MINUTES OF THE 56TH MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF ... _held_in_Goa_30.8.2016.pdf · Singh, Dr....

1

MINUTES OF THE 56TH MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 30TH AUGUST, 2016 AT GOA.

Present

1. Dr.Ramjee Singh - President

2. Dr.Arun Bhasme - Vice-President

3. Dr.Manilal S. - Member

4. Dr.Mridul Kumar Sahani - ”

5. Dr.Kulwant Singh - ”

6. Dr.Narayan Debnath - ”

7. Dr.A.P.Verma - ”

8. Dr. Vinod Kumar - ”

9. Dr. N.Srinivasa Rao - ”

10. Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma - ”

11. Dr.Birendra Bahadur Singh Nawab - ”

12. Dr. Sampath Rao - ”

12. Dr.K.K.Juneja - ”

14. Dr.Shyamal Kumar Mukherjee - ”

15. Dr.S.K.Nanda - ”

16. Dr.A.K. Seth - ”

17. Dr.S.M.Singh - ”

18. Dr.(Mrs.) K.S.Desarda - ”

19. Dr.(Mrs.)Ayesha Ali - ”

20. Dr.S. M. Desarada - ”

21. Dr. Pawan H. Dongre - ”

22. Dr.L.K.Nanda - ”

23. Dr.Dias Dominic Savio - ”

24. Dr.Chandan Kumar Das - ”

25. Dr.P.K.Satapathy - ”

26. Dr.Parul J.Patel - ”

27. Dr.Bhosale Shivadas - ”

28. Dr.Bhosale Ravindra Namdeo - ”

29. Dr. Tejinder Pal Singh -

30. Dr.Mohammad Zakharia - ”

31. Dr.G.Kannan - ”

32. Dr.B.T.Rudresh - ”

33. Dr.Neelam K.Trivedi - ”

34. Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval - ”

35. Dr.Mrinal Kanti Sarkar - ”

36. Dr.Bhakt Vatsal - ”

37. Dr.Rajat Chattopadhyay - ”

38. Dr.Biplab Kumar Kundu - ”

39. Dr.Rajesh Sharma - ”

40. Dr.Nandini Sharma - ”

41. Dr. Konkani Shrikant Basavanni - ”

Dr.Lalit Verma - Secretary

2

Not Present

1. Dr.Prasobh Kumar K.C. - Member

2. Dr.Ashutosh Bhardwaj - ”

3. Dr. (Smt.) N. Radha - ”

4. Dr. Rakesh Singh - ”

5. Dr. R. K. Manchanda - ”

6. Dr. A. L. Patil - ”

7. Dr. Ravi M. Nair - ”

8. Dr. Teli Hotu Comdir - ”

9. Dr. Choudhary Dayaram Bondkuji - ”

10. Dr. Jayesh K. Patel - ”

11. Dr. Girish S. Patel - ”

12. Dr. Kishor Onkarrao Malokar - ”

13. Dr. Atul Kumar Singh - ”

The Members namely, Dr. Aushutosh Bhardwaj, Dr. Rakesh Singh, Dr. Dayaram Choudhary

Bondkuji, Dr. Girish S. Patel, Dr. A. L. Patil, Dr. Prasobh Kumar K.C. Dr. Atul Kumar

Singh, Dr. Ravi M. Nair, Dr. R. K. Manchanda, Dr. N. Radha and Dr. Kishor Onkarrao

Malokar informed their respective inability to attend the meeting.

The Central Council appreciated the contributions of Dr. Pinkin N. Trivedi in

the Council whose membership seized on 31.03.2016.

The Hon’ble Minister of State (I/c), Ministry of AYUSH, Govt. of India, Sh.

Shripad Yesso Nayak Ji graced the meeting of Central Council. He paid his tributes to Dr. Samual Hahnemann, the founder of Homoeopathy. The

Members of Central Council namely, Dr. Rajesh Sharma, Dr. S. M. Desarda,

Dr. B. T. Rudresh, Dr. Tejinder Pal Singh, Dr. Rajat Chattopadhyay, Dr. Pawan Dongre, raised the points before the Hon’ble Minister about delay in grant of permission to

Homoeopathic Medical Colleges for admission for 2016-17, and they objected about

the conduct of surprise inspections of colleges by the authority of Ministry without having any statutory right. The Vice-President, CCH also raised the

said matter before the Hon’ble Minister. The President, CCH informed the

Hon’ble Minister that during his tenure it is the first time that Meeting of

Central Council is taking place outside Delhi that too in the home town of Hon’ble Minister. The President informed that the former Secretary in

Ministry of AYUSH has told the Parliamentry Standing Committee that the

Ministry has no authority to close the colleges but the inspection teams of Central Govt. are virtually raiding the colleges and highlighting only the

negative points. He questioned about the policy of the Central Govt. in this

regard. He pleaded with the Hon’ble Minister that if immediate decision is not taken by the Ministry regarding admission of students in Homoeopathic

Colleges for 2016-17, the managements and college authorities will suffer a

lot and it shall have adverse effect also on the profession. The Secretary of Council with the approval of Chair, also briefed the Hon’ble Minister and the

Council about a few pending important administrative matters of CCH in the

Ministry. The Hon’ble Minister in his speech told that he has already

3

spoken to concerned officers in the Ministry and assured that he will again impress upon them for an early decision. He also expressed his unhappiness

the way the surprise inspections are being conducted by the Ministry’s

authorities.

Agenda Item No. 56.1

CCoonnffiirrmmaattiioonn ooff tthhee mmiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 5555tthh mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 1155tthh FFeebbrruuaarryy,, 22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..

CCoorrrriiggeenndduumm ttoo tthhee MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 5555tthh mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff


The Central Council confirmed the minutes of its last meeting (including the

corrigendum), as circulated.


NNoottee ooff ddeesscceenntt aaggaaiinnsstt tthhee AAccttiioonn iinn rreessppeecctt ooff mmiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 5544tthh mmeeeettiinngg

ooff CC..CC..HH.. hheelldd oonn 1111tthh AAuugg,, 22001155 hheelldd aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii wwiitthh rreeffeerreennccee ttoo aannyy ootthheerr

AAggeennddaa iitteemm NNoo..88..

&

Agenda Item No. 56.2A

MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..ZZ..1166001111//1166//22001166--EEPP((HH)) ddaatteedd 1144..0066..22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg

CCoommppllaaiinntt ooff DDrr.. PP.. KK.. SSaattaappaatthhyy rreeggaarrddiinngg vviioollaattiioonn ooff CCCCHH AAcctt uunnddeerr sseeccttiioonn

99,, 1177 && 1188 bbyy tthhee CCCCHH OOffffiicciiaallss..

The Central Council decided to give an opportunity to Dr. P. K. Satpathy, Member to relook into both matters and make available his views to the

President within 30 days time. Objections of Dr. P.K. Satpathy are enclosed.


AAccttiioonn ttaakkeenn iinn rreessppeecctt ooff tthhee mmiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 5555tthh mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall

CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 1155tthh FFeebbrruuaarryy,, 22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..

CCoorrrriiggeenndduumm ttoo tthhee MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 5555tthh mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff


The Central Council noted the Action Taken Report on the decisions

reflected in the minutes of its last meeting.

Agenda Item No. 56.4 DDrraafftt AAnnnnuuaall RReeppoorrtt ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy ffoorr tthhee yyeeaarr 22001155--1166..

The Central Council approved the draft annual report for the year 2015-16.

4


ookkff’’kkZZdd yyss[[kkkk 22001155&&1166 oo’’kkZZ ddss ffyy,,AA

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Commiittee for

approval of annual accounts of the Council under Plan & Non-Plan respectively for the year 2015-16 which have been sent to DGACR and

Ministry for further action. Agenda Item No. 56.6 MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..RR--1133004400//8822//22001122--HHDD((TTeecchh)) ddaatteedd 88..1100..1155 rreeggaarrddiinngg

aammeennddmmeennttss pprrooppoosseedd iinn HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ((IInnssppeeccttoorrss &&

VViissiittoorrss)) RReegguullaattiioonnss,, 11998822..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in respect

of amendments to Inspectors & Visitors Regulations on which further action

may be taken.


MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo--RR--1133004400//2288//22001155--HHDD((TTeecchh)) ddaatteedd 2266..1111..22001155 rreecceeiivveedd

ffrroomm DDiirreeccttoorr,, MMiinniissttrryy ooff AAYYUUSSHH,, rreeggaarrddiinngg HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc PPrraaccttiittiioonneerrss

((PPrrooffeessssiioonnaall CCoonndduucctt,, EEttiiqquueettttee aanndd CCooddee ooff EEtthhiiccss)) RReegguullaattiioonnss,, 11998822..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter. Objection of Dr. P.K. Satpathy is enclosed.

Agenda Item No. 56.8 ((aa)) MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo.. RR..1133004400//112244//22001133--HHDD((TTeecchh)) ddaatteedd 1100..0022..22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg

aammeennddmmeenntt iinn HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ((MMiinniimmuumm RReeqquuiirreemmeenntt ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc CCoolllleeggeess aanndd aattttaacchheedd HHoossppiittaallss)) RReegguullaattiioonnss,, 22001133..

((bb)) MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo.. RR..1133004400//0011//22001155--EEPP ddaatteedd 1177..0022..22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg

aammeennddmmeenntt iinn HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ((MMiinniimmuumm RReeqquuiirreemmeenntt ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc CCoolllleeggeess aanndd aattttaacchheedd HHoossppiittaallss)) RReegguullaattiioonnss,, 22001133..

The Central Council approved the amendments alongwith justifications in

respect of HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013.


CCoonnssiiddeerraattiioonn ooff RREE ffoorr tthhee yyeeaarr 22001166--1177 aanndd BBEE ffoorr tthhee yyeeaarr 22001177--22001188 rreessppeeccttiivveellyy

uunnddeerr PPllaann && NNoonn--PPllaann..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee regarding

RE for 2016-17 and BE for 2017-18 respectively under Plan & Non-Plan and

it noted that the said estimates does not include the provision for payment

of arrears/salary in terms of 7th CPC.

5


ggkkssEE;;kkssiiSSFFkkhh ddssUUnnzzhh;; iiffjj’’kknn~~ iiaatthhddjj..kk ffooffuu;;eekkssaa eessaa llaa””kkkkss//kkuu

cckkccrr~~AA

The Central Council ratified the proposed amendments in Registration

Regulation by the Registration Committee. Agenda Item No. 56.11 MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..ZZ..1166001111//0011//22001122--EEPP((HH)) ddaatteedd 2222..0022..22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg ttoo pprroocceessss

tthhee ccaassee ffoorr iissssuuaannccee//nnoonn iissssuuaannccee ooff LLeetttteerr ooff iinntteenntt ((LLooll)) aanndd LLeetttteerr ooff ppeerrmmiissssiioonn

((LLooPP)) ttoo tthhee HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy ccoolllleeggee iinn rreessppeecctt ttoo tthhee aapppplliiccaattiioonn rreecceeiivveedd uunnddeerr sseeccttiioonn

1122AA ffoorr eessttaabblliisshhmmeenntt ooff nneeww ccoolllleeggee,, ooppeenniinngg ooff nneeww oorr hhiigghheerr ccoouurrssee ooff ssttuuddyy oorr

ttrraaiinniinngg aanndd iinnccrreeaassee ooff aaddmmiissssiioonn ccaappaacciittyy bbyy eexxiissttiinngg CCoolllleeggeess –– rreegg..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 56.12.A.

CCoonnssiiddeerraattiioonn ooff IInnssppeeccttiioonn rreeppoorrtt ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc CCoolllleeggeess,, MMeeddiiccaall CCoolllleeggeess uunnddeerr

SSeeccttiioonn 1122AA ooff HHCCCC AAcctt,, 11997733..

CCoonnssiiddeerraattiioonn ooff ccaasseess ffoorr iissssuueess ooff LLooPP bbyy tthhee MMiinniissttrryy ffoorr pprroocceessssiinngg aapppplliiccaattiioonnss

rreecceeiivveedd uunnddeerr SSeeccttiioonn 1122AA ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill AAcctt dduurriinngg 22001155--22001166..

56.12.B

The Central Council noted the status of various colleges so far as

recommendations for issue of LoP/ LoI/ continuation of course are concerned. However, the Central Council decided that actions being taken

as reflected in the agenda note, must be completed on priority basis, if any

still pending.


MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..RR--1133004400//1100//22001111--HHDD((TTeecchh)) ddaatteedd 1111..33..22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg

ccoonnssiiddeerraattiioonn ooff IInnssppeeccttiioonn rreeppoorrttss ccaarrrriieedd oouutt aafftteerr 3311..1122..22001144 aass ppeerr

pprroovviissiioonnss ooff rreegguullaattiioonn ((33)) ((44)),, ((55)) aanndd ((99)) ooff HHCCCC ((MMSSRR)) RReegguullaattiioonnss,, 22001133..

The Central Council ratified the recommendations made on inspection

reports to Ministry regarding grant of permission for admission of students

for 2016-17 or otherwise.

The Members expressed their deep concern on the delay in taking a decision

by the Central Govt. for grant of permission to the colleges for making

admission for 2016-17 session.

6

The Members of the Council also expressed their anguish on the conduct of surprise inspection by Ministry of AYUSH, Govt. of India of some colleges for

which H.C.C. Act does not authorise the Ministry.

The Central Council authorise the President to ensure that status of the

colleges of which reports of inspection has been received at a later date, may

also be sent to Ministry on priority basis.


RReeqquueessttss rreecceeiivveedd uunnddeerr sseeccttiioonn 1122AA ooff HHCCCC AAcctt,, 11997733 dduurriinngg tthhee yyeeaarr 22001166--

22001177..

The Central Council noted the status of applications received in terms of the

provisions of Section 12A of HCC Act, 1973 and decided that the applications which are deficient in respect of (a) application not received in

prescribed form or unsigned (b) application fee not received (c) NOC in

specified format not issued by respective State Govt. (d) consent of affiliation in prescribed format is not received from concerned University (e)

documents regarding ownership of land or leased land not received, and (f)

the documents are not attested by a gazetted officer may be rejected and informed to Central Govt. stating that application for want of said

documents or fee has not been found eligible. However, before taking the

said action one communication showing the deficiency may be sent to the

applicant concerned and the applicant may be given a specific time limit to do the needful.

It noted the fate of application of Parsar Homoeopathic Hospital & College, Bhopal.

The report of inspection of Sayali Charitable Trust College of Homoeopathy, Aurangabad is considered, and the Central Council decided to recommend

for issue of LoI to it for admission of 100 intake capacity in 1st year B.H.M.S.

Course for 2017-18 provided that it appoints Readers in subjects of Anatomy, Pharmacy and Materia Medica and Lecturer in Physiology; and

appoints one more Library Assistant besides providing a Clinical Laboratory

in its attached Homoeopathic Hospital alongwith diagnostic machines like X-ray, ECG and USG as well as Operation Theatre and Labor Room (in

functioning order). The College also be asked to appoint Surgeon,

Obstetrician/Gynaecologist in its Homoeopathic Hospital faculty and ensure

catering service in Hospital.

The Central Council considered the report of inspection of S.S. Agarwal

Homoeopathic Medical College and it decided to recommend for issue of LoI for admission of 100 students in 1st B.H.M.S. Course for 2017-18 subject to

appointment of Readers in subject of Anatomy, Physiology, Organon of

Medicine and Lecturer in Pharmacy subject for which no consent is reported. However College needs to appoint all teaching faculty in five

subjects of 1st BHMS Course for the purpose of LoP besides providing X-ray

7

and USG in its Homoeopathic Hospital and appointing obstetrician/ Gynaecologist as well as Pathologist/ Biochemist and X-ray Technician/

Radiographer in its Hospital Staff. It needs to appoint one more Library

Assistant. Dissection Table needs to be added in Anatomy for meeting the prescribed requirements.


RReeqquueessttss rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm uunnddeerr SSeeccttiioonn 1122AA ooff HHCCCC AAcctt ffoorr HHiigghheerr CCoouurrsseess..

The Central Council noted the status of applications received in terms of the provisions of Section 12A of HCC Act, 1973 and decided that the

applications which are deficient in respect of (a) application not received in

prescribed format or unsigned (b) application fee not received (c) NOC in specified format not issued by respective State Govt. (d) consent of affiliation

in prescribed format is not received from concerned University (e)

documents regarding ownership of land or leased land not received, and (f)

the documents are not attested by a gazetted officer may be rejected and informed to Central Govt. stating that application for want of said

documents or fee has not been found eligible. However, before taking the

said action one communication showing the deficiency may be sent to the applicant concerned and the applicant may be given a specific time limit to

do the needful. In case any advise or clarification has been requested for,

from Central Govt. and inspite one or two reminders reply is not received then the application may be returned back to Ministry stating that the

Council has not been in a position to complete its action for want of reply/

information from the Central Govt.


RReeqquueessttss rreecceeiivveedd uunnddeerr SSeeccttiioonn 1122AA ooff HHCCCC AAcctt ffoorr iinnccrreeaassee ooff SSeeaattss iinn UU..GG..

CCoouurrsseess..

The Central Council noted the status of applications received in terms of the

provision of Section 12A of HCC Act, 1973 and decided that the applications which are deficient in respect of (a) application not received in prescribed

format or unsigned (b) application fee not received (c) NOC in specified

format not issued by the State Govt. (d) consent of affiliation in prescribed format is not received from concerned University (e) documents regarding

ownership of land or leased land not received, and (f) the documents are not

attested by a gazetted officer may be rejected and informed to Central Govt. stating that application for want of said documents or fee has not been

found eligible. However, before taking the said action one communication

showing the deficiency may be sent to the applicant concerned and the applicant may be given a specific time limit to do the needful. In case any

advise or clarification has been requested for, from Central Govt. and inspite

one or two reminders reply is not received then the application may be

returned back to Ministry stating that the Council has not been in a position to complete its action for want of reply/ information from the Central Govt.

8


MMiinniissttrryy’’ss OOffffiiccee MMeemmoorraanndduumm NNoo..ZZ..2288001155//1177//22001166--PPPP&&CC ddaatteedd 1100tthh JJuunnee

22001166,, rreeggaarrddiinngg AAccttiioonn ppooiinnttss ppeerrttaaiinniinngg ttoo CCCCIIMM iinn rreeffeerreennccee ttoo

ddeeppaarrttmmeennttaall aaccttiioonn ppllaann ooff MMiinniissttrryy ooff AAYYUUSSHH..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter. However, regarding electronic registration by the State Boards/

Councils, it decided that a request may be made to State Councils but

ultimately the work has to be done by the State Councils/Boards under the respective State Acts for which prolonged persuasion by the Central Council

may not be practical. The Central Council did not find any provision in

Homoeopathy Central Council Act regarding Inspection/ Visitation of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges by the Third Party. So far as Aadhar linked

digital attendance by the teaching faculty, Hospital faculty and other staff

members of the college is concerned, the Central Council felt that it is possible only in colleges of Central/State Govts. but not in respect of the

private colleges and for such reason it may be difficult to ensure the same

by the Council. However, all the colleges may be once advised to install

Aadhar based attendance machines on which all employees and staff can put their attendance both for coming and going.

Agenda Item No. 56.18 ((aa)) MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..RR..1133004400//4400//22000088--HHDD((TTeecchh..)) ddaatteedd 2299..0044..22000088 rreeggaarrddiinngg

rreeccooggnniittiioonn ooff mmeeddiiccaall qquuaalliiffiiccaattiioonn uunnddeerr SSeeccttiioonn 1144 ((22)) ooff HH..CC..CC.. AAcctt,, 11997733..

((bb)) MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..RR..1133004400//4400//22000088--HHDD((TTeecchh..)) ddaatteedd 0033..0022..22001111 rreeggaarrddiinngg

rreeccooggnniittiioonn ooff mmeeddiiccaall qquuaalliiffiiccaattiioonn uunnddeerr SSeeccttiioonn 1144 ((22)) ooff HH..CC..CC.. AAcctt,, 11997733..

The Central Council ratified the decision of the Executive Committee in the

matter.


ddkk;;kkZZyy;; KKkkiiuu llaa--2255001133@@11@@22001166&&LLFFkkkk--,,&&IIVV ffnnuukkaadd 1111 eekkppZZ]] 22001166

JJhh llww;;kkZZ uukkjjkk;;..kk >>kk]] mmii llffppoo]] HHkkkkjjrr lljjddkkjj]] ddkkffeeZZdd]] yykkssdd ff””kkddkk;;rr vvkkSSjj

iissaa””kkuu eeaa==kkyy;;]] ddkkffeeZZdd ,,ooaa iizzff””kk{{kk..kk ffooHHkkkkxx]] uukkFFkkZZ CCyykkWWdd]] uubbZZ

ffnnYYyyhh llss ffoo’’kk;; LLookk;;RRrr llaaLLFFkkkk,,aa&& ,,QQvvkkjj 5566¼¼ii½½ ddss rrggrr llee;;&&llee;; iijj lleehh{{kkkk

iizz””kkkklluu ddss llqq))

9

The Central Council ratified the decision of the Executive Committee in the

matter.


((aa)) OObbsseerrvviinngg tthhee ssuubbmmiissssiioonnss//pprreesseennttaattiioonnss mmaaddee iinn NNaattiioonnaall SSeemmiinnaarr oonn

HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy aanndd DDiissccuussssiioonn tthheerreeoonn..

((bb)) OObbsseerrvviinngg tthhee ssuubbmmiissssiioonnss//pprreesseennttaattiioonnss//rreemmaarrkkss mmaaddee iinn IInntteerrnnaattiioonnaall

CCoonnvveennttiioonn hheelldd oonn WWoorrlldd HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc DDaayy aatt VViiggyyaann BBhhaawwaann,, NNeeww

DDeellhhii..

The Central Council approved the recommendation of Education Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 56.22 MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..221166001111//0033//22001166--EEPP((HH)) ddaatteedd 77tthh AApprriill,, 22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg aa

VViissiioonn NNoottee ffoorr ddeevveellooppmmeenntt ooff AAYYUUSSHH rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm DDrr.. NNaarreennddrraa BBhhaatttt..

The Central Council approved the recommendation of Education Committee

in the matter.


NNaattiioonnaall MMEEEETT aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..

The Central Council decided that the recommendations made in the

National Meet may be forwarded to Ministry.


TToo iinnccrreeaassee tthhee aaggee ooff rreettiirreemmeenntt ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc DDooccttoorrss ttoo 6655 yyeeaarrss..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the

matter.


## 5500]]000000@@&& llss vvff//kkdd ddss HHkkqqxxrrkkuu ddss cckkjjss eessaaAA

v/;{k }kjk iznŸk izfrfuf/k “kfDr;ksa ds vUrxZr ifj"kn~ }kjk fnukad 16-02-2016 ls fnukad

27-07-2016 rd # 50]000@& ls vf/kd jkf”k ds fuEu Hkqxrku fd, gSa &

fnukad 16-02-2016 ls 31-03-2016 rd &

dze la0 ykHkkFkhZ dk uke Yks[kk Ekn jkf”k Hkqxrku dh frfFk

1. Mk0 vk”khl nRrk NqV~Vh ;k=k fj;k;r O;; 50235-00 16-02-2016

2. lh-th-,p-,l- va”knku lh-th-,p-,l- 125505-00 16-02-2016

3. eS0 ,l0 vkj0 xzkfQDl NikbZ O;; 210985-00 24-02-2016

4. eS0 lqijLVkj dkWUQzsal lfoZflt lsfeukj O;; 740780-00 25-02-2016

5. eS0 ,YQk fizUVksxzkfQDl NikbZ O;; ¼lsfeukj½ 465050-00 29-02-2016

6. eS0 eksukdZ VªSoYl ;krk;kr O;; ¼lsfeukj½ 62145-00 29-02-2016

7. dUVªksyj vkWQ ifCyds”ku NikbZ O;; 107800-00 29-02-2016

10

8. eS0 MhyDl fizUVjh NikbZ O;; ¼lsfeukj½ 63375-00 09-03-2016

9. eS0 dsUnzh; Hk.Mkj ys[ku lkexzh O;; 65743-00 15-03-2016

10. Jh lquhy u#yk fof/kd O;; 110000-00 31-03-2016

11. eS0 lat; tSu ,.M da0 O;olkf;d ’kqYd 56602-00 31-03-2016





16. eS0 csnh ,.M csnh ¼fnlEcj] 2015½

Oksftt O;; (wages) 162336-00 15-02-2016

17. eS0 csnh ,.M csnh ¼tuojh] 2016½

Oksftt O;; (wages) 162239-00 09-03-2016

18. eS0 csnh ,.M csnh ¼Qjojh] 2016½

Oksftt O;; (wages) 166066-00 28-03-2016

19. eS0 ckEkj ykWjh ;k=k HkRrk 179815-00 15-03-2016

20. eS0 ckEkj ykWjh ;k=k HkRrk 291133-00 31-03-2016

fnukad 01-04-2016 ls 31-07-2016 rd &

dze la0 ykHkkFkhZ dk uke Yks[kk Ekn jkf”k Hkqxrku dh frfFk

1. Jherh lq/kk “kekZ] iwoZ dk;kZy; v/khf{kdk ¼r0½

vftZr vodk”k uxnhdj.k 532482-00 $14592-00 547074-00

27-04-2016 04-07-2016

2. Jherh lq/kk “kekZ] iwoZ dk;kZy; v/khf{kdk ¼r0½

fjVk;jesaV xzsP;qfV 887469-00 $24321-00 911790-00

27-04-2016 01-07-2016


4. eS0 iquhr QksVksLVsV QksVksLVsV O;; 167840-00 26-05-2016

5. lwpuk ,oa izlkj.k ea=ky; jk"Vªh; cSBd vfxze 83810-00 26-05-2016

6. eS0 ,Eiy bosUVl ,.M ,Dthfc”kUt+ lsfeukj O;; ¼;kstuk½ 74375-00 30-05-2016

7. eS0 dsUnzh; Hk.Mkj ys[ku lkexzh O;; 84935-00 15-06-2016

8. eS0 csnh ,.M csnh ¼ekpZ] 2016½

Oksftt O;; (wages) 169126-00 03-05-2016

9. eS0 csnh ,.M csnh ¼vizSy] 2016½

Oksftt O;; (wages) 185973-00 30-05-2016

10. eS0 csnh ,.M csnh ¼ebZ] 2016½

Oksftt O;; (wages) 187721-00 06-07-2016

11. iksLV ekLVj] ukjk;.kk bUMfLVª;y bLVsV] ubZ fnYyh

Mkd fVdV 50000-00 11-07-2016

12. eS0 ,Dlsl usV vkbZ-Vh- lksY;w”ku ejEer ,oa j[kj[kko 147597-00 13-07-2016

13. eS0 ckEkj ykWjh ;k=k HkRrk O;; 251471-00 10-05-2016

14. eS0 ckej ,.M ykWjh ;k=k HkRrk O;; 207855-00 08-06-2016




18. EkS0 bZ’ojk dke/ksuq jsLVksjsaV cSBd O;; ¼;kstuk½ 241320-00 12-08-2016

19. eS0 lqij LVkj dkWUQzsal lfoZl izk0 fy0

fofo/k O;; ¼;kstuk½ 190000-00 12-08-2016

20. eS0 lqij LVkj dkWUQzsal lfoZl izk0 fy0

fofo/k O;; ¼;kstuk½ 122425-00


IIkk== vvkkjj--1133001155@@1122@@22001133&&bbZZiihh¼¼,,pp½½&&llhhllhh,,pp¼¼iikkVVZZ½½ ffnnuukkaadd 2200

uuooEEccjj]] 22001155 iizzkkIIrr ggqqvvkk vvkk;;qq’’kk eeaa==kkyy;;]] uubbZZ ffnnYYyyhh llss ffoo’’kk;; ddssUUnnzzhh;;

ggkkssEE;;kkssiiSSFFkkhh iiffjj’’kknn~~ eessaa vvkk””kkqqffyyffiidd xxzzssMM&&MMhh ddss iinn~~ ddkkss HHkkjjuuss

cckkoorr~~ iizzkkIIrr ggqqvvkk ggSSAA


11


LLeetttteerr NNoo..AAKKHHAAMMBB//VVoo..II//0011//CCCCHH//001166 ddaatteedd 44tthh MMaarrcchh,, 22001166 rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm

DDrr.. EEnnoobboonngg RR.. UUddoorrookk,, SSeeccrreettaarryy,, GGoovveerrnnmmeenntt ooff AAKKWWAA IIBBOOMM SSttaattee ooff

NNiiggeerriiaa rreeggaarrddiinngg PPrrooffeessssiioonnaall aanndd AAccaaddeemmiicc CCoo--ooppeerraattiioonn aanndd CCoollllaabboorraattiioonn

wwiitthh CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy..

The Central Council approved the draft regulations namely, Homoeopathy Central Council (Scheme of Reciprocity) Regulations for seeking sanction of

Central Govt.

The Central Council also agreed with the recommendation of the

Regulations Committee to take up the matter with Ministry regarding the

Govt. of Akwa Ibom State of Nigeria Homoeopathic/ Alternative Medical Board for providing exchange of study in India for which HCC Act does not

have any specific provisions.


i= la[;k vkj- 13015@14@2010&,p-Mh-&lh-lh-,p- fnukad 31 ekpZ] 2016 fo’k; ifj’kn~ esa dk;Zjr fpfdRldksa dh fuf”fpr xfr”khy o;olk; izxfr ;kstuk ds foLrkj ds ckcr~ The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the

matter subject to modification that the Screening Committee M.A.C.P. of

recommended by the Executive Committee will be looking after the matter related to both Asstt. Secretaries but for MACP in respect of the Registrar-

cum-Secretary and Inspector the Screening Committee will be headed by

President (in absence of President it will be headed by the Vice-President) and the Members will be Dr. K.K. Juneja, Dr. N. Debnath and Dr. Shyamal

Mukherjee.


MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo.. RR..1133004400//1199//22001122--HHDD((TTeecchh)) ddaatteedd 1144..1100..22001155 rreeggaarrddiinngg

iinncclluussiioonn ooff BBHHMMSS qquuaalliiffiiccaattiioonn ooff GGuurruu RRaavviiddaass AAyyuurrvveedd UUnniivveerrssiittyy,,

HHoosshhiiaarrppuurr iinn SSeeccoonndd SScchheedduullee ooff HHCCCC AAcctt,, 11997733..

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the

matter.


jjffttLLVVªªkkjj ee//;;iizznnss””kk iiffjj’’kknn~~]] iiaattkkcc iiffjj’’kknn~~]] jjkkttLLFFkkkkuu cckkssMMZZ]] mmRRrrjjiizznnss””kk

cckkssMMZZ]] ggffjj;;kk..kkkk iiffjj’’kknn~~ ,,ooaa ffnnYYyyhh cckkssMMZZ }}kkjjkk HHkkssttss xx,, uukkeekkssaa ddkk

ffuujjLLrr ddjjuuss rrFFkkkk mmuu uukkeekkssaa ddkkss ddssUUnnzzhh;; iiaatthhddkk llss HHkkhh ggVVkk,, ttkkuuss ddss

llaaccaa//kk eessaaAA

12

The Central Council accepted the recommendations of the Registration

Committee in the matter.


LLeetttteerr ddaatteedd 2233..1100..22001155 rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm DDrr..LL..KK..NNaannddaa,, CChhaaiirrmmaann,, CCoommmmiitttteeee

oonn EExxcceelllleennccee iinn EEdduuccaattiioonn..

The Central Council noted that President has sent a DO letter to President,

MCI in the matter as such it decided to wait for a reply from MCI. It may be

placed in the next meeting of Central Council.

Agenda Item No. 56.32 MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo.. VV..2277001166//0011//22001166--EEPP((IIMM--22)) ddaatteedd 1155tthh JJaannuuaarryy,, 22001166

rreeggaarrddiinngg BBaassiicc TTrraaiinniinngg ooff TTTTTT ((TTrraaiinniinngg ttoo TTeeaacchheerrss)) PPrrooggrraamm ooff CCCCIIMM..

The Central Council approved the draft regulations namely, Homoeopathy (Post Graduate Diploma Educational Technology) Regulations which may be

sent to Central Govt. for sanction.


MMaaiill ddaatteedd 2233rrdd MMaayy 22001166 rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm DDrr..SSrriinniivvaassaa RRaaoo,, MMeemmbbeerr,, CCCCHH

rreeggaarrddiinngg RReesseeaarrcchh pprrooppoossaall ffrroomm AA..SS..CC..II.. ((AAddmmiinniissttrraattiivvee SSttaaffff CCoolllleeggee ooff

IInnddiiaa)) ffoorr RReesseeaarrcchh ssttuuddyy ttoo ddeevveelloopp SSttaannddaarrdd OOppeerraattiinngg PPrroocceedduurree iinn AArreeaa ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc iinn IInnddiiaa..



PPrrooppoossaall rreefflleeccttiinngg aa ppllaann aass ttoo hhooww ttoo pprroocceeeedd ttoo mmaakkee CCCCHH sseellff ffiinnaanncciiaallllyy--

ssuuffffiicciieenntt..

The Central Council considered the matter and decided that matter may be

reviewed after receipt of reply from the Ministry in respect of decision taken

by the Executive Committee.


13

SSttaattuuss ooff EEddiittoorriiaall BBooaarrdd ooff JJoouurrnnaall ooff CCCCHH –– rreegg..

The Central Council decided that the status of the Editorial Board may be

taken as of an independent Committee under the provisions of General Regulations.

Agenda Item No. 56.36 MMiinniissttrryy’’ss OO..MM.. NNoo.. ZZ..2288001155//112244//22001144--PPPP&&CC((PPaarrtt IIII)) ddaatteedd 2288..0066..22001166

rreeggaarrddiinngg AAccttiioonn TTaakkeenn NNoottee oonn rreeccoommmmeennddaattiioonnss ooff TTaasskk FFoorrccee..

The Central Council considered the matter and it ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter subject to the condition that if there is

any variation in the decision of Executive Committee and decision taken in

this meeting reflected elsewhere in these minutes than the Council’s decision will be the final decision.


MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..ZZ..1166001111//1166//22001166--EEPP((HH)) ddaatteedd 1144..0066..22001166 rreeggaarrddiinngg

CCoommppllaaiinntt ooff DDrr..PP..KK..SSaattaappaatthhyy rreeggaarrddiinngg vviioollaattiioonn ooff CCCCHH AAcctt uunnddeerr sseeccttiioonn

99,, 1177 && 1188 bbyy tthhee CCCCHH OOffffiicciiaallss..

The Central Council noted that it is the repetition of item No. 56.2A as usch

whatever decision has been taken in items No. 56.2A will be application here also.

Agenda Item No. 56.38 BBiillll NNoo..AAddvvtt..//33//44//EEOO//2200//1166((113333)) ddaatteedd 3300..0066..22001166 rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm

DDeeppaarrttmmeenntt ooff PPuubblliiccaattiioonn,, GGoovvtt.. ooff IInnddiiaa rreeggaarrddiinngg AAmmeennddmmeenntt iinn BB..HH..MM..SS..

DDeeggrreeee CCoouurrssee RReegguullaattiioonnss..

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 6,15,340/- for payment to Department

of Publication, Govt. of India.


LLeetttteerr ddaatteedd 2266..0044..22001166 rreecceeiivveedd ffrroomm DDrr..AAssiimm KKuummaarr DDaass,, HH..OO..DD.. SSuurrggeerryy,,

MMaahheesshh BBhhaattttaacchhaarryyyyaa HHoommooeeooppaatthhiicc MMeeddiiccaall CCoolllleeggee aanndd HHoossppiittaall,, HHoowwrraahh

rreeggaarrddiinngg rreevviieeww ooff AAmmeennddmmeenntt iinn DDeeggrreeee CCoouurrssee RReegguullaattiioonnss--rreeggaarrddiinngg..

14

The Central Council ratified the decision/ recommendation taken by the Education Committee in the matter.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 117744tthh MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EExxeeccuuttiivvee CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall

CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd iinn AApprriill,, 22001166..

The Central Council approved the decisions/ recommendations of the

Executive Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.

Agenda Item No. 56.41 MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee RReeggiissttrraattiioonn CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill

ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 2266tthh AApprriill,, 22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..


Registration Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.

Agenda Item No. 56.42 MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EExxcceelllleennccee EEdduuccaattiioonn iinn HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy ooff

CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 1100..0055..22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..


Committee on Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy which have not

been separately discussed in these minutes.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee LLiiaaiissoonn CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 1199..0055..22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..

The Central Council approved the decisions/ recommendations of the Liaison Committee.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EEdduuccaattiioonn CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 2233rrdd && 2244tthh MMaayy,, 22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..

15


Education Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee PP..GG.. EEdduuccaattiioonn CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 2255..0055..22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..

The Central Council approved the decisions/ recommendations of the P. G. Education Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.

Agenda Item No. 56.46 MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 117755tthh MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EExxeeccuuttiivvee CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall

CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 1155..0066..22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..


Executive Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.

Agenda Item No. 56.47 MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee RReegguullaattiioonnss CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill

ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 2266..0077..22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..


Regulations Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 117766tthh mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EExxeeccuuttiivvee CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill


The Central Council approved the decisions/ recommendations of the Executive Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes except point No. 14 under Any Other Item with Permission of Chair

as the Council after consideration of Ministry’s letter decided that until & unless the report of surprise inspection are received from Ministry and the

Council considers them alongwith reports of concerned colleges by

visitors/inspectors deputed by CCH, such visitors/inspectors shall not be

16

barred from undertaking inspections. The Council noted that HCC Act, 1973 does not authorise Ministry of AYUSH, Govt. of India to inspect any college.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EEdduuccaattiioonn CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff

HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 1133..0088..22001166 aatt PPuunnee..


Education Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.

Agenda Item No. 56.50 MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee FFiinnaannccee CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd

oonn 1166..0088..22001166 aatt NNeeww DDeellhhii..


Finance Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee mmeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee RReegguullaattiioonnss CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill


The Central Council approved the decisions/ recommendations of the Regulations Committee which have not been separately discussed in these

minutes.


MMiinnuutteess ooff tthhee 117777tthh MMeeeettiinngg ooff tthhee EExxeeccuuttiivvee CCoommmmiitttteeee ooff tthhee CCeennttrraall

CCoouunncciill ooff HHoommooeeooppaatthhyy hheelldd oonn 2288..0088..22001166 aatt GGooaa..


Executive Committee which have not been separately discussed in these minutes. The Council considered three letters of Ministry of AYUSH having

same number as R.13040/87/2012-SD (Tech.) Part-I dated 12.08.2016

wherein the Ministry has asked the Central Council to communicate the decisions of the Ministry to all concerned for immediate compliance. In

regard, to these letters the Central Council decided that the elections and

nominations to constitute the Central Council of Homoeopathy, are done by the Central Govt. as such it is for the authority of Ministry of AYUSH, Govt.

of India to communicate its decisions in the matter directly to concerned

authorities instead of requesting the Central Council in the matter.

17


MMiinniissttrryy’’ss lleetttteerr NNoo..RR..1133001155//0055//22001144--EEPP((HH))--CCCCHH ddaatteedd 1188tthh MMaayy,, 22001166

rreeggaarrddiinngg aammeennddmmeenntt ttoo CCCCHH ((GGeenneerraall)) RReegguullaattiioonnss..

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee (to be

read with) Regulation committee and accordingly a consolidated draft of

amendments proposed alongwith reply to the Ministry’s letter after bringing the same to the knowledge of President, may be sent to Ministry.


RReeccoonnssttiittuuttiioonn ooff vvaarriioouuss CCoommmmiitttteeeess ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill aass ppeerr pprroovviissiioonn ooff

SSeeccttiioonn 99((11)) ooff HHCCCC AAcctt,, 11997733 aanndd GGeenneerraall RReegguullaattiioonnss..

The Central Council did not find any merit in the letter dated 23.05.2016 of

Dr. P. K. Sathpathy, Member, CCH. However, it reiterated the authority

given to the President to reconstitute the committees including the vacancies, if any. Objection of Dr. P.K. Satpathy is enclosed.

Any other matter with permission of Chair. 1) The Central Council asked the Secretary to place in its next meeting

the correspondence exchanged with Central Govt. for providing

Laptops to Members.

The meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

Sd/- (Dr. Lalit Verma)

Secretary

Attested by:

Sd/-

(Dr. Ramjee Singh)

President

18

19.09.2016

EXTRACT TAKEN FROM THE MINUTES OF THE 56TH MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 30TH AUGUST, 2016

AT GOA.

XX XX XX


RReeccoonnssttiittuuttiioonn ooff vvaarriioouuss CCoommmmiitttteeeess ooff CCeennttrraall CCoouunncciill aass ppeerr pprroovviissiioonn ooff

SSeeccttiioonn 99((11)) ooff HHCCCC AAcctt,, 11997733 aanndd GGeenneerraall RReegguullaattiioonnss..

The Central Council did not find any merit in the letter dated 23.05.2016 of Dr. P. K. Sathpathy, Member, CCH. However, it reiterated the authority

given to the President to reconstitute the committees including the

vacancies, if any. Objection of Dr. P.K. Satpathy is enclosed.

XX XX XX

“A”

Not Present

MINUTES OF THE 56TH MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF ... _held_in_Goa_30.8.2016.pdf · Singh, Dr....

Documents

Transcript of MINUTES OF THE 56TH MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF ... _held_in_Goa_30.8.2016.pdf · Singh, Dr....