Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
-
Upload
circlestretch -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
0
Transcript of Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
1/127
Joshua D. Feder, MD
October 28, 2011
Tel Aviv, Israel
1
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
2/127
Redacted for Posting
Case material removed
Questions? email [email protected]
2
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
3/127
Director of Research, Graduate School,
Interdisciplinary Council on
Developmental and Learning
Disorders
Assistant Clinical Professor,
Dept of Psychiatry, University ofCalifornia at San Diego School of
Medicine
3
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
4/127
ICDL Graduate School
ICDL Southern California Regional Institute
NIMH/ Duke University/Pfizer
SymPlay, LLC
4
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
5/127
Feder 411
Math, Engineering, and Developmental
Disorders beginning 1978.
US Navy Child Psychiatry
Mike 1990 (1992)
Greenspan and Wieder 1993
Career expansion: clinic, teaching,
research, advocacy, tech development
and arts & media.
5
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
6/127
The DIR/Floortime Model
Reflective Process
Support for the DIR Model
Considering medication
Case examplesYour experiences
6
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
7/127
But First,
Some Commercials Because we build ideas together
And you can join us in the effort!
7
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
8/127
8
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
9/127
Working Together for
Parent Choice!
9
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
10/127
The Southern California
DIR/Floortime
Regional Institute
Pasadena, California
February 24-26, 2012
10
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
11/127
11
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
12/127
12
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
13/127
13
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
14/127
Thank You!
Families say a silent thank you
Greenspan & Wieder
Mara Goverman
Daniel Carlat
David Sackett (et. al.)
Ricki Robinson
Michael Chez
So many others 14
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
15/127
Assumptions
Varying familiarity with DIR/Floortime
and the supporing research.
Varying understanding of EvidenceBased Practice
15
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
16/127
Conclusions:
The program is paramount.
Reflective process is the key to a goodprogram.
Medication might help a good progam
work better
16
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
17/127
Why DIR?
because its
Broad whole child, supports family
Welcoming all about building love
Enriching closeness brings progress in
relating, communicating, and thinking
17
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
18/127
Taking Notes?
One word: ENGAGEMENT
Engagement goes beyond compliance
Connection before correction
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
19/127
DIR quick guide
Developmental - regulation, warm trust,
then a flow of enriching interactions
Individual Differences sensory, motor,
communication, visual-spatial, cognitive
Relationship Based connecting and
supporting at many levels
19
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
20/127
Quality of Caregiver-Baby
Relationship Matters
D.W. Winnicott
There is no such thing as a baby
A baby cannot exist alone, but is essentially part
of a relationship
Relationships are central to development
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
21/127
Affect = Emotional
Connection The glue that organizes all of the jobs
of the brain
Coordinates the nervous system from
the brain outward
Lends purpose and meaning to the
information we take in through our
senses Emotional based learning experiences
become an internal reinforcement that
motivates
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
22/127
Theory Behind DIR
Affect is the central organizer ofexperience in all developmentaldomains
Experience is dual coded in the sensorysystem and the affect cueing system
Individual differences in processingsensory motor information impact how
parents and children make meaningfrom their interactions and fromexpectations about their relationships
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
23/127
Individual Differences
Sensory modulation and processing
Postural control and motor planning
Receptive communication
Expressive communication
Visual-spatial funciton
Praxis: knowing how to do things to
solve the social problem of the moment
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
24/127
Things to Keep in Mind
Hypo-reactive (decreased sensitivity)
Sensory seeking
Does not register input or has delayed
responsiveness to sensory input
Hyper-reactive (increased sensitivity)
Sensory avoiding
Associated with increased reactivity to
sensory input (fight/flight/fright
responses)
Mixed Hypo/Hyper-Sensitivity: common
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
25/127
Caregiver Patterns and
Child Development
Sensitive responsiveness
Attunement
Mutually confirming interactions
Mirroring, Matching, Expanding
Attachment
Secure, Anxious, Avoidant, Chaotic, Aloof
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
26/127
Relationship Classification
Overinvolved
Underinvolved
Anxious/Tense
Angry/Hostile
Mixed Relationship Disorder
Abusive (verbal, physical, sexual)
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
27/127
More to the point:
Joint attention responsive (cured),
initiated (when we wait for it)
Intent
Engagement
Repair (Tronick)
These are at the core of the moment to
moment affective reciprocity that
supports the developing relationship.
27
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
28/127
Functional Emotional
Developmental LevelsI co-regulation, ability to attend, interest in the world
II engagement, attachment, gleam in the eye, warmth
III circles of interaction, purposive two way
communicationIV flow, social problem solving, behavior organization
V symbolic thinking (critical shift)
VI logical connections between ideas (what, when, how,
and why questions)
VII multicausal thinking
VIII grey area thinking
IX reflective thinking, stable sense of self, and an internalstandard
I alm enough: ( o
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
29/127
Know the person: individual differences
We do this together
Not a sensory break (= escape)
Reach wth 80% intensity to help theperson calm down with you.
Calm enough might mean active
enough. Think about what works and what
doesnt work
I - alm enough: ( o-regulation)
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
30/127
II - Truly Connected to Others
(Engagement)
That gleam in the eye
Mostly fun and feels good for everyone
creates the bond that will leads to learning Joint attention, but joyful
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
31/127
III Circles:
back and forth interaction
The person is always doing something
Follow the childs lead - Join in - be part
of the activity
Improv = yes
If you cant just join in, gently and
playfully get in the way
If he wants something, he has to get it
from you
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
32/127
IVFlow
(and avoiding questions)
Chains of 20-40 circles
Expanding complextiy
Questions make people close up or act mad Statements create social problems that the
other person can solve
Try it out. Its hard, but worth the work
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
33/127
Things to Avoid
Dont just entertain, quiz, or direct the childwith your games, demands, or ideas
Dont merely follow the child around use
the child lead to start off
Every idea is a good one to play with dont
say no to the idea - connect and play with it.You can set limits as needed.
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
34/127
What about other kids?
Start with adults
Build some skills
Semi-structured activities with peers
Limiting numbers of kids
Mediate the process slow it down
Statements more than questions
Democratic decision making
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
35/127
Things you might say or do:
We need to figure out what to do I need help with
Wait - I didnt hear you
We can vote on whether he was out.. Semi-structured: at times you direct things,
but work toward less of it.
In free play, you join the person in a way thatattracts other kids, then facilitate the mix
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
36/127
Likert Scale for Each Level
1. Not doing it
2. Barely able to do it
3. Islands of time where the child can do it
4. Can expand those islands with our help
5. Comes back for more with little or no
support
6. Pretty normal unless under stress
7. Age appropriate
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
37/127
Family /Caregiver Patterns:
Comforting
Finds appropriate level of stimulation
Engages in relationship Reads cues and signals
Maintains affective flow (for co-
regulation) Encourages development
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
38/127
The Learning Tree
38
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
39/127
Summary: Why DIR?
It is BPS, and BPS is good
We can change outcomes despite genetics.
Affect is the key - this is affect based
Beyond behavioral treatments
Medication can only support treatment
There is Evidenced Based Research to
support it
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
40/127
Research Support for DIR/Floortime
Macro: comprehensive interventions
Odom, et al. there is no one winner..Care reports, single case studies
Salt, Mahoney
PLAYPajareya
York
Micro: core conceptsJoint attention
Parent coaching
Repair 40
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
41/127
Evidence based medicine,
and informed consent
41
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
42/127
Reflective Process
There are always new challenges
Nothing goes as expected
Caregivers rarely have the supportand time they need to think
Make time a moment to l isten.
42
R fl ti P
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
43/127
Reflective Process:
in the moment Humility: you do not have the
answer
Facilitate problem solving
Wonder about the situation
Track the emotion, then and now
Statements vs. questions. Empowering vs. dictating.
43
R fl ti P
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
44/127
Reflective Process:
regular contact Selling the idea of making another moment
can we make an appt to check in later?
Set another time to check in.
44
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
45/127
Medications
Rationale for using medication: last
resort vs. covering all bases
45
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
46/127
Controversies about medications in
developmental and learning disorders:
Stimulants
Antidepressants
core symptoms
overmedication
46
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
47/127
Specific Medications
For details see circlestretch.com
For a framework, see The Learning Tree
(+caregiver profile)
47
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
48/127
Remember the Tree
48
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
49/127
49
Individual Differences CharliePreschool 5/05 &
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
50/127
Kindergarten 9/05
Sensory Postural Response to
Communicat io
n
Intent to
Commun i
cate
Visual
Explorat ion
Praxis -
Sensory
seeking,
distractible
AuditoryVisualTactile
VestibularProprio-ceptiveTasteOdor
Low tone;A bit clumsy -
impedes rapid
reciprocity in
the moment1 indicate
desires2. mirrorgestures3. imitate
gesture
---- 05/05----4. Imitate with
purpose.
5. Obtaindesires6. interact:
- exploration- purposeful
-self help-interactions
Trouble managing
more than one
thing at a time
1. Orient2. key tones3. key gestures4. key words
---- 05/05----5. Switch auditoryattention back
and forth6. Follow
directions7. Understand
W ?s8.abstract
conversation.
Dysarthric
Logical
discourse is
Difficult
1. Mirror
vocalization
s2.. Mirrorgestures3. gestures4. sounds5.Words
---- 05/05---
6. twoword
7.Sentences
8. logical
flow.
Distractible.1.focus on object
---- 05/05----
2. Alternate gaze3. Follow
anothers gaze todetermine intent.
3. Switch visualattention4. visual figure
ground5. search for
object
6. search two
areas of room7. assess space,shape and
materials.
-
Easily
frustratedIdeation-- 05/05---Planning
(including
sensory
knowledgeto do this)
Sequencin
g
Execution
Adaptation
50
Individual Differences Charley First Grade
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
51/127
Individual Differences CharleyFirst Grade
Sensory Postural Response to
Communicat io
n
Intent to
Commun i
cate
Visual
Explorat ion
Praxis -
Sensory
seeking,
distractible
AuditoryVisualTactile
VestibularProprio-ceptiveTasteOdor
Taste and
odor are
better
Low tone;A bit clumsy -
impedes rapid
reciprocity in
the moment1 indicate
desires2. mirrorgestures3. imitate
gesture4. Imitate with
purpose.
----3/07----5. Obtain
desires6. interact:
- exploration- purposeful
-self help
-interactions
Much betterpostural control
Trouble managing
more than one
thing at a time
1. Orient2. key tones3. key gestures4. key words
----3/07----5. Switch auditoryattention back
and forth6. Follow
directions7. Understand
W ?s
8.abstract
conversation.
Stronger foundation
Dysarthric
Logical
discourse is
Difficult
1. Mirror
vocalization
s2.. Mirrorgestures3. gestures4. sounds5.words
----3/07----6. twoword
7.Sentences
8. logical
flow.
NOT
CHANGED
Distractible.1.focus on object
2.----3/07----2. Alternate gaze3. Follow
anothers gaze todetermine intent.
3. Switch visualattention4. visual figure
ground5. search for
object
6. search two
areas of room7. assess space,shape and
materials.
Can focus pretty
well on an object
now
Easily
frustratedIdeationPlanning
(including
sensory
knowledgeto do this)
----3/07----Sequencin
g
Execution
Adaptation
A step
forward..
51
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
52/127
52
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
53/127
Sample Full FEDL (Charlie)
Not there Barely Islands Expands Comesback
Ok if notstressed
Ok forage
Co-regulate 3/06 3/07 3/08 3/09
Engage 3/06 3/07 3/08 3/09
Circles 3/06, 3/07 3/08 3/09
Flow 3/06 3/07 3/08, 3/09
Symbolic 3/06 3/07, 3/08 3/09
Logical 3/06 3/07, 3/08 3/09
Multicausal 3/06, 3/07 3/08 3/09
Grey area 3/06, 3/07, 3/08, 3/09
Reflective 3/06, 3/07 3/08, 3/0953
R l ti hi C i P fil
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
54/127
Relationships - Caregiver Profiles:
Not yet able
to support
Just starting
to support
Islands of
support
Moderately
effective in
supporting
50%
Becoming
consistent
in ability
to support
Effective
except
when
stressed
Very
Effective in
supporting
Comforting
the child
Finding
appropriate
level of
stimulation
Pleasurably
engages the
child
Reads
childs
emotional
signals
Responds
to childs
emotionalsignals
Tends to
encourage
the child
]
54
Relationships - Caregiver Profiles: first grade teacher,
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
55/127
p g g ,
aide
Not yet able
to support
Just starting
to support
Islands of
support
Moderately
effective in
supporting
50%
Becoming
consistent
in ability
to support
Effective
except
when
stressed
Very
Effective in
supporting
Comforting
the child
Not fuzzy,
but not
reactive
mellow
Finding
appropriate
level of
stimulation
directive unflappable
Pleasurablyengages the
child
directive Persistentattempts to
engage him
Reads
childs
emotional
signals
Sees when he is
upset
Can predict
when he will
become
upset
Respondsto childs
emotionalsignals
Unsure what to do Interested in theflow of activity,
not interaction
Tends to
encourage
the child
directive Wants him
regulated so
he can learn
(not interact
per se)
55
Relationships - Caregiver Profiles: second grade
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
56/127
p g g
teacher, resource teacher, aide
Not yet able
to support
Just starting
to support
Islands of
support
Moderately
effective in
supporting
50%
Becoming
consistent
in ability
to support
Effective
except
when
stressed
Very
Effective in
supporting
Comforting
the child
Kind and
clearmellow
Really there
for him, can
help him
settle
Finding
appropriate
level of
stimulation
directive Pretty good with
him
Calm and
positive, able
to flexibly
shift level ofstimulation
Pleasurably
engages the
child
directive Learning to
engage
Some nice
non-verbal
flow
Reads
childs
emotionalsignals
Predict when
he is upset
Tries hard to do
this in the
moment
Naturally
reads his
cues
Responds
to childsemotional
signals
Still unsure what to
do
Interested in the
flow ofinteraction
Naturally
responds
Tends to
encourage
the child
Still directive Strong desire
to see him
regulated and
engaged
Regulated for
interaction;
coaches
aides, staff
56
Medications Approved by the
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
57/127
Medications Approved by the
FDA for Marketing for the
Treatment of Autism
Risperdal - 10/06 - Irritability
Abilify - 11/09 Irritability
57
Thanks and Have a Good
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
58/127
Thanks and Have a Good
Day!
58
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
59/127
Ok, theres more to it
Are medications a good thing?
Medical Ethics
FDA
Evidence Based Medicine
Informed Consent
Family
How Doctors Think
Medications and medication options
59
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
60/127
Its complex
People like things simple and practical
This is not simple
But if you follow along, it can be quite
helpful and practical.
60
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
61/127
Good Medicine
Good = it might help (help what?) -
beneficence
Good = it wont cause bad side effects -
Do No Harmnon-maleficence
61
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
62/127
4 Main Principles of Medical Ethics*
1. Beneficence doing good (EvidenceBased Medicine)
2. Non-maleficence risk vs. benefit(Do No Harm)
3. Autonomy informed consentwithout deception
4. Justice allocation of resources,
laws (avoiding aversive practices)*Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. 3rd ed. New York,
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989.
62
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
63/127
History of Trying to do Good
Food and Drug Act of 1906 safe
medicines, not diet pills from tapeworm
eggs
Flexner Report on Medical Education1910 medical care has risks and so
medical education requires standards
63
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
64/127
The FDA
Approves medication for marketing for
specific symptoms of specific conditions
Allows doctors to use medications for
whatever they think is appropriate
64
FDA Approval
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
65/127
FDA Approval
of a Medicine for Marketing
Requires studies showing it works for
some symptoms of some condition
Safety studies now for kids too!
Difficult process
Expensive process
65
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
66/127
Its Especially Hard to Do Studies
On Medications in Kids with ASDs
Kids are hard to find
Kids have multiple diagnoses
Kids with Autism are a very mixed group
66
New approaches:
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
67/127
pp
CAPTNChild & Adolescent PsychiatryTrials Network
NIH / Duke
Efficiency Studies
Pharmacogenetics
Results pending
67
The upshot for the
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
68/127
The upshot, for the
moment
Companies seek FDA approval is for
BIG MARKETS
Most psychiatric medication for kids is
experimental
68
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
69/127
Doctors Need:
To know a lot
Respect for troubleSteady care
Judgment & Experience
69
Clinical Judgment & Experience
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
70/127
g p
with
the condition
the medications
otherneurobehavioral and medical
conditions
side effects & drug interactions
the terrible things
70
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
71/127
Doctors Experience
Often limited
In my experience = seen one
In a series = seen two
71
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
72/127
Terrible Things
Morbidity severe side effects (e.g. hepatic
failure, NMS, TD, etc. etc.)
Mortality
72
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
73/127
Avoiding Trouble
Good care: follow up, AIMS, labs, etc.
Laws governing medication
Report medication problems to the FDA
Talk to colleagues
Informed consent: family choice
73
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
74/127
Family Choice
For lifelong challenges
Severe symptoms and impact
Families must know their options
Family circumstances and values arepreeminent
Hope is essential - unfounded hope is cruel
Family choice is the heart informed consent
74
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
75/127
Diagnosis
Target Symptoms Treatment Protocol
Alternative Treatments
Results of No Treatment Side Effects
FDA Labeling: experimental
Consent & Assent
Comments, Questions & Concerns: trackclosely
INFORMED CONSENT IS A PROCESS75
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
76/127
So why use meds?
Can help, sometimes dramatically
Duty to Inform
76
Good information is part of
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
77/127
Good information is part of
good medical care
Could help, and perhaps
avoid harm
Standard of care
Practice guidelines
Evidence Based Medicine
77
E id d B d M di i
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
78/127
Evidenced Based Medicine
Sackett, et. al. British Medical Journal1996;312:71-72 (13 January)
the conscientious, explicit, and
judicious use of current best evidence inmaking decisions about the care of
individual patients.
78
M i h t?
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
79/127
Meaning what?
integrating clinical expertise withsystematic studies
consideration of clinically relevant
research and respect for the individuals
predicament, rights, and preferences
79
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
80/127
Misuse of Evidence Based Medicine
Cost cuttersno research
Vested Interestsonly our
research counts
Convinced Cliniciansmy
experience is what matters
80
G ld St d d E id
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
81/127
Gold Standard Evidence
Double Blind
Placebo (or wait list) Controlled
ProspectiveRandomized
Multiple Subjects
81
M di i T d
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
82/127
vs. Medicine Today:
Grave conditions cannot wait
We work with the data we have
Heterogeneity of populations
Extrapolating from other disorders
(OCD), other populations (adults)
82
A d P l H
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
83/127
And People are Human
Narrow thinking
Emotional reasoning
Placebo effects
References: How Doctors Think
Groopman; Science and Fiction in
Autism Schreibman; Lies, Damn
Lies, and Science Seethaler
83
S EBM i
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
84/127
So EBM requires:
Currentbest evidence
Clinical expertise & judgment
84
E id Ch O Ti
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
85/127
Evidence Changes Over Time
Half changes every 5 years
50% is wrong
We dont which half
85
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
86/127
Find one you can work with
Keep the doctor informed about whatis happening with meds and therapy
Dont overwhelm with data
Doctors can be confused
(
biomedical
)Respectfully offer resources
Good doctor consult other doctors
86
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
87/127
Competence: APBN Board
Certified
Ethics: AACAP = try their best
87
Th R l f M di ti
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
88/127
The Role of Medication
Overview
Progress?
A Good Enough ProgramA General Approach to
Medication
Gridding the Problem
88
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
89/127
1989 Magda Campbell: haloperidol helps
social learning; others: methylphenidatecauses side effects without benefit.
1990s - 2006: treating target symptoms,based on responses in other conditions to
medications; lots of use of neuroleptics foraggression, etc.
2004 Black Box warning for SSRIs in kids
2006 Risperdal
Early 2009 Celexa not working for OCDin ASD
Late 2009 Abilify
2010 Cochrane report on SSRIs and autism89
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
90/127
Most people consider meds because
they feel stuck, maybe desperate
Emergencies: aggression, depression,others?
Lack of progress
90
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
91/127
What do we want for our children?
The usual wish: a meaningful life(socially, emotionally, maybe cognitively)
Requires a plan, and medication alone is not
a plan.
91
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
92/127
self regulation, sensory, and motor function
trusting, supportive relationships
communication, maybe language cognition & learning
living and life skills: home, school, work
compliance with important rules
92
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
93/127
Are we asking too much of a child?
Of a family? Of a school?
93
The Central Question
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
94/127
The Central Question
Are you trying to improve an appropriate
situation or make up for a bad one?
94
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
95/127
Will they change my childs brain and fix it?
Could they injure my child? What should I expect?
95
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
96/127
To avoid losing time while pulling the
program together To do as much as possible
Awakenings are we trying for a miracle?
96
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
97/127
Cant guarantee results
If no emergency, theres time
When parents disagree
Side effects
Treatment teams
all about the meds
97
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
98/127
Complete workup a must: consider (24 hour) EEG, labs, etc.along with complete history, physical, t ime with the chi ld and fami ly, andcollateral information from school, therapists, etc.
Diagnosis: a hypothesis meant to focus treatment, as well as otherpossible & co-occurring diagnoses. The 5 axis system helps, and new dimensionalaxes may work better
Grid and prioritize target symptoms andpossible treatments and fill in likely +s & -s, in a flexible decision matrix Availability- doctor MUST stay in touc hwith family and school
GOLDEN RULE: think carefully before rapid,large changes in dose or before changing
more thing than one thing at a time.
98
Gridding Target Symptoms
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
99/127
Gridding Target Symptoms
Target symptoms
Prioritizing Symptoms
Core Symptoms
99
Name Your Symptoms
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
100/127
Name Your Symptoms
Activity,impulsivity
Anger Attention
Anxiety,specificfears
Cognition
Depression GI Distress Mood
instability,irritability,aggression
Motor Planning O/C,
rigidityPerseverati
ve Pain Reciprocal
interaction Seizures Sensory
Sensitivity
&Processing
Sleep Tics
Others??
100
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
101/127
Targe
ts
Activity
Atten
tion
Anxie
ty
Cogn
ition
Depression
Mood
Instability
aggression
Motor
Plann
ing
O/C,rigidity
Perse
verative
Recip
rocal
intera
ction
Sensory
Sensitivity
Tics
Sleep
Etc
Comments
Stimulants +/- +/- - +/- - - +/- - +? - - - Wt
Ht
tics
SSRIs - - +/- -/+ +? -/+ +? +? -/+ Wt, Ht
Sz
Neuroleptics +? -? + -/+ +? ++? - +? ++?? +? + + Wt. Sz
TD
NMS
AEDs +? -/+ + -
/+?
+? ++? -? +? +? +? +
?
+/- Mult.
SE
Steroids -? -? +? +? -/+ -? +? -? ++? -? +
?
-? Mult
SE
Central Alpha
Agonists
+? +? +? -/+ +/- 1/+? -/+? +? +? +? +
?
+ Sleep
BP
Etc
LIST OTHER
TREATMENTS!
101
Core Symptoms?
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
102/127
Core Symptoms?
Relating
Communicating
Healthy development: connected, regulated
emotions that breathe life into adaptive thinking
and planning
102
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
103/127
Support regulation and co-regulation bytreating, e.g., impulsivity, inattention, anxiety, rigid thinking,perseveration.
Widen tolerance of emotions sothe person is less likely to become overwhelmed.
Treat co-occurring conditions,e.g., depression.
Mightpromote abstractreasoning and thinking.
103
The Bottom Line:
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
104/127
The Bottom Line:
medication probably does not treat coresymptoms directly
might make some target symptoms or
co-occurring conditions better creating more affective availability so
that we can make progress
if you can avoid significant side effects.
104
Specific Psychotropic
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
105/127
Medications
Try to always know the brand andgeneric names of medications
Rxlist.com is often helpful
The following list and the informationprovided is not comprehensive; please
talk with your own health care provider
for further information
105
Stimulants
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
106/127
Stimulants
Methylphenidate: Ritalin, Concerta, Metadate,Methylin, Focalin
Dextroamphetamine: Adderall, mixed salts,Vyvanse
Slightly different mechanisms. Similar possible side effects: appetite, sleep,
withdrawal, depressed mood, unstable mood,tics, obsessiveness, etc.
Drug diversion vs. drug abuse risk ADHD and ASD
Often makes a good plan workable.
106
SSRIs
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
107/127
SSRIs
One of many classes ofantidepressants
Can really help depressed mood, maybe anxiety,less likely obsessiveness (although works well forthat forneurotypicals)
Prozac (fluoxteine), Zoloft (sertraline), Paxil
(paroxetine), Luvox (fluvoxamine), Celexa &Lexapro (citalopram).
Similar possible side effects: behavioralactivation, weight gain (and loss), mood instability,lower seizure threshold, etc.
Black box warning about suicidal thinking vs. lowerrates of actual suicide in people treated withSSRIs
107
Neuroleptics
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
108/127
Neuroleptics
Zyprexa (olanzapine), Risperdal (risperidone), Abilify(aripiprizole), Seroquel (quetiapine), Geodan(ziprasidone), Haldol (haloperidol), Mellaril(thioridizine), Thorazine (chlorpromazine) and others.
Discovered while looking for cold pills, developed for
symptoms of psychosis. Helping aggression, mood stability, and miracles? As
well as tics, and adjunct for depression, perseveration,etc.?
Side effects can include weight, lipid, and sugar issues,
as well as seizures, fevers (NMS) and new abnormalmovements (TD), stroke (elderly), cardiac
Should we always consider neuroleptics?
108
AEDs
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
109/127
AEDs
Anti-Epileptic Drugs (aka anti-seizure medications) So many and all so different in character
For seizures, and for mood stabilization
Many kids on the spectrum have seizures!
Might help other medications work better
(stimulants, antidepressants)
Combined pharmacology vs. polypharmacy
Sudden stopping might make seizures more likely
109
Specific AEDs
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
110/127
Specific AEDs
Depakote (valproic acid, valproate) prettyreliable, easy to load, watch levels, platelets,
bruising, liver, pancreas, carnitine, menstrual
irregularities, weight, sedation. Problems when
using with Lamictal Tegretol (carbemazepine) - ?reliable, watch levels,
blood counts, EKG, lots of drug interactions,
weight gain, sedation, rash
Trileptal (oxycarbezine)Tegretol light
?; motorproblems, electrolyte issues, rash?
110
More AEDs
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
111/127
More AEDs
Keppra (levetiricetum) easy to use, but does it work? Lamictal (lamotragine) mood stability, ?better mood.
Must go slow, and watch for rash
Topamax (topiramate) adjunct, may cause weight
loss, loss of expressive language, usually need to goslow.
Neurontin (gabapentin) Does it work at all? Does it
harm at all? Does help pain syndromes.
Lyrica (pregabalin) for pain in fibromyalgia, partial
seizures
Zarontin (ethosuccimide) for partial/ absence
seizures; liver issues
111
Steroids
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
112/127
Steroids
LKS variant theory epileptic aphasia 24 hrEEGs
Regression at a young age
Cell membrane stabilization in inflammation
So many side effects: cushinoid, moon face,hump, central obesity, peripheral wasting, immune
compromise, skin striations, mood instability
including depression and hypomania
Pulsed dosing regimens
112
Central Alpha Agonists
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
113/127
Central Alpha Agonists
Tenex & Intuniv (guanfacine), Catapres(clonidine)
Reducing fight flight sympathetic
tone, which can help in many ways Vigilance theory
Side effects can include sedation,
dizziness, early tolerance Mild medicine
113
Other Commonly Considered
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
114/127
Medications
Straterra (atamoxetine) for ADHD; may be asgood as placebo, may act like an antidepressant(+/-)
Wellbutrin (bupropion, etc.) dopaminergic,weight, loss, sleep loss, irritability, seiaure risk
Rozerem (ramelteon) melatonin agonist
SNRIs Effexor (venlafaxine), Cymbalta(duloxetine), Remeron (mirtazepine), Serzone(nefazedone), Pristique (desvenlafaxine).
Deseryl (trazodone) antidepressant often usedfor sleep; cognitive side effects, priapism
Buspar (an azaspirone) mild, serotonergic crossreactions
114
More Others
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
115/127
More Others
Lithium great mood stabilizer; anti-suicidal; bipolar-ASD connection; levels,
thyroid, kidney function
Namenda (memantine) Alzheimers med
antagonistof the N-methylD-aspartic
acid (NMDA) glutamate receptor, thisdrug
was hypothesized to potentially modulate
learning, block
excessive glutamate effectsthat can include neuroinflammatoryactivity,
and influence neuroglial activity in autism
115
Meds that I often avoid
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
116/127
Meds that I often avoid
Paxil (paroxetine), Effexor (venlafaxine), Cymbalta(duloxetine) - withdrawal
Tegretol (carbemazepine) hard to make it work
Combo Depakote and Lamictal
Tricyclics Tofranil (imipramine), Norpramin
(desipramine), Pamelor (nortriptyline); and, esp. goodfor typical OCD, Anafranil (clomipramine). Cardiac andblood pressure issues.
Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors Nardil (phenelzine) ,Parnate (tranylcypromine), Marplan (isocarboxazide),
Emsam (selegiline) can be useful although dietary,blood pressure drop and hypertensive crisis must beconsidered; lots of drug-drug interactions
116
Special Caution on
B di i !
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
117/127
Benzodiazepines!
Benzodiazepines Valium (diazapam), Ativan(lorazepam), Xanax (alprazolam), Klonopin(clonazepam), and others
Used so freely by many doctors and families
Problems nearly always outweigh risks Addicting
Destabilizing mood
Interfere with learning
Interfere with motor function
Interfere with memory
117
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
118/127
Targets
Activ
ity
Atten
tion
Anxiety
Cogn
ition
Depr
ession
Mood
Insta
bility
agg
ression
Moto
r
Planning
O/C,
rigidity
Perseverative
Reciprocal
interaction
Sens
ory
Sens
itivity
Tics
Sleep
Etc
Com
ments
Stimulants +/- +/- - +/- - - +/- - +? - - - Wt
Ht
tics
SSRIs - - +/- -/+ +? -/+ +? +? -/+ Wt, Ht
Sz
Neuroleptics +? -? + -/+ +? ++? - +? ++?? +? + + Wt. Sz
TD
NMS
AEDs +? -/+ + -
/+?
+? ++? -? +? +? +? +
?
+/- Mult.
SE
Steroids -? -? +? +? -/+ -? +? -? ++? -? +
?
-? Mult
SE
Central Alpha
Agonists
+? +? +? -/+ +/- 1/+? -/+? +? +? +? +
?
+ Sleep
BP
Etc
LIST OTHER
TREATMENTS!
118
Getting back to the tree
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
119/127
Getting back to the tree
119
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
120/127
Targets
Sens
ory
Proc
essing
Moto
rtone
andmotor
Planning
Rece
ptive
Com
municatio
n Expr
essive
Com
municatio
n VisualSpatial
Prax
is
Othe
rmedical
Etc
Com
ments
Stimulants -/+? -/+? -/+? -/+? -/+? -/+? -/+? WtHt
tics
SSRIs Wt, Ht
Sz
Neuroleptics Wt. SzTD
NMS
AEDs Mult.
SE
Steroids Mult
SE
Central Alpha
Agonists
Sleep
BP
Etc
LIST OTHER
TREATMENTS!
120
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
121/127
Targets
Co-regulation
Enga
gement
Circles
Flow
Symbolic
Logical
Multicausal
Nuan
ce
Refle
ctive
Num
ber10?
Etc
Com
ments
Stimulants Wt
Ht
tics
SSRIs Wt, Ht
Sz
Neuroleptics Wt. SzTD
NMS
AEDs Mult.
SE
Steroids Mult
SE
Central Alpha
Agonists
Sleep
BP
Etc
LIST OTHER
TREATMENTS!
121
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
122/127
Targ
ets
Rea
ding..
Writing
Arithmetic.
Ethicalrules
Trad
eskills
Swimming.
Etc
Com
ments
Stimulants Wt
Ht
tics
SSRIs Wt, Ht
Sz
Neuroleptics Wt. SzTD
NMS
AEDs Mult.
SE
Steroids Mult SE
Central Alpha
Agonists
Sleep
BP
Etc
LIST OTHER
TREATMENTS!
122
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
123/127
Targets
Com
forting
thec
hild
Findingan
appr
opriate
levelof
stimulation
Pleasurable
enga
gingthe
child
Read
ingthe
child
s
emotional
signals
Resp
ondingto
thec
hilds
emotional
signals
Enco
uraging
thec
hilds
deve
lopment
Etc
Com
ments
Stimulants Wt
Ht
tics
SSRIs Wt, Ht
Sz
Neuroleptics Wt. SzTD
NMS
AEDs Mult.
SE
Steroids Mult
SE
Central Alpha
Agonists
Sleep
BP
Etc
LIST OTHER
TREATMENTS!
123
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
124/127
124
Abnormal Involuntary Movement Scale (AIMS)
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
125/127
125
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
126/127
Look at the whole picture, and reflect
Be careful with meds Engage the Child
Your Experiences?
126
Never g ive up , neversurrender!
-
7/28/2019 Medication Support for DIR Programs October 28 2011 Tel Aviv
127/127
- Captain Peter Quincy TaggartCommander, NSEA Protector