MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation Program Report · 2012. 12. 3. · MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation...

MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation Program Report JEXU-1022-6301-NP(R0)

MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC CORPORATION

July 2010

2010 MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC CORPORATION All Rights Reserved

C

Non Proprietary Version

MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation Program Report



Prepared:

Hidetoshi Matsushita, Manager

Control and Protection Systems Section

Date

Reviewed:

Masato Kosuga, Manager

Control and Protection Systems Section

Date

Approved:

Tatsuaki Kawabata, Re-evaluation Team Leader

Nuclear Power Plant Quality Assurance Development

Date



Revision History

Revision Date

Page (section)

Description

0 July 2010 All Original issue



© 2010 MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC CORPORATION

All Rights Reserved

This document has been prepared by Mitsubishi Electric Corporation (“MELCO”) in connection with the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (“NRC”) licensing review of the MELTAC platform. No right to disclose, use or copy any of the information is this document, other than by the NRC and its contractors in support of the licensing review of the platform, is authorized without the express written permission of MELCO. This document contains technological information and intellectual property relating to MELCO’s Safety System Digital Platform (MELTAC) and it is delivered to the NRC on the express condition that it not be disclosed, copied or reproduced in whole or in part, or used for the benefit of anyone other than MELCO without the express written permission of MELCO, except as set forth in the previous paragraph. This document is protected by the laws of Japan, U.S. copyright law, international treaties and conventions, and the applicable laws of any country where it is being used.

Mitsubishi Electric Corporation 7-3, Marunouchi 2-chome, Chiyoda-ku

Tokyo 100-8310 Japan


MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC CORPORATION i

Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND ........................................................................................1

1.1 PURPOSE ................................................................................................................................1 1.2 SCOPE .....................................................................................................................................1

2. APPLICABLE STANDARDS ..........................................................................................................2 3. REFERENCES...............................................................................................................................2 4. EVALUATION.................................................................................................................................3

4.1 Evaluation criteria and results...................................................................................................3 4.2 Critical Characteristics (CCs) assessment ...............................................................................5 4.3 Built-In-Quality assessment ..................................................................................................192


MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC CORPORATION 1

1. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

This document is the final evaluation report of the MELTAC Re-evaluation Program (MRP) for the MELCO MELTAC Safety System Platform (MELTAC-Nplus S). The MELCO Energy Systems Center (ESC) submitted a topical report “Safety System Digital

Platform -MELTAC-” (MUAP-07005-P) to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) in 2007, in order to obtain the NRC’s approval for the MELTAC Safety System Platform. Due to the lack of a quality assurance program (QAP) that meets 10CFR50 Appendix B requirements, MELCO was requested by the NRC to verify that the past MELTAC design, development and qualification processes/activities produced a product that is equivalent to a product generated under a 10CFR50 Appendix B quality program. Therefore MELCO decided to conduct an MRP for MELTAC. The MRP is an activity to justify that the developed MELTAC Safety System platform complies with 10CFR50 Appendix B requirements, and to compensate for any deficiencies. The MRP is a one-time non-recurring activity. The MRP evaluated a base-line of the MELTAC

hardware and software, which establishes the configuration control starting point for all future MELTAC life cycle activities, including production, corrective actions and design changes. All of these future life cycle activities will be conducted under MELCO's 10CFR50 Appendix B quality assurance program (App. B- based QAP). Since all future activities will be conducted under MELCOs App. B-based QAP, the MRP is limited to design, analysis and testing activities that lead to the platform base-line.

1.1 PURPOSE

The purpose of this report is to document the results of the MELTAC Re-evaluation Program that assessed past MELTAC design, development and qualification processes/activities, to confirm critical technical characteristics documented in the MELTAC Topical Report MUAP-07005, and to determine the built-in-quality of the MELTAC Safety System Platform, using the assessment criteria given in the regulations, guidelines and standards identified in Section 2. 1.2 SCOPE

The scope of this assessment is limited to the design characteristics and the design process (including software quality assurance and equipment qualification) of the MELTAC components for which MELCO is seeking NRC approval for safety system applications in the U.S.; these are all the MELTAC components described in the MELTAC Topical Report MUAP-07005. This assessment does not cover any legacy activities related to production, such as procurement of parts, manufacturing, material control, QC, etc since no parts procured or manufactured prior to the Appendix B program will be used in the US.



2. APPLICABLE STANDARDS

Table 2-1 shows applicable standards.

Table 2-1 Applicable standards and guidelines

Standard/Guideline number Title EPRI TR-107330 (December 1996 Revision) Section 7

Guideline to evaluate quality characteristics of digital platforms

EPRI TR-106439 (October 1996 Revision) Table 6-4c

Guideline to evaluate quality characteristics of digital platforms

10CFR50 Appendix B Quality assurance standard IEEE 7-4.3.2-2003 Section 5.3.4 Guideline to evaluate lifecycle activities IEEE1012-1998 Guideline to evaluate V&V activities BTP 7-14 (2007) Guideline to evaluate lifecycle activities

3. REFERENCES

Table 3-1 shows references.

Table 3-1 References

MELCO document number Title JEXU-1022-0001-B Safety System Platform MELTAC-Nplus S

Re-evaluation Project Plan JEXU-1022-0002-A Safety System Platform MELTAC-Nplus S

Re-evaluation Plan MUAP-07005-P(R5) Safety System Digital Platform -MELTAC- MUAP-07004-P(R4) Safety I&C System Description and Design Process



4. EVALUATION

This chapter describes the results of re-evaluation activities. 4.1 Evaluation criteria and results

Table 4-1 shows the criteria and overall results of MRP activities. For detailed evaluation results, see sections 4.2 and 4.3 .

Table 4-1 Evaluation criteria and summary of results

No. Criteria Evaluation summary Result Reference

1 Was the evaluation performed with the evaluation method described in Re-evaluation Project Plan (JEXU-1022-0001-B)?

The evaluation was performed with the method as described in Re-evaluation Project Plan.

Good -

Re-evaluation organization (Qualification)

Evaluation was performed with the re-evaluation organization as described in Re-evaluation Plan.

Good -

Independence Evaluation was performed by an independent organization.

Good -

2 Were the items specified in Re-evaluation Plan (JEXU-1022-0002-A) performed as planned? Output Verified the outputs as

expected. Good -

3 Are the results of technical Critical Characteristics evaluation satisfactory?

As a result of re-valuation, the Re-evaluation team found that there are some items that should be reflected in the MELTAC Topical Report and specifications. (See Table 4-3.) The Re-evaluation Team asked the Design Team the principle of reflection and determined that it is acceptable. The above items were determined as resolution required. The results of the re-evaluation are satisfactory, except for the above items.

Resolution required in part.

Table 4-2 Table 4-3

4 Are the results of Built-In-Quality evaluation satisfactory?

All the re-evaluation results are satisfactory

Good Table 4-4 Table 4-5 Table 4-6 Table 4-7 Table 4-8 Table 4-9 Table 4-10



As shown in Table 4-1, the re-evaluation activities were performed as planned in Re-evaluation

Project Plan and Re-evaluation Plan and obtained satisfactory results, except for part of the CCs. For the CCs that require resolution, the Re-evaluation Team has confirmed that the principle of the Design Team is acceptable.

As a result, all the activities planned in this MRP have been completed and the re-evaluation results are all satisfactory, except for the resolution-required items. The Design Team will address the resolution-required items and the Re-evaluation Team will confirm that the items are addressed.



4.2 Critical Characteristics (CCs) assessment

This section verifies that the technical CCs extracted from MELTAC Topical Report ("Safety System Digital Platform –MELTAC-" MUAP-07005 Rev.5) are included in MELTAC design documents (original design, test, and UCP (US Conformance Program)).

The MELTAC Topical Report was used as the basis of the technical CC assessment because it defines the technical features and performance specifications that are critical to the implementation of the Protection and Safety Monitoring System (PSMS) and Plant Control and Monitoring System (PCMS), described in MUAP-07004, Safety I&C System and Design Process. As described in MUAP-07004, the PSMS and PCMS are the standard instrumentation and control systems offered to the US nuclear power industry by Mitsubishi for both new plant and digital upgrade applications. The critical characteristics defined in other industry documents, such as EPRI TR107330, were not used as the basis of the MELTAC CC assessment, because these documents do not encompass the requirements of the PSMS and PCMS. If the MELTAC platform is considered for other nuclear I&C applications, the suitability of the platform for those applications will be determined based on the critical characteristics described in the MELTAC Topical Report (MUAP-07005-P(R5)).

Technical CCs are extracted from Sections 4, 5, 7, and Appendix A and B of the MELTAC Topical Report that contain descriptions of performance characteristics, as described in Project Plan (JEXU-1022-0001-B) “2.3 Project summary <Re-evaluation (CCs assessment) phase>. EPRI TR-106439 Table 6-4c lists Built-In Quality as a CC. However, because Built-In Quality is a unique characteristic, it is described and evaluated separately from the technical CCs in section 4.3.

Chapters and sections of MELTAC Topical Report from which technical CCs were extracted are

shown in Table 4-2. Details of the technical CC assessment are shown in Table 4-3. The first column of the table

provides the applicable sections and titles from MELTAC Topical Report. The second column gives the technical CCs identified from MELTAC Topical Report and their related acceptance criteria. The third column provides the MELTAC documents and section numbers used to verify technical CCs and their acceptance criteria. If there is inadequate supporting MELTAC documentation, this column explains the method of verification (e.g. independent testing, equipment inspection, etc). The fourth column provides the results of the assessment.



Table 4-2 Source of technical CCs extraction

Extraction source (from MUAP-07005-P(R5)) 4.0 MELTAC PLATFORM DESCRIPTION 4.1 Controller 4.2 Safety VDU Panel and Processor 4.3 Communication System 4.4 Response Time 4.5 Control of Access 4.6 Elimination or Relaxation of Surveillance 5.0 Environmental, Seismic, Electromagnetic and Isolation Qualification 5.1 Environmental Test 5.2 Seismic Test 5.3 Electromagnetic Compatibility and Radio Frequency Interference 5.4 Electrostatic Discharge Test 5.5 Isolation Test 7.0 Equipment Reliability 7.1 History of Operation. 7.2 Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) Analysis 7.3 Controller Reliability Analysis 7.4 Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) 7.5 Periodic Replacement Equipment (Parts) to Keep Reliability 7.6 Performance history of self-diagnosis function Appendix A HARDWARE SPECFICATIONS Appendix B FUNCTIONAL SYMBOL SOFTWARE SPECIFICATIONS

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

7

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

8

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

9

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

10

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

11

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

12

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

13

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

14

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

15

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

16

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

17

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

18

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

19

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

20

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

21

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

22

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

23

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

24

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

25

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

26

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

27

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

28

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

29

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

30

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

31

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

32

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

33

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

34

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

35

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

36

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

37

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

38

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

39

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

40

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

41

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

42

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

43

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

44

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

45

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

46

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

47

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

48

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

49

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

50

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

51

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

52

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

53

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

54

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

55

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

56

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

57

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

58

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

59

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

60

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

61

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

62

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

63

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

64

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

65

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

66

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

67

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

68

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

69

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

70

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

71

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

72

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

73

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

74

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

75

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

76

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

77

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

78

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

79

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

80

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

81

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

82

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

83

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

84

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

85

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

86

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

87

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

88

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

89

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

90

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

91

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

92

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

93

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

94

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

95

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

96

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

97

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

98

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

99

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

100

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

101

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

102

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

103

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

104

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

105

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

106

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

107

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

108

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

109

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

110

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

111

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

112

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

113

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

114

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

115

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

116

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

117

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

118

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

119

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

120

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

121

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

122

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

123

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

124

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

125

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

126

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

127

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

128

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

129

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

130

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

131

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

132

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

133

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

134

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

135

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

136

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

137

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

138

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

139

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

140

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

141

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

142

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

143

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

144

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

145

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

146

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

147

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

148

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

149

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

150

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

151

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

152

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

153

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

154

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

155

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

156

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

157

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

158

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

159

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

160

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

161

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

162

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

163

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

164

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

165

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

166

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

167

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

168

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

169

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

170

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

171

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

172

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

173

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

174

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

175

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

176

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

177

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

178

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

179

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

180

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

181

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

182

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

183

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

184

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

185

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

186

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

187

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

188

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

189

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

190

Tab

le 4

-3 C

Cs

Ass

essm

ent

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

191



4.3 Built-In-Quality assessment

This section assesses Built-In-Quality of the Safety System Platform MELTAC-Nplus S. Assessment is performed based on the guidance of EPRI TR described in Project Plan (JEXU-

1022-0001-B) ”2.3 Project Summary <Re-evaluation (Built-In-Quality assessment) phase>. Built-in-Quality is assessed in accordance with EPRI TR-107330 Section 7 “Quality Assurance”

and EPRI TR-106439 Table 6-4c.

<Assessment in accordance with EPRI TR-107330 Section 7 “Quality Assurance”> Table 4-5 shows the results of assessment based on the requirements in EPRI TR-107330

Section 7”Quality Assurance” for evaluating MELTAC lifecycle activities. Note that 7.2 D (10CFR50 Appendix B Compliance Assessment) and 7.4 (Guidance for V&V Activities) of Section 7 are assessed in separate tables in detail.

Table 4-6 shows the result of evaluation based on EPRI TR-107330 Section 7.2D (10CFR50

Appendix B Compliance Assessment). Design, development and qualification of MELTAC Digital Platform were executed based on Japanese Standard JEAG4101 and ISO9001, not on 10CFR50 Appendix B. Therefore, MELCO Original Quality Assurance Program (Original QAP) applied to MELTAC was assessed by the Re-evaluation Team. Since all the items going forward (manufacturing, production, maintenance, corrective actions, design changes) for the US commercial nuclear power market are conducted under MELCO App.B based QAP, this assessment only covers design, development and qualification of the baseline MELTAC platform.

V&V activities for safety systems were assessed based on the guidelines of IEEE 7-4.3.2-2003

Section 5.3.4, IEEE 1012-1998. In addition, compliance to BTP 7-14 (2007) Section B 3.1.10 was also assessed based on the

NRC’s emphasis on this compliance in recent US-APWR meetings. Table 4-7 shows the results of assessment based on IEEE 7-4.3.2-2003 Section 5.3.4; Table 4-8

shows the results of assessment based on IEEE 1012-1998; Table 4-9 shows the results of evaluation based on BTP 7-14 (2007) Section B 3.1.10.

Quality of the past MELCO life cycle activities were assessed based on EPRI TR-106439

(October 1996 Revision) Table 6-4C. The results of the assessment are shown in Table 4-10.

EPRI TRs used for the assessment of Built-In-Quality and the summary of assessment results are shown in Table 4-4.



Table 4-4 EPRI TRs and summary of assessment results

No. EPRI TRs and summary of assessment results Remarks EPRI TR-107330 Section 7 “Quality Assurance”

1

<Summary of assessment results> Overall MELTAC lifecycle activities were assessed based on the requirements in EPRI TR-107330 Section 7 “Quality Assurance”.

(a)10CFR50 Appendix B requirements The Re-evaluation Team evaluated the past MELCO QA activities conducted under original QAP with extracting quality characteristics from 10CFR50 Appendix B and confirmed satisfactory results (Details are evaluated in No.2) (b) V&V requirements The Re-evaluation Team evaluated the past MELCO V&V activities conducted under original QAP in accordance with IEEE 7-4.3.2-2003 Section 5.3.4, IEEE 1012-1998, and BTP 7-14 (2007) Section B 3.1.10, and confirmed satisfactory results. (Details are evaluated in No.3) (c) Configuration management The Re-evaluation team confirmed that required elements are contained in the configuration management. The Re-evaluation team also confirmed that software configuration management is specified in accordance with RG 1.169 and is properly executed. (Details are evaluated in No.1)

Table 4-5

EPRI TR-107330 Section 7.2D (10 CFR 50 Appendix B Compliance assessment)

2

<Summary of assessment results> The past MELCO QA activities were assessed with extracting quality characteristics from 10CFR50 Appendix B.

(a) Establishment of quality assurance program The Re-evaluation team confirmed that MELCO has an original quality assurance program with Quality Manual (ESC Procedure Q-M002-) at the top and that methods of principle, organization, procedures, analysis, audit and improvement (corrective action) are documented. (b) Execution of quality assurance program The Re-evaluation Team verified the evidences of the above procedures and confirmed that the above procedures were properly executed.

Table 4-6

EPRI TR-107330 Section 7.4 (Guideline for V&V activities)

3

<Summary of assessment results> The past MELCO V&V activities conducted under the original QAP were assessed based on the standards and guidelines below:

(a) Assessment based on IEEE 7-4.3.2-2003 The Re-evaluation Team assessed V&V program for contents of activities, documentation of anomalies and recommendations for

Table 4-7 Table 4-8 Table 4-9



No. EPRI TRs and summary of assessment results Remarks improvements, and confirmed that they are specified and properly executed., . (b) Assessment under IEEE 1012-1998 The Re-evaluation Team verified V&V programs and evidences for integrity of V&V activities, establishment of V&V process, evaluation of V&V activities for each task, V&V reports, V&V documentation requirements, and V&V plans and confirmed that they are specified and properly executed. The Re-evaluation Team also assessed the V&V program for independence of V&V organization and confirmed that they are specified and properly executed. (c) Assessment under BTP 7-14 (2007) The Re-evaluation Team verified V&V programs and evidences for control characteristics, execution characteristics, evaluation criteria, documentation, testing criteria, and V&V organization, and confirmed that they are specified and properly executed.

EPRI TR-106439 Table 6-4C

4

<Summary of assessment results> To evaluate the quality of the past MELTAC lifecycle activities, an assessment was made under EPRI TR-106439 (October 1996 Revision). Table 6-4C.

(a)Built in Quality of design and production The Re-evaluation Team confirmed that MELCO properly executed MELTAC development, qualification and test activities under the original QA program. The Re-evaluation Team also confirmed that plan, organization, design requirements, traceability, V&V and evaluation test were specified and properly executed in the development process. In addition, the Re-evaluation Team investigated the operating history of MELTAC digital platform and confirmed that there have been no problems in safety and reliability. (b) Failure management The Re-evaluation team confirmed that MELCO has an appropriate failure management function from procedures and evidences. (c) Configuration management The Re-evaluation team confirmed that MELCO has an appropriate configuration management program and properly executes this program from procedures and evidences. (d) Reporting of defects Reporting of defects was not assessed: This item will be conducted going forward in accordance with 10CFR50 Appendix B, under the new QAP (per 10CFR Appendix B). (e) Reliability and availability The Re-evaluation Team investigated the operating history and design evidences of MELTAC digital platform and confirmed that there is no problem in reliability and availability.

Table 4-10

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

195

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

196

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

197

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

198

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

199

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

200

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

201

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

202

Tab

le 4

-5 A

sses

smen

t per

the

requ

irem

ents

of

EP

RI T

R-1

073

30 S

ectio

n 7”

Qua

lity

Ass

uran

ce”

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

203

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

204

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

205

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

206

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

207

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

208

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

209

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

210

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

211

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

212

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

213

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

214

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

215

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

216

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

217

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

218

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

219

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

220

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

221

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

222

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

223

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

224

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

225

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

226

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

227

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

228

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

229

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

230

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

231

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

232

Tab

le 4

-6 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.2D

（10

CF

R50

App

endi

x B

Co

mpl

ianc

e as

sess

men

t）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

233

Tab

le 4

-7 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 7

-4.3

.2-2

003）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

234

Tab

le 4

-7 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 7

-4.3

.2-2

003）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

235

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

236

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

237

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

238

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

239

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

240

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

241

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

242

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

243

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

244

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

245

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

246

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

247

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

248

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

249

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

250

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

251

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

252

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

253

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

254

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

255

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

256

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

257

Tab

le 4

-8 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4 （A

sses

smen

t per

IEE

E 1

012-

1998

）

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

258

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

259

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

260

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

261

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

262

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

263

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

264

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

265

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

266

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

267

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

268

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

269

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

270

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

271

Tab

le 4

-9 E

PR

I TR

-107

330

Sec

tion

7.4

(Ass

essm

ent p

er B

TP

7-1

4 (2

007)

)

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

272

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

273

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

274

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

275

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

276

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

277

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

278

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

ME

LTA

C P

latfo

rm R

e-e

valu

atio

n P

rogr

am R

epo

rt

J

EX

U-1

022-

6301

-NP

(R0)

M

ITS

UB

ISH

I ELE

CT

RIC

CO

RP

OR

AT

ION

279

Tab

le 4

-10

Ass

essm

ent p

er th

e re

quire

men

ts o

f EP

RI T

R-1

0643

9 T

able

6-4

C

MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation Program Report · 2012. 12. 3. · MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation...

Documents

Transcript of MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation Program Report · 2012. 12. 3. · MELTAC Platform Re-evaluation...