Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann...

53
Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh, Associate Public Health Officer, UNHCR Maysa Al-Khateeb, Emergency Reproductive Health Officer, UNFPA Shible Sahbani, Humanitarian Coordinator, UNFPA Sathyanarayanan Doraiswamy, Emergency RH Officer, UNHCR Basia Tomczyk, Health Scientist, CDC Lessons Learned from Reproductive Health Surveillance in Za’atari Refugee Camp — Jordan, 2013-2014 Center for Global Health Emergency Response and Recovery Branch

Transcript of Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann...

Page 1: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDCRachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC

Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCRDina Jardaneh, Associate Public Health Officer, UNHCR

Maysa Al-Khateeb, Emergency Reproductive Health Officer, UNFPAShible Sahbani, Humanitarian Coordinator, UNFPA

Sathyanarayanan Doraiswamy, Emergency RH Officer, UNHCRBasia Tomczyk, Health Scientist, CDC

Lessons Learned from Reproductive Health Surveillance in Za’atari Refugee Camp —

Jordan, 2013-2014

Center for Global Health

Emergency Response and Recovery Branch

Page 2: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

BACKGROUND

Za’atari Refugee Camp Reproductive Health Surveillance

Page 3: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Syrian Refugees Today

http://data.unhcr.org/syrianrefugees/country.php?id=107http://misp.lacrounfpa.org/unfpa/mispcalculator/advocacy/NjE5MTYwOzQwOzI0OzU7ODU%3D

Page 4: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Syrian Refugees Today

http://data.unhcr.org/syrianrefugees/country.php?id=107http://misp.lacrounfpa.org/unfpa/mispcalculator/advocacy/NjE5MTYwOzQwOzI0OzU7ODU%3D

155,647

Page 5: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Syrian Refugees Today

http://data.unhcr.org/syrianrefugees/country.php?id=107http://misp.lacrounfpa.org/unfpa/mispcalculator/advocacy/NjE5MTYwOzQwOzI0OzU7ODU%3D

18,678

155,647

Page 6: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Jordan and Za’atari Refugee Camp – Aug 2013

Page 7: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Jordan and Za’atari Refugee Camp – Aug 2013

More than 520,000 refugees in Jordan Majority of refugees in

urban settings

Page 8: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Jordan and Za’atari Refugee Camp – Aug 2013

More than 520,000 refugees in Jordan Majority of refugees in

urban settings

Over 120,000 Syrian refugees in Za’atari camp 30,504 women aged

15-49 3,660 pregnant women

Page 9: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Photo 7/2013: http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/syria-refugee-

camp-aerial-pictures-2067144

Page 10: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEM

Za’atari Refugee Camp Reproductive Health Surveillance

Page 11: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

UNHCR Health Information System (HIS)

Page 12: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

UNHCR Health Information System (HIS)

Standardized tool to design, monitor, and evaluate refugee public health HIS is implemented in over 18 countries Targets over 2.1 million refugees in camp and non-camp

settings

Page 13: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

UNHCR Health Information System (HIS)

Standardized tool to design, monitor, and evaluate refugee public health HIS is implemented in over 18 countries Targets over 2.1 million refugees in camp and non-camp

settings Up to 10 technical sections with three core

pillars

Page 14: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

UNHCR Health Information System (HIS)

Standards and

Indicators

Tools and Guidelines

Coordination and

Support

Standardized tool to design, monitor, and evaluate refugee public health HIS is implemented in over 18 countries Targets over 2.1 million refugees in camp and non-camp

settings Up to 10 technical sections with three core

pillars

Page 15: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

UNHCR Health Information System (HIS)

Standards and

Indicators

Tools and Guidelines

Coordination and

Support

Standardized tool to design, monitor, and evaluate refugee public health HIS is implemented in over 18 countries Targets over 2.1 million refugees in camp and non-camp

settings Up to 10 technical sections with three core

pillars

Page 16: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

UNHCR Health Information System (HIS)

Standards and

Indicators

Tools and Guidelines

Coordination and

Support

Standardized tool to design, monitor, and evaluate refugee public health HIS is implemented in over 18 countries Targets over 2.1 million refugees in camp and non-camp

settings Up to 10 technical sections with three core

pillars

Page 17: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Problem Statement

RH component of the HIS in Za’atari needed improvement

Many contributing factors

Transition & consolidation of comprehensive RH services highlighted need for quality RH data

Delivery Room in Za’atari Camp/UNFPA

Page 18: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

EVALUATION DESIGN

Za’atari Refugee Camp Reproductive Health Surveillance

Page 19: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Objectives

Page 20: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Objectives

Review the RH component of Za’atari HIS

Review national RH HIS and reporting templates to ensure proposed changes reflect national RH

Implement a system for maternal and neonatal mortality audits in Za’atari

Provide technical support and facilitate implementation of RH component of HIS

Develop an action plan to implement the proposed recommendations

Page 21: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Objectives

Review the RH component of Za’atari HIS

Review national RH HIS and reporting templates to ensure proposed changes reflect national RH

Implement a system for maternal and neonatal mortality audits in Za’atari

Provide technical support and facilitate implementation of RH component of HIS

Develop an action plan to implement the proposed recommendations

Page 22: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Objectives

Review the RH component of Za’atari HIS

Review national RH HIS and reporting templates to ensure proposed changes reflect national RH

Implement a system for maternal and neonatal mortality audits in Za’atari

Provide technical support and facilitate implementation of RH component of HIS

Develop an action plan to implement the proposed recommendations

Page 23: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Objectives

Review the RH component of Za’atari HIS

Review national RH HIS and reporting templates to ensure proposed changes reflect national RH

Implement a system for maternal and neonatal mortality audits in Za’atari

Provide technical support and facilitate implementation of RH component of HIS

Develop an action plan to implement the proposed recommendations

Page 24: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Objectives

Review the RH component of Za’atari HIS

Review national RH HIS and reporting templates to ensure proposed changes reflect national RH

Implement a system for maternal and neonatal mortality audits in Za’atari

Provide technical support and facilitate implementation of RH component of HIS

Develop an action plan to implement the proposed recommendations

Page 25: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Methods

Page 26: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Methods

August 18 to September 14, 2013

Qualitative Key informant interviews Facility site visits Review of RH documents, tools, and indicators Stakeholder meetings

Quantitative HIS reproductive health data

Page 27: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Methods

August 18 to September 14, 2013

Qualitative Key informant interviews Facility site visits Review of RH documents, tools, and indicators Stakeholder meetings

Quantitative HIS reproductive health data

Page 28: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Evaluation Methods

August 18 to September 14, 2013

Qualitative Key informant interviews Facility site visits Review of RH documents, tools, and indicators Stakeholder meetings

Quantitative HIS reproductive health data

Page 29: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

THE FINDINGS

Za’atari Refugee Camp Reproductive Health Surveillance

Page 30: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Multiple Non-traditional Health Actors

Page 31: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Multiple Non-Traditional Health Actors

Varied data

collection methods

High staff turnover

Lack of information sharing

Page 32: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Varied data

collection methods

High staff turnover

Lack of information sharing

Multiple Non-Traditional Health Actors

Page 33: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Varied data

collection methods

High staff turnover

Lack of information sharing

Multiple Non-Traditional Health Actors

Page 34: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Contributed to incomplete & inconsistent

reporting

Varied data

collection methods

High staff turnover

Lack of information sharing

Multiple Non-Traditional Health Actors

Page 35: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Contributed to incomplete & inconsistent

reporting

Reduced data quality

Varied data

collection methods

High staff turnover

Lack of information sharing

Multiple Non-Traditional Health Actors

Page 36: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Data Quality – Weekly HIS Profile Reports

Page 37: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Data Quality:

Data Quality – Weekly HIS Profile Reports

Few health actors reported family planning

(FP) data

Page 38: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Data Quality: Weekly HIS Detailed Reports

Page 39: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Data Quality: Weekly HIS Detailed Reports

No mechanism to monitor

complete postnatal care

(PNC)

Page 40: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Data Quality: Weekly HIS Detailed Reports

No SGBV cases reported

No mechanism to monitor

complete postnatal care

(PNC)

Page 41: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

ACTION PLAN

Za’atari Refugee Camp Reproductive Health Surveillance

Page 42: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Health Information System Action Plan

Standardize RH Data

Collection

Improve information Sharing

Encourage timely

submission

Train on registers and user guides

Develop FP register

Development of a RH Tally Sheet

Page 43: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Health Information System Action Plan

Standardize RH Data

Collection

Improve information Sharing

Encourage timely

submission

Train on registers and user guides

Develop FP register

Development of a RH Tally Sheet

Pregnancy Card implementation

Involve CHWs

Page 44: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Health Information System Action Plan

Standardize RH Data

Collection

Improve information Sharing

Encourage timely

submission

Train on registers and user guides

Develop FP register

Development of a RH Tally Sheet

Pregnancy Card implementation

Involve CHWs

Identify a RH Focal Point within each partner

Implement a Mortality Event Review & Response protocol

Page 45: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

LESSONS LEARNED

Za’atari Refugee Camp Reproductive Health Surveillance

Page 46: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

A flexible, systematic approach

to data collection and reporting is

needed

Page 47: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

Engagement with and training of

health actors on key RH data to be

collected at different phases

A flexible, systematic approach

to data collection and reporting is

needed

Page 48: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

A flexible, systematic approach

to data collection and reporting is

needed

Agreement on and development of a

standardized approach to RH data collection at global

level

Engagement with and training of

health actors on key RH data to be

collected at different phases

Page 49: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

A flexible, systematic approach

to data collection and reporting is

needed

Agreement on and development of a

standardized approach to RH data collection at global

level

Using RH registers early in a crisis highlight key

women’s health outcomes and guide

interventions

Engagement with and training of

health actors on key RH data to be

collected at different phases

Page 50: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

Provider involvement in

development and adoption of tools

enhances commitment and

collaboration

Page 51: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

Data sharing between services

provided inside and outside the camps

Provider involvement in

development and adoption of tools

enhances commitment and

collaboration

Page 52: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

Lessons Learned

Evaluate quality of HIS data early &

work with partners to develop and

implement an action plan

Data sharing between services

provided inside and outside the camps

Provider involvement in

development and adoption of tools

enhances commitment and

collaboration

Page 53: Michelle Dynes, EIS Officer/Epidemiologist, CDC Rachel Idowu, Medical Epidemiologist, CDC Ann Burton, Senior Public Health Officer, UNHCR Dina Jardaneh,

For more information please contact Centers for Disease Control and Prevention1600 Clifton Road NE, Atlanta, GA 30333Telephone, 1-800-CDC-INFO (232-4636)/TTY: 1-888-232-6348E-mail: [email protected] Web: www.cdc.gov

The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

AcknowledgementsUNHCRUNFPAMinistry of Health, Jordan Za’atari Health Actors - GSF, IMS, IRD, JHAS, MDM, MFH, MSF, RMS, Saudi ClinicCDC Syrian refugee population

Center for Global Health

Emergency Response and Recovery Branch