MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and...

53
1 MEMORANDUM TO: Members, Cambridge Planning Board City of Cambridge CDD Staff FROM: MIT DATE: May 12, 2016 RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update Attached please find an updated wind study prepared by RWDI which compares the existing wind condition in the Kendall Square area with the proposed condition at the time of MIT Kendall Project completion. This study supersedes the study submitted in the November 5, 2015 Final Development Plan as it reflects additional design strategies that significantly improve the proposed wind condition and addresses the specific concerns raised by Planning Board members. Below is a brief summary of methodology and results. A. GENERAL METHODOLOGY Wind conditions related to the proposed MIT Kendall Project were evaluated by RWDI, an international engineering firm that specializes in testing and analysis of wind conditions. The analysis is based on accepted “BRA Criteria” that evaluates both Mean Speed and Effective Gust Conditions. Mean Speed evaluates the relative level of pedestrian comfort expressed in terms of 1-hour mean wind speed exceeded 1% of the time. o Comfortable for Sitting <=12 mph o Comfortable for Standing > 12 and < = 15 mph o Comfortable for Walking > 15 and <= 19 mph o Uncomfortable for Walking > 19 and <= 27 mph o Dangerous > 27 mph Effective Gust evaluates locations for gust velocity and characterizes those areas where gusts exceed 31 mph more than 1% of the time as “Unacceptable”. Anything else is considered Acceptable”. The study evaluates both Mean Speed and Effective Gust criteria in Annual and Seasonal (Spring, Summer, Fall and Winter) conditions. Mean Speed on an Annual basis is the best representation of the typical conditions felt by the pedestrian throughout the year. SPECIFIC KENDALL SQUARE STUDY METHODOLOGY In order to comprehensively assess wind activity, the MIT Kendall Wind Study included approximately 170 sensor locations in and around PUD-5. 139 of the sensors were at the pedestrian (ground) level while 31 were located at podium level.

Transcript of MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and...

Page 1: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

1

MEMORANDUM

TO: Members, Cambridge Planning Board City of Cambridge CDD Staff

FROM: MIT

DATE: May 12, 2016

RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update

Attached please find an updated wind study prepared by RWDI which compares the existing wind condition in the Kendall Square area with the proposed condition at the time of MIT Kendall Project completion. This study supersedes the study submitted in the November 5, 2015 Final Development Plan as it reflects additional design strategies that significantly improve the proposed wind condition and addresses the specific concerns raised by Planning Board members. Below is a brief summary of methodology and results.

A. GENERAL METHODOLOGY

• Wind conditions related to the proposed MIT Kendall Project were evaluated by RWDI, aninternational engineering firm that specializes in testing and analysis of wind conditions.

• The analysis is based on accepted “BRA Criteria” that evaluates both Mean Speed and EffectiveGust Conditions.

• Mean Speed evaluates the relative level of pedestrian comfort expressed in terms of 1-hourmean wind speed exceeded 1% of the time.

o Comfortable for Sitting <=12 mph o Comfortable for Standing > 12 and < = 15 mph o Comfortable for Walking > 15 and <= 19 mph o Uncomfortable for Walking > 19 and <= 27 mph o Dangerous > 27 mph

• Effective Gust evaluates locations for gust velocity and characterizes those areas where gustsexceed 31 mph more than 1% of the time as “Unacceptable”. Anything else is considered“Acceptable”.

• The study evaluates both Mean Speed and Effective Gust criteria in Annual and Seasonal(Spring, Summer, Fall and Winter) conditions.

• Mean Speed on an Annual basis is the best representation of the typical conditions felt by thepedestrian throughout the year.

SPECIFIC KENDALL SQUARE STUDY METHODOLOGY

• In order to comprehensively assess wind activity, the MIT Kendall Wind Study includedapproximately 170 sensor locations in and around PUD-5.

• 139 of the sensors were at the pedestrian (ground) level while 31 were located at podium level.

Page 2: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

2

• The analysis compares Existing condition (No build) with the Built condition (with proposedproject).

• The proposed MIT Kendall Project has been evaluated in RWDI’s wind tunnel four times. Thishas enabled the team to understand where there are potential issues, develop and implementmitigation strategies and re-test them in the wind tunnel.

• Unless noted, the results below compare the Existing Condition with the proposed BuiltCondition as tested and shown in the accompanying MIT Kendall Square Initiative, PedestrianWind Comfort Study prepared by RWDI and dated May 11, 2016. These May 11 results reflectthe design teams’ most up to date mitigation strategies including building canopies andawnings, landscaping/species additions, and wind screens.

B. MIT KENDALL RESULTS - ANNUAL

1. MEAN SPEED ON AN ANNUAL BASIS

• In the Existing (2015) condition there are:o No “Dangerous” conditionso 22 “Uncomfortable” conditionso Remaining 117 are “Comfortable” for sitting, standing or walking.

• In the Build condition, there are:o No “Dangerous” conditionso 20 “Uncomfortable” conditionso Remaining 119 are “Comfortable” for sitting, standing or walking. (The project

resulted in fluctuations between “Comfortable” categories from the ExistingCondition. This can be seen on data sheets but are not discussed in detail here.)

• Therefore, the proposed Kendall Square project (NoMa and SoMa):o Generally maintains the existing complex urban wind condition.o Improves 13 locations from “Uncomfortable” to “Comfortable” (13, 14, 15, 33, 35,

46, 58, 64, 96, 110, 112, 137, 141).o Maintains 9 locations as “Uncomfortable” (19, 27, 28, 30, 39, 42, 53, 63, 146).o Deteriorates 10 locations from “Comfortable” to “Uncomfortable” (10, 36, 51, 56,

83, 92, 94, 124, 126, 133, 136).• Of the 20 locations still “Uncomfortable” in the Build condition:

o 10 are outside of the PUD development parcels. All but one of these (51) were“Uncomfortable” in the Existing condition and the project does not change them. 146 – South corner of Ames/Main (E19) 63 – Point Park 53 – At One Main Street 28 and 36 – North side of Broad Canal Way 42, 39, 30, 27 – Other areas around Third Street/Watermark/BioMed 51 – At 101 Main

o 10 are within the PUD development parcels and we are focusing on these areas aswe enter design review. The eight “Uncomfortable” areas within the SoMa PUD development

parcels have average annual wind speeds ranging from 20 -22 mph which

Page 3: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

3

are very near the threshold for “Comfortable.” (56, 83, 92, 94, 124, 126, 133, 136)

For NoMa, the average annual windspeed for sensor 10 is 22mph and forsensor 19 is 23 mph. Again, near the threshold for “Comfortable.”

2. EFFECTIVE GUST ON AN ANNUAL BASIS

• In the Existing condition, 5 pedestrian sensors register “Unacceptable” gusts on anannual basis. (13, 30, 42, 53, 146).

• The project improves annual Effective Gust conditions. In the Built Condition onlytwo “Unacceptable” conditions remain (30 and 53.) Both of these are outside of thePUD and are not easily improved by the project.

C. MIT KENDALL RESULTS – SEASONAL

1. MEAN SPEED BY SEASON

In the Existing (2015) condition, two sensors register as “Dangerous” for at least one seasonal evaluation (53 in spring and winter, 146 winter).

As noted by the Planning Board, in the Built condition without mitigation analysis conducted in November 2015, 5 sensors showed “Dangerous” for at least one season (53 only in spring, 83 winter, 92 winter, 94 winter, 157 winter).

In the May study, all of these “Dangerous” conditions have been eliminated. The project with mitigation eliminates both the “Dangerous” conditions that were created in the Built condition and those that are already Existing in the area.

Seasonal “Uncomfortable” mean speed conditions continue in both the Existing and the Built condition, primarily in the Winter and Spring seasons and many at the sensors that are already identified as “Uncomfortable” in the Annual condition. The team will continue to look at all of these areas but this seasonal condition is entirely consistent with urban wind conditions throughout Boston and Cambridge.

2. EFFECTIVE GUST BY SEASON

Consistent with the above there remain seasonal “Unacceptable” gust conditions in both the Existing and Built conditions, primarily in the Winter and Spring and many at the sensors that are already identified as “Unacceptable” in the Annual condition. The team will continue to look at all of these areas but this seasonal condition is entirely consistent with urban wind conditions throughout Boston and Cambridge.

####

Page 4: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

This document is intended for the sole use of the party to whom it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged and/or confidential. If you have received this in error, please notify us immediately.

® RWDI name and logo are registered trademarks in Canada and the United States of America

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

MIT Kendall Square Initiative Cambridge, MA

Draft Report

Pedestrian Wind Comfort Study RWDI # 1502103

May 11, 2016

SUBMITTED TO

Sandra Smith, AIA, LEED AP Perkins+Will

225 Franklin Street, Suite 1100 Boston, MA 02110

(617) 406-3424 [email protected]

SUBMITTED BY

Kevin Bauman, B.Eng., E.I.T Technical Coordinator

[email protected]

Jordan Gilmour, P.Eng. Associate / Senior Project Manager

T: 519-823-1311 x 2343 [email protected]

Hanqing Wu, Ph.D, P.Eng Principal/ Technical Director

[email protected]

Page 5: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

MIT Kendall Square Initiative - Cambridge, MA Pedestrian Wind Study RWDI#1502103 May 11, 2016

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................................ 1

Tables

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories

Figures

Figure 1a: Test Setup – No Build Figure 1b: Test Setup – Full Build with Mitigation

Figure 2a: Directional Distribution (%) of Winds (Spring/Summer) Figure 2b: Directional Distribution (%) of Winds (Fall/Winter) Figure 2c: Directional Distribution (%) of Winds (Annual)

Figure 3a: Pedestrian Wind Conditions – Mean Speed - No Build (Annual) Figure 3b: Pedestrian Wind Conditions – Mean Speed - Full Build with Mitigation (Annual)

Figure 4a: Pedestrian Wind Conditions – Effective Gust Speed – No Build (Annual) Figure 4b: Pedestrian Wind Conditions – Effective Gust Speed – Full Build with Mitigation (Annual)

Page 6: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

MIT Kendall Square Initiative - Cambridge, MA Pedestrian Wind Study RWDI#1502103 May 11, 2016

Page 1

1. SUMMARY

A pedestrian wind comfort study was conducted on the proposed MIT Kendall Square Initiative Project located in Cambridge, Massachusetts. The project will be a Mixed Use Project for MIT as part of the East Campus Development at Kendall Square. The objective of the study was to assess the effect of the proposed development on local conditions in pedestrian areas throughout and around the study site and provide recommendations for minimizing adverse effects.

The study involved wind simulations on a 1:300 scale model of the proposed building and surroundings. These simulations were then conducted in RWDI’s boundary-layer wind tunnel at Guelph, Ontario, for the purpose of quantifying local wind speed conditions and comparing to appropriate criteria for gauging wind comfort in pedestrian areas. The criteria recommended by the Boston Redevelopment Authority (BRA) were used in this study. The results can be found in the Table and Figures accompanying this report.

Page 7: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Employee Job Title

FIGURESFIGURES

Page 8: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Wind Tunnel Study Model Figure No. 1a No Build

Date: December 1, 2015 MIT Kendall Square Initiative – Cambridge, MA Project #1502103

Page 9: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Wind Tunnel Study Model Figure No. 1bFull Build + Oak Trees

Date: May 10, 2016 MIT Kendall Square Initiative – Cambridge, MA Project #1502103

Page 10: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Directional Distribution (%) of Winds (Blowing From) Figure No. 2a Boston Logan International Airport (1983 - 2013)

Date: May 05, 2016 MIT Kendall Square Initiative – Cambridge, MA Project #1502103

Spring (March - May)

Summer (June - August)

Wind Speed (mph)

Probability (%) Spring Summer

Calm 2.0 2.1

1-5 5.5 7.4

6-10 27.5 36.6

11-15 33.5 36.4

16-20 20.7 14.6

>20 10.8 3.0

Page 11: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Directional Distribution (%) of Winds (Blowing From) Figure No. 2b

Boston Logan International Airport (1983 - 2013)

Date: May 05, 2016 MIT Kendall Square Initiative – Cambridge, MA Project #1502103

Fall

(September - November)

Winter

(December - February)

Wind Speed

(mph) Probability (%)

Fall Winter

Calm 2.3 1.8

1-5 6.9 5.3

6-10 32.7 26.1

11-15 33.9 31.8

16-20 16.8 21.8

>20 7.3 13.2

Page 12: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Directional Distribution (%) of Winds (Blowing From) Figure No. 2c

Boston Logan International Airport (1983 - 2013)

Date: May 05, 2016 MIT Kendall Square Initiative – Cambridge, MA Project #1502103

Annual Winds

Wind Speed (mph)

Probability (%)

Calm 2.0

1-5 6.3

6-10 30.8

11-15 33.9

16-20 18.5

>20 8.6

Page 13: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

THIR

D ST

REET

WAD

SWO

RTH

STR

EET

AMHERST STREET

HAY

WAR

D S

TREE

T

CAR

LETO

N S

TREE

T

BROADWAY STREET

CHARLOTTE'S WAY

DO

CK

STR

EET

MAIN STREET

AMES

STR

EET BRO

AD CANAL WAY

BOSTONMARRIOTT

CAMBRIDGE

EXISTING

EXISTING

49

42

41

44

39

40

38

54

5556

57

5860

6162

32

31

53

5251

50

45

46

43

33

37

3436

35

30

28

29

63

59

65 64

6667

26

24

22

27

25

23

20

21

11

1314

12

1

2

17

16

18

15

19

34

568

47

48

6

9

8

7

10

83

86

79

9198

99

93

95

97

94

96

89

90

9277

80

78

82

81

84

8587 88

MIT Kendall Square Initiative - Cambridge, MA

Figure:

Approx. Scale:

Date Revised:

True North Drawn by: ARM

0 75 150ft

1"=150'

May. 6, 2016Project #1502103

MEAN SPEED CATEGORIES:

Dangerous

Standing

Uncomfortable

Walking

Sitting

LEGEND:

Grade Level

SENSOR LOCATION:

3aPedestrian Wind Conditions - Mean SpeedNo BuildAnnual

Podium Level

Page 14: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

THIR

D ST

REET

WAD

SWO

RTH

STR

EET

AMHERST STREET

HAY

WAR

D S

TREE

T

CAR

LETO

N S

TREE

T

BROADWAY STREET

DO

CK

STR

EET

MAIN STREET

AMES

STR

EET BRO

AD CANAL WAY

BUILDING ABOVEREMOVED FOR

CLARITY OF GRADELEVEL SENSORS

BOSTONMARRIOTT

CAMBRIDGE

BUILDINGABOVE

REMOVEDFOR

CLARITYOF GRADE

LEVELSENSORS

SITE 6

SITE 2SITE 3

SITE 5

CHARLOTTE'S WAY

49

42

41

44

39

40

38

54

5556

57

5860

6162

32

31

53

5251

50

45

46

43

33

37

3436

35

30

28

29

63

59

65 64

6667

26

24

22

27

25

23

20

21

11

1314

12

1

2

17

16

18

19

34

568

47

48

6

9

8

7

10

83

86

79

9198

99

93

95

97

94

96

89

90

9277

80

78

82

81

84

8587 88

15

MIT Kendall Square Initiative - Cambridge, MA

Figure:

Approx. Scale:

Date Revised:

True North Drawn by: EM

0 75 150ft

1"=150'

Apr. 8, 2016Project #1502103

MEAN SPEED CATEGORIES:

Dangerous

Standing

Uncomfortable

Walking

Sitting

LEGEND:

Grade Level

Podium Level

Roof Level

SENSOR LOCATION: LANDSCAPING:

Oak Trees

Deciduous Trees

Wind Screen

3F Full Build + Oak TreesAnnual

Pedestrian Wind Conditions - Mean Speed 3b

Page 15: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

THIR

D ST

REET

WAD

SWO

RTH

STR

EET

AMHERST STREET

HAY

WAR

D S

TREE

T

CAR

LETO

N S

TREE

T

BROADWAY STREET

DO

CK

STR

EET

MAIN STREET

AMES

STR

EET BRO

AD CANAL WAY

BOSTONMARRIOTT

CAMBRIDGE

EXISTING

EXISTING

CHARLOTTE'S WAY

49

42

41

44

39

40

38

54

5556

57

5860

6162

32

31

53

5251

50

45

46

43

33

37

3436

35

30

28

29

63

59

65 64

6667

26

24

22

27

25

23

20

21

11

1314

12

1

2

17

16

18

15

19

34

568

47

48

6

9

8

7

10

83

86

79

9198

99

93

95

97

94

96

89

90

9277

80

78

82

81

84

8587 88

MIT Kendall Square Initiative - Cambridge, MA

Figure:

Approx. Scale:

Date Revised:

True North Drawn by: EM

0 75 150ft

1"=150'

May. 6 2016Project #1502103

EFFECTIVE GUST CATEGORIES:

LEGEND:

Podium Level

Grade Level

SENSOR LOCATION:

Unacceptable

Acceptable

Pedestrian Wind Conditions - Effective GustNo BuildAnnual

4a

Page 16: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

THIR

D ST

REET

WAD

SWO

RTH

STR

EET

AMHERST STREET

HAY

WAR

D S

TREE

T

CAR

LETO

N S

TREE

T

BROADWAY STREET

DO

CK

STR

EET

MAIN STREET

AMES

STR

EET BRO

AD CANAL WAY

BUILDING ABOVEREMOVED FOR

CLARITY OF GRADELEVEL SENSORS

BOSTONMARRIOTT

CAMBRIDGE

BUILDINGABOVE

REMOVEDFOR

CLARITYOF GRADE

LEVELSENSORS

SITE 6

SITE 2SITE 3

SITE 5

CHARLOTTE'S WAY

49

42

41

44

39

40

38

54

5556

57

5860

6162

32

31

53

5251

50

45

46

43

33

37

3436

35

30

28

29

63

59

65 64

6667

26

24

22

27

25

23

20

21

11

1314

12

1

2

17

16

18

19

34

568

47

48

6

9

8

7

10

83

86

79

9198

99

93

95

97

94

96

89

90

9277

80

78

82

81

84

8587 88

15

MIT Kendall Square Initiative - Cambridge, MA

Figure:

Approx. Scale:

Date Revised:

True North Drawn by: EM

0 75 150ft

1"=150'

Apr. 8, 2016Project #1502103

EFFECTIVE GUST CATEGORIES:

LEGEND:

Podium Level

Grade Level

Roof Level

SENSOR LOCATION:

Unacceptable

Acceptable

LANDSCAPING:

Oak Trees

Deciduous Trees

Wind Screen

4bPedestrian Wind Conditions - Effective GustFull Build + Oak TreesAnnual

Page 17: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Employee Job Title

TABLESTABLES

Page 18: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 1 of 36

1 A Spring 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 17 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 20 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable 2 A Spring 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 23 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable 3 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable 4 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable

Page 19: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 2 of 36

5 A Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 21 Acceptable 6 A Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 18 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 24 Acceptable 7 A Spring 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 23 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 19 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 23 Acceptable 8 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 7 Sitting 12 Acceptable Summer 6 Sitting 9 Acceptable Fall 7 Sitting 11 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable

Page 20: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 3 of 36

9 A Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 11 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable 10 A Spring 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 25 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable B Spring 22 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Winter 27 Uncomfortable 36 Unacceptable Annual 22 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable 11 A Spring 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Summer 7 Sitting 12 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable 12 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 27 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable

Page 21: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 4 of 36

13 A Spring 25 Uncomfortable 36 Unacceptable Summer 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Fall 24 Uncomfortable 35 Unacceptable Winter 27 Uncomfortable 39 Unacceptable Annual 25 Uncomfortable 36 Unacceptable B Spring 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable 14 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable 15 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable 16 A Spring 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable

Page 22: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 5 of 36

17 A Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable B Spring 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Summer 6 Sitting 10 Acceptable Fall 8 Sitting 12 Acceptable Winter 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable Annual 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable 18 A Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 12 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable 19 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 25 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Summer 20 Uncomfortable 26 Acceptable Fall 24 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 23 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable 20 A Spring 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 29 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable

Page 23: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 6 of 36

21 A Spring 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 21 Acceptable 22 A Spring 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 25 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 25 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable 23 A Spring 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 25 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 26 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable 24 A Spring 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable

Page 24: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 7 of 36

25 A Spring 18 Walking 29 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 28 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 30 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 25 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 25 Acceptable 26 A Spring 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable 27 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Summer 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable B Spring 22 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Summer 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable 28 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable

Page 25: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 8 of 36

29 A Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable 30 A Spring 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Summer 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Winter 24 Uncomfortable 35 Unacceptable Annual 22 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable B Spring 24 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Summer 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Winter 25 Uncomfortable 36 Unacceptable Annual 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable 31 A Spring 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 22 Acceptable 32 A Spring 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 24 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable

Page 26: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 9 of 36

33 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Summer 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 25 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable 34 A Spring 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable 35 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 19 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable 36 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Winter 24 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable

Page 27: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 10 of 36

37 A Spring 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 24 Acceptable 38 A Spring 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 27 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable 39 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable B Spring 23 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable 40 A Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable

Page 28: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 11 of 36

41 A Spring 14 Standing 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable B Spring 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 22 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 27 Acceptable 42 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Summer 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Winter 24 Uncomfortable 35 Unacceptable Annual 22 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable B Spring 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable 43 A Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable 44 A Spring 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 22 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 19 Acceptable

Page 29: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 12 of 36

45 A Spring 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable 46 A Spring 23 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable B Spring 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable 47 A Spring 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 22 Acceptable 48 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable

Page 30: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 13 of 36

49 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable 50 A Spring 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable 51 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 22 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 19 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable 52 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 25 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 18 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 20 Acceptable

Page 31: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 14 of 36

53 A Spring 29 Dangerous 39 Unacceptable Summer 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Fall 26 Uncomfortable 35 Unacceptable Winter 28 Dangerous 37 Unacceptable Annual 27 Uncomfortable 35 Unacceptable B Spring 27 Uncomfortable 37 Unacceptable Summer 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Fall 25 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Winter 27 Uncomfortable 36 Unacceptable Annual 25 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable 54 A Spring 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 23 Acceptable 55 A Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable 56 A Spring 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable B Spring 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable

Page 32: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 15 of 36

57 A Spring 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable 58 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 13 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable 59 A Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable B Spring 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 27 Acceptable 60 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 19 Acceptable

Page 33: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 16 of 36

61 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 21 Acceptable 62 A Spring 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 24 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable 63 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 22 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable 64 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Summer 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 27 Acceptable

Page 34: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 17 of 36

65 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 30 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 27 Acceptable 66 A Spring 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable 67 A Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 18 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable 68 A Spring 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable

Page 35: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 18 of 36

**SENSORS 69 THROUGH 76 ARE LOCATED ABOVE GRADE AND DATA NOT AVAILABLE** 77 A Spring 11 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 15 Acceptable 78 A Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable 79 A Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 19 Acceptable 80 A Spring 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable

Page 36: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 19 of 36

B Spring 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Annual 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable 81 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable 82 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable 83 A Spring 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable B Spring 22 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 20 Uncomfortable 26 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable 84 A Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable

Page 37: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 20 of 36

B Spring 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 17 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 22 Acceptable 85 A Spring 14 Standing 25 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 23 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable 86 A Spring 15 Standing 26 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 25 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable 87 A Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 19 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable 88 A Spring 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable

Page 38: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 21 of 36

B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable 89 A Spring 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Summer 7 Sitting 12 Acceptable Fall 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable Winter 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Annual 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 14 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 12 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Annual 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable 90 A Spring 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Annual 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable B Spring 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 12 Acceptable Fall 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Annual 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable 91 A Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 18 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable 92 A Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable

Page 39: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 22 of 36

B Spring 23 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 20 Uncomfortable 26 Acceptable Fall 22 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 24 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 22 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable 93 A Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable 94 A Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 20 Uncomfortable 26 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 26 Acceptable 95 A Spring 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Fall 8 Sitting 15 Acceptable Winter 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Annual 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 22 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 23 Acceptable 96 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable

Page 40: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 23 of 36

B Spring 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 23 Acceptable 97 A Spring 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 25 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable 98 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 16 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 18 Acceptable 99 A Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable 100 A Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable

Page 41: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 24 of 36

B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable 101 A Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 24 Acceptable 102 A Spring 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 21 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 21 Acceptable 103 A Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable 104 A Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable

Page 42: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 25 of 36

B Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable 105 A Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 21 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable 106 A Spring 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable 107 A Spring 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 19 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 17 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 19 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 23 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 20 Acceptable 108 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 26 Acceptable

Page 43: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 26 of 36

B Spring 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 13 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable 109 A Spring 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 27 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 22 Acceptable 110 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Summer 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable 111 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 30 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 27 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 19 Acceptable 112 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 22 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 27 Acceptable

Page 44: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 27 of 36

B Spring 17 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 22 Acceptable 113 A Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 23 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable 114 A Spring 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 23 Acceptable 115 A Spring 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 23 Acceptable 116 A Spring 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable

Page 45: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 28 of 36

B Spring 13 Standing 17 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 18 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable 117 A Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 26 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable 118 A Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable 119 A Spring 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 21 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 29 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 24 Acceptable 120 A Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable

Page 46: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 29 of 36

B Spring 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 24 Acceptable 121 A Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable 122 A Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable 123 A Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable 124 A Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 25 Acceptable

Page 47: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 30 of 36

B Spring 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable 125 A Spring 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 24 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable 126 A Spring 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 10 Sitting 18 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable B Spring 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable 127 A Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 20 Acceptable B Spring 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 21 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable 128 A Spring 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 23 Acceptable

Page 48: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 31 of 36

B Spring 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 27 Acceptable 129 A Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable 130 A Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable 131 A Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 23 Acceptable 132 A Spring 13 Standing 22 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 21 Acceptable

Page 49: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 32 of 36

B Spring 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Summer 8 Sitting 12 Acceptable Fall 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Winter 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Annual 9 Sitting 13 Acceptable 133 A Spring 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable 134 A Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 16 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 18 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 21 Acceptable 135 A Spring 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 21 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable 136 A Spring 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Summer 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable

Page 50: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 33 of 36

B Spring 22 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 24 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable 137 A Spring 22 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Summer 19 Walking 29 Acceptable Fall 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Annual 21 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable B Spring 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 16 Walking 23 Acceptable 138 A Spring 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 11 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable B Spring 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 10 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable 139 A Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 16 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 20 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 18 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 25 Acceptable 140 A Spring 17 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 24 Acceptable

Page 51: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 34 of 36

B Spring 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 24 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 27 Acceptable Annual 18 Walking 25 Acceptable 141 A Spring 21 Uncomfortable 31 Acceptable Summer 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 28 Acceptable Winter 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable B Spring 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 25 Acceptable Winter 22 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 27 Acceptable 142 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 18 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 28 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 28 Acceptable B Spring 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 17 Acceptable Fall 13 Standing 19 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 13 Standing 19 Acceptable 143 A Spring 20 Uncomfortable 30 Acceptable Summer 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Fall 18 Walking 29 Acceptable Winter 19 Walking 30 Acceptable Annual 19 Walking 29 Acceptable B Spring 7 Sitting 12 Acceptable Summer 6 Sitting 10 Acceptable Fall 7 Sitting 11 Acceptable Winter 8 Sitting 13 Acceptable Annual 7 Sitting 12 Acceptable 144 A Spring 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Summer 9 Sitting 15 Acceptable Fall 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 20 Acceptable Annual 12 Sitting 18 Acceptable

Page 52: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 35 of 36

B Spring 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Winter 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 24 Acceptable 145 A Spring 15 Standing 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 21 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable B Spring 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Summer 10 Sitting 14 Acceptable Fall 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable Winter 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Annual 11 Sitting 17 Acceptable 146 A Spring 25 Uncomfortable 34 Unacceptable Summer 21 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Fall 24 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable Winter 28 Dangerous 38 Unacceptable Annual 25 Uncomfortable 33 Unacceptable B Spring 20 Uncomfortable 28 Acceptable Summer 16 Walking 23 Acceptable Fall 19 Walking 27 Acceptable Winter 23 Uncomfortable 32 Unacceptable Annual 20 Uncomfortable 29 Acceptable 147 A Spring 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Summer 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Fall 17 Walking 26 Acceptable Winter 18 Walking 27 Acceptable Annual 17 Walking 26 Acceptable B Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 12 Sitting 19 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Winter 16 Walking 25 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 23 Acceptable **SENSORS 148 THROUGH 170 ARE LOCATED ABOVE GRADE AND DATA NOT AVAILABLE**

Page 53: MEMORANDUM FROM: MIT · 12/05/2016  · DATE: May 12, 2016 . RE: MIT Kendall Project (PB #302 and PB #303) Wind Study Update . Attached please find an updated wind study prepared

Table 1: Mean Speed and Effective Gust Categories – Multiple Seasons

BRA Criteria Mean Wind Speed Effective Gust Wind Speed

Loc. Config. Season Speed(mph) %Change RATING Speed(mph) %Change RATING

Notes: 1) Wind speeds are for a 1% probability of exceedance; and, 2) % Change is based on comparison with Configuration A and only those that are greater than 10% are listed.

Configurations Mean Wind Speed Criteria Effective Gust Criteria

A – No Build Comfortable for Sitting: ≤ 12 mph Acceptable: ≤ 31 mph B – Full Build + Oak Trees Comfortable for Standing: > 12 and ≤ 15 mph Unacceptable: > 31 mph Comfortable for Walking: > 15 and ≤ 19 mph Uncomfortable for Walking: > 19 and ≤ 27 mph Dangerous Conditions: > 27 mph

Reputation Resources Results Canada | USA | UK | India | China | Hong Kong | Singapore www.rwdi.com

Page 36 of 36

171 A DATA NOT AVAILABLE B Spring 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 14 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 14 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 14 Standing 22 Acceptable 172 A DATA NOT AVAILABLE B Spring 16 Walking 24 Acceptable Summer 13 Standing 20 Acceptable Fall 15 Standing 22 Acceptable Winter 15 Standing 23 Acceptable Annual 15 Standing 22 Acceptable