Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water...

55
Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond Ohio Section AWWA September 28, 2017

Transcript of Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water...

Page 1: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Michigan City Department of Water Works

West Intake ExtensionPresented By:

Stanley S. DiamondOhio Section AWWASeptember 28, 2017

Page 2: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Michigan City’s Intakes - 2003

N

Washington ParkBeach

Water Plant

West Intake & Crib

East Intake & CribAbandoned Intake

Page 3: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Dates of Installation

19591959

19141926

Page 4: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Problem Number One - Sand Deposition Around The Shore Wells

First Sea Walls 1834 / Present Sea Walls 1904

Page 5: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Shore Wells and Intake Lines

West Shore Well

East Shore Well

WaterTreatment

Plant

Washington Park

Page 6: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

West Shore Well

Page 7: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

East Shore Well

Page 8: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

East Intake Partial Profile In 2003

35’30’

Page 9: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Problem Number Two -Sand Deposition In East Intake

• Special Recognition to:– Steve Davis, Indiana

Department of Natural Resources

Page 10: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Surf Zone Dynamics

Summer Winter

Lake water levels also impact the location of the sand bars!

Page 11: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Intake Restricted

Page 12: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

East Intake Profile

Page 13: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Proposed Intake Improvement Phases

East Intake ExtensionOn-Shore IOn-Shore II

On-Shore III

West Intake Extension

Page 14: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

2005 - East Intake Extension

New Intake Pipe

New East Crib

Contractor: Luedtke Engineering Company

Page 15: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

2006 On-Shore Phase I Construction

Contractor: Woodruff & Sons, Inc.

Page 16: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

2007 On-Shore Phase II

Contractor: Woodruff & Sons, Inc.

Page 17: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

2008 On-Shore Phase III –New Access Structure

Page 18: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Last Intake Improvement Project

East Intake ExtensionOn-Shore IOn-Shore II

On-Shore IIIWest Intake Extension

Page 19: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Design and Bid Documents Preparation

Page 20: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Permitting

• IDEM Construction Permit (Not Required)– July 31, 2014 – August 1, 2014

• IDNR Construction Permit– July 27, 2014 - Sept 17, 2014

• IDEM Section 401 Water Quality Certification– July 27, 2014 - Sept 30, 2014

• US Army Corps of Engineers– July 27, 2014 – March 28, 2016 (20 Months!)

Page 21: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Scope of Construction

• Video Inspect Existing Intake Pipe Interior• Backflush & Clean Out Existing Intake Pipe• Re-video Inspect Existing Intake Pipe Interior• Remove Existing Crib• Install New Intermediate Access Structure• Install 1,500’ of 48“ Pre-stressed Concrete Cylinder

Pipe• Install New Timber Crib and Rock Apron• Video Inspect Intake Pipe Interior, Crib, and Apron• Perform Bathometric Survey

Page 22: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Bid Results

• Bid Date: August 18, 2015• Bid Amount: $ 3,459,339.00• Successful Bidder:

Page 23: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Great Lakes’ Marine Construction Equipment

• Tug Boats – Fischer Hayden, Meredith Ashton• Jack-up Work Barge – Hannah Avery• Manitowoc Crane• Dump Scow – Scow 120

Page 24: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Internal Video Inspection Equipment

June 21, 2016

Page 25: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Backflushing Equipment & Piping

Page 26: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Pigging Existing Intake

Page 27: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Demolishing Existing Crib

Page 28: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Special Adaptor Required

Page 29: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Delivering, Staging & Handling PCCP

Page 30: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Installing New Intermediate Access Riser

Page 31: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Digging Trench & Installing Pipe

Page 32: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

GLD&M Photo

Page 33: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Pipe Installation Equipment & Materials

• Hydro-pull System• “Cookies” and Sandbags• Temporary Cap• Stone Bedding and

Backfill

Page 34: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Crib Layout & Design

Page 35: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Crib Inlet Funnel & Cleanout Riser

Page 36: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Building Crib

Page 37: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Building Crib

Page 38: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Ballast Compartment Caps

Page 39: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

GLD&M Photo

Transporting Crib

GLD&M Photo

Page 40: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Installing Crib

GLD&M Photo

Page 41: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Sinking Crib

Page 42: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Placing Ballast Compartment Caps

Page 43: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Placing Crib Cover

Page 44: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Crib Apron Plan

Page 45: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Crib Apron Section

Page 46: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Constructing Crib Apron

Illinois DOT Riprap #7

Page 47: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Construction Challenges• Weather (Winds)• Rough Lake Conditions• Public Events• Available Dive Time• Trench Failures• Custom Adaptor Fabrication Time• Pipe Delivery & Staging• 12+ Hour Shifts, Weeks at a Time

PHOTO CREDIT: NWI TIMES

Page 48: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Final Internal Video Inspection Equipment

October 11, 2016

Page 49: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Final Crib & Apron Video Inspection

October 26, 2016

Page 50: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Final Bathometric Survey

December 12, 2016

Page 51: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Substantial Completion & Construction Cost

• Substantial Completion: October 28, 2016• Construction Cost

– Original Bid Amount: $3,459,339.00– One Change Order: ($3,000.00)– Final Construction Cost: $3,456,339.00

Page 52: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Final Overall Intake Construction Cost

East Intake Extension - $1,446,954On-Shore Replacements - $3,939,055West Intake Extension - $3,456,339Total $8,842,348

Page 53: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Acknowledgements

• Department of Water Works– Randy Russell, Jim Kintzele Jr., Greg Burnett

• Wessler Team Members– Dylan Lambermont, Ryan Sidler, Michelle Everetts, Amy

Harvell, Brad Robinson, Josh Hood, Doug Stephenson, Dreama Doolittle

• Other Design Team Members– Dr. Ty Lynn, Donohue & Associates

• Great Lakes Dock & Materials– Joe Bailey, Peter Dunning, Adam Helfrey

Page 54: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Subcontractors

• Hibbard Inshore – ROV Video Inspections• Lake Erie Diving – Pressure Testing• Baker Corp – Temporary Pumping• Seaworks – Multibeam Surveying

Page 55: Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension · Michigan City Department of Water Works West Intake Extension Presented By: Stanley S. Diamond. Ohio Section AWWA.

Questions?