maniktala, KMC Ward No. 14, Kolkata – 700 067, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for Residential Complex comprising of residential block of B+G+ 11 storied building,
community blocks 2 storied and Club. Residential Complex has 185 nos. flats.
Chronology:
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 79th
SEAC meeting held on 28.12.2013. The State
Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the 79th
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 27.01.2014 from the unit is given below :-
Directions of the Committee dated
07.01.2014
Response of the Proponent 27.01.2014
1. Proposal for Inhouse MSW management. 1) Inhouse MSW management plan consisting of
segregated chamber for storage of biodegradable
and non-biodegradable waste facilities submitted.
2. Proposal for recycle of waste water to
reduce fresh water consumption along with
necessary treatment scheme.
2) The proponent submitted proposal for onsite STP
consisting of upflow anaerobic baffle reactor and
modified water balance with waste water recycle.
3. Revised CSR proposal. 3) The proponent mentioned that the CSR
commitment will be 2% of the project cost i.e.
Rs. 44 lakhs for five years.
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 9474 sqm.
Expected Population : 1045 (Residents – 925, Floating – 100, Service Staff – 20)
Total water requirement : 160 KLD
Fresh water requirement : 141 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 113 KLD
Wastewater discharged : 77 KLD (to be discharged to KMC drainage)
Waste water treated : 90 KLD
Wastewater recycled : 13 KLD (Landscaping)
Wastewater disposal : 77 KLD
Solid waste disposal : 0.53 Tonnes per day
Total Built-up Area : 21631.19 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 2568.75 sqm. (27.11% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 1898.78 sqm. (20.04 % of land area)
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 18 of 25
Internal Road & Pavement
(Paved area)
: 1216.00 sqm. (12.84 % of land area)
Existing Waterbody : 2427.97 sqm. (25.63% of land area)
Surface Car parking (Semi
Paved Area)
: 1362.50 sqm. (14.38% of land area)
No. of plantation proposed : 180 nos. (including 5 nos. trees to be retained)
No. of solar street lights
proposed
: 10 nos. (25%)
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 181 (covered – 72, open – 109)
Total Power requirement : 700 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (3x125 KVA)
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case is put up for
reconsideration. After careful consideration the SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental
clearance for the project.
4. Proposed Residential cum Commercial Complex “TIRUPATI PARADISE” by M/s. Tirupati Awas
Pvt. Ltd. at Jl. No. – 70, Mouza – Elaichi, Jl. No. – 71, Mouza – Jaggadal, PO & Vill. – Dakshin
Jaggadal (Shyam Khola More), PS – Sonarpur, Dr. B.C. Roy Road, Holding No. – 245, Rajpur
Sonarpur Municipality Ward no. – 26, Kolkata – 700151, Dist. – 24 Parganas (South).
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential cum Commercial Complex having 302 flats (21 blocks
of G+4 storied buildings).
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 15545.54 sqm (3.84 acres.)
Expected Population : 1813 persons
Total Water requirement : 294 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 272 KLD (Rajpur Sonarpur Municipality supply)
Wastewater generated : 245 KLD (to be discharged to municipal sewer)
Wastewater discharged : 213 KLD (after treatment in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 22 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
Solid waste disposal : 1295 kg per day (to be disposed off through local authority)
Total Built-up Area : 35123.59 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 6870.52 sqm. (44.19% of land area)
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 19 of 25
Total Paved Area : 3781.85 sqm. (24.33% of land area)
Total Green Area / Exclusive
Tree Plantation Area
: 3113.07 sqm. (20.04% of land area)
Open Area : 1780.10 sqm. (11.45% of land area)
No. of plantation proposed : 220 nos. (existing trees/ shrubs are 100 nos out of which 69 to be
retained)
No. of solar powered lights : 37 nos.
No. of Parking spaces
proposed
: 236 (Covered)
Total Power requirement : 1763 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (3x250 KVA, 1x380 KVA and 2x200 KVA)
RWH : Recharge 1237 KL, 5 nos. recharge pits, Recharge Pit dia 3 m and
depth 2 m.
Storage 2061 KL through 8 nos. rain water storage tanks having total
capacity of 378.36 KL.
CSR : Rs. 40 lakhs.
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 71st SEAC meeting held on 24.09.2012. The State
Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the 71st
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 09.04.2013 from the unit is given below :–
Directions of the Committee dated
12.10.2012
Response of the Proponent 26.03.2013
1. Rainwater harvesting calculations to be
resubmitted as per SEAC guidelines.
1. The pp mentioned that UGR capacity for storage
of rainwater is 378 KL, there will be 08 nos
storage tanks. Proposed number of recharge pits
05 nos. of 3m dia and 2m effective depth which
will recharge 1237 KL of rainwater harvested
during the monsoon.
2. Permission to be obtained from
concerned authority for sourcing water
from borewell during construction phase.
2. The pp submitted copy of permission letter dated
22.01.2013 for construction of borewell issued by
the Chairman, Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality.
3. CSR programme to be modified based on
need assessment of local community,
sanitation programme for nearby schools
may be included.
3. The pp submitted revised CSR proposal with
financial commitment of approximately Rs. 40
lacs.
4. Fly ash based construction materials to
be used as per prevalent norms.
4. The pp mentioned that there will be 100% fly ash
brick utilization i.e. 44,40,000 nos.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 20 of 25
Directions of the Committee dated
12.10.2012
Response of the Proponent 26.03.2013
5. Since the project is situated within 10
kms from Chintamoni Kar Wildlife
Sanctuary, a map duly authenticated by
Chief Wildlife Warden showing this
feature vis-à-vis the project location and
the recommendations or comments of the
Chief Wildlife Warden thereon should be
submitted
5. The proponent has submitted required documents
to Chief Wild Life Warden vide letter dt.
20.11.2012 and subsequent follow up letters dated
04.03.2013, 06.03.2013 and 19.03.2013. But they
have not yet received any response in this regard.
The SEIAA, WB has forwarded the copy of letter vide no. 1330/WL/2W-550/12 dated 28.03.2013 received
from Principal Chief Conservator of Forests Wildlife and Chief Wildlife Warden, West Bengal. The letter
mentions that the proposed site falls within 1.5 KM (by road) from Chintamani Kar Bird Sanctuary,
Narendrapur.
The PP submitted on 02.05.2013, a modified copy of permission letter dated 02.05.2013 for construction of
borewell issued by the Chairman, Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality.
The letters of the project proponent dated 26.03.2013 and 02.05.2013 and also the letter of Chief Wildlife
Warden, West Bengal dated 28.03.2013 has been considered in the 78th SEAC meeting held on 08.05.2013.
SEAC recommended that :-
Directions of the Committee dated
21.05.2013
Response of the Proponent dated 06.02.2014
1. Recommendations and comments of Chief
Wildlife Warden as per EIA Notification,
2006 and its amendment to be obtained.
1. The pp submitted the copy of recommendations
from the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests,
Wildlife and Chief Wildlife Warden, West Bengal
that the proposed project is about 1.5 km from the
Chintamanikar Bird Sanctuary and it is beyond the
eco-sensitive zone of Chintamanikar Bird
Sanctuary. Therefore, in the present situation there
is no objection against the project.
2. Specific permission for water supply to be
obtained from the competent authority.
2. The pp has submitted the copy of permission from
the Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality for water supply.
The pp also proposed to install mechanical
composter for management of organic component
of MSW and inorganic inert material will be
disposed off in the MSW management facility of
the Municipality as per concurrence of Rajpur-
Sonarpur Municipality.
The case is put up for reconsideration. After careful consideration the SEAC recommended stipulated
conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 21 of 25
5. Proposed Residential Complex „Eternia‟ by M/s. Concast Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. at JL No. 07, Ward
no. 58 under KMC, Borough – VII, P.S-Tiljala, Kolkata – 700 046.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 110 flats (1 block of B+G+31 storied).
Chronology:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 8105.85 sq.m (2.003 acre)
Expected Population : 1005 (Permanent- 660, temporary-345)
Total Water requirement : 156 KLD (KMC supply)
Fresh Water requirement : 156 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 106 KLD
Treated Wastewater : Nil
Wastewater recycled : Nil
Wastewater discharged : 106 KLD
Solid waste disposal : 0.52 TPD
Total Built-up Area : 29829.22 sq.m
Ground Coverage (basement ) : 2886.155 sq.m (35.61% of land area)
Total Paved Area (beyond
basement)
: 2013.462 sq.m (24.83% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 1686.058 sq.m (20.8% of land area)
Total Green area : 2840.863 sq.m (35.05% of land area)
Service area : 365.37 sq.m (4.51% of land area)
Open parking area (beyond
basement)
: 969.35 sq.m (11.96% of land area)
Semi paved area : 1340.260 sq.m (16.54% of land area)
No. of solar street lights proposed : 31 nos.
Total No. of plantation proposed : 114 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 220 nos.(Open-93, Covered at ground floor-27, Basement-
100) Total Power requirement : 1099 KVA
Backup Power : 2x500 KVA
Chronology:
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 80th
SEAC meeting held on 18.01.2014. The State
Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the 80th
SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 12.02.2014 from the unit is given below :–
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 22 of 25
Directions of the Committee dated
03.02.2014
Response of the Proponent 12.02.2014
1. Provision of waste water treatment facility
and recycle of treated waste water to
minimise fresh water consumption.
1. The pp has mentioned that the STP based FAB
technology followed by tertiary treatment will be
provide to maximize the treated waste water reuse
in flushing system, car washing and landscaping.
PP submitted the revised water balance statement
along with process flow sheet.
2. Details of Corporate Social Responsibility
(CSR) with financial commitment as
discussed during the said meeting.
2. The pp submitted revised CSR proposal with
financial commitment of approximately Rs. 60
lakhs for three years.
Name of the Environmental Consultant is not mentioned. The case is put up for consideration. After careful
consideration the SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
Summaries of above decisions are also provided in Table-1.
Table-1 : List of the projects which were placed before the SEAC in the eighty first meeting held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. and the Summary Decisions thereof:
A Miscellaneous cases
Sl.
No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. M/s. Gagan Ferro Tech Ltd.
Proposed expansion project for 3x20 MT Induction
Furnace with caster and 2000 TPM Wire Drawing
unit at Jamuria Industrial Estate, Vill & PO – Ikra,
Dist – Burdwan.
Noted & forwarded to SEIAA for appraisal
at MoEF as per EIA Notification, 2006 and
its amendment.
2. M/s. Shakambhari Ispat & Power Ltd.
Proposed expansion project for 0.9 MTPA Coal
Washery at Vill – Madandih, PO – Bartoria, Dist –
Purulia, PIN – 723 121.
Noted & forwarded to SEIAA for appraisal
at MoEF as per EIA Notification, 2006 and
its amendment.
3. M/s. Advance Surfactants India Ltd.
Proposed expansion of unit for manufacturing of
Linear Alkyl Benzene Sulphonic Acid (LABSA)
with the application of new technology in its existing
plant premises at Dag No. 252 & 432, Vill & PO –
Kaswarah, PS – Polba, Dist – Hooghly, PIN-
712102, West Bengal.
Activity falls under 5(f) category of the
Schedule and obtain Environmental
Clearance from appropriate authority as per
EIA Notification, 2006 and its amendment
4. M/s. Lingraj Properties Pvt. Ltd. & Others
Proposed Residential Complex at JL No. 48, Mouza
– Kumrakhali, PO – Narendrapur, PS – Sonarpur,
Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality, Kolkata – 700 103,
Dist – South 24 Parganas.
Matter is subjudice (Ref : C.O. No. 3698 of
2013 and 3699 of 2013 in the High Court at
Calcutta Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Appellate Side). Project proponent to be
informed accordingly.
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 23 of 25
B Cases placed for presentation
Sl.
No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. M/s. Lafarge India Pvt. Ltd., Mejia Cement Plant
Proposed expansion of Cement Grinding Unit at Jl.
No. – 41, Vill. – Amdanga, Mouza – Nandanpur,
PS – Gangajalghati, PO – MTPS (DVC), Dist. -
Bankura, Pin – 722183, West Bengal.
Modified Terms of Reference (ToR)
Recommended
2. M/s. West Bengal Mineral Development & Trading
Corporation Ltd.
Proposed Palsara-II Blackstone Mine project at
Mouza – Palsara, JL No. 121, Plot No. 2681, PS –
Kashipur, Dist – Purulia, West Bengal.
Recommended final Environmental
Clearance
3. M/s. Damodar Ropeways & Infra Ltd.
Proposed aerial rope way project at plot no. 792,
799, 800, 2746, 807, 819, 820, 821, J.L no. 78, Vill
– Paschim Gadadharpur, Amarabati Park, Digha
under DSDA, Dist – Purba Medinipur West
Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
4. Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority
(KMDA)
Proposal for the proposed 4 lane flyover from
Ramnagar More (Garden Reach Road) to Remount
Road (near Katapukur Morgue).
Recommended for exemption from
obtaining Environmental Clearance
5. State Bank of India
Proposed construction of State Bank Institute of
Management at plot no. IIF/2, Action area-II, New
Town, P.S-Rajarhat, Dist-24 Pgs (N).
Recommended Stipulated Conditions for
Environmental Clearance
6. M/s. Vivek Realty & Resorts Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex at Mouza –
Malancha, JL No. 131, Plot No. 1480(p), 1482 (p)
& 1496 (p), PO – Rakhajungle, PS – Kharagpur
(T), Kharagpur Municipal Ward No. 11 (Old No.
20), Dist – Paschim Mednipur, West Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
7. M/s. Calcutta Infrastructure Infotech Projects Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex “IDEAL GREENS”
at 591A, Motilal Gupta Road, KMC Ward No. 122,
PS – Thakurpukur, Kolkata – 700008, West
Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
8. M/s. Chowringhee Residency Pvt. Ltd. (previously
M/s. Diamond Empire Estate Pvt. Ltd.)
Proposed Residential Complex "CHOWRINGHEE
TOWER" at 42B, J.L. Nehru Road, KMC Ward
No. 63, PS – Shakespeare Sarani, Kolkata –
700071.
Recommended final Environmental
Clearance
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 24 of 25
B Cases placed for presentation
Sl.
No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
9. M/s. LORD Real Estates Pvt. Ltd & Others
Proposed Residential Complex at dag nos. 469, 476,
477, 478, 479, 480(P), 482, 483, 486, 487, 492(P),
493, 494, 495, 496, 547, 548 J.L No. 18, Mouza –
Mahisbathan, P.S - Rajarhat, Dist-24 Pgs (N).
Asked for additional submission
10. M/s. Tata Housing Development Company Ltd.
Proposed Housing Complex along with School at Plot
no. – IIG/7, Action Area II, New Town, Rajarhat,
Kolkata - 700 156, 24 Pgs. (N), West Bengal.
Recommended Stipulated Conditions
for Environmental Clearance
C Cases placed for consideration of Environment
Clearance
Sl.
No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. M/s. Classic Endeavour Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex at Plot No. – 101(P),
102(P), Khatian No. – 449, 451, Jl. No. - 2, Mouza –
Dabgram, SMC Ward No. – 43, PS – Bhaktinagar,
PO – Siliguri, Dist. – Jalpaiguri, West Bengal.
Recommended final Environmental
Clearance
2. M/s. Radiant Nirman Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex at Jl. No. – 76, Mouza
– Kalam, PS & PO – Matigara, GP – Matigara I, Dist.
– Darjeeling, Pin – 734010, West Bengal.
Recommended final Environmental
Clearance
3. M/s. Swastik Projects Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex at Premises No.
46A/1, Biplabi Barin Ghosh Sarani (formerly an
apportioned portion of Premises No. 46A, Biplabi
Barin Ghosh Sarani), PO – Ultadanga, PS –
Maniktala, KMC Ward No. 14, Kolkata – 700 067,
West Bengal.
Recommended Stipulated Conditions for
Environmental Clearance
4. M/s. Tirupati Awas Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential cum Commercial Complex
“TIRUPATI PARADISE” at Jl. No. – 70, Mouza –
Elaichi, Jl. No. – 71, Mouza – Jaggadal, PO & Vill. –
Dakshin Jaggadal (Shyam Khola More), PS –
Sonarpur, Dr. B.C. Roy Road, Holding No. – 245,
Rajpur Sonarpur Municipality Ward no. – 26,
Kolkata – 700151, Dist. – 24 Parganas (South).
Recommended Stipulated Conditions for
Environmental Clearance
Minutes of the 81st meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on
14.02.2014 at 15:00 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
Page 25 of 25
C Cases placed for consideration of Environment
Clearance
Sl.
No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
5. M/s. Concast Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex „ETERNIA‟ at JL No.
07, Ward no. 58 under KMC, Borough – VII, P.S-
Tiljala, Kolkata-700046.
Recommended Stipulated Conditions for
Environmental Clearance
The meeting ended with a note of thanks to the Chair.
(Prof. (Dr.) Sudarshan Neogi)
Chairman
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Prof. Jayanta Bhattacharya)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Dr. Kalyan Rudra)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Dr. Satya Kinkar Pal)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Prof. Bhabatosh Biswas)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Prof. (Dr.) Swadesh Ranjan Raychaudhuri)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Dr. Anita Chattopadhyay Gupta)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Dr. Amitava Roy)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(Dr. Arunkanti Biswas)
Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(P. K. Sarkar)
Secretary
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal