MHD related activities for DCLL Presented by Sergey Smolentsev, UCLA FNST MEEETING August 18-20,...

MHD related activities for DCLL

Presented by Sergey Smolentsev, UCLA

FNST MEEETING

August 18-20, 2009

Rice Room, 6764 Boelter Hall, UCLA

LAYOUT

• Assessment of DCLL IB DEMO blanket

• SiC-PbLi slip phenomena

• Status of “mixed convection” studies

• Status of “corrosion” code development

• Modeling Chinese “FCI” experiment

• “Corrosion” experiment with SiC in Riga and related activities

Assessment of DCLL IB blanket, 1

(a) (b)

(c)

(d)

Sketch of the IB DEMO blanket. Only 3 lower modules are shown. (a) Front view, including the blanket modules, He and PbLi access ducts, vacuum vessel, and the TF coil. (b) Rear view. Only the PbLi carrying elements and the TF coil are shown. (c) He and PbLi access ducts. (d) PbLi access ducts.

IB versus OB DEMO blanket:•smaller available space•lower heat load (the average neutron wall load is 1.33 MW/m2)

•long poloidal path of the PbLi flows (~2-4 m)

•significantly higher magnetic field (10-12 T against 4-6 T)

Analysis:3D MHD pressure dropEffect of FCI on p2D in poloidal flowsFlow in the access ducts

Main focus: How high is the MHD pressure drop?

Principal DCLL DEMO IB blanketdesign with He and PbLi access pipes

S. Smolentsev, C. Wong, S. Malang, M. Dagher, M. Abdou,MHD Considerations for the DCLL Inboard Blanket,

ISFNT-9, Dalian, China, 2009.


is the local pressure drop coefficientN is the interaction number

3D flow Ha N k p3D, MPa

Blanket. Inlet manifold 26500 7000 1.5 0.49

Blanket. Outlet manifold 26500 7000 1.5 0.49

Access duct (internal). Fringing field 13250 930 0.5 0.31

Access duct (annulus). Fringing field

26500 3750 0.5 0.14

Summary of 3D MHD pressure drop

Inlet/outletmanifold

Flow in a fringing field

23

1

2D mp U kN

, 0.2 2k is the empirical constant k

•Average NWL: 1.33 MW/m2

•Magnetic field: 10 T•PbLi Tin/Tout=450/750C•Velocity in a blanket duct: 0.015 m/s•Each module: 1.4x1.4x0.5 m•12 poloidal ducts per module, 0.2x0.2 m•The longest access duct is 4.2 m•5 mm SiC FCI

Total MHD pressure drop = 1.43 MPa < 2 MPa(providing ~1-10 S/m)


Effectiveness of the 5 mm SiC FCI as electric insulator in the poloidal IB blanket flow in a 10 T magnetic field (Ha=26500).

Effect of FCI electrical conductivity on MHD pressure drop in poloidal flows

3~ 10P MPa 2~ 10 1~ 10

Ideal insulation

<0.1 S/m - ideal insulation~1 S/m - p2D~10-3 MPa~10 S/m - p2D~10-2 MPa~100 S/m - p2D~10-1 MPa~1000 S/m - p2D~1 MPa

•If ~100 S/m, p2D~ p3D

Our goal is to have p2D<< p3D.Therefore, <100 S/m is required(<1-10 S/m is desired)


MAGNETIC FIELD

(a) (b)

Sketch of the cross-section of the PbLi access duct (a) and the computational mesh (b).

Flow in the access ducts

“cold” PbLi flow in: annulus“hot” PbLi flow out: inner duct

Assessment of DCLL IB blanket, 5Flow in the access ducts

- 2 - 1 0 1 2y / b

-1 .2

-0.8

-0.4

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

Vel

ocity

- 2 - 1 0 1 2y / b

- 1

- 0 . 5

0

0 . 5

1

1 . 5

Vel

ocity

B=

4 T,

=

0B

=4 T

, =

10 S

/m

•No flow occurs in the sections of the annulus perpendicular to B

•This may cause lack of cooling of the inner duct

•Pipe-in-pipe geometry looks attractive

•Turbulence (if appears) will likely result in better cooling

More studies for accessducts needed


CONCLUSIONS

• The total MHD pressure drop is 1.43 MPa (30%) • We are approaching the limit of 2 MPa. Special care

should be taken in case of any design modifications <100 S/m (5 mm FCI) is required, <1-10 S/m is desired• Flows in access ducts need more analysis (including

possible turbulence effects) as the present studies suggest lack of cooling. Pipe-in-pipe configuration seems to be the best option

SiC-PbLi slip phenomena, 1• Recent studies suggest that SiC is

not fully wetted by PbLi Pint, B.A., More, K.L., Meyer, H.M., Distefano, J.R.: Recent

progress addressing compatibility issues relevant to fusion environments, Fusion Science and Technology, 47, 851-855 (2005)

Morley, N.B., Medina, A., Abdou, M.A.: Measurements of specific electrical contact resistance between SiC and lead-lithium eutectic alloy, TOFE 18, San Francisco, Sep. 28 – Oct. 2, Book of Abstracts, P2.66, (2008)

Changho, P., Kazuyuki, N., Yamamoto, Y., Konishi, S.: Compatibility of materials for advanced blanket with liquid LiPb, TOFE 18, San Francisco, Sep. 28 – Oct. 2, Book of Abstracts, P1.67 (2008)

• Poor wetting is direct indication of slip phenomena

• We use a parameter called “slip length” to include the slip effect in MHD/HT models

CORROSION OF SILICON CARBIDE FILTER INMOLTEN METAL

K. Sujirote and K. GoyadoolyaNational Metal and Materials Technology Center

Science Park, Pathumthani 12120 Thailand

“Due to its non-wetting behavior, and excellent resistance to corrosion and thermal shock, corrugated silicon carbide filter is suitable for filtering molten metal.”

SiC-PbLi slip phenomena, 2

Slip length

increases

The slip effect can affect blanket flows in two ways:

1. Reduction of MHD pressure drop – definitely a useful tendency

2. More unstable flows –effect on heat and mass transfer; not fully understood yet

S. Smolentsev, MHD duct flows under hydrodynamic “slip” condition, Theor. Comput. Fluid Dyn., published online May 19, 2009.

Characterization of slip effect on MHD flow

SiC-PbLi slip phenomena, 3Reduction of MHD pressure drop

The slip length can vary from nanometers to microns or even tens of microns for specially designed superhydrophobic surfaces.

Assumption: the slip length is 1 mOB: MHD pressure drop reduction: 2 timesIB: MHD pressure drop reduction: 3 times

Assumption: the slip length is 10 mOB: MHD pressure drop reduction: 10 timesIB: MHD pressure drop reduction: 20 times

Superhydrophobic bio-fiber surfaces via tailored grafting architecture by Daniel Nystrom, et al, Chem. Commun., 2006, 3594–3596

Along with electrical insulation, utilization of slip effectbetween SiC and PbLi could be considered as another approach to control the MHD pressure drop in DCLL.

Example: =100 S/m superhydrophobic FCIis equivalent to =10 S/m no-slip FCI

Q: Can we engineer SiC superhydrophobic surfaces?

SiC-PbLi slip phenomena, 4Suggested experiment to

demonstrate that slip effect does exist by measuring the contact

angle

Inert gas

PbLi droplet

Heated SiC substrate

1. Simple demonstration experiments for PbLi-SiC

2. Flow-involving experiments to confirm directly the interfacial slip and quantify the slip length3. Understanding the interfacial slip mechanisms4. More detailed modeling of the effect of interfacial slip on MHD

flows / HT in blanket conditions5. Development and testing SiC-

based superhydrophobic surfacesPrincipal scheme

Steps towards development of SiC-based

superhydrophobic surfaces

SiC-PbLi slip phenomena, 5

CONCLUSIONS

• A strong effect of the interfacial slip on MHD flows (and also as a consequence, on heat and mass transfer) can be predicted

• Providing the slip length is of order of microns, the reduction of MHD pressure drop can be as high as ~10-20 times

• Engineering and utilizing superhydrophobic SiC surfaces in DCLL might be an effective approach (along with development of simple electrical insulation) to control the MHD pressure drop

• Further analysis on qualification of slip effect on heat and mass transfer is needed

Status of “mixed convection” studies

Pre-experimental analysis has been accomplished showing that major mixed convection effects can be simulated in lab conditions.

Preparation to the mixed convection experiment is in progress.

Linear stability analysis and non-linear numerical simulations demonstrate very rich physics. We have significantly advanced recently in understanding mixed convection phenomenon in DCLL blanket conditions.

Status of “corrosion” code development

There are three steps envisaged in the modelling effort for the compatibility of the ferritic/martensitic steels with the eutectic lead-lithium alloy in a fusion blanket system

1. Relatively simple and easy-to-use code, limited to the analysis of the transport of wall material from the wall/LM interface into the flowing liquid metal for canonical flow geometries and relatively simple flow conditions. This is where we are now

2. Conversion of this code into a subroutine to be used in an

available code describing MHD, heat transport, turbulence, buoyancy flow …. under the conditions of a fusion blanket (HIMAG).

3. Use of the experience gained with these codes in a new comprehensive code system to be developed for the prediction of the integral behaviour of a liquid metal fusion blanket.

Modeling Chinese “FCI” experiment, 1

Picture of experimental MHD facilities in the Southerstern Institute of Physics (SWIP), China.

We have unofficial collaboration with theMHD group in China lead by Prof. Zengyu Xu

Accepted for publication inMagnetohydrodynamics, 2009


Dimension Notation Value, m

Half-width of the FCI box b 0.023

Half-height of the FCI box a 0.027

FCI thickness tFCI 0.002

Thickness of the gap tg 0.005

Thickness of the slot ts 0.003

Thickness of the Fe wall tw 0.002

Magnetic field•2 mm FCI made of epoxy provides ideal electrical insulation•Maximum magnetic field is 2 T (Ha=2400)•Uniform B-field: 740 mm (length) x 170 mm (width) x 80 mm (height)

•Outer SS rectangular duct: 1500 mm long•FCI box: 1000 mm long •Pressure equalization openings: slot (PES) or holes (PES)•Measurements: pressure drop, velocity (LEVI)

Modeling was performed under the experimental conditionsusing the fully developed flow model

Modeling Chinese “FCI” experiment, 3•Experiment shows significant decrease in the MHD pressure drop by FCI•Experiment also demonstrates better pressure drop reduction in the PEH case compared to the PES•The computations show much more pressure drop reduction compared to the experiment

Prof. Xu: The flow is fully developed but the openings result in extra currents leading to extra high flow opposing forceSergey: There is no way the opening can cause such strong currents but the flow is developing

How to explain the differencebetween the experiment and theory?


Modeling confirms that there is a current loop associated with the pressure equalization opening but the current is too small to cause such a high MHD pressure drop

The pressure drop includes p3D(due to fringing magnetic

field) and p2D. It appears that in the experiment, p3D~ p2D.

Recommendation (experiment):(1) to measure pressure drop in the bulk (not in the gap)(2) to have more measurements of

electric potential

Recommendation (modeling):(1) to perform computations in 3D

“Corrosion” experiment with SiC in Riga

and related activities, 1

A picture of the PbLi loop with auxiliary equipment in the Institute of Physics in Riga, Latvia.

•Starting from the last summer we have intensive discussions with the Institute of Physics in Riga, Latvia (O.Lielausis, A.Shishko) on a joint research on SiC FCI in PbLi in a strong magnetic field•Other interested people: Prof. Rene Moreau (France) and material people from Grenoble•Plan: Latvia – experiment, UCLA – modeling, Prof. Moreau – development of a mathematical model•Although all parties are technically ready to start, Latvian group looks for about 50 K a year for this experiment



Z

Y

Bo

stainlesssteel

316L

SiC

Pb17Li

f1

f2

Cross-section of the test-section with the SiC plate

The main goal is to address MHD/corrosion phenomena when a SiC sample is washed by a flowing PbLi in the presence of a strong magnetic field.

•Outer duct: SS, 180 mm x 40 mm x 20 mm , 1.5 mm thick. •SiC plate: 100 mm x 40 mm. The thickness is 2 to 5 mm.•The SiC sample is fixed using 10 rectangular brackets (shown in red) made of non-magnetic steel AISI 316 L.•PbLi velocity: 5 cm/s.•Magnetic field: 5 T.•Nominal temperature of PbLi: 550C. •Duration of the experiment: 500 hours.•Bulk velocity is controlled by measuring the electric potential difference. Pressure drop is measured over the whole length of the test-section.•In the end of the experiment the SiC sample and all 10 brackets will be extracted and carefully weighted. An additional microscopic analysis can be performed either in Latvia, France or US.



B=0 B=1.8 T

Macrostructure of the washed samples after contact with the PbLi flow

Similar experiments on corrosion of FS in PbLi in Riga

From: F. Muktepavela et al. EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES OF THE STRONG MAGNETIC FIELD ACTION ON THE CORROSION OF RAFM STEELS IN Pb17Li MELT FLOWS, PAMIR 7, 2008

Corrosion rate for samples withand without a magnetic field

Strong experimental evidence of significant effect of the applied magnetic field on corrosion rate.


and related activities, 4Summary of the observations made with the Grenoble SEM (Scanning Electronic Microscope) and with optical microscopes (July 21, 2009).

• The main effect is an erosion of the wall• The eroded material is transported by the fluid flow without any re-deposition• The grooves in the eroded wall seem to be a footprint of periodic rolls that appear due to instability of Hartmann layers. Some irregularities are also present due to 3D disturbances in the flow.• The key mechanism might be coupling between the hydrodynamic instability (responsible for the rolls) and chemical dissolution of the wall material (probably related to an electro-migration effect).

Yves Bréchet, René Moreau and Laurent Maniguet

MHD related activities for DCLL Presented by Sergey Smolentsev, UCLA FNST MEEETING August 18-20,...

Documents

Transcript of MHD related activities for DCLL Presented by Sergey Smolentsev, UCLA FNST MEEETING August 18-20,...