MEETING AIR RESOURCES BOARD BYRON SHER · PDF fileMr. Bob Cassidy, Nissan Ms. Cynthia Cory,...
Transcript of MEETING AIR RESOURCES BOARD BYRON SHER · PDF fileMr. Bob Cassidy, Nissan Ms. Cynthia Cory,...
MEETING
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
AIR RESOURCES BOARD
BYRON SHER AUDITORIUM
SECOND FLOOR
1001 I STREET
SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA 95814
THURSDAY, OCTOBER 24, 2013
9:17 A.M.
TIFFANY C. KRAFT, CSRCERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERLICENSE NUMBER 12277
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
APPEARANCES
BOARD MEMBERS
Ms. Mary Nichols, Chairperson
Dr. John Balmes
Ms. Sandra Berg
Mr. Hector De La Torre
Mr. John Eisenhut
Supervisor John Gioia
Mayor Pro Tem Judy Mitchell
Mrs. Barbara Riordan
Supervisor Ron Roberts
Supervisor Phil Serna
Dr. Alex Sherriffs
Professor Daniel Sperling
STAFF
Mr. Richard Corey, Executive Officer
Mr. Alberto Ayala, Deputy Executive Officer
Ms. Edie Chang, Deputy Executive Officer
Ms. Lynn Terry, Deputy Executive Officer
Ms. Ellen Peter, Chief Counsel
Ms. La Rhonda Bowen, Ombudsman
Ms. Violet Martin, Air Pollution Specialist, Compliance Assistance and Outreach Branch, Mobile Source Control Division
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
APPEARANCES CONTINUED
STAFF
Mr. Mike McCarthy, Vehicle Program Specialist, Mobile Source Control Division
Mr. Jim McKinney, Manager, Alternative and Renewable Fuels and Vehicle Technology Program, CEC
Ms. Marcele Surovik, Air Pollution Specialist, Energy Section, Stationary Source Division
Ms. Anna Wong, Air Pollution Specialist, Zero Emission Vehicle Implementation Section, Mobile Source Control Division
STATE REPRESENTATIVES
Deb Markowitz, Vermont Representative
Anne Gobin, Connecticut Representative
Ashley Horvat, Oregon Representative
Kathy Kinsey, Maryland Representative
Christine Kirby, Massachusetts Representative
ALSO PRESENT
Mr. Alan Abbs, Tehama County APCD
Mr. Jason Barbose, Union of Concerned Scientists
Mr. David Barker, Subaru
Mr. Will Barrett, American Lung Association
Ms. Gretchen Bennitt, Northern Sierra AQMD
Mr. Robert Bienefeld, Honda
Mr. Kirk Blackburn, California Tow Truck Association
Mr. Clinton Blair, Jaguar/Land Rover
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
APPEARANCES CONTINUED
ALSO PRESENT
Mr. Constance Boulware, Yolo Solano AQMD
Dr. Rasto Brezny, MECA
Mr. Ryan Briscoe Young, The Greenlining Institute
Mr. Jack Broadbent, Bay Area AQMD
Mr. Rick Bosetti, Mayor of Redding
Mr. John Cabaniss, Jr., Global Automakers
Mr. Bud Caldwell, Alliance of California Business
Mr. Frank Caponi, LA County Sanitation Districts
Mr. Tim Carmichael, CNGVC
Ms. Angela Casler, Sustainability Alliance for California Business
Mr. Bob Cassidy, Nissan
Ms. Cynthia Cory, California Farm Bureau Federation
Mr. Matt Cox, Senator Ted Gaines
Ms. Pat Cramer, Pat Cramer Ins. Agency
Mr. Marlin Skip Davies, Yolo Solano Air District
Mr. Hank De Carbonel
Ms. Tanya Derivi, SCPPA
Mr. Steven Douglas, Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
Ms. Mary Jo Dutra, SAFE-BIDCO
Mr. Evan Edgar, California Refuse & Recycling Council
Mr. Allen Faris, Allen Faris Trucking
Mr. Greg Furlong
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
APPEARANCES CONTINUED
ALSO PRESENT
Mr. Douglas Gearhart, Lake County AQMD
Mr. Larry Greene, Sacrament MEtropolitan AQMD
Ms. Morgan Hagerty, CE2 Carbon Capital
Ms. Claire Halbrook, PG&E
Mr. Frank Harris, Southern California Edison
Mr. Michael Hartrick, Chrysler Group, LLC
Ms. Vicki Helmar, Tuolumne APCD
Mr. Paul Hernandez, CCSE
Mr. Tony Hobbs, BTI
Mr. Henry Hogo, South Coast AQMD
Ms. Bonnie Holmes-Gen, American Lung Association
Mr. Raymond Horspool, Omstar International LTD
Mr. Steven Jones, Garden City Sanitation
Ms. Trish Kelly, Applied Development Economics
Mr. Jamie Knapp, Clean Cars Campaign
Mr. Paul Larking, Co-Chair Port of Oakland Truck Work Group
Ms. Barbara Lee, Northern Sonoma County Air Pollution Control District
Ms. Julia Levin, Bioenergy Association of California
Mr. Michael Lewis, Construction Industry Air Quality Coalition
Mr. Richard Lokey, Lokey Trucking
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
APPEARANCES CONTINUED
ALSO PRESENT
Mr. Michael Lord, Toyota
Mr. Tony Luiz
Mr. Ian MacDonald, Clean Diesel Technologies, Inc.
Mr. Bill Magavern, Coalition for Clean Air
Mr. Mike Manna
Mr. Paul Mason, Pacific Forest Trust
Mr. Joe Matlen, Valley Farm Transport
Ms. Erika Morehouse, Environmental Defense Fund
Mr. Edward Moreno, Sierra Club
Mr. Ken Morgan, Tesla Motors
Mr. Simon Mui, NRDC
Mr. Diarmuid O'Connell
Mr. Justin Oldfield, CA Cattlemen's Association
Mr. Dave Patterson, Mitsubishi
Ms. Tanya Peacock, Souther CA Gas Company
Ms. Karen Pelle, Truck Drivers
Mr. Charlie Peters, Clean Air Performance Professionals
Ms. Betty Plowman, CCTA
Mr. Michael Quigley, CA Alliance for Jobs
Ms. Tiffany Rau, Hydrogen Energy California
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
APPEARANCES CONTINUED
ALSO PRESENT
Ms. Julia Rege, GlobalAutomakers
Dr. David Reichmuth, Union of Concerned Scientists
Ms. Mary Rose Taruc, Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Mr. Daniel Ryan, Mazda
Mr. Seyed Sadredin, San Joaquin Valley APCD
Mr. Chris Shimoda, CTA
Mr. Don Siefkes, E100 Ethanol Group
Mr. Richard Skaggs, Omstar Environmental Products USA
Mr. Matt Solomon, NESCAUM
Mr. Blain Stumpf
Ms. Tara Thronson, Valley Vision
Mr. Chris Torres, F&L Farms Trucking, Inc.
Ms. Eileen Tutt, CalETC
Mr. Jim Wagoner, Butte County AQMD
Mr. Michael Wang, WSPA
Mr. Chuck White, Waste Management and sWICS
V. John White, Center for Energy Efficiency & Renewable Technologies
Ms. Katherine Yehl, Volvo
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
INDEX PAGE
Item 13-9-3
Chairperson Nichols 3Executive Officer Corey 7Staff Presentation 8Mr. Hartrick 52Mr. Cabaniss 54Mr. O'Connell 56Mr. Reichmuth 59Mr. Cassidy 61Mr. Knapp 63Mr. Magavern 65Ms. Holmes-Gen 66Mr. Mui 69
Item 13-9-4Chairperson Nichols 73Executive Officer Corey 73Staff Presentation 73Mr. Solomon 84Mr. Morgan 85Mr. Siefkes 88Ms. Rege 90Mr. Bienefeld 92Mr. Reichmuth 94Mr. Douglas 95Mr. Lord 98Mr. Cassidy 100Mr. Hernandez 101Ms. Tutt 103Mr. Mui 105Mr. Barrett 107Mr. Patterson 109Mr. Barker 112Ms. Yehl 113Mr. Ryan 115Mr. Blair 117Mr. Hatrick 118Motion 137Vote 147
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
INDEX CONTINUED PAGE
Item 13-9-5Chairperson Nichols 148Executive Officer Corey 149Staff Presentation 151Mr. Cox 170Mr. Bosetti 171Mr. Hogo 172Mr. Sadredin 174Mr. Gearhart 177Mr. Davies 180Mr. Boulware 185Mr. Thomson 187Ms. Helmar 188Ms. Bennitt 190Mr. Abbs 192Mr. Broadbent 193Mr. Greene 195Mr. Furlong 197Ms. Plowman 198Mr. Shimoda 201Ms. Holmes-Gen 203Mr. Peters 205Mr. Oldfield 207Mr. Barbose 210Ms. Pelle 212Ms. Morehouse 214Mr. Caldwell 215Ms. Casler 217Mr. Hobbs 220Mr. De Carbonel 222Mr. Manna 225Ms. Cramer 226Mr. Blackburn 228Mr. Faris 229Mr. Horspool 230Mr. Lokey 232Mr. Luiz 234Mr. Stumpf 235Mr. Larking 237Mr. Torres 240Mr. Skaggs 242Mr. Matlen 244Mr. Lewis 246Mr. MacDonald 250
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
INDEX CONTINUED PAGE
Dr. Brezny 251Ms. Cory 254Ms. Dutra 256Mr. Wagoner 258Mr. Magavern 259Board Discussion 260
Item 13-9-6
Chairperson Nichols 281Executive Officer Corey 284Staff Presentation 285Ms. Lee 302EJAC members 306Mr. Hogo 316Mr. Caponi 318Mr. Shimoda 320Mr. Moreno 321Mr. Barrett 323Mr. Quigley 325Ms. Peacock 326Ms. Morehouse 327Ms. Halbrook 328Mr. Carmichael 330Mr. Barbose 331Ms. Rau 333Ms. Thronson 335Ms. Kelly 336Mr. Hagerty 338Mr. White 339Mr. Harris 341Mr. Mason 343Mr. White 345Ms. Levin 347Mr. Wang 349Ms. Derivi 351Mr. Jones 352Mr. Edgar 354Mr. Magavern 355
Recess 357Reporter's Certificate 358
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
PROCEEDINGS
CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: We will now come to order.
And ask everybody to stand so that we can say the Pledge
of Allegiance.
(Thereupon the Pledge of Allegiance was
Recited in unison.)
CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Madam Clerk, would you
please call the roll?
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Dr. Balmes?
BOARD MEMBER BALMES: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Ms. Berg?
BOARD MEMBER BERG: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Mr. De La Torre?
BOARD MEMBER DE LA TORRE: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Mr. Eisenhut?
BOARD MEMBER EISENHUT: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Supervisor Gioia?
BOARD MEMBER GIOIA: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Mayor Pro Tem Mitchell?
BOARD MEMBER MITCHELL: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Mrs. Riordan?
ACTING CHAIRPERSON RIORDAN: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Supervisor Roberts?
BOARD MEMBER ROBERTS: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Supervisor Serna?
J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC (916)476-3171
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
BOARD MEMBER SERNA: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Dr. Sherriffs?
BOARD MEMBER SHERRIFFS: Here.
BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Professor Sperling?
BOARD MEMBER SPERLING: Here.
BOARD CLERK JEN