Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali...
Transcript of Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali...
![Page 1: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
The Political Economy of Public Sector Absence
Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2
Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4
1University of California San Diego
2New York University
3Lahore University of Management Sciences
4International Growth Centre
July 16, 2012
1 / 29
![Page 2: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Research Objective
I Health worker absence is a serious and intractable problem inPunjab, as in many other countries (Banerjee, Glennerster,Duflo, 2008).
I Public health facilities receive 87.9M patient visits a year(Punjab Development Statistics 2010)
I But doctors are rarely there...(68.5% absence among doctorsat baseline)
I Why? Tammany Hall in rural Pakistan?
I Government jobs (with few work requirements) represent acommon means of patronage.
→ Do sinecures as patronage explain the intractability ofworker absence?
2 / 29
![Page 3: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Research Objective
I Health worker absence is a serious and intractable problem inPunjab, as in many other countries (Banerjee, Glennerster,Duflo, 2008).
I Public health facilities receive 87.9M patient visits a year(Punjab Development Statistics 2010)
I But doctors are rarely there...(68.5% absence among doctorsat baseline)
I Why? Tammany Hall in rural Pakistan?
I Government jobs (with few work requirements) represent acommon means of patronage.
→ Do sinecures as patronage explain the intractability ofworker absence?
2 / 29
![Page 4: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Research Objective
I Health worker absence is a serious and intractable problem inPunjab, as in many other countries (Banerjee, Glennerster,Duflo, 2008).
I Public health facilities receive 87.9M patient visits a year(Punjab Development Statistics 2010)
I But doctors are rarely there...(68.5% absence among doctorsat baseline)
I Why? Tammany Hall in rural Pakistan?
I Government jobs (with few work requirements) represent acommon means of patronage.
→ Do sinecures as patronage explain the intractability ofworker absence?
2 / 29
![Page 5: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Direct Policy Objective
I Information bottlenecks are a problem in many governmentbureaucracies
I In Punjab, there are about 3,000 health facilities spread across205,344 square kilometers.
I This creates a range of problems:
1. Lack of data on resource utilization in hospitals, schools, andother service facilities
2. Misallocations in service delivery resources
3. Absenteeism, bribe-taking, resource theft
I Mobilizing information can improve monitoring anddecisionmaking
3 / 29
![Page 6: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Direct Policy Objective
I Information bottlenecks are a problem in many governmentbureaucracies
I In Punjab, there are about 3,000 health facilities spread across205,344 square kilometers.
I This creates a range of problems:
1. Lack of data on resource utilization in hospitals, schools, andother service facilities
2. Misallocations in service delivery resources
3. Absenteeism, bribe-taking, resource theft
I Mobilizing information can improve monitoring anddecisionmaking
3 / 29
![Page 7: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Direct Policy Objective
I Information bottlenecks are a problem in many governmentbureaucracies
I In Punjab, there are about 3,000 health facilities spread across205,344 square kilometers.
I This creates a range of problems:
1. Lack of data on resource utilization in hospitals, schools, andother service facilities
2. Misallocations in service delivery resources
3. Absenteeism, bribe-taking, resource theft
I Mobilizing information can improve monitoring anddecisionmaking
3 / 29
![Page 8: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Direct Policy Objective
I Information bottlenecks are a problem in many governmentbureaucracies
I In Punjab, there are about 3,000 health facilities spread across205,344 square kilometers.
I This creates a range of problems:
1. Lack of data on resource utilization in hospitals, schools, andother service facilities
2. Misallocations in service delivery resources
3. Absenteeism, bribe-taking, resource theft
I Mobilizing information can improve monitoring anddecisionmaking
3 / 29
![Page 9: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
This Project
I In collaboration with the Government of Punjab, implement asmartphone-based innovation to increase health facilityinspections in 18 of the 36 districts in Punjab.
I The experimental sample covers 445 distinct electoralconstituencies. Does the success of the monitoring innovationdepend on local political conditions?
4 / 29
![Page 10: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Very Preliminary Results
In collaboration with the Punjab Department of Health, we haverandomly assigned 18 of districts to a new smartphone monitoringand health data collection program. We find:
1. After two months of operation, treatment increased facilitiesreporting inspections from 23.4% to about 53%.
2. Effects are localized to districts not controlled by the rulingparty.
3. Effects are localized to electorally competitive districts.
5 / 29
![Page 11: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Punjab Department of Health (simplified)
Health Secretary
Execu/ve District Officer (EDO)
Deputy District Officer (DDO)
Medical Officer (MO)
Member, Provincial Assembly (MPA)
6 / 29
![Page 12: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Predictions
Monitoring should be less effective when...
1. the local parliamentarian belongs to the ruling party
2. the local parliamentarian wins by large margins
7 / 29
![Page 13: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Predictions
Monitoring should be less effective when...
1. the local parliamentarian belongs to the ruling party
2. the local parliamentarian wins by large margins
7 / 29
![Page 14: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Predictions
Monitoring should be less effective when...
1. the local parliamentarian belongs to the ruling party
2. the local parliamentarian wins by large margins
7 / 29
![Page 15: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Program
I A new smartphone-based health data system with severaladvantages
I Real-time data on utilization, attendance, and access
I Data are instantly and clearly summarized to provide a basisfor action
I Smartphone-based performa requires EDOs, DOs, and DDOsto make their visits (time stamps, geo stamps, pictures)
I Smartphones provided to 92 health officers in 18 districts
I Program went live in all provinces mid-March 2012
8 / 29
![Page 16: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Program
I A new smartphone-based health data system with severaladvantages
I Real-time data on utilization, attendance, and access
I Data are instantly and clearly summarized to provide a basisfor action
I Smartphone-based performa requires EDOs, DOs, and DDOsto make their visits (time stamps, geo stamps, pictures)
I Smartphones provided to 92 health officers in 18 districts
I Program went live in all provinces mid-March 2012
8 / 29
![Page 17: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
9 / 29
![Page 18: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
10 / 29
![Page 19: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
11 / 29
![Page 20: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
12 / 29
![Page 21: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Project Timeline
Aug Oct Sep Nov Jan Dec Mar Feb Apr Jun May Jul Aug Sep
Technology pilot
Baseline
Training of staff
Dashboard and phones
live
Endline 1
Endline 2
13 / 29
![Page 22: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
14 / 29
![Page 23: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Table: Verifying Balance
Control Treatment Difference P-value # Treat # Control
Prov. Swing District 0.044 0.066 0.022 0.335 182 2430.206 0.249
Nat. Swing District 0.027 0.045 0.018 0.341 182 2430.164 0.208
PML-N District 0.385 0.407 0.023 0.636 182 2430.488 0.492
Share of Assigned Staff Present 0.528 0.530 0.001 0.942 421 4260.281 0.287
Log of polio vaccinations last month 4.433 4.554 0.120 0.422 306 3241.841 1.918
MO knows local MPA (=1) 0.333 0.273 -0.061 0.306 90 1760.474 0.447
Dispenser knows MPA (=1) 0.485 0.430 -0.055 0.155 330 3440.501 0.496
Distance from Headquarter 49.178 49.662 0.484 0.817 421 39928.838 30.914
MO time at BHU (months) 52.444 50.709 -1.736 0.827 90 17574.653 53.181
MO distance to hometown 154.822 137.006 -17.817 0.648 90 176352.973 270.014
15 / 29
![Page 24: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Effect of Monitoring on Health Inspections
0.2
.4.6
.81
CD
F
-.2 -.1 0 .1 .2 .3Change in % of facilities inspected (T) - change in % of facilities inspected (C)
16 / 29
![Page 25: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
0.2
.4.6
.81
CD
F
-.2 0 .2 .4Change in % of facilities inspected (T) - change in % of facilities inspected (C)
Constituencies with ruling party representation
0.2
.4.6
.81
CD
F
-.2 0 .2 .4Change in % of facilities inspected (T) - change in % of facilities inspected (C)
Constituencies without ruling party representation
17 / 29
![Page 26: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Does Political Competition Help?
−.1
0.1
.2.3
Cha
nge
in S
hare
of F
acilit
ies
Visi
ted
0 .1 .2 .32008 Victory Margin
Treatment Districts Control Districts
18 / 29
![Page 27: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
19 / 29
![Page 28: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Main Treatment Effects
Dependent Variable: DDO Inspection During Previous Month (=1)(1) (2) (3) (3a)
OLS OLS Probit ∂y/∂x
Treat x Post 0.283*** 0.272*** 0.783*** 0.285***(0.074) (0.074) (0.216) (0.081)
Treat (=1) -0.020 -0.023 -0.093 -0.032(0.057) (0.056) (0.180) (0.062)
Post (=1) 0.022 0.036 0.108 0.037(0.053) (0.052) (0.169) (0.057)
Constant 0.234*** 0.297*** -0.551**(0.044) (0.078) (0.226)
# Observations 1384 1384 1384 1384# Clusters 35 35 35 35R-Squared [Log-Likelihood] 0.074 0.132 -761.674
Notes: Level of significance: *p < 0.1, **p < 0.05, ***p < 0.01. Standard errors clustered
at the district level reported in parentheses.
20 / 29
![Page 29: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Treatment Effect Heterogeneity by Ruling Party Control
Dependent Variable: DDO Inspection During Previous Month (=1)(1) (2) (3) (3a)
OLS OLS Probit ∂y/∂x
Treat x Post (γ̂2) 0.330*** 0.317*** 0.889*** 0.323***(0.081) (0.081) (0.244) (0.091)
Treat x Post x Ruling Party (γ̂3) -0.165 -0.179* -0.311 -0.096(0.098) (0.099) (0.369) (0.102)
Constant (γ̂1) 0.227*** 0.279*** -0.602**(0.044) (0.081) (0.237)
P-value from test of γ2 = γ3 0.003 0.003 0.022P-value from test of γ2 + γ3 = 0 0.091 0.161 0.089Stratum FEs No Yes YesR-Squared [Log-Likelihood] 0.098 0.155 [-660.977]# Observations 1227 1227 1227 1227# Clusters 35 35 35 35
Notes: Level of significance: *p < 0.1, **p < 0.05, ***p < 0.01. Standard errors clustered at
the district level reported in parentheses. All specifications include the complete set of interactions
between Treat, Post, and Ruling Party. Victory Margin Share is defined as the difference in votes
between the winner and runner-up divided by the total number of votes cast for those two candidates.
Basic Health Units (BHUs) are spread across 227 of 445 provincial assembly districts in Punjab.
21 / 29
![Page 30: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Treatment Effect Heterogeneity by 2008 Vote Share
Dependent Variable: DDO Inspection During Previous Month (=1)(1) (2) (3) (3a)
OLS OLS Probit ∂y/∂x
Treat x Post (γ̂2) 0.395*** 0.377*** 1.058*** 0.384***(0.099) (0.098) (0.293) (0.107)
Treat x Post x Victory Margin Share (γ̂3) -0.611 -0.599 -1.327 -0.450(0.380) (0.383) (1.298) (0.443)
Constant (γ̂1) 0.234*** 0.298*** -0.545**(0.053) (0.088) (0.259)
P-value from test of γ2 = γ3 0.030 0.036 0.106P-value from test of γ2 + γ3 = 0 0.520 0.516 0.818Stratum FEs No Yes YesR-Squared [Log-Likelihood] 0.092 0.155 [-660.175]# Observations 1227 1227 1227 1227# Clusters 35 35 35 35
Notes: Level of significance: *p < 0.1, **p < 0.05, ***p < 0.01. Standard errors clustered at the district
level reported in parentheses. All specifications include the complete set of interactions between Treat, Post,
and Victory Margin Share. Victory Margin Share is defined as the difference in votes between the winner and
runner-up divided by the total number of votes cast for those two candidates. Basic Health Units (BHUs) are
spread across 227 of 445 provincial assembly districts in Punjab.
22 / 29
![Page 31: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Results
750
1000
1250
1500
1750
2000
Tota
l Vis
its
Mar Apr May JunMonth
Total Visits to BHUs in Program Districts
23 / 29
![Page 32: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Results
2530
3540
4550
Per
cent
faci
litie
s vi
site
d by
DD
O
November JuneMonth
Treatment Control
24 / 29
![Page 33: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Next Steps
I Continue quarterly surveys to examine health workerattendance
I Consider other applications:I Lady health supervisorsI Livestock innoculationI EducationI Monitoring mobile money agentsI Police registration
I Household surveys to examine health impacts
25 / 29
![Page 34: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
’
26 / 29
![Page 35: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
0.2
5.5
.75
1
MO Gov’t MO Primary Para Gov’t Para Primary
Absence Ratio Confidence Interval
Absence by Data Source
Notes: Data are from 847 of the 850 Basic Health Units in the primary sample for
which government data are also recorded.
26 / 29
![Page 36: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
(Very) preliminary evidence
27 / 29
![Page 37: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Table: Health Worker Absence in Primary and Government Data
Primary Government Difference t-test of:Data Data (1) - (2)
(1) (2) (1) - (2) (p-value)
Doctor Absent (=1) 0.685 0.635 0.050 0.005[0.465] [0.482] 0.018
Paramedic Staff Absent (=1) 0.208 0.100 0.107 0.000[0.406] [0.301] (0.016)
# Basic Health Units 847 847
Notes: Standard deviations in brackets and standard errors reported in parentheses. Data are
from 847 of the 850 Basic Health Units in the primary sample for which government data are also
recorded. Doctors are Medical Officers (MOs). Paramedic staff are Medical Technicians (MTs),
Health Technicians (HTs), and Dispensers.
28 / 29
![Page 38: Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain Yasir Khan€¦ · Michael Callen1 Saad Gulzar2 Ali Hasanain3 Yasir Khan4 1University of California San Diego 2New York University 3Lahore](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051607/603a6c63be1f83208f192d8f/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
01
23
4
0 .2 .4 .6 .8 1Share of Assigned Staff Absent
Primary Data (12/11) Gov’t Data (Avg. 01/08 − 12/11)Gov’t Data (12/11)
Worker Absence Densities by Data Source
Notes: Empirical densities estimated using a Gaussian Kernel. Data are from 847 of
the 850 Basic Health Units in the primary sample for which government data are also
recorded.
29 / 29